Compassion and the Passion for Practice
- Date:
- 2020-04-06
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-21 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Compassion and the Passion for Practice
I often feel grateful at the end of a sitting, and I often feel grateful for the people who I've meditated with. I want to express my thanks for this opportunity to be with you this way. For this evening, I would like to give a talk about the topic of compassion.
Certainly, we live in a time now where there is a lot of suffering. A lot of suffering is now shared by many people. It is shared either because the difficulties of our time affect people personally, or because there are so many people who care and are acting in response to try to make a difference or offer their support. It is quite a phenomenal event that the globe as a whole is sharing this degree of personal and collective challenge. There is this degree of suffering, this degree of concern for people who are dying, people who are in intensive care at the hospital, and people who are not sick but are having trouble finding enough food. They may have lost their work and now don't have enough money to take care of themselves and their families. The challenges that so many people have right now just go on and on.
How do we live with all these challenges? How do we live in the middle of this suffering, whether it is personal or shared with everyone else on this globe by our knowledge and understanding of it?
Buddhist practice begins with suffering. In a certain way, Buddhist practice starts and is concerned with suffering. A lot depends on how we relate to the suffering, how we respond to it, and how we live with it.
There are two basic movements that a human being can have when they encounter suffering in themselves or suffering in the world around them. One is a movement out into the world, and the other is a movement in toward one's inner world, toward oneself. Both of those movements, inward and outward, can be either healthy or unhealthy. Either one of those two movements can involve affliction, or it can involve the alleviation of affliction. They can involve causing more harm and suffering, or they can involve the end of suffering.
The Afflictive Movements
The afflictive movements—the ones that produce and perpetuate suffering in ourselves and in the world—happen when we meet our suffering with resistance. We meet it with despair, angst, contraction, or somehow we get caught in the grip of the discomfort, fear, distress, preoccupation, and the weight of it all. It is easy enough to do that; it's such a natural thing. There are so many challenges that people have, and things are so difficult.
When we are under the weight of our own suffering, it is possible to produce more suffering. Moving outward afflictively is to assign blame, to attack, to push away, or to create an "other"—people we are not going to have anything to do with, or people who are wrong. Moving inward afflictively is to pull in and to carry the burden of the suffering of the world on our shoulders, feeling overwhelmed by it, collapsing into it, or feeling pity. It is feeling caught up in the grip of our fear and anxiety of what is coming.
These are very natural human tendencies, so it is not exactly about condemning them, but recognizing that there is a way of being with suffering that just brings more suffering. Sometimes it spills over, and we cause harm to others. Sometimes it moves inward, and we cause harm to ourselves. It is natural enough to do these things because it is so confusing, and people feel helpless and threatened by all that is happening. So, these are the movements that can be afflictive.
Healthy Movement Outward: Compassion
Then there are the other movements, also going outward and inward, that do not produce more suffering. The healthy outward movement has to do with our care for the world: to feel the suffering in the world, to feel our own suffering, and to care for it. It is to step forward—rather than choosing fight or flight, we approach and soothe. We open up to find some appropriate way for us to step forward and care.
It is so important that the more suffering we experience in the world, and the more we suffer inside ourselves, the more we find some way to offer our care, our kindness, our support, and our generosity. Feeling helpless in the face of these kinds of challenges just makes it more difficult. Helplessness is often a condition that leads to some of the afflictive ways in which we relate to suffering. To be able to do something, to care in the smallest little ways—even if it is just with our good thoughts and our goodwill toward ourselves and to others—is essential.
One form that care takes is compassion. One definition of compassion, or karuṇā[1], is "the trembling of the heart of good people." It is the vibration, the trembling, the shaking of the heart, the empathy of the heart. These are the languages of good people. We are all capable of being good people. To be able to relax and rest in our goodness, to find that goodness and to care from there—to feel the trembling and the care for the world from there—allows us to suffuse the world. We can spread into our world with eyes of kindness, speech of kindness, and actions of kindness that show the world we care.
I mentioned earlier doing this at the "speed of love." I think this is a very important idea: that love is actually quite slow. Compared to the speed of light or the speed of sound, or the traffic on the freeway, love takes its time. Compassion takes its time so that there can be a calmness about it, a groundedness in it. It makes contact so you can clearly see what is there. You don't want to rush your love, because rushed love probably trips over itself. Take your time to find a way to gently open to it, feel it, and do it in a way that feels safe for you to offer compassion. That is one of the great movements outward.
This outward movement is also outward to yourself. From that light in your heart, you can bring love and compassion to yourself. It might be that you are the most important recipient of your compassion. There is a teaching that every individual is worthy of their own love and care. One of the reasons for this is that if the light of compassion doesn't go through a clear being (ourselves) when it goes out into the world, it often gets mucked up. It gets tripped up, dimmed a little bit, or even goes dark, even though we are trying to be compassionate.
We must somehow learn to care for ourselves, not necessarily so that our suffering goes away, but so there is space or ability for compassion to go through our own pain, challenges, or difficulties, and hold them with care and kindness. Instead of struggling with it so much, condemning it, or running away from it, we can have the capacity to open to it in a kind, supportive way. The pain might still be there, but that creates the capacity for love to go further and go out. Then, perhaps, our love and compassion for the world can be more useful.
When we are suffering ourselves, it can be useful because we can sometimes understand the suffering of others much better if it is similar to our own. Our own broken heart, pain, challenges, and struggles serve as a way for us to have more empathy and understanding. It ensures that our compassion and care won't be conceited, arrogant, or indifferent to others. In compassion, it is better to have humility than to step forward with confidence and bulldoze yourself into caring for everybody else. There is value in offering compassion and care to yourself so you can better offer it to others.
Healthy Movement Inward: Saṃvega
The inward movement that is healthy—and how we can suffer in a way that helps us become free of suffering—is to experience suffering in ourselves or in the world, and then to have an emotion or motivation called saṃvega[2]. There are different definitions of this concept, but I interpret it as the strong motivation to practice. It is the motivation to engage in mindfulness, to engage in the practice of concentration, loving-kindness, and compassion. It is entering into a path of practice to free ourselves from suffering.
Saṃvega is discovering for ourselves how not to carry the burden of our stress, distress, grief, fear, resentment, anger, greed, or disappointment. These are all things that can happen in this life to everyone, but we learn how not to be burdened by them, caught in them, or pushed down by them. We learn how to move in the opposite direction, how to become liberated, how to lessen and dissolve the suffering, and how to find the other side of that suffering.
This is one of the great, noble tasks of a lifetime. It is a dignified task of tremendous value to truly have saṃvega—to be motivated and say, "Yes, I want to find the path out of suffering. I want to practice. Now is the time to practice."
There are certainly times when we can do both: we can have compassion for the world and a strong motivation to practice. One way these work together is that some people, because they have compassion and really want to make a difference in the world, realize, "I have to do the work first. If I don't know how to come to the end of suffering, if I don't know how to be wise and how to compost suffering into freedom, how can I ever offer that to other people? How can I even support that in other people, or recognize that it's a possibility for them?"
One of the greatest gifts to give, and one of the greatest possibilities, is to discover a heart, an inner life, and a mind that does not suffer. A mind that knows how to be at peace, that no matter what happens around us, does not contract, get resistant, or feel closed down by the weight of it all. Instead, it is able to stay open, transparent, and porous; it is able to feel clearly and deeply what goes on in the world, but not suffer more because of it. We do this so that we can better serve the world.
This is how karuṇā and saṃvega can work together. It also depends on our circumstances; there are times when one seems more important than the other. If you are in the medical field right now, maybe this is a time where your compassion for the world is really needed so you can go to work and support so many people. If you are sheltered at home and have a lot of time, maybe this is the time for saṃvega. This is the time to practice more, meditate more, study the Dharma more, and study the Dharma of your heart. It is the time to understand what is going on here and be motivated.
It is important not to just watch more Netflix, be distracted, and read endless news, feeling the trouble and the weight of it. Rather, say, "This is important: the noble path of freedom from suffering. I've been waiting for a long time to have enough time to meditate. After work, I always had things left to do, but now I'm not working, I'm home a lot, and I have extra time." Maybe this is the time to have saṃvega. It is a sense of spiritual urgency. This is the time to practice.
The Two Noble Movements
These two are healthy movements in our encounter with suffering. One is to meet it with compassion and act appropriately in whatever way works for you. The other is to meet it with our desire, our aspiration, and our strong intention to find the end of suffering—not just for ourselves, but also for others.
I think one of the greatest things a person can do in their life is to do this practice in a deep way. Get to the bottom of suffering, the bottom of our conceit and arrogance, the bottom of our attachments, and discover the experience where the sense of 'I' dissolves and disappears. Experience the possibility of a liberated, peaceful heart—a heart that is finally at home in itself, at ease and safe, and then carries that safety out into a world where things are not so safe. Imagine that.
These are two noble movements. To use Buddhist language, there are also two ignoble movements. The ignoble movement of anger, hostility, attacking, pushing away, and closing down causes more suffering. The ignoble way of collapsing, blaming, contracting, and getting wrapped up in fear, distress, self-criticism, condemnation, or self-pity is very painful. It is not healthy to do that. It is very easy to do, and it is not easy to pull out of it. It needs a lot of care, a lot of compassion, and a lot of self-valuing to not believe the negative voices that say you are somehow wrong, bad, inadequate, or incapable.
Everyone is capable. Everyone is capable of beginning to take the noble path of compassion and the noble path of liberation. But remember this theme of the speed of love and the speed of practice: speed is maybe also quite slow. Don't feel like you have to do it too fast or make big strides. Your way may be slow, but slow and steady, the tortoise wins the race. That's what I've seen in my practice and in life. It is not about dramatic leaps into some great resolution of suffering; I've seen slow, steady growth. The movement is sometimes imperceptible day by day, week by week, but the ongoing dedication and saṃvega to practice is important. We are all capable of that, though we have to find what way works for us in our life.
Finally, I want to say that bringing together karuṇā and saṃvega—compassion for suffering alongside the passion for practice, the strong zeal, motivation, and desire for freedom and liberation—and having them work together to support each other is probably the noblest of the noble ways. This is the path of the Buddha. This is the path of the people who are most wise. Bring these two together and practice for the welfare and benefit of yourself, absolutely, and practice for the welfare and benefit of all beings everywhere, including all the ones you encounter along the way.
Thank you so much for participating and for listening. I hope you will give some consideration to these two movements of inward and outward. We are all going to suffer in all this; how do we suffer so that it leads to the end of suffering, not to more suffering? May you come to the end of suffering. Until that day when your suffering ends, may it be lessened. May you know that there are many people in this world who care about you, care about your welfare, and want to support you as you find your way.
Thank you very much.
Announcements
One announcement: some of you come here on Mondays. Next Monday I am teaching a retreat, so I won't be here Monday night to give this talk, but I will be back here in two weeks. Be well. During this retreat that I am teaching, I will continue with the early morning 7:00 a.m. (here in California) teaching, which is 30 minutes of sitting and a 15-minute talk. If you want to continue coming this way next week when the retreat starts on Saturday, I will still continue that morning teaching. May you be well, and thank you.