Anukampā (4 of 5) The Continual Act of Care
- Date:
- 2020-04-30
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-18 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Anukampā (4 of 5) The Continual Act of Care
I'll continue this morning, the fourth morning, to talk about the Buddha's teachings and discussion of anukampā[1]. I tentatively translate this word as "care." In doing so, I'm bringing into Buddhist language an English word which is very rarely used. I don't recognize it ever really being used, certainly not prominently, in the translations of the Buddha's teachings from Pali, or in many other translations coming out of Asian Buddhism. Why English translators haven't chosen the word "care" is a topic in itself, and I don't know the answer to that. But by translating anukampā as care, I am connecting it consciously with a very simple, ordinary, and common word used in the English language. As I think about it, it has a kind of humbleness to it, but it's really central and important in so many places in our lives.
We talk about health care. If you go to a hospital, there are all kinds of departments that have to do with care. There's the intensive care unit. There is palliative care. There is spiritual care, where hospital chaplains work. We use the word "caregiver." The word caregiver in English certainly can mean a health caregiver, but a caregiver is also someone who offers child care, or nursing home care for the elderly. A caregiver can be someone who is unpaid, simply a family member at home who has become a caregiver for someone who needs care.
The English word "care," in the sense of caring for someone, often means caring for someone's needs. Those needs are physical, emotional, psychological, spiritual, and social. We have all these needs as human beings, and we offer care for all of who we are. What's nice for me about the word care in this comprehensive way is that it is not just caring for people because they suffer, or because they have the potential of suffering and we want to help them not suffer. There's a much broader sense of caring for people simply because they're humans. We have needs, we have possibilities, and we want to live in a world of mutual care.
This idea of caring is so central to human culture and societies, but it's often forgotten as people become adults. I've known people who, only when they had children themselves, were surprised to realize that their parents did the same for them. There is a tremendous amount of caregiving offered to a baby, and caregiving offered for a child as they're growing up—hopefully, that's what's offered. Sometimes the tables are turned, and when parents become elderly, it's the children who become the caregivers and offer care in return. A lot of this happens quietly within families. It's not big public news that the couple down the street has been staying up all night caring for their sick, crying baby. But it's a very remarkable act of care that happens in all kinds of ways.
We also care for people when they're happy by providing them more opportunities. One of the great ways of caring for our children as they grow up in our communities is through all the people who volunteer to be sports coaches—soccer coaches, baseball coaches, and volleyball coaches. It's offering care and creating a healthy environment to grow up in.
So, I see the word "care" as being broader in application and concern than the word "compassion." This is what we seem to see in the teachings of the Buddha. As important as compassion is in Buddhism, in the ancient teachings of the historical Buddha, the word karuṇā[2], often translated as compassion, is really reserved for very deep meditation practice and a state of heart that's radiant, abundant, and expansive. But that word itself is not used to express the motivation for doing good in the world, or supporting people in the world. The word that's used for that is anukampā. As I've been saying, it has another meaning beyond just caring for people's suffering and orienting around avoiding causing suffering. It's caring for people's welfare and happiness. It's a broader term.
The Buddha never talks about cultivating anukampā. It seems that he just assumed that it's there. In the suttas[3], the Buddha suggests that anukampā is what is present when one has abandoned ill will and hatred. One abides with anukampā for the world, the Buddha says. One abides having care for the world when one has abandoned ill will and hatred.
This idea that we're letting go of ill will and hatred uses big, powerful words, but they also represent very subtle, small ways in which ill will might be present. It can be there in a little frustration, irritation, or annoyance we have with people or with ourselves. It can be there in an aversion to people, to things, or to ourselves, even as criticalness. When the mind or the heart has really shed its ill will, its hatred, its aversion, its irritation, and its tendency to complain—when it has really become quiet and open from this—then anukampā for the world arises.
In this sense, anukampā is not doing something. It's not conceiving and thinking, "May all beings be well, may all beings be free of suffering." It's almost as if the absence of something allows this part of our heart to shine and be here. That's certainly my experience: the more I've shed, the more I've settled, the more I've been open through meditation practice and become quieter and more sensitive to it, there seems to arise a care that sometimes takes the expression of compassion, or sometimes loving-kindness and friendliness. But the caringness is more fundamental.
The sense of caring, the capacity to care, the feeling of tenderness and resonance with people—that movement is broader and simpler. It's a humble thing because it doesn't come from active thinking and reflecting. In a hospital, when someone comes into the ICU and is sick, we don't ask or even expect that the health worker has to love the person, or has to have lots of compassion for them. They might have lots of compassion, but we simply expect them to care for the person.
It's possible to care for people for whom one does not have a particularly strong feeling of friendliness. That's not automatic. One can care even if they haven't cultivated or touched into compassion. Care can be a much simpler, more direct activity that doesn't require as much from us as compassion, friendliness, or loving-kindness does. I don't want to diminish the value of compassion and loving-kindness; they're fantastic and powerful parts of human life. But they do require a little bit more from us. To have them in the forefront all the time and call on them in difficult situations might be, for some people, more difficult to do than simply having an ordinary caringness to care for what is there.
Care is so central to human life that maybe we are not just "human beings," but at our core we're "human carings." Maybe care is fundamental to what it means to be a human being. We're social creatures. We depend on the care of others, and they depend on the care of us in some way. Care is perhaps the most fundamental thing in life.
Instead of looking at human beings as either matter or spirit—as having some spiritual essence inside of us, or just a material aspect—what if what's fundamental is not some core essence that is a "thing"? This dualistic approach is certainly not the way the Buddha talks about human life. Rather, the fundamental aspect of what it means to be a human being is caring. It is to care. Over and over again we see in the teachings of the Buddha that he expresses care, directly and indirectly. He is caring about the relationships between people. So much of the teachings of the Buddha can be interpreted to be ethical in nature because they have to do with taking care of how we relate to people, ensuring we don't harm them or ourselves.
The Buddha said that one of the motivations for not harming people is not karuṇā, not compassion. In his teaching, the motivation for not harming people is in fact anukampā—this care and caring. And perhaps caring is an activity, an action. That aligns with the Buddha's tendency to understand human beings in terms of their actions, not in terms of some fundamental essence.
But if anukampā is an activity and action that is more fundamentally who we are, it comes from letting go of all the things that get in the way, including conceit and self-preoccupation. It's almost as if anukampā is not something that I do. In my experience, it's something that is done out of me, out of my heart, when I'm most free, settled, calm, open, and present for experience. Anukampā is not a thing. It's the activity of being human when we're most grounded, centered, and quiet.
It's simple and humble because it's not connected to the conceptions and ideas of who we are. It's not a thing, but it is something we can allow for. We can allow for the heart's capacity to care, and let ourselves become human carers. We become the caretakers and caregivers of the world not because we should, not because it's an obligation, but because it's the fundamental functioning of a liberated and free heart and mind.
To care for the world is to care for our relationships to others. It's a beautiful thing, and I hope that I don't have to convince you. What I really hope is that you're inspired in meditation practice, or in just the practice of mindfulness, to discover underneath the layers of reactivity, fear, tension, anxiety, desires, and attachments that we might have, that there exists a functioning, an activity, a movement, and a flow out of us which is anukampā.
Maybe you'll choose a different word to translate it other than care, and that's fine. I'm not sure exactly how these words are going to be translated in the future. What's important are these fundamental, humble, beautiful qualities of being that we allow to operate from the deep dharmic place inside.
Thank you for the chance to talk this way and think about it. We'll continue with one more talk on anukampā tomorrow. Thank you.
Anukampā: A Pali word often translated as compassion, empathy, or in this context, care and sympathy for the welfare of others. ↩︎
Karuṇā: A Pali word typically translated as compassion; it is one of the four Brahmavihāras (sublime attitudes) in Buddhism. ↩︎
Sutta: A Pali word (cognate with the Sanskrit "Sutra") referring to a discourse or teaching of the Buddha. ↩︎