Moon Pointing

Thinking That Quiets Thinking

Date:
2019-11-10
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-18 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Thinking That Quiets Thinking

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Thinking That Quiets Thinking

Good morning. It's possible that the title of this talk could be Thinking That Quiets Thinking—the use of thinking to help the mind become quieter. There's a story of an expert, a skilled painter, who painted a tiger. He was busy painting it close up, and at some point, he stepped back to look at the work and was so frightened—it was so realistic—that he ran away.

Recently, there's a story of Gil needing to plan ahead for something a little bit dangerous. I was thinking out the scenarios that needed to be planned for, and then at some point, it got pulled into a hypothetical scenario around this danger. It got pulled into it like a fantasy, as opposed to methodically planning ahead. I wasn't in there very long. After a minute or so, I recognized that I'd been pulled into this fantasy of danger. What was interesting was not that I was caught up in that fantasy, but that it wasn't just an image. It wasn't just words. There was a little bit of trepidation involved because of this wonderfully realistic tiger I'd painted in my mind. I could feel that it affected my body. I felt a little bit of fear and tightness, and a little bit more vulnerable, just for one minute. It wasn't very dramatic, and I caught it. I realized that I'd gone off the planning mode and what I needed to take care of, and got lost in a little fantasy. So I changed gears, which was easy enough.

But it made me reflect on how not everyone can catch themselves so early. I wasn't able to when I was younger. The idea of just being lost in these thoughts, caught up in these kinds of ideas chronically... For some people, fantasies about the past or the future are more real than the present. The reason for that is the way in which we internalize it. Our fantasies, images, or emotions—all this stuff gets our expectations, our hopes, our sense of self. All these things can come up together as a complex. Sometimes this happens more so with fantasy, imagination, or being in our thoughts than it can in regular life. If those kinds of thoughts are not—to use a word of the Buddha's—beautiful thoughts, but harmful thoughts, then they harm us. Chronic rumination is a leading cause of depression, for example. And if those ruminations are tinged or filled with fear, it's no wonder that people are chronically anxious, because these kinds of thoughts are feeding us; our conditionings are affecting us.

So, one of the important aspects of mindfulness practice is to get wise about thinking. Not only wise, but also intelligent about it. It took me a long time. I've been doing this practice since I was twenty, and when I started, no one said this explicitly, but I got the message that you weren't supposed to use your intelligence. You were just supposed to show up and be present. In fact, showing up and being present was quite powerful for me, so it worked. I did a lot of meditation, and it was really great. But at some point, it occurred to me: here we're trying to be present for everything, allow for everything in a certain way, but I checked my intelligence at the door. Why not include that as part of it? Why not use a certain degree of thinking, understanding, or exploration to help with the meditation practice?

Now, it's easy, when we hear "use your intelligence in meditation," to drift off and just think even more and spin out even more. But the art of this is to use your thinking, use your intelligence for the purposes of quieting the mind. Not numbing it, but quieting the mind so it's sharper, clearer, and you can see what's happening in the present moment in a very clear, present, engaged way, without the filter of a lot of thoughts, projections, expectations, and hopes that we add on top of things.

Don't just use your intelligence to be an engineer of meditation and think more and more. Use it to say: What would be helpful for you so that you're more able to be disentangled from your experience? How do you be present so you're not so caught and lost in your thoughts, and are really here in the present? How do you use thinking to quiet your thinking? How do you use thinking so it doesn't obscure the present moment for you?

Forms of Thinking

That's a little bit the task of this talk. I think it's helpful to understand that there are many forms of thinking. Without appreciating all the different types of thinking, sometimes meditation instructions can be understood too simplistically. The most simplistic, and maybe harmful, way of understanding it is that you're not supposed to think in meditation—that somehow thinking is wrong or bad. I've gotten that message even from some of my teachers.

I had one teacher who I had a question for, and I started my question with the phrase, "What do you think?" It was innocent enough. "What do you think about that?" I don't think I finished the rest of the sentence. The teacher shot back and said, "I try not to think." Okay, so that was kind of the end of the conversation, and now it's a story in a Dharma talk. [Laughter] I think there is some wisdom to what the teacher was saying, but I think it can also give the wrong message that you're not supposed to think at all.

There are certain kinds of thinking which are not helpful for meditation, and to be able to recognize that kind of thinking and then be wise about how to engage it or free yourself from it is good. Then there are certain kinds of thinking which are helpful, and to be able to recognize how they're helpful and use what's helpful for meditation is a good thing. Having a one-policy rule about thoughts is not very helpful.

I like to think of thoughts as a many species, having different intensities, different amounts of energy and agitation as part of them. The most energetic, the coarsest, the most agitating tend to be the ones called discursive thinking. That's where we're having a discourse with someone. Either it's a monologue and you're holding forth, or you're having a dialogue and you're filling in both sides of the conversation, which is not very fair to the other person! Or you're explaining something, or you're telling yourself a story. Like when I was caught in my little dangerous story, spinning a tale that went on and on for a little bit.

This usually has nothing to do with what's happening in the present moment. Most often it has to do with the past, the future, or something which is not present here and now. It could even be fantasy; it's not even anywhere in the world. It uses a lot of imagination—imaginary conversations, imaginary people who are listening to us, imaginary scenarios. It can be quite captivating. One of the reasons why these things can be very interesting is that sometimes they're very entertaining. Sometimes what we fantasize is more entertaining than the present moment, so we might as well go off and think.

Another reason why they're quite captivating is that what we're thinking about feels consequential. When you fantasize or envision stories about things that are dangerous—some people specialize in that and spend a lot of time planning around something connected to fear and anxiety, worrying about what's going to happen tomorrow or the next day—our survival feels like it is at stake. We get sucked into those fantasies because it seems so consequential.

Also, one of the reasons we get sucked into them is that we're often the primary character in the discourse. It somehow reflects on us. If we're having a conversation with someone, I've been involved in rehearsing conversations I'm going to have in order to make a good impression or to be right. Or rehearsing conversations I had, in order to be right. "I should have said that," you know? There have been times in my life, unfortunately, when I was trying to think of the right cutting word to get back at someone. "If I had only said that!" So I'm a character. It's my ego, my idea of who I want to be seen as, how I present myself, how I was hurt, how I can be better, how I can be improved. I'm a major character in it. For better or for worse, that's very attractive to the mind because we're an interesting person to ourselves, one way or the other. That's the glue that keeps us there.

Waking Up from Discursive Thought

But to be caught up in discursive thought is not very helpful for calming and stilling the mind. It's not helpful to be able to see clearly what's going on. I noticed at some point in my life that when I had a grudge with someone, I was quite capable of thinking about the grudge, thinking about what I'm going to say, and thinking about who that person is. But I was operating with assumptions that were not very accurate. I had a caricature of the person in my mind, and I was reacting and talking to them as if they were that caricature. I learned at some point that I did not have a very good track record of viewing a person realistically whom I had a grudge with.

So I now have the practice, within reason, to go find the person and be in their presence, because then my caricature kind of breaks up. Especially if I can engage in a conversation with them, and even more so if I can be a little bit kind to them, give them the benefit of the doubt, or treat them decently with, "How are you? What's happening with you?" It helps me because it breaks me out of the mold of seeing the person through the filter of a caricature or my grudge. And then, if there's a valid grudge that needs to be talked about, I talk about it with the person. As long as I'm talking to the person about it only in my fantasy, it's really not realistic. It's kind of a waste of time. To learn this is so useful. Staying in the fantasy is not helpful; it doesn't help me see clearly in the situation.

So, we learn how to step out of that, to wake up from it. Some people who have practiced mindfulness enough have the clear mindful recognition of what they're doing. "Oh, that's what's happening." That is enough to break the spell. We wake up from the spell of our fantasy: "Oh, wait a minute, here I am, and I was thinking about something." Sometimes being mindful is enough, but sometimes it's not. Sometimes there are other options of what to do.

Subtle Thinking and Recognition

So there's this very coarse thinking, what I call discursive thinking. A more subtle kind of thinking is to be thinking about what's happening in the present moment. You're connected to the present moment, here and now, so the thoughts are much simpler. They're not involved fantasies or ideas; they're actually recognizing what's happening.

Like yesterday, I was teaching here, and I was thinking that some of the lights were on and some of the lights were not on. I was wondering, "Should I turn the other set of lights on? Are they doing okay? Maybe it's nice to have it a little bit dark when we're meditating for the day. What's the right way the lights should be?" I was having thoughts like that, and it stretched out over the day. It wasn't as fast as I just gave it to you now, but it was like, "What should I do? How should we be here?" Those thoughts didn't have a lot of power. They didn't have a lot of "me" in them. I wasn't thinking about how people see me in the best light. It was relatively settled and calm. There wasn't a lot of agitation. I was just having these simple thoughts about what was going on here.

Then there can be even simpler thoughts that are quieter, which are simple recognition thoughts of what's actually happening, with no concern about what's supposed to happen or what can happen. I can sit here and feel that, as I'm sitting here, my hands are warm, or my hands are cool. I can sit here and feel that my breath is a little bit tight. And as I sit there, there's a thought: "Oh, the hands are warm. The hands are cool. It's tight in there."

Or I can sit here and have a thought, "I'm spending a lot of time in fantasy. This is not useful." A thought that says "this is not useful" when I'm trying to meditate—to have thoughts about fantasy—is actually a wise thought. It's part of the solution to being caught up in fantasy. If you bat away every thought that you have and don't allow yourself that thought, then you don't benefit from the wisdom of it. Saying, "You know, [unintelligible] is not so useful here. I wonder if there's something more useful to think about?"

Using Imagination Strategically

Sometimes you fall into a fantasy again even before you answer the question. Then, after a while, you wake up. "Oh, wait a minute, caught up again." That happens a few times, and you say, "I need to do something different here. I can't even figure out what to do. Why don't I create a different fantasy? Why not fight fire with fire? Why don't I use my imagination to come up with a different scenario that engages my mind and connects me to the meditation I'm doing?"

Let's imagine I want to stay focused on my breath. Let's imagine that I'm coming up against my last breath before I die. In two or three breaths from now, I'm going to be laying on my deathbed, and this is going to be my very last breath. How do I want to be with that breath? Well, why waste my time having a fantasy about some crazy, abstract thing? This is actually important. This meditation... it's an existentially important issue we're up against. The issues of life and death. That's really what we're trying to address in meditation: how to find a deep sense of peace that sustains us, even in the moments of dying and the last breath. I better be there for that. That might galvanize us. "Okay, wow. I better be here now."

It's kind of like a friend of mine who used to sleep a lot in meditation. He was in Thailand, and his teacher told him to go meditate on the edge of the well, facing the well. That galvanized him! He wasn't going to sleep anymore. [Laughter]

I don't know if you like that fantasy about your last breath, but it's using a fantasy to help you show up, collect yourself, and be here. Suddenly it gets your attention. Or maybe a fantasy about your last breath might just really spin you out. So you have to use your intelligence: "You know, that didn't work. I know better than that."

Let's do something simpler. Say you're meditating at IMC[1]. Let me imagine that I'm meditating at IMC. You're meditating at IMC, but imagine it. Imagine the room at IMC, the big window. Imagine yourself on your cushion or chair you're sitting on. You're using your imagination to imagine what's actually happening with your eyes closed. It's not exactly meditation, but it begins gathering your attention, drawing you in to be here. Is there some way you can use your imagination to overcome being lost in imagination?

I sometimes use my imagination around the breathing. I love water and I love waves, and sometimes I've imagined that my in-breath and out-breath are the waves going up and down. I imagine I'm floating on the waves of the rising and passing of my breaths. It's imagination to do that; however, it's sometimes a better thing to do in meditation than the alternative, if I'm spinning off a lot. It feels very nice. I'm connected to the rhythm of my breathing. It's flowing along moving nicely, and it gathers me in. It gets me interested. It works as a counter-force to the mind that wants to spin off.

Then I use my fantasy to be there, be present. Then at some point, I know what I'm doing. That's part of the intelligent usage of this: I know what I'm doing. I'm using it strategically to help me calm the mind, quiet the mind, and get it connected to the present moment. I watch as I'm doing this: is this fantasy supporting me to let the thinking mind quiet down to become calmer? Or is there a way I could use that fantasy to calm my mind, maybe make it slower or calmer?

Adjusting the Intensity of Thought

Then there's the simple recognition of what's happening here. I recognize my hands are hot and cold. I recognize my breathing is tight or loose. I recognize, you know, there's a real thought for me that says that how I tell myself, how I explain to myself what is happening with my thoughts, can be done at different mental intensities and speeds. I can do it fast, like I could be in a hurry. Or I could slow it down. Or I could speak in a normal thinking voice, or I could use a whispering thinking voice. You can adjust the tone, the quality, the intensity, the loudness of how you're thinking. If you think in images, maybe you can change some of the images so they're a little bit more diffuse, more quiet.

One of the adjustments I like to give as a simile: sometimes talk to yourself like you talk to the librarian in a very quiet library. Lean over the desk and say, "I'm looking for my breath. Where's my breath? Where is my breath? Oh, there. There is an in-breath. There is an out-breath. Oh, look at that."

The idea is to just recognize where there's a thought. At some point when the mind is fairly quiet and still, it can be really powerful to recognize a new thought that's arising—a thought that's not part of the practice—and say to yourself, "It's just a thought."

To say that with a fantasy is not quite as accurate, because the fantasy can create all these emotional feelings inside, and then it's more than just a thought. That's why they're so dangerous. But for a simple thought, saying "just a thought" can pop the bubble or the authority of it.

For example, I'm sitting here meditating and I recognize my breathing is tight. It's kind of held. Every time I inhale, I feel a push up against the earth, a little bit tight and held. Then I have this thought: "In New Age California, that's a bad breath. It's supposed to be relaxed and open and spacious, and the last thing you should do is admit it to everyone." That silly thought comes up, and I say, "Oh, that's just a thought. I don't give it any authority. I don't invest it in anything. Just a thought."

If I don't say "just a thought," I might lean into it, believe it, and get caught up in it a little bit. But when the mind is quiet enough and a new thought arises, sometimes having the thought that says, "Just a thought," can pop the bubble and keep us from getting caught up.

Mental Notes and Subtle Adjustments

At some point, as we get settled down in meditation, calmer and more focused, we're able to cruise in the present moment. We're staying in the groove of the present moment. At that point, thinking becomes more and more an adjunct to the practice.

For example, an adjunct thought would be, as you're staying with your breathing and feeling the breath, you have the very simple thought, "Breathing in," when you're breathing in. "Breathing out," when you're breathing out. It's like having a little coach on the side that's cheering you on. "Stay there, it's okay. Stay with the in, feel it. Stay in the groove. Stay in the present moment with the breath." Using a little word like "in-breath, out-breath" can help you stay. This is especially helpful if you find yourself slipping off all the time into thinking. "Let me use a thought to help me stay in the groove, stay in the present moment."

In mindfulness, we call these mental notes. Just noting what's happening in the present moment: sound, hearing. Itch, itching. Breath, breathing. Thought, thinking. It isn't so much that the word is so important in and of itself; it's a way of using a thought to keep us in the groove of the present. Stay right here, as opposed to letting thinking carry us away.

As the mind gets more subtle, sometimes we can use that kind of one-word thought to stay here. Occasionally, I've actually said something to myself like, "Gil, stay here. Stay. Come on, stay right here." Because I'm there in the present moment, riding those waves, but I don't feel completely settled yet, and I just need a [unintelligible] "It's okay, Gil, stay. You can do it." At certain points, that way of thinking supports me, keeps me going, keeps me involved.

Sometimes I have little thoughts of experimentation. For example, I might have the thought, "Your mind is drifting off a lot. Let me take a look at this. What's happening?" I see that I'm actually planning a lot, and the planning is being fueled by anxiety. So I have the thought, "Gil, there's anxiety." "What would happen now if you brought your attention to the anxiety? Where is that anxiety? Oh, it's a little thought. Where's that anxiety? Oh, that's where it is, it's in my chest." "How does it feel?" It feels like agitation. "What would happen if I just held my attention there?" So I hold my attention there. There are very subtle thoughts that go on, pointing us to what we can do. "This is where you can pay attention."

Or, if I'm just with the breathing, I might have a thought, "This is good, I'm with my breath, that's nice. But I'd like to be a little more concentrated. Can I be even more still with it?" I've learned that if I really stay present for the exhale all the way to the very end of the exhale, I get stiller. I get quieter. So I have this thought: "Gil, I wonder if this is the time to do that long exhale thing, and really stay there." For some people, those are a cognitive use—a cognition, a kind of use of thinking.

The Space Between Thoughts

As it gets quieter and quieter, thoughts might occur to you: "Maybe I don't need to think anymore." And thoughts go away, and you get really quiet, or seemingly very quiet. One of the many pleasures of meditation is to have so little investment, so little energy going into our thinking, so little interest in our thinking, that a thought arises or passes by and it's like a very thin veil. The imagery used in Buddhism is like a little cloud in an empty sky. It has no more substance or weight than a cloud.

This is opposed to some thoughts being the heaviest things you could ever carry. We talk about carrying a burden. Where does that burden live? It probably lives very much in the thoughts we carry. It's the thoughts that give weight to these big problems we have. So it is a great pleasure to just have a thought drift by, and to realize you're not relating to it or identifying with it. It's just a soft thought.

That can be very educational. Very few people ever ask themselves, "What is thinking?" People just think. They think what they think is important. The important thing is to question what you're thinking, to look at the process of thinking, to question the authority of our thoughts, to question how much we invest in our thoughts.

Have the thought: "I wonder what it's like in between my thoughts? What's it like to be alive and present and aware in between thoughts?" For some people, thoughts are a mile a minute, one after the other, continuous. But as they quiet down in meditation, there start to be gaps. Maybe not long gaps, but what is in that gap? What's that like to be alive? Who am I when I don't use a thought to answer the question? That's a wonderful question: Who are you when you don't use thoughts to answer the question?

Another interesting thought is: How much space is there outside of your thinking? Is your thinking localized, or does your thinking fill the universe? And if it doesn't fill the universe, how much space is there beyond it? That can turn the mind a little. There's more going on in this universe than my thinking. What is that "more"? In our psychophysical being, we're much more than thoughts. What is that "more"?

The Intelligence of the Body

I'll end with an analogy that I'm fond of. It's possible to divide, to some degree, the mind and the body. In that division, thinking belongs more to the mind than to the body. The intellect seems more of a mind thing. We have intelligence, the intellect works in all kinds of ways. We have images and thoughts and words that we tell ourselves to figure things out, and do planning. We try to process our lives through our thinking, sometimes unsuccessfully.

The body has intelligence as well. The body understands things. The body can process our lives, sometimes better than our mind can. Our body is intelligent. However, the body doesn't speak. The body is silent. The body doesn't have the words or the images that the mind creates. Our attention tends to go to the place where it's loudest, and the mind is the loudest.

How about starting to give more attention to that which can't speak, but is just as intelligent and has just as much to teach you as the mind? Have the thought: "Let's discover. Let's pay attention. Let's listen to that in me which is not thinking, and see what it has to say. See what's there."

That's a way to support becoming quieter, because maybe you have to let the mind become quiet in order to listen to the quiet of the body. Maybe your body is a library that you let the mind become quiet for, so it can listen.

Or maybe the body is a temple that we contemplate with a quiet mind. The word contemplate comes from the word temple—templum in Latin. So enter the temple of your body with the quietest, most still mind. And if you're thinking in your temple, think quietly and reverently, lovingly, caringly. As you listen and sense and feel what is not your thinking, as you think about that, contemplate it. Think about it in sacred ways. May you enter the temple of your heart.

Thank you.

We're going to have tea in a few minutes. What I'd like to ask you, if you'd be willing, is to turn to one or two people next to you, say hello, and introduce yourself. And see if there was one idea from this talk that somehow interested you, or you found perplexing, or useful.



  1. IMC: Insight Meditation Center in Redwood City, California, where Gil Fronsdal is the guiding teacher. ↩︎