Moon Pointing

Life of Vow

Date:
2026-11-08
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-11 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Life of Vow

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Life of Vow

So good morning everyone and welcome.

When my son was in third grade, during the first week, the teacher gave all the students a poem, or part of a poem, that they had to memorize for the year. Once a week, each student in the class—I think there were 20 or 30 students—would recite their poem to the whole class. I asked my son, who is now 28, about that poem. He says he has no memory of it.

Maybe the poem was not meant for the kids; maybe it was meant for their parents, because I remember it. It was inspiring for me. It was two lines from a poem by May Sarton, and it goes something like:

Without darkness nothing comes to birth. Without light nothing comes to flower.

That's what he had to recite, and I thought that spoke to me very well and was very meaningful. At some point, I looked up the poem, and it actually has another phrase that begins with the sentence: "Help us be gardeners of the spirit, knowing without darkness nothing comes to birth, without light nothing flowers."

So what is it in our life that grows unbeknownst to us? What are the conditions that allow something to grow and be born? And what is it that's being born that then needs the light of our awareness, that needs us to focus on it?

The Bodhisattva Vow

I say this poem because, looking back over my decades of Buddhist practice, I look back at my early years when I was doing Zen practice. I've heard a lot of Buddhist teachings, and I've read a lot of Buddhist teachings. But maybe it was fortunate for me that I didn't really concern myself very much with them until I was ready—until something inside of me was ready to hear it. It became meaningful and significant not because it was coming from the outside in, but because it was helping me recognize something that was happening from the inside out. Something was being born, something was coming and growing.

Interestingly enough, one of those things in Zen is the idea of vow. Vow is very important in Mahayana[1] Buddhism and in Zen. I blissfully ignored all the teachings about vow and all the importance of it until the day arose where something about vow got born inside of me. I recognized, "Oh, there's something here that resonates with what they're talking about. There's something here that makes sense to me that becomes a vow."

There are a number of things like that, but I'll give you one example. As I was growing in my Zen practice, it came to a point where compassion and love were growing in me. I could see that I could occasionally, accidentally maybe, love everyone. That was a capacity of the heart: to love everyone. At some point, that ability to love everyone, regardless of the situation—who they were, or what they had done to me even—felt like a place of great value. It felt like a place of integrity, or wholeness. It felt like this was the deepest part of myself that I wanted to live by and be close to. I could feel that if I decided to hate someone instead, it would harm something. It would close something down. I would lose touch with something, and I would be coming from someplace that I didn't want to stand behind. I wanted to live a life where I stayed close to this place where I could love everyone.

I wouldn't say I thought of it at that time as a vow, but that was my commitment. This is how I want to live. It changed my life to understand that.

Related to that is the classic vow in Zen: the vow to save all beings. There is something called the Bodhisattva vow[2] that they chant every day in Zen. It goes something like:

Beings are numberless, I vow to save them. Desires (or as we might say in our tradition, clinging) are inexhaustible, I vow to end them all. Dharma gates are boundless, I vow to go through them all. The Buddha's way is unsurpassable, I vow to become it.

It has an interesting twist: "I vow to become it." Maybe it was Frank Sinatra who sang "The Impossible Dream." It's kind of like this is the impossible dream that the Zen people chant.

I chanted it for many years without thinking about it much; it's just kind of what you were supposed to do. Then at some point, it dawned on me that this is how I wanted to live my life. It wasn't so disembodied; rather, this is what was welling up inside of me. Responding to the suffering of the world was what this heart was about. This is the being that had been born, and though it maybe hadn't flowered yet, this was the being that I was. What made the most sense to me was to stay true to that and live with that.

There was something about this impossible vow of Zen—"Beings are numberless, I vow to save them all." I never took it literally, as if I was going to successfully manage that. What I took literally was the desire to live that way, doing what I can. If I live a few billion years, maybe I'll have some hope to do it! But being successful wasn't the point. The point was to step forward into the world that way. Not because it was a promise or a duty that I had to fulfill, but rather because this is what made my heart sing. This is what made my heart beautiful or wonderful. I wanted to stay true to that.

This idea of vow for me was not exactly a promise, and it didn't come from the outside. I was ordained as a Zen priest at some point. The heart of that is to take the Bodhisattva vows. It sounds like you're promising and committing, like you're obligated because you made this commitment. Fortunately for my unusual mind, I never saw it that way. Maybe my teacher would have been upset with me, but how I saw it was that I was acknowledging what was already in me, acknowledging how I want to find a way to live. Commitment is a heavy word, but a love for this, a dedication to this, a devotion to this—this is what's important.

It made a difference for me. It's been almost 45 years since I was ordained, and thinking about this Bodhisattva vow, I feel like it's still in me. It's still at the center of my life. I don't feel like it's at odds with our Theravada[3] tradition. The movement in Theravada Buddhism is also a movement towards responding to suffering wholeheartedly and completely, wherever it might be encountered. If it's encountered in yourself, that's where we address it. As we address it in ourselves, sooner or later, you're going to bump into someone else who's suffering. It happens occasionally. Rather than pull away, shut down, or say, "Well, that's your problem," it is something to respond to. It is something to care for, something to foster peace and freedom from suffering.

The Four Resolves

This vow has been a very important part of my life. In our Theravada tradition, there is something that is like a vow. There are four of them, just like the four Bodhisattva vows.

The word for them in the ancient language is adhiṭṭhāna[4]. Don't try to memorize it, but adhi- means "higher" and ṭhāna is a very ordinary word for "to stand." So, the higher stand. Some translators have rendered it as "foundation"—the foundation on which we stand. It's like the four foundation stones for a temple. What's the temple? You. Or if you don't like temples, the foundation for freedom, the foundation for life. These are the four foundation stones on which you build this wonderful dharma realm. They are the four standing stones on which you stand tall. In English, we say "taking a stand," which can mean staying committed to something. It is a higher stand, which is not the same thing as "standing your ground," which maybe isn't always so good.

Sometimes rather than calling them foundations, they're called resolves, or aspirations. I offer these different possibilities—foundation, aspiration, resolve, orientation—so that you can find your own words. Part of the art of being a good Buddhist student is this personal side of it. What does it touch in you? Sometimes you have to re-translate it for yourself. Give it a different word to make it work. A foundation stone of a house? Give me a break. [Laughter]

As you listen to these four resolves, don't listen to them as things "out there" that the Buddha said 2,500 years ago, things you have to believe, react to, reject, or protect yourself from. Rather, might it be that these four things already live in you? If they're already there, what happens when you recognize them in yourself? What changes in you? Can you imagine yourself saying, "Yes, this is something to stand on. This should be a good foundation to come from. Let me stand on these wherever I go."

Wisdom (Paññā)

The first one is wisdom. Wisdom is not a bunch of knowledge you read in a Buddhist book, memorize, and then live your life by. Wisdom is an activity, an action in the moment of seeing clearly.

Some people will translate the Pali word paññā[5] as "discernment." It really just means being discerning in the moment. What is happening here? How do I really understand, see, or recognize what's going on? I sometimes like to translate the Pali word paññā as "insight" because we are seeing into something very clearly.

What the tradition most emphasizes is having the discernment to clearly know for yourself: this is healthy, and this is not healthy. Emotionally, psychologically, spiritually. The ancient word is better rendered as wholesome. This is wholesome; this is unwholesome. This is helpful; this is unhelpful.

To have wisdom is to have the discernment to clearly see that distinction for yourself. If it's snowing outside and you go out in your t-shirt when it's 20 degrees below, that's probably not very helpful or healthy for you. You have the discernment to put on warmer clothes. If the mail carrier brings the mail at 6:30 in the evening when it's dark, and you yell at them, "How could you? Don't you realize that I need to have my mail earlier? It's very inconvenient!" Have the discernment before you say it: "This is not a good thing to do. There's no need. It has no real purpose. I'm just venting my frustration." Maybe there's a better way to vent your frustration. Maybe you should meditate. Then you'll have a better relationship with your mail carrier next time.

This discernment applies in meditation too. You sit quietly in meditation, and your mind starts going into something as simple as what you want for dinner. That's innocent enough, but then you find your mind locking in, getting tight and busy, getting upset because you didn't buy the right things yesterday at the grocery store. Your mind is taking off, but because you're sitting quietly, you notice it. A bit of discernment says, "You know, this isn't what I really want to do. This was pretty special for me that I was sitting and meditating, calmer and more peaceful than I have maybe ever been. I think I should stop thinking about dinner."

There's a discernment, a seeing, a choice. We choose the healthy one over the unhealthy one, the beneficial one over the unbeneficial one. In our tradition, that's what wisdom is: staying grounded on this idea. Look carefully and discern. Recognize not what you want (because wanting is overrated and isn't always the best thing for you), and not what you don't want. Not what you prefer, like, or dislike, but what is healthy, wholesome, and beneficial for you and for others.

Truth (Sacca)

This leads to the second foundation: the resolve of truth[6].

Truth is getting into something more exalted. A lot of people say they want to be committed to truth and be truthful—often more than they actually are. One of the really important areas of truth in the Dharma is telling yourself the truth.

Once you start talking about the philosophy or ethics of truth, people will come and ask, "What about when the ICE officers come to your door and say, 'Do you have any undocumented immigrants in your house?' Well, you kind of do. What do you say? We have to tell the truth, right?" People want to debate this. It's an interesting and important topic to discuss, and maybe there's a time not to say the literal truth. But the one place in Buddhism where it's never okay to avoid the truth is when you're speaking to yourself.

The mythology of Buddhism says that the Buddha lived for many lifetimes before he became a Buddha. He had a lot of adventures and made a lot of mistakes, breaking precepts in his previous lifetimes as part of his growing up. But the one mistake he never made in the mythology is that he never lied. It is that important for the spiritual life not to lie to yourself. It can be a hard thing to do because sometimes we don't even know we're doing it.

Stay close to the truth. What truth do we stay close to? The truth of what wisdom has shown us. This is helpful, and this is not helpful. This is wholesome; this is not wholesome. It's a pragmatic, functional truth. It's not some abstraction, but a truth for how we can live our lives.

Generosity and Relinquishment (Cāga)

The third foundation or resolve is a very interesting one because the word in Pali is cāga[7] (c-a-g-a). It has two meanings, and no one really knows which one we're supposed to use for these four resolves. Maybe both meanings should be understood to work together.

One meaning of cāga is generosity. To take a higher stand on being generous is seen over and over again in the teachings of early Buddhism. It's almost as if generosity is the beginning of the path of practice. To this day in Asia, many lay people don't meditate, but they practice generosity. I had a friend with tremendous psychological challenges who needed years of psychotherapy. When she went to her Buddhist teacher for support, he encouraged her to be generous. That made a world of difference for her. It was an opening that allowed her to find her way, start psychotherapy, and find healing.

What I like about generosity as foundational to Buddhism is that it puts our practice in the world of relationships with other people. A lot of people in the West begin their Buddhist practice by meditating: they sit down, close their eyes, and forget about the people out there. But practice is deeply relational. The heart of Buddhism, all the way to enlightenment, could be understood as an ethical teaching. To be generous establishes our mindfulness and awareness in the field of our relationships.

The other meaning of cāga is relinquishment, renunciation, or letting go. They work together because it's hard to give something away without letting go of it. Sometimes it's hard to give because we're not ready to let go, so we get to look at our fear, resistance, and clinging.

Letting go is an act that is supposed to be beautiful. In Buddhism, there's a lot of emphasis on letting go, but you have not really let go unless you feel some joy in it. Maybe you shouldn't let go if you're not going to feel joy. If you just feel neutral after letting go, it might come back and bite you.

We let go of clinging and grasping because we have the wisdom to recognize that it is not healthy or wholesome. So cāga can be generosity, letting go, or both: generous letting go, or letting go generously.

Peace (Upasama)

The fourth of these resolves is peace[8]. To be resolved on peace, to base your life on peace, to stand on peace, to have a vow for peace.

Why? You should answer that for yourself, but I can say that for me, to get agitated, hostile, mean, or restless—these are all ways that we are not peaceful. I have the discernment and insight to see that I'm harming myself when that happens. Why would I harm myself? Why would I diminish my wisdom and my ability to stay true?

Where there is peace, letting go brings joy and something beautiful. It doesn't diminish us or limit us. This is how to live an unlimited life in Buddhism. The Buddha talked about greed, hatred, delusion, and conceit—being caught up in self-definition limits us. To let go of these is the wise, beneficial thing to do. That is how we care for ourselves. That's how we live an unrestricted heart.

Reflections and Community

These four resolves are different from the four Bodhisattva vows of Mahayana Buddhism, but maybe there's a way of understanding that the behavior and the way we move through the world can be the same.

It doesn't have to be something you do out of duty. My hope is that what is growing in the dark for you, what is being born in the dark, is something beautiful, profound, and meaningful that one day flowers in you as a resolve to orient your life around these four: wisdom, truth, generosity and letting go, and peace.

This is my challenge to you: reflect on this. How is this for you? If you're really honest, if you take the time to reflect deeply, what do you base your life on if not these four? If an anthropologist from Mars came to study you and all they saw was your behavior and your screen time, they'd go back to Mars and say, "Oh, these people, they're really committed to Netflix. It must be their god. It's the most important thing." So, what do you base your life on?

I've had my turn here. Thank you. Now, we have time before the official ending. Because there's tea today, it's nice that you have a chance to say hello and introduce yourself to each other. You're also welcome to sit silently—it's really nice to be silent meditating when everyone's talking! For those who want to say hello, maybe share something about this talk with your friend that's not too personal, but something evocative or useful for you. In about seven or eight minutes, I'll ring the bell so we can finish.



  1. Mahayana: A broad movement of Buddhism that emphasizes the Bodhisattva path and the vow to save all sentient beings. ↩︎

  2. Bodhisattva vows: Original transcript transcribed this as "Buddhist sata vows"; corrected based on context. A Bodhisattva is a being on the path to awakening, motivated by great compassion to save all beings. ↩︎

  3. Theravada: Original transcript transcribed this as "terrain / terraata"; corrected based on context. Theravada ("School of the Elders") is the oldest surviving branch of Buddhism. ↩︎

  4. Adhiṭṭhāna: Original transcript transcribed this as "adana"; corrected based on context. A Pali word meaning determination, resolve, or foundation. ↩︎

  5. Paññā: Original transcript transcribed this as "pa"; corrected based on context. A Pali word for wisdom, insight, or discernment. ↩︎

  6. Sacca: A Pali word meaning truth or truthfulness. ↩︎

  7. Cāga: Original transcript transcribed this as "chaga / chuga"; corrected based on context. A Pali word for generosity, relinquishment, or letting go. ↩︎

  8. Upasama: A Pali word meaning peace or calm. ↩︎