Moon Pointing

Ethics for a Modern World

Date:
2019-11-24
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-15 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Ethics for a Modern World

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Ethics for a Modern World

And those of you new, welcome. So this morning I'd like to talk about what in the ancient language is called sīla[1], and usually in English was translated as ethics or virtue. It's part of the three trainings. The three trainings are three categories that are supposed to encompass all of Buddhist practice. The first one is sīla. The second is called samādhi[2], which is usually translated as meditation in this context, or cultivating the mind. And then the third one is paññā[3], which is usually translated as wisdom. There are certainly other ways of translating these words. The Dalai Lama[4] has a book on these three trainings, and his title for the book is Kindness, Clarity, and Insight. What we might translate as ethics, he calls kindness. What is meditation, he calls clarity. And then wisdom is insight.

Part of what motivates me to give this talk is an attempt to explore what I think is an important topic for our times. I believe that our society and our world are changing so much these days that it would be useful to reassess or rethink what Buddhist ethics is and how it works. As I study these things, I feel we are ready for a new interpretation and new understanding of how Buddhist ethics works in our lives because of how much our society is changing.

Sīla as Behavior

What's interesting about these three trainings is they not only encompass all the Buddhist practices, but they are also meant to encompass three major areas, maybe all areas, of human life. For an individual, the first one, sīla, has to do with our behavior. The second, samādhi, has to do with the state or quality of our inner life or mind. And wisdom has to do with the quality of how we see and understand the world. So the first is behavior, the second is the quality or state of how we are on the inside, and then the third is how we view, how we see the world we live in, how we understand it. That kind of covers most things.

Now, it's a little bit unusual, perhaps, in the way that we often talk about sīla, to hear that it's about behavior. It's very common to translate sīla as virtue. Virtue ethics is very popular in Western philosophy, and virtue has to do with inner qualities, how you are. You have virtuous qualities: you have a generosity of kindness, you have compassion. The measure of it all is how you are on the inside, and that motivates or inspires certain behavior, but what's important is to measure the quality of your virtue. Related to this idea of virtue is the idea that Buddhist ethics is centered on intentionality—that somehow it is the intentions we have that define whether something is ethical or not ethical. I want to question if that's adequate in the world that we're living in now, and I think this has to be looked at more carefully.

Sīla literally means behavior. In more recent times, Bhikkhu Bodhi[5], the great translator of the ancient Buddhist texts, has been translating the word sīla as "virtuous behavior." He used to prefer to translate it as "virtue," and then as he thought about it more, he realized, "Yeah, that's really about behavior." So now he uses "virtuous behavior," and that's probably fine. The emphasis is on the behavior, how we act and how we speak.

I want to read to you an ancient commentary about sīla. The translator, Bhikkhu Bodhi, before he changed it to "virtuous behavior," is still using the word "virtue" here: "Virtue should be reflected upon as the basis for rapture and joy, as granting immunity from fear of self-reproach, the reproach of others, and punishment. Virtue should be reflected on as praised by the wise, as the root cause for freedom from remorse, and the basis of safety." That's pretty good.

Now, if you read it again with Bhikkhu Bodhi's newer translation as "virtuous behavior," I think you get a little different flavor of it: "Virtuous behavior should be reflected upon as the basis for rapture and joy, as granting immunity from fear of self-reproach, the reproach of others, and punishment. It should be reflected upon as praised by the wise, as the root cause for freedom from remorse, as a basis for safety." So now it's the behavior that does all these things.

It's a little bit disconcerting for some people to hear the emphasis on behavior. It's particularly disconcerting, maybe, for someone who grew up in the 60s, because there was a rebellion against behavior that was insisted upon. There was a normative behavior that seemed, in many respects, very hypocritical. It didn't have any roots in sincerity or how we really were, and we were forced to fit into certain modes of behavior that didn't seem right. So there was a rebellion against behavior as being the definition of what was ethical. The radical extreme of that had to do with whether it feels right. And "whether it feels right" has some wisdom to it if your ability to feel is really deep. But if it's not very deep, and it just "feels good," then party time!

Guarding the Sense Doors

In this emphasis on early ethics, there's a particular form of behavior that's called "guarding the sense doors," and sometimes people call it "restraining the sense doors." Restraint, for someone who grew up in the 60s, is particularly uninviting and unwelcome, because you just want to say, "If it feels good, do it." But the literal word is to protect—protection at the sense doors. The idea of this protection is not restraint; it's not turning your eyes down, not looking at anything so you don't get caught by the sense world out there—the billboards and attractive people or attractive iPhones or whatever it might be. You actually walk in the world participating, seeing, sensing, and experiencing the world. But you're watching at the place where you see, hear, and taste to make sure that there's no grasping. We don't cling or tighten around anything; that's what the protection is.

There's also no pronoun, as far as I can tell, in the protection idea. What are we protecting? One of the things we're protecting—and this becomes true for people who begin meditating—is something that's precious inside. We're protecting a quality of beauty, a capacity for the heart to thrive. There's a word in Pali, vepulla[6], that I think is best translated by the English word "thrive." It means to grow, to increase, to develop—just the same kinds of meanings that go with the word thrive. But thrive really has an enlivening, invigorating kind of feeling. It's what helps the inner life to thrive, to be beautiful, to be a refuge for ourselves. As we meditate, we begin discovering that we calm down, we stop being so harsh on ourselves, we stop being so preoccupied and stressed out, and we start discovering there's something really good that lives inside of us. That is obscured by grasping and clinging. So when we grasp at the sense doors, we obscure this beauty, what lets us thrive.

But also, because there's no pronoun connected to it, it's a way of protecting others. It's generally a good idea to live a life that protects others as well. The Buddha actually gives these wonderful instructions. He said, "Make yourself safe for others." I'm inspired by that idea. Bhikkhu Bodhi translates that as "Make yourself a refuge for others," but the literal meaning is "Make yourself safe for others." Go through the world and not only don't cause harm, but answer a higher call, which is to be safe for other people as you go through this world. To be someone who is safe is someone who doesn't cause harm. It is someone who has discovered something inside that's worth protecting, something beautiful and valuable.

Moments of Imminent Danger

The second training, the training in samādhi, developing our inner life, is really crucial, and the two go hand-in-hand. How we are on the inside affects how we behave in the world outside of us. It's generally recognized that there's an expression now: "hangry." Have you ever been hangry? It's a portmanteau for hungry and angry. If you're hungry and angry and tired and thirsty and frustrated, the chance of doing something unethical, saying something that's mean or harmful to others, goes up dramatically. Even for the person who normally is maybe the most ethical person you know.

So to be safe, we guard ourselves so we don't allow ourselves to get to the place where we're hangry. We don't get to the place where we have a stressed-out inner life where we're triggered to behave in ways that are not good. For some people, that just means don't be mean in how you speak. For some people in our society, it means don't shoot someone, because there are people who have guns. Jacques Verduin[7] comes and speaks here. He works with lifers in prison who are there because they killed someone. He has worked with hundreds of them now and helped with their inner transformation.

He tells a story about how he does this wonderful work. He says he has groups of about thirty men who work together at any given time, who are lifers. He has them announce how many years they've been in prison, and then he adds it all up for the thirty men. Usually, they get to somewhere around an average of 700 years that, collectively, they've been in prison. And then he asks, "How long was the period of imminent danger?" Meaning, how long was the period in which you were in danger of committing your crime? For most of them, the crime they did—killing someone—was rather impulsive. It was a thing of the moment, sometimes in terms of seconds. So they add that up for those thirty men: how long was the period of imminent danger? I forget exactly what numbers, but it's in the range of about seven minutes for thirty murderers. Isn't that something? Seven minutes versus 700 years. That's quite a trade-off.

One of the things he teaches his men in prison is to pay attention to the moments of imminent danger, and learn to recognize them. Learn how to see it coming, learn how to take care of oneself so that they don't go overboard and do something they don't want to do. The same thing happens to people who are simply mean in what they say to their spouse or someone—chances are there was a moment of imminent danger. It's important to recognize when we're frustrated, impatient, hungry, or whatever it might be, and then be careful.

But what's even better, and more important I think, is not simply to recognize when we're in danger, but to actually cultivate the opposite. To cultivate an inner quality of being that is not just avoiding being triggered in harmful ways, but is actually going to be inspired to do completely the opposite—inspired to do things which are generous, kind, supportive, and nice to other people.

I don't know if this is the best example to give, but it's on my mind because it just happened. I was in Berkeley last week early in the morning, and this man came up to me with a hospital band on his wrist. He held out his hand with a bunch of coins in it and he said, "Can you give me some money? I just came out of the hospital and I'm hungry and I don't know where to go." Sometimes that's a nice story, so who knows. He had almost no teeth and seemed a bit ragged. I was actually on the phone on the sidewalk when he came up, and I said, "Just wait a minute." I wanted to finish my phone call. He kind of stayed on his corner, so he wasn't going anywhere.

I finished my phone call, and then I gave him five dollars. That was nice. I looked in my wallet, that's what I had, and it was nice to give him. I felt good about it, just a simple thing to do. But how he responded to me made my day. I was so happy! He was so happy, so relieved. Like, wow, that was a great thing. First, he fist-bumped me, and then he wanted to give me a hug, which I went along with twice. He also told me that he was in the hospital for pneumonia, so I wasn't so enthusiastic! [Laughter] And then he happily went off and left his corner.

The reason I'm telling the story is how I benefited from that. Somehow it was like food for me to see his joy, his delight, his warmth, his generosity to me in being grateful. What a great thing that I benefited from that—probably more than he benefited, who knows.

So what inner quality, what way of being, what kind of inner clarity (to use the Dalai Lama's language) develops your capacity to want to respond to the world in that kind of way, rather than shutting down and feeling unsafe? This is one of the functions of meditation practice. To develop this inner life, to have something precious, valuable, and beautiful that's worth protecting, worth living from, that inspires you. Rather than looking inside and finding someone who's a taskmaster, or harsh, or hostile even to himself. Look inside and find someone who's kind to oneself, supportive of oneself, supportive of the world. Find feelings of joy and delight and peacefulness and beautiful qualities. These two go hand-in-hand: behavior and inner state.

The Ethical Impact of Speech

How this works in our modern world is important. One of the things to consider is the way in which so much so-called news is spread that is not accurate, that's fake. Whether it's spread in some of the news outlets or spread on social media, it's having a huge impact on our society. Even with some of the newspapers I like reading because they have a political slant that I kind of like, when I read some of these articles, I question, "Where did they get this idea from?" Just a few times I've even gone and done some research to learn more about a particular topic, and realized, "Wait a minute, I'm not sure about this. Maybe they are just spinning this as well."

How much can we trust the media, how much can we trust what we read, is a huge topic in our society. When I was in fifth or sixth grade, I had this wonderful teacher. We used to read articles from something like Reader's Digest about the world and politics, and there was an article about Russia (back then the Soviet Union). He wanted to teach us how to read the news and reports to be able to see how it wasn't always accurate. This was 1965 or '66, so this has been going on for a while. It's just much more intensified in the modern world.

Because of how important it is to be careful with what we read, one of the ways to be careful is to have heightened care in how we behave as a result of it, in what we say and what we do. Buddhist ethics, sīla, has to do with our behavior. It becomes increasingly important to speak in ways that are truthful, that are helpful and beneficial, that are kind, and that are timely. If what you have to say is not true, or you doubt whether it's true, if what you say really doesn't benefit the world, if it's not kind, and there's not the right time to say it—the Buddhist instructions are: don't say it. Wait until it's true. Wait until it's a beneficial time to say it. Wait until you can say it in a kind way, and wait until the right time to say it.

If we can't be sure about what we're reading, hopefully we can be sure about how we speak. This is so important because we have a tremendous amount of mean-spirited communication going on in our society. I'm just astounded by the degree of it—certainly on social media, certainly in our comments on the news, certainly in all kinds of ways. I think people feel they have permission to speak this way. Not only permission, but it has earned a cachet; it has a certain sense of empowerment, feeling you're right, belonging, and creating a sense of self and other, which is enlivening for people. But enlivening is not inner thriving. If you don't have a sense of what inner thriving is, and you're relying on being enlivened, then it's a shallow world.

The Precepts as Brakes

And then there's the behavior of what we do with our bodies, and the Five Precepts[8] become increasingly important. There was one teacher who said that not having the Five Precepts as part of your life is like buying a really nice new car that you're going to love to drive around in, but you wanted to save some money, so one of the options you didn't choose to get was the brakes! You've been given this wonderful vehicle for this life—your body, your being—and sometimes we forget that we have brakes. We leave the brakes at the factory.

The precepts are really brakes. If you're getting close to wanting to kill someone, put on the brakes. If you're getting close to actively harming someone, put on the brakes, don't do it. If you're close to wanting to take what is not given, to steal, put on the brakes. If you're going to harm someone, anyone, through your sexuality, put on your brakes. If you're going to lie and you see it coming, put on the brakes. In Buddhism they say, if you're going to start getting intoxicated with anything, drugs or alcohol, put on the brakes. Don't do it.

This is a way of making yourself safe and making the world around you safe. Some of you perhaps feel like you can engage in alcohol and drugs safely, which maybe you can. But you might think twice about whether you're contributing to a world where other people are safe from the influence of these things. We're in it together, and what we do has some influence.

If nothing else, I'm very concerned about how I spend my money. I think of money as having an ethical spin on it. I live on donations, dāna[9], that people give. I feel like the money that I have to spend for my life and my family has a profound spin of generosity as part of it, and so I don't want to go out and buy cigarettes with it. What would you think about that? You give a lot of dāna, and I buy cigars? I not only want to be careful with it, but I also want to contribute to our society by continuing an ethical spin, a good spin on it. So I'll try to buy things or use the money in ways that continue that kind of way. Even though you can buy and drink alcohol happily and safely, what spin are you putting on those dollars—or those electrons now—as they go out into the world? It's an interesting thing to consider.

One reflection I have is that with the more fake news there is, the more we have to really be impeccable and careful with our behavior. One of the ways I see it operating is with all the self-righteousness going on around identity politics, and politics in general, and divisiveness. I think that when we are angry towards others, when we shame others, when we box them in, we're actually harming ourselves as well. Anything that limits our inner thriving closes it down, because creating division between people is harming ourselves. So we need to be really careful with what we do and how we do it. Find ways to engage in changing the world that don't shame people, criticize people, or make people feel less. I saw at UC Berkeley there's a new little project called "Zero Shame, 100% Empowerment." Let's empower people and encourage people to change, rather than close them down.

Intentionality vs. Consequences

The other thing I was thinking about along these lines is this idea of intentionality. "It's all about our intention. I didn't mean to cause harm. My intentions are good. I'm not doing anything wrong, so it's okay." Think about it. I assume all of us in some ways here are causing harm unintentionally. If you were the only person in California who ever drove a car, even if it was a really smoky, polluting car, it really would have a negligible effect on the air quality, and the people who live near freeways would not get asthma and all kinds of cancers. Because it's just one car, right? But when you have 36 million, or maybe 24 million cars in California, many of them concentrated in urban areas, your unintentional "I'm so innocent, I'm not doing anything" is contributing to the aggregate.

As we look at climate change and the environmental destruction that's going on on our planet, it's billions of people who have no intention to cause any harm, no intention to cause any damage. Are billions of people off the hook because their intention is innocent, while the harm just gets perpetuated?

In many ways, intentionality is not good enough. It's kind of a myth that's been perpetuated that the Buddha said what's important about our ethical behavior has to do with the intentions behind it. It doesn't seem like he said that at all. The Buddha analyzed our behavior, the ethics of it, based on the consequences that behavior has—whether it causes harm or causes benefit. That requires some study. That requires being awake and paying attention to what you say and what you do, and even what you think, and what kind of effect that has on the world around you. To be hyper-individualistic—"It's all about me, I can just take care of myself and just watch my own intentions, without any attention to the impact our life has"—is not the Buddhist way of analyzing our life. It has to do with the effect in the world.

One of the ways that this is stated by the Buddha is a wonderful statement that can be seen as a summary or encapsulation of all of Buddhism. It's a very powerful statement. It goes like this: "A wise person is not motivated to cause harm to oneself, to others, to both self and others, or to the whole world. A person of great wisdom is concerned with the welfare of oneself, the welfare of others, the welfare of both self and others, and the welfare of the whole world."

Those are consequentialist ways of thinking. We're interested in what the consequences are going to be for ourselves and the world around us. That's the analysis that the Buddha has. I think that with the environmental and economic challenges we have, we have to have that on the forefront of our concern. This is very different from some of the challenging views we have these days in the United States that are all about "me"—"I have a right, I deserve, no one should tell me what to do, I can live independently, and my intentions are good." But are they really? Are the consequences really good?

Implicit Bias and Mental Clarity

A third aspect of Buddhist practice that I think needs to be reconsidered and is really important for a modern world is what we've been learning, certainly in the last five years or more, about what's called implicit bias. It's kind of amazing what we're learning about how assumptions, beliefs, and attitudes that we have about other people are invisible to ourselves. They can be subconscious and involve bias and prejudice.

One example is ageism. There are all these studies of implicit bias showing that there's a huge bias in favor of young people and against older people. What's particularly interesting is that older people have just as much the same bias against older people as younger people. Isn't that amazing? It is so internalized, so part of the culture that we carry with us. This is true for all kinds of "-isms." One of the things I've noticed in the last five years is that the suffix "-ism" used to refer to beliefs; now it seems to refer to unconscious implicit bias that we carry with us. We have ageism, racism, ableism, sexism, speciesism—all kinds of things.

You can go online now and take an implicit bias test. I took it a few years ago, and you can choose different categories of "-isms" that you want to check yourself out on. What was surprising to me was that my self-evaluation before I did the exam was that I had less implicit bias than the test showed I did. I was on the minor side, the small side, but it was still more than I thought I had. Wow, this is interesting that my self-evaluation wasn't quite right. That's kind of the nature of implicit bias. If you have a chance, I would encourage you to do some of these tests. It's a little bit of a wake-up call. I think it comes out of Harvard University. If you search for "implicit bias test," you can find it.

How this relates to Buddhism is that the samādhi part, the part of mental training and training the heart, creates the conditions internally where mindfulness is able to watch much more carefully the thoughts, the attitudes, and the reactivity that we have to the people we encounter and to what goes on in the world. The quieter and stiller the mind gets, the earlier and more subtly we can see the arising of reactivity, of judgments, of beliefs that are happening. I don't know if it's going to catch all of our implicit bias, but we'll catch it more and more. We'll see the beginnings of it: "Oh, there it is."

If the mind is crowded with thoughts, ideas, desires, wishes, stressed out, and involved in all kinds of wonderful projects and judgments of everyone else, there's too much going on in the mind to really watch the birth of all these teeny little subtle decisions that are made all the time. To be able to catch this implicit bias earlier, you really have to learn to meditate, settle yourself, learn to be mindful, and carry that into your daily life. You'll start catching this much better, and this is really crucial for our society.

Another thing that I've been learning over the last ten years, in a way that I never dreamt of before, is how small, seemingly inconsequential implicit biases—implicit preferences for one kind of person—add up if a lot of people are doing it. Just like the driving thing, it adds up. I can see so many ways in which white people in our culture get a little preferential treatment. Sometimes huge, but what I mostly notice is a little preferential treatment here and there. A little bit here, a little bit there, and it adds up. If it happens ten thousand times a day, each time unnoticed, each time just part of the fabric and texture of society, just how the world is, it's not seen. But it adds up to a huge advantage that white people have in so many areas of our life.

Everyone is innocent. "I didn't do it." And just like older people have implicit bias against older people, people who are not white sometimes also have that implicit bias for white people—sometimes giving them a little bit of the benefit of the doubt or a little bit extra push here and there, and it adds up to a lot.

As a whole, the stresses developing in our society are being seen much more clearly now. In terms of living an ethical life, we train ourselves through something like meditation practice. We do some kind of internal mental development that allows us to really settle and quiet the mind, strengthen the mind, or, to use the Dalai Lama's language, create clarity in the mind. This allows us to start seeing more and more the tiniest little reactivities we have—cringing or opening, going for or against—so we can take responsibility for it and be much more careful in all kinds of ways.

Conclusion

In this way, I hope that in today's talk I've presented the idea of Buddhist ethics in a way that maybe is more relevant for how much our society is changing. I wanted to highlight that it has changed a lot, and we need to take that change into account, really being willing to change accordingly to get in harmony with what's happening. A wise relationship to what's happening is really appropriate for someone who wants to live a life grounded in the welfare of oneself, the welfare of others, the welfare of both self and others, and the welfare of the whole world.

Those are my thoughts. In about five minutes or so, we have a potluck, and everyone's welcome to come. Because it's a potluck, it would be really great if you would turn towards one or two people near you and say hello to them. If anything was inspiring or beneficial for you in this talk, maybe you can share that point with your partner as you say hello.

[Laughter]

I think it's too late, we've lost control. Can I... can I...



  1. Sīla: A Pali word usually translated as ethics, virtue, or moral conduct. The original transcript said "Cielo" and "Selah" / "Cecila", which was corrected to "sīla" based on context. ↩︎

  2. Samādhi: A Pali word translated as concentration, meditation, or cultivating the mind. The original transcript said "Samadhi", which was corrected to "samādhi" based on context. ↩︎

  3. Paññā: A Pali word translated as wisdom or insight. The original transcript said "punya", which was corrected to "paññā" based on context. ↩︎

  4. Dalai Lama: The spiritual leader of Tibetan Buddhism. The book referenced is Kindness, Clarity, and Insight. ↩︎

  5. Bhikkhu Bodhi: An American Theravada Buddhist monk and renowned translator of the Pali Canon. The original transcript said "a bigger body" and "bigger booty", which was corrected to "Bhikkhu Bodhi" based on context. ↩︎

  6. Vepulla: A Pali word meaning growth, increase, abundance, or thriving. The original transcript said "the Pula", which was corrected to "vepulla" based on context. ↩︎

  7. Jacques Verduin: A pioneer in prison rehabilitation and the founder of the Insight Prison Project and GRIP (Guiding Rage Into Power) Training Institute. The original transcript said "Jacque Verdana", which was corrected to "Jacques Verduin" based on context. ↩︎

  8. Five Precepts: The foundational ethical code for Buddhist laypeople: abstaining from taking life, taking what is not given, sexual misconduct, false speech, and intoxication. ↩︎

  9. Dāna: A Pali word meaning generosity or giving. The original transcript said "Adana", which was corrected to "dāna" based on context. ↩︎