Moon Pointing

Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (2 of 9): Mindfulness of Breathing

Date:
2020-03-31
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-16 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (2 of 9): Mindfulness of Breathing

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (2 of 9): Mindfulness of Breathing

Welcome back to our introduction to mindfulness meditation. You might want to keep in the back of your mind a very simple definition for meditation. Not that it is, by any means, the final definition of what mindfulness is, but it is a nice reminder of a possibility: meditation is the continual act of befriending yourself. Ideally, there would be a sense of kindness or kind regard towards oneself when we meditate. Of course, that's not always going to happen, but can there at least be some kind regard? Can we be friendly even towards that which is difficult, even the difficult feelings we might be having? We're not trying to avoid what's really going on for us, but over and over again, we're trying to meet it in a way that is kind, friendly, or caring, and not dismissive or disrespectful to ourselves.

With that general introduction to mindfulness, one of the important characteristics of mindfulness is what's called recognition or comprehension. It is not only being aware of what's happening, but having a relaxed, easy capacity to recognize what's happening as it's happening.

So many times, we live in the generalizations of life. With mindfulness, we're beginning to create more clarity in the mind, so we see more and more the specificity of the moment. We see what is actually happening, moment by moment, that would be invisible to us if we were living in the abstract idea of what's happening. An example that I've used before is when someone tells you that they're having a "bad day." Maybe they're having a lot of difficulty, and I don't want to deny that for them. But to label and call it a "bad day," it too easily becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. It becomes the lens through which we see everything, how we understand ourselves, and how we understand the day.

You might be walking with this person in a beautiful park with blue skies, sun, and nice weather. At that particular moment, it certainly doesn't seem like a bad day. Maybe they are having a really hard time at work, something big is going on, and it's bothering them a lot. But it is not the whole picture.

We begin breaking up the hold of our big-picture view of things and seeing what is happening in the moment. For example, there's a world of difference between being swept into the view that "it's a bad day" and seeing everything through that lens, versus having the mindfulness and clarity to recognize, "Those are my thoughts that it's a bad day." We really see with clarity that this is a way of thinking, an interpretation that I've put on top of it. In more detail, we might notice: "I'm feeling afraid, and that fear is in my belly. There are thoughts about the future and predictions. My breathing has become shallow and tight. And the sky is blue. I'm feeling comfortable, I just had a nice meal, and my stomach is comfortable—I was hungry before."

As mindfulness gets clearer, we are able to be in the present moment. There's greater clarity about what's actually happening, so we can see what is a thought, what is a feeling, what is an interpretation, and what are the actual details of the moment. This begins to carry a little more freedom in our experience when we see each thing for itself.

I like to think of it as being very respectful of everything we're aware of. Everything is allowed to be in its own simple way. We can't let each thing be its own thing if we have these generalizations like "Oh, it's a bad day," or even "It's a good day." Something is lost in the generalization of how we see things. The same thing is true for ourselves. If we have generalizations about ourselves, and that is how we see ourselves, then we're missing something. We are missing the ability to connect to the unfolding of what is really happening, moment by moment, in all its different ways and aspects.

One of the ways we do this in mindfulness practice is with conscious recognition. It is not just being aware of something, but recognizing it in the simplest possible way. We are not analyzing it, probing into it to find out what it is, or looking into its causes and conditions. We really just see, "Oh, that's what it is. That's the experience." We notice what is obvious about it, as opposed to something sophisticated.

A technique used in mindfulness practice that some people find very helpful is called a mental note label[1]. This is using a thought to help you be present and to recognize what is happening with a little bit of specificity. People who don't use mental noting will sometimes notice that their mind all too easily wanders off in thought. If there is a lot of thinking going on, it might be nice to redirect the thinking in a way that supports meditation. We use these one-word thoughts, so you're still using the thinking mind, but you're using it to connect to the moment and to be mindful.

If you are breathing, you might say "in" as you breathe in, and "out" as you breathe out. If you are hearing a sound, you might say "hearing, hearing." If there is a thought, you might say "thinking." Sometimes, people like to repeat the label a few times: "thinking, thinking, thinking." The reason for the repetition is that by the third time, maybe we've managed to find some freedom from it, where we step back and see clearly, "Oh, that's what's happening," as opposed to being entangled in it.

It is an art form to do this mental noting. Not everyone does it, and not everyone finds it useful. Some people discover over time that it's useful in some moments and not others. Learning it is like riding a bicycle: at first, it's wobbly and kind of awkward. But after a while, it becomes second nature to ride the bike. For some people, this mental noting becomes second nature and can really help us stay on track in the present moment.

I've known people who thought that their minds were too busy if they did mental noting. But if they look at their mind, they see they're actually just drifting effortlessly off in thought, often in a habitual way that's comforting, but they're not really present. Bringing in that little recognition—the mental note—can make a big difference.

Guided Meditation

Show meditation Hide meditation

So we will do a little meditation now. What I'd like to suggest is that when we settle down and start practicing with breathing, you might want to try using a gentle note, a soft little whisper in the mind. It could be "in" as you breathe in, and "out" as you breathe out. The classic label is "rising" as the chest or belly rises, and "falling" as it falls.

Experiment with the tone of voice in which you use the mental noting. Let it be kind, relaxed, and simple. It's not a sledgehammer that's supposed to hit everything over the head. It's not supposed to be forceful, and it's also not supposed to be reluctant. It is just a matter-of-fact, "Oh, that's what's going on," in a soft, quiet, relaxed way. The tone of voice you use should be supportive for who you are, helping you become a little bit calmer, more settled, and interested in seeing things in the moment more clearly.

If you find yourself drifting off in thought a lot, you might add the mental note "thinking." Clearly acknowledge that you're thinking. There's something about the clear acknowledgment of things that helps us become a little freer from them. Maybe the third time you say it—"thinking, thinking, thinking"—you can relax the thinking muscle, and then begin again with your breathing.

So, please take a posture for meditation that will be comfortable for you for the next 20 minutes, but also a posture that expresses a little bit of attentiveness, like you're going to be attentive to what's happening here and now.

Take a little bit of time to settle into that posture. Make small adjustments to be a little bit more aligned and balanced. And then softly close your eyes.

Very simply, become aware of how your body is breathing, with no concern about a "right" or "wrong" way to breathe. Just make a little connection with your breathing. Take a few long, deep in-breaths and out-breaths. As you breathe in, feel the expansion of the ribcage, the expansion of the torso, and the lifting of the shoulders. As you exhale, feel everything gather back together and contract. Feel the settling in. Breathe in deeply, and settle in as you exhale.

Then, return your breathing to normal. It is useful to scan through your body to see if there are some simple places you might relax. Perhaps you can relax the muscles of your forehead, around your eyes, your cheeks, and even your jaws might soften a bit. Relax your shoulders. It can be particularly useful to soften your belly, letting your belly hang forward and out. Maybe two or three times in the course of the meditation, check in with your belly and relax it. Don't worry if it gets tight again; it's just nice to relax it and feel the weight of your body settle a little bit further down into the pelvic cavity.

Within your body, as part of your bodily experience, become aware of the body breathing. Become aware of the more subtle expansions and contractions of the torso as you breathe. Or, if it is more comfortable for you to feel the air going in and out through your nostrils, feel the tingling, warmth, and coolness of those sensations.

As a way of getting settled into the recognition part of mindfulness, gently recognize how the experience of inhaling is different from the experience of exhaling. Different sensations come into play, different kinds of movements.

Take a moment to relax your thinking muscle—any pressure, tension, or energy associated with thinking, maybe behind the forehead or inside the skull. Let that relax and soften a bit, and then relax into the experience of breathing. Perhaps every time you exhale, you can let go of your thoughts.

To start the mental noting, very quietly, softly, and calmly use the note "in" or "rising" for the inhale, and "out" or "falling" for the exhale.

If there is a loud sound that pulls your attention, you can use the note "hearing." If you really get pulled into the world of thoughts, you might note "thinking, thinking, thinking," and then begin again with your breathing.

If thoughts take you away from the breathing, there is no need to be disturbed by that. The idea is to recognize that that's what's happening, maybe with the mental note "thinking." Sometimes, if it's acknowledged clearly, it can be easier to begin again with the breathing.

If you find yourself repeatedly being pulled into the world of thinking, then perhaps with every exhale, relax the thinking muscle. With every exhale, let go of your thoughts and let go into the experience of the body breathing.

If anything is happening for you now that makes meditation a challenge—maybe physical sensations, restlessness, emotions, or thoughts—take a few moments to recognize it with a mental note. It doesn't have to be too accurate. Use a simple mental note and repeat it a few times in a relaxed way, to see if you can step back and disentangle from what's happening. View it as if you have an overview of it, as opposed to being caught in it.

For the last minute or so of the sitting, return to your breathing. If possible, let your mind become quiet. Give yourself over to the breathing for one minute. Feel every breath like it is massaging you from the inside.

To end this sitting, take a few long, slow, deep breaths. Feel connected to your body, feel the contact with your chair, cushion, or the floor. When you hear the bell ending the sitting, you can open your eyes.

[Bell rings]

The Power of Recognition

One of the things I am emphasizing today is that basic mindfulness practice includes the recognition of what is happening, as it's happening. There is a learning curve to mindfulness—learning what it really means to just stay with the present-moment experience. One of the things it means is that we do very little retroactive thinking or analysis. Even if it happened three or five seconds ago, we try not to spend time thinking about it, because then you are staying in the past. You want to always be ready to step up and just feel what is happening now.

In this way, mindfulness is very forgiving. If it wasn't going quite right a minute ago, that is ancient history. The practice is to be ready to meet the next thing, not carrying the weight of what happened, and not carrying the expectations of the past into the future. If what was happening before was good, we do not try to get back there. We just meet the next moment: "Oh, this is how it is."

The recognition factor is very important because whatever is happening in the present moment, if you recognize that it is happening, you are doing mindfulness successfully. Mindfulness works even when it doesn't work. By that, I mean if you are unable to stay calm with your breathing, but you can recognize what is happening instead, that is mindfulness. It works even if your idea of what it is supposed to be isn't happening. It's very forgiving and freeing: the simple act of recognizing, "Oh, it's this now. Now it's this. Oh, it's like this."

It takes a while for practitioners to learn how significant it is to keep coming back to the simple act of recognition. There is a kind of freedom, an easing up, a calming of a situation when you simply recognize, "Oh, it's like this. This is what's going on."

In breath meditation, the breath serves as the baseline of what we are doing. We practice developing mindfulness with breathing, but the breathing functions a little bit like an analogy I learned while looking at a very clear, slow-moving stream. Looking at the water, I couldn't tell it was moving; it looked like it was standing still. I took a little twig and placed it vertically into the water. Then I saw a little wake form around the edges of the stick, and I could see the movement of the water.

Sometimes it's hard to see the movements of our own mind. We are so enmeshed in the river of our own life that we don't see with clarity how much energy there is, how much tension there is, or how many feelings there are. Coming back to the breathing—trying to stay with your breathing over time—is like putting that stick into the stream. You might not be successful at staying with the breathing, but don't worry about it. It is enough that you are trying. Because you are trying, you might start seeing, "Oh, this thinking mind is very powerful; I had no idea it was that powerful. I'm easily distractible. I'm caught up in X, Y, and Z, and I didn't realize how much I was concerned with them. I didn't realize I have all these emotions moving through, or how tense I am holding my body."

All kinds of things show themselves. You might say, "Well, it's making it impossible to stay with my breathing, and therefore I'm not meditating right." But the breathing meditation has done its job if it highlights for you what is going on that you hadn't seen clearly before. Recognize it: "Oh, this is what's going on." Have an open-handed attitude of, "It's like this right now," as opposed to, "Oh no!" or "Oh yes, I want more of that!"

As a person includes this recognition factor in their mindfulness practice, my hope is that they learn that even a moment of recognition is quite significant. I have seen books and articles about "Ten-Minute Mindfulness" or "One-Minute Mindfulness," focusing on efficiency. I would like to come back to the idea of "one-moment mindfulness." You can just take a moment, and if you have a clear recognition of what's happening, you can sometimes find freedom in that.

Maybe you've had the experience of someone naming what's going on in a room. Someone says, "Everyone is afraid right now," or "Everyone is excited." People are so afraid or excited they haven't even noticed, but as soon as someone names it, everyone realizes, "Oh yes, that's what's happening." We can do that for ourselves through this act of recognition.

This mindfulness practice is broad and allows us to be present in a friendly way with all of our experience. We are building the capacity for a heightened, useful form of awareness that can be used in all circumstances. We want a clear recognition—a settled awareness strong enough that when we're aware of any part of our human experience, there's a sense of freedom, space, and calm. This way, we aren't distracted or caught by what's happening. That makes a huge difference in everyday life.

It is nice to cultivate some continuity with the breathing, hanging in there with the rhythm of breathing in and out. Don't demand it, and don't feel like it's wrong if you can't do it, but it is useful to make the effort. The breathing can be relaxing, focusing, and settling. A lot of benefit in mindfulness comes when we're focused, calm, and settled. It's simply a wise thing to do in life: to have an ability to calm ourselves down quickly, and breathing is one of those things.

Yesterday, I taught the practice of the three-breath journey. I hope some of you have tried it over the last 24 hours and found it useful. In just three breaths, it's possible to settle oneself. I've done it in social situations with my eyes open; no one knew I was doing it, but I found that after three breaths, I was much more attentive and present.

We will keep using breathing as a foundation, but we are always ready to leave it if something else needs to be acknowledged and recognized.

A Short Exercise

I'd like to offer you a teeny little exercise. Perhaps you can just close your eyes exactly where you are, and discover for yourself the answer to this question in the present moment: What are you primarily aware of? What is the clearest experience of the moment?

Use a single mental note label to clearly recognize what that is. You might repeat that mental note a few times, as if you're taking two or three steps back to see objectively, to get an overview, and to make space around the experience without being caught up or reactive.

And then open your eyes.

The idea is to do that even shorter than the three-breath journey. This simple act of noticing, "This is what's going on," and naming it, strengthens our ability to recognize. One of the consequences of stronger powers of recognition is that everyday, moment-to-moment experience becomes clearer. Often, when the mind is claustrophobic with thinking—a lot of thoughts, desires, and concerns coming one after another—it obscures the sharp clarity of the moment. As mindfulness gets stronger, it almost becomes synonymous with greater clarity.

Maybe you've had the experience of waking up in the afternoon from a nice nap. Everything inside is calm and peaceful, and you feel refreshed. You look at things in the room, or go outside, and the individual things you look at stand out in highlight. That flower, that tree, that sidewalk—even a piece of candy wrapper on the ground stands out. The silver and the colors shine. A busy, reactive mind makes it hard to see the beauty and specificity of each thing.

It is a bit of a miracle that we are conscious. Normally, we are very consumed by what we are thinking about. We seldom step back and marvel that we even think to begin with. Five billion years of evolution have brought us to this point, to have thoughts like having pizza for dinner! Just the fact that we think is a miracle. Even more of a miracle is the fact that we are conscious. If we can step back, not be preoccupied with what we're conscious about, but simply know we are conscious, it is a game-changer. We live in an amazing world.

As we become more mindful of the present moment and appreciate the miracle of being conscious, the spaciousness of being aware becomes an open door for wisdom. It is an open door for deeper, beneficial emotions and impulses to come to the surface. When we're preoccupied with our thoughts and activities, those doors are closed; there is no space for something deeper to arise. Mindfulness of the present moment can lead to an amazement that we are conscious.

Five-Minute Meditation

Show meditation Hide meditation

I would like to suggest that we end with a five-minute meditation. You don't have to change your posture, or you can take a meditation posture if you'd like. Gently close your eyes. With nothing more you have to do, take a few moments to recognize how you are right now. What's up for you? Are you restless, settled, agitated, calm, content, or discontent? Is your body relaxed or tense? Does your thinking have the upper hand, racing along with you following it, or do you have a little more space from your thoughts?

Just recognize how you are. As you do, see if you can be very spacious and allowing. In the field of awareness, just let it be the way it is. One of the great mantras for meditation is the phrase, "It's okay."

Then, in the middle of what's happening—in the middle of how you are—become aware of your breathing. Become aware of the rhythm of breathing in and breathing out. As you breathe, you could almost imagine it is like a wave or a massage moving through what is happening for you. You are recognizing your experience, but almost as if your breathing is massaging it and moving through it. You are bringing these two things together: breathing and the recognition of what's happening.

And then, make yourself ready to open your eyes again and come out of the meditation as we end with this little bell.

[Bell rings]

Closing Remarks

In the last five minutes of our time together, I will say a few things. Often, when people are new to meditation, a fair number ask questions about sleepiness. "I get so sleepy when I meditate."

Some people are sleep-deprived and need to sleep more than they need to meditate. But there are other reasons why people get sleepy when they meditate. Sometimes working with sleepiness is a part of meditation. It is one of the things we can recognize in a mindful way: "Oh, sleepy. This is how it is."

A few practical things you can do: open your eyes. Sometimes leaving the eyes half-open, looking down at 45 degrees to the floor, is enough to bring alertness. Sitting someplace where there is bright light can make you more alert. Sometimes sitting up straighter, or even doing standing meditation, has more energy in it and helps us stay awake.

I would also suggest trying to do a 20-minute meditation between now and the next time we meet. If you can't, that's okay, but I encourage you to try using what we've talked about so far.

Additionally, in the next 24 hours, look for a situation in your ordinary life where you can use the little recognition practice. Stop in the middle of what's going on, close your eyes if you'd like, and just notice what's happening in the present moment. Use a mental note to recognize it clearly. Say the mental note a few times in a relaxed way, and see if you can begin finding some freedom or space around what's happening so you aren't entangled in it. Run that exercise a few times and see what you learn about yourself, the present moment, and the usefulness of this practice.

Tomorrow we are going to introduce mindfulness of the body. We will spend two days on mindfulness of the body. I'm sure some of you already have uncomfortable knees, backs that hurt, and different things going on. Learning how to be mindful of both the discomforts and the comforts of the body is an important part of mindfulness meditation.

Thank you for being part of this, for listening, and participating. I look forward to our time tomorrow. May you be well. Thank you.



  1. Mental Noting: A mindfulness technique often associated with the Mahasi Sayadaw tradition of Vipassana (Insight) meditation, where the practitioner silently labels their experience (e.g., "thinking," "hearing," "rising") to help anchor attention in the present moment. ↩︎