Moon Pointing

To Care and Not To Care

Date:
2019-08-18
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-21 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
To Care and Not To Care

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

To Care and Not To Care

So good morning everyone and welcome to IMC. The talk that I would like to give today could be titled, "To Care and Not To Care." It's a little bit inspired by a line from T.S. Eliot's poem Ash Wednesday, which goes, "Teach me, teach me to care and not to care." It maybe plays on two subtle, different meanings of the word care. The first one meaning compassion, and the second one maybe meaning to be caught up in, or to be agitated by, or preoccupied with something.

Another way of saying this, reversing the two meanings of care, is: hold everything lightly, but let compassion motivate you. So these are two sides of practice—to treat everything lightly, but have compassion and act on compassion. To care and not to care.

The challenge for people who do Buddhist practice is, as we discover degrees of freedom, degrees of peacefulness, ease, and release from our attachments, how to live that in our lives. How to negotiate the authority that comes along behind being agitated: the authority and the importance of being upset, being angry, being dismayed, or being discouraged by things that we encounter in our lives. There are a lot of things that happen in the world that can be quite arousing and quite activating, stimulating a lot of strong emotions and overwhelm. How do we negotiate that with this idea of the freedom we discover or the peace we discover? Do we give precedence to one over the other? I think in Buddhist practice the idea is to give precedence to the capacity to live with a heart that's free, and not to give that up.

But often we do give it up, because sometimes these other things seem more important, or we give more value or authority to them. In the background of this talk is the idea of climate change. There are people who have tremendous, strong emotions around what they're learning or reading about what's happening on this globe with climate change. Some people feel overwhelmed. Some people feel despair. Some people feel anger and grief. There are a lot of different emotions that come along, and some of them might be quite appropriate; I don't want to say that they shouldn't be there. But the authority that they're given by people sometimes means that we give up our connection to some inner freedom. How do we negotiate this? How do we stay true to whatever degree of inner freedom we discover? How do we not sacrifice it in the face of all kinds of challenges that the world comes along with, not just global climate change? Negotiating that in a wise way is part of the task of Buddhist practice.

I wanted to tell you a little story that I learned from a friend of mine who was a hospice nurse. She said that in working with families of a dying patient, there would come a day where she would tell the family, "From now on, there are no more crises. From now on, there's no more reason to call 911, because the person is dying, and at a certain point that's really what is happening." I imagine that was quite helpful for family members to hear, because it's natural for family members to treat someone's dying with great alarm and concern. Sometimes they want to do everything they can to keep the family member alive. But at some point it doesn't make sense to do that. At some point it makes sense to accept that this is what's happening. Sometimes it's the hospice nurse or the doctor on call that lets the family know, "We've reached that point now." That allows the family to hold the person's hand or to offer a presence for the dying person that is very different. If everyone is running around as if their head is on fire, agitated, calling 911, and screaming for help, it doesn't create a very nice atmosphere for the person who is dying. Maybe there's a different atmosphere to create to support this person. I thought that was a pretty powerful thing. The family definitely cares about the dying patient, but, "Teach me to care and not to care at the same time." To care about the person, but not to care in such a way that we get agitated or caught up in it. In a certain kind of way, both caring, loving, and not getting agitated by the fact that they're dying.

I've known people who have come to their dying and had terminal illnesses, and they knew that's what they had, but they didn't accept it. They did everything they could to fight it. They got lots of medical care, which seems reasonable and appropriate many times. And then they come to a point where it's clear to them that this is what's happening. They don't need a hospice nurse to tell them; they know. I've watched remarkable transformations in people when they come to that point. They just relax and allow it. I've seen a very deep letting go that they weren't ready to do before. Sometimes they really have to be up against the fact of their dying in such a clear and obvious way, and they've tried what they could, and something gets released. "Okay, this is what's happening. I'm not going to fight it. I'm not going to argue with it." I've seen in that transformation people attain degrees of peace, well-being, and spiritual or heart healing that they had never experienced in their life until then.

I've known people who were chronically agitated and chronically anxious, and then they came to that moment where they accepted their dying, and their anxiety went away. One person was anxious for years that they were going to die from cancer. And when they finally got cancer, that anxiety went away at some point. That's what was happening. I've known people here in the sangha[1] who've gone to visit these people because it was kind of like darshan[2]. It was like a grace to be in their presence because of this deep equanimity and peace that they had.

The challenge of Buddhist practice is to attain this kind of peace, this very deep letting go and well-being that can happen at these end stages of life for some people. Why wait? Why not now? I think it's easier to accept the possibility now if it's not an either/or. It's not just about giving up. When people are finally dying, there's a kind of giving up: "I give up trying to save the person, and give up trying to save myself." But that's not what we're talking about in Buddhism. We're letting go for sure, but I hope it's not a giving up on caring about life.

It is a giving up of being attached to it. Why not give up our attachments to life while we're still alive? Some spiritual teachers will say that you can only live if you die. In Zen monasteries in Japan, I've heard that some teachers will yell while people are sitting in meditation—and I'm not going to try it here, so don't worry—but the teachers will yell and say, "Die!" It's clear they're not telling you to literally die. Absolutely not. They're talking metaphorically. Let the ego die. Let these attachments die. Let the attachment to life die. Then you can live. Something gets set free.

The Buddha said this in a very powerful way in a poem in the Dhammapada[3]. To paraphrase it: Those who are unaware are on the path of death. Those who are aware are on the path of life. Those who are unaware are as if already dead. This idea of possibility is that some people live as if they're dead; something is dead when we live with our attachments and get caught. A certain kind of life gets born when we can let go. Why do we insist and feel it's so important to stay attached, to hold the clinging that is behind many people's relationships with their grief, their sadness, their anger, their despair, and their discouragement?

I'm not saying that grief, sadness, despair, or discouragement necessarily always involve attachment. They might arise, but many of us will then get attached to them. We'll relate to them with importance, give them value, identify with them, hold on to them, and take them personally in some very deep way, so they become a big deal. What is it to not take things so personally? What is it to not get attached, and to allow things to move through us? One of the things it involves, I believe, is allowing some of the best qualities we have to move through us freely, and one of those is compassion.

Teach me to care and not to care. If I was going to summarize what motivates me to be a Buddhist teacher, in some ways it's that little expression. Or to say it the other way: hold everything lightly, but let compassion animate you. Let compassion motivate you to act. To have those two together is really what I want to do as a Buddhist teacher. I really want people to know what it is to be free. And I want people to act in the world for the betterment of everybody, to act with compassion and care, to be sensitive to the suffering of this world, and to live in such a way as to ameliorate that.

But to act that way should be a natural expression of who we are. It's almost like a movement that comes through us. It's not a burden. It's not an obligation. It's not something heavy. It is something that fully animates us and flows through us. Some people feel like it's not okay to do that because we only show that we care if we're agitated. We only show that we care if we're anxious or worried about people. We only show that we care if we're upset, if we get all rallied up around something. For some families, that's the vehicle by which love or mutuality is shown. In some communities, it's easier to show that you care if you get all upset; then obviously you've been touched. To see suffering in the world and not be upset—sometimes it's not obvious to people that you care unless you act in good ways to try to do something. We want people to know that we care, so we say, "Let's get upset together."

It's not always the case what I'm describing here. I've encountered suffering in the world, whether individually meeting people, in groups, or sometimes even reading the news, and started to cry. But that crying seems to come out of this freedom. I didn't get angry, I didn't get discouraged, I didn't feel despair. Where someone who saw me cry might have gotten agitated and asked, "What can I do for you?"—nothing was needed for me. It's just what happens. It is a beautiful thing, in a way, that we have this capacity.

In our tradition, there is a suggestion of a daily reflection, called the Five Reflections[4]. Everything has the nature to get old; I have the nature to get old. Everything has the nature of becoming sick; I have the nature of becoming sick. Everything has the nature of dying; I have the nature of dying. We are the heirs to our own karma[5] through our own actions. And what is the fifth one? Everything I care for and everyone I love must be separated from me. There's no way to escape that separation.

So you know that you will get old, that you will get sick, that you will die, and that you'll be separated from everything that you care for and love. Either those things and people will go before you, or you will. And how you live, the actions you live by, don't just end when the actions are done. They create a certain kind of karmic momentum in your hearts and minds, and you'll reap the results and consequences of that. To reflect on that every day can function as a reminder: why wait until you are dying to really let go? What is it that you can really let go of now? What interferes with your freedom and with your good heart? What interferes with your capacity for a very deep sense of well-being that can be here? So that when you close your eyes to meditate and you're with yourself inside, it can feel like you've come home to your temple, to your sacred place. Sensing and feeling this living life here is actually a place that's as comforting as coming home to your temple or sacred spot over and over again.

I feel a little bit worried by the tremendous emphasis we have right now on global warming and climate change in some circles. It certainly seems like it's one of the defining issues of our time, and very important to address. But the reason I feel it's maybe overemphasized is that, independent of climate change and global warming, we human beings are causing so much destruction to the natural world. All the other things we're doing to the environment are reason enough to be motivated to change how we live and not to cause so much damage. By focusing over and over again nowadays on climate change, it becomes a singular issue. Many people in the public discourse are losing touch with the fact that there are so many other forms of environmental destruction going on.

I was amazed by the news this week. Last year, there was news about these microplastic particles ending up in the ocean and the bay. The bay is full of micro and nano-particles of plastic. Now there are plastic fibers that are raining down from the sky. These fibers are so light that the wind blows them, and we breathe them and drink them. All these sea creatures are imbibing plastic. What are we doing with our plastic, independent of climate change? One of the issues around climate change is the degree to which people feel overwhelming grief, overwhelming anger, despair, and discouragement. Some people feel like they're almost ready to give up. "It's hopeless. We've passed a point of no return, and it's just going to be horrible from now on." Maybe it will be.

I'm going to read you part of a story from the time of the Buddha. King Pasenadi[6] comes to visit the Buddha, and the Buddha says to the king, "Where are you coming from, great king, in the middle of the day? What have you been up to?" And the king makes this amazing statement: "Just now, venerable sir, I have been engaged in those affairs of kingship typical of an anointed king." So, what are typical behaviors of anointed kings? "I have been engaged in those affairs of kingship typical of anointed kings who are intoxicated with the intoxication of sovereignty, who are obsessed by greed for sensual pleasures, who have attained stable control of their country, and who rule having conquered a great sphere of territory on earth." Is this what political leaders confess to? "I'm the intoxication of power and I'm obsessed by greed. Vote for me!" [Laughter]

It seems like a very honest statement. Maybe he's able to hold his greed lightly, so he can confess it in front of the Buddha. Anyway, it's quite a statement. The Buddha then replies, "Great King, what do you think? Suppose one of your messengers comes back from the east and reports that the eastern mountains are rolling toward you, and nothing's going to stop them. Then a messenger comes from the south and says, 'Great King, the mountains of the south are rolling towards you, and nothing's going to stop them.' The messenger from the west reports that the western mountains are rolling towards you, and nothing's going to stop them. And the messenger from the north says the mountains of the north are rolling towards you, and nothing's going to stop them. All the mountains are coming towards you, destroying everything in their path." Then the messengers say politely, because it's the kingdom, "Do what you think should be done, great king." The Buddha asks, "If such a great peril should arise, such a terrible destruction of human life, the human state being so difficult to obtain, what should be done?"

So what should be done? The end of our globe is coming. If not through global warming, it's going to come. I think the prediction is that when the sun finally exhausts itself, all life on Earth will disappear in just a few billion years. Sooner or later it'll happen. So what should be done? The king answers, "If such a great peril should arise, such a terrible destruction of human life, the human state being so difficult to obtain, what else should be done but to live by the dharma, to live righteously, and to do wholesome and meritorious deeds?"

If you had a terminal diagnosis, you would say, "This is really when my dharma practice is useful. This is what I'm going to rely on the most." This becomes the most important. Even on your deathbed, if you were conscious, you would call upon your dharma practice the best you could. You would practice mindfulness. You would practice letting go. You'd practice not giving in to the authority of greed, hate, and delusion. You would see the tremendous value of working with your fear and attachments, keeping practicing, opening up, and letting go. One of the consequences for me of doing this practice is that I am quite confident that if I'm conscious enough as I die, it's a really wonderful thing to do to allow that continual letting go deeper and deeper in the process of dying. In a certain way, I look forward to the process of dying, because if I can stay conscious enough, I imagine it will be the same process of going into deep meditation practice, which is some of the best things I know, to experience that freedom in letting go. Relying on your dharma practice during that time is really the thing to do.

The Buddha goes on in his story. He talks about these mountains that are coming, and the king says he should practice the dharma. Then the Buddha gets kind of prophetic. "I inform you, great king, I announce to you, great king, aging and death are rolling in on you. When aging and death are rolling in on you, what should be done?" And the king answers appropriately, "As aging and death are rolling in on me, venerable sir, what else should be done but to live by the dharma, to live righteously, and to do wholesome and meritorious deeds."

So there are mountains coming to you. You're not going to get away from them. Aging and death are rolling in on you from all directions. They're coming. Some people live as if it doesn't matter, as if it's not going to happen. But sooner or later, most people get the message. I can see in myself—I've known this for a long time in Buddhism where it's emphasized. Now that I'm in my 60s, I can sense inside that my thinking changes a little. There's a different orientation, and a thought that comes up now is, "Maybe this will be the last time I do this particular thing. Maybe I won't do this again." There are certain endeavors that I don't think about like I used to. Like learning languages when I was younger; now I think, "Maybe not." [Laughter] I'm not going to have much use for it once I learn it. [Laughter] So I can see these different new thoughts happening. Even though the idea of death has been a common theme in my life, it has new meaning as I get older.

To practice, why wait? Do the work. A powerful teaching that I learned from Suzuki Roshi[7] is, to paraphrase him: You should start your practice now when you can, because when you come into a crisis in your life and you try to start practicing then, you won't be prepared. You won't be ready. You won't have the skills, the mindsets, or the inner strength to meet it. So don't just wait until you're on your deathbed. Find out now. What is letting go? What is attachment? I know some people who come new to the practice and they don't have a clue what letting go means. It's a completely foreign idea. When they hear the teachings about being mindful of thinking, they have no idea what's being talked about. Prepare yourself.

If you prepare yourself now and learn how to care and not to care, learn to let go, and learn to practice well, I think you will increase your capacity to have compassion, care, and goodness. As you practice, you naturally let go of the obstacles to your capacity to care and have compassion. The obstacles are hate, greed, intoxication with power, and fear. Look at the defining issues of our times: hate, racism, how we treat immigrants, how we treat people on the other side of political divides, the economic oppression that the United States is a big part of causing, and climate change. What are the obstacles in you from really being part of the movement to address these issues for the betterment of all? Is there fear? Is there greed? Is there hatred? Is there annoyance that you have to be bothered by these things?

Using the dharma practice to look at our attachments naturally means you look at these obstacles and discover how to be free in relationship to them. Are you being limited by your overwhelm? From a Buddhist analysis, being overwhelmed with these issues has its genesis in some form of attachment you have—some way you're taking it too personally, attached to self or something else. There is no overwhelm if you've really cleaned yourself on the inside and emptied yourself of attachment. There's no reason for it. The mountains are coming anyway. If you're overwhelmed by the mountains, you won't practice.

Who knows what the world will need of us as it changes even further. Right now, it needs everyone to participate in making this a better world. It needs all of us to learn how to consume less and consume more wisely so we don't contribute to environmental destruction. We need to be involved in the political actions that produce the environmental destruction on this planet. We need to address the issues of racism and hatred in our society. How we each address these issues, I don't know. There are so many different ways of doing it as individuals. But our way, the way that works for us, makes a difference.

Teach me to care and not to care. Live lightly. Hold everything lightly. But let compassion animate you. Let compassion flow through you. Let compassion be the source of your actions in the world as we face climate change.

Even then, don't give up your freedom. Don't give up the practice. Don't give up the heart's capacity for being at peace. But don't do that and do nothing else. If you do, that itself is probably a form of attachment and a kind of violence we do to ourselves. If we really want to care for ourselves and honor the peace and freedom of non-attachment, we would give voice to the impulses to care, to have compassion, and to make a difference. That lives in us as well. But we would not be oppressed by those impulses. We would not be overwhelmed. We would not feel like we're not doing enough. We will never do enough, but we'll hold that lightly.

For me, my understanding of where I've come to through Buddhist practice is summarized simply: to care and not to care. Hold everything lightly, but let compassion animate and engage you. I hope this talk has challenged you to really look at yourself and reflect on how these ideas exist in you. How are you with these issues of our society and our world? How are you with the authority you give your emotions and your attachments? How do these live together? Is there some powerful way that you can give authority, value, and importance to non-clinging so that you are not overwhelmed, but you do act? That's the challenge that I hope this talk has given you. It's an important motivation for me as a teacher. Please think about this, talk to your friends about it, explore it, and do some deep soul-searching around these topics. I think the world needs it, and we all need it. Thank you.



  1. Sangha: The Buddhist community of monks, nuns, novices, and laity. In this context, the local meditation community. (Original transcript said 'Aranga', corrected to 'the sangha' based on context.) ↩︎

  2. Darshan: In Indian traditions, an opportunity to see and be in the presence of a holy person or deity, receiving a blessing from the sight. (Original transcript said 'daron', corrected to 'darshan' based on context.) ↩︎

  3. Dhammapada: A collection of sayings of the Buddha in verse form and one of the most widely read and best known Buddhist scriptures. Verse 21 translates roughly to "Mindfulness is the path to the deathless, inattention the path to death." (Original transcript said 'Dharmapata', corrected to 'Dhammapada' based on context.) ↩︎

  4. Five Reflections: Also known as the Upajjhatthana Sutta, these are five subjects for daily recollection by Buddhist practitioners regarding old age, sickness, death, separation, and karma. ↩︎

  5. Karma: A principle of cause and effect where the intent and actions of an individual influence their future. ↩︎

  6. King Pasenadi: The King of Kosala and a frequent interlocutor and follower of the Buddha. (Original transcript said 'King Hanity', corrected to 'King Pasenadi' based on context.) ↩︎

  7. Suzuki Roshi: Shunryu Suzuki Roshi, a Zen monk and teacher who helped popularize Zen Buddhism in the United States and founded the San Francisco Zen Center. (Original transcript said 'Suzuki Rushi', corrected to 'Suzuki Roshi' based on context.) ↩︎