Moon Pointing

Caring for Yourself and Caring for Others

Date:
2019-12-22
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-18 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Caring for Yourself and Caring for Others

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Caring for Yourself and Caring for Others

I'll start with a little story from the ancient texts from the time of the Buddha. It involves a king who was somewhat friendly with the Buddha. He was the same age, and the texts present him as being a little bit self-indulgent, especially with food and things. His name was Pasenadi[1], and he was talking to Queen Mallika. He asked the queen, "Who do you consider most dear?"

Now, perhaps I interpret it a little bit that a self-indulgent king is expecting the queen to say, "Well, you, dear." But her answer is, "I hold myself most dear." Maybe he raised his eyebrows, and so she asked him, "Who do you hold most dear?" And he said, "I hold myself the most dear."

Apparently, this was noteworthy enough for the king—maybe because he didn't get the answer he expected from the queen—that he went to his friend, the Buddha, and recounted this exchange they had. The Buddha heard this story and said, "Well, this is right. People hold themselves most dear, that's appropriate."

So that part of the story is kind of interesting, but what's really interesting is what the Buddha did next. He continued his teaching, and it is preserved in verse. The Buddha stated, "Searching all directions with one's awareness, one finds no one dearer than oneself. In the same way, others are most dear to themselves." That's okay, right? So we are similar to everyone. If everyone holds themselves most dear in some way, if we see that in ourselves, we can then understand—maybe even empathically—that that's the case for other people, that they cherish themselves.

But here is where the real, wonderful emphasis comes that some people say is unique to the Buddha in this ancient context. Because this particular teaching[2] maybe is not particularly unique, and it's not particularly inspiring by itself. But the last line is: "So one should not hurt others if one loves oneself."

We see this emphasis on holding oneself as dear. An extreme version could be seen as a kind of selfishness, to have that kind of focus. Some people react to this kind of teaching as selfish, that you shouldn't be focused that way. I don't think that the Buddha, or the people of his time, saw it that way. There certainly were some records that survived from religious traditions of his time that put a tremendous emphasis on the self. The goal of practice was to realize this—some kind of fundamental union, communion, or realization of the self that was radically apart from the world we live in. In fact, we find some of these ancient teachings that preceded the Buddha to have very similar statements to this one here, that one should hold oneself dear.

But then this last line is so significant: that the Buddha is concerned with how we treat other people. He gets to the conclusion that if you love yourself, you shouldn't harm anybody else. Perhaps part of the motivation for this, the background for this which is explicit in other teachings, is the sense of recognition that other people have the same feelings as we have. We don't want to be killed, so probably other people don't want to be. We don't want to have things stolen from us; probably other people don't. We don't want to be the victims of sexual abuse; probably others don't want to be. It goes on and on. We don't want to be lied to; other people don't want to be lied to. This is a recognition of using oneself, and the impact these kinds of unethical behavior have on the self, as a reference point to understand what the impact will be for others. I don't want to experience this kind of hurt for myself. Why would I cause this kind of harm to someone else?

So he takes this teaching about self and turns it around to emphasize an ethical teaching. This is something we find over and over again in the Buddhist teachings, that there is a phenomenally strong ethical component to it. It seems like he doesn't tire of keeping referring back to something about his teachings that gives it an ethical nature. Ethical means—I think it's not always a very popular topic—but what it means in the Buddhist context is living a life that does not harm others, but rather is living a life that benefits others. Particularly this thing about not harming others, that is emphasized more than almost anything else. If you could just imagine that all the ways that humans harm each other stopped, how different it would be to read the newspaper. What a different world it would be. Just that! Even if people didn't do a lot of benefit for each other, if they just stopped harming each other, what a different world we would be in.

When the Buddha lays out the path of practice, he begins with an ethical component which has a lot to do with restraining causing harm. At every step along the way of the path, even up to enlightenment, the Buddha keeps referring back to the idea of benefiting others or not causing harm. There is a very famous statement the Buddha made. He started teaching at some point, and after some time there were sixty people who had become enlightened. When those sixty were enlightened, he sent them off. He said, "Don't hang out here. Go forth out into the world for the welfare and benefit of many. Out of compassion for the world, go out and benefit them." For him, the consequence of enlightenment was to go out and benefit people and support people.

The Metta Sutta

We see this very interestingly if we look at the Buddha's teaching on loving-kindness. There's a very famous text called the Metta Sutta[3] (The Discourse on Loving-Kindness). That title seems like it's about love, kindness, friendliness, or whatever metta might really translate into in English. But that's not explicitly what the text is about. It starts off being explicitly about if a person wants to reach a state of peace—the profound state of personal peace. To realize that for oneself, to attain that, he lays out what a person should do.

This is how it begins: "To reach the state of peace, those skilled in the good should be capable and upright, straightforward and easy to speak to, gentle and not proud, contented and easily supported, living lightly and with few duties, wise and with senses calmed, not arrogant and without greed for supporters. And they should not do the least thing that the wise would criticize."

There's nothing in here about being nice in the world, something about being kind, loving, or supportive in the world, even though the title is the Loving-Kindness Sutta. The titles usually came later from later editors. Apparently, the Buddha just spoke, and he didn't bother putting titles on what he said. But, "to reach the state of peace," this is all kind of very personal practice—how you would live your life if you want to live a life that was peaceful and nice.

But then it goes on: "They should reflect as follows: May all beings be happy and secure. May all beings be happy at heart. All living beings, whether weak or strong, tall, large, medium, or short, tiny or big, seen or unseen, near or distant, born or to be born—may they all be happy."

So this person who wants to pursue peace should live ethically and in a good way, and they should be concerned about the welfare of others. They should actually be having thoughts of wishing, intentions, or aspirations that everyone be happy, secure, and safe.

And then it goes on and says more about what they should reflect or how they should be thinking when they live in the world. They should be reflecting: "Let no one deceive another or despise anyone anywhere. Let no one, through anger or aversion, wish for others to suffer."

Again, the emphasis here has been turned. If you want to be at peace, the direction of the conversation now has changed towards, in order to really be at peace, maybe you should be concerned for the welfare of others. That's an important part of it.

It goes on and says more about how to do this, in very dramatic terms: "As a mother would risk her own life to protect her child, her only child, so toward all living beings should one cultivate a boundless heart. With loving-kindness for the whole world should one cultivate a boundless heart—above, below, and all around, without obstruction and without hate, and without ill will. Standing or walking, sitting or lying down, as long as one is alert, may one stay with this recollection. This is called a sublime abiding here and now. Whoever is virtuous, endowed with vision, not taken by views, and having overcome all greed for sensual pleasures, will not be reborn again."

So the idea is really discovering this path to peace. He takes at the end one of the ways that the final goal is described. But integrated in this whole thing, a major part of this text is this emphasis on loving others, being kind, and supportive of others.

Generally, the word in Pali[4] for loving-kindness is metta. It is a cognate to the word mitta, which is the Pali word for friend (mitra in Sanskrit). So it's often referred to as a kind of love that is like philia, a love of friendship, rather than erotic love or romantic love. It's a loving-kindness or loving friendship.

To give you a sense of how much the Buddha emphasized it or the value he put on it, there is this other verse: "Just as the light of all the constellations in the sky do not equal one-sixteenth the radiance of the moon, so no matter what the ritual sacrifice, the sacrifice of royal world-conquering kings does not equal one-sixteenth the value of a heart well-developed in loving-kindness."

This idea of loving-kindness being so important: "Monastics, disciples who cultivate loving-kindness for as long as a finger snap are called true monastics. They are not without meditative absorption. They cultivate the Buddha's teachings. They are receptive to advice and do not eat their alms food in vain. How much more so can this be said of those who frequently practice loving-kindness."

Some people who live lay lives like many of you, maybe sometimes you think, "Well, it would be nice if I could be a monastic. You could practice a lot and really dedicate your life to that. But how could I do something similar and get the same benefits?" Well, for a snap of a finger, if you have loving-kindness for other people, you get a lot of goodness that comes from that. It certainly is good for others to love them. But it's interesting that he then turns it around and focuses back on the individual. Those people who have that degree of loving-kindness, just that short, they are not without meditative absorption. They have getting concentrated in meditation. For oneself, it is very important in Buddhist practice. Here, something about this loving-kindness puts you in that camp. That's quite something.

And they cultivate the Buddhist teachings, and they are receptive to advice. You probably know people who aren't! But there is something about having some degree of friendliness towards people that apparently makes you a little bit open, receptive to what people say about you. It's kind of nice, I think.

Elsewhere the Buddha says, since monastics have renounced money and all that, they're not supposed to have any material wealth. But the Buddha says they still have lots of wealth; their wealth is their loving-kindness. It's nice to change the wealth from material wealth to what's in your heart. The nice thing about heart wealth, for those of you who are collecting it, is that it's portable. People can't really steal it. You can give it away or shut it down yourself, but it's there.

What is loving-kindness? There is an ancient description or definition of it: "The characteristic of loving-kindness is to promote beneficial conditions for other living beings." To be interested in creating good conditions for them. "Its essential quality is focusing on what is beneficial, focusing on what is helpful. Its manifestation is the removal of malice." When loving-kindness is strong, apparently the way it's demonstrated is no malice, no hate. "Its proximate cause is seeing the loveliness of beings."

It's nice, if you want to love people, if you want to have this kindness or friendliness towards people, first take the time to appreciate them, to value them. How would you take time to register people in order to appreciate them? I think most people want to be appreciated or feel valued. Take a time to really appreciate people, and by seeing their loveliness, it's easier to have loving-kindness.

It's one thing to say, "Loving-kindness is a good thing, and it's a duty and obligation," and so you bear down and get serious. That doesn't work so well. What comes naturally from you if you take the time to look at people, to tune into people, to take time to get to know them so that you have some appreciation or valuing of them. One of the advantages of meditation is to quiet the mind down, quiet the physical system down enough so we're not antsy and rushing off to this or that thing. So when we sit with people, we can take a little time to take in the situation, rather than having our desires or our fears predominate, where we're on to the next thing or pulling away or so caught up in our concerns. We relax our preoccupation so we take time to share each other, be with each other. It's phenomenal what can happen.

The metta is called loving-kindness because it is loving; it refers to tender love. It is also known as metta because it arises in one's relationship to a friend, a mitta. The ancient texts clearly connect it to the idea of friendship. And how does one abide with one's mind accompanied with loving-kindness extending outward in one direction? Just as one would feel friendliness on seeing a dearly beloved friend, so does one extend loving-kindness to all creatures.

The Monks and the Devas

I want to tell you an ancient story, a fable. The Metta Sutta that I read to you earlier about if you want to reach the state of peace, have kind, supportive well-wishing for all beings. There's a story of how the Buddha first gave this. One way of looking at this fable is, once again, to see this integration or non-separation of a personal path of practice and being concerned for the welfare of others. The two shouldn't be kept separate.

The story goes that the Buddha was in town, one of the places where he lived with his monastics. It was time for them to go off for the three-month rains retreat. For monastics, every year for three months they go off someplace to just be and be still, not moving around during the monsoon season in ancient India, when it was hard to walk around anyway. They would just sit in one place and practice, and they weren't supposed to leave that place during those three months, kind of like a three-month retreat.

His monastics headed off from town to find a place for the three-month retreat. A group of them went up into the foothills of the Himalayas, and they found this spot in an outlying district. They came to a cool, dense green forest grove. In it, they found a stretch of ground covered by white sand that looked like a net of pearls or a silver sheet. Nearby was a clean spring with cool water. Within sight was a great mountain forming part of the Himalayan mountain range. Awe-inspiring, the mountain sparkled like blue crystal in the sun. The monastics spent the night here, and in the morning found a town not far away where they could go for alms.

Since monks and nuns seldom visit outlying districts, the townspeople were quite joyful to see the monastics and happily offered them food. After the group had eaten, the townspeople requested they spend the rains retreat in the nearby grove. When the monastics agreed, everyone in town quickly built little huts, one for each of the monks. The next day, the monks re-entered the grove and wholeheartedly began the retreat with well-established mindfulness. They each sat at the foot of a tree to meditate.

Isn't that idyllic? We should all find a place like that under a tree, then we could meditate! But there was a problem. However, the tree spirits, the devas[5] that lived in those trees, were dismayed by the dedication of the virtuous monks. They came down from their tree homes and from a distance wandered back and forth with their children. It was like a king and his entourage commandeering a town, displacing the residents. Those townspeople stand in a distance asking themselves, "When are they going away?" In the same way, those devas wondered, "When are those monks going away?"

Then the devas realized that the monks were going to stay put for the entire three-month period of the rains retreat. Since they did not think it was possible to live with their children away from their homes for so long, they decided to try to frighten the monks away. So in the middle of the night, the devas created terrific apparitions that stood in front of each monk making horrible sounds. The monks shook with fear, became pale and sickly. They could no longer keep their minds concentrated. As the devas kept up their fear attacks, the monks also lost their mindfulness. Then the devas assailed the monks with an awful stench. The smell seemed to suffocate the monks' brains.

Each monk felt quite oppressed, but did not tell the other monks what was happening during the night. This continued for several nights until the senior monk asked them, "Friends, when we entered this grove, your skin color was pure and bright and your faculties were clear, but now you all seem withered up, pale, and sickly. What's wrong?"

Then the other monks explained to him what horrible fear they were experiencing at night. The senior monk said, "This place does not suit us. Let's go to the Buddha and ask if we can go to a more suitable location." That's reasonable, right? After all, they displaced the devas. It was the home of the devas; they shouldn't just walk in and take over. Anyway, they were so frightened, let's find a different place.

So they went back to town to the Buddha, explained what had happened, and the Buddha, in his great vision, looked around the world and said, "Well, it turns out there's no other place in the world that's better for you all than that place. You should go back there. However, if you want to be free from fear of devas, then learn the following as a protection. It will be both a protection and a meditation practice for you."

Then the Buddha expounded the Discourse on Loving-Kindness. The monks then returned to their grove of trees and began reciting the Discourse on Loving-Kindness and practicing loving-kindness meditation. As a result, the devas thought, "These monks wish us well and seek our good." Filled with happiness, the devas began to support the monks and did so for the remainder of the retreat. The devas kept the grove swept clean, prepared warm water for the monks, provided them with medical treatment, and arranged for their protection. Practicing loving-kindness, the monks became established in insight, and then all of them attained the highest enlightenment during that very retreat.

So it's a nice fable, a simple story, but what I want to emphasize in this story is this integration of these two. The monks went off and took up the practice to get enlightened themselves, which in some ways is an individualistic pursuit. And all the conditions were there for them to be able to do it, except one thing more was needed which they didn't realize they needed: to have hearts of loving-kindness for the location, for the spirits that were there, for the unseen world, and maybe for the seen world as well. So what they did is they practiced this loving-kindness. Practicing having this heart of goodwill for others for the three months, according to this text, that was the practice that brought them their individual liberation.

The Mutuality of Self and Other

Individual and other, caring for others, concern for others, loving others, loving oneself, caring for oneself—these are deeply intertwined in the Buddhist teachings. It's easy enough to cherry-pick and pull out of these texts a certain emphasis. I think not a few of the people here in the West, maybe myself included, have gone—like we went to Burma to practice, many of us, and we went to monasteries that were meditation centers. So they mostly taught us meditation, the individualistic side. We didn't get a lot of the social teachings. And then some of us came back and established centers here in the West, and since they're retreat centers, again it emphasizes meditation. Sometimes that was the emphasis, to keep emphasizing a particular subset of the teaching.

But if you read the suttas[6] as a whole, what you see is a tremendous integration of how we live in our social life as part of what the Buddha had to teach. That we would live ethically, we'd be very concerned about not causing harm in the world. We would cultivate loving-kindness, goodwill, to care for others, to have appreciation for others, to value others, and not only to do it just as a good thing, but also do it for our own practice. We benefit from doing it. This kind of mutuality, that concern for others benefits ourselves, and benefiting ourselves concerns others, they go hand in hand. They're not so separate from each other.

I think that in some of the currents of Western thought, there's a very sharp divide between altruism and selfishness. The ideal way is supposed to be altruistic in some circles in the West, and anything that you do that's not that is selfish. One of the ways I saw it when I first started practicing Buddhism when I was in my early twenties—so maybe it's changed, I haven't heard this for a long time now—but it was common back then for non-Buddhists, when they learned that their children or family members were practicing Buddhist meditation, to criticize them for being selfish. Maybe they meditated an hour a day, and the people who were criticizing them for being selfish were watching TV three hours a day! There's something about meditation being religious, that expectation if you're doing something religious you're supposed to be altruistic. But if you're not doing something religious, then it doesn't really matter. The fact that the TV is three hours, six hours a day, that's not in the same domain, so you wouldn't criticize someone for doing that as being selfish. So it was a little bit strange back then, I thought.

But this strong divide between altruism and being selfish that exists in some corners of the West, it doesn't seem to exist in ancient India. Often in Buddhism and other religions of that time, there is a sense of the mutuality of these, that if you benefit yourself, you benefit the world; if you benefit others, you benefit yourself as well.

In the Buddhist teachings, there is this wonderful little teaching of the acrobats. There were these two acrobats, the master acrobat and the apprentice, and they would do acrobatics on their own bodies, like one would climb on the other and do handstands and all kinds of wonderful acrobatics. They were going to do a show, and the master acrobat said to the apprentice, "You watch over me and I'll watch over you, and that way we'll be safe." It's reasonable enough, you know, it's kind of dangerous to be up there. And the apprentice says, "No, you watch over yourself and I'll watch over myself, and that way we'll be safe."

With a disagreement like that, they went to the Buddha, and the Buddha agreed with the apprentice. I think it's kind of like this idea on an airplane: you should put the air mask on yourself first, and then you can help others. Then the Buddha said, "Protecting oneself, one protects others; protecting others, one protects oneself." Here we see this mutuality; these are not sharply divided. They come together.

And how does one, in protecting oneself, protect others? "By repeated and frequent practice of mindfulness." So you protect yourself by practicing mindfulness. You certainly protect yourself from yourself! Who harms you the most these days? Not a few people in our world are harming themselves with their attachments, fear, criticism, and all kinds of things that go on. So one protects oneself by practicing mindfulness, but remember the Buddha said in doing so you protect others.

And how does one, in protecting others, protect oneself? "By patience and forbearance, by a non-violent and harmless life, by loving-kindness and compassion." So if you protect others with these attitudes, with these motivations, you also protect yourself.

This mutuality, these things go together. The impression I have these days is that one of the great contributions of the Buddha was to offer a spiritual practice, a path to liberation, where the individual and the social were deeply integrated and connected. You can't really separate them out, and you want to really be concerned with both. You're going to develop the heart that is open, sensitive, loving, or caring for both, and for all, in a sense, equally. Caring for oneself as we would be caring for someone else, that we are worthy and valuable people ourselves, and we're worthy of our own love, our own care. Trying to help ourselves for the best in us to come out, to become free and peaceful, and to do the same thing for the people around us. Not to shut down, not to close down, not to have blinders on, not to live in our own particular insulated world without paying attention to the world around us. But somehow to understand that maybe all of us in this world, every single human being and maybe all living life, are really in this together, and we can't really separate these two out.

I'll end with this quote that I read last night that I really liked, and maybe I can apply it to what I'm saying. We had history here recently at times in the United States of banks failing, and then the government goes and saves them. But the biggest bank we have, the bank that we were all relying on and withdrawing from all the time, and that is at risk of going bankrupt now, is the earth itself. Who is going to help that out of bankruptcy? All the resources are used up, and who do we turn to to say, "Well, we need a new loan"?

This idea of loving the world, really opening up and including all and not keeping it so separate—"us and them"—but really encompassing it all as part of our own welfare, I think is more necessary now in this world than ever before. So I certainly hope that you will consider how to do the best for yourself and thrive in some deep inner way, and that you'll discover that if you thrive broadly from your heart outward, that you'll see it's so obvious that it's a wonderful thing, a beautiful thing. It's an obvious thing to also care for the world around you. May our lives be lives of deep caring for self, for others, and all beings. Thank you.



  1. Original transcript said "Mizpah sanity," corrected to "Pasenadi" (the King of Kosala) based on historical context. ↩︎

  2. Original transcript said "this big girl teaching," corrected to "this particular teaching" based on context. ↩︎

  3. Metta Sutta: A famous discourse by the Buddha on the practice of loving-kindness. The original transcript had "Mehta Sutra." ↩︎

  4. Pali: The language in which the early Buddhist texts (the Tipitaka) were recorded and preserved. ↩︎

  5. Devas: In Buddhism, devas are celestial or non-human beings, often translated as gods, deities, or spirits, who share the universe with humans but exist in different realms. ↩︎

  6. Suttas: The Buddhist discourses or teachings, originally recorded in the Pali language. ↩︎