Moon Pointing

The Past Has Been Left Behind, The Future Has Not Been Reached

Date:
2020-04-12
Speakers:
Kim Allen [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-17 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
The Past Has Been Left Behind, The Future Has Not Been Reached

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

The Past Has Been Left Behind, The Future Has Not Been Reached

Good morning. It's nice to see everyone. I hope it has been a nice Easter morning so far. I wasn't sure how many people would show up, but according to my screen, there are about 74 people here, so that's pretty good. Feels like a nice group.

I heard recently from some friends of mine at Aranya Bodhi, which is a vihara[1] for nuns on the Sonoma Coast. They had noticed that a bird called a hermit thrush was not present for them during their last rains retreat sometime last year. They just didn't hear this bird, and they had normally been hearing it. Of course, I think they would be interested in a bird called a hermit thrush, so that's maybe something that was in their attention. But they wondered if maybe it was due to climate change, because it seems to come when there is cool mist in the forest, and they hadn't had that that year.

Just recently on retreat, however, the abbess of Aranya Bodhi noticed that the mists had returned, and that they could hear this hermit thrush once again. I thought I would play a little clip of what they sound like. I don't know if this is going to come through on the sound, but we're going to try it. It's pretty high-pitched.

[Plays audio clip]

I see some nods. Pretty cool, huh? The forest was alive with these sounds. Very beautiful. One website calls the hermit thrush an "ethereal singer."

I think this is just one of many ways, some welcome and some not, that the future is turning out to be unpredictable for us. Things are happening differently than we expected. Today being Easter, I wanted to weave a bunch of things together. You know, there are birds, which reminds me of eggs. There are new beginnings in the spring. There is, of course, the very human tendency to think about the future, which is often what happens this time of year. It's natural that we start thinking forward.

When we think about beginnings, eggs, and the future, it is possible to have the thought that the future has really changed, hasn't it? Or has it? Did the future ever really exist, except maybe in our minds? We're starting to see the impact of that on our system.

It is normal for humans to be able to project forward into the future and have an idea about how things are going to flow. That is one of the abilities of the human mind, and it's normal and fine to be doing that. But it's important that we relate to it skillfully. We need to relate to our ability to imagine the future, and try to bring it about, in a way that doesn't bring suffering for us. That's something that we have to learn over time as we work with our own minds and tendencies, and also with the way the external world flows—which is not always as we expect.

This is talked about in the Buddhist teachings in a number of different ways. The Buddha knew that people have this capacity to try to imagine things or aim toward things, and he wanted them to use that in a skillful way. One of the ways he talked about it was in how we walk our path, and our tendency to have goals. We decide that we want certain things, or that we want to let go of certain things, and we feel we're "working on" certain things as we see in our mind that we want to change them.

He had some teachings about this, and we'll go over a little bit of that today. I'm going to suggest that the way we relate to our spiritual practice—how we think about ourselves, working on our hearts, or our relationships—is similar to the way we walk through life in general. It is similar to the way we think about the future of our jobs or the things we're planning for our retirement. These are all activities where we project forward how we want things to go and try to move toward them.

There are ways to practice in which we aim toward a certain result. And there are also modes of practice where the main aim is simply to be in the present moment, to be as close as we can to the present, and not think about the past or the future. These are practices where we try to be with unfolding experience without clinging.

Following this kind of immediate way of practicing can allow the path to unfold in ways we wouldn't expect, sometimes taking us much farther than we would expect compared to when we're imagining something in the future to aim toward. That is an okay way to practice, but then we are limited by what we can imagine. Some of us may have experience with things happening that we could not have imagined, so we understand intuitively that our imagination doesn't always encompass all the possibilities.

There's a simile used a number of times in the suttas[2] that came to mind as I was thinking about this today. It's the simile of a hen sitting on her eggs, nurturing them so they'll hatch. It points out that her future-oriented wishes for her chicks are less important compared with whether or not she is properly incubating them.

Here is how the simile goes:

"Suppose a hen has eight, ten, or twelve eggs. If she doesn't cover them rightly, warm them rightly, or incubate them rightly, then even though this wish may occur to her, 'Oh, that my chicks might break through the egg shells with their spiked claws or beaks and hatch out safely.' Still, it is not possible that the chicks will break through the egg shells with their spiked claws or beaks and hatch out safely. Why is that? Because the hen has not covered them rightly, warmed them rightly, or incubated them rightly."

And then you get the converse:

"Suppose a hen has eight, ten, or twelve eggs and she does cover them rightly, warm them rightly, and incubate them rightly. Even though this wish may not occur to her, 'Oh, that my chicks might break through the eggshells with their spiked claws and beaks and hatch out safely.' Still, it is possible that the chicks will do that. Why is that? Because the hen has covered them, warmed them, and incubated them rightly."

It's a simple analogy, maybe simpler than our own lives, but we get the point: it's not so much about what we want, but more about what we do. Rather than having some future goal that we wish for, we can instead nurture what I like to call "the process of the path." We have a process that we're participating in, such as having eggs that are waiting to hatch, and the focus is on doing that process well. By linking it to a natural life process, we get the sense that this is a natural process we're engaged in. Often, another simile used is a seed growing into a tree.

Instead of imagining our little individual life proceeding in an external world and trying to make it be a certain way, can we rest more in the idea that there's a process going on that we get to participate in and tune into? It brings a different feeling to how we walk our path and approach our lives in general.

As often happens in the suttas, an image like this hen is followed by an application to Dharma practice. The Buddha says:

"Even though this wish may occur to a practitioner who dwells without devoting herself to development, 'Oh, that my mind might be released from suffering through lack of clinging.' Still, their mind is not released from suffering through lack of clinging. Why is that? Because of lack of development."

And then the inverse:

"Even though this wish may not occur to a practitioner who dwells devoting herself to development, 'Oh, that my mind might be released from suffering through lack of clinging.' Still, her mind is released from suffering through lack of clinging. And why is that? Due to development."

Again, it doesn't really matter whether you sit and wish for awakening or not; it matters whether the practices are done.

Developing what? The texts say, "due to development," or "the person dwells developing their mind." Different suttas give different answers, but they're all variations on the same theme of walking the Eightfold Path. If we're engaged in the practices about meditation, ethical conduct, and learning to see wisely, these practices will have a natural result in the mind becoming more free over time. It is much more important that we do that than we sit and wish, "I wish I could be free." The intention is clear that this moment matters.

It's important to do things well. The texts say "rightly," but we might just say "well," "skillfully," or "wholesomely." It's not that just anything will work. The Buddha gives a wide range of instructions, and we can study those and figure out which ones seem to work well for us.

We can also reflect on how poorly we tend to predict the future. I remember Gil[3] saying that one of the things that helped him let go of planning and trying to predict so much was when he started tabulating how good his record was at knowing what was going to come next. The reality is that we're not that good at it on a larger scale. We can predict certain things—like what's in the refrigerator, because we remember putting it in there—but as far as how things are going to go in the world tomorrow, we aren't so good.

I'm often surprised when I'm dealing with other folks that things go differently than I expect, sometimes in really good and surprising ways. So, I am finding that it's possible to let go of my tendency to think I can predict, plan, and control these sorts of things.

In a beautiful image from nature, caterpillars aren't very good at predicting what they're going to be in terms of a butterfly. That probably isn't in the mind of the caterpillar. I don't think they really know what that's going to be when they go into the chrysalis.

In a more human example, I remember a wonderful quote from Zen teacher Misha Merrill[4], who was talking about how we don't really know how our lives are going to unfold. She said, "You may think you're going to be a chocolate cake, but then you turn out to be a steak." It was quite amusing, because of course there are a lot of vegetarians in the Zen world, so it might be disturbing if you turn out to be a steak when you thought you were going to be a chocolate cake. Practice unfolds and even turns us into things that we didn't expect, and yet you'll deal with it. You'll probably be a good steak. I would encourage all of us to be good in whatever we're becoming in this current situation.

The Buddha had a more general and equanimous way of saying it. He said, "However people conceive it, it is ever other than that." Does that sound familiar right now?

Our ordinary mind likes ideas, plans, predictions, and structure, and this is fine, but invariably it's limiting because it tends to work within what is already known. We try so hard to engineer the future, but in reality, things are proceeding according to conditions that we can't fully see. So what is a more skillful approach to getting from here into the future, getting from now into the next week or month? A more reliable approach is to sense in the present moment what is happening and move forward from there.

Thich Nhat Hanh said, "To take care of the future, take care of the present." There's something very profound about that. It sounds almost too simple, but it brings us right into this moment. It essentially says if we get from this moment to the next moment—if we take care of this present moment—then we arrive in the best place that we could in the next moment. If we do the same thing, see where we are, take care of that present moment and go forward, then we'll get into the best possible version of the next future moment.

When things feel very uncertain, it can be very skillful to bring the mind into this very moment and focus on getting from here to the next moment, doing it well. What does "well" mean? It could mean calmly, kindly, peacefully, mindfully. Things that are in line with what we're developing in ourselves, what we value. Just do this, and then the next, and then the next.

I have a friend who is a very planning-oriented person, and she said that for a while her practice consisted simply of doing everything "quietly and well." As I reflected on that, I thought, that's a really good approach. If we could just do the things in our life quietly and well for a while, that would be really good.

At the Insight Meditation Society (IMS) retreat center in western Massachusetts, there is a picture on the wall outside the interview rooms. It's one of those Japanese ink drawings where you use a straw to chase the ink up the page. At the bottom, there is a picture of a plant with little stalks growing, the way stalks shoot up in the spring. Some are short, and then there is one stalk that goes all the way up about six feet on this tall, narrow page. The caption on it says something like, "Try not to have any expectations."

I think it's a very appropriate analogy for practice, and maybe for life. If we just stay with the present moment and follow it along, it might just go and go in some direction and shoot up into one of these tall flower stalks.

I'm not trying to imply a guaranteed, rosy future from things that are happening right now. I think there will be a lot of problems, and there already are. But I would still suggest that we don't really know, and that there is tremendous potential. One of the best things that we can do is simply to do this moment well. Ask yourself: What can I do right now to make this moment ethical, kind, gentle, mindful, or wise? Whatever feels appropriate for the moment.

Reflecting this way throughout the day can bring the mind back home to a feeling of just doing practice, just doing this moment. A lot of our spiritual path is actually about tuning into the voice that we have in our heart, the orientation that we have right here inside of us. It's not a voice we can hear easily because we have so much conditioning that's been put into our minds from our society. In these days when we are somewhat more quiet—even if your household isn't literally quiet, we at least have less stimulation coming from external world activities—it may be an opportunity to tune into that voice that we each have in our own heart, and see if we're willing to open to it and trust it.

It is something that we can hear long before awakening, and we can begin to place some of our trust in that inner quality. It's the same for life in the world. The way we go forward moment to moment can come from this voice, even if we're navigating relationships in our family every day. We can start to have some of this inner orientation as we go about our relationships from moment to moment.

The Buddha suggests in a teaching that simple awareness of this moment is one way that we can navigate. This teaching is called the Bhaddekaratta Sutta (A Single Excellent Night)[5], and I'm going to read part of the verse from that teaching:

Let not a person revive the past
Or on the future build her hopes.
For the past has been left behind
And the future has not been reached.
Instead with insight let her see
Each presently arisen state.
Let her know that and be sure of it
Invincibly, unshakably.

This teaching appears four times in a series in the Majjhima Nikāya[6], and the context is often that someone is trying to remember it. They'll ask somebody, "Do you remember that teaching?" and the other person says, "I don't remember that teaching. Do you remember it?" There's a sense that it's a teaching worth memorizing.

I know a teacher who encourages people to memorize it in the first person as an internal instruction, which I have done. I'll read the beginning part in the first person because I think it makes a helpful instruction that you might wish to bear in mind:

Let me not revive the past
Or on the future build my hopes.
For the past has been left behind
And the future has not been reached.
Instead, let me see with insight
Each presently arisen state.
Let me know that and be sure of it,
Invincibly, unshakably.

The past has been left behind. And the future has not been reached. There's just this moment. The moment when we can hear what's going on in our heart and we can respond to the people around us in a way that is kind, clear, wise, peaceful, and gentle. And maybe, if we do so, we'll hear the voice of the hermit thrush on these lovely spring days that we're enjoying. Thank you.

Questions and Answers

Kim Allen: If we have a few minutes, if anybody has any questions, you're welcome to unmute yourself. There are so many of you I can't see everyone on my screen, so you would need to unmute.

There are a few chats coming in. "Could I say which sutta the metaphor is from?" Oh, that's probably the hen sutta. That is found in several places. The Samyutta Nikaya[7] 22.101 or Majjhima Nikaya 53 would be good places to look. And the Single Excellent Night is Majjhima Nikaya 131.

All right. Have a good morning. Happy Easter. Be well.



  1. Vihara: A Pali and Sanskrit term for a Buddhist monastery or dwelling place for monastics. ↩︎

  2. Sutta: A Pali word meaning discourse or teaching of the Buddha. ↩︎

  3. Gil: Refers to Gil Fronsdal, the founding teacher of the Insight Meditation Center (IMC). ↩︎

  4. Misha Merrill: Original transcript phonetically said "Meisha Marrow"; corrected to Zen teacher Misha Merrill based on context. ↩︎

  5. Bhaddekaratta Sutta: A well-known discourse (MN 131) often translated as "A Single Excellent Night" or "An Auspicious Day," focusing on living deeply in the present moment. ↩︎

  6. Majjhima Nikāya: The Middle-Length Discourses of the Buddha, one of the major collections of suttas in the Pali Canon. ↩︎

  7. Samyutta Nikaya: The Connected Discourses of the Buddha, another major collection in the Pali Canon. ↩︎