Moon Pointing

Bringing Caring-ful Attention to Dukkha

Date:
2019-10-21
Speakers:
Tanya Wiser [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-09 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Bringing Caring-ful Attention to Dukkha

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Bringing Caring-ful Attention to Dukkha

Introduction

Hey, how's the volume? My voice is a little soft, so we might need it up a little bit. To me, what's important is that I'm a spiritual friend. In terms of introductions, that's what I'm here to do tonight, is to be a spiritual friend. More than anything, that's my hope and intention. Something else that might be helpful to know about me is that I'm a therapist, so I tend to bring some of that language and perspective into sharing the Dharma.

Tonight, what I want to talk about is bringing love to our experience of dukkha[1]. Who knows what dukkha means? Okay, some not so much. Dukkha is a Pali[2] term that's often thought of as the word "suffering." You've all heard the word "suffering." The nice thing about this word "dukkha" is that it doesn't have the same associations in language for us as the word "suffering." With "suffering," we often think about things that are really difficult, hard, painful, and unwanted. But dukkha has a much broader meaning. Truly, the definition that the Buddha intended had a much broader feel. It encompasses everything from stress to discontent, to being slightly troubled or irritated, uneasy, to pretty horrible things. So I use the term dukkha to reference all of those states. There can be very subtle states of not liking and discomfort, to extreme ones.

I want to say again, this idea is to bring love to our experience, to our relationship with the dukkha, to our stress, to our suffering. I'm not asking you to love what's causing you pain necessarily, but rather to bring love to your experience when you're relating to things that cause dukkha. The reason that I'm wanting to share this topic is that for me, my relationship to my suffering—what energy I bring to it—can be like a linchpin. A linchpin is a pin that goes through the center of an axle to keep a wheel in its place, and it also can mean something that's indispensable. Our relationship to how we experience difficulty and stress is really quite amazingly powerful and, in fact, indispensable on the path to freedom from suffering.

The Buddha teaches and says in some of his suttas that bringing careful attention to suffering was the key to his awakening. When we find that we're suffering, when we recognize the presence of suffering and we start to relate to that with this kind of caring-ful or loved attention, our relationship to suffering can start to change. What can start to happen is that as we bring loving-kindness and wisdom to our experience of suffering, it starts to change what happens. And as that starts to happen, faith starts to develop that if we relate and attend differently, it's going to help. When that starts to happen and we start to develop this faith, there's something else that comes, which is this sense of gladness.

I remember a very clear moment on a retreat where I recognized that I started to get happy and glad when I would see my own suffering. It was quite a surprising thing to recognize that by carefully attending over time and developing this faith, the reward was just increasing in its bounty in the sense of this gladness. This excitement would be like, "Oh wow, I'm seeing my suffering! Oh my goodness, what is going on?" But it's held true. It's been a beautiful support, and this is what the Buddha discovered and taught, and this is the right way of going. My hope is that I'll share some of that joy with you tonight, and that I'll inspire whatever in you wants to bring suffering to an end for yourself and for others, or maybe both even.

The Three Kinds of Suffering

If all goes as planned—and who knows—I'm going to share some parts of some suttas and talk a little bit about my relationship to the story and what it brings out for me. First, I'm going to talk a little bit more about the Buddha and this turning towards suffering, and then some suttas. If we get there, maybe we'll explore the idea of cultivating careful attention, you know, love toward our dukkha. And if we really get there, maybe we'll even start talking about the right way of going and transcendental dependent arising. Who knows where we'll go!

The Buddha was really interested in understanding suffering. He asked, "What is it? Why do we suffer?" He really wanted to figure it out. There's this sutta called "Suffering." There's something about the rhythm and the words that are shared that I think communicate this energy. He's talking to Sāriputta[3], one of the other monks, and he says, "Friend Sāriputta, it is said, 'Suffering, suffering.' What now is suffering?"

"There are, friend, these three kinds of suffering: the suffering due to pain, the suffering due to formations (meaning the mental thinking that we do and the conditions in life that are all forming), and the suffering due to change. These are the three kinds of suffering." "But friend, is there a path? Is there a way for the full understanding of these three kinds of suffering?" "Yes, friend, there is a way for the full understanding of these three kinds of suffering." "What is it, friend?" "It is this Noble Eightfold Path[4]; that is, Right View, Right Intention, Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood, Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, and Right Concentration."

The Buddha was really motivated to figure out and solve the problem of distress in the world. There's a sutta that comes before the one I read in terms of timing in the Buddha's life, before he was enlightened. He was saying, "Alas, this world has fallen into trouble." He goes on to ask, "When now will an escape be discerned from this suffering?" And then he says, "Through careful attention, there took place in me a breakthrough by wisdom." So it was by turning toward this distress, toward suffering, with this careful attention that his breakthrough occurred, that he became enlightened. He says there was this right way of going, this Noble Eightfold Path, and the Four Noble Truths are part of that. He also said there's a wrong way of going, and the right way of going provides the solution to the problem.

There were many people in his time doing all these spiritual practices. I'm not a scholar, right? I read the suttas, and then I'll call my friends that are scholars and ask, "What about this? What about that?" So I can't speak as a scholar. Again, I'm your spiritual friend who's curious and interested here. I just want to be really clear that that's where I'm speaking from. But this is a pretty profound thing. Everybody else was doing all these practices, and the Buddha was the one that said, "This suffering thing, we've got to figure out what's going on here." So I feel indebted to him, and I'm really grateful.

When I was contemplating the Buddha saying, "Yes, this was important to attend to," I found this other sutta. It's a story about a monk named Rādha. He was sitting, and a group of wanderers approached him. After exchanging polite greetings, they sat to one side and asked the venerable Rādha, "For what sake have you gone forth to cultivate the holy life under the recluse Gotama?" The venerable Rādha replied, "I have gone forth to cultivate the holy life under the Blessed One for the sake of abandoning dukkha." They asked him again, and he said, "I have gone forth to cultivate the holy life for the sake of abandoning dukkha." When he said a little bit more about that, they didn't really like hearing this. They were not pleased in their minds. They rose from their seats, blamed him, and left.

He sat for a bit longer, and then he thought, "I better go talk to the Buddha. Maybe I messed up here. Maybe I got this all wrong." So he goes to the Buddha, pays respects, and tells the Buddha the complete story. He asked, "Blessed One, having proceeded to speak in this way, did I not incur a fault? Did I not misrepresent the Buddha?" He essentially expressed this doubt and concern that maybe he didn't get it right. But the Buddha said to him, "You spoke truthfully. You did not misrepresent the Tathāgata[5]. You spoke as you should speak. You spoke according to the Dharma. Speaking the Dharma in accordance with the Dharma, what is that, Rādha? Bodily form is dukkha. One goes forth under me to cultivate the holy life for the sake of abandoning that dukkha." Rādha was happy to hear this; he was relieved.

As I was contemplating this sutta, I thought, "This is very clear. I appreciate this." I was thinking about these different people. Sometimes I relate to dukkha like it's not important. When am I one of those visiting wanderers, thinking that when dukkha comes up, I don't really think it's that important? Yeah, that happens. I don't always find within myself this aspiration, this joy, to treat my dukkha with love. So I appreciated the sutta from this perspective as well. Rādha got it right, and it's easy to doubt yourself, and it's easy to be the doubter. Sometimes, maybe I can really see that yes, this is the purpose of the holy life; this is the purpose of this practice.

Appropriate vs. Inappropriate Attention

There's another sutta that I want to share, and it's about going to the opposite of careful attention: inappropriate attention. It goes like this—are you enjoying the stories? I like the stories; I think they're cool. I've heard that on one occasion, a certain monk was dwelling in a forest thicket. Now at that time, he spent the days thinking evil, unskillful thoughts—thoughts of sensuality, thoughts of ill-will, thoughts of doing harm. Then a devata[6] inhabiting the forest thicket, feeling sympathy for the monk, desiring his benefit, desiring to bring him to his senses, approached him and addressed him with this verse: "From inappropriate attention, you're being chewed by your thoughts." I like that, right? That feels right.

"Relinquishing what's inappropriate, contemplate appropriately, keeping your mind on the Teacher, the Dharma, the Sangha, your virtues. You will arrive at joy, rapture, pleasure without doubt. Then, saturated with joy, you will put an end to suffering and stress." The monk, chastened by the devata, came to his senses.

So we've got this idea of careful attention, which I'm going to flesh out a little bit more here, and the opposite, inappropriate attention, which in the sutta is defined as "being chewed by your thoughts." I really like that; it feels like what happens. It means focusing on inappropriate things like lust, ill will, and doing harm, just getting consumed by those things. They work on us and chew on us.

So what is careful attention? First of all, one of the things I noticed immediately with this term "careful attention" was how much I'd heard that. I'd heard people say, "Be careful, be careful." I noticed in myself a sense of contracting a little bit, like, "Yeah, I know I need to be careful." Just like we say it a lot to kids: "Be careful." We have people who worry about us; they say, "Be careful." There's a certain worry or anxiety that comes with this term often. In fact, when I looked at the definition, it includes a lot of these kinds of words.

But this is our language, not the Buddha's language. The term is yoniso manasikāra[7], and "careful attention" to us probably means something different than it did in the Buddha's time. Partly because I find that if I am just careful with my dukkha, it doesn't help. It's not enough to just be careful; it needs to be full of caring. Sometimes for me, it's really helpful to do this with language a little bit. We'll hear "careful attention" in the Dharma, we'll be told to bring careful attention to our experience. I don't know what your relationship is to the word "careful," but for me, it was worth really emphasizing and bringing in this idea of something that's more closely akin to love.

I was thinking about how we're sitting here together in this room. What would happen if all of our dukkha could become visible and seen right now? How many of the things that we're suffering around would we see mirrored in other people that we can't see right now? Maybe just taking a moment to acknowledge: I suffer, you suffer, we suffer. Dukkha happens, stress happens, difficulty happens for everybody sitting here. It's something we all share. And I just wonder, how often do I bring true, real caring, loving attention to my dukkha? There's so much of it, right? So much subtle dukkha. How about you? How about when you're encountering someone else's dukkha? Someone else's suffering might be easier for you or harder for you at different times, or depending on the person.

The Dukkha of Pain, Change, and Formations

What can inspire us to bring a caring-ful attention? I know that for me, I have a few simple things that help me with different kinds of dukkha at different times. Earlier I mentioned that the Buddha said there were three kinds of suffering, three kinds of dukkha. I'll share these with you.

One is the dukkha of pain, pain born of pain. The idea here is not that it shouldn't hurt when we get a shot—that's just a normal part of life. But how we relate to getting a shot is what the Buddha is talking about, preventing us from adding to that pain. For example, at some point as an adult, I had to get an immunization and I braced my arm. Do not do it! It was unbelievable that I was anticipating the pain of an immunization, but this was like crazy bad pain that lasted a really long time. It did not pass; it was hanging out. My tensed muscles, my resistance to the pain, just made my suffering much worse. The reference I like for this kind of suffering is: pain times resistance equals our suffering. You're going to get a flat tire, you're going to have emotional pain and physical pain. However much we resist it, the pain times our resistance is how much suffering we're going to have. That was a lot of suffering for an immunization that really could have been over in a blink.

Then there's the pain associated with change. We don't like it when pleasant moments pass, or good things like vacations end, and people die. All these things in our life are constantly changing. For me, I really like this connection: on some highways, like on Highway 1, on the side of the road if you go off too far, there are these bumps called rumble strips. It goes rumble rumble rumble. To me, this is like that dukkha of change. There's an experience in the body that just wakes you up. And that's the gift of dukkha coming up sometimes—it wakes you up to what's going on. A lot of times I relate to the dukkha of change as a rumble strip waking me up. Yep, you get sick. Yep, people die. Yep, all these things happen. Be thankful for those rumble strips so you don't go off the road.

And then the third kind of suffering has to do with formations, the upkeep of life, the stories that we create and tell ourselves. It's also just the relentlessness of life—like, "I've got to clean again? Are you kidding? And then cook, and then eat, and then go to bed, and have to set my alarm, and go to work, and do this..." It's just this relentlessness. And then the relentlessness of our thinking and ruminating mind, how we can get going. For me, the inspirational way of relating to that, that helps me find love, is this quote by Jane Hirshfield[8], a Zen practitioner and poet: "Suffering is to beauty as thirst is to water." Suffering is to beauty as thirst is to water.

Essentially, in its most simple form, when we get thirsty, it's our body telling us we need to get something to drink; we need to take care of our body. In this very simple way, if we can pay attention to when we have suffering, and we bring a kind and loving attention to it, it can help us not increase our suffering. It can help us bring this wise, kind attention to our experience that can lead to faith, gladness, joy, and much more. But the other thing I like about this quote is that we don't always listen to our thirst, do we? We don't always go get water when we're thirsty. In fact, if I did that, I'd be taking a drink right now. And so I will.

We can ignore it. We don't pay attention to it. It's not going to lead us to beauty if we're ignoring our thirst, not paying attention, not listening. Not being receptive to what signals we're getting is not going to help us take care of our body. Not only that, but if we're really not in a good mind state, we might go get a Diet Coke or coffee instead of drinking water, which makes us dehydrated. We're thirsty, but we drink something that makes us more dehydrated. In the same way, we can sort of ignore our suffering and do the wrong things that try to address it but don't really help and can make it worse. Does that make sense?

What I like about this saying is that it really is true: it can lead to great beauty, just like thirst can lead to water. We have to be paying attention, we have to be willing to listen, and then we have to be willing to respond in a careful and wise way to what's coming up for us. This suffering of formations is something that can be so chronic and so steady. It's very easy to get into a place where we aren't really attending to it in the way that we could.

A Personal Story of Formations

I thought I'd tell a simple story that highlights this process. A situation came up in my life where I was really grateful that I was able to attend to it without regret. My 19-year-old daughter had gone off to college, and she came back for the summer and said, "I'm not going back." As a parent, it's a big deal. First of all, you want your kid to go off and be successful. You don't want them home making a mess and being unhappy. But this is part of growing up, people having to find their right way. It really wasn't something I was expecting, and I noticed that a lot of stuff was coming up for me. I was feeling pretty upset and afraid. There was this fear coming up, and this clinging to the idea of wanting her to stay in school.

I couldn't become the mom that pushed and said, "No, you have to do this, you have to go to school, you have to stay." Or I could become the mom that says, "Okay, I have to back up, let go of what I'm wanting to have happen, and figure out how to support this person who's finding their own path." That was a linchpin moment. I could see my own suffering was what I wanted, what I was clinging to. I was craving for her to have this experience, and for me to be this mom that helps her go do these things. But I could see that if I did that, I would regret it. It was going to put distance between myself and my daughter, it was very unlikely to be successful, and it was going to create a lot of conflict. So that was a moment of bringing a lot of love, care, and attention to myself and to her.

This changed so much of what started to happen between her and I, and in our relationship. It allowed for her to have faith in me that I could support her. It created a sense of gladness and relief in me because I didn't have to regret how I acted or how I behaved. I found in myself a capacity to trust in her goodness, to trust in her capacity, and to trust that she would find her own way. There was a lot of joy in that, and a lot of ease came from that process of accepting and not fighting, and happiness because she was happy. She could feel supported, she felt heard, she felt seen. Love happens, intimacy happens.

This is what the Buddha says is the right way of going. When we start to relate to our suffering, and our clinging, and our creating of these things with caring-ful attention, one stage flows into the next. One stage fills up the next stage, going from the near shore to the far shore, and it can take us to freedom in practice and in life.

A Discourse on Volition

This is a discourse on volition. It's related to this, and I wanted to read this as we're coming to an end, almost like a meditation, to invite you to see and feel if you resonate with any part of this progressive process. Sometimes when I'm working with clients, I see this starting to happen for them. They'll come back and say, "Hey Tanya, I noticed this thing, and I'm starting to trust." There's the faith, right? And then there's this gladness. And with the gladness comes this energy to address and be present, and to stay on this path. Just see if anything comes up for you.

"Bhikkhus[9], for a virtuous person, one whose behavior is virtuous, no volition need be exerted: 'Let non-regret arise in me.' It is natural that non-regret arises in a virtuous person. For one without regret, no volition need be exerted: 'Let gladness arise in me.' It is natural that gladness arises in one without regret. For one who is glad, no volition need be exerted: 'Let joy arise in me.' It is natural that joy arises in one who is glad. For one with a joyous mind, no volition need be exerted: 'Let my body be tranquil.' It is natural that the body of one with a joyous mind is tranquil. For one with a tranquil body, no volition need be exerted: 'Let me feel happiness.' It is natural that one tranquil in body feels happiness. For one feeling happiness, no volition, no effort is needed: 'Let my mind be concentrated.' It is natural that the mind of one feeling happiness is concentrated. For one who is concentrated, no volition need be exerted: 'Let me know and see things as they really are.' It is natural that one who is concentrated knows and sees things as they really are. For one who knows and sees things as they really are, no volition need be exerted: 'Let me be disenchanted and dispassionate.' It is natural that one who knows and sees things as they really are is disenchanted and dispassionate—freed from lust, freed from getting enchanted with our ideas, notions, and fears. For one who is disenchanted and dispassionate, no volition need be exerted: 'Let me realize the knowledge and vision of liberation.' It is natural that one who is disenchanted and dispassionate realizes the knowledge and vision of liberation."

"Just as, bhikkhus, when rain pours down in thick droplets on a mountaintop, the water flows down along the slope and fills the clefts, gullies, and creeks; these being full fill up the pools; these being full fill up the lakes; these being full fill up the streams; these being full fill up the rivers; and these being full fill up the great ocean. So too, with ignorance as a proximate cause, mental formations come to be, and consciousness..."

But when we come to suffering, and we see suffering with this caring-ful attention, faith can arise. Non-regret can arise, and this whole process of gladness, joy, tranquility, happiness, and concentration—they can flow. May they flow in you. Thank you.



  1. Dukkha: A Pali word often translated as "suffering," "stress," or "unsatisfactoriness." ↩︎

  2. Pali: The language of the early Buddhist scriptures. ↩︎

  3. Sāriputta: One of the two chief male disciples of the Buddha. ↩︎

  4. Noble Eightfold Path: An early summary of the path of Buddhist practices leading to liberation from samsara, consisting of eight practices: Right View, Right Resolve, Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood, Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, and Right Concentration. ↩︎

  5. Tathāgata: An honorific title for the Buddha, meaning "one who has thus gone" or "one who has thus come." ↩︎

  6. Devata: A generic term for a deity or spirit in Buddhism and Hinduism. ↩︎

  7. Yoniso manasikāra: A Pali term typically translated as "careful attention," "wise attention," or "appropriate attention." ↩︎

  8. Jane Hirshfield: (b. 1953) An American poet, essayist, and translator, known for her Zen Buddhist background and writings on poetry and spiritual practice. ↩︎

  9. Bhikkhus: Fully ordained male Buddhist monastics. ↩︎