Moon Pointing

The Present Moment is Not the Goal

Date:
2019-09-29
Speakers:
Ajaan Thanissaro [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-08 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
The Present Moment is Not the Goal

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

The Present Moment is Not the Goal

I was in France a couple months back teaching. Toward the end of my stay, I was waiting in front of a hotel to be taken to a Dharma group in Paris to teach, and I suddenly realized this is my first time in France without a translator nearby. And the thought occurred to me, what if someone asked you a question? And sure enough, there was a telephone line worker working with a crew on the street across the way. He saw me, came up, and said, "Marvelous, marvelous, you're just the person I want to see. I've got this miserable job, I'm surrounded by dishonest people. This Buddha doesn't make you happy."

And I said, "Yes."

"How does it do that?"

"Okay." And so I talked about generosity and virtue, and this is all very pidgin French. And for me, generosity, virtue, meditation...

"How do you meditate?"

So I said, "We have a website." [Laughter]

I gave him the address and he shook my hand. The irony of all this was that I was on my way to the center to give a talk on the topic I'm going to talk about today, which is that the present moment is not the goal of the practice.

When I got there I mentioned the story to the people in the room. I said, you know, if I had told him that you could be happy simply by accepting the present moment, accepting your miserable job, accepting your dishonest friends, he would have walked away. He would have had good sense. Unfortunately, that is not the message that the Buddha teaches. When the Buddha does talk about being in the present moment, he never says to just hang out in the present and be fully present in the present moment. It's always in the context of death contemplation. Death could happen at any time, and there are duties that have to be done. If you don't do them now, they're not going to get done.

So today I'd like to talk a little bit about what these duties are in the present moment and where they actually aim. We focus on the present moment because we are creating suffering in the present moment, and we want to learn how to stop. It comes from our actions, and so it's important to understand the Buddha's take on what exactly we are doing in the present and how that shapes our experience.

When the Buddha described his teaching to distinguish it from other teachings that were available in India at the time, he called it Kammavāda[1], which means a teaching or a doctrine of karma. Now, we may have heard that everybody in India believed in karma and rebirth. That's not the case. It was a controversial topic, and there were some people who thought there was no rebirth. Other people thought there was no karma, or there is karma but it has no effect on your life. Some people thought there was both karma and rebirth, but they said karma doesn't affect your rebirth; you just get reborn willy-nilly dependent on fate or the will of a creator god. And so the Buddha, in calling himself a Kammavādin, was basically making two points: that karma is real, and it also is effective.

But he also differentiated himself from other teachers who taught karma, particularly a group called the Niganthas[2], who were the forerunners of the Jains. There were two points of difference in the way the Buddha taught karma and the way the Jains did. The first was how your present karma shapes the present moment. The second was which kind of karma is most effective: physical or mental. The Jains said your present moment experience is totally shaped by the past. You simply have to accept the fact that you're being presented with this experience, and you accept the experience. If you want to speed up the end of your time here in samsara[3], you undergo austerities in order to bring on basically more painful karma, so you can burn off your old past bad karma. That was basically their teaching on karma.

We tend to think of the Buddha as being very polite, friendly, and gentle, but when he talked about the Jains, he tended to ridicule them. He went to visit some Jains, and it's interesting that the Buddha was not the kind of person to go out and pick fights, but he did go and confront them. He said, "Do you really teach karma like this, that you cannot shape your present moment with your present actions?" And they said, "Yeah."

"And these austerities that you do, have you ever noticed that when you're doing austerities you have pain, right? Have you ever noticed when you stop doing the austerities you don't have pain? In other words, what you're doing right now has a big impact on the extent to which you're going to suffer."

The other difference, of course, was that he taught that it's your mental karma that is the most important, because after all, it's through your intentions that you decide to do various things. And so this is why we meditate and focus on the present moment. It's because our present moment actions are shaping our experience of pleasure and pain in the present moment. We want to see why it is we are creating suffering. I mean, nobody wants to create suffering, and yet we keep doing it again and again. So we have to look into why is it we're doing this.

By focusing on the present moment—focusing on the mind in the present moment—the Dharma teaches us what to accept. There are influences coming in from the past; we can't go back and change our past karma. But we also have the ability to do something about this raw material coming in from the past. We're actually taking the raw material provided by past actions and shaping it into our present experience. So we have a choice in how we're going to shape that material. And that's something we also have to accept, that we are playing a role in this, so we have to look in to see what role it is that we're playing.

So the Buddha tells us what not to accept in addition to what we're doing that's unskillful. He doesn't accept a lazy and defeatist attitude. Suffering does have a source, but it doesn't really come from your past actions; it comes from what you're doing right now. And the teacher's duty from the Buddhist point of view is to give you a basis for deciding what you should and should not be doing in the present moment. This reflects the active nature of the mind, that we are constantly doing things in the present moment. His role as a teacher is to give us some guidance on what are some good choices to make here in the present moment.

When he would start people out, he would start them talking and thinking about what he later called the practice of merit. In other words, being generous, being virtuous, and learning to meditate to get to know your own mind so that you can see that you can take an active role in shaping your life for the better. As I told the telephone line worker, try to be generous, try to be more virtuous, try to meditate. These things will give you a handle on how you can stop suffering so much from the present moment. But as you do that, you begin to get some insight into the fact that even skillful present karma is something that constantly needs to be done. There is no point where you ever have enough good karma in the present moment; you're constantly having to shape the present moment.

This is why the present moment can be a part of a path, but it's not the goal. It's like a house that's constantly under construction. You know that house down in San Jose they never finished? Well, your house is different, because your house is constantly falling down. It has to constantly be repaired and put together again. And in the Buddhist image, it's not only falling apart, but it's also burning. It's burning with suffering, so you can't just stay in the present moment and say, "Okay, I'll learn how to accept the fact that I'm burning." The Buddha says there is a way out.

In preparation for my trip to France, I got online and was watching a weekly TV program called Sagesses Bouddhistes. I can imagine the United States having a weekly TV program where they interview a Buddhist teacher. They have that in France, and I was amazed to discover... you know what you do when you're struggling to learn the language, and then you hear garbage in the language, it's kind of frustrating. But there was a lot of garbage on Sagesses Bouddhistes. There was this one teacher on there one time who was saying the whole purpose of the practice is to learn how to accept things as they are. That you can't really do anything about going against the way of nature, and happiness lies in acceptance. And the interviewer, who was normally a very gentle and sort of motherly-like character, got curious: "But isn't that defeatist? Too pessimistic?" And the woman being interviewed said, "Only if you think about it." [Laughter]

Well, the Buddha is not the sort of person to tell you to stop thinking. He says your suffering is what makes you think to begin with. I mean, if we didn't suffer, we wouldn't need to think, right? But it's the fact that we're suffering that got us thinking, to figure things out. And the Buddha says, "Okay, learn how to think skillfully." When you look at the images the Buddha gives of people who are on the path, there's never the image of somebody sort of sitting back and just accepting. It's always images of people who are searching, people who are engaged in battle, people who are trying to develop a skill. In other words, trying to learn how to be more skillful in how they shape the present moment. He actually calls the Noble Eightfold Path the unexcelled victory in battle. So there's a battle that can be won, and there's work to be done.

That's why when the Buddha is talking about being in the present moment, or focusing on the present moment, it's in the context of realizing there is a battle that's going on, it can be won, you don't have much time, and you have to do it super fast. So focus on right now.

There's one famous poem in Majjhima Nikaya 131 that starts out saying this: "You shouldn't chase after the past or place expectations on the future. What is past is left behind, the future is as yet unreached. Whatever quality is present, you clearly see right there, right there. Not taken in, unshaken, that's how you develop the heart. Okay, so focus on it then, ardently doing your duty today. For who knows tomorrow, death? There's no bargaining with Death and his mighty horde."

And in other suttas where the Buddha focuses on the present moment, there was one case where he told the monks they should practice heedfulness and think about death frequently. One monk says, "I think about death once a day." Another monk says, "I think about it twice a day." A third one says, "I think about it four times a day." And then it got to shorter and shorter periods of time. Finally it gets to two monks. One says, "While I'm eating my food, I think, may I live for as long as it takes to chew this morsel of food, so I can do good things in the practice." Another monk says, "May I live long enough to finish this breath, so I can accomplish great things in this practice." And the Buddha says, "Okay, those last two monks are heedful. Everybody else is heedless."

So it's not that you are just being in the present moment; there's something to be done in the present moment. And the Buddha gives you another example. He says every night—and this is why you're thinking about death twice a day—every night when the sun sets, remind yourself, "I could die tonight. Am I ready to go? Are there any qualities in my mind that would make it difficult for me to let go? And if so, focus on working on those qualities, abandoning those causes of suffering." The same thing in the morning when the sun rises: "This could be my last sunrise. I could die today." And he gives a list of various ways where it's very easy to die in the course of a day. And then he says, "Am I ready to go? If not, there's work I've got to do right now."

These duties that the Buddha is referring to here, of course, are the duties that come under the Four Noble Truths. There is suffering. Okay, what is the suffering? You want to comprehend it. Now, comprehending means understanding it totally, to the point of dispassion toward it. We tend not to think that we are passionate for our suffering, but there are a lot of things we do that create suffering, but we just hold on to them. We say that the suffering doesn't matter, "This is something I've got to do or I want to do." And the Buddha would want you to look carefully at that. Do you see that you're doing this, you're causing yourself suffering? Is it worth doing it? That's the duty with regard to the first noble truth.

The second noble truth is the cause of suffering, and that's craving. That should be abandoned. When you see the cause of suffering, that's what you let go of. Now most of us get these duties confused. We try to let go of the suffering. Clinging to something, we say, "Well, let go." Well, first you understand what induced you to cling to begin with? What was the desire or the joy? That's what you let go of. Otherwise it's like going into a house, seeing the house is filled with smoke, and you put out the smoke. Well, you can keep putting out the smoke, it's not going to stop. You've got to find where the fire is, put out the fire, and then you're done.

The duty with the third noble truth, which is the cessation of suffering, is to realize it. That's basically realizing the point when you finally do let go of the craving. At first you see this in moments when you let go of a particular craving, there was a moment where the suffering ceases. But the Buddha says ultimately there is a point where you stop the craving entirely, and that's the end of the suffering. You have dispassion for it, so you try to realize that.

And then there's the path. The path is to be developed. All the factors from right view through right concentration are things that you work on. Now as you work on following these duties, you find more detail on exactly what's going on here in the present moment. The Buddha describes this in some of the steps in dependent co-arising. There are a lot of steps that come prior to sensory contact, and even prior to sensory consciousness. If you look at the list, half of them come prior to just the fact that a sight hits you or a sound comes to you. You're already working to create suffering for yourself. Or, if you do these processes with knowledge, you're actually creating a path so that no matter what comes in through your senses, you're not going to suffer. So you want to look at what is it that you bring to the present moment.

The Buddha talks about the process of fabrication. We fabricate what he calls the five aggregates: the aggregate of form, which is your sense of your body; feeling, feeling tones of pleasure and pain, or neither pleasure nor pain; perceptions, which are the labels and images that you use to communicate "what this is" and "that's that," like instant text messaging in your mind; fabrications, where you put thoughts together; and consciousness, which is the act of knowing or being aware. All these things, the Buddha says, are fabricated. In fact, they are fabricated from your potentials, and we do them for the sake of something. When we're in the present moment, we don't just sit in the present moment. We're fabricating these things for a particular purpose.

So the arrow of time is already embedded right there in the present moment. Sometimes you hear people saying, "Well, you get into the present moment, you step out of time." It's not the case. In the present moment you are still fashioning things for the sake of something. Usually, you hope for happiness. Even when your mind is just being the knowing in the present, you're fabricating that consciousness aggregate and taking on an identity with it. What this shows, of course, is that the mind is active. In other words, we're not just passively accepting contact coming in. We're right out there. We're usually looking for trouble, but we're out there looking for something. Which is why the Buddha has us look for the causes of suffering inside, rather than say, "Well, let's change the world outside and people will stop suffering." You know, to say, "Well, what is everybody bringing to the present moment that's why they're suffering?"

In fact, what we bring to the present moment actually comes prior to our experience of old karma. It's interesting, new karma is our immediate experience; the results of old karma that come in through the senses come afterwards. So these things include the way we talk to ourselves, the images we create. They have a more immediate reality for us than the events we get through the senses. So you have to focus on the fact that the present moment is something that is under construction, and it's moving through time.

You get some people saying, "Well, I'm going to hang out in the present moment. I'm not going to care about what the results are of my practice." There are some schools of meditation that actually pride themselves saying that our school of meditation has no purpose at all, so we just sit in the present moment. They think it's a higher level of practice because it shows a lack of concern for the future. But you're turning a blind eye to the fact that you are creating causes for the future by the way you interact with your present moment.

Now, just as the mind is proactive in its engagement in the present moment, there is a proactive role for the path in shaping your present aggregates. Right resolve, right effort, right mindfulness, right concentration—these are all purposeful activities. With right resolve, you make up your mind, "I am not going to act in ways that are based on sensuality, based on ill-will, based on the intention to harm somebody." Right effort, of course, you generate the desire to do what is skillful. You generate the desire to abandon what is unskillful. Concentration, of course, you make up your mind you're going to stay with one object. And even mindfulness is proactive the way the Buddha taught it. It's not just accepting the present moment, it's realizing what's coming up in the present moment and then saying, "Okay, what needs to be done with this so I can shape it in a skillful direction, so I can get the mind into concentration?"

You learn about the process of fabrication by doing it skillfully. Think about the Army Corps of Engineers, because they've had to keep the Mississippi River from breaking out and creating a new mouth, which it has in the past. It's done fairly regularly. It just kind of moves, silts up, and then it moves. And they figured if it moved, you know, New Orleans would die. And so they've been putting levees along it and creating all kinds of things to keep the Mississippi River going in its path. They've learned an awful lot about the Mississippi River in doing that. Things they would never learn otherwise. Another example you can give is, if you want to know how strong the currents of a river are, you build a dam across the river. And then what may certainly seem like a placid river suddenly shows some resistance. And so it's by actively engaging the present moment through the path that you begin to see how deeply this process of fabrication goes.

Even what we would tend to think are relatively passive qualities in the practice have their role within this proactive context. Things like equanimity, patience, and contentment. The equanimity the Buddha teaches is not just "I don't care. Nothing really matters to me." It's more like the equanimity of a doctor. Think about the equanimity of a doctor. It has to be practiced together with goodwill, compassion, and empathetic joy. You don't just be equanimous on its own. You've got to develop these other qualities. And so they say a doctor has a patient who has some symptoms that cannot be cured. The doctor has to be equanimous toward that part that cannot be cured, so he or she can focus on what can be done, where the patient can be helped.

The Buddha, when he talks about the practice of equanimity in meditation, says you have to watch out for having too much equanimity because it leads to stagnation. It has to be practiced together with a sense of effort, also with the practice of concentration. The image he gives is of a goldsmith. The goldsmith has to put the gold in the fire for a while, then has to take it out and examine it, blowing on it to cool it off. If he just examines it without putting it in the fire, blowing on it, just sits there, nothing happens to the gold. If he just puts it in the fire, the fire burns it. If he cools it off and nothing else, again nothing would happen. It's the combination of those three things—effort, concentration, and equanimity—that allows the gold to develop. In this case he's saying, right with your mind. So when you're developing equanimity it has to be in the context of goodwill, that you want to see good results coming. And there are certain things that are not going to happen, so you don't focus your efforts there. You learn how to focus your efforts on the places where they will make a difference.

As for patience, the Buddha teaches the patience of a warrior. In other words, there will be setbacks in the battle, but you don't let yourself get upset by that. You say, "Okay, there may be interval waiting. I'll wait for the next chance." Which is motivated by your desire for victory. When the Buddha talks about patience, he basically deals with two types of problems that come up in life. One is harsh words, and the other is physical pain.

With harsh words, he has you remind yourself that this is the nature of human speech. There is kind speech, there is unkind speech. There is ill-meaning speech, there is well-meaning speech. There is true speech, there is false speech. There is gentle speech, there is harsh speech. When someone is speaking to you in unskillful ways, it is not something new, it's not something out of the ordinary. This is the way human speech tends to be. And then he has you reflect even further. If somebody is saying something really nasty, you tell yourself, "An unpleasant contact has been made. An unpleasant sound has made contact at the ear." How many times have you told yourself that? [Laughter] He says, let it stop right there. Okay, but we tend to pull it in and we make lots of stories about it. It's like we're taking those words and we're stabbing ourselves with them.

As for physical pains, the Buddha says, "Okay, you learn how to develop a sense of pleasure through the meditation so you have an alternative place for your mind to go." This is why when the Buddha talks about working with the breath, there's a lot about developing pleasure and developing rapture, breathing in a way that provides you with sensations that calm the mind so that you have an alternative place, so you're not totally overcome by the pain.

So the patience here is not just accepting things. It means there are certain setbacks I have to accept, but I accept them for the sake of looking for the opening where I can do something positive. So there are many images in the Canon that talk of the patience of a warrior.

As for contentment, the Buddha teaches contentment with external conditions. In other words, food, clothing, shelter, and medicine. If it's enough to practice, you've got enough. What you do not content yourself with is the level of skill in your mind. This is shown in a teaching called the Customs of the Noble Ones. The first three have to do with being content with food, clothing, and shelter. And the Buddha says you have to watch out to make sure that you don't get worked up about times when you don't get what you want, and on the other side, you don't pride yourself that "I'm able to do without things that other people cannot do without." That's a danger.

As for the fourth of the Customs of the Noble Ones, you think if the first three deal with food, clothing, and shelter, the fourth one would be medicine. But it's not. It's learning how to delight in developing and to delight in abandoning. In other words, delight in developing skillful qualities in the mind, delight in abandoning unskillful qualities in the mind. And these are areas where the Buddha said you cannot just rest content. If you see yourself creating suffering, you don't say, "Okay, that's okay, I'll be calm." I've had some students tell me, "Don't push me so fast, you know, it's going to take me a while to learn to become more skillful." I said, "It's not that I'm trying to push you, but it's the fact that you know, how much time do you have left? We don't know." So you have to motivate yourself to say, "I cannot rest content with unskillful qualities." The Buddha said that was the secret to his awakening: he didn't let himself rest content with whatever his level of skill he had. You see that in practicing, there is a sense of discontent that drives the path. After all, we are suffering. We don't want to just sit around in the suffering, and this is what motivates you to develop the path.

And ultimately, developing what the Buddha called the heart of the path, which is right concentration, you're able to get the mind in a good steady state. It's called jhāna[4], because it's related to the verb jhāyati, which is for a fire to burn in a steady flame. You're trying to get your mind to be really steady because there's a sense of pleasure there and there's a sense of well-being. And also the stability of the mind allows you to see things in your mind that you wouldn't have seen otherwise. In particular, you see that even the state of getting the mind in concentration is a kind of fabrication. Yeah, you've got the form of the body. You've got the aggregates all together here. You've got the feeling of pleasure. You've got the perception that holds you with the breath. You've got the fabrication of yourself talking to you about how to just settle in with the breath, and then finally the awareness of all these things. So even this is fabricated. So use these fabrications in order to pull away your attachment from other things, and finally you have to realize again, this too is fabricated.

This is where the other meaning of that verb jhāyati comes in. In other words, even the state of concentration, which is very real, very calm and very steady, is burning as well. And it's when you develop a sense of dispassion for that, too, that's when you go outside of the present moment into something that's not fabricated. And this is your very first taste of the deathless. There's no fabrication there anymore. So that state of the deathless, which is basically outside of time, it's not done for the sake of anything, it's just there, it's present. There is a kind of pleasure, but it's not a feeling. There's a kind of consciousness, but it's not one of the aggregates, part of the aggregate of consciousness. So this is what the practice is aimed at, is getting to this state that is outside of space and time, outside of the present moment. When you come back from that first experience, you return to the processes of fabrication as before, but you have a big difference. You've seen that there is something deathless that can be touched by the mind. There was an awareness there, but it had nothing to do with any of the aggregates. There's no fabrication involved, so you don't identify with the aggregates anymore. You have no doubts about the Buddha's teachings about the existence of this timeless dimension. And you realize that what kept you from experiencing that was all the unskillful fabrication you've been doing up to that point. So you resolve this: you resolve not to fabricate in unskillful ways again.

So that's where we're aiming in the present moment, to see even the best present moment is fabricated, and to gain some dispassion for that. It's through dispassion that our experience of the present moment will separate, both will cease. That's just the first taste.

Now, this may seem far away, but there are implications for us here and now. One, it tells us what to do with the present moment. We don't just enter into the present moment to stay there. We don't resign ourselves to it or to any momentary pleasures. There's an image you often see, that you learn how to sit there like a person sitting on a shore watching the waves come in. And whatever waves come in are perfectly okay, big waves, small waves, whatever, and we're just resigned to that position. The Buddha's image, of course, is one of going across a river to safety on the other side. You're not being asked to turn a blind eye to the limitations of staying where you are. The telephone line worker with his miserable job and his dishonest friends, he doesn't have to just accept that. The Buddha said there is something better that we can find, not by lowering our expectations for happiness, but actually raising them through developing skills.

So this way we learn what to accept. Accept things coming in from the past karma that cannot be changed. What not to accept: we don't accept a lazy attitude, we don't accept a defeatist attitude. We realize that we can make the present moment into a better place. This is through the practice of merit. Now, here in the West we don't like the word merit. It sounds too much like brownie points, Boy Scout points. Perhaps a better translation for the word puñña would be goodness. I mean doing or developing our goodness as best we can. That too, however, is a word that doesn't get much press in the West. I don't get online often, but I did get on one time when I got onto Amazon, and just for the fun of it I started typing words into the search box, like honesty, wisdom, discernment. Got to goodness. Goodness was mainly books on baked goods. [Laughter] So I think it's time for us to sort of take the word goodness and shake it off and clean it up and put it into practice. I mean, you do make the present moment a better place by the goodness that you do.

We can free ourselves from bad influences from the past. As I said, the Buddha said there are skillful ways of dealing with unpleasant contact coming in from the past so you don't have to suffer from it. He talks about developing the brahmavihāras[5], developing your wisdom, your virtue. Learn how to train the mind so that it is not overcome by pleasure and not overcome by pain, so that when bad contact comes in from the past, we don't have to just sit there and say, "Okay, I'm just gonna be miserable because of this." I can develop a state of mind which is much more expansive.

One of the images he gives to show this is the difference of someone being fined for having stolen a goat. If a poor person is fined for stealing a goat, he usually doesn't have the money to pay it off, so he gets thrown in jail. If a rich person steals a goat, the rich person has plenty of money to buy off the judges. It's an image we don't like, but you know, you have a lot of wealth. So with it you can counteract the influences from the past, at the same time by engaging in the present moment in a more skillful way, we create better conditions for the future. And also we're not stuck here. We're not stuck in this house. The house is constantly burning. You can't stop it from burning, but the Buddha says there is a fire escape, and so we look for the fire escape through the practice, and that way we get out.

Ultimately there is a freedom that is non-flammable, that will not burn us. And it's outside of past, present, and future entirely. Because it's outside of time, it's not going to be touched by anything. Once you've gained it, you've gained it for good. If I'd been able to explain things in French to the telephone line worker, that's what I would have sat him down to tell him about.

So, are there any questions?

Q&A

Question: Would you elaborate on what you just said about once you have it you have it?

Ajaan Thanissaro: Appreciate there's not much to say. I mean, the Buddha talks about different stages in the awakening process, different levels. But from then on, it's there. You're outside of space and time, then there's no question about forever or not forever. It's just you're outside entirely. The Buddha does describe Nirvana, he uses lots of different analogies and images to describe Nirvana, and they fall into five major classes. One is that it is true, in other words it's not going to change. He calls it permanent and the unchanging, the true. It's also bliss, there it is a state of consciousness. He calls it consciousness without surface. The image they often have in the Canon is of a light beam that's coming through a window of a house. And if it's, say it's coming... sun rises, the light beam from the sun is coming and it's going to hit the western wall. The Buddha says what if there's no western wall, then it's going to land on the ground. What if there's no ground? It's gonna land on the water. What if there's no water? It doesn't land. They said the image of the light beam that doesn't land, that's the image of the consciousness of this. So in this case we have truth, bliss, consciousness. Also freedom, you're freed from your defilements, you're freed from suffering, you're freed from all kinds of limitations. And then finally that it's excellent, it's really, really good. So those are the kinds of epithets that the Buddha would use to describe it.

Question: Can you explain why you call it a battle when you first began to speak, that sounds violent.

Ajaan Thanissaro: Well, sometimes your greed, aversion, and delusion get pretty obstreperous and say, "I don't want to do this. I'd rather hold on to this, hold on to that." And you have all kinds of reasons, and so it's not just a bloody battle, sometimes it's a battle of wits. Sometimes it's a battle of you have to think strategically. Let's put it that way.

Question: Hello. This is a practice question. I've been practicing for some time, but when I pay attention to my breath, I start to try not to control it, but I start to yawn, and then sometimes outside, and I may even gasp for breath a little bit. And the usual advice is just don't meditate on the breath, it doesn't work for you. I don't know if that's what I should do or if that's what I need to work on.

Ajaan Thanissaro: Okay, you can try relaxing before you even focus on the breath. In other words, just some things you may do before the breath. One thing I found that is really helpful is, as you sit in your meditating, you think about where are the bones in my body. You start with the bones in the tips of your fingers, and you feel, okay, where do I feel the tips of my fingers right now? Is there any tension there? Allow it to relax. Then move up to the next joint, and then the next, the next, and next, up the arm. And then start with the toes, the tips of your toes, and work up. Feet, up the legs, the pelvis, the spine, and when you've got everything kind of calmed down that way, then it's, okay, let's look at the breath now.

Question: Okay, so you recommend I keep working at trying to be with the breath instead of giving up?

Ajaan Thanissaro: Yes. I mean, there's probably some energy issues in your body that you need to work on.

Question: I have a question. So around the practice, it's kind of like a battle. I understand it in that yes, with certain mind states like anger, or like yesterday I was actually in a state of mind where thoughts were so intrusive, and I would bring myself back, but again this commentary was being a part of me which ultimately generates more and more anger. And so ultimately I thought it was about fear underneath the anger. There was fear I'd been in trouble, and then once I realized there was fear of being in trouble and acknowledging that, something shifted, something gave space. And ultimately I wasn't sure what it was, whether it was a phone call that came through, whether it was that I had washed my face and somebody had plucked my eyebrows and there was a lot of pain in that, so my mind generated a different focus and had let go temporarily from that. But I also noticed that when anger comes to me I get consumed by it, and it's something that is just so, it's like possessed. A certain amount of possession by this feeling. And so you know, certainly there are lots of layers to it. Since we're on the quest to learn more about suffering, your talk is so rich, it's pretty serious, I think a lot of the answers are sitting there, but how to become skillful into working on just this particular part?

Ajaan Thanissaro: Okay. You have to take the anger apart as I said, you're fabricating your present moment. The Buddha says there are basically three types of fabrication that are involved there: there's bodily fabrication, which is the way of breathing; there's verbal fabrication, the way you're talking to yourself; and there's mental fabrication, which are the perceptions, the images, and the feeling tones. And so you can ask yourself, "Okay, my anger has hijacked my breath. It's hijacked my mental conversation. It has hijacked even the images I'm using in my mind. I've got to take these things back."

And so you start with the breath, say, "Okay, breathe calmly." And the part of the mind that says, "No, no, no, no, I don't want you to be angry," you say, "No, no, no, I've got to breathe calmly right now." And then you can ask yourself, what are the images that are driving this? It's kind of flashing through the mind. Can I consciously replace them with alternative images? For example, you're dealing with your boss, and you have this image of some blob monster movie that comes out and flashes. Say, "No, the boss is not a monster. The boss is a human being," and you replace that image with a human being image. And then part of your mind will resist, but you say, "No, I've got to hold on to this."

And then start talking to yourself. It's like, "Do I want to follow through with this anger?" And part of the mind will say yes, part of the mind is saying no. This is where the image of having the mind as a committee is useful. Some members of the committee have taken over, and I've got to go back and I've got to bring the conversation back to where I want it. And that way if you start seeing the committee, there's no sense of "I'm overwhelmed by this, my mind is overwhelmed by this, I've got to give in." "Okay, I can take my faction of the committee and strengthen it, and then whichever other members of the mind I can convert, I'll convert them, and the ones I can't convert I'll throw out the wall." And that way you learn more about the anger by resisting it. And like the image I gave of the dam across the river, you don't know how strong the river is until you've put a dam across it. You're going to learn a lot about exactly what it is about the anger that has an allure for you, why there's part of the mind that wants to go to the anger. And then you begin to see that a lot of those reasons are weak, and then that's when you begin to get free of it. So try that.

Question: In thinking about anger, so usually when I'm angry it's to a person or group of people, and so what I often do is do mettā[6] for them. So I'm wondering if you think this is more effective or less than examining it in some way?

Ajaan Thanissaro: This is kind of like a good way of cutting across the what I call the verbal fabrication that's saying, "So-and-so is a bastard, so-and-so really deserves to be impeached." I mean that kind of stuff, if you say, "Wait, let's have a little bit of compassion for this person, let's have a little bit of goodwill," that changes the conversation. But sometimes you can't bring yourself to feel goodwill, right? And the Buddha has sort of a knee-jerk reaction, which is, "If I act on my anger, I'm going to do something stupid, and this person is going to be pleased to see me do something stupid. Do I want to please them?"

So whatever works. I mean, you have to give these things a karate chop to begin with, and then you stop and think. You say, "What is it really good for me to let myself be consumed by my anger? No, have some goodwill for yourself." But also learn how you've got to understand your mind if you're going to overcome these things. Simply spreading a nice sort of pink haze around the world is not going to get to the root of why did you like the anger to begin with. Which part of the committee liked the anger and found it appealing, enjoyed engaging in the anger? And when you see that, then you can get beyond it.

Question: The word rich for what you're saying is absolutely true. You've given us so much wisdom here. I'm trying to break some of it down. How do you speak to self-sabotage in practice as coming from the past?

Ajaan Thanissaro: Okay, again that's just one of the voices in the committee that's partly afraid of what you're doing if you're practicing. It wants to be more comfortable in its old ways of doing things, and feels unstable entering a new environment like that. And so you have to ask yourself, "Okay, which part of me wants to sabotage the practice? Which part of me wants to sabotage my happiness?" See if I kind of trace it out, why would I go for that? And there's usually a sense of, "If not too much is expected of me, I'll be okay." So you might have to ask, is that what's going on in the mind? Just sort of ask questions about what the Buddha says, when something like that happens, you want to see what sparks it, and then once it's come, why does it go away? And then when it goes away, why do I pick it up again and keep coming back to it? Because these things have their lifespan, and yet we dig them up again and again and again.

And of course, watching yourself digging it up, you may see this has a certain allure. There's something about this that I really find attractive. And many times self-sabotage is just that: "If my expectations for myself are lowered, then I won't feel challenged, I won't have the embarrassment of failure." These are some of the things that might be playing in there. And when you can see the allure, then you think about the drawbacks of falling for that. Is it worth it? And when you really see why it was you went for it, and then you can see it's not worth it, then you can let it go.

Question: Feels like there is a child inside an adult, and parent kind of. And our child wants to be heard, and sounds like the method you're suggesting is like to a child, parent saying "be quiet", you know, and that's not going to work. So there's that part that wants to be heard, it feels like a little child in us. And so I'm wondering how to deal with that, maybe it will always come back until it's really heard and thoroughly feeling like being understood. And so it will come up and up again until it's really heard. I'm wondering how you utilize...

Ajaan Thanissaro: You need a wise parent. In other words, what are the "shoulds" that this parent is trying to impose on the child? And you might think, let's try the Buddha's "shoulds", which are you should try to understand why you're suffering. You should try to understand, to let go of the cause, and reason with the child and not just say, "You just gotta do what I tell you." "Because they're going to tell you what to do." It says, "There are reasons for this, why you will be happy if you..."

Think about it that way. Think about it that your adult is a parent, a mother, and says, "Look, I don't want you to be miserable, and this is going to be good for you. And I understand your problems, but at the same time we have to learn to not let the child run the committee." I know it wants to be heard. Let it be heard. And when it's okay, "We've heard you, thank you for sharing. But this will actually be good for you in the long run." I mean, it's the kind of parent that beats the child down, that's why the child feels, "I have never been heard, I haven't been treated properly." But if the parent says, "Look, it's reasonable to say there are certain ways of acting that are going to make you happy, certain ways of acting that are not. In the long term we're not going to make you happy." So you start thinking long-term. How much more time do we have?

Question: I just have a short question. Did the Buddha recommend students meditate on death?

Ajaan Thanissaro: The meditation on death is basically designed to make you realize how little time you have. You don't know how much time you have, so take advantage of right now. That's the purpose it's for, to make you heedful and to give you more encouragement to say, "Okay, I really do have to do this work in the present moment." That's the kind of meditation.

Question: So if we're really motivated to practice towards the deathless, we're trying to prioritize retreat practice, practice more in everyday life, jhāna practice, wisdom practice. You know, the Buddha has many different practices, the brahmavihāras. Is there some way to be more efficient knowing we don't have much time? Knowing death is good, okay, is there this way the Buddha had to plan our time towards different practices?

Ajaan Thanissaro: I would say get to know your breath really well. And then work on the qualities that keep you mindful, keep you balanced, and in a sense of solidity in the present moment, so that when unskillful things come up you're not knocked off by them, that you learn how to deal with them. And for this bodily fabrication I was talking about, learning how to work with the breath in a way that's comfortable. You can... they keep mentioning my books as being on Access to Insight, they're actually more on dhammatalks.org. Go onto dhammatalks.org, there's a book called With Each and Every Breath. And that talks about breath meditation and also integrating breath meditation into your daily life. There's some copies over there... okay.

And also, in terms of your job, you know, how far do you need to go in the corporate ladder? Because when you work your way up, are you actually going to give yourself less and less and less time to actually practice? There comes a point you say, "Look, I've got enough in terms of where my career is now. I can focus more time on what I really need to do." Nobody has ever regretted spending a little less time at the office, okay?

Question: People have talked about anger, and it does feel like it's a lot about battling in wits, right? And I think when it comes to having to deal with sensual pleasure, I feel like it's a lot more about battling in good wits because I always have a hard time telling my friends about the dangers of sensual pleasure. And I rarely succeed in convincing them that it's not good for you, for example.

Ajaan Thanissaro: Not all sensual pleasures are good or bad for you. You have to look at if you indulge in a particular pleasure, what happens to your mind? What is your motivation for indulging in it to begin with? And if it's unskillful in either way, then you say that this is something I have to avoid. Now you're battling Madison Avenue. I mean, the whole culture has been cultivated on the idea that you give in to your desires. Give in, obey your thirst, remember that commercial? And so there's a lot in our culture that goes against that, and people who deny their sensual pleasures, they're twisted. If you saw the film The Devils—this shows that I'm a monk in my references to films, my films are back in the 70s—but it had Vanessa Redgrave and Oliver Reed. And Vanessa Redgrave's first appearance, she's coming in and she's a nun, and she's got her head twisted off to the side. And I went there with my girlfriend and we said, "We know where this movie is going. We don't need to see this." We left.

So you're battling against a lot of very strong tendencies in our culture that basically say there... The Buddha didn't say sensual pleasures period are bad. Just say there are certain sensual indulgences that are going to be bad for you. You've got to watch out for them and be very careful. But you also have to give people an alternative. This is why we meditate, learn how to meditate in a way that is pleasant, so we have an alternative pleasure to go to. So I can say I don't cling. But it has a bad impact on your mind.

It's not the sensual pleasures themselves, the question is what is my motivation for indulging in this? And when I do indulge in it, what kind of impact am I having on myself and other people? Those are things you've got to watch out for. And the Buddha says the big culprit is our fascination with thinking about sensual pleasures, and embroidering them to make them more than they actually are. And all the techniques that Madison Avenue uses on us, the mind uses on itself all the time: planning a pleasure, reflecting on the pleasure, how great it was, writing restaurant reviews in your mind over and over and over again. That's the problem. Work on that.

Okay, we're done. Thank you for your attention.



  1. Kammavāda: The doctrine of action (karma). The Buddha's teaching that actions have real consequences. ↩︎

  2. Niganthas: The historical precursors to the Jains, who taught that all present experience is predetermined by past actions. ↩︎

  3. Samsara: The continuous cycle of birth, death, and rebirth in Buddhism. ↩︎

  4. Jhāna: Meditative states of profound stillness and concentration. ↩︎

  5. Brahmavihāras: The four "divine abodes" or sublime attitudes: loving-kindness (mettā), compassion (karuṇā), empathetic joy (muditā), and equanimity (upekkhā). ↩︎

  6. Mettā: Loving-kindness or goodwill. ↩︎