Moon Pointing

Not Self

Date:
2019-06-23
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-14 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Not Self

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Not Self

So, good morning everyone. Welcome to IMC.

Some weeks ago, mention was made about the Buddhist teachings on not-self, and I think there was an interest in hearing more about this. I said I would at some point, and so now is the time.

I like this topic quite a bit in that I associate it as a teaching that addresses some of the fundamental suffering of human beings. When we're meeting people or encountering ourselves in our suffering, it's a tender thing. As human beings, the connection we have with each other and the connection we have with ourselves is very important. It is a tender, caring thing that we have some love and concern for. To understand this teaching of not-self—or to realize it, more importantly—is a way of caring for ourselves and for others.

That's the spirit and attitude through which I want to present this, if I can, because it's very easy for this teaching of not-self to get pretty heady. It's often presented as a philosophy or some kind of doctrine about how things are. I don't think it's meant to be a philosophy at all. Rather, it's a realization; something that we realize or see for ourselves experientially.

If you don't understand the Buddhist teachings on not-self, you don't have to try too hard. It's not exactly something that's meant to be understood as a doctrine where you logically put it all together. You might find lots of logical reasons why this doesn't make sense, but don't get too hung up on that.

One way of preparing for these teachings on not-self is to first talk about the Buddha's perspective or understanding of what it is to be a person. If you go through his teachings that survive, he doesn't specifically say, "This is my understanding of personhood." But the way that he talks about human beings, you can piece together a general view of what it means to be a person. The teachings of not-self are not meant to be a negation of the basic understanding of what it means to be a person.

The whole enterprise of early Buddhism is based on a lot of respect and valuing of the individual person, both in their individual uniqueness and in that which is universal about human beings. The word "personhood" in my mind bridges both what is unique and specific to individuals, and what is universal for human beings. To understand who we are as human beings is one of the great enterprises of human life. Many people and other religions besides Buddhism are involved in the enterprise of understanding, "Who am I? What am I? And what's going on here?"

Sometimes—and I was probably responsible for this when I was a young, idealistic Buddhist teacher—people who asked, "Who am I?" or "What am I?", I would reply by trying to pull the rug from underneath them, saying, "Well, there is no self, so get over it." [Laughter] Now that I'm older and maybe a teeny bit wiser, I feel more tender around this topic. For many people, waking up to who they are is done through the layers of their suffering and challenges. It's a tender thing to connect down deep.

There's a story from the Ramayana[1] that is often quoted in the Buddhist world that I'm fond of. Rama is walking in the woods with companions and he hears a very faint voice. He can't quite make out what it's saying. He asks his companions, "Do you hear this voice?" and no one else hears it. So he begins to walk towards that voice. No one still hears it, but he gets closer and then he hears what it's saying. It is calling his name: "Rama, Rama."

He gets closer and finds that it seems to be coming out of a large boulder. Boulders are solid, maybe granite. He takes the soft palms of his hands and he touches the boulder. As I remember the story, the boulder breaks open and inside there is a woman. She's been there for a very long time in that prison.

To interpret this as a myth: what is it that's petrified inside of ourselves? What's frozen inside of ourselves, and what's calling our name? In what way are we calling for ourselves to connect and be present for ourselves? We don't take a sledgehammer to that, but we take what's soft and tender and we just touch it and meet it. Once we find it and meet it, something gets revealed and opens up. Different religions have different answers as to what's core or essential inside.

To begin getting to what the Buddha had to say, I wanted to say a few things about how the Buddha understands what it is to be a person. With the nature of being a human being, a person is subject to suffering and to happiness. Subject to aging and dying. Subject to integration—becoming whole—and disintegration—becoming fragmented. Becoming connected to themselves and being alienated from what's here. A person is subject to healing and to wounding, or psychological illness. In classic Buddhist language, a person is subject to bondage and to freedom; to the fetters and our attachments, where we can break free of those attachments and become free. This is the nature of us.

Another very important part of being a person is that the Buddha saw that each person as an individual is a moral agent. We are responsible for the ethical choices we make—the choices to cause harm or cause benefit. We're not just robots going through life on some kind of automatic self-driven ethics. It involves reflection, care, attention, and the cultivation of a moral character that we have responsibility for. We are moral agents, and in that regard, a human being is able to make choices.

The Buddha distinguishes between people not on anything inherent, but rather based on their choices. People self-identify by their choices. If someone steals, the Buddha sees that person is a thief. This morning I met a wonderful park ranger who seemed like a lovely, beautiful man at a local park, who was preparing to receive Eagle Scout volunteers. He just seemed completely kind, supportive, and enthusiastic, setting up and having his Eagle Scouts come and repair a trail. So by his choice, he wasn't just a park ranger; he was a kind person.

The Buddha would differentiate people by their choices and what they did. A huge part of that for the Buddha was their moral choices. He was very clear about identifying people by their morality. It wasn't like keeping them in a box and saying, "This is who you are," but rather pointing to the fact that you have choice and you can grow, go in a different direction, and become a different person.

This idea that we can grow, develop, and change is inherent in the Buddhist teachings of impermanence and inconstancy. The teachings of not-self are clearly built on the teachings of impermanence. It's the experience of impermanence that gives us the experience of not-self. The radical, changing nature of ourselves and the world is a huge foundation for understanding not-self.

Sometimes I maybe talk too much about impermanence. It can seem like, "These Buddhists are always talking about impermanence, and it's kind of a drag." It can sound pretty depressing for some people. The fact that things change and are constantly in flux implies that things are lost and end, but it also implies that things begin, and that things are changeable. Change doesn't mean that we're the victim of change. The fact that everything changes means we can set the direction of that change. We can change ourselves, our character, our moral stance in the world, and how we live.

Part of the Buddhist view of the person is that we can establish and commit ourselves to ways of living that better ourselves and better the world around us. The Buddha saw that human beings are subject to cause and effect, to conditionality. Whatever we do has consequences, and we can take responsibility for those consequences. We can put conditions in place to allow ourselves to become better people, better servants, or carers of the world around us. So that's nice.

The last thing I want to say about the Buddhist view of personhood is that spiritual liberation—liberation of the heart—is a worthwhile goal and a potential we all have. This idea of potential is very important. We have potential to do evil, but we also have potential to do good. And separate from both those categories, but related to doing good, we have the potential for liberation. We have the potential to heal ourselves, to open the heart, and to free the heart from all the fetters, ties, chains, contractions, and armor that may be around it.

There's powerful language in the ancient world of bursting out of this mass of darkness. Someone who's awakened bursts through the mass of darkness. We have this potential, and this is kind of who we are and our nature.

Later Buddhism got very reluctant—especially in the modern world—to talk about human beings having a "nature," because it easily leads to the idea that we have some essential, true nature that is a permanent, existing thing. We don't want to reify this essential nature. But there can still be a nature inside of us that is potential, that is changing, like the nature of growing. We all have that.

The rumor is that every single one of you at one point was a child running around in diapers. I don't want to assume too much, but probably. If we were in this room together right now, and maybe you're the only adult and everyone else showed up as a two-year-old, I think our hearts would all break open. They'd be so cute. We've grown and developed and now we're this age, and maybe it's a little bit harder to have our hearts break open so easily, but it's pretty sweet that we're here together.

This idea that we have a nature is represented nicely in a very important chant that we do sometimes at funerals, sometimes at births, whenever Buddhists can. It's a chant on impermanence. In Pali it goes something like: Aniccā vata saṅkhārā, uppādavayadhammino. Uppajjitvā nirujjhanti, tesaṃ vūpasamo sukho.[2] All things are impermanent, all conditioned things are impermanent, they have the nature to arise and pass. They have the possibility of stilling, of quieting, of ceasing. The stilling of all these conditions, these mental formations, is the greatest happiness.

Here we have this: "All things arise and pass, and they have the nature of being impermanent." The word for nature here is dhamma[3], which has many different meanings, but here is being used to mean "nature" or "subject to." The nature of arising and passing. This is a very central word that's associated with what the Buddha's teaching is. Things do have a nature, but it's not an essential, permanent core; it has this nature of arising and passing, of change. A huge part of mindfulness practice is to attune ourselves to the impermanent, changing nature of reality, of ourselves, and of what's going on.

I chose the words "attune ourselves" carefully, rather than "understand" or "realize." I could almost use the words "to be in harmony with," or "resonate with," or "center ourselves" in the middle of this changing world. As we were meditating here just before this talk, I could feel myself being attuned to the present moment in a deep, clear way, feeling how things were shifting and changing. It was like resting on the waves of the ocean, feeling myself moved around by them, nicely massaged by them.

Then I could find myself drifting off in thought. I could see how in the thinking, things would seem a little bit more solid. The concepts and ideas took me out of the experiential world of change into the world of something that has more constancy. Concepts give ourselves a constancy. Even if I'm thinking about what's changing, the way I think about it, I'm latching on and holding on.

Going back to resting in this flow—the changing nature of phenomena—would be a little bit like if you're watching a river go by, mesmerized and absorbed in watching the waves and the current, and it's very peaceful. And then you remember an important thing you had to do, or some resentment you have, and suddenly you lose touch with the river and you are contracted around your thoughts. This movement away from being contracted in our thoughts back into the river of our life is a huge part of the direction we're going in Vipassana[4] meditation. As we do this, and we're no longer caught in our thoughts, we're here in the flow of the experience. That's when the teachings of not-self become more interesting and relevant.

You can see how self-preoccupation takes you out of the flow of the river of life. Being concerned with the self—me, myself, and mine—leaves that world and enters the world of contraction, concepts, and ideas, and then we lose touch with the present. Sometimes the times we think about ourselves can be wonderful. We can have wonderful fantasies about how great things are. If it's about the future, the future has a lot of hope for some people. It can be quite compelling to be up there, until the future comes and it is nothing like what we hoped it would be, and then, "What was I thinking?" Or we get caught up in the past. Sometimes it's seductive, sometimes it can be very pleasant, but it is a separation away from here.

If what we're doing is putting our hands on the boulder to really feel what's here, and let it break open or dissolve, it requires us to really be here in the experience. As we're able to do that better and better, we notice how we leave that experience. If you're paying attention to how much "selfing" is going on—how much "me, myself, and my concerns" are going on—it's probably a high percentage of the time. To be able to not get caught up in that self-preoccupation all the time is one of the great tasks of life, to discover what we are without it.

I was walking up in the hills a week or so ago at Edgewood Park. There are a lot of deer, and they must be very used to people because I walked by, and one was about ten feet away. She looked up at me. Deer have big eyes. Up close, those deer eyes are quite something. She looked up at me completely unconcerned that I was ten feet away. She looked at me for a while and then she went back to eating. In those moments that we made eye contact, being felt, being seen, I was not thinking, "Boy, I'm a good deer seer. I really know how to stare at a deer, and I better tell people how great I am at looking at deer." The opposite happened. For those moments, self-concern was not in the picture at all. Everything was still and quiet.

We have the potential to have a mind that is alive and present and experiences life, that's not constantly self-referential or self-consciously preoccupied with trying to prove or apologize for itself. It can be a relief. What we start seeing is how much we do this and how much it's not necessary. It might be necessary sometimes; after all, we're moral agents and no one else is going to think for us about what to do. We're responsible for ourselves, so some kind of thinking about ourselves is quite appropriate. But to always do it is a form of attachment. To learn to put it to rest when it's not needed and to let go is restful, but it's also a doorway to understand more deeply how to live a life, how to be present, and how to experience real freedom from self and self-concern.

As meditation practice unfolds, being able to let go of self-concern and these thoughts of "me, myself, and mine" and just be alive and present brings a stillness in the mind around self, as when I was looking into the eyes of the deer. You probably have a similar reference for yourself. Think of a time in your life when maybe you felt safe enough, things were comfortable or pleasant enough that you were involved in something, or maybe looking at something like a river, and you had the experience that self-concern just dropped away. Maybe for some moments, part of the relief and beauty of it was that you weren't thinking about yourself in any kind of way—your projects, your needs, your resentments.

Just to be alive is enough. Just to be here and settled and quiet. To settle in or drop in to that way of being is our potential. It's a remarkable thing to discover that we have the potential to have a state of heart and mind that's not preoccupied, that's really rooted and centered in the present moment without the mind having any tendency to drift off. It is not an easy place to experience in meditation, but we have that potential. It's a wonderful North Star to head towards, but also to use as a reference point to understand better how we do get preoccupied. A huge part of the task is to really see that.

As these things settle down, there are very significant insights that the tradition holds up as being very important in this path to liberation. The first insight that's important is giving up any belief in what's called sakkāya-diṭṭhi[5]. Diṭṭhi means view or philosophy or doctrine, and sakkāya is a difficult word to translate. Literally, it means the "true body" or the "existing body." Some Western translators translate it as "individuality," some translate it as "personality view" or "individualism." I don't think that really captures what the original is in the ancient context. Sakkāya probably refers to the idea that there is a soul or a spirit or an essential thing that resides inside of us, that's somehow always been here. In the time of the Buddha, people called this the ātman or the attā[6].

In this context it probably meant something related to the English idea of "soul." To realize that there is no essential, permanent, abiding soul or essence is a core Buddhist principle. But it isn't so much a principle, it's a realization. And it's not really a negation of this soul theory either, because that's just more philosophy. Rather, it's to be settled enough, quiet enough, clear enough in the present moment, seeing what's here in the experience of things moment by moment, free of all these concepts we have, and become really clear that nothing here qualifies as being permanent.

Nothing here qualifies as being an essential, ongoing, permanent thing that we can call the self. Whether there is one or isn't one is beside the point. At least from the Buddhist point of view, if it can't be experienced, it is not really relevant to his project. If it can't be seen or known, but is just a theory or an idea people have inherited from their past, it's not relevant. What people get attached to, and what they cling to and get contracted around, is concepts and ideas of what can be experienced. So if we're letting go of our attachment to concepts, we have to also let go of the concept that the self exists, and the concept that the self does not exist.

If we focus on what can be directly experienced, and we look around, nothing here is permanent. Nothing is the existing body or the existing self. That realization supports people to begin letting go of attachments even more, and gives people a very palpable and visceral experience of release that for some is life-changing. Rather than always chasing after the next thing to hold, or to be, or get, a lot of this freedom has to do with release.

Release around this very complex attachment people have to self. It is almost built into being a human being, because we are individuals and moral agents, so it is appropriate to focus on ourselves and help ourselves find our way in life. But then we have a lot of societal messages that pile on complicated attachments around what it means to be "yourself". All you have to do is spend a little bit of time watching advertisements, and there are a lot of messages about what kind of self you should be. Very smart people get paid a lot of money to convince you that you're supposed to be a certain kind of person. Politicians and cultures pile all this stuff on top of ideas of self, and so it gets very complicated and difficult to begin to shed it.

That is the task of Buddhist meditation: shedding a lot of this and experiencing this deeper potential we have. A potential which is not an essential thing, but it has to do with the essential impermanence, the essential changeableness, the essential possibility of growth, the essential possibility of being a moral agent, and the essential nature of becoming free. This is what the teachings open up, this is what the teachings of not-self are pointing to.

Finally, I'll say that to translate anattā[7] as "not-self" rather than "no self" is actually quite important. When you say there's "no self," you're making a philosophical, metaphysical claim. If you're saying "not-self," it's more like an adjective. It's describing something as being not-self. It's called a characteristic of things. The things we actually can experience moment by moment, that appear and go, they have the characteristic of being changeable. Those things that are constantly changing also have the characteristic that they themselves are not-self.

Does that mean there's no self? The Buddha explicitly said don't bother with that. In one place he calls it a philosophical quagmire. Once you go down this road of saying there's no self, you're caught in doctrine and philosophy. But there are experiences of not-self, beautiful experiences where it feels like there is no self in this experience. I think what the Buddha is saying is to enjoy them, learn not to cling, but don't come to any philosophical conclusion that there is or is not a self. Be a responsible person and become free.

So that's my attempt today to introduce this idea of not-self. We have about five minutes if you want some clarification or questions about that, or have counter views.

Q&A

Questioner: I hope I can find the right way to express this question. In regards to experiencing and knowing that it's not self, it's not soul... who is it that's doing this experiencing? Who is it? I don't know how to answer that question for myself.

Gil Fronsdal: It might not be necessary to answer the question. To the degree to which you're the moral agent or the agent of choice, you can just say, "I'm experiencing this or not," and you don't need to know exactly who you are in terms of your essential nature. In a conventional way, I'm talking and you're hearing me. I think that's enough for me.

But when we get quiet, then there can be hearing without there being a hearer. There is seeing but no seer. There's tasting but no taster. When we realize the idea of a seer, hearer, or taster is a concept that's laid on top of it, it's helpful because if I'm hungry, it's helpful to be clear I'm the one who's hungry so I can go do something about it. But if I'm really quiet, I realize there's an experience of hunger, but I don't have to say "I'm hungry." There's an experience of pain; I don't have to say "I'm in pain."

Actually, to experience hunger without the "I," pain without the "I," it becomes a lot simpler. You might live in a nice place where there are ducks and water, and you might go out and see what it's like just to experience those things as you walk down the pathway without any concern about who is seeing the ducks. It's just seeing.

Questioner: Yeah, I guess I'm thinking in terms of how do I handle this at the time of death? If I am aware that I am dying, is it "I am dying"? How do I encompass that? What's the need to encompass it? I'm not dying yet, but it just seems important. When I'm thinking about death and that's the biggest change that I'm going to experience, I would like to have some sense of who is this happening to or how... do you get what I'm trying to say?

Gil Fronsdal: I may say that my attitude towards my dying is directly related to some of the clearest experiences I've had in meditation where self-concern was not present at all. If I'm fortunate about how I die, without being comatose or in too much pain, but have enough clarity, I kind of look forward to dying because I imagine that it's very much the same process that goes on when meditation deepens and deepens. I trust that process.

I trust the letting go process and I trust the letting go of self-concern. The question of who's dying, I imagine if I'm dying that's completely the last thing on my mind; that's irrelevant. I knew one person who was dying and he got all these books on death and dying so he would do it right. People have been dying for a long time, so the system knows how to take care of it.

I trust the system. If I let go, if I relax, if I stay present... What I don't trust is fear. What I don't trust is anguish or clinging to something, and that makes it hard. If I was clinging or really afraid when I'm dying, then I might have some more concerns and look at, "Who do you think you are? What's this self that's clinging and holding on?" I'd bring my mindfulness to that, because I've spent so many years looking at the clinging and contraction around self. If that happened as I was dying, I would just turn my attention to that. But if it's not there, I just let go. Let go and trust the process.

Questioner: Can I ask just one more thing? How does one hold grief at the death of someone else?

Gil Fronsdal: Yeah, it's a great question. How do we hold grief at the death of someone else? I think with a lot of kindness and clarity and space and non-embarrassment, and a willingness to have it move through us. For me, I like very much the image of... I would find my grief, which I do sometimes when I have it, and try to sit right in the middle of it as if it can be there forever, as if it has its own life. Allow it to be there with the attitude, "Something wants to be born here. What is it that wants to be born in this grief?"

For me, asking this question, "What wants to be born here?" is an antidote to the ever-so-subtle views or thoughts—a way of thinking, kind of almost invisible—that feels, "Oh, this is a problem, this is wrong, it shouldn't be here," which actually makes it so much more difficult. The question "What wants to be born here?" makes space for the grief and allows it to be there. It gives it permission to be there, almost like, "You're welcome, come show yourself."

Sometimes in order to die well—to use the phrase as shorthand—sometimes we have to resolve some of the stuff like the grief we have. Doing this practice of mindfulness and learning how to open to this and be present for it in an uncomplicated way is really powerful.

So, may you take your not-self person and... [Laughter]



  1. Ramayana: An ancient Indian epic detailing the journey of Rama. ↩︎

  2. Anicca vata sankhara...: A well-known Pali verse often translated as "Impermanent, alas, are all formations. Their nature is to arise and vanish. Having arisen, they cease. Their stilling is true bliss." ↩︎

  3. Dhamma: (or Dharma in Sanskrit) A Pali word with many meanings. Here it is used to mean "nature" or "characteristic," but it can also refer to the teachings of the Buddha or the fundamental principles of reality. ↩︎

  4. Vipassana: A Pali word often translated as "insight," referring to the meditation practice of seeing things as they really are. ↩︎

  5. Sakkāya-diṭṭhi: Often translated as "personality belief" or "identity view," it is the belief in an unchanging, permanent self or soul. ↩︎

  6. Ātman / Attā: The Hindu / Indian philosophical concept of an eternal, essential self or soul. ↩︎

  7. Anattā: The Pali word for "not-self," referring to the teaching that no permanent, unchanging self or soul can be found in any phenomena. ↩︎