Moon Pointing

Hatred and the End of Hatred

Date:
2019-08-11
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-18 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Hatred and the End of Hatred

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Hatred and the End of Hatred

From time to time, things happen in the world that have a big impact on many of us, and certainly on me. Sometimes when this happens, I feel that it deserves some talking about in this setting, but I feel unprepared to do so. Sometimes I'm just impelled to do it anyway. A variation of this is that often enough, what happens is related to hate. I feel like I should really talk about hate, but I feel unprepared. It seems like such a big, deep topic. I don't know how to talk about hate in this context, and so I've come to that kind of place again. I still feel unprepared to talk about it, but I can't do anything else. So maybe this is an exploration of the topic—a very important topic for our society.

The way into the exploration that comes naturally to me is to refer back to these ancient teachings of the Buddha and look at what he had to say about the topic of hate. Hopefully, that helps our exploration and consideration of it.

The word for hate, which could equally be translated as hostility, is dosa[1]. One of the most famous occurrences of this particular word is a verse from a four-line poem in the Dhammapada[2], which has had an illustrious history down through the centuries and a big impact right up to the 20th century. I wrote a newsletter article about this verse, the Buddha's poem on peace, last year. It goes something like this: "Hate is never overcome by hate; only by love is hate overcome. This is the ancient truth, the ancient teaching." As a little soundbite, that's very powerful. If people take it in a certain way, it has a powerful lesson, especially if we think about how much hate there is and how hate begets more hate.

Non-Hate

In this poem of peace, the word that is usually translated as "love" ("only by love is hate overcome") is not actually love. It's just that that's what we want it to be, and it's reasonable that it's translated as love, but the literal word in the ancient language is "non-hate" (adosa). It's very common to be understood in this ancient language that when there's a negative prefix "a" in front of a word, it implies the positive opposite. It doesn't imply simply the absence of something.

The opposite of hate seems like "love" is a pretty obvious candidate, so that's nice. However, by saying "non-hate," it's implying something positive, but it actually doesn't define it very exactly. It includes a range of concepts: maybe generosity, maybe kindness rather than love, maybe respect, maybe appreciation. There is a variety of different states that fit into the category of non-hate. When we have a word like love—even though love is kind of vague in English—we know somehow it still specifies that it's something, and then we feel like we have to fit that thing and make ourselves into that thing. But what's beautiful and profound about referring to the negative, the absence of something, is asking: in the absence of hate, in the absence of defilements, in the absence of attachment, what arises? What comes?

One of the marvelous things about meditation is that it can be, for some people, the shedding of preoccupation, the shedding of attachments, the quieting of the mind that's caught up in its hindrances, desires, and aversions. The mind gets quiet and peaceful. Even the usual conceits around self and self-concern fall away, and a person can feel quite peaceful and content. They could say, "Yes, there's no hate now." But then it makes room for something to arise from within. Maybe that won't be love. Maybe it's respect, maybe it's generosity, maybe who knows what the circumstance calls for us to feel and to be. To not specify what it has to look like carries a lot of wisdom. For people who have the ability to let go deeply, they can allow the deeper part of our inner life to bubble up into this field that's not obscured by things like greed, hatred, or delusion.

The Three Roots

Greed, hatred, and delusion[3] are considered in the Buddhist teachings to be the fundamental roots, the fundamental causes or conditions for all unethical behavior. If it happens to be that once upon a time any of you did anything unethical, chances are that in the background of that was greed, hate, or delusion—one of them, two of them, or maybe all three of them operating. If you read about unethical things going on in the world, from the Buddha's analysis, not far beneath the surface are the psychological conditions of greed, hatred, or delusion operating in some person or some people.

Part of the Dharma practice is to delve deep inside oneself to discover what those roots are. They're called roots, and they're also called poisons. That's a powerful metaphor because it speaks to how these things are poisons, and you can see this especially with hate. Hate is a poison; it poisons the person who has it, and it poisons much of the world around it. In fact, part of what's happening in our society is the spreading and growing of hate. It's almost an industry that is built around perpetuating, developing, enhancing, and creating hate, not just in this country but in many countries in the world. It's a poison that can spread and spread.

The ancient poem says hate is never overcome by hate, but it's easy enough to be the recipient of hate and then to hate in return. There, the division happens. There, the perpetuation happens. The poison that has begun to spread is doing its work in society if we respond to hate with hate.

There were people who encountered the Buddha and said to him, "I see who you are now, you're embodying loving-kindness." The Buddha said, "No, don't say that. But if you say that I embody the opposite of loving-kindness—I embody the absence of ill will—I allow you to say that." Here, he doesn't want to be narrowed down to being someone who is love or loving-kindness. It's a little bit jarring, a little cognitive dissonance to some of us, that the Buddha would say, "No, I'm not loving, don't define me that way." But he is willing to be defined by the absence of ill will.

I see this as a call to really do our own personal inner work, to get to the bottom of our ill will, empty ourselves of it, free ourselves of it, and then see what wants to flow out. That work wouldn't get done if the Buddha had said, "Oh yes, I'm so loving," and then we thought, "Oh, we're supposed to be loving like the Buddha, let's put on the loving persona." That covers over the fact that inside there might be all this ill will. With a tremendous force of will, some people can cover over the deeper poisons that exist in them, and it can stay hidden for years.

One of the sad things you occasionally see is people who have had a successful public persona for years, but then they start getting senility, and they can't keep it up. That surface persona falls away, and lo and behold, there's all this venom and poison underneath. It's a shock to people to start seeing this. There's also the opposite: people start getting Alzheimer's, and they just get more and more loving. It's like they've done their work; they don't have that inside. A friend of mine went to see a very accomplished person who was the president of the American Psychological Association. They had known each other for decades. My friend knocked on the door, and this man opened the door, looked at them, and said, "I don't have a clue who you are, but you're welcome in my house."

Acknowledging Our Own Hostility

This idea of doing the inner work and getting to the bottom of all this requires a lot of courage and a lot of honesty. It requires the willingness to look inside and identify that there is hostility, hatred, or ill will present in ourselves. "Hate" is a big word, and my guess is a lot of us don't go around thinking of ourselves as hating people. But if we think of the word as hostility—even the most minor hostility—we can look closer.

Now, for the last few weeks, I have had a wonderfully complex relationship with ants in my kitchen. I am doing my darndest to not have them in the kitchen without harming them, and they're so persistent. I have certain things in little moats of water, and yesterday they managed to get across the water. I don't know if they were swimming. Some of them are dead, but some swam across. One friend said they probably make little bridges by holding onto each other. I don't know what they do. But there's certainly impatience that comes up for me, and annoyance. If I look carefully at the impatience and annoyance—I don't want to admit it publicly to all of you, but I think that underneath that is some degree of hostility. It's so wonderfully complex, and I get to look at it.

That's a small thing. But we are talking about things that are bigger, like feelings we have towards people. This is such a big thing in the news right now, because we have people killing other people out of tremendous hostility and hate. This hostility and hate are being praised and supported. There's a whole community of people for whom hating "the other"—hating immigrants, hating all kinds of races and classes of people—is their language. There are websites where people meet, and those who study these communities say that if a person indicates any willingness to not have pure hate for the other, they get pushed out. That's how they bond, and so it just gets supported more and more. It's not surprising that some people get pushed into a deluded mental state where that's all they're thinking about, and at some point, they get pushed over the edge.

The Fire of Hate and the Gift of Anger

An analogy for hate given in the ancient texts is that hate is like a fire that burns the fuel it depends on. Think of a grass fire: it burns up the grass, and when the grass has burned out, the fire goes out. It's burning up the very thing it depends on. So, how does hate burn ourselves? Does it burn us up? Some of the most dramatic examples we've had are when a killer gets killed. It seems like humanity has burned up inside a person who does these things. The poem says hate will never end with hate; only by non-hate will hate come to an end. How do we meet hate with non-hate?

There is a story of a man who was hostile and angry towards the Buddha. The Buddha didn't just float on a cloud where everything was nice around him. One man came to him, saying angry things and giving the Buddha a piece of his mind. The Buddha apparently just sat quietly and listened. When it was over, he said to the man, "If you go to visit someone's home, like a friend, and you come with a gift and offer the gift, but the host doesn't take it, who does the gift then belong to?" The man said, "Oh, then it's still mine." In the same way, the Buddha said, "I don't accept your anger."

I imagine that could be said in a calm, relaxed way, leaving the anger without its desired impact. It leaves the person carrying it, feeling it. I've known people who have struggled with anger or resentment for years towards someone. Often, I've talked to meditators, and they realize in meditation that the person they're resentful toward has long since forgotten them. Even though the angry person is regularly conjuring anger, they realize, "Wait a minute, who's being damaged here? I wanted to get revenge, but after all these decades, I'm the one who's harmed." As some people say, you're doing the work for your enemy. The enemy wants to get to you, and they got to you by having you constantly live in hate and anger. Seeing it that way reframes it and takes away the rationale for living with hate when we realize how much we're hurting ourselves.

Frustrated Desire

It's not easy to do the inner work of getting to the roots to really see what's going on with hate. In the ancient Buddhist tradition, they point to two primary causes for hate. One is frustrated desire. The idea that "I want something, I need it, I have to have it," and not being able to get it, is a huge source of the momentum of hatred in society. Many of the people who do mass shootings are young men in their late teens or early twenties, and it seems there's a lot of hatred towards women as part of it. It seems part of that hatred is not having loving relationships with women. This frustration builds into anger and hatred.

Underneath all that, we have to look at desire. What is the nature of desire, and how do we relate to frustrated desire? One of the great benefits of doing a regular meditation practice is that all the different flavors of who you are get processed. If you only meditate when you feel good, you get your ideal persona. If you only meditate when you feel bad, you get another impression. But if you do it regularly, you get the cross-section.

A really good thing about meditation that we don't say publicly in advertisements is being uncomfortable. When you get a cross-section of who you are, it's phenomenally important that you have an uncomfortable meditation. You might have a meditation that's really restless, where you're filled with venom, greed, impatience, and frustration. When that happens, you should say, "Wow, it's finally happened. Now my work begins."

Learning to sit with that involves learning how to make your peace with it rather than letting those feelings motivate you to think, act, and feel in unhealthy ways. Learn to step back, observe, be present, and breathe with it without it getting the upper hand. You have the upper hand simply by observing it. Learning to be comfortable with discomfort is phenomenally important. When frustrated desire comes up, we learn how to be present for it without it impelling us to do things we later regret—before it spills over into hate or ill will. If we can be at ease with difficulties, we won't be as easily pushed. I encourage you to embrace uncomfortable meditations, stay with them, and see them through.

Fear

Another important cause for hate is fear. People get afraid of being hurt or afraid of a threat. Pushing things away that are threatening is a deep instinct. But if it's an instinct that comes out of fear, what happens if we change our relationship to fear? When fear arises in meditation, don't be in a hurry to get rid of it, fix it, analyze it, or solve it. First, learn to sit with fear. Have fear be present without you being identified with it, without it saturating you so fully that you are "the one who is afraid."

When fear arises, we have the capacity to bring mindfulness and presence to it, rather than it automatically triggering hatred or other unhealthy reactions. Learning to sit quietly and wisely with fear is also a task of meditation. If you feel afraid in your meditation someday, you should congratulate yourself: "Finally, it's my turn." For some of you, your turn with fear will come sooner or later. Just being able to breathe with fear, hold it in the body, and let it be there as a phenomenon—as opposed to it being my fear that I'm reacting to—is powerful.

Creating the Change

Being able to understand ourselves more deeply is an appropriate response to the big tragedies and political issues going on. I was partly motivated to talk about this because as I read the news about the state of our country and others, I see hate operating as an ideology. Fifty years ago, there were struggles over political ideology; now it's an ideology of hate being perpetuated and funded to invoke fear. As a society, we really have to look at this and see how it's being spread.

From a Buddhist practice point of view, when we see horrible things in the world, the appropriate response isn't immediately, "They should fix it, the problem is out there, they are bad, we have to get rid of them." The question is: "Given what's happening in this world that has a big impact on me, how will I now be changed by this? How will I become a better person?" Change begins with yourself. If the topic is hate, and we are seeing huge demonstrations of hate in society, how will I become less hating? How do I respond in ways that reduce the amount of hate in the people I encounter?

Some of the people who commit hate crimes had horrific lives themselves. They were bullied, abused, or neglected. You never know who you will meet later today. If you walk by them and ignore them, maybe you are the straw that breaks the camel's back. What if you did the opposite? Any one of us could potentially prevent a mass shooting simply by meeting someone with kindness and care. I've known people whose lives were dramatically changed by a simple act of kindness, especially people who were really struggling. You may never know that the person you stopped and were kind to was prevented from doing something horrible. If the change doesn't start here within us, it doesn't make a lot of sense to be focusing so much out there.

The Fable of the Monastery

I'd like to end with a fable. Once upon a time, there was a monastery. As happens in monasteries around the world, all that was left was half a dozen old monks. They were dying out, and no new recruits were coming. The monastery had been continuously inhabited and a thriving spiritual center for a thousand years, but it looked like it was coming to an end.

The abbot knew they had to do something. He heard that a hundred miles away there was a rabbi who was really wise. Even though it was a different religion, this person was very wise. The abbot went there, explained what was going on, and the rabbi thought about it for a while. The rabbi said, "There's really only one thing I have to tell you. Among you few monks there, one of you is the next Christ."

It was a strange thing to say. The abbot went back to the monastery, where everyone was waiting to hear what the wise rabbi had said. The abbot said, "He said something very strange. All he said was that one of us is the next Christ." They all thought it was strange and didn't think about it too much.

But over the next days, weeks, and months, they started wondering. "Could it be Charlie? He's cynical, but he's always ready to help. Could it be Sam? He's very quiet, but when he has something to say, it's always wise." They kept looking at each other in new ways and wondering, "Could it be?" They started treating each other with more kindness, care, and respect. The atmosphere in the monastery changed.

From time to time, young people from town would come to the monastery grounds for picnics. They picked up that something was different there. They started talking with the monks and were struck by something special going on. Some of the young men decided to live there, get ordained, and live the spiritual life. Within a few years, the whole place was a thriving spiritual center again.

Maybe, just maybe, one of the people you're going to encounter this week is the next Buddha. Please don't hate anyone, because who knows—you might be meeting the next Buddha. Study your hate, get to the bottom of it, and don't take these hatreds in the world as only things "out there." Reflect on how you want to change, how you want to be better, and with what eyes you want to see the people around you. If you look upon all people as maybe being the next Buddha or the next Christ, maybe we'll make a better world.

Reflections

Since we have a few minutes before tea, maybe you could turn around to two, three, or four people around you. If someone doesn't have a partner, invite them in. Say some short, simple, quiet words about what this talk brought up for you today. Thank you.



  1. Dosa: A Pali word commonly translated as "hate," "aversion," "hostility," or "ill will." It is one of the three unwholesome roots in Buddhist psychology. ↩︎

  2. Dhammapada: A collection of sayings of the Buddha in verse form and one of the most widely read and best known Buddhist scriptures. ↩︎

  3. Greed, Hatred, and Delusion: Known in Buddhism as the "Three Poisons" or "Three Unwholesome Roots" (Lobha, Dosa, Moha), these are considered the fundamental causes of suffering and unethical behavior. ↩︎