Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation Part 2 (8 of 8): Appreciating the Absence of the Hindrances
- Date:
- 2020-04-30
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-22 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Introduction and Early Q&A
Good morning again. Good morning, Rahul, Monica, Lisa, Louise, Pamela, Connie, and all of you who are here. I am very happy to be back for this last day of the Introduction to Meditation Part Two. We're starting a little bit informally like we have the last few days, so if any of you have any questions you'd like to ask before 9:30, I'll do my best to respond.
Hello to those joining from Belgium, Chicago, Wisconsin, Hawaii, Switzerland, Slovenia, and France! Very nice to have you.
"Any thoughts on cultivating trust and patience?"
I think the central mindfulness way of cultivating trust and patience is to turn your attention to study, to understand, and to really see clearly the ways that you are not trusting and the ways that you are not patient. That will make the trust and patience trustable. If you really understand what the obstacles are, then sometimes the trust has a chance to come up on its own. Or, if you understand the obstacles and can overcome them, the natural thing that should be next from our goodness can come. Maybe that is trust, or maybe that is patience. Or it could be that something else comes up that surprises us. We might think we need trust and patience, but when we somehow free ourselves from the obstacles to them, lo and behold, what was actually needed or what comes up is courage instead.
"Thank you for your advice on physical anxiety and the way to accept it equanimously. When I try to feel my body sensations, I tend to analyze them pretty quickly. Instead of feeling my body, I end up thinking about what I should feel. Seems like I try too hard to feel my body."
Absolutely, that can happen. It's easy with these kinds of mindful instructions to hear them as prescriptions of what you have to do, and then you try very hard. So there are a few things you can do. One is to hear the instructions not so much as prescriptions of what to do, but rather descriptions of what you'll be aware of. When we talk about mindfulness of the body, those are descriptions of what you can notice. The attitude is more of receptivity, curiosity, or allowing the body to show itself to us. Analysis is more of a "going into" and focusing, where the locus is the mind and the self doing the analyzing. When it's descriptive, the locus is what's revealing itself.
The other possibility is that if there's a lot of analysis, that is the natural tendency or habit of your mind. Rather than trying to overcome it, you might turn your attention around 180 degrees to really start feeling, sensing, and observing the analytical mind itself. What's happening physically in the brain and the body when we're analyzing? Maybe the eyes get tense, or there's tension in the forehead, or a physical pressure in the brain. What's happening emotionally? Subtly, but importantly, underlying analysis might be fear. We might over-analyze because we've learned—perhaps from a strict elementary school teacher—that this is how we succeed, stay safe, and present our brilliance. Step back and take a good look at that analyzing mind. Understand what beliefs and values you are operating under, so you can question it and not be habitually committed to it.
"How do we explore thoughts?"
I'm glad you're asking the question. To answer this briefly, in the Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation Part One, there is a whole session dedicated to mindfulness of thinking. You might go back and listen to that on the AudioDharma website or YouTube channel. I've given many instructions on thinking over the years; if you search for "thinking" on audiodharma.org, you'll find lots of examples.
"Do you recommend a specific time, a specific hour of the day to meditate?"
"Recommend" is a strong word, but if all things are equal, I would suggest meditating when you first get up—as soon as you feel fresh or awake enough in the morning to do it. That might be directly after waking, or after having some food, tea, or getting some fresh air. Meditating relatively early in the morning sets a wonderful tone for the rest of the day. For some people, because they haven't yet gotten involved with the busyness of the day, it's easier to settle and get focused.
If all things are equal, I would suggest meditating twice a day. A pattern that was very supportive for me for many years was meditating first thing in the morning, and then again around five or six o'clock in the afternoon or evening. Having that balance on either side of the daytime hours was very helpful. The afternoon sitting had a different function; it was often about processing and settling out from the activities of the day. I found that if I meditated when I first came home, my evening was clearer, I was more alert, and I slept better.
Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation Part 2 (8 of 8): Appreciating the Absence of the Hindrances
We're beginning again for the last of these eight sessions on Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation Part Two, where we've been looking at the hindrances. The literal meaning of the ancient Pali word nīvaraṇa[1] is a covering—that which covers over something. It's a beautiful, profound thing to take the covers off the depths of our hearts and our minds, and discover the treasure that is quite beautiful there.
The Buddha likened the process of becoming free of the hindrances to a goldsmith who purifies gold. When gold is full of dross and impurities, it can be rigid, hard, and brittle. But heating the gold and hammering the gold eventually frees it from those impurities, making it soft and malleable. Once it's pure and malleable enough, it can be shaped into something beautiful. The same applies to the mind. We're freeing the mind from the hindrances, and it's a slow process. Step by step, over and over again, we are refining it. Eventually, the mind becomes clear, clean, and beautiful. It becomes a wonderful companion to have with you wherever you go.
We clearly want to overcome the hindrances, but it might be best to think of it as freeing ourselves first and foremost from the way desires, ill will, sloth and torpor, restlessness and worry, and doubt hinder us. They get in the way. One of the primary tools in mindfulness is making that 180-degree turn to really look back at the hindrances and see them for what they are. Once we have real clarity in seeing what is happening, there's a kind of freedom in that seeing. The desire or ill will might still be there, but they're no longer hindering the clarity and wisdom of the mind.
As this process continues, we become more familiar with these states, and at some point, they drop away or we are able to let go of them. This is an important turning point in a meditator's life. It can be like coming to a fork in the road where one sees clearly that there is a choice: taking one direction goes towards greater hindrances and greater clinging, and the other direction goes towards freedom from clinging. If we just allow the hindrances to operate unabatedly, it leads to more clinging. But if we bring mindfulness, wake up to them, see them clearly, and learn to lessen them, it's a process towards freedom.
Having a clear experience of the absence of the hindrances is important because then we don't get confused about what real inner freedom might be. It's very easy for people to confuse inner freedom with the unhindered pursuit of desire, the unrestrained expression of ill will, the unchallenged disinterest of sloth and torpor, the uninhibited movements of restlessness and worry, and unquestioned doubt-like skepticism or cynicism. When we allow the hindrances to operate freely, people can value it and feel like there are no barriers. Some might think, "I should be free to do whatever I want; whatever is in me needs to be expressed." But if what needs to be expressed is harmful, like ill will, this is not the freedom of the Buddha.
The freedom of the Buddha is a freedom from. It is a real freedom from being restricted by clinging and grasping. In Buddhism, people who become spiritually mature might describe liberation and awakening differently, but they all value non-clinging. They learn not to contract around something or grip onto it tightly, realizing it's possible to take care of life from a place of non-clinging—open-handed, open-minded, and open-hearted.
The last step of BELLA (Be, Explore, Lessen, Let go, and Appreciate) is to appreciate the absence of the hindrances. Take time to take it in. Because hindrances can be quite powerful, they can limit a life much more than people realize. Sometimes in retrospect we realize, "Oh my, I lived a truncated life by always pursuing my desires, my complaints, my ill wills, my irritations, even when they were very mild."
To help us really feel the absence of them, the Buddha gave a few similes. He wanted to emphasize that in appreciating the absence of the hindrances, we can allow ourselves to be glad and full of joy. The Buddha said that someone who is free of the hindrances is glad and full of joy like:
- A person who is no longer in debt.
- A person who has recovered from being seriously sick.
- A person who is no longer imprisoned.
- A person who is no longer enslaved.
- A person who has made it safely through a dangerous journey in the desert.
Being in debt or being sick can be very debilitating; being free of those things produces joy and happiness. Getting through the desert of the hindrances and feeling that purity and clarity can be a profound source of gladness. Take time to allow yourself to be glad and recognize, "This is really good."
As concentration and meditation practice deepen, and the hindrances fall away, that gives rise to gladness. Sequentially, like a river that keeps building as tributaries join it, gladness gives rise to joy. Joy brings tranquility and relaxation to the body. Tranquility brings happiness, and from happiness flows deeper and deeper states of concentration.
Some people learn from society that we're almost justified in being hindered. We're supposed to complain. Some families show love only by worrying, and if you don't worry, you aren't showing that you care. You're taught to be skeptical of everything. You're told that only by having and fulfilling desires are you a successful, praiseworthy person. Or that having critical opinions proves you're right and smart. To practice meditation and discover it's possible to let all that quiet down, and to discover the goodness of that absence, is deeply satisfying. It feels like coming home. It's a profound intimacy that can't happen when we're caught in the churning turmoil of the hindrances. It is a life-changer to realize there's a whole other way of being, prioritizing moving towards freedom, goodness, joy, and well-being.
I built these sessions on hindrances as part two of the mindfulness class to build upon the basic instructions. Those foundational instructions are so important. As you practice paying attention, what eventually becomes appropriate to focus on are the very things that make basic mindfulness difficult—the things that interfere with it. Learning how to work with the hindrances is a way to learn how to work with all the obstructions that can come up as we meditate and live our lives.
Guided Meditation
Show meditation
Hide meditation
Guided Meditation
So I thought that now we would meditate. If you want to stand a little bit, stretch, and refresh yourself so you feel more ready, please do so.
Then, when you're ready, take a meditation posture that might support inner freedom. A meditation posture that has room in it for something to be freed from the inside out. If you're slumped on a couch, there isn't much room in the chest for something to become free. Sitting or standing upright, or laying down with your chest expanded, allows for some room and space. Take a posture that allows for both relaxation and physical alertness.
Close your eyes.
Take a few moments first to look back over your life for a particular time or occasion when you might have been the most free of the hindrances. The most free of clinging. A time that you felt deeply at peace, at ease. A time when you felt safe enough to release your fear, where you were contented and had no desires that had to be fulfilled. No aversion. Maybe it was as simple as waking up from a nice nap, laying in bed feeling content. Maybe it was after accomplishing something difficult and just sitting quietly, releasing everything. Or a time in nature.
Allow yourself to remember what it felt like to be that way. By visualizing the situation, touch into what it felt like in your body, energetically, in your heart, and in your mind.
Then, let go of the image and the ideas of that time. To whatever degree it's available—even if it's very small—let the feelings of that peace linger in your body and your mind. Notice where in your body this exists. Perhaps opening further to those feelings.
With that feeling as a reference point, become aware of your breathing. Almost as if the breathing is a gentle wind that blows on top of a very quiet lake. Allow the breathing to come and go over or through whatever feelings you have of being at peace, safe, and free of the hindrances. Even if it's a very small feeling of well-being, let your breathing breathe with that part of you.
Perhaps learn to let go of your thoughts, so you can better feel the peacefulness and calmness somewhere in your being. Part of the connection to the present moment is a connection to this well-being. You might have many other feelings, some very difficult, and you aren't denying them. But you're recognizing there is also some place within that is free of difficulty, some sense of well-being that can exist side-by-side with the difficulties. You don't have to be preoccupied with the difficulties; you can just allow them to be known as well.
Allow yourself to feel your breathing. Not so much that you're doing mindfulness of breathing as a technique or trying too hard, but rather you're allowing the breathing to appear in awareness. You're allowing the breathing to be felt by the body and known by a quiet mind.
If you find yourself thinking, relax the thinking muscle. Then allow the breathing to come back into awareness. Welcome the experience of breathing back into an awareness which is free of desire, ill will, sloth, restlessness, and doubt. Welcome the breathing into that part of awareness that is free.
As we continue a little bit longer with this meditation... is there anything within you that corresponds to a quality of non-clinging, non-grasping, or non-resistance? Even if there is grasping and resistance happening somewhere else within, is there something that feels like a place of non-clinging? What is it like to know that is there?
Do you have any intuition or vision of a choice between moving towards the hindrances and clinging, or moving away from them towards non-clinging? Any sense of that divide, that fork in the road? Is there any way that knowing that divide might be a support for you?
Reflections and Q&A
So my friends, we're coming to the end of what I have to say about the hindrances. I want to end on a particular note about freedom. In Buddhism, there are lots of similes and metaphors. For some people, these give a more embodied, emotional, and holistic feel to a teaching than plain concepts do.
Freedom is likened to turbulent water that has become clear and still. It is like a dirty mirror that has become clear when cleaned. It is like a bird gliding in open air. Freedom is accompanied by peace, clarity, and a resting, gliding openness.
This whole practice of mindfulness and working with hindrances is part and parcel of a movement on the path toward our potential for a deep, embodied, and enheartened liberation. It is considered one of the great purposes of human life—a noble and dignified endeavor that we do not just for ourselves, but for others. The more inner freedom someone has, the greater their capacity to care for others and to live in ways which do not perpetuate harm in this world. Living a harmless life of care is one of the great purposes of the Buddhist path.
Now we have some time for final words. If you have any questions or concerns you'd like to raise, I'll try to respond. I welcome them and am very fond of having this chance to share this final connection with you.
"I notice that the beauty of nature calls me into the present in a gleeful, peaceful way. Does noticing when presence happens naturally help increase the habit of being more present?"
Oh, absolutely. There is a very powerful lesson in noticing when we find ourselves naturally present. Notice the naturalness of it—the lack of work, the lack of forcing, the lack of obligation, and the lack of self-conceit in it. It's a wonderful lesson about what's possible.
You're right about feeling that in nature. It's also possible to feel that in meditation in a simple way. When the mind wanders away in thought, it is very common for people to get upset or discouraged, and to jerk their mind back to the breath, causing a kind of whiplash in the mind. If instead, you recognize that when you're deeply lost in thought, you don't even know there's a problem! But the very first moment you notice you were involved in thought, that noticing probably has some of those qualities of the beauty of nature, of just naturally finding yourself present. There's a simplicity, an ease, and a lack of judgment or commentary in that first moment of waking up from thought. If you can learn to recognize that and stay in that ease, and then welcome the breath back, it's very nice.
"I've noticed hindrances that are so subtle. This has given me some freedom. Thoughts on this?"
This is very good. I did many years of Zen meditation and benefited from it, but it was only when I started doing mindfulness and paying real, careful attention to the subtleties of the mind that I saw a lot of hindrances operating very subtly. As practice continues, I hope you have the experience of recognizing your hindrances and feeling a certain delight, amusement, and joy—not in having the hindrance, but in recognizing your habit! In that recognition, there's freedom. All the things I've been teaching about the hindrances operate when they're subtle, too. Allowing the attention to get more and more subtle actually makes the mind more still and more quiet.
"Do you have any suggestions for dealing with skepticism and sarcasm?"
Yes, the same thing I've been saying before: get to know skepticism and sarcasm better, and really feel the impact they have. Assuming you are asking for yourself and not about dealing with other people's sarcasm, really feel the cost that skepticism and sarcasm have on you very personally. In what way does it create distance between you and other people? To what degree does it shut something down in you? To what degree is it like sandpaper on the mind or the heart?
Really turn around and look at it, and get to know what motivates it. It's possible that the skepticism and sarcasm should be respected; even though it's unfortunate to have it, it might be arising out of something deeper. If you just try to bat it away, you might not notice that deep inside there is a desire to be safe, to be liked, or a need for love that requires a very different kind of attention. When we turn toward the difficulties we have, we might find they are covering over something precious deeper down.
"Self doubt is one of the kilesas[2] that has plagued me for a long time. You've enheartened me to have faith in my practice, and feel some inner freedom."
Fantastic. Thank you. I love reading that.
"What exactly is enlightenment? Is it the complete absence of clinging and desire?"
Yes, the absence of clinging is awakening or liberation in Buddhism. That can happen to various degrees. It can happen in mild ways, moderate ways, and very strong ways. Even in very mild ways, we can get a taste of what full liberation is when we recognize the absence of clinging. As the absence of clinging becomes stronger, we start using it as a teacher.
We have to be very careful about talking about the absence of desire. In full-blown awakening, there is no clinging; everything drops away in that deep release. However, an enlightened person will still have desire after that experience of deep release. They don't have compulsive or neurotic desires, and there's no clinging as part of the desires. Their desires are basically either neutral or wholesome and helpful.
"Where does fear of being taken advantage of fit into the hindrances?"
We have to be very careful with fear. Fear is sometimes healthy and appropriate to have. If the question had been, "Where does caution of being taken advantage of fit into the hindrances?", I think that caution and care are part of a wise, good life. However, even healthy desire and healthy fear can be accompanied by the hindrances. When they are, it's hard to take care of the fear or operate from caution in healthy ways. You can have a healthy fear, but if it comes along with ill will or doubt, it all gets more complicated than it needs to be.
"So the translation of 'idle speech' is confusing?"
Yes, it is confusing. The ancient Pali word translated as "idle speech" is one that no one really knows how to translate perfectly. Some translate it as "gossip," which makes it a little bit clearer. "Idle speech" by itself can sometimes be a beautiful way of connecting with people and having a nice relationship. So, maybe a better translation would be "pointless speech" or "vacuous speech."
"How do we differentiate between letting go and giving up?"
When we learn to let go in healthy ways, letting go always brings some form of joy, delight, or well-being. If I let go and just feel neutral, I haven't really let go, and it will usually come back and bite me. You really know you've let go when you feel, "Ahh, this is good. This is right." If you let go and feel, "Ugh, well I let go, but that was a drag," that's not real letting go.
There can be healthy giving up if we're forced to give up. I've sometimes been forced to give up on retreat because every effort to address an issue just made it worse. Finally, in frustration, I just gave up and surrendered to it, and a path opened up. But if you give up consciously out of despair or discouragement, there's no joy or openness that comes from it. Hopefully, you can feel for yourself the different effect that healthy letting go has versus unhealthy giving up. This is why mindfulness is so important—we're supposed to find the evidence in ourselves so we can become our own teacher.
"Variations of the same type of hindrance seem to repeat, and I feel I'm causing my own suffering. I'm struggling to understand. Guidance?"
This is probably common for everyone. In a Buddhist analysis, the suffering we are trying to address is the suffering we cause ourselves. If that's what you're tuning into, Buddhism is good for you. Starting Monday in my 7 AM morning sittings, I will be talking about The Four Noble Truths[3], which is the core teaching in Buddhism around suffering itself. Next week will be focused entirely on the First Noble Truth (suffering). I hope to present these teachings in a way that doesn't make you suffer more, but actually the opposite.
You say you are struggling to understand. Keep struggling; it's a worthwhile struggle. But try to understand: what is it you're attached to? What are you trying to do? What is the nature of the struggle itself? Remember to turn that attention around 180 degrees to look at the challenge. Study the struggle itself. If the challenge is in the suffering you keep having, look at it honestly.
"I like humor, most of which is sarcastic. Advice?"
If you're with people who understand you well and know you're a good-natured, generous person, maybe it's okay. It depends on what kind of sarcasm it is. I just know that many times when I hear sarcasm, something inside of me closes up, gets tight, and I get more discouraged than encouraged.
If you like humor, maybe learn a different kind of humor. Use your intelligence to learn about comedians or read joke books that are not sarcastic. See if there's a way to be amusing that isn't sarcastic. One thing I've learned to do is that if I find a humorous observation to make, instead of making it about the person I'm talking with, I try to turn it around and make myself the subject of the joke. That way, I'm not making any statement about other people.
[Laughter]
I think it's time to stop. I appreciate your questions, your comments, the good mornings, the thank-yous, and the warmth between you. It is really nice to have this connection and share these teachings with you. I will consider doing an "intermediate mindfulness meditation" part three at some point. I need to take a break for a while, but perhaps near the end of May or in June, I can start again. You can check the IMC website calendar for when I am ready to do that.
Thank you very much, and I look forward to more opportunities to practice with you.
Nīvaraṇa: A Pali word typically translated as "hindrances" or "obstacles." In Buddhism, the Five Hindrances are negative mental states that impede meditation and insight: sensory desire, ill will, sloth and torpor, restlessness and worry, and doubt. ↩︎
Kilesas: A Pali word often translated as "defilements," "corruptions," or "afflictions." They are negative mental states that cloud the mind and manifest in unwholesome actions. ↩︎
The Four Noble Truths: The foundational framework of the Buddha's teachings, comprising the truth of suffering (dukkha), the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path leading to the cessation of suffering. ↩︎