Moon Pointing

Practicing with Fear

Date:
2020-03-23
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-21 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Practicing with Fear

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Practicing with Fear

Good evening, everyone watching and listening to this Monday night talk at IMC. At the beginning of the year, I started a series of talks on the introduction to Buddhism. For the time being, those have been put aside because it feels more appropriate to address the situation that all of us find ourselves in: the pandemic, which is traveling around the world and disrupting so much of human life. So, for this evening, I would like to talk about fear.

It seems like a topical theme right now because there is a tremendous amount of anxiety and fear. For some people, how they are feeling can be described as dread. One person I know has described the life she is living now as anticipating, in slow motion, an invisible tsunami coming. How do we live with anxiety, with fear, with worry, with dread? This is a really good question for everyone, for all human beings. Fear is one of the core human emotions and motivations. To bring our practice of mindfulness to fear is one of the great tasks of mindfulness. It is not to see fear as a mistake or even as a problem, but to see it as something that is worthy of our respect, our care, our attention, and our mindfulness.

I think it is interesting that ancient Buddhist psychology divides much of our emotional and motivational life—what we do and how we live—into two categories: those aspects which are skillful[1] and those aspects which are unskillful. Some people translate it as wholesome or unwholesome. Sometimes I like to think of it as healthy and unhealthy, or helpful and unhelpful. In simple terms, this unskillful, unwholesome side is often considered to be the "bad" part. Things like hostility, hatred, lust, and greed are considered unskillful, not useful, and unhealthy for people.

What is interesting is that fear is never considered in this category. It is never considered to be somehow bad, unskillful, or unwholesome. I am not familiar with it being put on the wholesome side particularly, though there are some exceptions regarding the conscience that makes us ethical—the fear of causing harm[2]. But generally, things like anxiety, fear, and dread are not put into a class of emotions that Buddhist practice is supposed to uproot. The language of "uprooting," "letting go of it," or "overcoming it" is generally not used when talking about fear. One simple way of understanding this is that fear is multifaceted. There are appropriate, healthy fears to have, and there are ones that are debilitating and might limit our lives—sometimes a little bit, and sometimes a great amount.

This idea of not putting fear into a negative camp is very important. We need to understand that it is not bad that we are afraid. It is not morally wrong, and it does not make us a bad or wrong person. Being afraid simply comes with being a human being. The great majority of people have some fear and anxiety, and sooner or later, it will appear. What is it that makes people anxious? I have seen long lists of things that people are afraid of, and sometimes I think, in shorthand, it is just that life can be dangerous. Life can be frightening. Fear comes with the territory of being a human being. Sometimes it is intense, and sometimes it is mild.

The real problem with fear is not the fear itself, but rather what is associated with it—how we behave because of the fear. Some people's strategy when they feel afraid is to get angry, to blame, and to attack. Some people collapse when they are afraid, while others run away. One unhelpful way of relating to fear is the ostrich strategy: putting our heads in the sand and pretending there is nothing there. I have done that sometimes in my life, and it does not really work as a good strategy. What do we do with the fear? How do we behave because of it? It is the behavior that comes out of fear—the secondary emotions, judgments, ideas, and reactions—where we start having greater problems.

We do not have to be afraid of fear itself. Fear is not really a problem in and of itself; the reactivity and the way we live with it might be. I say this to emphasize that in mindfulness practice, the idea is to respect our fear and to get to know it. We learn how to live with the fear and let it accompany us, but not to limit us. We learn how to study our fear and learn its wisdom. Fear is sometimes a very good indication that something is dangerous, wrong, or problematic, and it is good to listen to that.

However, sometimes the sense of danger that comes from fear—the threat that we feel—is not real. Sometimes it is completely imaginary and has nothing to do with anything real. It may just be conditioning, a habit we carry with us where we imagine scenarios. I remember when I was a kid falling asleep, sometimes I had all kinds of imaginations of the dangers that were lurking all around. My mind was quite vivid. I remember when I was about ten or eleven, my parents went away for the evening, and I was supposed to go to bed by myself, but I wouldn't. I would peer out the window into the dark just to see what monster or looming thing was coming my way and what I had to be concerned about. It turned out there was nothing out there, but my fantasy life certainly painted a big picture of what was lurking outside.

Normalizing the Experience of Fear

In mindfulness practice, the idea is to respect our fear, study it, and get to know it. But that can be hard to do. Sometimes fear is a little bit like touching a hot electric wire; it is just too much to get close to it. One of the best ways to begin the study of fear is to start talking about it. Talk with friends, people you trust, or even strangers who look trustworthy. Begin to normalize the experience of fear that we carry with us by talking about it.

Nowadays, many people are sheltering in place and have a lot of time. They are home all the time, spending time on the phone or Zooming with friends and family members. If it is appropriate for the people you are with, you might start having conversations about fear. Maybe do not start with the deepest fears and most difficult things you have, but start with the very safe and general topic of fear. There are a number of questions you could ask each other.

You could talk very generally about your usual way of experiencing fear. How do you experience it in your body? How do you experience it with your beliefs? How receptive are you to fear, and how close do you let it get to you? What is your attitude toward the fear? Do you get angry? Do you get afraid of the fear? Do you have an attitude that this is wrong, or that you are somehow a mistake because you are afraid? Are you embarrassed because of it? What goes on? What is the experience of fear like for you?

It is interesting to talk about what you think the threat is. Fear usually arises because we feel threatened. You can talk a little bit about the various things you feel threatened by. Sometimes the threat is not obvious. For example, a number of people I have talked to say they are afraid of dying, but it turns out they are not afraid of actually dying and no longer being alive. What they are afraid of is the pain they might experience as they die, or the challenge and difficulty of that process. There is a big difference between being afraid of no longer existing versus going through a challenging phase of life during the process of dying.

Even more interesting than asking what the threat is, is asking the question: what inside of us is threatenable? What is it inside of us that is being threatened? In insight meditation[3], we try to avoid language like "I am afraid," because that general statement carries the assumption that who you are is fear. You are just equating yourself with fear. Instead, we tend to frame the experience by saying, "There is fear here," or "There is fear within me." In that way, fear is not the whole picture of who we are. You can get a little bit more distance and hold it more in context if you change the language of how you view it.

The same thing applies when we ask what is threatenable inside of us. If it is just generic fear and anxiety—"I am afraid and it is dangerous out there"—it feels like all of who I am is being threatened. But what specifically is being threatened? Is it your sense of security? Is it your comfort? Is it your life? Are you threatened because you feel the danger of fear itself? Is it your pride? Is it your survival? Is it a limitation on your freedom to go hang out with friends and do whatever you want? What is it particularly that is being threatened by the assumed or real threats out there?

These kinds of conversations can be broad. They can be far out on the edges of fear, just talking about it in the abstract to begin normalizing it. Another question you can ask is: what behaviors do you exhibit that come out of the fear? What are the secondary reactions, responses, or ways of being that emerge when you are afraid? Different people tend to have different patterns of behavior when they are afraid. What is your way? Having these conversations in comfortable, theoretical, or even intellectual ways helps to normalize the experience. It helps us become comfortable sharing our little fears and big fears with friends and people we trust.

This normalization can make it easier for us to show up and be present for our fear. It gives us pause before we get reactive, before we get caught up in it, and before we behave in ways that are not so useful. It helps us not be afraid of the fear or embarrassed that we are afraid. We can just say, "Oh, there it is. There is my old friend, my companion, fear. There it is again. Yep, there is fear. I am anxious." It becomes a little bit more normal, a little bit more ordinary, and not such a huge thing.

Meditating with Fear

When we do our mindfulness practice and sit in meditation, that is a wonderful place to begin touching into the fears that we carry. With this pandemic going around, it is a particularly useful time for mindfulness to touch in. It is helpful because it calms us down. It relaxes the ruminations, fantasies, and ideas we are spinning that talk us into being more and more anxious. Meditation calms things down, helps some of this fear dissipate, and makes us a little bit more stable.

There is also a deeper opportunity. The stronger the anxiety and dread about the pandemic, the more it often stirs up ancient fears. It stirs up whole other layers of things that make us afraid, bringing up how we have been afraid in the past. Fear from old experiences still lives within us and can be reawakened. It becomes not just a particular fear of the pandemic; our feelings can become the sum total of all the fears we have carried in our lives, pouring out because they were triggered by current events.

The opportunity of mindfulness is to begin to touch and address some of these things, and maybe even to heal some of the unresolved fears we carry. We begin finding a different relationship with fear—learning how to hold it with a lot of compassion and care, not being at war with it or critical of ourselves, but learning how to hold it gently.

One of the great tasks in mindfulness practice is bringing a kind of attention and presence to the fear that actually helps the fear feel safe. Many times, the way we react to fear is unhelpful. If I were my fear, living with how I used to react to it in the past, I would be even more afraid! The way I used to talk to myself was so uncomfortable. I would push the fear down, try to hide it, deny it, or get angry because it had been triggered. I would be angry at the fear, and I would be angry at myself. There were a whole slew of things I would do that would make the fear feel even more afraid. Mindfulness practice goes in the opposite direction. It goes toward the fear with kind regard, providing a safe attention and a safe presence for the fear.

Now, this is not an easy thing to do. There are times when that is quite hard. But sometimes it is possible to start way out on the edges, to imagine you are standing far, far away from the fear. I know one teacher who taught this by saying, "Imagine you are standing up on a hillside far in the distance. Can you look back at the fear now and feel like it is okay just to be there with it?" I remember one person replied, "No, no, that's still too close." And the teacher said, "Well, then it's not the hilltop over there. It's the mountain far, far across the central valley." And the person said, "Oh, then I can turn back and look at the fear." Take whatever distance you need to just let it be there and be aware of it. Instead of running away, closing down, or collapsing, simply hold it in awareness from a distance so that you do not have to be threatened by it, and you are not threatening it.

Over time, you can get closer and closer. The image that I like for being with fear is that mindfulness is like cupping your hands together to make a bowl, coming from underneath, and just holding the fear. Where do you hold the fear? Wherever you feel it most strongly in your body. Strong fear and anxiety usually manifest as tension, energy, tightness, pulling, or other sensations in the body. You come to it, feel it, and hold it. If it is too difficult to get close, you can imagine that your hands are holding soft cotton balls. You just gently tap the fear and then pull away. Get close, softly tap it, and pull away. You do this just to be close to it and to begin letting it know that you are there, that you care for it, and that you are allowing it to be there.

With a lot of patience and time, you begin getting closer, allowing yourself to truly feel the physical sensations of fear. One of the advantages of staying in the body with the sensations of fear is that the sensations are not the story. If we go into the story about what we are afraid of, it is all too easy for rumination to trigger and spin out even more fear. Part of the function of meditation is to quiet the stories just enough so that we can simply feel and be with the fear.

Doing this in meditation is particularly useful because, hopefully, when you sit to meditate, you are safe for that period of time. Nothing needs to be done. You do not have to fend off dangers while you are meditating. It is meant to be a time when it is safe to be with fear without having to solve it—to be with it and feel it without pushing it away. So acknowledge it, feel it, and hold it gently.

If you cannot hold it gently, a very important part of this study is to become aware of your relationship to the fear. In what ways do you relate to it? You might have aversion. You might have a fear of fear. You might want to escape and close down. Those reactions are the things that need our attention. I have worked with people who were so afraid they could not get close to the fear itself. I asked them, instead of connecting directly with the fear, to connect with the fear of the fear. They said, "Yes, I can do that." They held an awareness of the fear of the fear for a while, and eventually, that secondary fear would dissipate. Then I would ask them if they could feel the original fear, and they found it was much easier to get closer to it.

Finding Freedom and Tenderness

As the fear calms down, as we hold it gently and learn to let it be there without it being so disturbing, fear can become our companion. We can go through life with some fear and anxiety, but it does not limit us. We can still do what we need to do, while acknowledging that the fear is there. It is a tall order to learn how to do that, but that is one of the profound benefits that can come if you practice with fear and anxiety.

The idea that you are going to bring mindfulness to your fear is a powerful stance. It is a powerful form of strength and courage. It is a decision not to let business be as usual, not to let the old habits persist, and not to collapse into your habitual relationship with fear. It is a decision to be somewhat independent of the fear—to be, in a certain way, a little bit free of it. From that place of freedom, we can look at it with kind eyes. We can see that there is fear, but we are not afraid of it. We can see the fear there, but it does not have to take over our mind, our heart, or our stomach. It is simply there.

As we go deeper into the fear and learn how to be with it, we learn to live our lives without being limited by it. This is an opportune time to look even more deeply. We can ask deeper questions: What is it that is threatenable? What is being threatened inside by the danger we assume is there? It is possible that, even deeper than the fear, there is a place of tenderness or vulnerability. There is something soft inside of us that normally is not afraid, but is simply vulnerable. There might be a little movement of belief or attachment that is the actual source of the fear. If we can drop down, be quiet, be still, and not be agitated by the fear, we can feel our way into what underlies it.

It is fascinating what we can discover about ourselves. We might find parts of ourselves that are quite wonderful to be connected with. It is nice to learn how to support and carry that vulnerability, love, or care that may have been hurt or closed down in the past. We can learn to be wise and have the street smarts to walk in the world with love, care, and tenderness.

Conversely, some of what we find inside might be that we are attached to a particular idea of who we are. It feels so important that we be seen as a certain kind of person in the eyes of others. The reason we get threatened so easily and feel afraid is because we fear people will not like us, or that they will reject us or fail to see us in the way we want to be seen. Perhaps some of the identities we form and get attached to are not really useful to have. If those attachments lie beneath the layers of fear, mindfulness practice is meant to address them—to see them without shame or criticism, and to hold them with kindness. We can view them as a place inside that is frozen or iced over. We hold it in the warmth of our attention so it can thaw, relax, and reveal other parts of ourselves.

The Gift of Fearlessness

Fear is entirely worthy of our mindfulness practice. There is nothing inherently wrong with being afraid. Fear carries wisdom, and we can tap into that wisdom much more effectively if we are relaxed and calm about the fear itself. It is a valuable part of developing a spiritual life. When we investigate fear, get under its roots, and learn to be with it, we find something deeper. Sometimes, spiritual practice itself leads to a period where there is fear. It isn't a pandemic causing it; the spiritual growth itself can be frightening. Sooner or later, fear becomes a very important object of study that requires our care and attention.

For those of us—and I include myself in this—who have some anxiety and fear about this pandemic, the economic impact, the social impact, and the health impact it has on ourselves, our loved ones, and our friends, it is a great opportunity for mindfulness practice. It might actually be the most opportune time to meditate. Sitting with your fear might be one of the best things you can do right now to develop a completely different relationship with it. Whether it is through conversations with friends, quiet time spent journaling, or sitting in meditation to find a radically different way of holding it, fear is a wonderful thing to study.

Finally, it is said in Buddhism that one of the greatest gifts a person can give others is the gift of fearlessness[4]. I interpret that to mean two kinds of gifts. First, others do not have to be afraid of us. Second, it is the gift of letting people experience someone who is not operating from fear. To experience fearlessness, calm, and settledness[5] in another person is a profound gift. It helps other people relax. It helps them feel that they are safe and that they can get their bearings on what is going on.

I hope that this mindfulness practice can help all of us to become fearless in both ways. May we become people whom others do not have to be afraid of, and to the degree that we become fearless, may we become a refuge for others. In these difficult times, may we become a beacon of support, safety, and calm that helps everyone be a little wiser as we go through this pandemic. Thank you very much for being here this evening and listening. I look forward to our next opportunities together.



  1. Skillful and Unskillful: In Buddhist psychology (Pali: kusala and akusala), actions, thoughts, and emotions are categorized by whether they lead to well-being and liberation (skillful) or to harm and suffering (unskillful). ↩︎

  2. Fear of causing harm: In the Buddhist tradition, Ottappa (often translated as moral dread or healthy fear of wrongdoing) is considered a wholesome state that protects one from acting unethically out of concern for the negative consequences it brings to oneself and others. ↩︎

  3. Insight Meditation: Known as Vipassana in Pali, this is a traditional Buddhist meditation practice focused on developing a clear, experiential seeing of the true nature of reality. ↩︎

  4. The Gift of Fearlessness: In Buddhism, Abhaya-dana (the gift of fearlessness or safety) is considered one of the highest forms of generosity, alongside the giving of material goods and the giving of the Dharma. ↩︎

  5. Original transcript said "subtleness," corrected to "settledness" based on context. ↩︎