Samādhi (2 of 5) Connecting, and Sustaining Awareness
- Date:
- 2020-04-07
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-21 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Samādhi (2 of 5) Connecting, and Sustaining Awareness
So again, good morning. Today I'll continue on the theme of samādhi[1], the fourth of the five faculties. I have a lot of reverence for samādhi. Somehow this samādhi represents a wonderful state of being, of wholeness, of subtleness, of well-being that somehow makes me feel whole in this world, or settled, or peaceful—beyond or wider than anything I could think. That's samādhi. At the very best, it's kind of like entering into sacred ground. So maybe it's a little dangerous to treat samādhi in such a lofty way, but I do have that kind of feeling for it.
Yesterday I talked about two aspects of concentration (samādhi). There are preparations for developing concentration, and it's also part and parcel of concentration. Thinking of it as a preparation, to initiate the process of concentration is to relax, let go, and let go into being centered—to find a center within you. And that is to compose yourself on that center, to be settled. This is an alternative way of talking about being focused. Many times, concentration is associated with focus, bringing a focus of the mind on the breathing, for example, or whatever you're concentrating on, and that's fine. But it tends to lend itself to kind of being in the control tower of the head, and with the mind's eye looking in like a laser beam.
In the Buddha's teaching, samādhi is initially a fully embodied state. Our whole body is suffused with the qualities of concentration; it's not only a mental act. So to talk about composing ourselves, to me, is a physical language. To compose our whole body, we settle our body, we align our body and settle. In that aligning and settling, we begin the process of concentration.
It works particularly well, I think, if we compose ourselves on the breathing, or compose ourselves on some center of gravity within. It is a kind of reorienting ourselves from how we usually are thinking, doing, or being in the world, to something that for some people is maybe counterintuitive or even foreign: the idea that we would be settled and composed with our body here and now, and not thinking about things, wanting things, and avoiding things with our mind.
With a kind of relaxing, letting go, and centering ourselves on the breathing, we have that initial beginning. Then there are two movements of concentration practice that are the initiating and engaging part of practice, which can go hand-in-hand with mindfulness practice; it doesn't have to be separate.
In the ancient language, it's called vitakka[2] and vicāra[3][4]. The way my brain plays with words and sounds, vitakka to me sounds like a knock: tuk-tuk, knock-knock. It's an initial showing up and connecting. "Knock-knock, come here, open the door," or "Here I am, letting you know that I'm here."
And vicāra, the sound of it to me—I'd like to kind of stretch the 'a'—is more like lingering, or staying, or coursing, or surfing on something. There's continuity there.
Sometimes vitakka is called the initial application of mind, or of attention. It's bringing the attention to the focus. So if we're focusing on the breathing—if that's the center of gravity for meditation—and the mind wanders off and goes someplace else, the very act of bringing the mind back and reconnecting to the breathing is knocking on the breath: "Here I am." That initial connection is just a momentary thing. It does involve a little bit of rudimentary thinking. In fact, the word vitakka in Pali can also mean thinking. If you notice your mind is wandering off, there is some kind of cognitive working in the mind: "Okay, let's come back. Let's reconnect to the breathing."
How we have those thoughts and how we come back to the breathing is actually very important. Today, it's maybe more important than actually returning to the breath, because we want to make the return be something that's welcome, enjoyable, and calming in and of itself. I know that sometimes I've jerked my mind back quite violently. I felt bad—"Oh, there I am again, drifting off"—and jerked it back, and that's more agitating. I've also sometimes pounced back on the breath, kind of located it, and thought, "Now I'm really going to bore into it," and that also is actually more agitating than calming. So how can we come back in a calm way and reconnect to the experience of breathing?
It's maybe a little bit instructive that, as far as I know, in the ancient language of the Buddha's teachings, there is no equivalent idea to what we use in English of "coming back" to your breathing, or "returning" to your breathing. It is a metaphor to bring the mind back. The mind doesn't go anywhere; the mind is always here. The metaphor of bringing it back maybe lends itself to a certain kind of agitation, moving the mind, or feeling that movement.
Maybe vitakka is noticing that we're drifting off, having this thought of "where is the breathing?", and then allowing the breathing to knock on you: "Here I am, knock-knock." So there's no movement. It's more of a relaxing, opening, and making that initial connection. That's a conscious, somewhat intentional movement: "Okay, back here I am."
Then, once we're there—some people are very good at this coming back or connecting to the breathing, or to the focus of meditation. But once they're there, they kind of don't apply themselves so much anymore, and so then the mind wanders off again.
The second aspect of concentration is vicāra, which is sustaining the attention on the breathing, or on the object of attention—lingering, hanging out there. The analogy that's used in one of the ancient texts is vitakka is placing a cloth on a bronze bowl, and vicāra is rubbing it, cleaning, and polishing it. Or maybe an even more poetic image that's used is a bee landing on a flower—that's vitakka—and vicāra is the bee walking around picking up the pollen, exploring and wandering around on the flower. The word vicāra comes from cara, to walk or to wander. So it's the idea that we're wandering, we're staying with, we're feeling. Some translators and meditation teachers translate vicāra as "evaluating"—kind of being there and discovering the experience, getting to know it better, feeling it, and letting it register more fully.
So, vitakka is connecting to the breath, or allowing the breathing to connect to you and your awareness. And then vicāra is sustaining that attention over time, lingering there, resting in that, letting go into the whole experience of the exhale. So you're really there, vicāra-ing, cruising on, resting in, polishing, being polished by the exhale. The whole length of the exhale stays in awareness. And then the same for the inhale: connect to the inhale, the whole inhale. This vitakka and vicāra are relevant to some degree at the beginning of each breath. For each inhale and each exhale, there's a connection, and then there's a resting, sustaining in it.
Now, this idea of connecting and then sustaining through time—sustaining will always come to an end. So there's always going to be a time to do it again and again. Sometimes the sustaining can be a long time, really long, and your mind's not going to wander off. But more often, especially near the beginning, it wanders off quickly, and the sustaining doesn't have much momentum.
The analogy I like for vitakka and vicāra is a push scooter. You have one foot on the top of the scooter, and the other foot is pushing the ground and pushing you along. If you give yourself a good push, then the momentum will carry you for a while, and you don't have to push for a while. But eventually, unless you're going down a steep hill, the momentum fades away and disappears, and then you have to push again, and then you glide along. When I was a kid on a scooter, I never complained about having to push again to get the momentum going.
So sometimes, as we start developing concentration in practice, there are these two movements. A little push—that vitakka, a little tap—and then gliding along, allowing ourselves to be carried along as we go. And then, when we need to make that connection again, a little push again: "Here we go," push again, and then ride it, ride it, ride it.
As the practice deepens, these two intentions—it's intentional to connect, or allow the breath to connect to us; it's intentional to linger and ride it, or let the whole experience wash over us—as you do that and you settle into the practice more and more, at some point this need for vitakka and vicāra, connecting and sustaining, falls away. We're just really right there, just cruising along, and no intentionality, no thoughts are needed to keep going that way.
Finally, what I'd like to say is, with these two things that I've been talking about today—the initial connection and the sustaining of the connection of awareness—if you want to experiment with it, see if you can find a way to do it that's calm, relaxed, and spacious, without expectation or demand that it be any kind of way. See if you can actually make it kind of fun, or nice, or enjoyable, so you actually like doing it. You want to come and do it; it doesn't feel like work, just like for a kid pushing a scooter is not work.
So thank you very much for being here. I'll continue the theme of samādhi tomorrow and take it to the next level, maybe. I've said it many times now, but I feel very appreciative and have a lot of gratitude for being able to do this together with all of you. So thank you.
Samādhi: A Pali word often translated as "concentration," "composure," or a unified state of mind. ↩︎
Vitakka: A Pali term denoting the initial application of mind or attention; directing the mind toward an object. ↩︎
Vicāra: A Pali term referring to the sustaining of attention; keeping the mind engaged with, or exploring, the object of meditation. ↩︎
Transcript Correction: The original auto-generated transcript contained various phonetic misspellings for Pali terms (e.g., "be taka", "potaka", "vichara", "Chara"). These have been corrected to vitakka and vicāra throughout the text based on context. ↩︎