Doing What's Beautiful
- Date:
- 2019-11-11
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-15 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Doing What's Beautiful
Good evening everyone. Welcome to IMC. It might be a little bit loud today, they have a volume, so let's see. How does that sound out loud? Loud enough for everyone? Yep, okay.
I think there's a fair number of people who, one way or the other, are concerned about knowing what is the right thing to do. Maybe because they want to do the right thing, or they want to somehow at least know what it is. There are people who want to know what the ethical thing is to do. What's the right thing to do, the wrong thing to do, the good thing to do, the bad thing to do? When people come to religions such as Buddhism, that sometimes takes a stronger emphasis because somehow religion is supposed to have wisdom, rules, and ideas about what is right, what is good, and what is that goal. It's not a few people who will come to a Buddhist teacher and ask, "What is the right thing to do here?" In some ways, it's quite a wonderful thing that people are concerned and careful, and many people ask the question because they don't want to harm someone.
But sometimes the questions are asked because they have some abstract idea that there's a right and a wrong, a good and a bad, and they feel obligated—they're required—to do the right thing or be the right thing. If they're Buddhists, they want to know the Buddhist "right thing." And if they're Buddhists at a center, then they're particularly concerned about doing the right thing. I'm going on like this because it's one way of thinking; it's not so uncommon.
But what would happen if, instead of asking what is the right thing, what is the good thing to do, what's the ethical thing to do... what if the question was, "What's the beautiful thing to do?"
What's the beautiful thing to do here? I think that that would create a different kind of orientation. I believe that the question "what's the beautiful thing" would not immediately evoke people's ethical sensibilities or immediately evoke the idea of what's the right thing to do, as if we have an obligation or duties. I think if you ask, "What's the beautiful thing to do?", some people would relax or be inspired. "Oh, that's an interesting thing. Yeah, I'd like to know what that is." There'd be a little bit more inspiration, or maybe even delight. What's the beautiful thing to do?
This is also true in our own minds. It's one thing to do the right thing in terms of our behavior in the world and what we say. It's another thing to be concerned about what's the right thing for your own mind. That can become a particularly oppressive burden for people because we're not exactly in control of our own mind. Our mind has a mind of its own sometimes, and it has its own thoughts, impulses, desires, and all kinds of things going on in there. To have this idea that certain movements of the mind are the wrong movements to have, the bad movements to have... some people identify those movements much more closely with who they really are than maybe their actions. Not a few people struggle with themselves and are in conflict with themselves because they have some idea that they're supposed to internally be a certain way. They're supposed to always be generous, or always have good thoughts, or always have compassionate thoughts, or not be the opposite of those things. All kinds of ideas.
But what if you look at your mind and wonder about how the mind operates, and there you ask the question, "What's the beautiful thing for my mind to do?" How would that shift you? What would be the beautiful thing internally in your own mind? If no one else sees it, why bother? Because it's beautiful. It's a delight, it's a joy, it's an inspiration to just be. Of course, it would be nice to have it beautiful in there. What if your mind was one of the most beautiful things that you've ever seen in the world? How would you relate to your mind if you decided the mind was really beautiful?
There's a story I'd like to tell. When I was about thirty, I had been practicing for about ten years or so, and I went to Asia to practice. Part of doing Vipassana was a month-long retreat in Kathmandu, Nepal. I arrived there some days before the retreat, and having nothing to do, I just wandered around. I was a little bit of a tourist wandering the streets here and there. I came across—they had a lot of them, probably still do—all these little shops with Buddhist artwork, paintings, statues, clothes, and stuff mostly for the tourists coming through.
There was one shop that had a Buddhist statue in the window that really captivated me, and I thought, "I'd like to buy that." I had very little money. I don't remember how much the statue cost, but it was probably like a hundred dollars, and that was maybe a third of how much money I had—a third of my worldly wealth! So it was a lot of money, right? And I was in Asia to practice for the duration, I had no plans of coming back exactly. It was a big deal to buy it or not buy it. But I tell you what, it was really a good statue.
Then it occurred to me that while this statue was beautiful and inspiring, the most beautiful thing I know in the universe is a pure mind. I thought to myself, "I'm not gonna buy it. I'll save my wealth and use it to support someone else to do this practice so they can experience that mind." And so that was the decision. I don't know if it was just hours later or a day later, I went to the post office where we had to make long-distance calls and called back to Berkeley to talk to my girlfriend. Her roommate answered, and I said, "Could I talk to her?" And he said, "Oh, she's on her way to Kathmandu to see you." She had less money than me, so that's where that hundred dollars went, because she was coming to practice too. So, beautiful mind.
The teacher that I practiced with there, Sayadaw U Pandita[1], he has a book with a chapter titled something like, The State of Mind Called Beautiful. Did you know that the mind can be beautiful? How beautiful is your mind, and what would it take to make your mind beautiful?
This is not just an abstract idea or idealism. It turns out that in the ancient teachings of the Buddha, he uses the word "beauty" and "beautiful" quite frequently, but it's not obvious in the English translations. Many of the translations translate the word kalyāṇa[2] as "good."
One of the places it appears has to do with karma, and translators will translate it as "good karma" and "bad karma." But the word for good is not "good," the word is kalyāṇa, and it's a hugely different thing. In Buddhism, the concern about karma—karma means your actions that have consequences—is that you want to be careful with your actions. The concern is not about doing good and avoiding bad; the concern is to avoid malicious actions and to do beautiful karma, beautiful actions. Literally, there's a passage where it says you do beautiful actions for beautiful results. Isn't that kind of nice? A whole different feel. It takes the ethical sting out of this whole karma idea if the intention is to do the beautiful thing.
One of the places where this emphasis on beauty gets really strong in Buddhism is a common expression the Buddha used to describe the Dharma—which is the teachings, the practice, the path that we're involved in. The common translation is that it's "timeless, good in the beginning, good in the middle, and good at the end." So it's "good." Good that it's good, but the word good... you know, it's okay. A meal is good, it's good for you. I'm happy that it's good. But it turns out that it's this word kalyāṇa, which the first definition in many of the Indian-English dictionaries is "beautiful." The Dharma is beautiful in the beginning, beautiful in the middle, beautiful at the end.
Wow. We're talking... that's like, wow! "Good" doesn't really get me going, but "beautiful," wow! The Dharma is beautiful! How does that work? Where do I find that beauty? Well, guess where you find it? In yourself. What's the beautiful thing to do?
As you go about your daily life, what if your actions, what you do in the world, is beautiful? What if you drive beautifully? I wonder what that would look like if everyone was driving beautifully. I'm not sure what it would look like, but I sure know what it doesn't look like. You see a lot of it.
Sometimes the standard people have of what's beautiful is things that are performed really well. Sometimes looking at dance or athleticism, people who have mastered and developed and trained themselves do something with elegance, simplicity, care, and mastery, and it can just be beautiful to watch. Wow, look at that!
I don't know if any of you have done a Japanese tea ceremony, but to watch someone who is really trained, the way they pour the tea and hold the cups, it's just beautiful to watch. It can be mesmerizing. I once watched over at Green Gulch Zen Center, they had a very big, somewhat oldish barn that became the meditation hall. They had Mrs. Nakamura (Kimura Sensei), a woman who was a teacher there who taught Japanese tea ceremony for a few decades at Zen Center. She was going back to Japan, and they were gonna have a kind of final ceremony to honor her. She was gonna make tea in the meditation hall, and because of my role there, I was placed kind of at the center, just a few feet away from her. I got to watch her make tea. She was in her eighties, and that was beautiful. Just the way she used her wrists and her hands and picked things up. You'd think that you can just pick up a bowl, but watching a person pick it up—this is art.
So what's the beautiful way to hand your friend a cup of tea? What's the beautiful way to offer a gift? Gifts are nice to give. In Buddhism, and also in places like Japan, the beautiful way is to do it with both hands. You put yourself together and you're really there fully for the experience. You're consciously and intentionally present, as opposed to handing it looking the other way or throwing it at them. It's a very different thing. Generosity is beautiful. What about being generous for the sake of beauty, or as an act of beauty, as opposed to a duty? It's a very different feeling.
So karma is sometimes categorized as being beautiful, and the opposite is actually not translated as "bad." I like to translate it as "malicious." So you want to avoid doing the things that are malicious and do the things which are beautiful.
This word for karma comes from the root that means action. There are a lot of related words in Buddhism, and one of the etymologically related words is saṅkhāra[3]. Saṃ means "with" or "together," and kāra means "to make" or "to do." Saṅkhāras are the inner mental actions that we do. They are activities of the mind that influence us, influence how the mind works and shapes the mind. If you are constantly thinking miserly thoughts and you do it regularly, that's going to influence the habits of the mind. If you are regularly being generous, that's going to influence you in a different way. One of them might keep you contracted, tight, fearful, and separated from people. The second, being generous, might make you feel more open and happy to see people. If you do that once or twice, it probably won't have created much influence on you, but if you spend years one way or the other, it creates a big change in who we are. One of them creates beauty, one of them creates something like the opposite of it.
The mental activities that we do, saṅkhāras, are consequential. We can ask ourselves, what is a beautiful thing to do in the mind? Buddhism has an answer. These mental activities that we have in the mind are categorized in all kinds of ways, but there are two major categories. There's a category of those things which are unskillful or unwholesome to do, and in street language those are the "bad" ones. But "unskillful," that's a very different feeling than saying it's "bad." It's just not skillful, not useful, it's not helpful. Then the opposite ones, you would think they are the skillful ones, the wholesome ones. But what they're called are the beautiful ones. They are the beautiful states of mind. It's a different word, it's sobhana[4], not kalyāṇa, but it means beautiful states of mind.
Because of the way this psychological analysis works, it's not a comprehensive list of all the qualities of mind we might think of as beautiful, but it is an interesting list. There are things like faith, trust, and confidence—they are considered beautiful. Mindfulness is considered a beautiful state. That's a little bit hard for some of us to tell when we're new to practice or struggling in the practice and mindfulness is hard to come by. But when mindfulness is strong and stable, and we're steadied in this very clear, strong present moment awareness, mindfulness is not just a good idea, mindfulness becomes a state. A state of clear awareness that, when it's established, would be similar to there being no smog or haze in the Bay Area air. Those of you who live here on the peninsula know that when the air is clean, it's really nice to look across the bay. It's surprising how close the East Bay hills are. But many days you can't see across the bay. When it's clear, it's really clear. Wow, that's cool! When mindfulness is strong, the state of the clarity of the mind, the knowing quality of mind is kind of like that. There's an elegance and beauty.
And then there's things like the lightness of the mind, the buoyancy of the mind, an uprightness of the mind, a rectitude of the mind. Having a conscience is considered a beautiful thing. Softness of the mind. Tranquility of the mind.
If these things are well-established, they're nice. Like a tranquil mind, you can understand how it could be beautiful when you compare it to the opposite, which is an agitated mind. Many people come to meditation in order to quiet and calm an agitated mind, and when it is calm, it can be really exquisite. I talked about this beautiful mind that we can experience sometimes; one of the higher quality minds that we can experience is in fact a mind that's very, very tranquil. Not tranquil and numb, not tranquil and unenergized, but tranquil and clear. It's a profound state of peace that you feel and experience in the mind.
Another one on the list is equanimity, or a sense of a balanced mind. So it's not out of balance. People get off balance, they say, but this feels strongly balanced. These states of mind really feel palpable and good.
So what's the beautiful thing to do in the mind? This word saṅkhāra, which is related to action, if you look it up in various dictionaries—especially Sanskrit dictionaries—it has a wide range of meanings. Unfortunately, the English translations lose some of the richness of the word. The most common English translation lately is "mental formations." I'm sure this was good news for you! Formations, constructs, constructions, fabrications. You know, they don't really do justice. But if you look it up in the Sanskrit-English dictionary, you find it has meanings like: to put together, to make, to prepare, to concentrate, to make sacred, to polish a gem, to refine a metal, to perform sacred rituals. The Sanskrit word saṃskāra is almost the equivalent of our word "ritual." For Brahmins, there are twelve rites of passage over a lifetime, they're called the twelve saṃskāras. You get a very different feeling when you get this association with making sacred, concentrating, polishing, making special. To translate it as constructs and fabrications, you lose some of those rich associations. I don't think we can translate it as "to make it beautiful," I think that loses some of the meanings of it too, but the associations are like that.
What if meditation is a practice of beautifying your mind? The Buddha talked about adorning the mind. Adorning your mind—maybe that's not very interesting. A lot of people are motivated to come to meditation because they suffer, they're stressed, agitated, having problems and they want relief, some help to get free of that. They heard that Buddhist meditation is to bring an end to suffering. It's pretty promising. If some people hear, "Oh, come to Buddhism and have a beautiful mind," they might think, "Well, that's self-indulgent. There are important things to do in the world, important websites to visit! To indulge in just making a beautiful mind doesn't seem very good."
I remember when I was a new Buddhist practitioner in my early twenties, I heard this a lot. Maybe society's changed now, but back then you'd tell people that you meditated, and they would say, "Oh, that's selfish. You meditated an hour? That's selfish, because you're self-involved. You're focusing on yourself, you should go do things for people." I think the idea that meditation is selfish came because Buddhism was considered a religion, and religion is supposed to be altruistic, so if you weren't being altruistic, you were being selfish. The same people who would say it's selfish to meditate for an hour would spend three or four hours watching television. It didn't occur to them that that was selfish. It was kind of cognitive dissonance for me that people would watch television for hours and then tell me that my one-hour meditation was selfish.
If you tell someone the purpose of Buddhist meditation is to make a beautiful mind, maybe it doesn't inspire people or maybe it seems selfish. But what if, in fact, Buddhist meditation is to do a very profound thing? It is to really help you get to the root of your suffering, and show you liberation, a freedom from it. The profound state of peace gives birth to wonderful qualities of mind. Often Buddhist teachers say, "Well, it gives birth to compassion," because that has cachet, that's something people want, to be helpful in the world. And it is a good fruit to practice. But what if we say that yes, we're here to do a path of practice that leads to freedom from suffering, and the means to that is to cultivate a beautiful mind?
When you think things, what would be the beautiful thing to think? When you engage in meditation practice and make an effort to be mindful, it's not "what's the right way to make effort?", but "what's the beautiful way to make effort?" The quality of the way you pay attention, is there a way of doing that beautifully? Like you're doing a Japanese tea ceremony in your mind. What is it to carefully bring your attention to look at the experience you have? Attend to what's happening with your breathing, with your body, in such a way that it's elegant and inspiring. If someone looked at you from the outside, they'd be inspired by it.
What's the beautiful thing to do? How do you practice beautifully? Would that free you from striving? Free you from being upset with yourself if your mind wanders off in thought? Because that wouldn't be beautiful. "Gil, you just blew it. You slipped off your breath, you missed ten breaths, that was really a drag." That's not inspiring. But rather, "Gil, you just wandered off here, come back. I'll help you come back to your breathing and settle there." Why not that way? Have you listened to the tone of your inner voice? Some people, when they start paying attention to the tone of their inner voice, find that it's harsh or angry. Who's in control of the tone of your voice in there? Do you just have to go along with what's given to you, or can you take some responsibility for how you think and talk to yourself? Can you do it in ways that are inspiring, conducive to peace and well-being, but also a sense of beauty?
The Buddha said that beautiful actions lead to beautiful results. Beautiful ways of relating to ourselves, beautiful ways of thinking and talking lead to beautiful results. I think I've probably done my job that I intended here today. I don't know if it was beautifully done, but I did want to try to emphasize a particular point. The kalyāṇa idea that's missing for the most part in English discussions of Buddhism creates a very different perspective, orientation, or approach to how we would live our lives or how we would engage in meditation practice. It brings in a reference point that can make things a lot easier. It creates a much more compassionate, caring, careful way of doing this that is freed from being angry with yourself, freed from being self-deprecating, and freed from a sense of harsh duty. Feelings that you have to walk on eggshells to be a good Buddhist because you have to do the right thing and avoid the bad thing.
There are all kinds of ways in which people engage in Buddhism that are rather un-Buddhist. What I mean by that is, hopefully, the purpose of Buddhist practice is to become free of suffering. Don't suffer because of Buddhism, that doesn't make sense! "I have to follow the Buddhist way of life, I'm not doing good, right? I'm supposed to be mindful—that's what Buddhism teaches, I have to be mindful so that I can be free of suffering—and I'm not doing it right, I'm terrible!" It's just illogical. To find a way to do this Buddhist practice so that we live a good life, support people in our lives, and take care of ourselves, maybe sometimes we need a different language and different concepts in which to look at this and understand it.
I've offered you this word today, and maybe you'll find it interesting to experiment with and explore it. Ask yourself the question, "What's the beautiful thing to do in your actions, in your speech, and in your mind?" Maybe try it for a week. Just keep that question close by, maybe even write it on the palm of your hand, carry it with you, and keep asking yourself that question and see what kind of answers you come up with. Will those answers lead to a different life than what you've been doing so far? That's my thoughts. We have ten minutes before the end, and if any of you would like to ask a question, comment, or protest beautifully... yes, if you can wait for the mic please.
Q&A
Question: As long as we're dealing with meanings of words, "beautiful" has a lot of different meanings too. Is it up to each person to decide what they mean by beautiful, or are there some kind of "right" beautifuls? Do the Buddhist texts tell you what the right way is?
Gil: No, I think it's personal, but I'm very interested in your question about the idea that it has many connotations or associations. There's the most obvious interpretation of surface beauty—do you look good doing something? Then there's beautiful in the overall implications. Something is beautiful if it brings about good results, and not beautiful if it doesn't. And then there's the whole association of beauty with skillfulness, things that are skillfully done are also beautiful. What do you think Buddhism points towards?
Questioner: I think the skillful connotations.
Gil: Thank you. Although, it's interesting because the Chinese, who are the predecessors to the Japanese, they didn't care about tea ceremonies. They just make beautiful Buddhist temples!
I was tripping on the words "right" and "ethical" and the way they sounded in my head. "Right" and "ethical" have a hard, straight edge to them, and it's very easy to slip off into a judgmental aspect. But the word "beautiful" has much more softness and roundness to it, and an expansiveness to it.
Question: A friend of mine is an avid Buddhist practitioner. When I asked him how he decides what is the most skillful thing to do, he was always very confident in his actions. I would see his actions and think, "There are ten things wrong with what you just did!" I do that to myself. He would say, "I'm secure in my own good intentions." It would drive me crazy, because beauty is subjective. I would define my action as beautiful if I knew it came from a really good intention, but when I see ten different intentions going on at the same time, do I just get to pick one and say, "Alright, I see the compassion in this part of my thinking, so it was a good action?"
Gil: That's a great question. One of the criteria that is very important in Buddhism is not to cause harm. But even that's hard to know, whether it causes harm or not, but we do our best. I felt very lucky when I was seventeen, I was talking to an aunt and asking this kind of question. She pointed out that we have a range of intentions. If seventy percent is a good intention, but thirty percent is not, don't sacrifice the seventy percent good intention for the thirty percent bad intention. We have multiple intentions, but you have to weigh them together.
For example, you might want to help your neighbor because the neighbor is sick. But one intention is you want everyone on the street to know that you're the best helper on the block. That kind of egotism is probably not so useful, but she still needs help! Just put up with your egotism so you can help her, because the intent is a better intention. Look at the balance of things and see which is the higher percentage, and look at what the consequences can be. If all things are equal, then also look at the consequences for yourself. Which makes you a better person, helps you grow and develop, and become a freer, kinder, happier person?
Questioner: It's wonderful to clarify a little bit. If I have one selfish intention and one selfless intention, I can kind of take a minute and align myself with the beautiful intention. And if the other one is still kind of there getting its way, that's okay, but I'm gonna align with the beautiful one?
Gil: Yeah. Don't give up the good intention just because a little bit of bad intention is kind of holding it hostage. It's a matter of balance, and the harm caused. If it's 99 percent bad and 1 percent good, well then maybe you want to take a second look.
Question: In my earlier life, more than twenty years ago, I had the chance to live in Asia and I got to go to Japan many times. I saw the tea ceremony put on by a master who took twenty years of her life to get to that level. I still remember it to this day, how she served the tea, rotating the cup around, delivering it to the individual. That wasn't the only beautiful ceremony I remember seeing. The exchange of business cards I thought was also quite a beautiful ceremony, with the two-hand delivery, the two-hand reception, the studying of the card and the acknowledgment. There must be a lot of beautiful things happening out there that, if you take a step back to see them, are happening all over.
Gil: Yes. Some of the things that are being expressed also are care and respect. There's a respect for the other person, valuing another person, when you give something really consciously and carefully and fully, as opposed to just throwing the business card or the tea at them.
Thank you. If this was somehow a provocatively useful and interesting idea that I presented today, and if some of you would like to tell me in some months what kind of difference it made in your life, I'd be very happy to hear. Thank you.
Sayadaw U Pandita: (1921–2016) A renowned Burmese Theravada Buddhist monk and meditation master in the Vipassana tradition. ↩︎
Kalyāṇa: A Pali word often translated as "good," "beautiful," "virtuous," or "noble." ↩︎
Saṅkhāra: A Pali term frequently translated as "formations," "volitions," or "mental constructions," referring to the mental activities that shape our karma and experience. ↩︎
Sobhana: A Pali term used in the Abhidhamma (Buddhist psychology) to denote "beautiful" or wholesome mental factors. ↩︎