Moon Pointing

Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (9 of 9)

Date:
2020-04-09
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-21 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (9 of 9)

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (9 of 9)

Good morning. I'm happy to be here with you in this way. A few weeks ago, I never could have guessed that speaking in an empty room to a camera like this was possible for me, or possible as a way of communication. I'm surprised by these chats and the different ways that I actually feel quite connected, not only to many of you but also to a sense of a wide network of community, people interested in the same thing, and a lot of goodness that exists around the world. So I want to thank you for the opportunity to share these instructions.

This is the last class for the introduction to mindfulness meditation. At the end of the session, I'll talk a little bit about what could be next and other things I might offer coming up that are related.

I think there are a few things I'd like to say as an introduction for today, which is a small review of what we've done so far. First, I want to repeat what I've said a few times: this principle that if it's not simple, it's not mindfulness. If you find yourself trying too hard to figure things out—"There's a technique, and do I do this now or that now? What do I have to investigate now to figure out what to be mindful of?"—it might be useful, but it might not be necessary for the purposes of mindfulness.

The idea of the simplicity of mindfulness is to learn to be aware of what is obvious. You don't have to have a label for it. You don't have to know exactly what it is. It is the capacity to be in the present moment with present-moment experience, with whatever is obvious. In different circumstances of life, we might have to investigate or look more carefully to figure out what's going on, but for the purpose of mindfulness meditation especially, a lot of what we're doing is settling, opening, or freeing our capacity to be aware.

If I hold something—like this striker for the bell that we have—I could hold it really tight. This striker could be very important. It can be a symbol of my status as a Buddhist teacher. I might feel I have to keep this close by so everyone knows who I am, or something silly like that. And so I hold on really tight to it. Because it's so important, I don't notice that I'm holding it tight. After a while, I don't even notice that it's hurting to hold it tight. I don't notice that my fingers and hands are going numb from holding it so tight because I'm so focused on the striker, the meaning of the striker, what it's going to do for me, and all these kinds of things.

If I now switch my attention from the striker and all its importance to what it's like for my hand to be gripping it, then I might notice that I'm gripping it more than I need to. Sometimes I need to hold the striker, but I don't need to grip it so tight. In fact, I could loosen the grip. I could relax it. It's possible to open up the palm in a relaxed way without losing it. It's possible to open the hand and hold it loosely. I still have it, and it's ready to be used, but how I'm holding it is very different.

In the same way, awareness—how we pay attention, how we're mindful—is as important as what we're mindful of. It's kind of like there are two sides to meditation practice: there's what we're aware of, and there's how we're aware. These two go together and support each other. They hold each other up. Sometimes we pay more attention to one, and sometimes we pay more attention to the other.

This idea of simple mindfulness means that how we're being mindful is also something we pay attention to. Are we straining? Are we pushing into something? Are we gritting our teeth and really trying to be mindful as a duty or as a good student? Or are we too lackadaisical? If I hold the striker and I'm not careful how I hold it, but I'm relaxed about it and relax the holding, the striker drops out of my hand. In the same way, if we hold our mindfulness too loosely and without much dedication and care, we lose it; the mind wanders off.

There is a way of being careful of how we're mindful. The care is to hold it in a way that we stay present, stay with the experience, and hold the experience well so it's seen and known. We neither lose it—the mind doesn't slip off the breath into daydreams—nor do we grab things or push them away.

Noticing how we are aware can be a hard thing to do, especially for someone who is beginning to meditate, but it's the second side of meditation: how the mind is relating to experience.

To say all this in a slightly different way, there are always two things going on. This is very simplistic, but it's useful to think of it this way: there's what's happening (which of course can be an infinite number of things), and there's how we're relating to what's happening. There is what's happening, and then there's how we push it away, grab it, try to avoid it, run away from it, or all the things we do to it. Or we might stand watching it and judging it: "This is a bad striker, it's dirty, and a real Dharma teacher has mahogany strikers, and poor Gil because he doesn't have the right striker." All these thoughts, commentary, ideas, judgments, reactions, and activities are distinct from the striker. The striker is just a striker, and my relationship to it is different.

Earlier, when I talked about mindfulness of emotions, the 'T' in the RAFT[1] simile was "teasing apart." It means to tease apart how I'm relating to something from the thing itself. To do this well doesn't require a lot of sophistication, knowledge, or even a lot of intelligence. It requires being quiet enough to be able to distinguish between an experience and the relationship we have to it. As the mind gets simpler and quieter, we relax, and the thinking mind relaxes. It's a natural thing to begin seeing these as two distinct things: the experience and how we know it; the experience and how we relate to it.

As we start feeling and recognizing how things are, it's important to stay simple and just see it. Don't add second arrows. Don't be upset about the fact that you're upset. Don't be afraid because you're afraid. Don't judge yourself because you're judging yourself. One of the little mantras that can represent mindfulness meditation would be something like, "Oh, so that's what's happening." Or, "Oh, so it's like this. Now it's like this." If I'm clinging to my striker, "Oh, it's like this now. There's clinging."

Don't be in a rush to relax it, but have really simple observation. "Oh, look at that. This is a human being clinging to a striker. That's interesting. Let me be aware of that for a little bit. Let me just know it." That movement of, "Let me just know it. Let me just be aware of it. Let me be curious about it," is a very different relationship than, "Oh, I've got to get rid of it. This is wrong. I hope no one notices that I'm clinging to it." All this extra stuff.

As mindfulness deepens, we begin to see more clearly, and making this distinction can be very helpful. So with that, let's do a meditation session.

Guided Meditation

Show meditation Hide meditation

If you could please take a meditative posture, whatever is appropriate for you. Generally, if it's possible, it's good to sit up a little bit straighter than you normally would. And then softly, kindly close your eyes.

Perhaps as we begin this meditation with the eyes closed, reflect that a mindfulness meditation session is meant to be a time of kindness or positive self-regard. It is doing something which is a good thing for oneself because we care and we value what we are and how we are. We're trying not to live with so much stress, upset, and distractibility.

With a little bit of that positive self-regard, begin by taking some long, slow, deep breaths. Do this in a gentle way, not deeper than is appropriate for you, but as a way of connecting to yourself to feel more of your body. Maybe these are the deepest breaths you've taken today. Really feel more of the body's process of breathing: the expansion of the rib cage, the lifting of the shoulders. Be aware more fully of that whole process of breathing out, the letting go, the smooth ending of it, or the fading of the exhale.

Then let your breathing return to normal.

You might search through your body to see if there are any obvious places where muscles are held tight and contracted. Don't relax right away, but take a few moments just to feel how that is. Sometimes the muscles will relax themselves when they're seen and recognized as being tight. That's kind of a nice process—to let the body take care of itself rather than us always being in charge.

If it's easy enough to relax, let go, and soften the body, especially the belly, and maybe around the eyes and the face.

Maybe your awareness can be global in some way. For a few moments, be globally aware of your body in whatever way is easy for you to do that. Within this global body, as part of it, maybe as the functional center of it, become aware of your body breathing. Allow the body's breathing to come into your awareness.

As you tune into your breathing, have a clear acknowledgement, intention, or recognition that this experience of breathing will be the home. It will be the center where you keep your attention and rest your attention. Not as an avoidance of other things, but by sitting at the center of all things, rooted and grounded here in the body.

Perhaps as you're exhaling, relax your thinking muscle. Relax any tension or pressure to think, any physical agitation or activation associated with thinking. As you exhale, let it become softer. Let the mind become broader, quieter.

As you exhale, let go of your thinking. Not by rejecting it, but by allowing it to float away, to fall away. Then let go into the experience of breathing.

If there's something occurring for you right now that makes it difficult to be with your breathing, let go of the breathing. Bring your mindful awareness to this other thing—in the body, in emotions, in thoughts, in the sounds around you—and recognize what that is.

There's something about the power of recognition, sometimes supported by a mental note recognizing what it is, that can create a little bit of freedom and peace in relationship to what is recognized. Sometimes the mental note needs to be done gently a few times so that the mind eventually gets the sense of it. "Oh, this is being recognized." The recognition is not the same thing as what is recognized. It's like we step away and look back: "Oh, that's what's happening."

Whether you're with your breathing or you're recognizing what takes you away from your breathing, notice how you're recognizing. Notice how you're aware. What attitudes come along with being aware? Is the awareness a simple recognition? Or does it come along with more complicated attitudes of being for or against, liking or not liking, having all kinds of evaluations, projections, and ideas about what's happening?

Is the awareness tight and forceful? Might it be too loose, too relaxed, so that you slip off too easily from what you're bringing attention to? Learn how to have the hand of awareness open so that whatever you're attending to is resting in the palm of awareness. Not falling off, not dropping away, and not being gripped.

In the simplicity of meditation, where very little needs to be done, accomplished, or thought about, a moment of mindfulness can be a moment where you allow each thing that occurs to be itself. We're simply aware of what is and have the generosity to allow it to be just as it is. What is happening can be what is happening, and then we know it with a clear, relaxed mind.

If the mind is not clear and relaxed, then it's useful to recognize how that mind is. That can be the subject of mindfulness.

If you're off noticing other things besides the breathing, you might now come back for the last few minutes and be with your breathing, being a companion to your body breathing.

To end the sitting, take a few deeper breaths again. Feel more connected to your body, perhaps waking up in a certain way with the deeper breaths. Then breathe normally again before you open your eyes.

Just recognize. Mindfulness is always about recognizing, being aware of how you are now compared to how you were before.

[Music]

Direct Experience

There are many perspectives to talk about in mindfulness meditation, and one of them is that what we're tuning into and aligning ourselves with is our direct experience. "Direct experience" is often a term that's used in our circles of meditation. What direct experience is pointing to is being aware with very little mental chatter, concepts, judgments, or stories. Some of the labels and concepts we put on top of things are extra.

Before, I used the analogy of the striker for the bell. It's possible to experience this object without putting the idea of a "striker" on top of it. In fact, I might use it as a doorstop, and then it becomes a doorstop, or just a piece of wood. Direct experience is just feeling the shape, seeing the color, and sensing the texture of it. I can have all those experiences without the concept of a striker. It's innocent enough to call this a bell striker, but it's also possible to experience it much more simply and directly.

In meditation, we're moving in the direction of that simplicity of direct experience, and it requires the mind to be a little bit quieter than usual. It's not racing and rushing from one story or idea to another, but it's quiet enough to start seeing what's happening moment by moment.

Part of the value of this direct experience—the value of getting quiet enough or still enough to be able to see the difference between what's happening and our relationship to what's happening—is that wisdom can arise. In Buddhism, the wisdom that is being pointed towards is not book knowledge or knowledge about things that we carry with us, remember, and apply. It's more like a discernment that we discover and see, or insight that we see moment to moment that's always fresh. This deep wisdom can arise as mindfulness deepens and as we start being with direct experience more directly.

I want to give you a little taste of how wisdom gets awakened or begins to occur. There are many forms of wisdom, discernment, and insight that are part of this practice as it deepens. Here is one that maybe you'll find interesting and useful.

I'm going to hold up a flower. It's a rose from the single rose bush that's outside of the Insight Meditation Center here in Redwood City. I imagine you can see it. There's a famous story in Buddhism where the Buddha holds up a flower. He doesn't say anything; all he does is smile. There's one person in the audience who somehow understands something very deeply and is enlightened by that, and the Buddha then acknowledges his enlightenment. Maybe that person was able to see a direct experience, and somehow the direct experience of the flower, the simplicity of it, released something in his mind.

Here we have a flower. Just a flower. Sometimes in Buddhism, we call it the suchness[2] of something. Without any concepts or ideas, it's just the experience of the flower in and of itself. So that's nice.

But now look what I can do. I hold up another flower. Now I can say something that I couldn't say before. I can say that this is the small flower, and this is the big flower. This wasn't a small or big flower before; it was just the suchness of the flower. It's still a flower, but the mind can say that there's a smaller flower and a bigger flower.

Now watch this magic trick that I'm going to do. Remember, the rose was the small flower, and this other one is the big flower. Now I hold up a third flower, and what was the big flower before has now become the small flower. You saw how the trick was done, and right before your eyes, this went from being the small flower to being the big flower.

What this points to is that we live in concepts. Sometimes we live in concepts of comparisons. That's a function of the mind, and they are accurate in and of themselves in a certain way, but a lot of human suffering arises in comparative thinking.

For example, people have comparisons about their physiology: they're too tall or too short, their hairline is too high or too low, their hair is too long or too short. All kinds of things about their body have to do with comparison to other people's bodies or the idea of an ideal body. These are all mental ideas and concepts, some of them inherited or taken in from society.

If we can see that we're doing that, we can put aside all these extra attitudes and concepts and just experience the suchness of our body. Just experience the body in and of itself without the comparisons. Unless there's physical pain or something similar, our body by itself often has no problems. The forehead is completely content to have a high forehead. The hair has no agitation around how much, how little, how long, or how short it might be.

It is a generosity to allow ourselves to be who we are. The generosity of relaxing and just letting the simplicity of the direct experience be itself. We can do that for ourselves, and we can do that for others as well. Allow our friends just to be their friends. Learn how to separate out the judgments, the ideas, and the attitudes we have as being distinct from what the direct experience is. Making that distinction allows wisdom to choose what we do and choose what is wise about the attitude: what is extra, what is maybe harmful, what we can put down, and what we keep up. It allows something just to exist in itself.

If you remember, we did this exercise on the day of mindfulness of the body: just feeling the hand by itself. In and of itself, the hand is just a hand. Some of us will look at our hand and feel like our hand is not quite right. Its fingers are too small or too long, the fingernails are this way or that way, there are too many wrinkles or warts. But from the inside out, the hand doesn't have those judgments and ideas. It's a more complicated mind that makes those associations and thoughts. We want to quiet that down, be able to see clearly what is the relationship versus what's happening, and begin to prioritize the direct experience.

As we prioritize the direct experience, we do a number of things. We're benefiting ourselves by just allowing ourselves to be who we are in a simple way. It begins dissolving the layers of armor and the layers of reactivity which many of us live in. We dissolve them, settle them, and take them off so we can just be simpler and simpler, just ourselves, and more at ease and calmer with who we are. We become so calm and at ease that, at some point, we realize how little we need to put on top of ourselves: all these representations of who we are, all these ideas of being a good or bad person, who we should or shouldn't be, how we want to be seen in the eyes of other people, or how we want to prove ourselves or apologize for who we are. We can just be there.

At some point, even a sense of self dissolves in the flow, in the richness of just direct experience. You don't lose yourself, of course, when there's no sense of self. If you look at a sunset, there's no attribution of self to the sunset. It's not, "That's me up there in the sunset." It's just the beauty of the sunset. In the same way, when some of these concepts of self dissolve, the beauty of who we are can stand there, sometimes even better than when we have all this extra stuff we put on top.

I hope that example conveyed some of the wisdom that's possible through this practice.

Developing Momentum in Practice

Wisdom comes a lot from mindfulness getting stronger, and part of the strength of mindfulness has to do with the strength of our concentration. Mindfulness and concentration are partners, and they support each other.

There are a number of ways to develop mindfulness further so that it has more momentum, more clarity, and the groove of mindfulness becomes second nature. One way is simply doing it in daily life. Meditating every day is very powerful. I've been doing meditation every day, mostly, for the last 45 years. If you can meditate at least six days a week, even just for 20, 30, or 40 minutes, it helps. When I first started my regular meditation practice, I did it twice a day for 40 minutes, but never on Sunday. I had learned meditation at a Zen center, and I never got a reason why, but on Sundays they did not meditate. So I thought that was the way to do it.

Other people find it's good to meditate every day, seven days a week. To have some momentum, I know one person who likes meditating five days a week. If the person misses a few days, they make it up so that by the end of the week, there have been five meditation sessions. There are all kinds of ways and tricks to get oneself to meditate regularly.

For those of you who enjoy these instructions, we now have an online morning meditation at 7:00 AM (California time), Monday through Friday. You're welcome to join me for that, have some continuity, and have a little bit of support from others to keep doing it.

Concentration also develops by occasionally going on a meditation retreat. This means giving yourself more time to meditate. It could be a three-hour retreat that you give yourself on a free day, where you do sitting meditation for a while and walking meditation for a while, going back and forth between the two. Going back and forth for 20 or 30 minutes each for a few hours in daily life begins to build up the momentum of concentration so that mindfulness becomes stronger.

It's also possible to go on longer meditation retreats. Our particular form of Buddhism puts a lot of value on residential retreats where you go for a few days. Generally, these retreats are conducted in silence. They're a contemplative time where teachers offer instructions and Dharma[3] talks, and you often meet with the teacher. The chance to do this all day long and be in an environment that really supports contemplative, mindful awareness is a wonderful thing, and it really lets this mindfulness and concentration build over time.

Finally, it's possible to develop the concentration to support mindfulness by focusing only on concentration for a while. One of the ways to do that is with the breathing, maybe counting the breaths one to ten. If the mind seems really restless and scattered, and you find that during meditation you're mostly daydreaming, it might be useful to spend a period of time—maybe even a few months—only doing a discipline of staying with the breath the best you can without strain. Do it without feeling bad about yourself, always happy to start over again, but keep coming back to the breath. Use the breath as a foundation for developing stability of attention in the present moment.

These are some of the ways of supporting the practice, continuing the practice, and developing the practice further. I hope that this introduction to mindfulness meditation has given you enough—but not too much—to support you, launch you, or keep you going in your practice. I would be very content and happy if you learned just enough that it inspired you to do the practice, find your own way with it, and that you found meditation useful in your life.

I want to take the last ten minutes to give you a chance to ask some questions.

Q&A

Question: How can mindfulness help control pain?

For me, that's a very touching question because someone wants to use mindfulness to address what can be very challenging in life. Some people live with a lot of chronic pain. I've known a lot of people who have had very intense chronic pain who did find mindfulness very helpful for it.

First, I want to be a little bit careful. Generally, I don't feel comfortable answering the question directly the way that it was asked because I don't want to use the idea of "controlling" pain. Some people ask, "Can I get rid of the pain?" Sometimes mindfulness is advertised as being effective for pain—that it'll make your pain go away or fix it. I feel very hesitant to imply that mindfulness can help the pain go away or control the pain. It can, so I don't want to rule it out, but to promise that is not really realistic.

However, what I can say that's almost as good is that what can radically change is not the pain, but how we relate to the pain. That has to do with what we talked about today: there is the experience, and there is how we relate to it. Some of the difficulty we have with pain is not the pain itself, but rather our relationship to it: the resistance, the pushing away, the fear, the contraction we have toward it.

I remember when I had a lot of knee pain. I noticed that if I had self-pity and felt sorry for myself, the pain would get worse. I think what was happening was the muscles around my knee were contracting when I was resisting it and feeling sorry for myself. When I relaxed those self-pity thoughts, those muscles around the knee relaxed as well, and it was less painful.

The relationship we have to pain is where we can loosen up. There are times when I have pretty bad migraines. I will go someplace where I can be quiet, meditate, or lie down, and I'll bring my attention right into what I think is the heart of the pain, and just let my attention rest there. If I put myself right in the middle of the pain rather than resisting it or being outside of it looking at it, and really feel it intimately and closely, it stops being pain in the usual way. Or it stops being a problem in the way that it had been before. That ability to hold it right at the center helps free me from some of the relating to it that I'm doing. It's just there in a very simple way.

How we relate to pain sometimes actually contributes to the pain. I once read a study where there were ten different factors that contributed to the intensity of pain, and it was the combination of the intensities of these ten things that added up to the pain. If some of those things were weaker, then the pain wouldn't occur. Sometimes it's our relationship, our resistance, our hate, or our fear that involves the pain.

We can control pain a little bit by controlling how we relate to it and finding some equanimity and peace with it, rather than always fighting it, feeling pity, or projecting into the future how difficult this is going to be. That might not make the pain go away, but it makes it a little bit more bearable. We can bring a lot of care and attention—maybe compassion and love—to ourselves and to the pain, and hold it softly and gently, and learn how to go closer and closer, letting it be more of a direct experience.

When mindfulness is strong, many people have the experience that the pain is intense, but at some point it stops being an intense pain and becomes something different. It dissolves in a certain way. It's still intense, but it's not really pain anymore. It's possible with enough concentration and mindfulness to actually have joy at the same time as having pain, or to have peace at the same time as having pain.

Question: I noticed that the imagery you use—"holding awareness with gentle hands"—speaks to me very clearly. Do you think about why imagery is helpful? And if so, can you please elaborate?

The Buddha used imagery to describe and instruct meditation. Part of the usefulness of imagery is that it becomes much more holistic and engages more of who we are: our visual side, our imagination side, and our kinesthetic or physical side. Holding a hand up as an image is something we have a physical, embodied relationship to. We can sense or feel that.

Rather than just saying, "Hold your pain in awareness"—which is nice instruction—saying, "Hold a pain in the soft palm of your hand" evokes many more associations within us. We have a lot of different attentional faculties that can be brought together. Imagery awakens more of who we are to engage in the mindfulness practice.

Imagery can be helpful provided it doesn't become fantasy and take us away from direct experience. Imagery can easily do that. It is useful to have a little bit of very simple, rudimentary imagery to help bring us into the practice, and then with time the imagery falls away.

Question: Please talk about the relationship between meditation practice and the study of Buddhism.

Ideally, the study of Buddhism would be in the service of supporting the meditation practice. When I was doing a lot of meditation practice living in a monastery, I studied Buddhism every day. I would read a Buddhist text, but I would only read maybe at most a page, sometimes just a couple of paragraphs. That was enough to be encouraged, inspired, and to have new perspectives to bring to my practice and explore.

Dip into a Dharma book or study Buddhism just enough to be given something to work with and explore new perspectives. Don't try to acquire a lot of knowledge at first, but use it to encourage your practice. Some people need to do a lot of study until they feel like they have a foundation to really be able to meditate, so different people need different things. But in general, study in a way that supports your meditation. If what you're studying in Buddhism seems too abstract and not connected to meditation, maybe find something different to study.

Question: I often use distraction for pain control. Meditation makes me more aware of my body. Should I find a balance?

I've known people who have very intense pain. I know one person who was paralyzed and learned to separate out his attention so he didn't feel his lower body. I never had that kind of experience, and I have a lot of respect for what he was able to do. Sometimes it is wise to avoid pain using distraction.

There is one meditation technique for pain, sometimes used when there's very intense pain, which is to find a place in the body that has pleasure. It could be just a small square centimeter of something that feels soft, comfortable, or pleasant. Then you really focus on that, develop concentration, and begin to spread that pleasure through the body. It is a concentration practice more than mindfulness, but that's a way of moving one's attention into something more helpful, allowing the mind to relax.

Sometimes the mind is overly tense if there's always pain. This practice allows the mind to relax, soften, and get a break, and then spread that pleasure throughout the body. Then there's a whole different relationship to the pain. I've known people where that pleasure gets spread into where the pain is, and the pain gets transformed. But to do that requires a lot of concentration. Sometimes when people are in intense pain, their motivation is so strong that the concentration can be there.

If you are using distraction all the time—like staying in fantasy—maybe it is a way of avoiding pain, but it's not really cultivating mindfulness and the capacity to meet life in a clear way. It depends on what you want to do. If what you want to do is cultivate mindfulness, you want to be careful you're not making too much of a habit of being distracted in fantasy or thoughts.

Question: I used to practice meditation a lot when younger. Now I notice my asthma makes me kind of tense about my breathing. How do I work with that instead of feeling like fleeing it?

I'll answer the question as you asked it, and also offer another perspective on it.

How do you work with the tension? The simplest way in mindfulness is to make your tension the object of meditation. You find out where in the body or mind that tension lives, and then you just be with the simplicity of that experience. Just hold the tension. Be with the tension.

There are times when I don't have asthma, but I've been busy and involved in a lot. I sit down to meditate and I notice that my chest is being held tight. There's some pressure or contraction there. When I sit and meditate, I will bring my attention to that feeling of contraction in my chest. I'm not trying to relax it. I'm not judging it. I don't feel like I'm a bad person because of it, or that I shouldn't admit that to an audience of meditation students. I just hold it in my awareness and breathe with it. Sometimes I've imagined that the rhythm of breathing in the chest is like a massage for that place of contraction, and then after a while it begins to loosen and relax. It's possible the tension that you're feeling with the asthma will relax if you just hold it in your awareness gently.

The other thing to do, though, is to find a different place in your body to be aware of the breathing. There are times when I've had a contracted breath where I brought my attention to my back rib cage and felt the more subtle movement of the back rib cage as I breathed. That took me away from the place where the breath was problematic. Then it kind of eased up, and the breath came in a more natural and easy way. Maybe feeling the breath in the belly rather than in the area of the lungs can make it easier for the asthma. Keeping a soft belly might allow you to breathe more deeply in a relaxed way.

The other perspective I wanted to share is that for some people—like those with asthma or certain traumas from when they were younger, such as a near-drowning experience—the breath has become a problem to connect to. Fear gets triggered when they bring their attention to it. It's completely fine to have other home bases for mindfulness meditation. It doesn't have to be the breathing.

One common alternative offered in our Buddhist tradition is to use sounds. Sounds are always in the present moment. Open your awareness and just hear the sounds that are going on around you. We tend not to interfere with the sounds; just allow them to arise and pass receptively in awareness. Some people find that very relaxing. Some people feel like their mind almost expands outward to become as large as the distance the sound is coming from. It makes for a very spacious sit. Then, if other things become predominant—like sensations in the body, emotions, or thoughts—one would let go of the sounds and come back to those things to be mindful of them.

Question: Can you comment about the difference between emotions and thoughts?

It's hard to know what emotions are exactly as a unified thing, but there's a huge overlap between emotions and thinking. Sometimes they're not really separate from each other. Sometimes we can see how thoughts trigger an emotion, and sometimes we see how an emotion influences or triggers certain thoughts. It's interesting to watch the play back and forth between thinking and emotions.

Generally, in the simplest way, thoughts occur without a lot of associations and involvement. A thought is almost effortless. It's soft, empty, transparent, and has no weight. It's like a cloud. It's not necessarily embodied.

Emotions always have some embodied component to them. There are sensations; something is activated in our body. With that is what we call feeling—something that seems more pleasant or more unpleasant, a feeling tone. I don't know if we can make a clear separation of these two worlds, but maybe all we're asking to do is create just enough separation to see the difference enough to be mindful of it.

Another difference is that emotions are always happening in the present moment. They can be triggered by thoughts of the past and the future, but the emotions are always present phenomena. Thoughts are also present phenomena, but they can be about the past and the future, and we can get lost in that past and future if we're too involved in our thoughts.

Question: When I turned away from breath, I realized I was feeling happiness, almost euphoria bubbles arising. I tried to back away, which was difficult. What is your advice for not clinging to an enjoyable emotion?

As meditation deepens, and some concentration and letting go happen, experiences of happiness, joy, and well-being can arise. Sometimes it can be a very subtle feeling of contentment and ease. Sometimes it can be quite strong—euphoria bubbles arising, or cascading waves of joy passing through a person. Sometimes it just has a life of its own.

Backing away from that euphoria can be difficult; it needs to take its time. If it's too much, you can just stop meditation and go for a walk or have some tea.

If this feeling of happiness is arising out of meditation, there's an innocent and appropriate way to be with it. This is part of a positive feedback loop that can occur in meditation. It's good, and you want to just allow it and appreciate it. The Buddha talked about taking that joy and happiness that bubble up in meditation and spreading it out through your body. You're allowed to enjoy it!

The problem is when you cling to it, expect it, push for it, or try to get the absolute last drop of joy out of the experience. The idea is to be very open-handed with it. See it as a gift. Receive the gift. Open to the gift, and let it support you to be more in the present moment. The well-being is a sign the meditation is going well.

If going back to the breathing seems a little beside the point or diminishes the happiness, then maybe just enter into the happiness. If that's the compelling thing happening, it's completely fine to do mindfulness of happiness. Just like when I had migraines and put myself right in the middle of the pain, when you feel happiness, put yourself right in the middle of the happiness and feel it.

As I kept saying, there's the experience and our relationship to it. Become skilled at noticing that your relationship is extra—that you don't have to cling, grasp, want, build up a self, or want to tell all your friends. Just stay with the simplicity of the happiness.

Question: How much do you meditate daily now?

These days, I meditate most days anywhere from 30 to 45 minutes. I feel very lucky that I have a job teaching meditation. Some days I'll meditate a lot because I'm teaching a retreat or something. Isn't that pretty cool to have a job that lets you meditate?


So, I think that's enough. I feel like I'm kind of talked out, and my mind isn't as agile.

I want to thank you all very much for being part of this. I would certainly be delighted to have you come back. If you ever come to Redwood City and we're no longer sheltering in place, I'd be very happy to see you here and say hello. Perhaps in a couple of weeks, on April 21st, we'll meet each other again this way. Thank you so much for your comments and your good mornings and thank yous. It's all been very meaningful for me, and I feel very nourished and delighted to have this connection with you all. Thank you.



  1. RAFT: An acronym used in mindfulness practice to help work with difficult emotions. It stands for Recognize, Allow, Feel, and Tease apart. ↩︎

  2. Suchness (Tathātā): A Buddhist term describing the true, ultimate nature of all things, just as they are, without conceptual labels or mental projections. ↩︎

  3. Dharma: A central concept in Buddhism representing the teachings of the Buddha, the truth of how things are, and the path to liberation. ↩︎