Earth Day as Earth Care Day
- Date:
- 2020-04-26
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-22 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Earth Day as Earth Care Day
Good morning, my friends, and here we are for IMC's celebration of Earth Day. In Buddhism, we don't call it Earth Day; we call it Earth Care Day, where the emphasis is not on simply appreciating, valuing, and celebrating this Earth that we live on, but also our role in caring for it. Part of the Buddhist emphasis is to emphasize human responsibility more than human rights. Both are very important, but sometimes the idea of rights blinds people, binding us from our ability to respond, our capacity for sharing, building, and creating a better world for everyone. What we're learning so much is how interconnected we all are. The welfare of others is clearly important for our own welfare, and our welfare is important for them. How do we care for the world, the Earth, and how do we care for ourselves so it's mutually supportive? This is one of the big tasks of our era, of this generation of people.
We're living in remarkable times. We all know that; few people could have expected this even a few months ago. There are radical ways in which our societies, the whole globe, has been changed in unimaginable ways. To some degree, it's been a global pause. Many things have slowed down, many things have stopped, and many people—not everyone, for sure, but many people—are not doing many of the normal activities they would have done before. In this global change, it is an opportune time to rethink how society is organized, how governments run, how we care for the Earth, and how we live our lives. There is an opportunity now to change in ways that were probably unimaginable even just a few months ago.
What has happened now, as I said, was unimaginable, but it has happened. Environmentalists wanted us to use airplanes less; airplane traffic is down ninety percent. We are using less fossil fuels—there's a little bit of a crisis in the oil industry because people are using a lot less oil and gas. The air has gotten cleaner, waters have gotten cleaner, animals are happier, apparently. There is an anecdote of a story of the pandas I heard at a zoo, where they've been trying to mate the pandas for thirteen years. They finally mated in the last few months, and the theory is that they were finally left alone. Maybe pandas don't like to mate on display. The zoos are closed, they're left alone and quieter, and they could mate. It's a nice, representative story of maybe the natural world renewing itself without the ongoing onslaught of human society and its insatiable consumption of goods.
Earth Day is a day to appreciate the natural world. I was very surprised a couple of weeks into the sheltering-in-place to walk outside here in Redwood City and breathe in a way that I've never breathed the air before here. I think it was a combination of all kinds of factors that made it so fresh and so alive, and it had little elements of the sea coming in as well. It wasn't just that there was much less car pollution and factory pollution, but certainly, that contributed. Without that, I wouldn't have been able to feel this beautiful fresh air that felt like medicine. It felt healing, helpful, and wonderfully beautiful to breathe. I reflected on how a hundred years ago, probably less for many people, this was an ordinary part of human life—to have fresh air in most places in the world. In a sense, it was a right that people had, a right that didn't have to be a right because the air was just clean. That is representative to me of so much that we've lost. We've lost clean water, clean air.
Some of the places that have the most polluted air right now in the United States are places I wouldn't have imagined myself. Los Angeles still has a lot of pollution, but also Fairbanks, Alaska, and Chico, California. Some of that, especially for Fairbanks last year, had to do with fires. The particulate matter that came from fires elevated quite a bit. With this idea of the air becoming clean and quiet, I just love the quiet that I'm experiencing now. Certainly, there are no leaf blowers, or very few. I don't hear the regular airplanes flying over, which is really nice, and there's not so much traffic. It is really something to experience the quiet, and also the spaciousness, all the space.
Looking back to my growing up—I grew up in different countries and different circumstances for sure, but I look back at that time as maybe an innocent time compared to now. I remember there being much more space than what I experience in the San Francisco Bay Area, where there has been so much traffic and so many cars and people. But now the streets are kind of empty. Sometimes I walk in the middle of the street just because I like all the open space around me. There are no cars coming, so I might as well enjoy the spaciousness. The other day I was walking down the hill from my house, in the middle of the road, and there was a little intersection. There in the intersection, just sharing it with me, was a four-foot heron. Who could have imagined a four-foot heron on the asphalt of an intersection? We looked at each other, and I stood there for a while enjoying it. There was a wonderful pleasure in that.
Fifty years ago, the first Earth Day happened; there have been fifty of these celebrations now. Perhaps this is the most sober one. Sober, I think, in both meanings of the word. It means serious and solemn; it's a serious time we're in. It also means free of alcohol, to be sober and free of addiction. Certainly, our society is addicted to consumption. I think we can see it. We are addicted to oil production, oil sales, and oil usage because of the huge need for employment in the oil industry, for profits in the oil industry, for stockholders in the oil industry. It just goes on and on. This addiction is fraught, certainly, with a lot of suffering, which has to be taken seriously and considered. But we have this sober time, this very serious time, a very important time of crisis that is giving us an unparalleled opportunity to rethink everything, including our relationship to the Earth, to the natural world, the more-than-human world.
The natural world, the Earth, is not a passive entity. We can't just keep using it, exploiting it, and polluting it as if it's a passive recipient that can absorb it all. Like Gaia[1], this Earth lives in this amazing homeostasis, trying to come back and forth. It rebounds, it reacts, it responds to what is done to it. This is especially true at the scale at which humans can act now—a scale which wasn't really that relevant long ago. There is a very odd teaching that I had never really understood in early Buddhism. It's in just one or two places in the texts where they make a reference. It's not even a teaching, it's just a concept. It says that human beings have the idea of six consciousnesses[2]: there's eye consciousness, ear consciousness, taste, smell, body consciousness (tactile consciousness), and then the consciousness or awareness of the mind. The concept is that the Earth has only one consciousness. It doesn't explain what that is, but it's an intriguing idea—that the Earth too is conscious. Perhaps it's the tactile consciousness, and to what is done to the Earth physically, materially, the Earth responds accordingly. It's responsive; it changes. Things die, the fall comes, spring comes. And it is said repeatedly now that because of how much human beings have pushed into the natural world, it's having an impact that's affecting us back.
All the fires in California that we've had in recent years are partly because we've moved into places that are fire zones, pushing too far into them without setting up proper safety measures. We have polluted waters; we have a water crisis in this country and certainly around the world. There are rivers that can no longer be drunk out of, rivers that are so polluted we can't even swim in them. In this country, some of the poorest people—in Detroit, for example, Alabama, and in Central California—face a major water crisis. Either there is no water, or the water is very, very polluted, full of lead and all kinds of things. We put things into the water, pollute it, and it comes back. We put chemicals into the soil—pesticides and herbicides—and it percolates down into the groundwater, and it comes back.
There is this rebound, this cycling, this returning that goes on. The Earth, we know, is a phenomenal, complex ecosystem that is constantly shifting and moving into homeostasis. But if we contribute too much to that homeostasis, we affect the rebound. It changes things, and that change then can affect us. Our health depends on having clean air. Our health depends on having clean water. Our health depends on having just the right balance of fire—not too much, not too little. Our health depends on the land being harmonious, in fact, being an Earth system where what grows on the land lives in harmony and is supportive.
I grew up in a city in Italy called Trieste, at the top of the Adriatic. We would drive down the coast of Yugoslavia—back then Yugoslavia, the Adriatic coast—sometimes for the weekend, and visit some of the little islands there. There are beautiful islands on that Yugoslavian coast, what is now Croatia. They were beautiful, but they were beautiful because they were so stark. They were barren, for the most part, of soil. They had once been filled with soil and forests, but the Romans came in and cut down the forests to grow grapes. Still, back in the 1960s, you could go diving in some of the harbors and bays and see all these Roman shards on the ground. Some people found whole vases that had been lost overboard, which held wine. The land was over-farmed, and the soil washed away, and now it's stark. Much of the islands of Greece are the same thing, and Mesopotamia. There are all these places in the world where human beings have overstretched and overutilized the environment and destroyed it. They destroyed the very things of subsistence, the things that supported them.
So, humans have a long history of doing this. It isn't a new phenomenon; it's just that the scale is now at a global level. The coronavirus is an indication, symptomatic or representative, of the phenomenal ways in which we are interconnected, the phenomenal ways in which we influence each other, affect each other, and connect to each other for better or for worse. With the coronavirus, it's for worse. People are dying, people are trying to figure out how to stay alive, and it is having a tremendous damaging effect on the economy. I think that the coronavirus could easily be the first of a number of crises that come.
So, rather than being Earth Day, for Buddhists, it's Earth Care Day. The idea that we're caring for the Earth is the same for Buddhists as caring for ourselves; these two are intimately connected to each other, they are inseparable. The more we care for the Earth, the more we care for ourselves and for the people we love.
There was a remarkable study done a few years ago during the Olympics in Beijing. Beijing is one of the most polluted cities in the world, but for the Olympics, for three months, they cut back on car driving and factories to clean up the air. During that time in China, they did studies about the health effects of this clean air. One of the things they found is that during that time of clean air, or in the wake of it, pregnant women stayed in gestation longer than the average had been for many years, and the babies were larger and heavier. In other words, there was a correlation between smog and gestation rates for human beings. Smog doesn't come cost-free; it has a huge impact on our health, and we don't pay attention to it enough as a society.
We're willing to have pollution and smog in the Bay Area, up in Chico, and down in Fresno, where it affects people with asthma. We're willing to have dirty water. We're willing to destroy pieces of land and have soil erosion that destroys it even more. Our society as a whole is willing to live with a lot of damage that is unhealthy for human beings. There is a trade-off. Is that a trade-off we want to live with? Do we have human rights? Does everyone have a human right to health services, to clean air, to clean water? Is that a right that we should prioritize? And are there human responsibilities where we as a society, as a community, provide that to each other, to really guarantee that everyone has health care, everyone has clean air, clean water, and a clean Earth? How do we do it?
This is where this global pause we're in comes into play. I very much hope that everyone is deeply emotionally, psychologically, intellectually, philosophically, and politically influenced by what's happening right now, so that we don't go back to how things were. I hope that we begin some serious conversations, some serious study about how we can live differently, how we can do things differently. If we go back to what we had, it's going to get awful, it's going to get worse. The term "climate change" is just kind of a polite word to say that crisis after crisis is going to come.
Even with how much has changed now—which is kind of like an environmentalist's dream, how far we've come for these six weeks or so in terms of reduced consumption and reduced pollution—it turns out it's not enough. And if that's not enough, doing even more is going to disrupt the economy, and we don't want people out of work. So how do we form an economy, create an economy that's robust and dynamic, that supports people, where people feel that they're used in good ways and are being supported, that also takes care of the environmental health of our planet? We are in it together, and it really requires us to think it out.
It's something that I have put a lot of hope in—not from leadership from the top down, especially in this era, but from the ground up. We all have to contribute, not just by recycling; recycling has been almost ineffective the way it has been going on in recent years. We need to do something much more radical. I was instructed by a figure I saw recently: I saw that half of the United States lives and breathes dirty air. Half of them, amazing. The poorest people have the worst air. The bad air is breathed by the poor, who are the people who have the least voice. The Earth has no voice for itself; it doesn't vote. Those who have the least amount of voice are not heard, and they are the people who suffer the most. How do we listen to the people who don't have a voice so that they count, they're supported, and they can be helped?
There are all kinds of ground-up things. There are a lot of people involved with solar power. It probably shouldn't be seen as the only solution, but apparently, in 2016, there was a hundred billion dollars in investment for solar power around the world. That's pretty impressive. I'm impressed by the scale of money that's being used these days. I mean, wow. Let's use it wisely, let's use it carefully. Let's be smart about this and really think out how we do this.
Because if we want to become free, if we want freedom and liberty—there is no liberty, from a Buddhist point of view, without caring for others. If we're not interested in the welfare of others and the world, liberty is actually the opposite. From a Buddhist point of view, to have the freedom to do whatever we want without any interest in the consequences it has in the wider world is actually to be caught in the opposite of freedom. There is something about caring, about being interested, that comes out of freedom, that's part and parcel of that freedom. If you want to know if you're free, see how much you care about others.
I once asked a Zen teacher of mine, "How do you know if someone's enlightened?" His answer was quite powerful for me. He said, "If they help people." There are certainly people who help others who are not enlightened, so it's not the only criterion. But if that's the first criterion, how do you know that you're maturing in the Dharma[3] practice? Sooner or later—and it can be later, because sometimes self-care is really important, and there is a time to go deep inside, like during your meditation time—we find this out. Rather than caring for others and caring for the Earth being an obligation, rather than it being a responsibility that's a heavy weight, through freedom we discover an ability to respond. We have a "response-ability," an ability to respond that can flow out of freedom, and that is peaceful. It is not weighed down by duty or responsibility, or weighed down by all the difficult emotions that come with being in the world. There is a freedom, there's an ease, there's a peace that is possible.
That might not be popular because we're supposed to care by worrying, we're supposed to care by being angry. But that's not necessary. If you're free, if you discover the freedom of the heart, that freedom gives you an ability to respond from that peace, from that freedom, from that sense of well-being. As we discover spiritual well-being and emotional well-being, that is responsive to the world. The Earth is responsive to how we act, and our liberated heart responds to how the world is. So on Earth Care Day, the day to care for the world, we use our meditation practice, the Buddhist practice, to prepare ourselves for what's coming, and what we want to see is a well-prepared world.
Crises are coming. How do we prepare ourselves for them? How do we prepare ourselves spiritually, emotionally, and psychologically? And how do we prepare for them as a society, as a global community? These are the tasks of our times; this is the challenge of our times. I suspect that this challenge is as big, or maybe bigger, than some of the major challenges of previous generations: the challenges of World War I, the challenges of World War II, the challenges of the Depression in the 1930s. What's happening now is on that scale. Just as those times required something of the people of that time, this is our time to be the generation that cares, to be the generation that makes a difference.
May it be that Earth Care Day is every day for us. Thank you.
Gaia: Original transcript said "Disgaea", corrected to "Gaia" based on context. In mythology and ecological theory (the Gaia hypothesis), it refers to the Earth as a living, self-regulating entity. ↩︎
Six Consciousnesses: In Buddhist psychology, consciousness is categorized into six types corresponding to the six sense bases: eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mind. (Original transcript said "air consciousness", corrected to "ear consciousness" based on context). ↩︎
Dharma: A Sanskrit word (Dhamma in Pali) that refers to the teachings of the Buddha and the underlying truth of how things are. ↩︎