Moon Pointing

Mindfulness of Breathing

Date:
2020-01-26
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-21 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Mindfulness of Breathing

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Mindfulness of Breathing

I would like to talk this morning about mindfulness of breathing. It is one of my favorite topics, and it also is a very practical topic. In a sense, it's a continuation of the few talks I've given this year so far, especially the last two talks on the Eightfold Path[1]. The one part of the Eightfold Path that I went through in one sentence or so was mindfulness—it was right mindfulness. I think I said something like, "Mindfulness is a practice that brings us into the present moment with clear awareness of what's happening," or something like that.

One of the means that Buddhism has taught since the time of the Buddha for having relatively high-quality attention to the present moment, settled, focused attention in the present moment, is through the practice of mindfulness of breathing. It's possible that it's the Buddhist meditation practice that has been a common thread through the history of Buddhist practices down to the modern world. I think every Buddhist school that I practiced in, there was some reference or some centrality to mindfulness of breathing.

I started practicing mindfulness of breathing when I was first introduced to Zen when I was 20 or 21 years old. I've been practicing attention to my breathing ever since. It's been one of the great, rewarding practices of my life, and it still continues to unfold and develop. I appreciate it immensely, and I feel like it's been a wonderful companion for me through this life. It provides stability, provides a means for understanding, provides a means for insight, for concentration. All kinds of wonderful things come from my attention to breathing.

It's certainly been true that spending time with breathing is how we become familiar with it. Spending a lot of time with it, getting to know really well the ins and outs of breathing, is one way to become enriched by the possibilities of mindfulness of breathing. I had no clue when I first started meditating that the breathing could be so valuable.

I had a little hint of it, perhaps, before I really started meditating. I lived alone for one week taking care of a small dairy farm. In that week of solitude, I discovered that my chest could breathe in a very relaxed way, in a way that I'd never known before—breathing freely and lightly. As I continued living that rural lifestyle, outdoors a lot, working in the fields, there was something about that lifestyle that continually freed up my flow of breathing. I got the feeling sometimes that my breathing was breathing itself in a way that I had never identified, felt, or experienced earlier in my life. There was a sense of freedom in the breathing, a sense of ease, and a sense of delight that my body was just breathing. So I had some hint from that.

Then, when I started doing my Zen practice and spending a lot of time with the breathing, the experience of the value of it became clearer and clearer. And then when I was introduced to Vipassana[2] practice, that mindfulness of breathing practice continued, and it has continued right down to today.

This mindfulness of breathing is the only practice that I know of that the Buddha claimed he did himself. He offered a variety of different meditation practices he taught to people, but the one he kind of specified—like when he went off on retreat by himself—he said, "I am practicing mindfulness of breathing." Apparently, it was quite central to him. He formulated, or we think he formulated, a set of sixteen practices, or a sequence of sixteen practices—I call them steps—having to do with mindfulness of breathing, where the breathing is the continuity through these sixteen steps, experiencing the inhale and exhale in a different way.

Continuity and the Stick in the Stream

Part of the value of bringing attention to the breathing is that the breathing offers two seemingly contradictory benefits: it offers continuity, and it offers discontinuity. The continuity is kind of like if you're walking on a wilderness path. If the path is clear, there's continuity of the path as you walk. But as you walk on the path, there's discontinuity in your steps. One step has to end before the next step begins. The stepping is continuous, it goes on and on and on, but each step comes and goes. In the same way, the breathing is kind of like the path, or like the steps that we take. They're continuous in that they just keep going and going.

What provides that continuity is a wonderful check and balance for not getting lost in thought. A distracted mind and a preoccupied mind, wandering off in thought, is one of the big interferences to our ability to be really present in a clear way, to be settled, relaxed, and here in the present moment. A big part of meditation is coming to terms with this, training the mind, or relaxing the mind enough so that it doesn't wander off. A big part of that is noticing when the mind wanders off and coming back. If you have this dedication to the continuity of breathing, since it's always there, it acts as a reference point to catch the fact that you've wandered off.

If you just sit down to be present in some open kind of way, you might not notice as much that your mind has wandered away and you're not present. But if you have the regularity and the commitment to just being with the breath, you'll start seeing your mind wandering off. An analogy I like for this I thought up when I was sitting by these creeks in the Santa Cruz Mountains. I was sitting at the edge of a creek with beautiful, very clear, shallow water—probably three or four inches deep. The slope of the creek was very small, so I couldn't tell that the water was flowing. It looked like it was completely still because there were no ripples, no current, nothing.

Then I took a little stick and stuck it into the water in a vertical way. Lo and behold, a little wake was formed. Ripples got formed on the edges of the stick that showed there was a current. In the same way, mindfulness of breathing can be that stick that we put in the flow of our life. We start seeing things that we wouldn't have seen if we didn't have that reference point. We start seeing how much the mind wanders off. We start seeing how much emotions are operating and influencing us. We start seeing some of the desires and aversions that are operating, some of the tensions that are building up.

Because of my strong habit now of being aware of my breathing, it brings me back into my body. One of the things I notice because of that is when I get tense. I might be having a conversation or doing some kind of task, and I'm so busy with it that I don't notice anything else. But then if I come back and feel my breathing, I say, "Oh, look, my shoulders are tense. My belly is tight." So I discover something about myself. Mindfulness of breathing is a teacher; it is a way of learning about oneself. Coming back, coming back.

The Meeting Place of Our Life

Breathing is kind of the nexus; it's the meeting place of maybe our whole life. It's remarkable how much breathing is affected by our mind and our heart, our thoughts, and the activities we do. The agitation, the busyness, the involvement of our emotional life and our thinking life affects the breathing. As we get more agitated, the breathing gets more agitated, bigger, or stronger. As the mind gets calmer, you can feel how the breathing becomes calmer and more settled.

The same thing happens with physical activity. If you do vigorous physical activity, the breathing gets pretty labored and strong. That's quite nice to do if you exercise or play a sport, but you need a lot more oxygen in order to keep your energy going and be active. How you are physically affects the tempo, the depth, and the fullness of your breathing. And it works in reverse order as well. If you calm down the body, sit, and be still, the breathing calms down and gets quieter.

The breathing has a reciprocal relationship with these other areas of our life. If we calm our breathing down, it calms the mind and the heart; it settles it. If we calm the breathing down, sometimes the physical body begins to relax as well. We can expend a tremendous amount of energy in the body by being tense. You could be sitting completely still in a chair and use a lot of energy because of all the tension coursing through your system. But if you allow the breathing to relax—breathing deeply with a full exhale, fully tuning into your breath and regulating it a little bit—sometimes that begins to settle the body as well.

I like to think of the breathing as the meeting place of all these different parts of our life. Breathing changes because of the emotions we have, where we breathe, and how we breathe. We might breathe more shallowly, or we might breathe more in the belly, and more in the chest. All kinds of things shift and change in how we breathe because of what we're feeling and what we're doing. To begin bringing attention to the breathing gives us a vantage point to address, to touch, to change, to have an effect, and to understand so many different aspects of our life. It's really a fantastic vehicle for self-understanding and self-transformation.

Breathing Freely and Quietly

In the sixteen-step instruction for mindfulness of breathing that the Buddha gives, he talks about breathing in and breathing out. The word that he uses for the inhale is a word that normally would just mean "breathing in" in the ancient language of Pali[3]. But when it's used together with the word for exhale, it means inhale. The word is assasati[4], and that's the verb to breathe. That's the first dictionary definition. The second entry in the dictionary for the word is "to breathe in a free or quiet way," or "to breathe freely or quietly." So it's not just any old breathing, but to breathe freely and quietly.

It also means to feel relieved, to be comforted, and to have courage. Somehow, for the ancient people, this word for breathing had these other associations. We do that a little bit in English too, right? We might say something was a "breath of fresh air" by association. Or we have the expression, "I want some breathing room," or, "I finally have some breathing room." For the ancients, to have courage, to be relieved, and to be comforted was associated with breathing.

To cultivate and develop in an experiential way this feeling where the breathing is breathing freely, quietly, where there's a feeling of being relieved, comforted, assured, and a feeling of having courage—these are very important qualities. That the breathing should help us have that is fantastic. As the path of meditation deepens, there are times where having some form of comfort from the practice helps us go through the uncomfortable parts of spiritual growth. Having some capacity for courage helps us go through the fear-producing sides of spiritual growth. If you're on a spiritual path that is never uncomfortable and never involves some fear, you're probably not on a spiritual path.

If you think it's all about just dropping in and being in bliss, and that it's all good, then you haven't really studied your mind or your heart. It's a big deal to meet oneself and see one's attachments, fears, and the conditioning we have. It really helps to go through it if we've cultivated comfort and ease inside, and have discovered how to breathe in an easy, relaxed way where the breathing feels like it breathes itself. It gives us inspiration, courage, and the capacity to go through things which are difficult. It's like two things can exist together: a breathing which is easy and relaxed, and a difficult situation that we're in, and then we're not caught by the situation.

Finding Success in Coming Back

One of the wonderful things about mindfulness of breathing is that if the breathing is held, we're probably caught by something. If the breathing has gotten too shallow and we're hardly breathing at all, you've probably gotten caught in your mind. You're completely attached to something. Any of you who've gone to yoga classes know that one of the most frequent prompts is, "Remember to breathe." The first few times I heard that, I thought, "What do you mean, remember to breathe? Of course I'm breathing!" But there was a lot of holding because of trying too hard or facing challenges. We do that in small ways. Learning to notice even the small ways the breath is held, and then learning to relax and soften it, is something we do over and over again in meditation.

To do this ten thousand times in meditation, it becomes a habit. It becomes something we're so familiar with—like second nature—to check in and feel what's going on. If you feel the breath being held, that's the information you needed to know that you should relax. If you do that, you're going to be a little bit less caught up in the situation. You might just know, "Okay, let me relax. Let me breathe in a relaxed way, relax my belly, and just breathe." Then the build-up of tension and stress doesn't continue.

When mindfulness of breathing is first practiced, the practice is just to get to know your breath. Just come back and be with your breath, feel your breath, establish yourself in your breathing. It doesn't matter how often your mind wanders off from the breathing; it only matters that you come back. I say that because people often have the idea that to be successful at something, you have to be successful at doing it. At mindfulness of breathing, all you have to do is be successful at coming back, not staying there.

It's almost like you're giving yourself a massage, massaging your thinking mind and relaxing it. When it goes away from the present moment and you bring it back, every time you bring it back you're doing the massage. You're lessening the strength of energy that goes into preoccupation and rumination. It might be insignificant how much you weaken that force by doing it once, ten times, or a hundred times. But maybe a thousand times begins making a difference. Maybe ten thousand times makes a difference.

Some of you are probably thinking, "Gil, that's ridiculous, ten thousand times. Why would I ever do that?" Well, we sat for 35 minutes here today, and I wonder how many times you brought yourself back during that. Once a minute? That's 35 times. What does that mean in 30 days? You'll get your thousand times coming back. Get a Fitbit[5] that tells you how many times; program it! [Laughter] It begins changing and changing.

In addition to weakening the forces of the mind this way, we're also developing understanding. We're developing a capacity to understand what takes us away, how to connect to the breath in a nice way, and how to enter the breathing experientially so it's pleasant, enjoyable, and a place we like to be. We're getting to know the breathing. Where does it feel good when you breathe? What part of the breathing feels nice? What do you have to relax in your torso so the breathing feels more natural and pleasant to be with? What we're looking for is coming to an experience of breathing that you enjoy being with.

Gathering at the Hearth

For people who are beginners, that's not what's happening right away. It might take a long time to cultivate a breathing that's really a nice, pleasant place to attend to. The breathing can feel like cardboard, it can feel mechanical, dull, boring, or uninteresting. But if we allow ourselves to settle and let go, things begin to relax. One of the things that relaxes are the very strong forces inside of us that tell us we shouldn't relax and that we have to be busy.

The idea that the breathing is boring could be very strong. If we're living with discomfort, we feel, "I have to do something about my discomfort. I have to entertain myself. I have to fix something. I have to be busy." The paradox is that the impulse to fix, be successful, acquire something, or entertain oneself is in itself uncomfortable. One of the responses to discomfort that some people have is to do something, to get something, to want something.

You see the loop we get stuck in? If we start feeling uncomfortable, the strategy is to get something or do something in order to settle that discomfort. But the very act of looking and trying to get something is itself uncomfortable. I've experienced it in a funny way. Sometimes if I get too busy cleaning my house, going around in a hurry trying to do a lot of it, when it comes time to stop, my mind is still searching for something to clean. "I gotta do something, I gotta do something," because that's the mindset.

Sometimes when mindfulness of breathing is boring or we feel like there are more important things to do, it's a simple symptom of a very force in the mind that the whole meditation is trying to settle. If you give in to the boredom, you don't allow yourself to relax, settle, and discover what's much deeper.

As the mind relaxes, as we meditate, as the breathing relaxes, and as the body relaxes, we find ourselves in a very interesting place. The space of relaxation and awareness creates room in which our life can begin gathering together. It's kind of like family and friends gathering around the hearth of the house. Your thoughts, your emotions, your impulses, your psycho-physical life—all the different aspects of it—will come in and gather at the hearth, gather by the fire.

Everything that's active in our life, the centrifugal forces of fragmentation where things are spinning out away from each other, stops being fed. If there's space and relaxation, we're no longer feeding those fragmenting forces. Everything wants to flow downhill. All the different activities in our mind, heart, and body want to come to some kind of wonderful rest. As we settle, get relaxed, and make space just to be with things, that space allows things to settle together. They gather together at the bottom of the bowl instead of spinning out on the sides.

This wonderful experience of things becoming unified, gathered together, and settled is one of the great pleasures of meditation. Feeling whole, having some sense of integrity, and no longer feeling fragmented—all the different parts of who we are gathering together into a whole—is a wonderful feeling.

Observing and Letting Go

But that is only a stepping stone for going further in meditation. We develop a pleasant breath, the ability to stay with the breath, and this gathering together. The breath becomes a comfort, a guide, and a support, and then it becomes easier and easier to stay in the present moment. At that point, we're capable of something that Buddhism places tremendous importance on. It's core to mindfulness, but it's actually difficult to do if the mind is not settled.

If we're settled and connected here in a nice way, we can simply observe our experience. We observe what's happening and have the ability to settle back and not interfere with it, not judge it, not be in conflict with it, and not be reactive to it. We have an equanimous[6], open, peaceful mind just observing what's here. Some people will complain, "Just to observe is not enough. I have to do something." Observing is doing something, because the mind is affected by what it does. You can't watch your inner life with a simple, non-reactive awareness without changing it.

As we just observe and no longer interfere, we start witnessing a natural process that Buddhism calls the spiritual process towards liberation. It's a beautiful thing, feeling and experiencing that there's wisdom and a liberating force inside of us—a natural process that wants to happen if we get out of the way. Settling back and really watching without interfering is often considered in the teachings of the Buddha a very high practice, a highly developed art. It's what the Buddha called practicing in accordance with the Dharma[7], or practicing in harmony with the truth.

For the Buddha, this practice of mindfulness of breathing, the sixteen steps, is building and building and building until it gets to the stage—the last four of these sixteen steps—where the person has the ability to settle back and just observe. The whole process to get there is a beautiful, wonderful process. To finally be able to just sit still, where the mind has no tendency to wander off, is stabilizing. The mind is stabilized and present, and the breathing continues. The breathing keeps us grounded, acting like a massage or the rhythm of being present with all things just as they are.

Then we watch this process towards liberation, which is a process of release, of deep letting go. At the very core of our being, something can let go and release itself. To have our heart release itself is one of the greatest things your heart can have. To find a place where the heart releases itself and the mind releases itself is one of the results of mindfulness of breathing.

Conclusion

So that was a pep talk for mindfulness of breathing! Occasionally, there are some people for whom mindfulness of breathing doesn't work. They've had some trauma in their life around breathing, and so it's not a useful practice for them. There are other things to teach, other ways of practicing mindfulness, so don't worry about that. But for many people, it's a wonderful practice.

It's wonderful to check into your breathing throughout the day. Standing in a supermarket, waiting for a light to turn green, or waiting for the bus to come—just breathe. Check in. Ensure you're home. There's a fair chance that spending a few moments or minutes with your breathing in those kinds of circumstances, when you have little gaps in the day, is probably a better thing to do with your time than the alternative. I don't know what alternatives you're doing sitting there in traffic, but breathing is pretty good! [Laughter]

I believe all of you have been breathing for a long time. [Laughter] We're having a potluck in about ten minutes or so. It's nice on these potluck days for people to introduce themselves to each other. If you don't mind taking a couple of minutes to turn towards maybe one or two people near you and say hello to them. Notice if someone around you doesn't have a partner, just to be more inclusive. And if you want to have a little bit more conversation, maybe share one thing that you know about your attention to your breathing that's been nice for you in your lifetime. One nice thing about breathing to share with your friends. Thank you.



  1. Eightfold Path: The Buddha's principal teaching on the path to liberation, consisting of Right View, Right Resolve, Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood, Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, and Right Concentration. ↩︎

  2. Vipassana: A Pali word typically translated as "insight." It refers to a type of meditation that aims to develop deep insight into the true nature of reality. (Original transcript said 'be passed in the', corrected to 'Vipassana' based on context.) ↩︎

  3. Pali: The ancient language in which the early Buddhist scriptures of the Theravada tradition were recorded. ↩︎

  4. Assasati: A Pali verb generally translated as "to breathe in." As Gil notes, it also carries connotations of breathing freely, feeling relieved, and having courage. (Original transcript said 'a Sasaki', corrected to 'assasati' based on context.) ↩︎

  5. Fitbit: A brand of fitness and activity trackers. (Original transcript said 'get a pit bed', corrected to 'get a Fitbit' based on context.) ↩︎

  6. Equanimous: Exhibiting equanimity; maintaining mental calmness and evenness of temper, especially in difficult situations. (Original transcript said 'economist', corrected to 'equanimous' based on context.) ↩︎

  7. Dharma: A key concept in Buddhism referring to the teachings of the Buddha and the underlying truth or universal law of nature. ↩︎