In the Elephant's Footprint
- Date:
- 2018-09-23
- Speakers:
- Ajaan Thanissaro [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-22 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
In the Elephant's Footprint
There is a passage in the Pali Canon where the Buddha makes a comparison. He says, just as all the footprints of all the animals on earth could fit into the footprint of an elephant, in the same way, all the Buddha's teachings, all dhammas, can fit into the Four Noble Truths. I want you to keep that image in mind as we talk about today's topic, which is the relationship between the Four Noble Truths and the three characteristics.
Years back, I was listening to a Dhamma talk by a scholarly monk in Bangkok. He was complaining about a meditation teacher he'd heard who taught that Right View was seeing things in terms of the three characteristics. He said, "No, that's not true. Right View is the Four Noble Truths." When I listened to the talk, I thought this was often pedantic. It seemed like a scholarly issue, but not really a real issue in life. But then, the more I've lived with these teachings, the more I began to realize that it really is an issue. Which is more important? Which is the container for the other? Do the three characteristics contain the Four Noble Truths, or do the Four Noble Truths contain the three characteristics? This changes the meaning of the teaching. Which one is actually the giver of meaning, and which one has to fit into the meaning of the other?
When you look at the Canon, it's very clear that the Buddha places the Four Noble Truths as the container. It's one of the few teachings that he said is categorical—in other words, true across the board, for everybody, at all times. When he gave his own descriptions of awakening, it was in terms of the Four Noble Truths and not in terms of the three characteristics. When he began teaching, he taught the Four Noble Truths first in his first sermon. His second sermon was on the three characteristics. So the Four Noble Truths for him were the container.
After all, he said at some other point that all he taught was suffering and the end of suffering. As a little footnote, those are two things, not one thing. You've probably heard it said, "I teach one thing and one thing only: suffering and the end of suffering." It's not one; it's two. Ask anybody in the hospital.
The Four Noble Truths basically expand on this point. It comes down to the question of how you desire and how you act in the context of knowing that there is suffering, and knowing that your actions might make a difference between whether you suffer and whether you don't suffer. So the teaching of the Four Noble Truths takes on the assumption that you want happiness and you're willing to act on it. You want to act skillfully.
At another point, the Buddha said the beginning of wisdom is when you ask the question of a reliable person, "What, when I do it, will lead to long-term welfare and happiness?" The wisdom there comes in, one, seeing that there is such a thing as long-term happiness; two, that long-term is better than short-term; and three, that it's going to depend on your actions. So actions form the context of what he's talking about.
Actions, of course, are based on desire. This is why the Four Noble Truths focus on two kinds of desire: there's the craving that leads to suffering, and then there's the desire as a part of Right Effort, a part of Right Resolve, that actually leads to the end of suffering. Basically, what the Four Noble Truths are giving you are ways to sort through your desires to see which desires are going to be helpful and which ones are not, which ones are skillful and which ones are not.
In terms of the Four Noble Truths, each of the truths has a duty. The duty with regard to suffering is to comprehend it. That means understanding it to the point where you have dispassion for it. We don't usually think that we're passionate for our suffering, but you look at people doing a lot of stupid things in life, and they want to do them, and they're going to suffer. So we are passionate, many times, for the things that actually cause us to suffer or constitute our suffering. The duty with regard to the cause of suffering is to abandon it. The duty with regard to the cessation of suffering is to realize it. And you do that by developing the path, which is the Fourth Noble Truth.
Now, within this context of the duties regarding the truths—these are truths, as I said, that guide action. They give you some direction on how you sort through your desires as to which ones you should follow, which ones not to, and what to do. The three characteristics fit into this context. But first, it's important to note that the Buddha never called them the "three characteristics" of inconstancy, stress, and not-self. Sometimes it's called impermanence, suffering, and non-self. The Buddha never describes these as characteristics. He always described them as perceptions. These are labels that you apply to things in your experience. In the context of the duties of the Four Noble Truths, they actually help you develop some dispassion for the various things that cause you to suffer.
One of these perceptions, the perception of not-self, is not the perception that there is no self. The Buddha is basically asking you to pass judgment: if something is going to cause you suffering, if it's stressful, if it's changing all the time, is it worth calling your self? Is it worth claiming as you or yours? It's basically a value judgment, saying, "No, not in this case. I don't need to identify with this."
So when you look at suffering, one of the ways of getting past your passion for suffering is to learn how to perceive the things that you're clinging to—as the Buddha said, clinging is the suffering. The things that you're clinging to are not worth it. Why is that? Because they're unreliable, inconstant. That's my preferred translation for anicca[1], because "impermanence" doesn't really get to the heart of the matter.
You can build a house on a mountain and say, "Well, that mountain isn't permanent, but it doesn't matter to me because I can still build my house there. I trust the mountain is going to stay—unless, of course, it's a mountain in California—but long enough for me to live and be happy. I don't care about what's going to happen down the line in a couple of eons." Whereas if you say that something is inconstant, it's like trying to sit comfortably on a chair where the legs are uneven. You have to sit very carefully and not get too relaxed, because otherwise the chair may tip over. I think that's what the word is pointing to here. The Pali term anicca does come from the root nicca, which means constant.
Secondly, you can't depend on these things to be there for you all the time. If you can't depend on it, is it stressful? Yes, it's stressful. If it's undependable, if it's stressful, why claim it as yourself? So the things that you would cling to, the things that you would hold to, the things you might crave—these are things you want to see: "I don't really want to get anything out of these things. I've misunderstood my relationship to them. I thought they were worth the effort that went into it, but now I can see it's not worth the effort." So you apply that perception both to the suffering and to the causes of suffering.
Now, as for the path, that's something different. It's something you have to do, and in order to do it, it's based on desire. You have to want to follow the path to the end of suffering, and you need passion there. So, for the time being, you don't apply these three perceptions to the path itself. You apply them to anything else that would pull you away.
For instance, in the case of virtue, the Buddha says at one point there are five losses that can come to us: loss of health, loss of wealth, loss of relatives, loss of Right View, and loss of virtue. He says of those five, the first three are not all that serious. Health, wealth, relatives—you can lose them and still maintain your virtue. You can still maintain your Right View. That's your real possession, because you can maintain those things all the way through life and even on into subsequent lives. But so many times, it's because of our concern about losing wealth, losing our health, or losing our relatives that we might want to steal, lie, do something dishonest, or do something against the precepts. The Buddha says in that case, you have to regard these worldly things with the three perceptions to develop a sense of dispassion for them. You don't cling to them so tightly, so you are willing to hold to the precepts rather than holding on to things that were pulling you away from the precepts.
Similarly with concentration, when you're getting the mind concentrated, you don't just watch it get concentrated and say, "It arises, passes away, and that's insight." No, once it comes, it's something you've got to develop. So when the concentration comes, you maintain it. You're trying to create a state of mind that is constant, that is stable, and is under your control. In other words, you're fighting against those three perceptions at that point. You're trying to find something that you can really rely on. As you get more skilled in the concentration, you learn that you can rely on it. Then it's easier to look at the other things around you that you've been holding on to and say, "You know, I don't really need to hold on to these things so much. They're causing me trouble, they're causing me stress. Maybe it's worth letting go."
So you apply the three perceptions to things that would pull you off the path, but you don't apply them yet to the path itself. It's only when your concentration has done its work, your discernment has done its work, your virtue has done its work—that's when you develop dispassion for them too. Because after all, they are fabricated; they're based on desire. You let go of those. Letting go doesn't mean you go back to being unvirtuous or unconcentrated, but you find that there's another alternative. When the mind opens to the deathless, which is the cessation of suffering, at that point, you let the path go.
The traditional image in the Canon is the image of the raft. You take the raft across the river. Once you get to the other shore, you let the raft go. You don't carry it on your head as you continue to travel. But in the meantime, before you get to the other shore, you hold on. The Thai ajaans give lots of images for this. One is being a carpenter working on a piece of furniture. While you're working on the furniture, you've got to hold on to your tools. When the furniture is done, you can put the tools down. So you hold on to the path. You don't apply the three perceptions to the path until it's totally done its work. That's when you say, "This still is something that's fabricated. I want to go to something that's unfabricated." And that's when you let it go. So that's the way in which the Four Noble Truths form the context for how you apply what the Buddha would call the three perceptions.
Now, however, these teachings morphed as they got into the commentaries, and there's a question of why it happened. One theory is that there were these debates being held in ancient India. A king would come into power and say, "I'd like to hear all the different religions in my kingdom debate a particular topic that I find interesting." The Buddha had warned the monks not to get involved in these debates, because after all, once the king sets a question, you can't say, "That's a stupid question."
But you know, when the Buddha was teaching, people would often come up with certain questions and he would say, "No, this is a question that's not worth answering." Because he was in a position of control there, he was able to control which questions got asked and which questions didn't get asked. And for a question that he wouldn't answer, he'd also give a reason for why it was not worth answering. For example, the question: "Is there a self? Is there no self?" That's a question he put aside. However, that was a question that the kings of the time really were interested in having an answer for. Over the generations, over the centuries, you finally got someone who said, "Let's answer the king's question, otherwise we will lose support." So they came up with the answer that there is no self—that was the Buddhist teaching. And forever since then, for 2,000-some years now, we've been entangled in what the Buddha called a "tangle of views." If there is no self, who does the action? Who receives the results of the action? How can rebirth happen? All these other things—all this tangle that the Buddha avoided by not answering the question.
But anyway, what happened was the "not-self" teaching becomes a "no-self" teaching. It becomes a metaphysical teaching: this is the nature of reality. There is no self, things are impermanent, things are stressful, things are not-self; this is the nature of reality out there. Nothing has any essence. And as a result, the three characteristics then become the context for the Four Noble Truths. They become the categorical teaching.
In the commentaries at the same time, the Four Noble Truths began to morph. Clinging, instead of being what suffering is, becomes a cause for suffering. We cling to things because we believe that they're permanent, not knowing that they are impermanent. Ignorance, which is another cause of suffering in addition to craving, comes from not seeing things in terms of the three characteristics. Now, originally, ignorance was not seeing things in terms of the Four Noble Truths—in other words, not remembering the guidelines for what actions are skillful and which ones are not. It now becomes a question of not remembering the true nature of reality out there. We're assuming permanence in things that are impermanent. If people realized the truth of the characteristics, they wouldn't cling and they wouldn't suffer. And this becomes the purpose of mindfulness practice: just to see how impermanent things are. Things arise and pass away; there's nothing there to hold on to, so I'd better just let go.
And finally, the picture of what happens in experience becomes a lot more passive. For the Buddha, he said all your experience is rooted in desire. You're out there basically looking for trouble; you're looking for things to feed on, sometimes with a lot of ignorance, but you are the active factor there. In the commentaries, experience becomes more passive. The mind is there, it's kind of just sitting calm, and then a sensory input comes and hits it, and then it reacts, rather than going out and looking for the input to begin with. So experience becomes a lot more passive in the commentaries.
Now, this commentarial view is what has influenced modern Buddhism. You see this in many, many books, even scholarly books. When they treat the Four Noble Truths, the discussion quickly morphs into a discussion of the three characteristics. "Yes, we suffer. Why do we suffer? Because we think things are permanent. But if we knew things were impermanent, then we wouldn't suffer." The three characteristics become the context. And when they describe the Buddha's awakening, it is described as the Buddha seeing that things were impermanent, stressful, and that there was no self. Even secular Buddhist teachers who reject the Four Noble Truths accept impermanence as a metaphysical truth that we have to hold to.
As a result of this, four misunderstandings come up that you find common in modern Buddhism.
One is that "there is no self" means there's no agent. There's nobody doing anything. It becomes the idea that people suffer because they think they can resist change. I went to an explanation of the Four Noble Truths saying people suffer because they resist change; if they would just accept and embrace change, everything would be okay. Tell that to somebody who's in a concentration camp. "Things change, just embrace it, you'll be okay." That's not the issue. We do have agency, but we're taught that we have no agency within this version of Buddhism.
The second misunderstanding is that there is no such thing as long-term happiness. Pleasures and pains just come and go without you being able to extend the pleasures or shorten the pains. You just have to learn to accept that things are going to come, and they're going to go.
Thirdly, we're taught that to cling means to assume that things are permanent, and we hold on. However, if we could learn to hold on just briefly, realizing their impermanence—in other words, embrace things as they come and go—you've probably heard the image of the dancer dancing with lots of different partners. You leave this partner, you go on to the next partner, and you accept the fact that you're going to be changing partners all the time, then you're okay; it doesn't count as clinging. Images that you often see about this: one is the image of the dancer. A second, very common one, is sitting on the beach watching the waves come in. If you try to hold on to the nice waves and push the bad waves away, then you're going to suffer. But if you just accept the fact that waves are going to come and they're going to go, then you're going to be okay. Ultimately, there is no such thing as good or bad waves, just waves coming and going.
And the fourth misunderstanding that comes up is that clinging means holding on to fixed views as to what is right and what is wrong. Now, in this case, we have to realize that when you just say the world is impermanent, things are stressful, there is no self, there are really no duties implicit in that. There's no way you can say that you should do this or should not do this. People can react to impermanence in lots of different ways. Some people can say, "Well, if everything's impermanent, stressful, and there is no self, let's go and have a drink." And it would follow logically from those premises, right?
So the Buddha's recommendations as to what should be done and what should not be done are seen as results of his cultural background. "The Buddha lived in a different period. We live in a new period now. There are new ideas of what we should and shouldn't do, and that's perfectly fine because, after all, everything changes, everything is impermanent. There are no right or wrong ways of interpreting the Dhamma, except that it all changes."
An example of this way of thinking is something I saw a while back. I was watching a TV show—they have a TV show on Buddhism in France once a week. The producers asked me, "Why don't you do this in America? After all, you have a lot more Buddhist teachers than we have." They have trouble keeping new faces coming in, and they're right. There was a French Buddhologist on one day. He was talking about dependent co-arising and impermanence, and the interviewer asked him, "So what does this mean in daily life?" And he said, "It means that if two people are in love, they have to accept the fact that their love today will be expressed in different ways than how it was expressed yesterday." When I listened to that, I thought two things. One, that's a really French explanation. [Laughter] Two, you can excuse a multitude of sins by saying, "Hey, my love today is different from yesterday." So it's irresponsible, is what it is.
So what kind of views are they? As I said, one, they're defeatist. "There is no true long-term happiness in life. You just learn how to accept things as they come and go, and if you're quite peaceful and calm about that, then you'll be okay." Another person who was on the same show was advancing this idea, and the interviewer asked her, "Isn't this defeatist? Isn't this depressing and pessimistic?" And she said, "Only if you think about it. So just don't think, and you'll be okay." I'd say I think a lot of Vipassana courses are like that. Okay, it's defeatist, it's irresponsible, and secondly, is this really realistic?
Why do we cling? Do we cling to things only thinking that they're permanent? Well, what are the things that people cling to most fiercely? Food and sex, right. Any other candidates? Children, okay. Do you think they're permanent? Do we think food is permanent? Sex is permanent? Children are permanent? No. We know they're not permanent, but we cling anyway. And that's why we suffer. We're doing it fully knowing that these things are not permanent.
Why do we cling? Because we think it's worth it. It has nothing to do with whether they have some permanent, innate nature or essential essence. It's simply: is it worth holding on? And we say yes, the pleasure we get from it is worth it. That's why we hold on. Basically, it's a value judgment that we're making. We don't hold on to these things because we have a metaphysical view that they have an essential essence. We hold on because we think, "If I do this, if I act on this, if I hold on to this, I'm going to get enough pleasure that's going to compensate for the holding on."
But as human beings, we tend to be pretty bad judges of what's worth doing and what's not worth doing. There was a positive psychologist—the type of psychologist who studies happiness—and he was interviewing people about what things made them happy. He had this arrangement with them that he would call them up at random hours of the day. If he happened to catch them when they were doing the thing that they said made them happy, he'd ask, "Are you happy?" It turned out the answer was, "Well, not especially." But then if he asked them afterwards, "Were you happy?", they'd say, "Oh yes, I was quite happy doing that."
He asked himself why people are so foolish about their own happiness, such bad judges of their own happiness. Then he thought about himself. He realized he liked to climb mountains. If anything is not worth doing, it's climbing a mountain for the sake of climbing a mountain and coming back down. He realized while he was doing it, he was miserable, cold, and afraid of dying. But then he came back down and he couldn't wait to do it again. This is the way we are.
Basically, what the Buddha is doing in the Four Noble Truths is giving us better standards of judgment. He gives us a means of judgment regarding what really makes us happy and what doesn't, and what we can do to gain happiness.
So this analysis of taking the three characteristics as the nature of reality and using that as a container for the Four Noble Truths has got everything backwards. Because it's teaching us views that are defeatist, irresponsible, and really not very realistic. They don't describe reality as we behave. They don't describe clinging properly. They don't describe happiness properly.
Let's go back and compare this again with the Buddha's teachings. For him, clinging—which he constantly says constitutes suffering—is a type of feeding. We feed on things because, of course, we think we're going to get nourishment out of them. And this is not just physical food, but also emotional food, mental food. We're looking for the happiness we get out of holding on to these things.
From the point of view of the Four Noble Truths, the idea of simply embracing things in the moment, being willing to let go, doesn't work. We're serial clingers. If we do that, we're going to suffer each time we cling and have to let go, cling and have to let go. There's no real happiness there, and there's no real peace in that.
So the Buddha's strategy in dealing with this problem is that we have to see the drawbacks of our feeding. I was talking about this yesterday during the course: there are five stages to letting go of something when you realize it is unskillful. First is to see it come—when it arises, what's coming with it? What's the cause? Secondly, when it goes, how does it go? Thirdly, what's the allure? Why do you like it? This part is often especially hard for us to see clearly because we have likes that we tend to hide from ourselves. Fourth is seeing the drawbacks: if you hold on to this, what actually happens? And finally, if you actually see what the allure is and see what the drawbacks are, you will develop dispassion. That's how you free yourself from that particular state of mind.
The three perceptions are applied to this comparing of the drawbacks with the allure. Okay, this is what you think you get, and this is what you actually get. Is it worth going for? If you see that what you're really getting is nothing you can really depend on, why go for it? If it's something stressful to hold on to, why go for it? The judgment of not-self is: "Okay, I'll let it go."
In order to do this, however, you need an alternative source of food. That's what the path provides. In the practice of virtue, you develop a sense of self-esteem. In the practice of concentration, you have a sense of visceral pleasure that is not a sensual pleasure. It's a pleasure that comes from—as we were working on earlier during the meditation—having a sense of the breath flowing smoothly through the body, a sense of inhabiting a body that feels good to be inside. That gives you a pleasure that you can hold on to. Then, as you begin to look at the other pleasures you were going for, you begin to see that they're not quite as good as you thought they were.
The advantage of this is that the Buddha says this adventure leads you to an experience of something that's totally unconditioned, which is the deathless. The three characteristics don't apply there at all. It's not inconstant, it's not stressful. Questions of self and not-self no longer apply.
The image that the Buddha gave us: instead of having you lying on the beach watching the waves come in, he says you're actually crossing over a river, and you're going to be standing on firm ground where you're safe from the waves. In this case, there are no quotation marks around "good" or "bad" waves. The waves of the river can sweep you away. You want to get past them. When you get on firm ground, you don't have to worry about them.
The advantage of the Buddha's approach is that, one, it gives you duties—not in the sense of duties imposed on you, but if you want to find happiness, the Buddha says this is what you should do. If you just look at the three characteristics, there are no duties imposed. Things are inconstant, impermanent; you can do anything you want, grab for whatever you can, but with the understanding that we suffer because we crave and cling. But we can go past that. Craving and clinging is an action that we're doing that's not necessary. The Four Noble Truths give you a sense that there's a course in life where you can start making choices. Here is some guidance.
It also gives you some focus on what kind of change you have to watch out for. If everything changes, everything is kind of equal. But in the context of the Four Noble Truths, one of the things that you have to watch out for—as the Buddha said, the most changeable thing in the world is your own mind. He says the mind can change so quickly that there's no analogy adequate to express how quick it is. Even the blink of an eye is too slow. You have to watch out for that. This is why we practice mindfulness: to remember what guidance the Four Noble Truths give and the reasons why we should stick with that guidance. If we forget that, we can change at any moment. So this is the real role of mindfulness in the context of the Four Noble Truths: to keep us from forgetting what the Buddha taught so that we can apply it as we go through life.
The second focus is on where you are looking for your happiness. Is it solid enough to support your happiness? That's the kind of change you have to watch out for. The Buddha's approach, seeing change in terms of the Four Noble Truths, gives you focus on where the changes are that you have to be careful about. It's when you place your hopes for happiness on something unreliable. This is where you have to develop your discernment. Mindfulness and discernment are the two big elements on the path. So this approach actually puts you in control. There's something you can do to gain long-term happiness rather than just having to accept the fact that things are going to come and go.
Now, in terms of views, it's interesting with that image of the raft. We very rarely think about what that river represents. To the Buddha's eyes, one of the things it represents is the flood of views, the views that would sweep you away. But the raft itself is composed of the elements of the Eightfold Path, which includes Right View. Right View is going to take you across other views, to the point ultimately where you don't need views.
The purpose of Right View is for you to look at your processes of holding on. You apply it to all the unskillful things you've been holding on to. And finally, you take that same view and turn it on itself. You say, "Even this process of holding on to Right View has some stress built into it." Now, it's much less than the stress that comes from holding on to other things, but when you get to that point and that's the only stress left, you say, "Okay, now I can let go." This is how Right View transcends itself.
So this kind of view is always responsible. It provides guidelines for what you should and shouldn't do, and it gives you focus on what kind of changes you should watch out for. As I said, it contains the seed for its own transcendence.
And then you compare the types of happiness that are possible. The first kind of happiness, taking the three characteristics as your context, is, as I said, very defeatist. There is no long-term happiness, so satisfy yourself with things as they come and go. However, the Buddha's approach is not defeatist at all. I mean, the Buddha is anything but a defeated person. Another name for the path is "unexcelled victory in battle." You're going out there and doing battle with your own stupidity. You want happiness, and you're doing things that are causing yourself miserable misery. That's close to Einstein's definition of insanity, right? You do it again and again, and you think you'll get a different result. In fact, the Thai ajaans would use that word: it's because of our own stupidity. That's what the Buddha is battling and having us battle as well.
So this seemingly pedantic point makes a big difference. The question is, which do you want? The Buddha says an ultimate happiness is available. He's been teaching swimming lessons to get to the other side for 2,600 years, and where are we? If you think about what this three-characteristic Dhamma does, it is actually siding with the advertising industry. It says, "Hey, look, total unchanging happiness is impossible, so content yourself with sitting on the shore. We'll bring you drinks and umbrellas, but don't count on us when a hurricane comes and the waves get big." So the choice is yours.
Those are my thoughts for the morning. Are there any questions? We have a few minutes before we have to break.
Q&A
Q: I've personally found the Eightfold Path very helpful, and it feels like probably a lifelong pursuit to understand it and work with it. But I just have to be honest: I've been practicing for about five years, and I don't really see any evidence that it's possible to get to the other side of this stream, and I'm actually okay with that. It's hard for me when people teach it because I don't believe it.
Ajaan Thanissaro: Ajaan Maha Bua had a great saying about this. He said, you know, the people who've attained Nibbana, if they could take it out and show it to you, that's all you would want. So it is possible. The question is, to what extent do you feel motivated? Are you really going to say, "I want this enough that I'm gonna sacrifice all these other things for that"?
Even if you don't get there, think of it as something that gives you some hope. If you think of it as "we just are born, we eat, and then we die"—the Buddha's recollections of his previous lifetimes were: he had this appearance, he had this name, he lived in this location, this was his food, this was his experience of pleasure, this was his experience of pain, and then he died. Birth, feeding, pleasure, pain, death. If you just think about that as the rest of human life, it gets very depressing. So it's good that there is this possibility, and people have been finding it. People of all nationalities, genders, and ages have found it in the past. It's available, and that gives you some hope.
Q: Could I just ask, when you find it, does it stay with you forever? Is it a thing that just continuously comes and goes?
Ajaan Thanissaro: No, it stays. It makes permanent changes. I was talking to an attendee one time who asked, "How could any change be permanent?" I said, "Chop off your arm!" [Laughter] So it hits you. Once you've seen the deathless, you realize the Buddha really knew what he was talking about, and it ends your uncertainty about his teaching, about the Dhamma. You also realize there was nothing that you would identify as you or yours, and you're not attached to any ideas about who you are. And then you realize it was through your own unskillful actions that you were blinding yourself to this dimension. So you'd never want to do anything unskillful again. It makes that kind of permanent change.
Q: Have you attained this yet?
Ajaan Thanissaro: I can't answer that because there's a rule against it. The Buddha said not to answer that question. Imagine if all the monks who had these attainments were saying, "Hey, here I am, an arahant[2]." Well, everybody would want to make merit[3] with those monks, and the other monks wouldn't get a chance to eat! Lay people want to do good deeds that will lead to a good rebirth, and one way is finding a highly attained person and giving to them. There's a lot of reward that comes from that. So the rule is that nobody gets to tell lay people who has attained and who hasn't.
Q: Can you tell monks?
Ajaan Thanissaro: Yes, I can tell monks, but you have to be very discerning about that too.
Q: Thank you for your talk about the three marks and Four Noble Truths. I work a lot with the teaching of the Eight Worldly Winds[4], and that seems like a teaching that says it's not possible to escape pleasure, pain, and worldly winds. Can you comment about whether maybe it's unskillful to work with that in the beginning, and it's something more towards the end?
Ajaan Thanissaro: Those teachings are actually very useful for everyday life. Realize that these are the truths of the world as opposed to the truths of the practice. This is what the world has to offer: gain and loss, status and loss of status, praise and criticism, pleasure and pain. That's it. The purpose of this teaching is to say, "I don't want my mind to be distracted by these things." So I put this in the category of things that you would apply the three perceptions to, so that you don't get waylaid from the path.
Q: Is it a correct understanding of the sutta that even the Buddha experiences the Eight Worldly Winds?
Ajaan Thanissaro: Yes, but he's not blown around by them. You know, the image they have is a stone column sixteen spans tall, with eight spans buried in the rock. It's not going to move. That's the mind that has gained awakening.
Q: I'm puzzled. I thought there was an exchange where the Buddha's cousin Ananda said to him, "I think admirable friends must be half of the holy life," and the Buddha corrected him.
Ajaan Thanissaro: Yes, Ananda said admirable friends[5] are half of the holy life, and the Buddha said, "No, admirable friends are the whole of the holy life." Then he went on to say, "It's because of me that you know about the path." Without him, we wouldn't even know that there was a path. Now, he can't walk the path for us, but without him, we wouldn't know it was there. He's a necessary but not a sufficient cause.
An admirable friend is someone who is generous, someone who has conviction, someone who is virtuous, someone who has wisdom. You associate with that person and you try to develop that person's qualities, because without that example, you wouldn't know how to do it. Ananda was often the straight man in the suttas. He'd say things like, "Dependent co-arising is so easy," and the Buddha would say, "No, no, it's not easy at all." Or Ananda says, "Admirable friends are half the holy life," and the Buddha says, "No, the whole of the holy life." But his illustration is good: "I am the admirable friend for everybody out there because I found a way." We have to depend on him, but we depend on him by taking him as an example and trying to develop those same qualities within ourselves. That becomes our refuge.
Q: It seemed from what you were saying earlier that it's okay to lose our relatives. So it just seemed strange to me that there is a valuing of the Sangha and a lesser value placed on family relationships.
Ajaan Thanissaro: Your best friends are your admirable friends—people who are good examples. Now, sometimes members of your family are good examples, and sometimes they're not. In which case, if they're not, then you've got to look for a good example outside.
Q: But our children—we have to look after our children.
Ajaan Thanissaro: You have to be the admirable friend for your children. You've got to embody the good qualities. That's a whole other talk. We have to break now. I guess that's all for today. Thank you for your attention.
Anicca: A Pali word often translated as "impermanence," but more accurately described here as "inconstant" or "unreliable." ↩︎
Arahant: A fully awakened individual who has eradicated all mental defilements and will not be reborn. Original transcript said 'aura of iron', corrected based on context. ↩︎
Merit: (Pali: puñña) Actions that generate positive karmic results, often cultivated by lay people through generosity toward the monastic Sangha. Original transcript said 'Mara', corrected based on context. ↩︎
Eight Worldly Winds: Describes four pairs of universal opposites that constantly buffet human experience: gain and loss, status and loss of status, praise and criticism, and pleasure and pain. ↩︎
Admirable friend: A translation of the Pali term kalyāṇamitta, a spiritual friend or mentor who exemplifies the Buddhist path. ↩︎