Moon Pointing

Introduction to Buddhism Part 3: The Path

Date:
2020-02-03
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-19 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Introduction to Buddhism Part 3: The Path

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Introduction to Buddhism Part 3: The Path

For those of you who are new, at the beginning of the year I started a ten-part series that's called the "Introduction to Buddhism." I could say, just as a more background introduction for those of you who might be new to this, that to call it an introduction to Buddhism is actually a strange thing to say. Because there are many forms of Buddhism, and no one really should be in the position of representing all of Buddhism. But people who are Dharma teachers have a little bit of religious license to say something short like "an introduction to Buddhism," and what we mean is it's an introduction to the Buddhism of my tradition, our tradition locally. So you're getting a particular take on Buddhism from me, as opposed to "this is the pristine, perfect Buddhism that has been taught down through the ages," because there is no such thing.

There's only that which people have found useful, and they try to teach and pass on. As we pass it on, it's the spirit, the attitude that you'll try it on and find out what works for you. The whole spirit of trial and error is a hugely important part of discovering what Buddhism is for oneself. To learn some teachings, learn some practices, and then try it on and experiment with it. Find out what way it applies in your life, how it's useful in your life, or how it supports you in your life.

However, at the same time, Buddhism is called a path. In our Pali[1] ancient Buddhist language, it's magga[2]. Some of you who are familiar with modern Indian languages know it as a marga. There is a religion called Ananda Marga[3]; it's a great name because it means "path of joy," the joy path. So Buddhism is a magga, a path, and it's a path that goes to someplace. That place is the guide for how we experiment and do the trial and error. If you want this as the goal of your practice, then Buddhist practice is used for that purpose.

Actually, there can be many goals of Buddhist practice, and sometimes it's good to be clear why you're practicing Buddhism and why you're interested in it. Then you can explore, experiment through trial and error, and find out how the teachings and practices work for you given the goal and purpose that you have. There are plenty of people who come to Buddhism these days because they want stress reduction, which is a great thing, and that's a particular goal. So then, how do these teachings work for that? Some people are coming to live a happier life, a better life, a life of greater integrity. So how does that work out? How do the teachings and practices support that? Some people are looking to calm their minds in some very deep way, so how do the teachings support that and bring some kind of peace?

And some people are looking for enlightenment because Buddhism is famous for enlightenment. Some people are looking for it and don't have a clue what it is, but they know they want it. They know it's the ultimate, it's the greatest. It'll make you certainly the most popular person on your block! Lots of friends and all kinds of success in life if you could just get enlightened. So it doesn't really matter what it is, it's just a great thing. But it also helps to know what it is, because there are different ideas of what enlightenment is in Buddhism. So you go around and see what speaks to you, what inspires you, or what fits you.

Sometimes people come to Buddhism, and they're very inspired by the goal. They hear the idea of Nirvana or awakening, they hear a particular expression of what that means, and that inspires them: "That's what I want." Sometimes people encounter the practice, and they just love the practice the way it's presented. They don't really care that much or think so much about where it goes, but they're just inspired by the practice. For example, some people find mindfulness dedication is to be honest. Some people have a tremendous inspiration in their lives to live an honest life, and mindfulness is a practice of honesty, of self-honesty. Every moment that we're mindful is a moment of recognizing actually what's happening and being honest about it to oneself. Where that goes, people may not be so clear, but that's what they want: to live a life of integrity with that kind of honesty and have that available.

Some people are inspired by the notion of compassion. Buddhism offers a practice to try to live a life that supports them to meet compassion and be of service to the world. Awakening doesn't really have that much inspiration for them, but rather the idea of a life of compassionate care, with the values of Buddhism that maybe are less supernatural than some of the religions they grew up with and don't care for so much anymore. So in a sense, you can personalize it. How far you can go and still call it Buddhism is an open question, but it's okay because no one has the authority to tell you what it is.

Though there are lots of people who will judge you. If you say, "This is what Buddhism is," or you teach it this way, there are people who will say, "No, that's not it. You're too much this, you're not doing the right thing. There's a right one." You know, "You teach too much about rebirth," or "You don't teach enough about rebirth." Or, "Your teaching is way too secular, you're just teaching secular humanistic values, and really there are great spiritual values we have to include, and without that it can't be here." "Yes, you're teaching meditation, but you're not teaching enough ethics." "Yes, you're teaching ethics, but you're not teaching enough meditation." And it goes on and on. Because I guess it's a religion. I don't know if you've noticed, but religions bicker a lot, at least some of the ones that are more public, and Buddhists are not free from that either.

If you go back to the ancient teachings of the Buddha, he has some teachings that I find quite radical, and I find quite inspiring. One of them is: don't bicker about all the different views. It's not about having views. It's not about having opinions. In the most ancient teachings, it's not about having opinions. It's not about holding onto ethics, making ethics ultimate. It's not about having religious practices and making the practices ultimate. It's not about some great cosmic experience of consciousness, some wonderful opening and special state of consciousness, and all the things that people associate Buddhism with. It's not what it's about, really. They're part of it maybe, and they have their place—some of these things like ethics—but it's a very simple goal. Kind of what I talked about two weeks ago: it's not to cling. Don't cling to anything.

You might ask, "Well, why shouldn't I cling? Isn't that useful?" The reason not to cling is that clinging is suffering[4]. Clinging is painful. Sometimes it's not as painful immediately, and sometimes people cling unconsciously, unknowingly, to things for decades, and then something happens, it's torn away from them, and it's devastating. Then they see that they were really holding onto this, they were depending on it, and it didn't serve them in the end. One of the ways of seeing the goal of Buddhism—and this is what inspires me a lot—is the end of suffering, the end of clinging that brings suffering.

So then the question is, if that's the goal, what's the means to that? How do you live? What are the teachings, what are the practices that lead to that? We experiment, we learn them, and we apply them for ourselves. It's not my job to tell you what you should do or what Buddhism exactly really is. I just have to get in the ballpark well enough to inspire you, just well enough that you try some of these things out and find what works for you and what's best. That's why it's not exhausting being a teacher. Because if a teacher is supposed to teach everyone the pristine, perfect practice and pristine, perfect Buddhism, exactly at the right view and philosophy, and get everyone to agree on that—that's exhausting. But if you allow me just to be close enough that it's something that works for you, that's meaningful for you, gives you a new perspective, supports you in some way, and that you can apply and use in your life, then hopefully we've done the job.

So Buddhism is called a path. What a path means is that it's practices that lead you somewhere, that take you somewhere. The metaphor of a path is something that you bring your whole body into. You walk on a path, so it's something you engage in with all of yourself. Traditionally, Buddhism is not meant to be a hobby. It's not meant to be something you do just on Sunday or something, but it's something that you engage your whole life with. That's what they're offering you with this idea. For some people, the idea of the end of suffering and understanding what that potential is about can evoke a tremendous amount of compassion. As we encounter the suffering in the world around us, then we understand something about suffering, the cause of it, how to address it, how to meet it, how to respond to it in ways that support us not to suffer, but help us to suffer less and do the same for other people.

The Two Paths

It's called a path, and classically in Buddhism, there are two distinct paths that are taught by much of the tradition. One is a path for the people who just want to live a happier life, either in this lifetime or in future lifetimes. So it's advice on living a good life for the purposes of going to a good place. Then there's the other path, which is the path of awakening. The path of awakening, or the path of liberation or freedom from suffering, is a higher cause for a higher level of commitment. It's meant to be for people who really want to put all of themselves in here and somehow be transformed in the process.

For people who want the path of liberation, there are three major trainings in that path. One of the ways Buddhism is referred to as a path, it's also called a training. We're training ourselves in some way. There are three major categories of trainings: there is ethics, there is mental development, and there is wisdom. These are a whole set of things that we engage in. If you want to be involved in the path of liberation, you do all three. If you want to do the path of worldly happiness, then the primary emphasis is on ethics.

What's happened here in our culture, not just in the West but in modern Asia in the last hundred years as well, is that a lot of lay people have also started to learn meditation. Many people who do meditation are not really so interested in awakening, the insight or the wisdom, but they're using meditation to live a healthier, happier life. The great example of this is what's nowadays called secular Buddhism here in the West, where people can go to a local hospital, clinics, spas, the local library, or corporations, and they teach classes in mindfulness. We have someone here at IMC who currently is teaching a class in mindfulness, and we were invited to teach students at a local college. It's nice to bring these together. I was told they wanted someone from IMC to come teach because there's an epidemic of suicides on national colleges, and we have to bring wellness to the students. A lot of these students coming to the college are already being introduced to mindfulness meditation, they want more of it, or they want to be taught more. So they're not there for awakening; they're there for a happier, healthier kind of life.

But classically, people who want a happier life are living an ethical life. What's nice is these two paths, the path of awakening and the path of a healthy, happy life, share the same first training: our training in ethics.

For laypeople, the path as is classically taught in Buddhism is to be ethical primarily through adhering to five sets of precepts: not killing, not stealing, not engaging in sexual misconduct, not lying, and not making yourself crazy with drugs and alcohol (don't get intoxicated). Those five are considered fundamental trainings for laypeople. The interesting word there is "trainings." They're not called commandments where it's all or nothing, and if you break them you go to hell or something. These are trainings that you are training to grow into, to really learn how to live that way. It's a process of trial and error, reflection, thinking deeply about your life, trying to do your best, and trying not to do those things.

An example would be, it's not uncommon for someone to come to me who is trying to live an ethical life. They come to me and they're asking about the first precept: not to kill. They're not in danger of killing people, but they feel like they need to fumigate or put poison on their homes because of cockroaches or termites. "What do I think about that?" What I think about that is I'm so happy that they're asking! I'm so delighted that someone is concerned about the welfare of these little critters, that they're reluctant to kill them and they feel some kind of moral concern that they come to me and ask what I think. I don't generally want to answer their question. I don't want to be in the position of arbitrating what they should or shouldn't do, what's right and what's wrong. But I will encourage them to go look for all the alternatives to killing. I say that a lot of times people are quite quick to go for the violent way, it's supposed to be the easy way and to be done with it. But to really live an ethical life, a minimum would be to reflect deeply about what we're doing, look for alternatives, and find how to accomplish what we feel we need to do without causing harm.

Many years ago, a person came to me and said she was thinking of getting a gun to protect herself, and what did I think. I didn't say I was happy she was thinking that way, but I did say I didn't want to answer her question yes or no, but I did want to encourage her to consider the alternatives. There are a lot of alternatives that might actually make you safer, but it takes time and effort to get trained and get wise. The idea of going quick without getting trained is different. So these five precepts are the core ethical guidelines for laypeople interested in living a healthier, happier life. It tends to put together the conditions that, over time, better circumstances come our way. They tend to create a good life that way.

The other primary practice for lay people for living a happy life is generosity. There's something about the alchemy of generosity and how we relate to other people and ourselves that really begins to change dramatically the relationships we live in. To be generous to the people we live with, in our communities, families, and places of work. Making generosity a primary vehicle, a bridge to the world around us, changes the world we have around us. People relate to us differently, we relate to other people differently. Generosity gives us a deeper connection to people; we see them in different ways, not just on the surface, not just as instruments for our own welfare. It really creates a healthy relationship to the world around us that will come back and support us, and support the kind of happiness that is reliable and good. That is much more helpful than winning the California Lottery. Do you know they've done studies on people who win big lottery jackpots, and they studied them a year after they win, and they're less happy than they were before they won? Some still want to win. Many people say, "Let me win the lottery and be unhappy! Where do I sign up for that?" [Laughter]

So generosity as a path, ethics as a path.

The other path, the path of freedom from suffering, is traditionally in Buddhism the path for monastics. Because back in the old days, especially in the time of the Buddha, there were not any IMCs down the road where you could go to a local community center and get teachings and meditate. Even just a few decades ago, people would travel a long way to get Buddhist teachings. Not my direct teachers, but my "grand teachers" in the Dharma would travel through jungles for weeks. Back in the forests of northern Burma or Thailand, there was a great meditation master people had heard about. There was no AudioDharma app, no bookstore to get the books, no radio. In order to get that teacher, you had to walk there. People would spend weeks sometimes to find a teacher, just to sit there and learn. And there was no support for that. Most people's work didn't give them vacation time to go on a retreat. There were no meditation centers where you could just go and do a retreat. So having deep spiritual engagement available was kind of unheard of for centuries and centuries unless you became a monastic.

Some people's drive for freedom and liberation was so strong that they had to do that. They would renounce the world and engage full-time, wholeheartedly in the practice. Some people suffer a tremendous amount, the horrific challenges they've been through, that sometimes ordinary life doesn't make any sense anymore. To do something really serious and deep, like engaging full-time in spiritual life, is what's healing, or what's liberating, or is the only thing that makes sense.

There are other people whose personalities are contemplative in some deep way. I've known people who are struggling to—if I may use this metaphor—come out of the closet as contemplatives. Family members don't want them to live a quiet meditative life of contemplation or study; parents want them to go off to college. I've had people tell me literally, "I'm supposed to be a doctor, all my siblings are doctors," or "We're supposed to follow in our family's footsteps and take over the family business, but I just want to go off and study and practice and meditate." Some people, just who they are, are contemplative. I've seen people finally step into that role and blossom. It's like, "Oh, that's who they are. Wow." They inhabit that in such a beautiful way.

Three Trainings for Awakening

For the people who want to go much further than just having a happy life, there are those three trainings: training in ethics, training in mental cultivation, and training in wisdom.

The background for this kind of training is a fundamental orientation or perspective that we have on human life, and that begins with the idea of change. Our life is characterized by impermanence. Most Indian religions at the time of the Buddha emphasized how impermanent this world is. In Greece, I think it was Heraclitus[5] who said you can't step in the same river twice because everything's changing all the time. A lot of people understand that, and it's an important insight to have. But the Buddha's contribution to seeing the changing nature of this human life of ours is that the impermanent way things change and morph over time is not random. Change occurs based on the conditions that influence it, the conditions that come to bear on the situation.

If it gets cold and there's a lot of humidity, those are the conditions for rain. If those conditions come together, you'll have rain. But if it's hot and not so humid, probably we're not going to have rain. As this climate changes because of climate change, those are conditions that mean we're having different kinds of weather all over the world. What are the conditions that contributed to that? There's some argument these days about the human role in creating those conditions, but we certainly see that humans have created lots of conditions in recent decades and centuries that influence all kinds of things in the world. Human health is phenomenally affected by the conditions of how humans live their lives. The smog in cities around the world, people getting asthma and worse, is phenomenal. It's clear that it's humanly caused smog. The litany of things goes on and on. So the conditions that we create shape how things change in the future.

That happens in our hearts as well, and in our minds. If you kill, steal, engage in sexual misconduct, lie, and maybe drink alcohol—if you do it all—that creates a very different set of conditions influencing how your life's going to unfold than if you do the opposite. Chances are if you break all the five precepts, you're going to end up being miserable, probably end up in jail or worse. If you do the opposite, that's a very different set of conditions that's going to create a very different direction for your life.

The Buddhist teaching of conditionality is that we have a role in influencing how impermanence changes things over time by the conditions we put into the system. If what we want is to become free of suffering, we have to create the conditions that will allow that to happen. If you want to become free of suffering and you just spend all your time reading romance novels, watching pornography, spending your time at the casinos, or all kinds of things, that's not going to be the conditions that allow you to look deeply into your heart and mind. You have to begin putting conditions in place that begin to shape and change your mind in such a way that your mind can be transformed in a useful way.

This is called the second training: mental cultivation. We're developing our mind. We're developing a mind to be mindful, to be able to be in the present moment so we're not always being pulled away and distracted by our thoughts or preoccupations or concerns. That's something we can train our mind to do. It takes practice. Practice over and over again and the mind will change. The mind is plastic. You can cultivate your mind to develop greater concentration. Concentration really helps a lot to stay calm, balanced, and to be able to see more clearly. Concentration practice is kind of like clearing the windshield from dirt so you can really see well. Mindfulness can be strong, but if the windshield is dirty you can't see so well. So we cultivate concentration.

It's possible to cultivate equanimity, to cultivate a capacity to be non-reactive. A non-reactive mind puts in place very different conditions than a reactive one. Different things happen and unfold because of that non-reactive mind. We cultivate loving-kindness and compassion. We cultivate healthy feelings of goodwill and generosity for the people around us. That creates a very different inner landscape than one that's motivated by greed, wanting to acquire more for oneself, or not caring about other people. We cultivate these things.

Initially, people might think, "That's too much, I can't do that. It just seems like too high of a mountain to climb to change myself. It's too hard." But actually, it's not that hard. It's remarkable how much the mind and the heart can grow, develop, and get stronger through regular practice. You have to do it regularly, ongoingly, again and again.

I'll give you a favorite analogy for how doing small changes can be really big over time. I learned it from a yoga teacher. A long time ago, there was something called the triangle pose where you kind of lean over to one side and try to get one hand flat on the ground. If you can't lean over and get your hand on the ground, the instruction back then was to get some telephone books. Those of you who don't remember telephone books, the paper in a telephone book was probably the thinnest paper you could see in ordinary life. So you get a stack of these telephone books, as many as you need so you can get your hand flat against some surface while leaning over. Every day you tear out one page. One page is so thin, it seems inconsequential, but you do it every day, and eventually, all the pages will be gone and you'll have your hand down on the floor. That's training.

Some of the teachings about concentration make it seem so lofty and distant from my mind. Being mindful and being in the present seems so distant and far away given how distracted my mind is. But in fact, we can be trained if we do it slowly. Maybe if you meditate every day you won't see the distance you've traveled because it's so thin, just like that thin paper from the telephone book, but over time you will change.

What's very important about this teaching of conditionality is that we're not the cause of our spiritual change. We're not the cause for how we really change. We are just putting the conditions in place and allowing this natural process of growth and development to happen. It's kind of like I would tell my kids. One of the ways I bothered my kids was I would tell them, "Please stop growing! I like you just the way you are. Stop!" They were little kids, right? Usually, they'd laugh at me because they knew it was impossible, and they took it as an expression of love. If these kids are eating, they're going to keep growing, you can't stop it. It turns out that we don't stop developing and growing when we turn 17, 18, or 20. When you're an adult, the natural movement towards growth and maturation can continue until you're 100, if we create the conditions for that natural growth to happen. Most people get so preoccupied and caught up with lay life and adult life that they actually put a stop to that natural maturation that's there.

The practice of mindfulness, of concentration, of kindness, are some ways of helping us get out of the way. Taking the distractions—the greed, hate, and delusion, the fears we live under—and getting them out of the way to allow this natural growth to continue happening. It really feels that way. It's a beautiful thing because it takes it out of "me, myself, and mine." It's almost not you who's growing; it's just nature, or it's the nature of the mind and heart to grow in these beautiful ways. It's a wonder, I think, one of the really beautiful adventures of human life, to do these kinds of mental cultivation practices that help us to encounter and experience this natural wonder of inner growth, the maturation and movement that can be there. It doesn't have to be dramatic, but in small ways, we change and develop over time if we put the conditions in. One of the conditions is to put in the effort. One of the conditions is to be willing to be changed; without that willingness, we probably won't.

Then the third training is a training in wisdom. Wisdom is to have insight, deep understanding of our minds, how it works, of our clinging, the nature of attachment, and the nature of freedom. Probably the best kind of insight you can have in Buddhism is to really understand the nature of freedom. To really feel and know firsthand something about the nature of how the mind becomes free, and then have that as a reference point for how you live your life. To have that as a North Star, a guide: "That's how you can be free." Then you go through your life and you see all the ways you have a choice, or all the ways you get caught, and you know there's another way. Because you already have an embodied experience of freedom, you can really see the difference now between being caught and not being caught. Then you can navigate with that, and maybe lean in the direction of freedom, of how not to be caught. If you lean in that direction, that's a condition for the growth of freedom. If instead you lean in the direction of your clinging, thinking "it's too much work to be free, it's easier to cling," that's a condition for reinforcing the habit of clinging. Beginning to have these practical insights gives us much greater choice and gives us a clear sense of what the purpose is we're doing this for, because now we really know it for ourselves.

It becomes more and more of a personal experience. This path remains a path we walk and engage in, but more and more as we do it, it becomes our own path. They say in Buddhism that as you keep doing it, at some point you become the path. There's a joining of the two. One teacher said that when you really understand Buddhism, Buddhism becomes you.

In terms of this "Introduction to Buddhism" series, I wanted to convey a few points today. One is that this is a very personal path that we explore and develop for ourselves. We use ourselves as the canvas. We use ourselves as the material that we're experimenting with. We have to have some sense of what our goal is, and then we're trying to match our practice in the way that supports our goal. If you mostly want to have a happy life, then by all means be ethical and be generous. If you want a little bit more, be kind. If you want a little bit more, meditate. But if you want the path of liberation, if you're interested in the full potential of this path, then you need to do more than ethics and generosity. Then it's really the work of mental cultivation.

It's a path, meaning that it's an unfolding, a journey, a growth. It's not a sudden, all-or-nothing kind of thing—hit the enlightenment button and you'll be happy ever after. You know, "Why should I do all this hard work? I could just take LSD or psilocybin, or maybe there's an app that's much more efficient than meditation!" The idea is to walk a path that includes all of who we are, not a quick fix, and to become transformed in the process. Classically, that's to be transformed to become a totally free person, a person who knows firsthand what it means to be liberated or free. This is synonymous in the classic Buddhist language with experiencing a profound level of peace, a peace where we feel completely at home in our hearts, completely at home and alive, without any suffering, without any feeling of oppression or restriction or limitation. We just feel no fear. We feel free.

So it is a path, a practice, we walk a path. Next week when I come, I'll talk about one very famous version of this path called the Eightfold Path[6], that's at the foundation of classic Buddhist teachings.

Thank you.



  1. Pali: The ancient Middle Indo-Aryan language in which the early Buddhist scriptures and texts of the Theravada tradition are preserved. ↩︎

  2. Magga: A Pali word meaning "path" or "way," often referring specifically to the path of practice leading to liberation. ↩︎

  3. Ananda Marga: A socio-spiritual organization founded in India in 1955, whose name translates from Sanskrit as "Path of Bliss." ↩︎

  4. Suffering: Often a translation of the Pali word dukkha, which broadly encompasses suffering, stress, unsatisfactoriness, or anguish. ↩︎

  5. Heraclitus: A pre-Socratic Greek philosopher famous for his insistence on ever-present change as being the fundamental essence of the universe. ↩︎

  6. Eightfold Path: The Noble Eightfold Path is the Buddha's principal teaching on the way to end suffering, comprising right view, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration. ↩︎