Moon Pointing

Not Self

Date:
2019-05-12
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-15 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Not Self

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Not Self

I touched on the topic of not-self two weeks ago, and there was a lot of interest for me to go into more detail, so I will today.

The topic of not-self is considered by many people to be a very important teaching of the Buddha. I get the sense that it might be considered more important sometimes in the modern West. In particular, in countries that dishonor the ideas of the soul in Christianity, for example, and also in the modern psychological West, which has put a tremendous amount of emphasis on the individual and the ecology of the individual. In some ways, certain forms of psychology have been benefiting individualism. Because of the strong sense of individualism that exists for many people here in the West, the teachings of not-self have been provocative, maybe eye-opening, challenging, or engaging to listen to.

Buddhist teachers have often emphasized this not-self teaching. I find that in the many years I've been teaching, I've taught less of it than I used to. I find it maybe not quite as interesting as I used to find it, and I am not quite sure how to explain that. But anyway, I'll talk about it today; I'm interested enough.

Not-Self vs. No-Self

The first thing I really want to sear into your mind so you remember is that it's a not-self teaching; it is not a no-self teaching. Many people interpret and understand that what the Buddha taught on this topic is that there is no self, and he explicitly did not teach that. In fact, when he was asked about this topic, he was very explicit that the teaching that there is no self is a quagmire, a marsh, just a quicksand to get into.

The idea that there is no self is certainly popular. You find it in modern books on psychology and neuroscience. It's been a popular topic to talk about how the concept, idea, or feeling sense of self is a neurophysiological construct. But for the Buddha, it was just a philosophical quagmire to posit a "no-self" that you'll never get out of if you go into it. It's philosophically and metaphysically complex to posit such a thing, and the Buddha wasn't interested in going down this metaphysical or philosophical idea that there is no self.

But he did have a teaching about not-self. In a sense, no-self is like a noun and not-self is more like an adjective. Not-self is always used to characterize something. No-self is a blanket, broad statement about the nature of human beings or reality—that there is no self. But not-self is an adjective describing or characterizing something, which I'll talk more about as we go on.

Part of the reason to have this insight—to perceive rather than believe the teachings of not-self—is because it can be liberating. It can liberate us from an excessive attachment to self, preoccupation with self, and attachment to "me, myself, and mine." Selfishness, self-preoccupied conceit, and the whole complex of things around this idea of self. It isn't so much that we're supposed to somehow believe or not believe in a self exactly, but it's the attachment and clinging to this complex thing that is the heart of what the Buddha is pointing to. He was emphasizing that there's a way of perceiving that we see for ourselves this idea of not-self.

You can rest assured that you don't have to believe what I'm teaching today. That's not the point. It's not like you have to be a card-carrying Buddhist and believe that there is no self or not-self. What I'm going to talk about is pointing to an insight, a perception that people who do Vipassana[1] practice will at some point see for themselves. So don't struggle with the whole belief thing. Don't believe what I'm saying; it's not a belief.

Self-Consciousness vs. Self-Awareness

To get into this topic, I think it might be useful to do it a little bit indirectly, and that is to highlight what it's like to be self-conscious as opposed to self-aware. In my way of using the English language, being self-aware is really a wise and useful thing, and we use mindfulness to become more self-aware. But self-consciousness has the connotation of somehow being excessively preoccupied with self, concerned with self, and focused on oneself in such a way that it gums up the workings of the gears inside.

If you're going to do something that you have mastery over and you've done many times before, but you have to do it in front of other people, you might get self-conscious. In doing so, you trip over your own words or trip over your feet. You just don't click and get absorbed in doing the thing you have mastery over, because part of you is thinking about it.

For example, Stephen Curry is one of the most famous basketball players in America. Imagine it's a championship game, his team is down by one point, and he's about to make one of those great shots that he makes so easily. But just before he shoots, someone on the sideline says, "Which foot do you push off from, the right or the left?" Suddenly he's self-conscious. He wonders, "Well, what do I do?" Or someone yells out, "Your mother is watching!" or "Your high school girlfriend is watching!" Suddenly you're self-conscious, concerned with, "I better make this shot," as opposed to just making it.

Self-consciousness can trip people up. Sometimes it trips us up quite dramatically. People get stage fright and don't know how to speak. Or people are in social situations and are very self-conscious about what people think about them, whether people like or reject them, or what's going to happen. Even in ordinary social situations, it can be very awkward and difficult to have a fluid conversation because of so much self-consciousness.

That kind of self-consciousness is a wind drag on navigating through the world. It slows us down and trips us up. You can see how it limits extremely shy people; it makes interactions awkward because of this self-preoccupation and worry.

The Value of Forgetting Oneself

As people develop mastery, get more comfortable, feel people aren't going to judge them, or stop caring as much about whether people like what they do, self-consciousness begins to drift and fall away. We can also absorb ourselves in an activity. One of the reasons an absorbing activity can be relaxing and destressing is because of the lack of self-consciousness. Part of the reason people get exhausted through a day is not necessarily the work they're doing, but rather a constant preoccupation with themselves.

Someone might come home exhausted and get absorbed in a really good novel. Their mind is certainly active, busy, and participating in the novel, but they've forgotten themselves in reading it. By just forgetting oneself, the self-conscious neurons are not firing. I don't exactly know how it works in there, but they tend to involve stress, contraction, and tightness—a certain kind of exhaustion. Having those neurons not operating relaxes the brain and settles its agitated energy.

Some people can do vigorous activities that take a lot of energy, like exercising, and at the end of it, feel much more relaxed. I suspect a good reason for that is that the ways they're self-preoccupied have been put down while involved in the activity. The ability to put down self-consciousness is often recognized as a source of relaxation, ease, and openness.

Some people find it quite profound to do that. People go into nature partly for that purpose. When involved in urban life with lots of people, it's so easy for the brain and mind to be involved in concerns about where we fit, how it all works, and planning what it's like to be a member of society. For example, what you wear can be quite self-conscious. It's said that some people spend more time thinking about what they're going to wear than what they're going to say. I wish it were the other way around; it would be easier for society!

But when you go into the wilderness, go backpacking, or go down to the beach, part of the value is that the social self and socially interactive concerns drop away. It feels so peaceful not to have that operating. It can be inspiring in almost a religious or existential way.

I was very touched many years ago reading an account by an adult woman writing about when she was a child. She got an awful haircut and was quite upset. In response, her father took her for a drive up into the hills next to where they lived, where there was a spectacular view of the natural world. They sat in the car looking out across the rolling hills, and her father said something like, "Nature doesn't care about your haircut." That freed her. It created a different context. If her father had taken her to a school assembly, had her go up on the stage, and said, "Notice the haircut," it would have been devastating. But coming into the natural world and resetting our understanding of our place in society is almost life-saving for some people because it's hard to get free of self-consciousness when around people all the time.

For some, meditation is a time to settle our self-conscious mind. The relaxation, closing our eyes, not being part of the social world, and just focusing on the breathing allows us to let go of our thoughts—a lot of which are self-conscious ones. That is why meditation can be so calming and destressing. It can have the same value, if you get calm enough, as that girl looking out across the natural setting. Sitting with your eyes closed and the mind getting very still and quiet has the same sense of beauty and resets an existential understanding of who we are. It's refreshing and allows people to enter the world in a different way.

If we're fortunate enough to get concentrated, we discover the tremendous value of really settling on the breathing. We value it so much more than our self-consciousness that we don't get pulled into the thoughts we're spinning in. When we get settled and absorbed, it can be as good, if not better, than being absorbed in a really good novel. The self-consciousness drops away.

The question is, how thoroughly can self-consciousness drop away, and what is its value? One value is that it puts a question mark next to our self-consciousness. Is this self-conscious concern as important as it insists it is? Do I really need to invest in it? It's still operating in me, but do I need to give it so much credence? Can I step back, recognize the self-consciousness over there, pat it on the shoulder, and say, "It's okay, you can relax"? You can ask deeper questions: Is it true? Is it really talking about important things? Is it necessary to be this way?

Not having it operate highlights it, and we see it more clearly. A lot of self-consciousness operates semi-invisibly; it's second nature. The deeper calm and stillness of meditation allow us to see what is often invisible, just like the fish that supposedly doesn't see the water it swims in.

Identifying with Our Experience

How deep can we go with this? It's not just what we consider self-preoccupation, but the more subtle and precise ways in which we identify with our experience. We see our experience, the things of the world, and ourselves through the framework of "me, myself, and mine."

This goes on all the time, and to some degree, it's reasonable. If I get hungry, I pick up the fork and put it in my mouth, right? I need to know where the hunger is and in what direction to put the fork. But imagine saying, "There's grumbling and contraction and yearning for food mid-body, and it would be nice to find a fork and some food, so this appendage to this body can pick up the fork, poke the food, bring it up to the high point of this body where this aperture will open wide, stick it in, and then have those hard teeth gnaw it for a while, before this natural process in the throat swallows it down to where the rumbling was, bringing a feeling of satisfaction." How about just saying, "I'm hungry, I would like to eat"?

I've heard excessively idealistic, young Buddhists get into this teaching, thinking there is no self, and avoiding all personal pronouns. You'd ask them how they were feeling, and they'd say, "There's a lot of heat and contraction." You'd say, "But how are you feeling? You look angry." There was a strong tendency to avoid pronouns to avoid responsibility and clarity. So we have to be a little bit careful with this.

But there is value in noticing the problems that arise when we identify excessively with our experience. A classic example meditation teachers talk about happens in the meditation hall. Right smack in the middle of the floor, there's an empty zafu[2]. I don't know why it's empty; maybe the person went to the bathroom. Someone arrives late, sees the empty zafu, and sits down. The person comes back from the bathroom and is self-righteously horrified: "Someone is sitting on my zafu!" It's not your zafu; it's IMC's zafu! We take it as "mine," even though two hours from now it will be back on its shelf and you'll never recognize it as "mine" again. A lot of heat, tension, and social conflict arises because we've identified it as "mine." Is that the best way to go through the world?

A very famous story—maybe I said it at IMC because I like the saying of the founder of the San Francisco Zen Center, Suzuki Roshi[3][4]. He made a statement while holding his glasses out in front of his eyes. We know this because someone took a picture just as he was saying it. He said, "These glasses are not my glasses, but you know about my tired old eyes, so you let me wear them." That's very different than saying, "These are my glasses." It's a different way of framing it that creates more space and relaxation, making it less likely to glom onto it as "mine."

The language we use is impactful. Using the word "I," which we do a lot in English, is not an innocent word. I was fortunate to live in Japan for a year in a Zen monastery. It was a very intense situation where we slept and ate in the same room, always together. As I was learning to speak Japanese, I didn't know that in Japanese you very seldom use pronouns like "I." I was trying to speak Japanese the way I spoke English. There is a way to say "I" (watashi wa), which requires four syllables, whereas in English it's just one. I would constantly start all my sentences with watashi wa, and it got painful for me to listen to myself because it was so out of context in that culture to keep referring back to yourself.

Because of that experience, I have become much more self-aware about how often we use the word "I" in English. I'd like to propose that it is seldom innocent. The word "I" is a magnet for unconscious, subconscious, and conscious ideas of what it means to be yourself. We all have ideas of what it means to be a human being, a self, and a member of society, learned from our culture, family, and life experience. When we use the word "I," it comes along with a lot of baggage.

The Self in Different Cultures

For people coming from an individualistic culture, like in the United States, there are all these ideas of what it means to be an "I." You hear it in sayings like: "Think for yourself," "Stand on your own two feet," "Be your own person," "Take care of yourself," "Be true to yourself," "Stand your ground," and "Find your true north." In some ways, it's appropriate for a culture that has organized itself around individualism.

But there are other possibilities. Societies that organize themselves collectively have different sayings. For some people coming from a collectivist culture to an individualistic one, it can be quite grating. I've known people from Japan who put their kids in first grade and were horrified when their kid had to make a poster about all the ways they were a special person. This goes against the grain in traditional Japanese culture, where a common saying is, "The nail that stands up will be hammered down." If you stand out, you will be pushed down.

In collectivist cultures, they might ask, "What do the elders want?" or "What is right for the family or community?" Thinking for yourself isn't as important as fitting in. When I was in the monastery in Japan, I saw a Japanese man ostracized by the other monks because "he's thinking for himself." To be a self there is to be part of a community. Neither way is worse or better; they are just different ways groups organize themselves, each with pluses and minuses. Those of us in the modern West can feel the shortcomings of individualism, while some coming from a collectivist culture find individualism to be a breath of fresh air.

The point is that using the word "self" is not innocent; it brings ideas and understandings with it. You might look in your closet and say, "Those are my clothes." But people sometimes wear clothes to represent who they want people to see them as, or who they believe they are: "I'm beautiful, I should prove it," "I'm a professional," or "I'm an outdoors person." When I first came to the San Francisco Zen Center, there was a uniform that students wore so people knew they were Zen students: Thai fisher pants[5], Danish school bags, and Amish vests. But if you pack those clothes away and find them 20 years later, it's hard to identify with them. "I used to present myself as that person, and now I'm not." Clothes, and opinions, act as magnets for what we're trying to prove about our identity.

The Practice of Not-Self

When we do Vipassana practice, sometimes there's a technique where we change how we talk about ourselves in our minds. If you're fairly settled and calm, and you have knee pain, notice the difference between saying "My pain" and "There is pain." "My pain" is a magnet for preoccupation and contraction. It says something about me. Seeing it simply as "the pain" creates more space and relaxation. It carries less psychological weight.

If you are angry—and humans get angry—saying "my anger" or "I am angry" is rarely an innocent statement. Suddenly, I'm a wrong person for being angry, I'm embarrassed, I shouldn't be angry, and I hope no one sees me. It gets complicated around identity and representation. If we can just relax and see it as "the anger," it's easier. In deep meditation, it's a great place to switch from saying "my" or "I" to just recognizing the presence of anger. I don't need to identify with it or use it to represent who I am. It can just be anger that floats up.

If you're really settled in meditation and nothing is sticky in the mind, you can see anger arise and act like Teflon—it just arises and goes. There is no self involved. "Hi," you say as it goes by.

I had an interpersonal experience of this that was formative for me. When I was the kitchen manager at Tassajara[6], supervising people working in the kitchen, I was concerned with wanting everyone to like me. That's a topic of self. The mental gymnastics I tried to do to make everyone like me were exhausting. It's impossible to make everyone like you! I was managing an older man, who was already wise to the world, and I told him to do something. He turned towards me and directed this white-hot anger, saying, "Don't ever do that again." As soon as he finished saying that, his anger was completely gone. I had never experienced clean anger with no residue. I got the message, and there was nothing left over. If he had been self-conscious and self-righteous about his anger, it would have lingered and created challenges in our relationship. But he didn't identify with it.

We find in meditation that it becomes easier and more relaxed to not add "I, me, myself." We don't have to interpret our experience through that lens. An emotion arises, it's just an emotion. A thought arises, it's a thought. Pain arises, it's sensations. It might seem innocent to call it "mine," but it involves a complex operation of the brain and agitates the mind. Having it be simple is refreshing and easeful.

As "I, me, myself, and mine" and the related concepts quiet down, we stop projecting them onto our experience. We start seeing that our projected concepts tend to reify reality and camouflage how things are constantly changing and moving. It's fascinating to watch how, when involved in thinking, I lose touch with the changing flow of sensations. It's like turning on the radio and not being able to hear the birds outside. To watch that tipping back and forth, and to just be with direct experience without the concepts of "me, myself, and mine," lends itself to having this insight into not-self.

Conclusion

Some people spend a lot of money and time on their fingernails. There must be a lot of selfing[7] involved—"my fingernails." But when they get clipped off, the clippings lay there. Do you put them on a silver platter to show your friends who you really are? No, people put them in the trash or compost them, and forget about them. They're no longer "me."

So the question is: Are our fingernails, our hair, our emotions, our opinions, our possessions inherently who we are? The not-self teaching recognizes that the particular things we touch, see, smell, and experience—individual thoughts or thinking itself—are not the self. They don't qualify. Your little finger is not the self. The itch on your forearm is not the self. A thought arises, and you can say, "I don't know what that is, but it's just not me." Thoughts happen because something stimulated them, not because "I" am intentionally thinking.

My wife had medically induced, temporary menopause in her mid-30s. She wisely observed, "I'm having these thoughts which are not my thoughts." Just thoughts happening, without glomming onto all the extra baggage of self. When you look at anything in particular, the adjective that describes it is "not-self." A not-self thought, a not-self feeling, a not-self emotion. You start seeing that in every possible particularity in our experience, a self is not found there.

Does that mean there is no self? The Buddha said, "Don't go there. Don't bother with that question." Just that the particularity is not-self. Is there a generalized concept of self? Sometimes it's useful to say, "I need to go to the bathroom," or "I need to end this talk." But there is a world of difference between using concepts of "me, myself, and mine" practically while being cognizant that they are constructs, versus using them as magnets for the heavy baggage of identity.

It frees us from a lot of self-consciousness, attachment, and clinging. Stepping into this not-self world is fascinating. You haven't changed at all; you're still the same person, and you might still use the word "I." But when you have a deep experience of not-self and let go of attachment, it's like two things coexisting. It's like watching a movie: you're completely aware that actors are acting and it's not real, but you still enjoy it. You can be clear that using the word "self" is provisional and useful, but you're ready to drop it when it's not.

The Buddha's teachings are not-self. I hope you appreciate that the function of this teaching is not to believe in not-self, but to liberate us from excessive attachment and preoccupation with self. May you be liberated from all self-consciousness, while remaining happily self-aware.

Thank you. Everyone's welcome to stay for tea.



  1. Vipassana: Insight meditation, a Buddhist practice aiming at developing deep insight into the true nature of reality. Original transcript said 'do the past in the practice', corrected to 'do Vipassana practice' based on context. ↩︎

  2. Zafu: A round cushion used for seated meditation in Zen and other Buddhist traditions. ↩︎

  3. Original transcript said 'I am see cuz I like the saith', corrected to 'I said it at IMC because I like the saying' based on the context of Gil Fronsdal speaking at the Insight Meditation Center (IMC). ↩︎

  4. Suzuki Roshi: Shunryu Suzuki Roshi, a highly influential Soto Zen monk and teacher who helped popularize Zen Buddhism in the United States and founded the San Francisco Zen Center. ↩︎

  5. Original transcript said 'fat pants', corrected to 'Thai fisher pants' based on the context of common 1970s Zen center attire. ↩︎

  6. Tassajara: Tassajara Zen Mountain Center, the first Zen monastery established outside of Asia. ↩︎

  7. Selfing: A term often used in modern Buddhist teaching to describe the active, continuous process of creating and identifying with a sense of self. ↩︎