Mindful Speech for a Modern World
- Date:
- 2019-12-01
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-18 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Mindful Speech for a Modern World
I would like to read a passage from the suttas[1], his ancient discourses, and in it there's a passage that describes the ethics of the Buddha, the description of the ethics of Buddhist speech, how he speaks. I'd like to read this passage:
"Abandoning false speech, the Buddha refrains from false speech. A truth speaker, he can be relied on, trustworthy, dependable, non-deceptive. Abandoning malicious speech, the Buddha refrains from repeating what he has heard that harms others. A reconciler of those who are divided, he encourages those who are friends, rejoicing in peace, loving peace, delighting in peace, he speaks words that make for peace. Abandoning harsh speech, the Buddha refrains from it. He speaks what is blameless, pleasing to the ear, agreeable, reaching the heart, urbane, pleasing, and attractive to many. Abandoning idle chatter, he speaks at the right time what is true and to the point of the Dharma[2] and the discipline. The Buddha is a speaker whose words are to be treasured, seasonable, reasoned, well-defined, and connected with liberation."
This comes from well over 2,000, 2,500 years ago—a long time. And I suppose it was relevant to say this; the opposite was common enough that there were people who didn't speak the truth, who spoke maliciously, who spoke in harmful ways to others, and people who spoke in ways that created division in society, not peace and reconciliation. I think this has been an issue for probably all of humanity's history. There are people who have studied such things as political falsehoods. There are records from thirty-three hundred years ago of pharaohs in Egypt who were lying about how successful they were at fighting wars, which there are records that they didn't win. That's a long time that people have been doing this kind of thing.
When I reflect on our current society, it seems that the most publicly visible issue that's going on is how people speak to each other. It's quite aware that for some people, going to Thanksgiving is a difficult time because of how people speak about politics, and families are divided these days around politics. Some families have truces where no politics are allowed over Thanksgiving because otherwise it's just too painful. It has to do with how people speak to each other.
And then we have it going right up to the person who's supposed to be the leader for the country, who is well known now for lying, seems to be a serial liar, and as the producer of what he calls fake news. This is quite significant, because for some people that's how they get their news. So what is said, whether it's through political leaders or in the media or Facebook or different places, has a big impact on society. People don't have so much discernment around the source of what they read. Studies of the 2016 election pointed out that the twenty most popular news items—more popular than any news article from the sixteen major national media outlets—were fake news that was produced for all kinds of political reasons.
How people speak, what we write, and how we communicate to each other has a huge impact on what goes on. You might say that some of it has to do with divisions and what people believe. People believe what they're told, or they believe what's presented to them, and that's true probably for all sides of the political divide and social divides of all kinds. People have a preference to accept what goes along with their beliefs, and in doing so, they're sometimes not very discerning about the sources of it.
I became aware of this in myself when I was about twenty-one or twenty-two. I was a born-again organic farmer. I lived on organic farms, farmed, and read organic gardening magazines and books of all kinds back then. I had very strong opinions of what was right having to do with environmentally sound agriculture, and how evil the people were who weren't doing that, and it was quite a division. I went and got a degree in agriculture from the University of California, Davis, one of the world's preeminent agricultural schools, where we had a lot of support. The students initiated all kinds of action for alternatives in agriculture, maybe nowadays it's called sustainable agriculture. We got lots of support, including getting lots of money. Back then, we managed to finagle one hundred thousand dollars—the undergraduates did—from the legislature, and a granting of ten acres on the University of California land to start an organic research center. So it wasn't like we didn't get support for it.
But as I did my studies in the science of soils, pesticides, and fertilizers specifically, I discovered that these hard and fast beliefs I had—beliefs that I spoke forcefully to others and held up as being true—were not true. This was quite humbling for me, quite soul-searching, that I would have such strong, tightly held beliefs without having done the research or been well informed by it.
I think that a lot of these divisions we have in our society today because of how people speak to each other—whether it's politics, gender divides, racial divides, or all kinds of divides in which people form tribes and form "us versus them"—are supported by speaking in ways that put down the people who are not in their tribe. It is hugely important for our society.
If those of us who are Buddhists want to look at what Buddhism has for this, certainly Buddhism has a lot of teachings on right speech and careful speech, and that might be nice to talk about. But what I thought was nice to do was to take this passage that I just read to you and adapt it. Here it goes:
"Abandoning false speech, leaders refrain from false speech. Truth speakers, leaders can be relied on, trustworthy, dependable, non-deceptive. Abandoning malicious speech, leaders refrain from repeating what they have heard that harms others. Reconcilers of those who are divided, leaders encourage those who are friends, rejoicing in peace, loving peace, delighting in peace, leaders speak words that make for peace. Abandoning harsh speech, leaders refrain from it. They speak what is blameless, pleasing to the ear, agreeable, touching the heart, urbane, pleasing, and attractive to many. Abandoning idle chatter, they speak at the right time what is true and to the point of the Dharma, of the truth, and of ethics. Leaders are speakers whose words are to be treasured, seasonable, reasoned, well-defined, and connected with liberation."
Many years ago, when Dennis Kucinich was running for president, a friend of mine was having him for dinner and said, "Will you come to dinner with us?" I've been to the person's house, so eating a meal at the dinner table—sure. But I was asked, "Before we start the meal, can you do a little prayer?" Okay, well I was the designated clergy, I guess.
It turned out that people had a little bit bigger yard, and the whole yard was set up with canopies and tables, and there was a big group of people. So suddenly I had to do this prayer. I read something called the Ten Dhammas[3], ten behaviors of a ruler. I don't remember them right now, so I just read them very slowly. I don't know if it was just searching for votes or what, but the presidential candidate came over and loved that. He wanted a copy of that.
I could imagine in a situation like that reading this passage I just gave. I think that how we speak is one of the big, important issues of our society, these public visible issues. And I think how we speak is also one of the hardest areas to be mindful. There's something about the way that we get pulled into the world of communication, of talking, of our stories, our beliefs, what we're trying to get from the communication, and how we're trying to relate to people, that lends itself to being so involved with what we're saying that we're not actually paying attention to what we say or the impact of what we say.
And we're not paying very much attention to the impact on ourselves. How we speak, independent of what we speak, is actually quite important. Some of these descriptions here have to do with how we speak: not to speak harshly. The tone of voice carries certain things. The forcefulness of the voice has a certain impact. The speed in which we speak, the rapidity in which we step in to speak, the way we physically lean into the conversation, even what we do with our hands and our posture—all these things are part of what we communicate.
One interesting place to start practicing mindfulness of speaking is mindfulness of how we are as we speak. Try to train yourself to stay connected to your body as you speak. Feel what it's like to be in your body, the energy going through your body, the sensations, the emotions that are here as you speak. If you want extra credit, you would also do the same as you're listening to people. You would actually be listening to what's happening inside of you as you listen. If you just listen to the words and are debating the words or considering your verbal response, then you're missing a lot of the cues inside of you about how you feel, what's going on, what motivates you, how you're tightening up, how you're starting to get forceful, how you're closing down, how you're getting irritated, sad, or discouraged. All these kinds of things start going on.
To know that those are happening makes you a wiser speaker. If you don't know what's going on, if they're in the background or subconscious, then they spill out in what we say. People who are frustrated can easily spill out with words that are mean. People who are feeling discouraged or sad might say things that are self-deprecating in such a way that it pushes us back and makes us more closed or feeling sad. But if we can track and see how we feel, and then be careful how we speak, I think we can speak much more carefully.
We will also sometimes get the cues of how we're feeling about the person we're speaking to. If we don't like the person, or are opposed to them, or against their politics, gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity, or race, that all gets very complicated for us. We start getting tense, or tight, or hot, or fixated. There are all kinds of reactions that happen before people start saying something.
They've done studies on implicit bias where they tracked people's eye movements when they looked at photographs of different people of different racial and gender backgrounds. The eyes get fixated, the eyes turn inward, the eyes shut down. This points to how much information there is in our physical body. Training oneself to be in one's body, feeling connected and knowing what's going on, gives you early warning signals for what's dangerous, but also early notifications for what's really good. Feelings of warmth, kindness, love, and generosity might begin deeper than your conscious mind.
Communication is a difficult thing to do because of how quickly we get pulled into the words, ideas, and back-and-forth exchange. But it's a worthwhile training to give yourself. I still do it, and still find it difficult at times, so I'm not saying it's easy at all. But I've been doing it now for thirty years, and slowly and steadily I've watched my ability to be mindful and "body-full" in times of communication increase. It's better now than it was thirty years ago. If I'd said to myself, "Gil, start training now so you're better thirty years from now," it probably wouldn't have been very motivating for me. But now that I've done it for thirty years, I'm really glad. I've probably saved myself and others a lot of problems and difficulties because of the ability to track what's going on and to be present when I speak.
I think there's a different reference point for looking at the ethics of how we speak. If we're only looking at the ethical judgments we have—what's right and wrong in terms of speaking—it's too easy for ethics to be another divisive element in our society. Ethics can divide self and others. But really being in touch with and knowing what's going on in here with ourselves will show us if what we're going to say is something that is going to create distance between me and the other person, or is it going to create some kind of connection and unity? Do you want distance? Do you want separation? Do you want people to close down? Or do you want to feel more friendship, more familiarity, more contact, more mutual support for each other? What is happening in the communication, and what's motivating it?
Another thing that is useful for mindful speaking is in your free time, sitting having a cup of tea or going for a walk, to consciously contemplate and think about this in some deep way. What purpose do you want your speech to have? Why do you want to speak? What are the purposes you use now for speaking? What are you trying to accomplish when you speak?
Is it simply that you're giving people information they're asking you for? Or you say, "You might be interested in knowing that I ate at the best diner on the peninsula yesterday. It was really good, and I thought it was important for you to have this information." It's not information; it's self-aggrandizement. It's, "Look at me and how great an experience I had, and I had this special thing happen." That could be celebratory, but is it bringing people together, or does it subtly make some separation? "Look at me, how special I am, I bet you didn't eat at a good diner yesterday." It may be a little bit under the motivation, to create a sense of, "Oh, I'm special in relationship to other people."
One of the very mature things to do for anybody interested in Buddhist practice is to actively spend time researching for themselves why they say what they say. Don't be satisfied with the first answer; we often have multiple reasons why we say what we say. So you go through what the different reasons are. How much of it is information to be given? How much of it is to make an impression? How much is it to keep people together and have people want to like me?
I spent a lot of time when I was younger trying to get people to like me, and one of the places where that was impossible was when I was the kitchen manager for the monastery kitchen. I was in charge of a group of about fifteen people cooking food. Monastery kitchens are notorious for being an explosive kind of place where there's a lot of tension, and the person who's the kitchen manager is at the center of it. If you want an exciting life, be the manager at a monastery kitchen.
That's where I discovered how exhausted I was by constantly trying to do the social gymnastics of getting everyone in the kitchen to like me. It turned out it was an impossible task. Because I was meditating a lot in the monastery, I started to see the contrast between trying to get everyone to like me and sitting in meditation feeling completely content and at peace with myself. Then I'd get out of meditation, go to the kitchen, and there was back to that effort. Going back and forth between those two started to put a question mark after my efforts to get everyone to like me. I got to see it more and more acutely. Because meditation was a healthy alternative that I kept touching into, it wasn't so much that I decided not to try to get people to like me; I just started to relax around it. So slowly I learned to give up this impossible task.
What are the reasons why you say what you say, and how thoughtful are you about the purposes you want to have for what you speak? If you look at the way the Buddha spoke, are these some of the ways that you would like to speak? Are you motivated enough that you want to infuse yourself with this motivation? You would go through that, really reflecting and thinking that you can live and talk this way: abandoning false speech, being a truth speaker; abandoning malicious speech, not repeating what one has heard that harms others (and don't make up things that harm others); speech which is reconciling those who are divided and keeps together those who are friends; words that rejoice in peace, love peace, delight in peace; speaking words that make for peace; avoiding harsh speech; speaking what is pleasing to the ear, words that reach the heart and are pleasing to many; and abandoning idle speech.
Being motivated to speak at the right time, I think, is a hugely important thing. I noticed that myself when I was first looking at all this—this sense of being in a hurry to speak, like I had something to say and had to say it soon and quickly, or there was pressure to say it. If there was social tension going on with people, needing to kind of get it out there and explain or do something about it. "I feel frustrated, I feel uncomfortable, I have to do something."
To learn there's a right time to speak something. Some things are better spoken at other times than now. Is it okay not to say it when you feel like it needs to be said, just because you feel the pressure? If the reason you're speaking is not to relieve pressure but to try to do some good for everyone involved, the timing is going to be quite important. So wait until it seems like the right time. Sometimes it could just be minutes, sometimes days, sometimes longer. A few times in my life, I've waited four years for the time when it was the right time to speak, and I knew that if I spoke before that, it simply wasn't going to work. Even though I felt justified and had a really good cause, having a good cause and being justified has no good consequence if it has no impact. Why waste your words? Why bother?
One reason not to bother is that maybe you don't have that many opportunities to make a difference, and so you might want to try to save it to the time when you really can make a difference. Sometimes the right time has been when I'm really ready, waiting for myself to be ready, because even though I'm right, I'm angry. I've learned that I've made mistakes in communicating with people when I've been angry, and it's been hard sometimes to hold my tongue because there's also pressure to speak. And if on top of that I feel the cause is right—"they deserve it now"—that pressure and those ideas are not necessarily the ones that should carry the day.
So you have the ability to track this, to see this, and to ask yourself, "Is this the right time to speak? To be a speaker whose words are to be treasured?" That's a pretty high bar. I was thinking about this, and there is a saying that goes something like, "If it's not beneficial, don't say it." Maybe not speaking is sometimes a really wise thing. And maybe what's to be treasured is not brilliant words or beautiful words, but what's to be treasured is not causing harm, not causing difficulties, not stirring the social pot. Maybe what should be treasured is not speaking if what you're saying is not beneficial. Why speak if what you're going to say hurts anyone?
For someone who's a meditator, there's sometimes this reference point of learning to be still and silent. Not just silent with our mouths, but much more deeply quiet and silent with the mind. A stillness, a softness, a gentleness, a warmth of just being still within that can feel so wonderful and so rich. It's a reference point to stay close to in social situations. Not to be shut down and not speak, but to be able to ride that edge between not saying what is harmful and staying close to what is beneficial.
If it's not beneficial, maybe don't say it. If it is not beneficial, take a deep look at what's really going on for you. Perhaps what is beneficial is not to say it the way you're going to say it, but to find a different way of saying what you were about to say that brings everyone together.
For example, if your roommate has left the dishes piled up in the kitchen for the thousandth time, and you clearly have an agreement about keeping the dishes clean. You have a good cause, you're justified, you're angry, and the roommate deserves to hear your wrath. "How could you be such a lousy dishwasher? How could you be so thoughtless?" You really lay it at them. Maybe that's not going to help anything. Maybe that really is not going to create the right conditions to go forward, so don't say it.
But simply being silent is not healthy either sometimes. So then we take time to figure out the right time and the right way to say: "Dear roommate, when I come home and find all the dishes in the sink, I get frightened. It really frightens me because I value our sharing this home, I value our relationship, and I feel so much sadness and sometimes anger and hurt when I see those dishes one more time. Because of how frightened I am around this issue, I wonder if we can have a talk about this."
You'll probably get a radically different answer. If you stand tall, look the person in the eye and say, "You know what, this frightens me," with all your strength—actually, more strength is needed for that conversation than is needed to be angry. So it isn't that I'm suggesting being silent, but if it's not beneficial, maybe don't say what you're about to say, and maybe there's another way you can find.
In this way, I hope that our care with speech in the democracy of the United States—where everyone in a certain way is supposed to be a leader—that the passage I read is instructions to you. To the degree to which every individual is a kind of a leader, a contributor to the welfare of our society as a whole, no one is not capable of somehow supporting our society. It can spread out from how we speak.
Use whatever mindfulness you're developing and growing to turn it towards the whole world of communication. How you speak, what you speak, what motivates you to speak, what you try to accomplish when you speak, and can you, by this care, be a leader to create a better society? A society in which we care for each other, we respect each other, and in which we feel like we're here to support each other in this large human family that we are.
Those are my thoughts for today. We have about seven or eight minutes if someone would like to ask questions or comments.
Questions and Answers
Question: Hi, my name is Beth, and this may be off topic, but my concern is, if it's the right time to speak—the other person perhaps has asked me to speak—and I don't have the courage to speak, and it causes a problem. Do you have any thoughts?
Gil: Sometimes it's useful to turn it around to really understand some things. Turning it around for you is, you don't have the courage. What do you have here? Compassion? Oh, that's nice. They've asked me for a reason, probably because they're in pain. But I suspect that if you say you don't have courage, it means something like you have fear. If you identify this fear, does that change what you want to look at or how you want to consider it?
Questioner: It does. I recognize the fear and I'm just stuck. I'm just afraid, and I just don't return their call or email.
Gil: So if fear is a regular part of a person's life, then it deserves a deep look. Sometimes, with the help of someone you can talk to about it regularly—which in our society often is a therapist, but it could be a friend or your journal—you try to begin understanding fear and working with it. It's a whole interesting, valuable, and noble thing to do, to really spend time with it. It might be that you're not ready to have a conversation until you've become wiser and more at terms with your fear.
If you really need to have that conversation, if the person is a friend, sometimes when a person asks you to speak about something, explain to your friend: "Thank you for asking, but I'm actually afraid." Or maybe if that's too scary to say: "It's actually kind of awkward for me to speak. I don't have the background or the skill. Before we do the conversation you're asking for, I think I need some support or some understanding of what's going on here." And if it's the right friend, they might then think, "Okay, we have to figure out a way together and be prepared for that conversation."
Questioner: That's great. I have a Dharma buddy now who's very wise and I just never brought it up with her, so I think if I have a conversation or two or three about this I can...
Gil: Ten or eleven. [Laughter] I say that out of respect. These things can be very deep inside of us, things like fear or social fear, and I think we need to have a lot of respect for it, care for it, and give it its due.
Question: This is a related question. I'm just thinking about the role of courage and speech in public life right now, and how there seems to be a dearth of that among our public leaders. What you've said about looking at our own fears seems really helpful, but I'm wondering if you in your own practice, or in the Buddhist texts you've read, have encountered anything that might speak to speaking to power? Saying what's uncomfortable on the public stage, saying what's uncomfortable in a room where the person who is leading is not leading in the ways that you've described?
Gil: Yeah, I think what comes to mind is to know oneself well, so that we know why we're afraid to speak and what makes it difficult for us. Because there's a whole lot of things that can make it difficult. One can have a lot to do with ideas of who we are and what we're protecting in terms of our self-concept and how we want people to see us. This idea that we want everyone to like us—you know, that's overrated. But if we're constantly operating on that and trying to operate as if we're supposed to be liked, or we want to show ourselves as being a certain kind of person, the whole complex around self is something that's very important in Buddhist practice to look at. I think that would probably cover a lot of different areas.
The other is to learn to be comfortable with discomfort. If you're speaking truth to power, saying what you think is true and needs to be said, and everyone in the audience now hates you—I think normally that would be uncomfortable. But if you've learned to be comfortable with discomfort, within reason, then it can be easier. "This is unfortunate, I didn't plan to have this happen, this is really uncomfortable, but I know when I'm uncomfortable. I'll just feel my body, ground myself in my feet, and not spin out in my thoughts that predict the future." Because my prediction of the future in this kind of situation just makes me more and more anxious. And so I think, "This is not the time to do a lot of thinking, except I think I'm going to try to figure out where the closest exit is that might be reasonable." [Laughter]
Okay, so we should stop. I'm sorry, but if you want to ask me afterwards I'm very happy to stay, but I don't want to keep people beyond our designated time. So thank you very much, and may your speech be a gift to the world.
Suttas: The ancient discourses or teachings of the Buddha. ↩︎
Dharma: A Sanskrit word with multiple meanings, often referring to the teachings of the Buddha, the truth, or the fundamental nature of reality. ↩︎
Ten Dhammas (Rajadhamma): The ten behaviors or virtues of a ruler in Buddhist teachings. ↩︎