---
ai_generation_date: '2026-11-16'
ai_model: gemini-3.1-pro-preview
ai_prompt_hash: 2d625dd6
audiodharma:
  talks:
    - date: '2019-10-13'
      is_meditation: false
      mp3_url: https://audiodharma.us-east-1.linodeobjects.com/talks/10582/20191013-Gil_Fronsdal-IMC-practicing_with_imagination.mp3
      section_slug: practicing-with-imagination
      speakers:
        - speaker_name: Gil Fronsdal
          speaker_url: https://www.audiodharma.org/speakers/1
      talk_start_time_seconds: 0
      title: Practicing With Imagination
      url: https://www.audiodharma.org/talks/10582
      video_unavailable: false
collapsed_sections: []
location_city: Redwood City, CA
video_unavailable: false
youtube:
  id: PYVEnoM3LWs
  imprecise_upload_date: '2020-05-04'
  title: 'Gil Fronsdal: Practicing With Imagination'
  upload_date: null
  uploader_str: Insight Meditation Center
  uploader_url: https://www.youtube.com/@InsightMeditationCenter
youtube_url: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYVEnoM3LWs
---

# Practicing With Imagination - [Gil Fronsdal](https://www.audiodharma.org/speakers/1)

_This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers._

## [Practicing With Imagination](https://www.audiodharma.org/talks/10582)

Lately I've been thinking quite a bit about the role of imagination in meditation, and I want to share some of my thoughts with you. I'm certainly not an expert on this area of imagination. Some people have given a lot of study, attention, and practice to using it. But maybe my thoughts, what I'll offer, are a little bit preliminary.

There are times where I've used various imaginations to help bring the mind into the present moment. For example, I like water a lot. My particular background is water, and so it's very meaningful for me to see water or be around water. Sometimes when I start meditating, I bring on the image of waves coming into the shore and I'm surfing on the waves. The in-breaths and out-breaths are the waves that are coming. When I catch the in-breath, I'm catching the wave or getting up on the wave, and then on the out-breath, I'm surfing the wave.

As I continue using a little bit of imagery—I don't use it very much, but sometimes I'll use it—it switches to being just the waves washing up on the sand or the shore, going in and out. They're very peaceful, spreading out long and flat and smooth. And then it becomes being in the water myself at the edge, and the waves are washing over me. And then it's me in the water; when I was a kid I used to love going under the water and flipping around at about five or six feet underwater and looking up at the waves. It would be turbulent up there, there would be wind and waves up there, but where I was was really calm. I'd watch the waves from above, coming and going.

I've used these kinds of imageries to help me be present. The reason I've done it is that the alternative, what the mind will do on its own, is make its own imageries about things. In fact, much thinking could be understood to be using imagination. For people who think in images, the word imagination works particularly well. We're imagining scenes and scenarios in the past, or future fantasies in the present, and we're pulled into the imagery of that. Some people are brilliant storytellers, so it's more verbal, or not so brilliant, but still brilliant enough for you to get pulled in.

Storytellers repeating a story a variety of ways, imagining conversations that we've had or we will have. When we get lost in thought, caught up in our thinking, I think of it as a kind of imaginary world we're in. The function of imagination, I define it by the mental construction of reality, mental constructions of ideas, of places, of people, of events that are not actually happening in the moment.

If you're having a memory of something that happened in the past, that act of remembering is the imaginary mind constructing something. It's an imagination of the past, and how accurate is it? It probably isn't 100% accurate. We imagine the future. A lot of anxiety that people have is said to come from imagination of the future, imaginary futures which are going to be dangerous or troublesome or problematic. And some people tell themselves stories. Some people call it rumination, but a lot of it is stories, ideas, conversations, imaginations of what's going to come. And some of it is not very specific or detailed. It's just a general imagining, a mood almost like danger is coming.

What I'm trying to say here is a mind that gets distracted is often a mind that's imagining something one way or the other. And why this word imagination is so useful here, rather than referring to it as distracted thought, is that if you just call it distracted thought, it's actually a very narrow... [perfect mindfulness bell rings] [Laughter] Well, I'll breathe. Great.

The problem with just calling it distracted thoughts is it actually doesn't represent the fullness of the function of what's going on. Fullness in the sense of all the different human faculties that are coming into play around those thoughts. For example, if we are thinking about the future, maybe it's a nice thought, maybe it's a happy anticipation for something. Coming along with that might be an image of the nice thing that's going to happen, a birthday party with balloons. It's not just thoughts about this birthday party, it comes along with imagery. And that imagery you're making up has some personal meaning, it's associated with your own birthday parties you went to, other things you've done. The mind that associates things comes into play there in the background.

Also with imagery, imagining something or telling a story is not often emotion-free. There might be emotions connected to it. For birthday parties, oh, that's just a lot of happy screaming kids around and how nice it'll be. I don't get to be around kids so much anymore and that'll be great. I'm feeling delight and happiness about this thing I've imagined, and it might not have much basis in truth. It might be that my mind is going off on a little tangent. I'm going to a party, but I'm filling it in. There might be motivations that come into play as I'm thinking about this party, things I want and things I don't want. It's not just a neutral picture of a party I'm going to. I have concerns about who I'm going to sit next to at the party. I'm going to have the right cake. I don't like frosting and so I hope they don't have frosting again. Maybe I should bring my own cake without frosting.

There are these thoughts, ideas, desires, what I don't like. It's a whole complex of things when I'm trying to paint. It's not just a series of words or neutral pictures in the mind. Our emotional life comes into play. Our motivational life comes into play, and our physiological life comes into play, I think, because as I'm imagining going to this party, I'm imagining myself walking through space. I'm imagining myself sitting there, how I am. Imaginary proprioception comes into play. So when we're distracted, there are a lot of things attracting us or glue pulling our mind into it. There might be a lot of hope in the imagination or all kinds of things that are tied into what we're thinking about.

What I'm trying to say is there's a lot of imagination of different kinds. Imaginary emotions that are being constructed around that image. Imaginary desires around it, imaginary people to talk to, and experiences, all kinds of things come into play, and it's a very rich environment being distracted. It's not like a simple little thing.

If those kind of distracted thoughts and imaginations are getting the upper hand in meditation, and you've tried to be mindful of it, you try to let go and come back, and they get the upper hand, you can—I apologize, I shouldn't use this language—fight fire with fire. You use the very thing that you're being pulled into to support you, to corral the mind into the present moment. So when I use this imagery of the waves and surfing, I'm utilizing my imagination to point my attention not into the imagery, but I use the imagery as a background that points me back to my breath, connects me to my breath. To me, it's engaging those images of surfing or the water on the sand going up and down. I find it much more interesting. My mind is more interested, more involved than simply, "Gil, focus on your breathing, up, in, out, up, down," which I love doing, but sometimes it's a little bit dry.

If I'm easily distracted, then I'll bring in and create a rich environment with my imagination, where my emotional connection to water comes into play. It's so calming to see or even imagine flat surfaces of water, and there's so much joy involved in surfing. All these little emotions come into play, wanting to be there, wanting to feel it. It becomes a little playful, a little bit of a game, and all that begins to corral the mind to stay with the breath. And as I get focused on that, things calm down. As it calms down in my case, the imagination changes accordingly. At some point, I'm not surfing the waves, that's too exciting. It's much more calming to imagine the water going up and down the sand, or even more calming to be underwater and just looking up at the surface.

Now, there are plenty of people who believe—which I did as well—that if you're doing mindfulness meditation you're not allowed to do this. Mindfulness meditation is about seeing things as they are, without concepts, without other ideas, without imagination. Imagination is actually the death of mindfulness. That if you have imagination then you're lost in an abstract world, a conceptual world, and you have to let go of all that and just be with the raw facts, just the event, just the data that's coming in without any added things. That's actually true at a particular stage of meditation. Sometimes these teachings and instructions we get in practice are stage-specific. There are different stages of concentration, stages of mindfulness that people go through, and instructions that are appropriate for one stage might not be appropriate for other stages.

The suggestion I'm making here is that if the distracted mind is in control of you, you just keep getting pulled into imaginations that have nothing to do with the here and now. And not only that, but you see it's not really useful for you. It may even be harmful for you. A lot of people's mental challenges of all kinds have a fair amount to do with what their mind is imagining. It's a world that for many people is not a very useful world to be in. However, imagination also makes the world a much richer place to be, and makes it more valuable, and more comes into play when we're in the imagination doing things.

I went for a hike today in the hills up here, and part of the joy, the delight of the hike had to do with my imagination. I just like doing it. I like the physicality of it. I like how much it puts me in the present moment to be in the hills and just being there. But in fact, there's a certain kind of delight in knowing that the grogginess of this morning is going to be lifted as I walk. A little bit of delight knowing that I'll have more good energy for a few hours after I finished my hike. That memory, which is an imagination of how I was waking up, and this projection into the future of how I'm going to be, which is reasonable enough to do, is adding some of the richness and value and appreciation of actually doing the walk itself. I've walked those hills for a long time, and so in the background for me is just how delightful it's been so many other times. It's not actively remembering all that and being blind to what's going on now, lost in past memories, but it's wafting in the background like atmosphere, making that whole walk richer and more valuable, more delightful.

So in the very walk itself, imagination is coming in, I would say, in an innocent and valuable, useful way that adds to the richness of the experience. Some imagination is very creative and creates all kinds of new ideas and expressions.

It turns out that the Buddha used his imagination a lot in his teaching. I imagine he used it a lot in his own mind for himself. He was very creative in coming up with stories. He was a brilliant storyteller. He was a brilliant creator of metaphors and similes. He was a poet. He had a rhetorical ability that's not so obvious when you read the way the English is translated, but he was brilliant in his artistry and his creativity and creating imagery for people. He was involved in using his imagination for teaching purposes, but in return, what's happening is that he's providing imagery that if we can learn, they can live in us like an imagination that can actually teach us about meditation. It can help us with channeling or corralling the mind into the present moment and guiding it deeper and deeper into the meditation itself.

So using imagination rather than being used by it, and not using imagination just for the sake of pleasure. I've known people on retreat who come and tell me, "Oh, for the last three hours, I've just been fantasizing about something because yesterday was a hard day and I deserved the break." They do something to have a pleasant fantasy. Maybe that was useful. Maybe that was healing for them and got them centered. They needed three hours to have a sexual fantasy so they can finally be here. Maybe, but I think we use imagination for the purposes of waking up, for the purposes of really being here for our experience. It has to serve that purpose. How do we use our imagination to really encourage us to be present here? It's kind of like pointers rather than something that takes us away from here. It puts us more and more here, and puts us here in a good way.

It's okay to have some sense that what we're trying to do here is to calm down. What we're trying to do here is to cultivate a sense of well-being in the present moment. If you have too much expectation and striving for that, you can miss the present moment. But if you're using all these things to serve you to really try to be here, then you're using the richness of all your intelligence to settle in and be here, rather than leaving some of your faculties and some of your intelligences at the door when you sit down to meditate.

Some people meditate as if the only thing they're allowed to do—I've been this way—was sit up straight, keep coming back to the breath, keep being with the breath, and that's it. Sometimes that served me very well and I wouldn't want to knock the value of that. But it's also okay, at times when it's needed, to bring all of ourselves into the meditation and unify it so it's all there for the same purpose. And I would like to argue, me who doesn't know much about imagination, that one of the roles or potentials of our capacity for imagination is to unify all the different faculties that we have.

There's something about stories, imagery, and pictures that has channels or connections to all the different parts of who we are, all the different faculties. If we simply use prose, it is much more boring or much less evocative than poetry. If it's just intellectual thoughts going on and the train of thoughts thinking about things, it's much less multifaceted than having an image of the same thing. A picture is worth 10,000 words, they say. As we have an image, if the imagination is using imagery or if we have a little bit of a story, like surfing on the waves, then our emotions are involved. Certainly, our powers of imagination are involved. Our thinking might be involved. Our capacity to evaluate, our capacity a little bit to have some planning and some sense of purpose come into play there. The surfing has my physical sense of my body participating in a felt sense of what it's like to surf. All these things come into play.

The suggestion I have is that an act of imagination gathers together all these things to unify them or activate them. And when it's done in the service of meditation, it's helping meditation to do the same thing, because one of the functions of good meditation is in fact to unify our faculties. Everything we're doing is unified, involved in the same thing at the same time for the same purpose. If we're sitting here and the mind is thinking about the future, your body and mind are in two different places. The idea is to unify the body and mind and have the mind be involved in the present moment as well. If you're in the present moment and your mind is in fact thinking about what you'd like to have for lunch, thinking about getting concentrated, thinking about did I pay my taxes this year, the mind is actually fragmented and jumping around. But to have the thinking itself focused on the meditation practice, nothing more than the meditation practice. If the emotions we're feeling are a leftover mood from all the challenges of the week, the slights and desires and happinesses, kind of swimming around together in a mixed-up kind of way, if how we feel emotionally is all arising out of the meditation practice—meditation can be extremely emotional in a particular way—we want to have our capacity for emotionality also be harnessed or gathered together, unified for the purpose of meditation. As we meditate, that is to become whole, unified.

The proposal I have is that we can use our imagination to help with that unifying, gathering-together process, but it has to be for the purpose of meditation. It has to be done very carefully so that it doesn't take us away. It actually helps us to be more and more here.

The Buddha did this, and I want to share some of these imageries that the Buddha provided people. Whether he actually had this imagery as you meditate, by teaching this over and over again he's planting these images in people's minds. At the right time they come up for people and they have that wafting there in the background, the atmosphere almost that's supporting them to be present. I suspect also these imageries that the Buddha was teaching are planted in the subconscious. They operate there even without us actively bringing them up. Part of the reason to read these ancient texts of the Buddha, and this can be done other ways too, is to internalize the imagery that he uses for meditation. It also is there to support you and guide you as you go through different stages of imagery. The more I've studied and practiced with these imageries the Buddha uses, the more brilliant I think it is. Maybe my evaluation is biased, but I just think it's amazing how well he captures in similes, for example, what can happen in meditation and different stages of meditation.

## The Five Hindrances

I'll give you a few examples. The Buddha talked a lot about the hindrances[^1]. There are five. The literal meaning for the word is not hindrances. It's the five coverings. The five things that cover our wisdom, the things that cover our ability to be present in a clear way, or interfere with our ability to really be here in a stable, focused way. This is desire for sensual pleasures, which human beings can specialize in; thoughts, ideas, and imaginations of ill will; the traditional English translation for the next one is sloth and torpor, lethargy and being deflated; restlessness and remorse or regret; and the last is doubt.

These five are very strong forces that keep us caught up in distraction. Even if a lot of other neuroses are settled, these are considered basic common human ways of thinking processes that keep us distracted and caught up. The goal for the Buddha is for us to overcome those hindrances, quiet them down enough so they're not interfering with our ability to really be present, really be here.

He has similes that he uses for these five. He doesn't explicitly connect these five similes with each of those five, but he presents them as a kind of imagery for all of them. Maybe because for different people, different similes work for them. Being caught up in the hindrances, he said, is like being in debt. You have a huge debt that you're trying to pay off somehow. The second is that being caught up in these hindrances is like having an illness. Being caught by these hindrances is like being in prison. Being caught in these hindrances is like crossing a dangerous desert with all your savings and all your possessions, where there are hoodlums and pirates and all kinds of dangers. And then the fifth one is being a slave, who has no independent life at all, is completely dependent, taking orders from other people, and cannot go anywhere they please.

It's kind of graphic. In some of these hindrances, maybe you can feel sometimes like, "I'm caught. I'm not the master of my own life. This strong ill will I have keeps taking over, and wherever I go it's with me, so I'm not really free." They're strong imagery, and maybe it gets people's attention and says, "Wow, I don't want to do this. I thought it was okay to fantasize, but I don't want to live this kind of way if that's what it is." It is a kind of imagery that has a certain impact, but the bigger impact the Buddha was hoping to have with this imagery was to evoke in people the goodness that comes when we're free of these five states. When we're free of illness, free of debt, free of slavery, free of prison, and have made it across the desert to safety.

"Wow, I've been in prison for fifty years. Wow, this is good. Finally, I'm out." Or, "I've been chronically sick for four years and I'm finally well enough to go out. Wow, this feels good." Or, "I've been struggling with my school debt for twenty years, finally it's over, now I got to think about retirement." [Laughter] Finally it's over, and this thing has been lifted. There is a feeling of being lifted, of being free, of fresh air, of having energy. The emotion the Buddha was actually trying to inculcate in people is an emotion of gladness, a certain kind of delight and gladness. It isn't just a matter of coming into the present moment and finally the mind settles down and is here. The Buddha felt it was appropriate, and encouraged it, that a person felt a certain delight and happiness. "Oh wow, I'm finally here. This is good."

The way that my mind works with instructions, or used to, is I just follow the instructions literally. "This is what you're supposed to do." If I'm told to be present with the breathing and I have the hindrances, I'll struggle to get over them, and eventually the hindrances abate. Then I used to just, once they were gone, I wouldn't pay any attention to the fact that they're gone because I'm on to the next thing, being on my breath. There's always the next thing. However, the Buddha seems to encourage us to wait a minute, slow down. Don't just go on to the next thing. Appreciate what just happened. Appreciate that you're no longer caught up in your distractions, and feel the goodness of that. Be glad about that.

If the Buddha is painting this imaginary picture of prison and sickness and debt and all these things, and you can feel the goodness, the gladness, the delight of no longer having that, then when you no longer have the distractions, maybe the sense of gladness feels richer. It involves our imagination, involves the emotions and purpose and all kinds of things. It helps gather our attention not only in the present moment but in the gladness, the happiness of being here. The idea for the Buddha is to have that gladness, that delight as a support for wanting to be present. Wow. It's kind of like a little cheerleader on the side. "Oh, yeah. Now that I'm here, it feels good. Let me use this goodness, remind myself of this goodness, hold this goodness on the edges of my peripheral awareness to encourage me. Stay here. Be present. Continue with it. Don't just go on to the next fantasy about something. Just stay." It supports you.

As the meditation deepens further, this gladness begins to morph into joy. It's really joy and happiness about being present. There might be some serotonin or endorphins that come into play when the mind is really able to stay concentrated and be in the smooth groove of just staying present. But for whatever reason, there tends to be born from the inside a feeling of well-being. To learn to recognize those feelings of well-being, of lightness, of ease, of calm, recognize them and value them so they encourage you. "Yes. Stay here. Stay here. This is good. This is good," is part of the art of meditation. If you just ignore the good feelings that arise because you're supposed to be following instruction to just be with the breath, you're missing some of the good support that can support you to be here.

## The Mountain Lake

At some point, as these good feelings arise, and joy arises, the Buddha gives this brilliant simile. Imagine that there's a mountain lake with clear, beautiful water, and there are no streams feeding into the lake, and there's no rain replenishing the lake. The replenishment of the lake comes from an underwater spring at the center of the lake, in which water flows upward like a fountain, an underwater fountain. This is flowing up and spreading out throughout the whole lake, filling the lake with new, fresh, refreshing water. That's the simile. That's the Buddha's imagination for sitting, really being stable, sitting here, being really present in the moment. The mind is not distracted. The mind feels really engaged and present in this kind of pool of the lake. Soft, relaxed, comfortable. There's welling up from inside a kind of energy, a feeling of well-being, of refreshment that begins spreading through the body. Some people will feel it in different parts of their body. For me, it's much more in the torso. Some people feel something wonderful in their face, around their lips, different places. This feeling of pleasure begins to bubble up, begins to flow. When it's really strong, it really feels like it's welling up from the inside and spreading out everywhere.

And it's not being supported by anything outside, which means that there are no sensual sense data coming in from the outside that's supporting you in that well-being. It isn't that you're watching something really beautiful or tasting something or listening to music. You're not getting any input from the outside. All the well-being is arising and flowing from the inside out.

He provides this image, and so people who meditate have really memorized this image. In the ancient world, if you were a monastic, there were no books to read. The way that you had a library was you memorized what was taught, and the Buddha taught the same thing over and over again so that people really memorized it. He taught this simile over and over again. People who sat down to meditate, the monastics at least, could recite this wonderful story. If you've memorized something, it lives in your imagination. It lives in your psyche in a very different way than if you just read it once and you're trying to remember it.

I can imagine that when they sat down to meditate, at some point little inklings, little hints of goodness, of calm, of pleasure, of joy would begin to bubble up from the inside and they'd say, "Oh, this is what the Buddha was talking about. I feel it now." That would encourage them to focus on that. It would encourage them, "Let's just stay more present. Let's even be more here. Let's really relax and open up here. Be really here." As they do that, the flow becomes stronger. Which supports us to be more present, and the flow becomes stronger. This imagination of this mountain lake is not distracting us from the present moment. It's one that's encouraging us to be even more here. Be even more here.

The Buddha had a lot of these imageries that he used for meditation. The proposal I have is that in Buddhism there is a role for our imagination for helping the purposes of what Buddhist meditation is about. If Buddhist meditation is about being present directly without concepts and without the imagination, just with how things are as they are in the moment, to get there we can use our imagination. We use our imagination until it's no longer useful, and then we let it go.

So what do you think of that? I hope that this is something you might find a little bit interesting to try out, to experiment with. If you can, in a very light way, or a mild, light way, just enough, see if you can start using some little pieces of imagination that's not a complicated story or scenario, something very, very simple, and see if you can bring that in when you're meditating that would help you to actually do better what you're trying to do in meditation. To be present for whatever you're being present for. Then see if you can kind of keep using it until you feel so stable in the present moment that you don't have to use the imagination anymore. You can just stay there with things as they are.

---

[^1]: **Five Hindrances:** (Pali: _pañca nīvaraṇāni_) In Buddhism, the Five Hindrances are mental states that impede successful meditation and lead away from awakening: sensual desire, ill will, sloth and torpor, restlessness and remorse, and doubt.
