Moon Pointing

Touching the Earth

Date:
2019-06-09
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-20 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Touching the Earth

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Touching the Earth

What I have in mind to talk about today, I have this idea that it would be nice if you followed it with your imagination. Meaning, some of the things that I talk about, if you don't just listen to it in terms of ideas or doctrines or things to just understand on a cognitive level, but maybe you can have a reference point in your imagination. Maybe you can visualize some of the things being talked about or find a reference point in your own experience for them. I think it'll probably be more interesting that way. I don't know if I can talk in a way that will evoke that, but that's my wish.

Partly because what I want to talk about, I think, is deeper than our cognitive ideas. I want to start with a kind of overarching quote from the Buddha that we will come back to near the end. It's a quote that I find personally meaningful, and that is, the Buddha said once, when he summarized what he taught: "I teach suffering and the end of suffering." I teach about suffering and how to bring suffering to an end. I think that's a very significant statement about the core principle of what he was about. In some ways, it doesn't have to be very complicated. It doesn't require a lot of doctrine or a lot of metaphysical or cosmic ideas. It's a very simple, ordinary human phenomenon of suffering and then coming to an end of it. So that's in the background as I give this talk.

Some weeks ago, I gave a talk where I evoked the image of the Buddha we have here in our statue of the Buddha touching the earth. I'd like to do that again. It's a very powerful image, and it's evocative or suggestive. It's symbolic, so it can be applied, interpreted, or experienced in many different ways. It has been used down through the ages as a reference point for teachings.

Sometimes there are very florid, dramatic Buddhist texts that describe the circumstance of the Buddha touching the earth. It was supposedly the night of his enlightenment, and there was a semi-deity named Mara[1], whose seemingly job description was to prevent people from getting enlightened. When Mara got a sense that the Buddha was on the brink of enlightenment, Mara came along with all his forces, all his armies, attendants, daughters, and everything, in order to throw everything he had at the Buddha to prevent him from being enlightened.

There are these dramatic stories of legions of soldiers—it's kind of like Lord of the Rings—legions coming and attacking the Buddha with spears and arrows. The Buddha just sits there peacefully under the Bodhi tree. The arrows, spears, and discus being thrown at him all turn into flowers and fall around on the ground around him. Then Mara sends all the possible forces of temptation that a person could ever struggle with. He offers the Buddha every temptation you can imagine, and nothing moves the Buddha; he sits there peacefully.

But then Mara comes with his secret weapon, the one that truly is going to challenge the Buddha. He gets the Buddha to finally flinch. Mara says, "You have no right to be enlightened." For many people, doubt is often a huge hindrance: "Who am I? Am I up to it? Can I do it? Do I deserve it? Do I have a right to it?"

The reason I think the Buddha engaged with that point is that he no longer relied on his own ability to hope, stay calm, be non-reactive, and just not buy into it again. Rather, what he did was lean forward and touch the earth. The idea of touching the earth was that he was calling upon the earth, the earth goddess, to be his witness for his right to be awakened. At that point, the earth shook, and the earthquake frightened Mara and all the soldiers and temptations away. The Buddha was left alone to then proceed to his enlightenment.

This idea of touching the earth, touching nature, and receiving protection and support from it, is an image which I find very powerful. At the end, the Buddha couldn't do it by himself. He didn't just see it as, "I can do it, I can manage everything," but he had to call on something larger than himself. Maybe it was still himself, but certainly larger than his small self. He called upon nature, or the earth, for support, to be a witness, to be seen, to be recognized for what he could do. Reaching and opening oneself up to the wider world, to the natural world as part of who we are, as part of what can maybe awaken us or open the doors for awakening, is a profound metaphor. Rather than being closed and caught in ourselves—"it's all me, myself, and mine"—we open up and become attentive, aware, and connected to the natural world.

I might have talked about this recently, but there are a few big scholars now who are beginning to criticize the secular mindfulness movement—which Buddhist mindfulness overlaps with—for being excessively individualistic and reinforcing the individualistic values of our culture. This idea of going outside of yourself and calling upon something larger than yourself for connection to the natural world somehow has a role in this movement towards real inner freedom.

So the Buddha touched the earth, and he touched it with a very soft, gentle, peaceful kind of reach. In statues and pictures, you can usually see him reaching his hand forward with open hands, gently touching the earth. He's not wanting to hurt the earth; he touches it gently. It would be very different if the statues had him making a fist and reaching down to punch the earth. I don't think that would be as powerful for us. Perhaps if we come with what the fist represents, the earth would not have protected the Buddha and wouldn't offer its support for us.

We know that we can live in ways that are in harmony with the natural world. Our whole life depends on being supported by the natural world, so we can live in harmony and continue with that support, or we could also destroy it. The history of humankind for thousands of years has been filled with events where civilizations were destroyed from overutilizing the resources of their local area. I grew up in part near the Dalmatian coast of Yugoslavia (what is now Croatia). Those islands were beautiful but barren rocks. They used to be forested and full of soil, but they were over-farmed, mostly for grapes apparently. We continue to do this today, this overuse, and we destroy the very thing that is supporting us. So how do we touch it? How do we connect to it?

The word for mindfulness in Pali is sati[2], and one of the meanings that the Buddha gave to sati is to remember things that existed long ago. It's not only about being in the present moment here and now. When it's our turn to touch the earth, to reach forward and call on our planet, our globe, our natural world around us, what do we reach forward and touch? One of the values of Buddhism is to both remember the past and to touch what is here, specifically right here and now.

All of you right now have in common that you're right here in these two rooms. But where are you? What do you touch when you touch the earth here? "Where are we?" is an interesting question. If we simply say we're at the corner of Birch and Hopkins, that's okay, but there are other ways of touching and knowing where we are at. We are sitting on top of 400 feet of alluvial mud plains. Underneath us is 400 feet of clay that's been deposited for the last four to eight million years—soil coming down from the coastal mountains. As this trough that makes up the Bay Area has been steadily sinking for these millions of years, it gets filled in with all this clay and beautiful, rich soil.

There grew wonderful oak trees. I don't know if you've noticed the big, beautiful Valley Oaks around here. Just close by in the hills are beautiful Black Oaks and Coast Live Oaks. There used to be plains of ancient oaks growing here, among which grizzly bears, elk, deer, rabbits, and all kinds of animals roamed.

Then about five to ten thousand years ago, people came down from further north, the Canadian and Alaska areas. The indigenous people started to settle here, and we know that in this area people have been settled for about 5,000 years. One of the very touching remnants of that is San Bruno Mountain. At least contemporary Native Americans from this area consider it a sacred mountain. One of the biggest villages that existed in the Bay Area was at the foot of San Bruno Mountain, next to 5,000-year-old shell mounds that were sacred. One of the biggest shell mounds left in the Bay Area was squeezed between Highway 101 and the steep slope going up San Bruno Mountain. You have this wonderful juxtaposition of 5,000-year-old shell mounds and a modern, tall building right there as you drive north on the freeway.

So people have been living here for a long time. There wasn't a very big population; people think that between San Mateo and San Francisco, there were about 14,000 Native Americans. They lived in apparently 11 or 12 different tribes. Today they are collectively called the Ohlone[3], but within the Ohlone, there were different tribes. It seems that where we are here, the tribes were the Puichon and Lamchin people, and this wider area was known as Yelamu land.

They lived here peacefully. At some point, Sir Francis Drake came and named this area New Albion. Then around the 1750s, the Spanish came, named it Alta California, and built missions up and down the coast. The Native Americans were forced into the missions, where many died from measles and other illnesses brought by Europeans, ending up in poverty. They had a language known as Ramaytush. This history is part of the earth we are touching. The last person fluent in Ramaytush was a woman named Isabel Meadows, who died in 1939 in Washington, D.C., where she was helping the Smithsonian Institution learn about her people, her language, and her stories.

In 1792, after the Spanish had built their missions, the British explorer George Vancouver came to San Francisco on his ship, HMS Discovery. He went horseback riding from San Francisco down to San Jose as a guest of the local Spanish governor. This is probably the first English-language account of what became Redwood City. People think that the creek he talks about in this passage is Cordilleras Creek, which is the border between Redwood City and San Carlos. You wouldn't know it was there anymore unless you go up into the hills.

He wrote this when he was about 34 years old: "At noon we arrived at a very pleasant and enchanting lawn, situated amidst a grove of trees at the foot of a small hill, by which flowed a very fine stream of excellent water. We had not proceeded far from this delightful spot when we entered a country little expected in these regions. For about twenty miles it could only be compared to a park, which had originally been closely planted with true English oak. The undergrowth had been cleared away and had left the stately lords of the forest in complete possession of the soil."

So the first account of Redwood City was that it was like an English park with huge, stately oak trees spotting the area. Probably the Native Americans burned the land regularly to keep the undergrowth low. He made this trip in mid-November, so the first rains had happened, things were starting to get green, and it was a wonderful time to see it.

We are on top of alluvial soil deposited over millions of years, in a place that used to have no buildings, no freeways, and no roads. Around 1795, the Spanish governor of California was given 35,000 acres of land between San Mateo and Palo Alto to be his property, called Rancho de las Pulgas. In the 1820s, when California became part of Mexico, the title passed to his family. In 1848, when California became part of the United States, a rumor spread that the owners no longer held the title because it was Mexican. So people started squatting on the land.

By this time, a woman named Doña Argüello owned it. If you go down to the train station, you can see a bust of her. She hired a man named Simon Mezes in 1854 to contest the squatters. Mezes won the lawsuit, and as payment, he was given what is now Redwood City east of El Camino. He originally named it Mezesville, and there is still a small park three blocks from here called Mezes Park. He turned around and sold parts of the property to the squatters and others for a profit.

The land was later divided into smaller properties. A large section from Whipple Avenue all the way south to Woodside, and from El Camino into the mountains, was owned by Moses Hopkins, brother of Mark Hopkins, one of the four railroad tycoons who built the Transcontinental Railroad. They ran cattle here. Then, around 1906, two Japanese brothers started growing chrysanthemums, and by the 1920s, Redwood City was the chrysanthemum capital of the world.

Does this long story have anything to do with freedom, liberation, and touching the earth? As the area developed and grew, it became a working-class area. In 2001, we came here to be in this building, which was built in the early 1950s by a semi-mystical Christian church called the First Christian Assembly. They sold it to Unity, then bought it back, mostly holding it waiting for someone to come along, and they found us.

When I first met the couple who were the ministers, they gave me a tour. It's a small building, so the tour didn't take long. There were pews lined up and a stage with a cross. The two ministers and I ended up sitting in the pews in silence. It was quite a beautiful thing to sit in this shared silence. They wanted us to be the continuity of what they did. When other people from IMC came to see the church, I leaned over to the couple and said, "They will have to continue where we left off." I often think about coming here to sit in silence; we are continuing something that was started way before us.

Now Redwood City has developed, and its biggest employers are companies like Oracle and Electronic Arts, as well as hospitals. The city is gentrifying. I read recently that the highest rent for studios and one-bedroom apartments in the Bay Area, maybe the world, is in Redwood City—right on these 400-foot-deep alluvial plains where grizzlies roamed, Native Americans lived, and wave after wave of people have come to live.

The Esselen Indians used to live here before the Ohlone pushed them out. Then the Spanish decimated the Ohlone, and the Esselen were pushed further south into the mountains, where they survived. I talked to an Esselen native last summer who lives in the Big Sur mountains. Up until the 1960s, his father would go into the mountains to do small one- or two-acre burns, keeping the vegetation just right for what they needed, as natives had done for generations. The Forest Service came along and said they had to stop burning. But in the last couple of years, they’ve come back to him saying, "We need you to tell us how to read the terrain. How did you know what to do?"

We read that the Monterey Bay, at a depth of about a thousand feet, has as much plastic as the Great Pacific Garbage Patch in microplastics. George Vancouver talked about the excellent water of Cordilleras Creek. How many of you would go over to that creek now and drink it? We have a wide well shaft on our property, and we had the water tested once—it is not to be drunk. The Esselen removed the Ohlone, we decimated the Spanish, the United States came and made it hard for the Mexicans who were here, and waves of people keep coming, growing, and developing. That's part of the nature we are touching here. Some of it should be celebrated, and some of it should break our hearts.

The earth here has been changed dramatically from ancient times. Is it really still a natural world that supports us, that we can touch and feel its protection?

The Buddha said, "I teach suffering and the end of suffering." He didn't say, "I teach about your own little personal life and how to be free of your personal suffering." It is very significant that he said "suffering," because suffering is not only a personal thing. As we become mindful and connected to this world, we remember what this world is about. We look around and experience lots of suffering in the world. The end of suffering is not just the end of our personal suffering, because suffering doesn't end when our personal suffering ends. We live in an ocean of suffering all around us.

So how do we touch the earth? How do we connect? I am very fond of the word "remember" because it means to bring the members back together. To remember ourselves, to be mindful of ourselves, is to reassemble all of who we are with no part left out. It also means remembering to touch the earth, reconnecting, and reassembling all of what we are. We are also the natural world, and we are also the suffering of the world around us.

Do we have the capacity, the freedom, and the care that allows us to sit like the Buddha with an open chest, an open heart, and a soft, gentle hand that touches the world? A hand that touches gently and caringly, inclusive of all that is here in this place and time, inclusive of the world we live in? Our practice of Buddhism should not be insulated from where we sit. When we touch the earth—maybe metaphorically, by really waking up and being connected to this place—we understand where we are, we learn its history and momentum, and we care about it. We are the caretakers of it, not as a burden or obligation, but with the lightness of a heart that feels no separation between ourselves and what is around us.

What is around us is as much ourselves as our own hands, feet, hearts, and thoughts. How do you want to treat yourself? How do you want to treat the world? Treat it with care, love, and appreciation. Help contribute to creating a relationship with the natural world so we are in harmony and the natural world can take care of us. If we don't do that, if we leave it to someone else, then when it's your turn to reach forward and touch the earth, the earth might not be there for you.

Here we sit. This is where we are. If you give directions to someone, you might say we live on the corner of Birch and Hopkins. But that's just a teeny bit of the richness. When our address used to be 1225 Hopkins, we asked the post office if we could change our address. They said yes and gave us a range of numbers to choose from. We chose 108[4], which is a special number in Buddhism. So now all this history is here, and you are here, a contributor and part of that flow, history, development, and movement of the natural world.

I look forward to our ability as a community, as individuals, and as part of society to discover what happens when we touch the earth and feel connected to this multifaceted, rich world. I hope this talk has inspired you to consider that you are part of something much bigger than you ever imagined. Please live in it with mindfulness and remembering. May our practice contribute to the ending of suffering in all directions. Thank you.



  1. Mara: In Buddhist cosmology, a demon or semi-deity who tempted the Buddha with visions of beautiful women, doubt, and fear to try to prevent his enlightenment. ↩︎

  2. Sati: A Pali word typically translated as "mindfulness," which also carries the fundamental meaning of memory, recollection, or calling to mind. ↩︎

  3. Ohlone: A Native American people of the Northern California coast. The speaker mentions tribes such as the Puichon and Lamchin, and languages like Ramaytush. ↩︎

  4. 108: A sacred number in Dharmic religions, frequently used for the number of beads on a mala (prayer beads). ↩︎