Moon Pointing

Exploring Intentionality

Date:
2019-07-01
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-17 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Exploring Intentionality

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Exploring Intentionality

What's on my mind these days is intention. Maybe we can say the power of intention. In Buddhist psychology, they say that an intentional sense of purpose is there in every mind moment. There are seven mental factors which are always present. A lot of others come and go, but intentionality is one of them. It's an interesting idea that they have: that a sense of purpose, a sense of motivation, a sense of intentional direction for what we do is part and parcel of every mind moment we have. Are you tracking them all? Are you tracking all the purposes and intentions that you have?

So, one of the reasons for mindfulness practice is to be able to cultivate a strong mind that's able to track much more carefully what goes on in the present moment, in particular what goes on in our own minds. Because it's in our own minds that we create karma[1]—our own minds where we set in place the conditions that play out over time.

Intentionality and karma are closely connected topics. I understand it this way: karma has to do with psychological causality. What goes on outside of our psychology is kind of unknown; it's too difficult to figure out. But our psychology, the workings of our mind, is very much shaped by the intention, the quality of the mind with which we act or speak. There's a little saying that captures this idea of karma and intentionality: if you act in ways that cause harm, you create more harm. If you act in beneficial ways, you create more benefit. You don't get off scot-free. If you do things which are harmful, somehow they're going to live in your mind and your psychology in a variety of different ways. One of the ways they're going to live in your mind is that you're setting in place conditions, traces, memories, and remnants. They're going to play out, and if nothing else, they're going to set the conditions for doing more.

It's not exactly my own psychology, but I saw it when my kids were quite young, how these things can play out. It was very alarming to see this and very educational for me. My older son sometimes was—they call him a spirited kid—so sometimes he would do things that, at least the parents thought, he shouldn't be doing. I discovered that if I used a strong, loud voice, he would stop doing what he was doing. So very occasionally, I'd use that strong voice to say, "No, you have to stop." Then one day, I heard him use exactly the same voice on his younger brother, who was maybe a year and a half or two years old. I said, "Oh my, what have I done, passing this on?" That's the day I stopped using that strong voice.

The same thing happens to our minds. We use a strong voice, we say something in an angry or spiteful way, and we set in motion—we condition or influence ourselves—more likely than not to do it again. It works those channels and smooths them over. So you want to be careful with what you do because of the conditions you're setting up, the influence you're having on your own mind. If you do things which are beneficial, you create beneficial conditions for your own mind.

Front-Loading Our Efforts

Here's an interesting modern idea: the idea of front-loading and end-loading. Sometimes if you front-load, meaning you put effort and energy into something at the beginning, it becomes easier at the end. But if you aren't careful in the beginning, and don't front-load your efforts, then sometimes you have a lot more end-loading to take care of at the end. Karma is like this. If you're careful with your actions and are attentive to the quality or the intentionality that's behind them, it takes more work. You have to pause. You have to look at yourself. You have to be mindful and present for yourself. Some people find doing work to be a drag. Some people want to just be impulsive, have nothing get in the way, and just do whatever they feel. But if you slow down and take a good look at what goes on, what's driving you, what's motivating you, and why you're doing things, and do it wisely, then there's a lot less cleaning up to do afterwards. There can be a lot of work to clean up afterwards if you're not careful. Some people have found out that it would have been a lot easier to have been careful for those three seconds when they said something than to spend years cleaning up from what they did or said. People can impulsively say things that hurt and damage relationships pretty quickly. So the teaching of karma is a teaching about the importance of front-loading: being careful how you live your life as you're living it.

All this points to the idea that the present moment is a creative moment. The present moment is not a neutral time. You're always involved with forces of the mind that are creating a future for yourself—a future for the next second, the next minute, the next day. It's a creative moment. If you're there to be creative in it, you're creating something. If nothing else, you're shaping your own mind and heart. The seeds for that shaping in Buddhism are often said to be the intention: the quality, purpose, or decisiveness behind what you're going to do.

I think of intention as what's between what we want and acting on it. Some people can have lots of desires, but they don't act on them. Something a little extra is needed: a commitment, a decisiveness, a stronger push in the mind that we can call intentionality, which really pushes us to do what we want to do. This is important to realize because someone can have a desire—say, "I'm hungry and my desire is to have food to eat." What gets me to act, and the character or quality of how I act, is intentionality. If I decide that the best way to get really good food is to rob a bank, get some money, and then go out to a nice restaurant, that creates very different karmic consequences in our psychology than going to the bank and taking money out of your own account, or going to a store and reflecting on what you're going to buy so that it supports the environment a little bit, or at least doesn't undermine it.

You can add all kinds of things around the desire to go eat. You can be greedy for food. You could go down the supermarket aisles and push everyone else aside so you can get to your food and grab it. Or you could go into the market and be patient, open doors for people, not be greedy, and go in with a sense of generosity and compassion for animals and decide to eat vegetarian. There are all kinds of spins that we put on our desires as we act them out. To stop and look at our intention—what's the purpose we have for what we're doing? What purpose do we infuse into the act that we do? That's the front-loading part.

The Purification of Intention

When I was a young Zen[2] student, I was very influenced by a Zen teacher. I'd been practicing at Zen Center for a long time, and then I went and practiced in Southeast Asia in a different Buddhist tradition, the Vipassana[3] tradition, which we're teaching here. In Vipassana practice, we talk a lot about the details of our meditation practice, what goes on in meditation, what the experience is, and the instructions for it. In Zen, when I was at Zen Center, there was no discussion about meditation practice whatsoever. It was almost taboo, even though we did a lot of meditation. So I asked in a public way, in the presence of a lot of the priests at the center, "Why is that?" No one answered. So I just didn't think about it anymore. But afterwards, one of the senior priests came up to me and said, "I'll tell you. Zen practice is the purification of intention. In Zen, we're not so focused on the details of meditation practice, how concentrated you get, or how mindful you are. Rather, we're purifying or clarifying the sense of purpose, intentionality, the motivation for doing the practice. As the intention gets clarified and purified, everything else gets lined up; everything else fits into place."

I found this over and over again: if we can do a deep study of our intentions, the purposes we have for what we do, and really take time to look at them deeper and deeper, there is a clarification, a deepening, a reworking, a reassessment that's quite significant. That might in some ways be more powerful than meditating every day because intentionality is what shapes how we live our lives. How happy we are, how free we are, and how much we grow has a lot to do with what motivates us for how we're going to live this life.

When I was at the Zen monastery during my first year or so, it was a strange thing to do. I was supposed to go to graduate school. Just a few weeks before I was going to go to graduate school, I decided to go to the Zen monastery. So I wrote to the department and said, "Something has come up, and I can't start this year. Can I defer my start for a year?" I went to the monastery for a year, but in the back of my mind, I knew they had agreed to defer it. So I had this graduate school hanging over me. Should I go to graduate school, or should I do something else with my life? What should I do with my life?

What I really wanted to do was to be of service to the world, to try to address the suffering of the world. And I wanted to do it through the means of Buddhist practice. For me, Buddhist practice was the clearest, strongest, most effective way that I knew to address the depth of human suffering—to get really down to the core of it. I wanted to do that, but I didn't trust my intention. I didn't trust the purity or the clarity of it. I thought, "Well, people who want to serve other people, they're probably doing it for selfish reasons. And I'm probably selfish." So I spent a year reflecting, thinking about my intention. What is it? What's going on with me? I was teasing apart what was going on, looking at all the little motivations, the fears, the "I shoulds," and the sense of obligation that came along with that. There was certainly a sense of conceit involved. There were all these different things involved with my idea of being of service. It was not such a pure, clear idea of being of service to the world.

So I spent a year reflecting, thinking, and looking at this. It turned out to be a year really well spent. I wasn't so happy doing it because I was filled with doubt and angst, but by the end of the year, I realized—and it was a monumental decision for me—that in theory, it's possible to be of service purely. When I at least in theory knew it could be done, that was part of the decision for me to devote my life to Buddhism, which I've done all these years.

Clarifying Our Deepest Purpose

I've done this at other times as well, taking a year or so of my life to just keep looking at my intentionality. One of the interesting questions I explored was asking: What is my deepest intention? Not just my intention for shopping for food, or my intention for what I'm going to say in a certain conversation, but what is the sense of purpose that I want to base my life on? What is most important to me? One of the things I discovered in that year was how easy it was for me to lose touch with it. How easy it was to get busy with life and all kinds of things that were not so deep. Superficial aspects of my life somehow had all this drama and pulled me this way and that way, making it easy to lose touch with this deeper sense of purpose. And when I could tap into it, it became like a ballast. It became a sense of purpose, a sense of confidence, a sense of directionality, a clarity about what I was about, that kept me from being tossed about in the currents of life. I knew what I was about. This is what I'm doing.

It was also very interesting over that year to see how this sense of deepest purpose shifted and changed over time. I learned a few things which I'll pass on to you if you want to reflect on your own intentions and sense of purpose. In this process of clarifying and purifying it, you can ask these kinds of questions. First: Is your intention compensatory? Are you trying to compensate for some suffering, some distress, some sense of lack, or some sense of emptiness you have? Are you compensating for it by filling it with something else? Or is there some deeper place of intentionality that isn't compensating because something is wrong in your life, but something that wells up from a deeper place, maybe when you're completely happy, contented, and everything is good? What wells up then?

In my case, I was doing a lot of meditation. Outside of meditation, I had my own angst, my anxieties, and various issues. But in meditation, all that would drop away. I'd become peaceful enough that my normal everyday anxiety fell away and got quiet. So asking the question, "What is my deepest intention?" was not trying to compensate for or fix some problem in my life. It arose out of there being no problem in this moment: I'm sitting here peacefully, at ease, content. Then there was a feeling of some deeper spring arising inside that would answer that question. So, is it compensatory or not? Ideally, it wouldn't be in compensation or in reaction to something, but rather you really go deep enough to find out: what wants to come out of you?

The second thing is to notice if your intention is negative in nature—like you have the intention to live without fear. That's a good intention to have, but you can go deeper than that. You can ask a second question: "If I had no fear, what would be my intention then?" So when there's a negative intention, celebrate it maybe, but then see if you can restate it positively. If you could have this negative thing not happen, what would you really want to do? I remember one person who told me that her deep intention was to live without fear. I asked her, "Well, if you had no fear, what would be your intention then?" She surprised herself with what she said: "Oh, then I want to love people." So what would you rather do? Live without fear or love people? Sometimes we have to deal with the fear first, for sure. I don't want to diminish the importance of working with it; I had to work with my fear a lot. But sometimes if you realize a deeper intention—like to love people—knowing what's underneath can help address the fear much easier. It changes the game, changes the whole perspective of what we're doing. It gives some strength behind it and a different context than just trying to be without fear.

The third thing to inquire into is to feel into the intention and see what it's like. Is it an intention that brings you a sense of well-being, or is it an intention that brings you a sense of uneasiness? Is it beneficial or is it harmful to you or to others? What are the consequences of having it? You can feel some intentions are alienating. Some intentions separate us from people; some intentions bring people together. Some intentions separate ourselves from ourselves; some intentions bring us together. There are not a few people who are at war with themselves or at war with parts of themselves. Part of their subconscious intentionality is to be critical of themselves, or to push parts of themselves away, or shut down parts of themselves. Is that the best intention to have? Really see what's there and keep inquiring deeper and deeper.

Turning Towards What Drives Us

Another thing about intention is to think about how there are actually layers of intentionality, layers of purpose. I have a lot of faith that if we can use mindfulness to turn towards what's driving us—the motivations we have, the impulses we have—and clarify them and respect them, we start going through these layers. We start going deeper and deeper. Things that might seem like unfortunate intentions to have, like maybe you're very judgmental towards yourself, we can respect in this way: turn towards it. Allow yourself to be that way. Don't say that's wrong. Don't be at war with yourself for what you're doing. Hold it carefully and attentively and really get to know it well, as if it has permission to be there.

And then feel into it. You might discover that underneath the intention to be self-critical is a desire to be safe. It might be a misdirected way of trying to become safe, but trying to be safe seems like a better place to be. But what is underneath that? Deeper down than the desire to be safe—which is a little bit like a negative desire, a desire not to be afraid—maybe there's a desire to be open, present, and receptive to this world. A desire to love, a desire to care. I know for myself, and I think for not a few people, things can happen in life where our impulses to love, impulses to care, impulses for a sense of wonder or the beauty and value of life, can be easily squashed, covered over, and closed up. But they don't go away. They fester, or we try in unsuccessful ways to deal with them. But if we can very patiently turn the gaze back respectfully and see what's driving us, it's a beautiful thing.

It's a profound thing to do in meditation, because in meditation you're not going to move. You can have any motivation at all—allow it to be there no matter how ugly it is—but you're not going to act on it. So it's a great place to sit very quietly, turn your gaze towards it, and look respectfully, caringly, maybe lovingly, at that which is actually very difficult about yourself. And then see how it opens up. What wants to open? What wants to show itself that's deeper? I have this profound faith that if you really look deeply into anything, it takes you down to the beautiful depths of who you are.

Spend time with your intentions. Look at your intentions, clarify them, purify them, explore them, and get to know them. Take time to recognize them. Pause in your life long enough so that you can ask yourself: What is my deepest sense of purpose? Not a few people I've known have had a deep, wonderful sense of purpose for their life, and then in the busyness of a career lost touch with it, and felt bereft because they had this wonderful thing going, but now felt trapped by their career and family and all these different things. What they really wanted to be about couldn't really be there. It can be there if we pause long enough to look, if we listen and pay attention to it, and really go in and find what's there. I believe that the depth of our intention is some of the most beautiful and important parts of who we are. It's not something we want to ignore. It's not something we want to be casual about, or not give time to because there are all these important chores of everyday life to be done, or websites to visit.

The "What" vs. The "How"

Exploring our intention and getting to know it comes with a few warnings. When you ask questions like "What is your deepest purpose or deepest intention?", there are a lot of societal or family messages we get about what's the appropriate purpose to have. One of them that exists in this society is to associate a sense of purpose with finding the right career, finding what you're supposed to be doing in your life. There are all these examples of people who figured out a great "what" and get written up in the newspaper—"If I just find the what, write the great American novel, then I'll be great."

In Buddhism, the "what" we do is actually much less important than the "how" we do it. For some people, their sense of purpose in life and intentionality has a lot more to do with how they live their life than what they actually do. For some people, it doesn't actually matter what kind of job they have. What matters is they do it with integrity. They do it with compassion, with love, they do it with generosity. Those are the qualities that are the creative acts that shape good karma. Whether you get a promotion or not does not do much good for your karma. But if you do your job with generosity, it does a lot for the psychological cultivation and influence that karma is all about. How we do things might have a bigger impact on your long-term happiness than what you do.

So as you explore your deepest intention, be careful you don't too easily fall into the idea of a "what". There might be something about the "how". In Buddhism, the maturing in practice and the liberation that comes, I think of as a "how". How to live this life without suffering, how to live this life without causing suffering, and how to live this life compassionately to help alleviate suffering. That's a beautiful and profound way of living. In Buddhism, that's probably considered the most profound motivation that any human life can have.

Group Reflection

I think you can tell that I think this is an important topic, and one that I've spent a lot of my life exploring and working with. Now that I've shared something important for me, would you be willing to turn to maybe three or four people near you and just talk about what this topic of intention has stirred up in you? Just don't let any one of you talk for very long. If you have a group of three or four, just make short statements—not everything you have to say on this topic—so you can hear from each other and go around a little bit. It's interesting to hear other people too. Will you do that for about six or seven minutes, and then we'll come back here.



  1. Karma: A Sanskrit word meaning action, work, or deed. In Buddhism, it refers to the principle of cause and effect where intentional actions shape an individual's future and psychological conditioning. ↩︎

  2. Zen: A school of Mahayana Buddhism originating in China that emphasizes rigorous self-control, meditation practice, and insight into the nature of things. ↩︎

  3. Vipassana: A Pali word often translated as "insight" or "clear-seeing." It is a traditional Buddhist meditation practice focused on seeing the true nature of reality. ↩︎