Three Kinds of Happiness
- Date:
- 2019-08-04
- Speakers:
- John Martin [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-19 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Three Kinds of Happiness
It is great to be back here with such a thriving Sangha and hearing about all of the activities during the week as well. The Dharma is really thriving here. So, I was sitting earlier this week, thinking about what to speak about, and a little exchange with someone downtown caused me to decide on speaking on this theme of happiness today.
It's a very simple, ordinary story. I had just had my annual exam in downtown San Francisco, and walking back along Mission Street, I decided I'd call a friend and see if he happened to be free on short notice to get together. I stopped into that beautiful Yerba Buena Gardens, a really nice little park, and stepped in to get all quiet for my phone call. My friend wasn't home, so I just left a message.
I saw people enjoying a beautiful day, sitting on the grass, and then stepped back toward Mission Street. A stranger spoke to me and said, "You look so happy, you must have a lot of money in the bank."
I replied, "Oh, well, no actually. I just have the Dharma."
It was a beautiful reflection. In effect, he held up a mirror for me to see my own happiness in that moment. There was absolutely nothing special going on. I was just present, present to see other people being happy in the park. I was not caught up in being disappointed that my friend didn't answer his phone. Just present. So we open to more and more of these moments of happiness in our lives, whether or not we have a lot of money in the bank.
This is a path of happiness. As Bhikkhu Analayo, the Buddhist monk and scholar, says, this is the path of happiness. There are lots of bumps along the road, but it is a path that leads to a greater happiness.
So today I'll frame the talk on happiness in terms of three kinds of happiness. I think it is important to reflect on happiness and appreciate the happiness that comes forward in our practice, because at times it can seem like there's so much emphasis on dukkha[1], the unreliability of human experience, the emphasis on suffering. So it is good to also reflect and appreciate the happiness and benefits of the practice that come forward.
It's always an inspiration for me in practice that the Buddha—who lived almost 2,600 years ago, a human being who fully realized the truth—was known as the Happy One. Even though he could see the whole mass of suffering of the entire world—not only the suffering of the whole world present in his life, but the suffering of the past, and the suffering of the future—the Buddha could hold it all with a heart of infinite compassion, a heart of perfect wisdom, with a heart of equanimity holding it in balance, and he was still known as the Happy One. He had realized an unconditional happiness, not dependent on any condition of the world.
All of us in our practice, this practice of present awareness, of mindfulness, allows us to open to more happiness in our lives, just with the ordinary experiences of life. Just perhaps going outside—it looks like the sky is blue now, the clouds have cleared—just the happiness of seeing the blue sky. To be present more fully for happiness. To be fully present when we're in nature, when we are present with friends, we are more fully in our direct body experience with this practice of present awareness. So we can enjoy those ordinary moments of life more fully, not so caught up in thinking about the past or thinking about the future.
And then, with our practice, we begin to open to a deeper happiness as we accept the present moment as it is. Kind of no longer being in contention with our present experience, a sense of peace for the present experience just as it is. So we begin to open to a sense of peace, contentment, and calm, perhaps in the midst of being sick. Perhaps even when we read the newspaper and follow all the politics of the world or our country, we begin to find a peace that isn't shaken so much by the external conditions of the world, or by our own individual circumstances of relationships, finances, or health. That's a direction of our practice.
And if we open up to understanding that the present moment experience can't be any different than it is, our hearts also open up, a beautiful benefit of practice. Our hearts open to kindness, compassion, and sympathetic joy. It's a very natural opening of the heart because we're more fully present, more kind to ourselves, more kind to others. Our hearts are responsive to see the suffering of others—the heart of compassion, which wishes suffering to end—and to recognize and feel the joy of others and celebrate that joy, wishing it to continue. It's a very responsive quality of heart that we are cultivating with the practice.
I think of someone like His Holiness the Dalai Lama, where this is manifested so beautifully. He might be in a room full of people, maybe a big hall offering a talk, answering questions, and someone is talking about their experience of suffering. You can see that His Holiness the Dalai Lama feels compassion, is right there to feel the suffering and wishing it to end. And finishing that conversation, His Holiness the Dalai Lama might turn toward seeing a laughing, smiling child, and immediately feel such joy, mudita[2], sympathetic joy.
This is the same quality that opens up in our own hearts in our own practice. Our practice is leading in this direction, toward an unconditional happiness that could be called Buddha nature. In the practice of Insight Meditation, Buddha nature can be understood as the seed of awakening, the potential for awakening within every being. The Buddha acknowledged every being has this potentiality to awaken.
So that's the overall direction of our practice. It may not always seem like this is a path of happiness, right? There is loss. There is pain in life; it's inevitable, as the Buddha acknowledged. And with our practice, we are called upon to just turn toward this. We're called upon to be present for whatever is in awareness. So we might experience sadness, fear, or anger, and the practice calls for us to be fully present for that experience.
There are bumps along the way, but everything that is in our practice is supporting waking up, supporting the opening of the heart, and leading to a greater happiness. As expressed by Archbishop Desmond Tutu, "We are meant to live in joy. This does not mean that life will be easy or painless. It means that we can turn our faces to the wind and accept that this is a storm that we must pass through." So we turn toward the wind, but it leads in the direction of a greater peace and joy, contentment, and happiness.
Three Kinds of Happiness
I'll highlight the three kinds of happiness and then talk a little bit more in detail about them. I'm drawing from the Buddha's discourse in the Samyutta Nikaya 36:31, in which the Buddha speaks about the three kinds of happiness, particularly in the context of deep concentration practice. I'm also speaking from teachings by teacher Phillip Moffitt, one of my teachers. Many of you may know Phillip, who has offered teachings on the three kinds of happiness.
The first kind of happiness is happiness based on conditions of the world, ordinary happiness. Times when our health feels relatively good, times when we feel financially secure. Maybe it's more momentary kinds of ordinary happiness, like enjoying a good meal or having a cup of tea. Or, before I got here this morning, I went to Peet's Coffee in Redwood City and had my espresso. That's my simple pleasure.
The Buddha didn't say these simple, ordinary pleasures of the world are to be rejected. He pointed out that they're ultimately not satisfactory. They're not reliable because they're temporary. So he didn't say they're to be rejected, and in fact, he was teaching a middle way of neither extreme asceticism nor extreme indulgence, but he was pointing toward a deeper happiness.
The second kind of happiness is happiness based on understanding. The attitude of the mind accepts the present experience as it is. Perhaps knowing that in the next moment there may be an appropriate action taken to address a harm or an injustice, but the very present moment can't be different than it is. We begin to find a balance, an acceptance right in the middle of things. This is one of the great benefits of practice. We begin to find a way to be at peace when our body is in discomfort, or when we're not feeling well. We don't get swung around so much by the vicissitudes of life when we have relationship problems, and we don't make our happiness so dependent on specific outcomes.
The challenge for many folks right now is to be happy even in the midst of the difficult political situation in our country. It's very easy to attach our happiness to specific political outcomes we're looking for. It doesn't mean that we don't still work hard for what we believe in, that we don't speak up and take action, but we can open to a peace, an acceptance of the present circumstances. We can actually find greater strength and clarity to take the actions that we think are appropriate.
And then there's a happiness entirely independent of any conditions of the world—the happiness of the Buddha. This is often expressed as the heart freed from all confusion in perfect clarity, perfect wisdom, and all of the beautiful qualities of the heart naturally opening up. I like to emphasize this isn't so far away. We all have moments of this kind of happiness, where we're neither coming nor going, neither leaning into the future nor hanging onto the past. Just fully present in any moment, we do experience this. These moments are great peace.
Foundational Supports for Practice
I'll speak a little bit about foundational supports for our practice that support happiness. It's interesting to reflect that so many of the foundations of practice that the Buddha offered instructions on—that support waking up to see and know things as they are—also provide immediate support for happiness.
The practices of gratitude, generosity, sila (or morality), and the cultivation of loving-kindness all support the waking up process. The Buddha identified these as foundations for practice, but they also bring forth happiness. I'll say a little bit about these factors.
Regarding gratitude, there is a quote from Maya Angelou: "Let gratitude be the pillow upon which you kneel to say your nightly prayer." A beautiful quote on gratitude. When we open to gratitude, we have a sense of enoughness, a sense of contentment. It supports a sense of connection to other beings and supports a deeper letting go to our present experience as it is.
I was really feeling gratitude during this sitting as I was reflecting on this center, and the generosity of all those who supported it and who continue to support it. I was feeling gratitude for having found the Dharma. There are so many things to be grateful for that we love to reflect on. I don't always do it by any means, but taking time, having the intention to reflect with gratitude before every meal, is kind of an underlying intention. Just to pause and acknowledge all of the beings involved in bringing the food that's in front of me to the table.
It's very powerful to reflect on all of the workers in the fields who plant the crops, grow the crops, and harvest the crops. My partner grew up in the Central Valley, and many of his relatives still work in the fields. My partner was a packer, so I now recognize the importance of packers—they pack the grapes. It's a direct connection; he did that when he was in high school. And the truck drivers, people in the warehouses, the grocery stores, and then the miracle of life, this human connection.
The miracle is that very few of us in our lives ever really go hungry. We have a tremendous amount to be grateful for, living in the Bay Area, living in this country. We are also wealthy compared to the rest of the world.
I have two favorite quotes on gratitude from two very wise beings. The first is from Piglet. Piglet noted that even though he had a very small heart, it could hold a rather large amount of gratitude. The second is a beautiful quote from Brother David Steindl-Rast: "It is not happiness that makes us grateful. It's gratefulness that makes us happy." Every moment we open to gratitude, we open to more and more moments of this happiness, of this joy.
And very naturally, what comes forward is generosity. The Buddha offering teachings on generosity is a kind of entry point for people coming into the practice. In my own practice, generosity has become more and more important as I recognize its foundational role in purifying the heart, and as I open to the joy that comes forward when I practice generosity. Not just watching for the impulse to give, but having the underlying intention to always act on that impulse. The Buddha said there is joy in the intention to give, joy in the actual action of giving—whatever form it might take—and joy in the reflection afterwards.
I always encourage folks to bring this into your practice, to reflect on that. Pause when you feel the impulse, and acknowledge the joy you're feeling. Maybe for the six of you who are doing the cleanup here for 15 minutes, if you don't feel joy... when you do feel joy now, reflecting on that impulse to offer time and support for the Sangha. And then, after you leave the center, pause and reflect on whether there is joy that comes forward from your generosity, and having given that time to support the group.
So, sila. Sila is often translated as morality. I really prefer the definition of harmony. I see actions of words, speech, and thought that are rooted in non-harming, rooted in caring for others, as ultimately rooted in a sense of harmony: harmony with our own hearts, harmony with others, harmony with society. I like this understanding that we're in effect harmonizing our hearts, harmonizing our practice, when we practice with sila.
The word morality can have a sense of just conforming to rules, but it's really not about conforming to rules. It's about supporting the purification of our own hearts. And the Buddha said there's a bliss, a happiness, the bliss of blamelessness that comes from practicing sila.
This is something that comes forward in my own practice, and maybe you've felt this in your own practice too. It is the recognition that every single action has a consequence. Everything we do in the world has a consequence, and the more we see this, the more profoundly it impacts us to really commit to being in the world in a non-harming way. We all make mistakes, especially around wise speech. This is especially challenging. We all make mistakes, so that's the aliveness of practice: to catch the mistakes, but having an underlying intention to further purify our actions.
I may have mentioned this some years ago when I was here. A particular turning point in my practice was when I decided to really bring these qualities of the heart—gratitude, generosity, sila, intentions of kindness, and compassion—into the whole of my life, and even into my work life. I had been practicing diligently before that, probably doing seven or eight weeks a year on retreats, but not really practicing much in the rest of my life. In 2007, after a long six-week retreat, I thought, "I just can't continue to work in the world. I really need to be devoting my whole life to the Dharma."
But it wasn't in the cards. I had a partner—still with him—who was not very happy with that. I actually had a job that I liked, so I couldn't quit my job. It wasn't in the cards to become a monk. I decided I just needed to bring the whole of my practice to my life, including especially these qualities of kindness, compassion, and sila. That meant even bringing it into my work life.
Of course, that's what the teachers had been saying the whole time; I hadn't grasped it up until that point. It was transformative, bringing more happiness to my life, and I think a lot more happiness for the people I worked with, and deeply supporting the deepening of practice overall. I started talking about kindness and compassion in the workplace. Some of you may know my job—I loved my job—I was airport director for SFO, the CEO of a very large organization.
When I first started talking about kindness and compassion in the workplace, that was a little bit of a surprise for my staff. Like, "What? What are you doing? This is work." But everybody wants to be connected to the heart. Everybody wants to be seen, and this is where we are seen most clearly—through the heart. It was really transformative for me to bring the practice in this way to the whole of my life, and I have a lot of gratitude for having those nine years where I was in my workplace and bringing the Dharma into the work. I couldn't quite sit and bring the Dharma directly into the work, but I did slip some yoga and meditation rooms into the airport during my tenure there.
The happiness that comes forward when we practice gratitude, generosity, sila, and loving-kindness kind of becomes contagious. Just like when that stranger saw my happiness and reflected it back to me, I felt even happier. Maybe being smiling now, you feel some happiness. It's contagious. It's a great practice to be able to express our happiness to others, to consciously recognize the happiness of others, and maybe reflect it back to them and say, "I see your happiness. I'm happy that you're happy." This is mudita; it's a beautiful practice, really getting the multiplier effects.
Exploring the Three Kinds of Happiness
So, a little bit more about each of the three kinds of happiness. Happiness based on conditions of the world—Phillip Moffitt calls this sukha dukkha[3]. It's happiness, but dukkha, because it's ultimately unreliable.
Again, the Buddha didn't deny this kind of happiness but recognized its unsatisfactoriness. I think it's one of the things that first brought me into the practice twenty years ago. Coming into the practice, I had a good job I liked, I was with my partner that I'm still with after 25 years, but I had a sense that this is ultimately unsatisfactory. There has to be something more.
The ordinary way that most people experience the world is that when they have things going well—if their health is really good—they attach their happiness to having perfect health. People think, "If I can only keep my perfect health, I'll be happy for the rest of my life." It doesn't work that way. There is old age, sickness, and death. "If I can only get my finances just where I want them to be... If my partner and my children would only behave just the way I want them to be, then I could be really happy." It doesn't work that way.
There's an endless stream of suffering that comes from this misunderstanding, thinking we can find ultimate, lasting happiness in the material world. It isn't to be found in the material world. There is happiness in the material world, but it isn't the deeper happiness that the Buddha is pointing to.
We can begin to let go and really enjoy more of these ordinary moments of happiness without a sense of clinging to them. There is a great quote from another wise being, Dr. Seuss: "Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened." We can experience the joy of something but not cling to it. It's a great thing we open to. The Buddha spoke about the vicissitudes of life, all of the ups and downs—the Eight Worldly Winds[4] of praise and blame, gain and loss—and how we can attach to the gain and feel "woe is me" with the loss, and we just get swung around.
I used to really experience this in my job. I remember in the early years, right when I was starting my practice, we had a terrible time at the airport. 9/11 hit, and then United Airlines filed for its first bankruptcy. Some of you may remember the SARS epidemic in Asia. The airport lost 40 percent of our traffic, and our finances were devastated. Loss. "Woe is me."
Other airport director friends around the country called me to console me on the job of an airport director. But around 2003, things started to bounce back. Gain. "Wow, this is great." Attaching to the gain. I came back from a five-day retreat and there was an article in the Chronicle about the airport bouncing back. Fame! Great. There was even a picture of me in the paper.
That very same night, the airport duty manager called me at home and said, "The taxi drivers are picketing. They've taken your photo, blown it up, and put it on their picket signs with a circle around it and a red slash mark." Disrepute.
It was as if I got whacked over the head by this "fame and disrepute." Okay, I'm not going to attach to this anymore. A very good lesson. We learn to be with the ups and downs, to enjoy those good times but not attach to them, and not be so devastated by the difficult times either.
Now, the second kind of happiness comes as we cultivate our practice of present awareness and mindfulness, developing stronger concentration. It is happiness based on the attitude of the mind and understanding. Phillip Moffitt calls this anicca sukha[5], impermanent happiness. It's happiness, but we recognize that it is impermanent. We're not confused. We recognize how little control we actually have over the unfolding moment.
From Sharon Salzberg: "In those moments when we realize how much we cannot control, we can learn to let go." And from Edith Wharton: "If only we'd stop trying to be happy, we could have a pretty good time."
A little example of our practice with this, because it is a very alive practice. I was with a friend for her 65th birthday dinner, and we went to a very nice restaurant with a group of friends. Very expensive, too. I came in with the expectation—there's the warning signal, expectation—that I was going to have a very good meal and very good service. We sat down, and 15 minutes went by; no server came around.
The friends I was with were just having a good time in conversation. They didn't seem to notice, but my mind was caught in clinging. "I'm paying a lot of money, they should provide better service." Finally, a moment of waking up: "Oh, I do have this practice. What's going on? I'm suffering. I'm clinging." And kind of a letting go, returning to the conversation.
The clinging came back again. I compare it sometimes to being like a bouncing basketball; it has to bounce five or six times before it comes to a stop. Eventually, the clinging came to a stop, and I could return to being present with my friends.
Another example of the aliveness of practice: just driving into Redwood City today, I saw a sign that said "Traffic Tickets Available Ahead." I imagined a sign in the roadway right here that says "Peace and Happiness Available Right Now." If we stop clinging, if we stop wanting and needing things to be different, peace is possible in any moment.
In the second stage of happiness, we begin to see the choice point. We see what leads to suffering and what leads to happiness. If we cling to any part of our experience, want to make it permanent, or want to push it away, there is suffering. If we open up and accept the present circumstances as they are, with a sense of balance, it supports a letting go of the sense of self. It opens to the understanding of impermanence, of the changing nature of our experience, and opens to the possibility of peace at any moment.
It supports a deeper understanding. We begin to see the ephemeral nature of every part of our experience. There is nothing we know and love in this world that we can hang on to for lasting happiness. So you begin to see that the letting go itself is what leads to the greatest happiness.
A quote from Ajahn Chah: "Try and be mindful and let things take their natural course, then your mind will become still. Problems will arise, and you will see through them immediately. This is the happiness of the Buddha."
Equanimity also begins to come forward with a deeper understanding that recognizes "it's like this." There's a quality of being right in the middle of things, a sense of balance and acceptance. I think I just have time to tell a story about when we open to equanimity.
When equanimity comes forward... I think we all have equanimity arising in our lives. We couldn't be in the world and live through the sickness and deaths of loved ones if we weren't able to bring in a quality of equanimity that holds things in balance, accepting things as they are, even as we experience grief.
Just to touch on this, from my experience as airport director: in 2013, we had the Asiana plane crash. It was a very powerful benefit of my practice to see equanimity very naturally arising in that crisis. I felt a sense of peace right in the middle of the shock of learning about the crash. And then I felt very calm, actually changing from my gardening clothes to different clothes to go into work to respond to the emergency. I wasn't panicked.
Equanimity has a heart quality. I felt the real quivering of the heart, the tears, as I drove down to the airport and saw all of the ambulances going to San Francisco General. And I felt an even greater peace as I arrived at the airport Emergency Operations Center. It was so moving to see everybody doing the best they could. I think we're always doing the best we can. It was so clear with the balance of equanimity: everyone there doing the best they could to save lives. I was very grateful for the practice, to feel that support.
I remember, too, walking in two hours later. We had a press conference, and I didn't know how many people had died or were seriously injured. There were 65 TV cameras—I didn't even know there were 65 TV cameras in the Bay Area—and probably 120 reporters. I felt a little nervous at first, and recognized how little I knew, that I really would have to say, "I don't know."
In a moment, from a place of equanimity, I could look through the lenses of the cameras and see millions of people on the other end who'd seen news stories around the world, knowing that tens of millions of people were naturally wishing well. That natural wish for kindness and compassion coming forward. And in that moment I felt safe. I felt safe that I could be vulnerable, acknowledge what I didn't know, and let my heart be seen too.
So it inspires my own practice in daily life to cultivate equanimity in every moment of my life. Recognizing the clarity, the groundedness that comes forward as we cultivate equanimity. Acceptance is a first step toward deeper equanimity.
The Happiness of the Buddha
The third kind of happiness is a happiness entirely free of any condition of the world: the happiness of the Buddha. The ultimate direction of the practice, with the cessation of suffering—the Third Noble Truth—that peace is possible.
From Thich Nhat Hanh: "Letting go gives us freedom, and freedom is the only condition for happiness. If, in our heart, we still cling to anything—anger, anxiety, or possessions—we cannot be free."
That release is pointing directly the way toward freedom, to non-clinging. There is this unshakeable peace at the deepest level that can be opened to with practice, but we can open to it at any moment. Any moment we can experience this peace when there is non-clinging.
I always encourage folks to appreciate those moments; I think we often miss them. It might be a moment in nature, maybe watching a beautiful sunset. When we're watching a beautiful sunset, we know we can't hang on to it, so there's no hanging on. Maybe there's no thought in that moment, just seeing the beauty. No thoughts of the past, no thoughts of the future. The mind of peace. There might be a moment of freedom right there.
Maybe it's just a time with loved ones. Sometimes I've experienced moments like that watching modern dance, just everything else seeming to drop away. Those are moments of freedom that we should appreciate, for they do support the practice overall, leading toward that deeper, unshakeable kind of happiness that can arise at the deepest level of practice.
Reflections
Perhaps this framework is helpful for your practice, these three kinds of happiness. I encourage you to really recognize and appreciate the happiness that arises in your practice, to share your happiness, and celebrate the happiness of others.
To close with a quote from Guillaume Apollinaire—thank you for the pronunciation help—"Now and then it's good to pause in our pursuit of happiness to just be happy." [Laughter]
Thank you for your attention. We should probably end by closing our eyes for a moment to offer the merit of our practice, the merit of our time together, to be for the benefit of all beings. May our practice, may our presence in the world be for the benefit of all beings without exception. May it be so.
Dukkha: A Pali word often translated as "suffering," "stress," or "unsatisfactoriness." ↩︎
Mudita: A Pali word translated as "sympathetic joy" or "appreciative joy," taking delight in the happiness and well-being of others. ↩︎
Sukha Dukkha: A phrase combining sukha (happiness or pleasure) and dukkha (suffering or unsatisfactoriness), pointing to the truth that worldly happiness is inherently bound up with suffering because it is impermanent. ↩︎
Eight Worldly Winds (or Conditions) describes four pairs of universal opposites that constantly buffet human experience, keeping us bound to suffering unless met with wisdom and equanimity: Gain and Loss, Fame and Disrepute, Praise and Blame, and Pleasure and Pain. ↩︎
Anicca Sukha: Combining anicca (impermanence) and sukha (happiness), meaning a happiness derived from understanding and accepting the impermanent nature of reality. ↩︎