Moon Pointing

How Goodness Accrues on the Path

Date:
2019-11-03
Speakers:
Matthew Brensilver [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-20 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
How Goodness Accrues on the Path

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

How Goodness Accrues on the Path

Oh, nice to be here. How's it going? There's something about Sunday mornings where I feel like I should be an inspiring preacher, but my vibe is more in the "depressed rabbi" kind of sort. I do what I can. [Laughter]

What is the function of a Dharma talk? There are many functions, and one we could say is just to point a way out of the forest of suffering. Suffering, by its nature, regresses us. It disorients us and bewilders us. The state of mind amidst suffering is often bewildered, and we forget so much. Suffering is a kind of forgetting. So the Buddha says to teach step by step, to actually even just begin to name suffering as suffering, and to begin to see the patterns. To see, "Oh, I am in the forest right now. What can be remembered? What wisdom, what love can be remembered?"

Dharma talks are a kind of invitation for people to look more carefully at experience, to inspire investigation. The Buddha said that when we're suffering, we can blame ourselves, blame others, despair, or investigate. The answer is investigate.

A lot of the function of Dharma talks is to get us interested in experience. In the storms of suffering, there is a certain kind of disinterest in what is actually happening moment by moment. We are so mesmerized by the pain or the confusion of the moment that there isn't this hunger to look. A lot of the Dharma is just about finding ways to re-engage and get interested in what is actually happening.

Dharma talks are sometimes meant to unsettle us. I'm realizing it's easy as a teacher, without really knowing that one's doing it, to collude in creating Dharma talks that make us feel good. In one way, that's totally appropriate; they should mostly feel good. We need refuge, we need shelter from the storm. We need ways of reconnecting with our heart, and a sense of solidarity together. Without even knowing it sometimes, I can feel like I'm being coached into giving Dharma talks that lead people to feel good. Somehow I wind up giving more talks on mettā[1] than renunciation, but renunciation is just as beautiful. Sometimes talks unsettle us, and there is a certain willingness to feel the pain of growth.

We think about Dharma talks as disseminating information, but they're really powerfully like a transmission. The teacher invites us into her mind, and we can rest there in the spaciousness or the field of her own mind. It's not exactly a hypnotic induction, but it's not totally different in the sense that something happens when we are invited into something. It is less about verbal information being shared. Sometimes people say to me, "Matthew, I don't really know what you're talking about and I don't really care"—which is maybe not the highest compliment—but something happens. That something is usually the sense that we are dwelling in the Dharma together. With some teachers, I feel this very strongly. I feel like I'm sitting in the lap of their mind, and we can just rest there.

Early in practice, I remember listening to cassette tapes of Jack Kornfield[2]. Even through the medium of recorded audio, I could sense his heart-mind[3], and it was awakening long-dormant parts of my own heart. I got a sense of tasting goodness, tasting the Dharma before I even really knew what that was, but I knew something was being evoked and remembered. That led me onwards.

Maybe the most important function is really just to remind us of goodness, to gladden the mind, and to inspire some persistence to keep going. So much of a Dharma talk's function is just to normalize the peaks and valleys of a Dharma life.

The Gradual Accumulation of Goodness

This morning I thought to talk a bit about how goodness accrues on this path, and to talk more about the outcomes of practice rather than getting into the trenches of dukkha[4] right away—which is my native ground. I have to resist talking about it, but knowing dukkha is a lot different than experiencing it. When I started out practice, it was so vital to hear that we were talking in very honest ways about the moment-to-moment experience of being human. Even if our life is going really well, even if we find ourselves amidst great fortune and privilege, it's intense being human.

The realization[5] of the noble truth of dukkha is discerned by the wise, and is totally opposite to the kind of dukkha one feels. The understanding of the truth of dukkha is wisdom; the mind feels strength, energy, freedom, and detachment with this understanding. The experience of dukkha, however, is accosting. The true realization of dukkha is free from clinging[6].

That is, in a sense, the backdrop of this. But I want to talk about how goodness accumulates. The Buddha was much more explicit about the suffering that gets released than what freedom looks like. He left a little vague what a free life or an awakened heart looks like. My experience in knowing practitioners and teachers is that burgeoning freedom in someone's heart looks very idiosyncratic. There isn't one fingerprint of the freed heart; it is filtered through one's own personality, quirks, and foibles. It's almost like we become more idiosyncratic the deeper we go into the path. The tidy maps we have that map out the transformations of the heart-mind, with various signposts and archetypes, are messier than that, as far as I can tell.

I don't know how many experiences are truly necessary and totally sufficient to wake us up. This would be a debate with more traditional formulations of the Dharma. Sometimes things happen dramatically, and it feels like we can point to an experience and say, "Absolutely, a before and after." There is a famous description from Bill Wilson when he had an experience leading to his sobriety. From a different tradition, but with resonances to our own, he says:

"Suddenly the room lit up with a great white light. I was caught up in an ecstasy which there are no words to describe. It seemed to me, in the mind's eye, that I was on a mountain and that a wind not of air but of spirit was blowing. And then it burst upon me that I was a free man. Slowly the ecstasy subsided. I lay on the bed, but now for a time I was in another world, a new world of consciousness. All about me and through me there was a wonderful feeling of presence, and I thought to myself, 'So this is the God of the preachers.' A great peace stole over me, and I thought, 'No matter how wrong things seem to be, they are all right.'"

Sudden, dramatic changes where we feel safe in a new way are celebrated. But much of the way the path actually develops is very gradual. Shunryu Suzuki Roshi[7] famously compared it to getting wet by walking through mist for a long while. He said that when you get wet walking through mist, it's very hard to dry off.

Often we are trying to track our progress, almost like after each mindful breath we look around to see if we're wiser, more concentrated, or more free. It's like going to the gym, doing one repetition, and then looking at our bicep to see how it's going. Because we can look at the surface layer of our mind and judge how concentrated we are, how much chatter there is, or how peaceful we feel, we get fixated on these markers. They aren't really reliable indicators, but we compulsively sample data all the time to see how it's going. A lot of it is just learning to actually trust the logic of the practice, the logic of the Dharma—to just breathe, to just do the repetition.

For me, just having a path feels like goodness. As a kid, I can remember testing out various ways my life could unfold, just imagining them. That was painful because I couldn't envision the happiness and peace that some part of me was longing for. Even amidst good fortune and safety, I simulated various futures and had the sense that they would leave me feeling incomplete. Not that those are bad lives, but I had an intuitive connection with a longing for a path. Gil Fronsdal[8] has said something like he's just so happy to actually have a path of practice, he doesn't even care so much how he's doing. It's beautiful.

In a way, we fall in love with the Dharma. To be in love with something feels good; it feels like a kind of companionship. As the practice unfolds, there is no more questioning about practice or doubt in oneself. The ambivalence that riddles the mind sometimes for years or decades just collapses. That obsessive, ambivalent rumination about "Can I do this? Is this right? Do I have the capacities?" dissolves, and the relief from being out of its grips is immense.

We are left just walking a path that may look a million different ways. As Rumi says, there are a thousand ways to kiss the ground. Life gets a lot simpler. There is an end to seeking—that nagging sense of needing to become someone, get something, or add the Dharma to my life falls away, sometimes very dramatically. The relief of not seeking something outside oneself, and not perceiving oneself as a deficient creature still on the hunt for goodness, is very relieving to just give up.

Knowing What We Want

Part of not understanding ourselves well is not really knowing what we want. It is very common that we find ourselves living someone else's vision of a good life. We don't realize all the ways in which we've accumulated ideas about what a good life is. We don't know where we inherited them from, and often we haven't evaluated if they are actually a viable philosophy of happiness for us.

Part of Dharma practice is becoming more honest and realistic about what we want. It's about knowing what we want, which doesn't sound very Buddhist because we are used to hearing about non-clinging. But a teacher I was teaching with last week, Phillip Moffitt, had been on a retreat with Ajahn Sumedho[9]. Ajahn Sumedho is one of the senior monastics in the Thai Forest lineage, and he said, "No, no, no, desire is desire. Desire fills the room. Desire is not the problem; it is clinging to desire." Clinging—essentially acting out our preferences in a compulsive way—is the engine of suffering. As we start to know more about ourselves, we simultaneously relinquish clinging while knowing what we want more deeply.

In college, I remember reading Don DeLillo's White Noise. He described the end-of-summer garage sales in a college town as "driveways arrayed with failed possessions." Somehow that stuck in my mind for twenty years. Failed possessions. We tune into the deeper set of goals that we long for.

There is a body of research on affective forecasting[10]—imagining the emotional impacts of events in the future—and we are not too good at this. Researchers Timothy Wilson and Daniel Gilbert say that affective forecasts are important because people base many decisions on them—who to marry, what career to pursue, whether to donate money. To the extent that people's predictions about what will make them happy are flawed, they fail at maximizing their happiness. Finding ways to increase the accuracy of affective forecasts is a worthy enterprise, though not a particularly easy one.

Over the course of a normal life, we get better at predicting what will actually make us happy. We become more realistic in not buying into the ways that goals over-promise. One psychoanalyst said, "There's nothing like getting what you want to realize you don't fully know yourself." You get it, and there's still something incomplete in the heart. Being realistic about what accomplishments do and don't do for the heart helps us calibrate how we want to relate to them and how much energy they are worth.

Our intuition gets better over the course of practice. We start to listen more deeply to that very subtle "yes" or "no" approach-avoidance feeling. It cuts through the analytic approach—which is vitally important in some ways—but a lot of times what we really need to hear is that subtle yes/no. It contains a lot of data about what we need, what we want, what we can handle, and the limits of our equanimity. So much of a Dharma life is pairing analytic thinking with that other channel of data that we become open to, and learning when it's most trustworthy.

Transparency and Peace with the Past

As the Dharma transforms our heart, people come to treat us differently. That's not to minimize the realities of how racism or sexism distorts the treatment of people, but I think over time, as our heart blossoms, we evoke less defensiveness and fear in others. They can actually sense the refuge of your own heart in some way, and that changes the field of relations.

We feel more and more transparent. Rilke says, "I want to unfold. I don't want to be folded anywhere, because where I am folded, there I am a lie."

As we gather up the shards of our own past and start to metabolize our history, there is less and less to be ashamed of. We talk about being present, but the present is composed of the past. The present is the leading edge of everything that has come before. To be here now is actually to make deep peace with the past. All the momentum of our habits, energy, ideas, memories, loves, and heartbreaks protrudes into the present. Moment by moment, we are blessing the path. We are blessing memory and the karmic momentum of our life with wisdom and love.

As that happens, we become less intimidated by our past, our inner life, and our feelings. We naturally move toward more transparency. There is less to hide. The feeling of "Oh, I can't be found out"—there is a blessing in that. That dissolves so much of the anxiety around curating one's self-presentation.

There is a confidence in the heart, a trust in equanimity. It's the sense of, "Okay, I can't be run over by experience in the same way." Bad things can happen, loss is inevitable, but there is a confidence in the strength of the heart to weather the intensities of a life. The winds of pain will blow, but they will not blow something over in our own heart. That inspires a certain kind of ease and confidence in our living.

There is so much less attention pulled up in ourselves. One of the great gifts of Dharma practice has been that I think about myself and the project of my life dramatically less. Ajahn Sumedho said that after 50 or 60 years of monastic practice, "Every time I think of myself, I get depressed." In that sense of, "Oh yeah, me and my life, and where it's going, and the path of my happiness and livelihood, and who I'm becoming." Let me put all of that down. Being freed from the fantasy of "I'm going to grow into the person I'm supposed to be," or seeing oneself as a self-improvement project that just needs a few more decades of work before resting, is wonderful. We just don't think of ourselves in that same way.

Ethical Evolution and Completion

Our behavior begins to align more fully with our deepest values. To be really aligned, the Buddha described it as bliss. It's not about being mired in guilt and the story of self, but coming to peace with whatever harm we have done and knowing that a part of our heart really wishes not to do it again.

Some of this growth feels blissful, but the story we tell about ethical goodness is not final. We are called into an evolution as ethical creatures. We keep refining our ethical intuitions, knowing the fragility of life. We ask, "What does goodness entail?" This means we have to tolerate a sense of moral incoherence sometimes—that haunting, unsettling effect of feeling like we can't justify our life. We often glance over this, let it cause shame, or avoid it entirely. But part of the fruit of Dharma practice is that it provides us the courage to feel into the zones of moral incoherence, where we are out of alignment with our deepest values.

For me, this is an unending question: How do I refine my behavior? What does goodness ask of me? Maybe more than I'm ready to give right now. I try to hold that sense of the undefendable quality of the ways in which I privilege my own pleasure over the well-being of others in distant continents[11]. Dharma practice gives us the courage to stay with that, to evolve ethically. What do we owe to others, to the least fortunate, to future generations, to non-human animals? Staying with that in a way that doesn't deflate us, but enlivens us.

At some point, we've touched into goodness and explored enough of the chambers of the mind that life actually feels complete. We may never be fully ready to die—even if life were a thousand years, we might still want to hold on—but marinating in goodness and knowing the capacities of the heart-mind leads to a sense of completion. Life feels complete, and whatever time is left is gravy. It gives us the courage to live and to die.

Let's sit for a moment.



  1. Mettā: A Pali word meaning loving-kindness, friendliness, or goodwill. ↩︎

  2. Jack Kornfield: A well-known American Buddhist teacher and author, and one of the key figures to introduce Vipassana meditation to the West. ↩︎

  3. Original transcript said "hard mind", corrected to "heart-mind" based on the common translation of the Buddhist concept citta. ↩︎

  4. Dukkha: A Pali word often translated as "suffering," "stress," or "unsatisfactoriness." ↩︎

  5. Original transcript said "ciation", corrected to "realization" based on context. ↩︎

  6. Original transcript said "Klingon", corrected to "clinging" based on Buddhist context. ↩︎

  7. Shunryu Suzuki Roshi: A Soto Zen monk and teacher who helped popularize Zen Buddhism in the United States. ↩︎

  8. Gil Fronsdal: The primary teacher at the Insight Meditation Center (IMC) in Redwood City, California. ↩︎

  9. Ajahn Sumedho: A prominent senior monastic in the Thai Forest Tradition of Theravada Buddhism. (Original transcript had several phonetic misinterpretations such as "audience amido", "Ajinca Meadows", and "Arjun samito"). ↩︎

  10. Affective forecasting: The psychological study of people's predictions about their future emotional states, prominently researched by Timothy Wilson and Daniel Gilbert. (Corrected from "effective forecasting"). ↩︎

  11. Original transcript said "distant condoms", corrected to "distant continents" based on the context of global ethical well-being. ↩︎