Forms of Awareness
- Date:
- 2019-06-02
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-14 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Forms of Awareness
I would like to pick up the theme for that daylong retreat here, and I would like to pick up the theme for that daylong as the topic for this morning. As I started to talk yesterday, I'll start it this way with an analogy.
I've lived here on the peninsula now for about 25 years, and a good amount of that time—about seven years—up in the mountains up here on the top of Skyline in the woods. I live with my wife, who is a botanist. She worked professionally in those mountains as a botanist doing plant surveys, so she knows these plants very well. We've done a lot of hiking together and alone in these mountains and hills. I love it and love the nature here.
Amazingly enough, especially living with a botanist, I haven't really learned the plants of these hills for most of that time. It was kind of just a blur of plants. I knew there were trees, and I knew there were bushes. I knew there were little flowers, and I did learn what some of the invasive weeds were—French broom and thistles. I knew a little bit, but I didn't really know much. I was quite content; I just love being in nature and being out there, but I didn't know.
Then, about a month ago, she was back for a little while from a big hike that she was doing. We were going regularly up walking in the hills, and I started to ask her about the plants. I found myself quite interested in them, and kind of amazed that it took this long. I was quite struck by the difference between how it used to be—I was quite content—and what it's like now. I'm still learning; there's a lot to learn, boy. But I can now identify the predominant trees, different kinds of oaks. I can identify some of the chaparral, the bushes, and some of the plants and flowers. Some of the trees I can identify by their bark; I don't even have to look up at the canopy because the bark is distinctive.
As I'm learning more and more about them, I am also getting curious about what uses these have. I'm reading a little bit about the Native American uses and the early Spanish settlers, and how they used the different plants and what they did with them. I find it fascinating. Now, when I go into the woods up here, I find my attention is heightened, and I'm much less likely to continually drift off and think about things as I'm walking. I'm very attentive and just love noticing what's around me—noticing the different plants and different things. Things stand out and highlight. I notice things about the vegetation, about the local little climate zones and how things shift and change. That world has come alive in a very different way. I have a delightful, heightened attention to my environment as I walk now and find myself increasingly curious about what's around me. So that's nice.
The Inner Ecosystem
The same thing can happen with our minds in meditation. I think some meditators can spend 25 years, and it's all a blur in there. They generally know a little bit about it; we know a little bit about the invasive weeds—the destructive thoughts that come in. We know we should pull them out and not get caught up in them, let go of them, and come back to the present moment. That's helpful to calm down. In the blur of just going for our meditative hike in our minds, it's all kind of nice. It's a blur of things in there, but we know some of the highlights. We know we're getting calmer or more steady, or have some general sense of what it's about.
It's also possible to become cognizant, to be able to identify the different species in there—the different elements of the mind, the qualities of mind. We have an amazingly rich, complex inner life. In terms of the highlights of what you really need to know, it's probably a lot fewer things than going up to one of these nature preserves here. One of the books that we have for the plants in one of the preserves has 400 plants. If you want to learn all the plants, that's a lot to learn; I'm kind of intimidated by it. But to learn your mind, luckily you don't have to learn 500 items. There are actually a few; it's a simpler ecosystem, believe it or not.
But it is possible to learn more about what's going on in there and the different elements that come into play. If you do that as you meditate, the meditation becomes richer. Things become more noticeable. You're more engaged, you're more involved with yourself in meditation, and it becomes more interesting because it's not just simply "I'm either calm or not calm" or "I'm either distracted or not distracted." It becomes a very appealing inner world to get to know and explore. I think of it as an ecosystem. Our inner life is just as much a part of the natural world as being out and walking in the preserves. If you want to be in awe or be inspired by nature, take a walk in your mind. Take a walk in your inner life, get to know it, and know what's going on there.
Directed and Undirected Attention
One of the things that I wanted to highlight about what we can get to know that helps meditation is to know the different kinds of attention. It's almost like there are different species of attention, and different ones are useful in different vegetation zones called microclimates. This means that in different circumstances we find ourselves in, different forms of attention are useful. In the inner climates of our mind, different attentions are useful. We know that well enough if you think about it. If you are at the beach, just relaxed on the sand dunes and looking out across the ocean, it's a very different kind of attention being used than if you're at the grocery store, they've given you your receipt, you think something's wrong with how much they're charging you, and you want to check. You use a very different kind of attention to look at those numbers and figure it out. It's very focused and attentive. It's not like, "Oh, look at these numbers! Wow! Human beings have had numbers for a while. They do wonderful things, and this is so inspiring that grocery stores use these wonderful tools. Numbers, wow!" [Laughter] There's a laser focus, and it's very attentive for a purpose. In different situations, we use different kinds of attention and awareness. It's the same thing in meditation.
I'd like to talk a little bit about some of the main forms of attention that come into play when we meditate, with the idea that maybe you'll recognize these in yourselves. As you start recognizing them, they become something that you can choose to use as needed, as opposed to a one-size-fits-all approach to meditation where there is only one kind of attention. Sometimes people have the idea that concentrated attention is what you're supposed to do—just keep concentrating. They have a very narrow idea of what concentration is, as opposed to it being a variety of different factors that are brought together. Some people have the idea that it's only about noting; it's only about recognizing what's there, and that's all you're allowed to do. I've known people, maybe because their inner life was so challenged, who have used the technique of mental noting like a lifesaver. They're holding onto it for dear life, because any giving up of that means that difficulty in their life bubbles up and makes life too chaotic or difficult. So they're hanging on. It's not really meditative attention; it's just keeping there, noting everything that's going on, making the note, and keeping everything at bay.
I've also known people who practice who don't want to do any kind of directed attention. They don't want to make any kind of effort; they like things being effortless, relaxed, open, and spacious. Maybe this is because their mind is usually the opposite, and so this is a relief. But sometimes if that's all they do, there's no real learning about what's in there. It's not really clear recognition. Some people drift off sometimes for years into a kind of—I don't know if "stupor" is the right word, but some kind of vague place. I've known people who have spent—I think someone recently said 25 years meditating regularly—going into a very peaceful, spacious place where there was nothing there. To spend 25 years in "nothing"—no body, no world around them, going into a kind of blank place—is probably not very useful. There's probably not a lot of wisdom and learning that goes on in that space. But it can be a welcome relief from the challenges of daily life. Some people go into those spaces sometimes because of a tremendous difficulty they've had in their lives, and they're really looking not to have to deal with that, so they're looking for something that checks out. There's a season for everything, and I think there's a season for every type of meditation state and different ways of using attention. But I think it's a wise thing to start learning the different options, the different ways that things can work, and to know when they are needed.
If we are going to get wise about the inner landscape that comes into play when we meditate, we want to be able to notice the important landmarks that are there. With the landmarks in mind, you can begin finding your way. For most meditators, especially people in the beginning, one of the primary landmarks is to notice the particular species of thinking which is distracted thought—that you're lost in thought. Some people come to meditation and haven't had a clue that they've ever been distracted in their life. They've never been "lost in thought" because they're just so lost that they don't know. It's a bit of a shock for some beginning meditators to see how crazy it is in there, or how distracted they are, and how the strong momentum and current of being caught up works. That's actually a very important part of the landscape; it's a very important part of the terrain that you're exploring.
If you go up in these preserves, especially this year, I think one of the really important things to recognize for most of us is poison oak. It has exploded this year. I've been a poison oak expert because my wife gets poison oak very badly. I've been an expert on our hikes to point it out to her: "Watch out, that's there." This year it's hanging down from above. I'm looking down at the ground, and it's hanging from above and hits you in the face. It's like it's there to trap us, reaching out. So it's good to know about poison oak, and it's good to know about this phenomenon of distracted thought—getting lost in thought—because that's like going into the bushes where the poison oak is. It's too easy to get caught up in places that are sometimes not very ideal, useful, or healthy for us. It is important to learn to recognize that and be cognizant of it.
One of the things we notice with these distracted thoughts is that sometimes it's not just that we're distracted, but there's a lot of momentum. There's a strong gravitational pull or a strong drive in the mind to want to go there. That's why it's difficult to just let go. We let go, and the drive to think is still there; the emotional pull or push for it is there. Something is needed to correct for that if we want to be present and not in that world. There are two primary things that are useful.
One is, if it's possible, to relax that momentum to keep thinking. I often teach about relaxing the "thinking muscle." Sometimes just relaxing physically, mentally, or emotionally means there's less power in that distracted thought.
The other is to counter it with a counterforce, and that counterforce is to use directed attention. We direct our attention to something that is not distracted thinking. The most classic thing in Buddhist meditation is to direct the attention to breathing. It can be directed to other things as well, like directing it to loving-kindness[1] or other forms of meditation with developed focuses. But it is an act of choice, an act of will, to direct the attention to something that's considered healthy or skillful.
As we do that—like staying on the breath—we are slowly strengthening the capacity to stay present. We're strengthening the capacity to have directed attention, and we're slowly, bit by bit, weakening the energy of distraction. Every time you bring your attention back, the "food" of attention is going to feed that ability to have directed attention. Every time you don't do that, you're feeding distracted thoughts. Slowly we begin feeding one more than the other, strengthening one more than the other. Sometimes that shift happens in a single session of meditation. Sometimes that state shifts and changes over a period of time or years of meditation, and people slowly get the ability to stay more directed and stay present. Directed attention can itself take a number of different forms.
Clear Recognition
If directed attention is the genus, then the species are the different forms of directed attention. One of them is attention that simply knows what's happening. You're there, and you simply know, "That's the breathing. I'm with the in-breath. That's the out-breath." We know it, and that knowing can be both active and passive. We can engage, direct the attention, and heighten that directedness to get to know and recognize what's there.
First, it's a very simple knowing, but there can be a heightened knowing. That heightened knowing in Pali is sampajañña[2], clear comprehension, or, as I like the expression, clear recognition. This is a phenomenal capacity of the mind to not just kind of know what's going on, but to clearly know what's going on: "This is an in-breath," or "This is a distracted thought," or "This is a particular emotion," "This is sadness," "This is joy." It is to be very clear about the recognition.
When I'm walking up in the hills these days, before, I could recognize it was a tree—I wasn't that lost—but now I clearly recognize it. I was walking down here this morning, and some of these local native trees are street trees. I've been kind of in awe these last couple of weeks with the black oaks. When I was walking down the street, I said, "Oh, there's a black oak!" I didn't know it was there, and that was pretty cool. I clearly recognized it now that I'm paying attention.
The other day, about a week or two ago, I walked by a tree that I've walked by for a long time—about 17 years. I walked by and said, "Wait a minute... wait a minute... wow, this is a dawn redwood." Do you know about dawn redwoods? No? That's a really cool story. Can we do a little aside, because it has a Buddhist association, this dawn redwood?
It was a redwood that was thought to be extinct. In the 1940s, Chinese botanists found a few of them deep in the mountains in China. The way I was told the story, the way it was preserved down through the centuries was in Buddhist monasteries. Deforestation was not uncommon, but at the Buddhist monasteries, the trees were kept. So, at a Buddhist monastery, they found this dawn redwood. It's a deciduous redwood; it doesn't grow that high. In the late 40s and early 50s, it was brought to the United States, and they disseminated the seeds in different places. I first learned about it from a Native American elder, a chieftain up in Marin County, who had been a botanist himself at UC Berkeley in the 50s. He was one of the first people to get a little seedling or seed, and he planted it near Muir Woods. He took me to the tree and showed me, and that was pretty cool. And so there it is, right here. If you come to the picnic, I'll show it to you. How is that for an incentive to have you come? It's in the park there.
So I clearly recognize this, and it's like, "Aha, this is a wonderful moment. I know this black oak, the dawn redwood." We have the capacity in the mind to watch what's going on in ourselves. So this is what it is: "Wow, I'm angry."
Now, that might not seem like a big deal, but clear recognition is very distinct from entangled recognition. Entangled recognition goes something like this: I'm aware that my body is uncomfortable while meditating. Yes, I recognize I'm uncomfortable, but I recognize it like this: "Oh, it's so uncomfortable. Well, why am I meditating today? Why am I meditating at all? It's so uncomfortable. And you know, I probably didn't do enough exercise. I didn't do enough exercise because my parents didn't encourage me enough to exercise when I was a kid. Those parents that I have... I really didn't grow up well. This discomfort is really just their fault." [Laughter] I'm entangled. I recognize the discomfort, but I'm completely lost in a story, in meaning, and associations and all that.
That's a dramatic story, but entanglement can be much more subtle. It could be as simple as, "I'm uncomfortable. It's my discomfort; it's not yours." It's not an innocent thing to call it "my" discomfort. If you really get still and quiet, you can feel the difference between just feeling it as "discomfort" versus "my discomfort." There's a kind of entanglement with "me, myself, and mine." But to clearly know the simplicity of it—"Wow, this is discomfort"—is a way in which that recognition is not entangled. It's kind of like you step back enough and you say, "Wow, I see it for what it is."
One way to get to that is to experiment with it next time you get entangled in your mind with your favorite entanglement. Start using mental noting to recognize it. So, maybe it's distracted thinking. Just doing it casually might not do enough; you're still entangled with it. But you can note: "This is distracted thinking... distracted thinking." You kind of do it emphatically until the emphatic recognition is clearly distinct from what's being recognized. It's like you've really stepped back, and there's a place in the mind that recognizes it, which is not entangled with what's being recognized. That's a little exercise that points to what's possible with clear recognition. When it's really done well, there's a kind of freedom in it; there's an independence from what is known.
One of the capacities we have in using attention is attention that includes recognition. That recognition can be very simple, or it can be very clear and powerful. To engage clear recognition, it helps to be specific about what we notice in the mind. If it's all a blur, it's hard to have the kind of specificity of recognizing a black oak or a dawn redwood, or whatever it might be. That's one way of using attention, and it works very well sometimes if it's chaotic in here, or if we're very distracted, as a counter to all that. It also works very well in order to start seeing more clearly and not being entangled with things or reactive to things.
That's good, but then there are other forms of attention. Another one that the Buddha talks about is observing—the capacity to observe, to look. "Looking," the way I understand it, is much more easily both an active and a passive thing to do. We can look very clearly. It's kind of close to clear recognition, but the focus now is not just recognition. Maybe you already recognize what's there, and it's very clear what's there, but to look is to actively look more closely at what's really going on here. What's the nature of this thing that's going on? Maybe you're looking at the dawn redwood. When I first got there, I wasn't sure to see if it was a dawn redwood, so I started looking more carefully at the leaves and at the bark, and what was going on there, until I was convinced. There were little cones growing there, and I convinced myself, "This is it."
We can look. Even with something like breathing, you can be clear that you're breathing, but you can really look closely. That looking closely can be a microscopic look. You really look closely at where the breathing is most highlighted, and you really look at the microscopic details of the sensations that come into play as you're breathing. This is what we were expected to do when I was doing Vipassana[3] in Burma—to have a microscopic view on the experience.
Other times, it's much more useful to look in a very passive and receptive way and have a kind of macro lens. Attention can be micro or macro, and to some degree we can choose that. Sometimes you want to have a macro lens and not bore in close up, but take the wide-angle lens and just take in the whole scenery. Up in the local park here, there's a bench you walk up to. I'm looking at all the trees and plants now, and then I come to this bench that's kind of high up. It overlooks the plain, the meadow, and the trees, and I stop doing this fine-detail looking. Then it's just beautiful to relax, settle back, and take in the sky, the bay, the trees, and the meadow that's there. It's quite lovely.
We have a capacity for a kind of wide-angle observation, which is not actively looking carefully at something, but is more receptive. It can be delicious to have this receptive mode and just allow things to be there and come and go as they do, provided that the mind is stable enough. The forces of distraction have to be lessened, because otherwise, as soon as we go into a passive, receptive mode, the mind zips off into its preoccupations. Sometimes we're using a form of attention that helps us get centered, helps us get less distracted, and helps us to be in the present moment enough so we have more choice. One of the choices then is to relax and open up.
Generally, it's people who have meditated for a long time who have a greater capacity for non-directed attention, a receptive attention, a macro attention. That can be quite lovely to practice with, and it has its advantages. Sometimes that can highlight all the ways in which we contract. It can also sometimes make a lot of space and room in the mind and heart for the movement of different forms of understanding and processing. For the unfolding and resolving of things in our life from the inside out, our system can do it because it has a lot of space. We have breathing room for things to begin happening.
So this observing can be a close-up, really taking it in closely and seeing it. It could be a little bit further away, or it can be really far away. It can be really useful to know you have those options when things are really difficult. Meditation works best for some situations closely zoomed in, and sometimes what works best is to back up really far. Fear is one of those. Some people find that if there's a lot of terror and fear when they sit down to meditate, being closed up in the middle of fear is not useful; it just triggers even more of it. Sometimes people who have a lot of fear in meditation learn to step back and use their awareness to lean back, almost as if their awareness is two blocks away. With that distance, looking at it, then it's safe to be with the fear. To close in doesn't work.
The different forms of attention can include this close-up and this far-away. Where is the best place to be? Sometimes, with discomfort, I find it useful to be really precise, right close up, right in the heart of where it's most uncomfortable. Sometimes with emotions, I find it useful to be very broad and macro, and just open to them. Different ways of being are useful at different times.
Mindfulness and Abiding in Awareness
What's interesting in terms of different kinds of awareness is that the most famous awareness in our scene is mindfulness. I think that word, mindfulness—I don't really know what mindfulness is even though I'm a mindfulness teacher! But when I read the teachings of the Buddha, the word that we translate as mindfulness, which is sati[4], is much better translated into English as awareness.
Awareness, distinct from different forms of attention, is the underlying, basic, natural, automatic capacity to be aware. It doesn't require attention. It doesn't require effort. It doesn't require a choice or decision. The mind will naturally be aware without you trying to do so. In fact, if you're listening to me, and I insist that you have to stop being aware, just cut it out—this is nonsense. It's kind of hard to stop being aware. That's just what the mind will do.
When the Buddha talks about mindfulness, he never actually talks about it as something that we "do." Oddly enough, given that here in America we talk about "practicing mindfulness," it's never something that's done, but rather something people rest in. People abide in awareness. The ability to abide in awareness takes a lot to get there. It takes a lot of self-understanding. You have to know the inner landscape. You have to know how not to get distracted. You have to learn how to establish a kind of centered, focused attention to be really here in the present moment. Then, when you're really rooted in the present, you can kind of rest in an open, relaxed awareness.
The advantage of that is that it is unselfconscious awareness, an awareness that we're not directing or doing, where the self is not an agent. To really rest and be in that awareness sets the stage. It's kind of like we've loosened all the ropes that keep us entangled. As they're loosened, the knots can just unravel. But as soon as we are the agent, the one who's trying to do something, trying to accomplish something, some of those knots get tighter.
One of the definitions that I like for "what is the self?"—since Buddhism says there's not supposed to be a self—one definition I like is that the self is a knot. You can live with that knot, or you can untie it. As we rest in awareness, these knots begin to disentangle. When they are loose enough, at some point the knots can just slip away from each other, and the strings can be free.
So there's directed attention, and there's undirected attention. There is attention that involves simple recognition and knowing, and attention that involves clear recognition. There's a kind of attention that is more observing and watching, which can be closed in or far away. It can be passive and receptive, or it can be active—really directing the microscope to look someplace.
And then there is an attention that is a natural functioning of the mind. If all the conditions have come together right, it's something that we can rest in. It feels like we're resting or abiding in clarity and openness and real presence. Mostly what we need to do then is to not mess it up. We don't make ourselves aware; mostly we recognize when we start getting pulled into thought, and we let go of it. It's mostly a letting go back into it—if anything is needed—because any attempt to do it is just tying more knots.
There are many more forms of awareness, but one of the things I wanted to convey today is for you to get interested in what you do. Maybe rather than trying to learn what I taught today, take a good look. Chances are high that a good number of you as meditators have been taking that wonderful walk in the mental park, and all the things in there have kind of been a blur. Start looking: what are you doing when you're paying attention? How do you engage your attention, and what are the different forms of attention you use in the course of the day? Do you use a different form of attention when you're doing your taxes than when you're driving? Do you use a different form of attention when you are going for a walk in the park or at the seashore than when you're making love? What are the different forms of attention that are operating for you, and how are they operating? As you see the variety of different ways that knowing, attention, awareness, and recognition are operating, what are you learning and what are you doing there?
Mindfulness of the Body
I wanted to stop, but then I remembered one really important form of knowing and awareness that I wanted to mention. It's one that I think is really very important for mindfulness and meditation, because the kinds of attention I've been talking about so far are all mental; they're aspects in the mind. A whole other way of knowing and being aware is sensing—to sense our experience. A lot of knowing, awareness, and attention has to do with how we take in stimuli from the world around us or within us, how we take in the data that comes in.
There is a mindfulness of the body, where we're tuned into how things are being sensed physically. This is phenomenally important for a variety of reasons, but one of them is that it takes us out of our heads. There's a lot of information that we acquire about this wonderful natural world of ourselves by tuning into what's alive in the body, what's being stimulated, what's being released, and what's being expressed in the body. Sensing the body gives us access to a tremendous amount of wisdom and processing. That's another way of knowing and being aware: to sense the experience. I find it very useful sometimes to drop into the body and just know things through how they're felt in the body, nothing more complicated than that. As I got better at it, or more centered in my body, then I might bring in the recognition of what's there, and the two can operate together.
How much are you sensing your environment? How much are you sensing your own body in different circumstances? Is your body a resource? Does the body have any relevance in how you're with another person? I find it's very helpful to be really in touch with my body when I'm having important conversations with other people, because that's when I really need to track my emotions, my feelings, my responses, and my reactions. The early warning, the early way I discover that, is through what's happening in my body. That's where intuition comes alive.
There are so many ways of being aware, and there are more. What do you do? That's your homework: what's your way? What are the different ways that you have? As you become more conscious of the different ways, does that give you more choice? Can you recognize which forms of your attention are useful at different times? As you begin learning about yourself and how it works for you this week, I'd encourage you to find someone—a friend, an enemy, a total stranger, it doesn't matter—and talk to them about what you're discovering. Say, "I'm discovering it's useful to do this here, and this there, with this kind of awareness," and see where that leads. You can have some interesting conversations about this very important part of our life.
So, that's probably enough. Good. Thank you very much.
Loving-kindness (Mettā): A Buddhist meditation practice cultivating benevolence and goodwill toward oneself and others. ↩︎
Sampajañña: A Pali term often translated as "clear comprehension" or "clear recognition." It is the observant capacity that contextualizes and clearly comprehends what mindfulness keeps in mind. Original transcript said "some pagina". ↩︎
Vipassana: A Pali word often translated as "insight meditation"; a Buddhist practice aimed at seeing the true nature of reality. Original transcript said "little be pasta not". ↩︎
Sati: A Pali word traditionally translated as "mindfulness"; it refers to awareness, presence of mind, and the capacity to keep something in mind. ↩︎