---
ai_generation_date: '2026-11-10'
ai_model: gemini-3.1-pro-preview
ai_prompt_hash: 2d625dd6
audiodharma:
  talks:
    - date: '2019-11-04'
      is_meditation: false
      mp3_url: https://audiodharma.us-east-1.linodeobjects.com/talks/10623/20191104-Gil_Fronsdal-IMC-generosity.mp3
      section_slug: generosity
      speakers:
        - speaker_name: Gil Fronsdal
          speaker_url: https://www.audiodharma.org/speakers/1
      talk_start_time_seconds: 0
      title: Generosity
      url: https://www.audiodharma.org/talks/10623
      video_unavailable: false
collapsed_sections: []
location_city: Redwood City, CA
video_unavailable: false
youtube:
  id: hI0gRnMOb5s
  imprecise_upload_date: '2020-05-04'
  title: 'Gil Fronsdal: Generosity'
  upload_date: null
  uploader_str: Insight Meditation Center
  uploader_url: https://www.youtube.com/@InsightMeditationCenter
youtube_url: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hI0gRnMOb5s
---

# Generosity - [Gil Fronsdal](https://www.audiodharma.org/speakers/1)

_This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers._

## [Generosity](https://www.audiodharma.org/talks/10623)

It's this thing about managers and recorders for IMC [Insight Meditation Center]. It's a great act of generosity to support the community in this way, and support people far away through the recording. So let's see, is that getting louder? Is that loud enough now? No one nods their heads, I wonder if... okay, good.

So, let's talk about generosity. There is a saying that if you can't meditate, be generous. That's quite a significant thing to say, putting generosity as being maybe next best, or equal to, doing meditation. There is certainly an intimate relationship between meditation and generosity. We see it in language, like "giving attention." Giving attention to your breathing is very different than saying you're "paying attention" to your breath. I try not to say pay attention; I don't want it to be expensive. But you can give attention. And it is an act of generosity to use your awareness, your attention, and to attend to anything. If you attend to a friend, someone in distress, or you attend to yourself—bring attention to yourself—it's a kind of food or nourishment that supports us.

The meditation practice that we do has generally come down to us through people's generosity. For me, I don't think I would have meditated except that I encountered people who, through their generosity, taught me to meditate. And now I'm eternally grateful for having that opportunity. But where did they learn what they had to teach? Because they meditated. But how did they learn to meditate? Because someone taught them. And where did those people learn? They had something to teach because they meditated, and it goes back and back and back. It's kind of a chicken and egg thing. Where does it begin? Does it begin with this warm-hearted generosity and care that someone offers to teach us something, or does it begin with someone meditating and then from that comes the impulse to give and support others?

Generosity is considered to be a fundamental aspect of Buddhist practice. It could probably be said that there would be no Buddhist practice without the practice of generosity. If you go to Thailand or Burma, it's one of the great experiences to be in the Buddhist culture there to experience the tremendous generosity of the people. I was blown away when I first went to practice in Thailand and experienced so much support and so much generosity coming my way.

It was represented one day in a very little story. I wasn't meditating on retreat, I was young, and I didn't have much experience with generosity in my life before that. I went to Thailand to practice, and I meditated at a small monastery outside of Bangkok for ten weeks. When I showed up, the abbot gave me what's called a kuti[^1], a little hut at the edge of the monastery that was built on stilts because it was on top of a swamp. In order to get to the steps of this kuti, there were all these planks of wood that zigzagged across the marsh, so if you walked on the planks you wouldn't sink in. Those planks led to three little steps that went up to a very little deck. You would walk across the little deck and open the door, and you'd come to this one-room hut that had enough space for a bed for me, and enough space for the door. It was pretty small, and I was to sit there and practice by myself. I was supposed to meditate every day, and I did walking meditation. Somehow in that swamp nearby, maybe ten feet away, was someone's grave. It certainly looked like a grave, the only long cement square thing anywhere nearby. So I did my walking meditation back and forth there, and that was my life.

I was not a monk, but the monks of the monastery went out every morning for alms rounds[^2]. Meaning, they went out with a bowl with the lid off, making themselves available for people who wanted to make food offerings to them. They would come back with these bowls full of food, and take it to their so-called kitchen. The main kitchen job was to reorganize all the food that had been given that morning and make a big buffet table. The one meal a day—the lunch meal—was made up of the food that they had gathered.

One day, early in the morning, maybe after the monks had come back from their alms rounds, I had just finished my morning meditation. I opened my door, and my eyes went across the little three-foot deck. At the top of the steps was a single apple. When I looked up further, on the fourth plank of wood going back to solid land, there was a monk who was walking away. He'd left an apple there for me. It was nice to receive an apple, I could appreciate it. But what struck me the most, in my small mind and background, was that he wasn't staying long enough to get any thanks or recognition. He was doing it without any need to be known as the person who was giving. This act of generosity—where he wasn't trying to get anything in return, just a pure act of generosity to make a gift without wanting anything from me—was a powerful lesson. My heart was very open, and the example of a little gift like that touched me.

That monk was the recipient every day of people's generosity; all the food available to him came from the generosity of the people around him. Sometimes these monks, especially in rural Thailand, don't get much food. Sometimes they have hungry days because the people are too poor, or they are only given a little bit of rice.

Similar things happened in Burma when I was there. There was just an outpouring of generosity, and it was very clear that the laypeople were being generous because they wanted to support me and the other people meditating in the monastery. I almost had the feeling that the whole country of Burma was supporting me in meditating because of the amount of generosity. I was sitting one day, minding my own business, completely still, very quiet and peaceful. Suddenly, a filling fell out of my tooth into my mouth. I hadn't moved; I don't know if it was a temperature change or what happened. I mentioned it to someone, and the next thing I knew, a dentist came to see me. I didn't make an appointment; the dentist just came to take a look and tell me it was okay. Another time I was sick, and a doctor came from the local hospital to take care of me. It was particularly touching.

In Japan, I also had the same experience of people being incredibly generous. I was a monk in Japan for a while, and going on alms rounds there, people often gave money. I remember these old ladies, who gave the impression of being extremely poor, would come and give just a little bit of money. When I was in Burma practicing intensive meditation for eight months, part of what fueled my practice and sustained my inspiration was that I wanted to be worthy of those gifts. I wanted to live up to all that people were doing to support me.

These experiences were very powerful for me. I began to appreciate how wonderful it is to be the recipient of generosity, and it inspired me to start being generous myself.

## The Joy of Giving

I discovered a number of things about generosity. I learned that generosity isn't always easy. I found that sometimes, especially when I had the idea that it would be a nice time to give but I didn't want to, that turned out to be a wonderful time to take a good look at myself. What's going on in me? Am I afraid of giving? Am I being stingy? Am I attached to something? What is happening with me when I don't want to give? As I learned to notice those things, it became easier to let go of them. It became easier to be wiser about giving and to truly give when I wanted to.

As I started giving more, I learned how to let go. Sometimes I had things I wanted to give but didn't want to give away because they were important to me. But when I saw how meaningful the gift was for the other person, I realized this letting go thing is pretty good. Sometimes the primary motivation was the gift to the person, but other times it was because it felt so good to give. It felt so good to let go of something I was holding onto, to feel the release of the heart, the release of my attachments and fears in giving away. I could feel this physical releasing and opening.

Giving is nourishing. If giving comes not from obligation, duty, fear, or for an exchange, but from the heart, it is nourishing. It's inspiring. It brings joy, it brings delight, it brings happiness.

There was a king who was talking with the Buddha, and the king asked at some point, "Who should I give to?" And the Buddha answered, "Give where you have joy. Give what gives you joy." That's nice. When I first heard this little saying, I thought, "Wow, give where there's joy." That establishes a different reference point for giving. It's not a heavy, difficult burden or an obligation. Am I supposed to feel joy in giving? Is that allowed? I thought I was supposed to give because it was a duty. But to have this kind of delight and be nourished by that is profound.

Another translation of what the Buddha said is, "Give where you have confidence." You might give money to a scoundrel, and it probably won't bring you joy, and you probably don't have much confidence that the person is going to do useful, beneficial things with the gift. So give where you have confidence. I asked myself the question, "Where do I have confidence here? What does it mean to have confidence?" If you look in a dictionary, the Pali word that's being translated as joy and confidence literally means "what makes the mind bright; what makes the mind peaceful, calm, and clear"[^3]. That is pretty cool. The Buddha is saying that you can give gifts to people and it creates a sense of clarity and calm in the mind.

This idea that generosity benefits the giver is very common. In karmic analysis, they sometimes say there are two approaches to Buddhist practice: those interested in creating good karma, and those interested in liberation. The people who want karma will give to build up merit points for a better rebirth. For people who want liberation, that's not really the concern. There is a folktale of two people who thought they had figured out how to make a lot of good karma. Every day they had a little pile of money, and each day one of them would give it to the other. They gave it back and forth, supposedly making lots of good merit. The folktale goes that they died and got reborn as wells with poison water next to each other. The wells would poison each other. It wasn't really good karma they created; they were poisoning each other with a certain kind of greed and selfishness by just giving back and forth to themselves.

That is why they say that if you can't meditate, be generous. Generosity can benefit the giver tremendously. Just as meditation is a fantastic process of self-understanding where people understand depths of who they are, generosity can also be a great area of self-education. Meditation is a place where we learn to let go of our thoughts and preoccupations so we can be present. Generosity is a place where we learn the goodness of what it feels like to let go. The clarity that comes, the openness that comes, the joy that can arise, the confidence that can come from that—there are a lot of benefits from generosity that are comparable to the benefits that come from meditating itself.

## Generosity as Relational Practice

But generosity does something for people that meditation usually doesn't do: generosity is interpersonal. It's something we do in relationship to other people, to other beings, or to the planet. Generosity involves a relationship between the giver and the receiver. It is often said that generosity is really the foundation of Buddhist practice. What's nice about that is it puts the foundation of Buddhist practice in the relational world—how we relate to others and how we live together.

In the West, when people come to Buddhism, they often start with meditation. And meditation can be somewhat self-concerned, just about "me, myself, and mine." But if you start with generosity, then it's all about how you are in relationship with other people, developing healthy relationships.

The Buddha once said something like, "If the giver hates someone, and gives a gift to the hated, it reduces the hate." So if you feel ill will or resentment, that's a time to give them a gift. I've given that advice to people—it mostly has to do with in-laws. [Laughter] You know, they're struggling with an in-law, and it's been going on for years sometimes, and I've suggested that they give the in-law a gift. Every time you go see them, bring something small: a cookie, baked bread, a cake, a pie. Bring something. A few times when I've given that advice, they've come back and said that it made a difference. It began to ease, or open up, or soften the in-law who had some kind of issue around it.

If you feel some resentment, don't wait for them to give to you. Give to them, unless you want to keep your resentment, unless you think it's a good idea to have ill will or stubbornness. Giving starts with creating a healthy relationship with the people we have trouble with. Even if we just give them a smile, or give them our attention and ask how they are, it shifts the dynamics. I've done that a number of times where I've had difficulties with people. I made sure to go find them and be in their presence. It was clear there was a lot of tension, but I asked them how they were. The generosity on my part was not in terms of giving them a physical object, but giving them friendly contact where I wasn't trying to resolve or challenge the issues. I was just trying to establish a little bit of human contact with them.

I can't tell you confidently how much it changed them, but it did change me. I learned that when I have resentment or ill will toward someone, it usually goes along with not having a clear, realistic idea of who the person is. I end up with a caricature of the person. But if I'm in their presence, I get the full person again, and it's harder for me to hold onto my resentment. To go toward the people we have these feelings for and be friendly and generous can be a powerful way to help us overcome our own hurdles. It has allowed me to enter into conversations to resolve differences with much more goodwill than if I just called them up on the phone.

The Buddha said to make offerings, make gifts. Making an offering cleanses the mind in all ways, for the offering helps abandon hatred. He also said, "If people knew, as I know, the fruits of sharing gifts, they would not enjoy their use without sharing them. Even if it were their last bite, their last morsel of food, they would not enjoy its use without sharing it, if there was someone else to share it with."[^4]

When I was in Zen monasteries, after every meal in the meditation hall, you would take a little piece of your food and put it aside. All the people's set-aside food gets gathered together and taken someplace in the wilds as an offering for the fish or the animals. You always offer something back; you don't just take it for yourself. That was a powerful lesson. Even if one throws away the rinsing from a pot or cup into the village pool or pond, wishing that the living beings there may feed on them, even this would be a source of merit—not to speak of giving a gift to human beings.

When your food goes down the garbage disposal, or into the compost to go off when the recycling drives it away, I suppose the equivalent would be: "As I send this off where it's going to go, I hope that it benefits some being—some bacteria, some fungi, something." It seems pretty petty to have that kind of thought, but consider what you might otherwise be thinking about when you turn on the garbage disposal. If you're daydreaming and thinking about your resentments, or thinking about how to keep more things for yourself, or thinking about how unfortunately you have to clean the dishes, how does that condition you? How does that change you? How do you benefit from opening your mind to a whole different perspective about how to live this life?

This is a crucial question for many of us. I get the sense on the Peninsula here that there's a fair amount of selfishness. People get too far into the business and technology world to see a lot of self-absorption with money, wealth, and status. It's contagious. "More things, more experiences, I want this, I want that." To begin breaking the shell of selfishness through generosity means creating a habit of wanting to give, wanting to support this world, and letting it be a selfless world where generosity is at the forefront. How can I give every day? What can I do to give?

Here's an exercise if you're interested: Take a $50 bill and keep it with you, looking for some stranger that you can give it to, and see what happens to you. Not to that person, to _you_. You might think, "Fifty dollars? You've got to be kidding. That's a lot of money, I could have coffee every day for a few weeks." If fifty dollars isn't a big deal for you, make it a hundred dollars. I've done that. Sometimes I'm given fifty or a hundred dollars when I teach, and I put it in my wallet waiting. Sometimes I wait a long time and forget it's there. But then something comes along, I meet someone doing something inspired, and I can say, "Here."

One of the first times that happened was many years ago. I went into San Quentin prison and there was a Native American man who I met there. A beautiful man. He was up for parole, but he really needed a lawyer to help him, and he had no money. I said, "Oh, I have $100 in my wallet," so I gave it to the facilitator, because I couldn't give the money directly to him.

The joy of generosity—the task is to discover what that joy is for yourself. The task for Buddhists is to discover how you benefit from generosity. You may benefit even more than the person you give to. There is a tremendous benefit when you learn to let go of your selfishness.

## Q&A

**Speaker 2:** I work in downtown San Jose a few days a week, and on my way down there I always put a twenty in my pocket and I look for someone homeless. I just give them enough to feed them for the day. What I've found is that it doesn't matter how deranged they seem to be, usually when they realize that they're not going to be hungry, they come into this incredible presence and give me a blessing. It's usually deeply religious and very warm. Sometimes it's the most intimate contact I have with someone all day, and I'm really sure that it's their moment of clarity. It's the most clear moment that they have.

**Gil Fronsdal:** How nice. I was at a shopping center nearby once, going in with my young son to get a burrito. Outside the burrito place, there was a man who asked for some money. He said, "I'm hungry, I'd like some money for food." I said, "Oh, I'll buy you food, come with us." He went in and ordered one burrito. I said, "Do you want more? Whatever you want." "No, no, this is enough, that's all." I had it in the back of my mind—I wondered if I offered him anything on the menu, would he go for the most expensive thing? But he just wanted one burrito. I offered for him to come eat with us. "No, no," he said, and he went back outside. So my son and I went outside on the sidewalk, and he was waiting for us. He said, "I'm a poet, and in return for you buying me lunch today, I want to read you one of my poems." He pulled out a torn piece of a brown paper bag where he had written this poem, and it was a beautiful poem. The question was, who gave the biggest gift that day? Was it me giving a burrito, or him reading his poem to me? I think it was me getting the poem. We had a beautiful little exchange.

**Speaker 3:** For me, selfishness was imbued in culture, and parents, and childhood. It's just so common nowadays in our society, and I'm wondering how we can change that. I know that one answer is to be more generous myself. I guess this goes with the dichotomy between self and other, and not wanting to impose on others, but also realizing change starts with myself. I'm curious about your thoughts around that.

**Gil Fronsdal:** Certainly, change starts with yourself. Selfishness is a deeply rooted thing. That's one of the functions of meditation: to really get down to the roots of something like that, understand it, and somehow release it. I also think it's important not to make people feel like it's a crime to be selfish, because some of the sources of selfishness are feelings of inadequacy, feeling wrong, feeling bad. If you shame people, they feel more closed into themselves and protective. I don't know how to change a society, but I think that if you could show people that there are better ways of living than being selfish—give them high-quality experiences, one-on-one and in community. Take them for a walk in the park and show them how much love, delight, and joy there can be that doesn't require getting something. Take them out of their selfish concerns. I don't know, it's a great question. I hope that you can all come be a manager at IMC so that we have more programs and stay open here, so more people can meditate and hopefully become less selfish!

Thank you very much. Whether you know it or not, you gave a gift to all the people who came today just by coming here to meditate. Many of us come here to meditate and to receive the support of others. You offered your presence; even if it's your first time meditating, it was a support for other people to meditate here. So, thank you for your gift.

---

[^1]: **Kuti:** A Pali word for a small hut or cabin used by a Buddhist monk or nun.

[^2]: **Alms round (Piṇḍapāta):** The traditional daily practice of monks walking to receive food offerings from laypeople.

[^3]: **Pasāda:** A Pali term often translated as confidence, joy, or clarity. It refers to a state of mind that is bright, peaceful, and clear.

[^4]: **Itivuttaka 26:** This references a famous teaching of the Buddha on generosity, recorded in the Itivuttaka, a collection of the Buddha's sayings.
