Moon Pointing

Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (4 of 9)

Date:
2020-04-02
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-22 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (4 of 9)

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (4 of 9)

So we are going to continue with this topic of mindfulness and begin talking a little bit about mindfulness of emotions. Emotions are a very important part of human life. Not only are they important, but they certainly warrant a fair amount of respect. I love the word respect because, for a person doing Vipassanā[1], doing mindfulness practice, it kind of goes along with it. The word Vipassanā—passanā means to see, and vi means to see in a special way. Respect means to see the spectacle part of it, and the re- is to just do it again. So I think of it that respect means to take a second look, to look again. That's one way of characterizing mindfulness practice: that we don't just settle for the first glance, first impressions of what goes on, but with mindfulness we take a second look. We give it more attention; we offer ourselves to really see what's happening here, what's going on.

Some people like to emphasize that mindfulness, in certain circumstances, does involve a kind of a pause, maybe even a sacred pause, where we don't disconnect completely from what's going on, but the pause allows us to see more clearly what is actually happening. What's happening around us, but also what's happening within us, so that when we respond, we're actually better informed. We kind of have a better picture of the full idea.

For those of you who might be new to this joining us now, I want to emphasize that in doing mindfulness practice we're using a very ordinary, everyday human capacity: the capacity to pay attention, the capacity to be aware. We use awareness all the time in our daily life. You're using your awareness to listen to me as I speak. Most of the time, there's some degree of awareness going on. It's when we do something and we don't stay aware of what we're doing—we're lost in daydreams or something—that we end up making accidents, or tripping, or something goes awry. As people learn mindfulness, they learn that a heightened development of this capacity to be attentive helps us to live a better life. It tends to be a safer life; it tends to bring safety. Some people call it a refuge. It tends to bring clarity, greater self-understanding. It can also help bring a greater sense of ease in our lives. So whereas using this kind of ordinary everyday activity might seem boring, it might seem not exciting and interesting, it's actually very, very helpful. In my experience, life actually gets more and more interesting, and in a certain wonderful way, not exciting exactly, but it becomes a greater and greater adventure to live this life with a much more full attention to what's going on, how it's unfolding. We start becoming aware of the layers of depth that exist in any given moment, any given exchange, involvement, or activity we're doing.

Developing this natural capacity of attention so it becomes strong enough that we can remain attentive, we can be attentive in a clear way of what's happening moment by moment—to do that is a training. It's like a muscle that you have to work out and to keep doing it and become stronger and stronger. Keep doing the mindfulness thing, the mindfulness muscle. That muscle not only gets stronger, but becomes more, with time, second nature. We find ourselves more and more just naturally present for our experience with a wonderfully heightened sense of awareness. Not heightened in terms of being on alert, but heightened in terms of better taking in the fullness of the situation in all the different aspects of it.

Emotions are an important part of the experience, and to become aware of our emotions makes us wiser, makes us safer, makes us able to navigate the different ups and downs of the emotional life. It helps our emotional life to kind of come to fulfillment, to move through us, and to allow them to find their own way. I like to think of the word emotion coming from the Latin, meaning motion, movement, and then e-, which means out as a prefix in Latin. So emotions are moving out there; they're in movement. And when they are allowed to move, then most emotions move towards health, move towards homeostasis, move towards the growing of beneficial qualities. It's when we interfere with them, when we block them, when we ignore them, when we somehow try to manipulate them, or we get too involved with them, that emotions get much more difficult. This process of learning to free up our emotional life is part of the movement of mindfulness.

Now, not everything that we free up emotionally should be expressed in public and with all kinds of people, for sure. But meditation is a very special place where hopefully you sit and meditate and you're committed to being still and not moving for a period of time, and maybe you keep your eyes closed. In this context, it's one of the few places that some people have where they can allow their emotional life to manifest, to bubble up, to really show itself, where it's okay to make space for it. So we're not trying to repress, we're not trying to deny, and there's no emotion in the context of meditation practice that we have to be concerned with as a good emotion or a bad emotion, or feel shame that it's happening, or feel pride that it's happening. The idea is to just keep opening, keep opening in a way that doesn't fuel it. We don't identify with it, we don't get caught in it, but in a sense we make space for it. That's what I mean by this respecting. We want to respect all emotions so that some deeper process can unfold in our emotional life. It takes some skill and some wisdom to learn how to be with the emotions in a good way, a useful way, to do it in a mindful way. That'll be some of the things we're going to be talking about today.

The Parable of the Two Arrows

I want to first tell you a story from the time of the Buddha as a little teaching analogy or metaphor[2]. The Buddha was sitting with a group of people and talking, and he said to them, "If an archer comes along and shoots an arrow at a person and it hits the person, is that going to hurt the person?" And the people in the audience told him, "Oh yes, that'll hurt."

And then the Buddha said, "If that archer then comes along and takes a second arrow..." Let's wait a minute, there's a lot of noise outside, and there's street cleaners happening here in Redwood City.

So then the Buddha said, "If the archer strikes a second arrow, it hits the person, would that hurt the person even more?" And the audience said, "Yes, if the person got struck by two arrows, a second arrow, that hurts more than just one arrow."

The Buddha used that analogy to say something like this, to paraphrase him: the first arrow is what life does to you, and there's no guarantee that life doesn't throw you arrows. The second arrow is the one that you use yourself, that you strike yourself with. What that means is that I could be walking down the sidewalk and trip on something on the sidewalk. That's unfortunate, but these kinds of things will happen to human beings—that they have a little accident, they trip and they fall. And I could then get up, and I could now be angry with myself because I'm a bad walker, I'm not a very good walker. Or, since I'm a mindfulness teacher, I might say, "Oh, this is embarrassing. You're a disgrace to the world of mindfulness that you weren't paying enough attention to notice the crack in the sidewalk. You're really not up to being a teacher, and I certainly don't want to admit it to everyone around the world seeing this." And I could bury myself in self-reproach and self-criticism around the fact that I tripped on the sidewalk.

Or, I could trip on the sidewalk and then pick myself up, make sure I wasn't injured, remind myself in the future to be careful with that part of the sidewalk, and just keep walking along without shooting second, third, and fourth arrows into me.

Life as we live it, all kinds of things happen. Some of them are unfortunate, some of them are painful and cause difficulty and challenges. And then there's the second arrow that we're responsible for. Not all the arrows are we responsible for, but the ones that we can do something about are the ones that we shoot. The idea is to experience things without the reproach, without the criticism, without the anger, without the clinging, just to experience the first arrow and let it be.

For some people, it isn't just one arrow they shoot. Something happens—they trip on the sidewalk—and they criticize themselves for being a poor walker. That's a second arrow. Then they think about all the people who might have seen them, and now they're embarrassed—that's maybe the third arrow. And then they tell themselves, "I really need to go get therapy to learn how to be a better walker, but I can't afford therapy because my parents didn't raise me properly, and I never get any kind of advantages, I'm always taken advantage of, and my life is so hard." All those things might be true—I don't want to just diminish anyone's life—but to keep slinging those arrows at oneself is debilitating. To have some clarity—"Oh, that's a second, third, fourth, fifth arrow"—is not to then shoot a sixth arrow: "Look at me, I'm doing all this terrible stuff."

In mindfulness practice, this sacred pause just to be aware functions as a ceasefire of these arrows that we can throw at ourselves. Sooner or later, the idea is just to kind of open and let things be, not because we're condoning anything, but because we're letting them be so we don't add more arrows.

I give this teaching in particular because we're doing emotions today, and emotions can be quite difficult. Many people will bring to their emotional life all kinds of judgments, all kinds of reactions to it, all kinds of resistance or ideas that are very much in the domain of these extra arrows, which makes it actually harder than it originally is. Some emotions are hard enough as they are, but to add the arrows makes them more and more difficult. So to learn to be mindful of emotions is to learn how to keep the emotions simple. Just allow the emotion to be there and respect it, look at it again, make space for it for something that might unfold.

Checking In with Emotions

To start this process of looking at the mindfulness of emotions, I'd like to ask you to, just as you are, no special change of posture, whatever posture you're in, to close your eyes. Then if you could just check in with yourself as you are and notice what emotion is predominant in you. How are you feeling? Any way you're feeling is allowed for this exercise. It might be very subtle; maybe you're subtly impatient, subtly content. Maybe it's quite strong what you're feeling inside.

Whatever you're feeling, the mood that you have, the emotional state, the mind state that seems to be present, take a moment to really recognize, "Oh, this is what's happening. This is what I'm feeling." If it's obvious, use a mental note: sad, happy, irritated, delighted. Just make the mental note just to acknowledge it, to really recognize what is happening.

And then, having recognized how you're feeling, now do what I taught you on the first day: do the three-breath journey. Just allow yourself to breathe the way you are, but count your breaths to three. Really kind of in the middle of how you're feeling, just tune into your breaths and breathe three breaths in a clear, connected way.

And then you can open your eyes.

Of course, I can't know what everyone's experience is of doing this little exercise. But one of the possibilities that maybe teaches a little bit of something is that when they take time to see how they're feeling, for some people it's the first time they've checked in and noticed what's happening. They didn't really know clearly what they're feeling until they stopped to look. That can be useful to know. For some people, you might have already known what you feel, but to clearly acknowledge it, to recognize it, maybe something different happens. There's more space for it, or more clarity.

Sometimes the very acknowledgment of something reduces the hold it has on us, some of the ways in which we're maybe struggling with it or it's struggling with us, and then kind of allows it to be there. Allowing it to be there but not giving it any real attention, but not ignoring it either, by taking three breaths in the middle of it—for some people that will remove some of the ways in which they're entangled with it, fueling it, or reacting, judging, or concerned with it. That makes more space for the emotion to be there, but we're getting even more out of the way to allow it to settle or to open up.

There's a tendency for afflictive emotions—those emotions which are painful—to begin to unwind themselves and settle if we're not feeding them, if we're not holding them or involved with them. There's a tendency for the beneficial emotions—the ones that can really come from a deeper place inside—as we hold them and see them in awareness, they tend to be onward-leading to better states. They can get stronger; there's more space for them.

This principle that bringing open awareness, clear mindfulness, recognizing what's there, does have an effect on our emotional life. Not because we're doing it and wanting it and expecting it, but because we're shifting where the fuel of our mind is going. The fuel of mind, if it's going towards afflictive emotions, it's so easy to reinforce them and strengthen it, and then those get stronger. But if the fuel of attention goes to noticing what's beneficial, then those tend to grow and develop.

Guided Meditation

Show meditation Hide meditation

Let's do a 15- or 20-minute meditation, and I'll do some guidance for you. At some point, we'll do a little extra exploration of mindfulness of emotions a bit further.

So if you could take a posture that makes you somewhat comfortable for meditation, but also gives you some sense of alertness. That balance between being comfortable, relaxed, and alert is what we're looking for in the meditation posture. For some people, that's to sit a little bit straighter than they normally would, just so the spine is a little more energized or alert in itself.

And then to softly close your eyes. Have a little process or ritual to help you arrive, help you really connect to yourself here and now. It can be helpful to take a few long, slow, deep breaths in a relaxed way, but to really take a deeper breath so that you feel the connection to your rib cage, your torso. As you breathe in, to feel the stretching and expanding, and then as you exhale, feel the settling, the coming back, the contracting and settling down. Especially as you exhale, if you can do it in a relaxed way, maybe linger a little bit longer with the exhale than you normally would. Kind of ride it out, so you're settling, relaxing with the end of the out-breath. And then letting the breathing return to normal.

Also, to help us arrive and be here in a little bit fuller way, it can be helpful to roam around your body to notice where in your body you can relax muscles. It might be possible to soften the muscles of the face. To relax the eyes; maybe the eyes can rest in their sockets. Some people do mindfulness by trying to see, even with their eyes closed they're actively engaging their eyes. Just let the eyes be soft, resting.

It might be possible to relax and soften the shoulders. From the shoulders, to relax all the way down the arms, until you even soften the hands. It might be possible to soften the chest, maybe as you exhale softening around the heart, and softening the belly. Perhaps you can allow your belly to hang forward and hang down a bit, releasing the habit of pulling the belly in.

And then becoming aware of your breathing, breathing in a normal way, and allow yourself for a few minutes to notice the body's experience of breathing. So in a sense, you are experiencing breathing from the inside of the body. Sometimes when we are watching or knowing something from the mind, in the head, we might almost be outside of the experience. But to let go into the experience of breathing in, let go into the experience of breathing out.

If your mind wanders off in thought and you notice that, make a small mental note, a gentle quiet note: "thinking." Take your time, a sacred pause to recognize that you're thinking. No need to see it as a problem. No need to jerk your mind away and jerk back to the breathing. If you notice you're thinking, acknowledge that that's happening, and once it's acknowledged, in a calm way begin again with your breathing.

Wherever part of the body you're experiencing breathing, let yourself feel the sensations of that part more fully. See if you can gently sense or feel the various sensations that come into play wherever you're experiencing breathing. Maybe in the belly, maybe in the chest, maybe in the nostrils and air going in and out. As you exhale, gently see if you can relax with the exhale. Let go with the letting go of breathing out, letting go into the experience of the body breathing.

And then look around inside and notice how you're feeling right now. Even if it's subtle, what is the basic mood, emotional state, mind state that you have? Is that mind state or mood or feeling you have, is it more on the pleasant side of things, or is it more on the unpleasant? Regardless of whether it's pleasant or unpleasant, allow it to be that way. See if you can experiment with an awareness that perceives but doesn't add second arrows, doesn't get involved or entangled, doesn't judge. Just to be aware of what's there.

It's possible your mood or emotional state is quite subtle, or maybe it's something you don't normally think of as an emotion. It might be that you're a little bit more calm than usual, or settled. Or it might be that you're a little anxious about what's happening, but anxiety is just part of the furniture, it's part of the wallpaper, it just doesn't occur to you to notice it because it's just part and parcel of your experience all the time. Or maybe even there's a feeling of clarity, or a feeling of dullness. There might be tiredness or feelings of being energized.

As you're noticing how you're feeling emotionally—mind states, mood—if you have an obvious single word to describe it: sad, happy, tired, energized, agitated, calm, confident, anxious... see if you can name it. Note it quietly a few times. As you do the mental note, see if you can allow that noting as a way of stepping back, taking a sacred pause to respect it, to see it more clearly, to make space for it, to allow it to be while you recognize that it's there.

And if your mood or emotional state shifts, notice how it shifts. Maybe it gets stronger, maybe it gets weaker. Maybe it transforms into something else, maybe it disappears. If it disappears, see what's replaced it.

And then, if you're able to, see if you can notice where your emotional state, your mood, how you're feeling—where does it most manifest in the body? Where do you feel it the most physically? What part of your body is energized by the mood, the emotional state you have? It might be anywhere. It could be in the belly, in the chest, in the face, the shoulders. Could be in the arms, the hands, the legs, the feet. If you're able to feel the physical side of the emotions that you're having, bring your attention to that part of your body and do mindfulness of the body there, like we talked about yesterday.

Bring your attention to that part of your body and just feel the sensations there, allowing them to be there, giving complete permission to the body to have those sensations that are associated with the emotion. Make room for them, allow them to do what they want to do. Your job is just to know them, to be aware of them. Notice what happens to your emotion if you allow yourself to focus on how it feels physically, with a relaxed awareness, just to make space. It's a way to respect the emotion.

For the last few minutes of this sitting, return to your breathing. Perhaps imagining that the breathing is a gentle wind or a gentle wave that comes and goes. It washes through your whole body, gently massaging whatever you're feeling right now. The whole experience of breathing is like a tender wave of caring for you and caring for what you have, whatever is going on, breathing through and with what's happening as the breath travels through the body.

To end this sitting, you can take some deeper breaths to feel yourself here, to connect to yourself, perhaps feeling your cushion, your chair. As I ring this bell three times, before you open your eyes, let yourself do listening meditation. Just hear the sound with your whole body.

The Composite Nature of Emotions

Perhaps some of you got some sense of a different way of being present for your emotions than you normally do. Certainly to be aware of it maybe with more permission for the emotions to be there, but without being involved with them, without being for and against them. Just being aware of them. It can help to recognize them clearly. Sometimes the emotions need to be acknowledged, and something different happens if we fully acknowledge an emotion, maybe by naming it.

It's also possible to feel the emotions in the body. This is why I like to teach mindfulness of the body before doing emotions. Because part of what an emotion is, is something that's energized or engaged, sensations that come alive in some part of the body associated with that emotion.

With that, I want to say that emotions, this category, this thing we call emotions—in English, we have a singular noun for emotions that covers a lot of different feelings that people have. It might give the impression that an emotion is a singular thing. But the emotions that we have are composites. They're actually the coming together of different parts of our psychophysical being to operate together. If we treat emotions as one big thing, it's hard to respect it fully, to really see what it really is, and to allow its time and place to unfold.

As a composite, emotions involve body sensations. If you're attentive enough, you'll discover that pretty much every emotion that we have has some kind of corollary sensations in the body where it gets expressed. Sometimes fear is felt in the belly or in the chest. Anger can be a flame in the belly; there might be contraction and tension. There might be strong desire, and we can feel the leaning forward and being ready to grab something. There might be sadness and a feeling of heavy weight and a sinking feeling. There might be grief and a tremendous sense of vulnerability, perhaps tenderness or vulnerability in some part of the body, like a vibrating chin when about to cry. All kinds of places these things live in the body. So that's one part of an emotion, the physical side of it.

There's also the story part of it. The ideas, what we tell ourselves around it. Sometimes the stories we're telling and repeating are the very things that are fueling the emotion. If someone has hurt us and we have resentment, and we keep repeating the story of how we've been mistreated and how terrible that person is, we're retelling ourselves a story that we're going to react to again and again. We're going to get re-angered, re-irritated over and over again. It's maybe appropriate enough sometimes to review and think about what happened, but to ruminate around it over and over again—do we really want to have to experience the impact, the second and third arrows, how debilitating it is to keep repeating a story that keeps us caught in a certain emotional state?

Grief is another one. Grief is part of human life and the events that bring on grief can be quite sad. But there's one way of grieving where we keep living in the stories and the ideas and the predictions of the future, reviewing everything, and feeling self-pity or feeling sorry for ourselves. We're weighed down by it. There's a way of respecting grief, allowing grief to be there, realizing it's a human phenomenon, but not adding second arrows, not having the stories and beliefs. Beliefs are another part; some of our beliefs actually are the trigger for the emotion.

There's also what we want, the motivational side. A good part of emotions have a motivational side, something that we're trying to do or want. With fear, we want to be safe. With anger, maybe we want to strike out. With grief, something wants to move through us and express the sadness we have, the tears that want to come. What wants to be motivated? What's the desire that's part of the emotion?

And then there's something that is more the mental mood that's associated with the emotion.

So these are all component parts that we can start feeling if we're not just looking at emotion as a singular thing. The emphasis for today is to, when you have an emotion, start becoming familiar with what it feels like from the point of view of the body. What happens in your body as you feel the emotion? Where does the emotion most live in your body? What's revitalized, what's energized in your body with the sensations? What happens to the muscles in the body as this emotion appears?

There are two primary reasons why it's very useful to check in with the feeling in the body. One is that the body sensations around emotions are not part of the story. They're always in the present moment. By grounding ourselves and connecting to the physical body part of the emotion, we're respecting the emotion, we're attending to it, but we're not reinforcing the rumination. We're not thinking over and over again and getting swept up in the story. Grounding ourselves in the body starts giving room for the emotion to unfold the way it needs to unfold. If we can get out of the way of emotional life and allow ourselves to feel it and make room for it, our emotional life generally knows what needs to unfold sometimes much better than we know ourselves.

The second advantage of mindfulness of the body when we have emotions is that there's something about feeling the emotion physically, in an embodied way, that allows the unfolding, the movement of the emotion, to move a little more freely. It's almost like by feeling it in the chest, the belly, the face, wherever it might be, we're making room for those sensations to move and to change. And as those have a chance to unfold, move, and change, that is synonymous with allowing the emotion to resolve, to dissolve, to do all kinds of things.

I'll talk more about emotions tomorrow, and how to practice with them and include them as part of meditation. But for now, I want to emphasize that for the next 24 hours, as you have emotions going through your day, you might want to drop back and make it really simple. Drop back into your body and see what's happening in your body as you're having those emotions. What do you learn by studying the physical, embodied side of the emotion? What happens if you give yourself the sacred pause, the respect to really feel it, make room to feel it in your body, and not just race along to the next thought or the next story or activity? What difference does it make to feel it in your body?

If you have some extra time in your daily life, after you've felt the experience in your body, you might do the three-breath journey. See if you just kind of acknowledge how it is, and then give yourself over to three breaths. After those three breaths, do that mindfulness exercise again of noticing how you're feeling. What shifted and changed in what's happening in the body? What shifted and changed with the emotions you have?

Hopefully, you'll continue to sit and do a 20-minute meditation between now and the next time we meet. Perhaps the center of gravity for your meditation can be breathing, but if some strong emotion arises that's more compelling than the breathing, then you can let go of the breathing and do mindfulness of the emotion. Maybe do it the way we've done it today: notice what it is, name it, acknowledge it, and feel it in your body. If it's no longer compelling, or you feel ready to go back to your breathing, then go back to your breathing.

If a body sensation becomes compelling, like we talked about yesterday, then you can again leave your breathing and do mindfulness of the body sensations until it's no longer compelling or you feel ready to go back to your breathing. So we're slowly expanding the range of things that are included in this sacred pause of mindfulness, and today we're venturing into the area of emotions. I'll talk more about it tomorrow.

Cultivating Goodwill

We'll end with another very short meditation. Once again, if you'd be willing to close your eyes. Part of the reason for closing the eyes is so that you can feel your insides a little bit better rather than being concerned with what you're looking at.

There is a particular way that in Buddhist meditation we work with emotions, a meditation that has to do with emotions related to goodwill, to being friendly or kind. You might sit here for just a minute or so and use some thoughts—you can use thoughts to tell yourself wishes of goodwill towards yourself. Think about how you would like to care for yourself, what you wish for yourself, and offer yourself some positive wishes.

Something like: May I be happy. May I be calm and peaceful. May I be safe. May I be happy.

If you can offer those good wishes to yourself from some place inside that you really mean it—that it would be nice if this could happen—then perhaps you can also receive it well, that it's nice that you care for yourself, especially if life is difficult.

Some people will begin every session of mindfulness meditation with 30 seconds or one minute of offering themselves these kinds of good feelings, good intentions, good wishes. Some people will end their sittings for 30 seconds or a minute with that.

Thank you for participating in this, and thank you for your interest and your engagement. I hope that you'll put this mindfulness into practice for the next day. Hopefully, if you practice a little bit what I've taught today, that'll be a foundation for the further discussion about mindfulness of emotions tomorrow. Thank you very much.



  1. Vipassanā: A Pali word often translated as "insight" or "clear-seeing." It refers to the Buddhist meditative practice of observing the true nature of reality. ↩︎

  2. Two Arrows: This teaching is from the Sallatha Sutta (SN 36.6), in which the Buddha describes physical pain as a first arrow and the subsequent mental or emotional reactivity as a second, self-inflicted arrow. ↩︎