Anukampā (5 of 5) The Ethics of Care
- Date:
- 2020-05-01
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-14 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Anukampā (5 of 5) The Ethics of Care
So, greetings. This morning is the last of the five talks on anukampā[1], the concept that the Buddha used and discussed many times that I'm translating as care. It is sometimes translated as compassion, but I'm suggesting that compassion, as wonderful and important as it is, has a narrower domain and a narrower range of meaning than the word care. Care, in addition to caring for people's suffering, also cares for their welfare. So people who are not particularly suffering, we are still caring for them. It is a kind of general benevolence, maybe, for all beings in all circumstances.
I'm suggesting that this word care is simpler than attitudes and emotions like loving-kindness and compassion. It requires fewer concepts and ideas than what is often associated with compassion and love. Love and compassion as feelings are not always accessible to us, because we don't necessarily have automatic goodwill for everyone we meet, or automatic compassion for some people. We can certainly work for that and try to develop a universal kindness and compassion, but it's easier to do so if we recognize that underneath those—as a foundation—is a kind of tenderness of heart, a sensitivity and resonance of heart that is the care of anukampā.
One of the reasons it's been very useful to look at this word and distinguish it from compassion is that the Buddha repeatedly used the word anukampā as the motivation and the prompt for actions in the world, caring for the welfare and happiness of others. The word karuṇā[2], often translated as compassion, was never used by the Buddha as a motivation, an action, or a source from which to actually care and support people in the world. This is very different from how the word came to be understood later in Buddhism. In this early tradition, there was anukampā, a word which I think kind of got forgotten, lost, or subsumed underneath the word karuṇā over the centuries. By bringing forth this word anukampā, I found it very helpful to recognize something very simple that is a foundation for these things.
I'm interested in exploring this because for a long time I've been interested in the ethics of freedom, the ethics of awakening. What would that look like? What are the ethics of awakened, liberated people? What are the ethics of mindfulness when mindfulness becomes strong?
To answer that question, it might be best to drop the word "ethics" because it has a lot of associations in English that might not be a very good fit for the teachings of early Buddhism, which is my reference point. The closest word in the Buddha's language for the English word ethics is probably the word kusala[3], which is usually translated into English as either wholesomeness or skillfulness. So the question in early Buddhism is: Is what we're doing skillful? Is it wholesome? That gives you a slightly different flavor than asking, "Is it ethical?"
Many people will say that the word for ethics in Buddhism is sīla[4]. That's not quite right. It's okay to say that's what it is, but if you go back to early Buddhist texts and see how the word sīla is used, it really means behavior—what we do. So much so that Bhikkhu Bodhi[5], in his latest translations of the Pali suttas, now translates sīla as virtuous behavior or virtuous conduct, where the emphasis is on conduct and what we do. Action is important. Action has to do with how we live in the world and how we interact with people. Another way of talking about the ethics of awakening, or the ethics of non-attachment, is to call it the conduct of awakening. What skillful, wholesome conduct comes out of it is part of the topic I'm interested in.
Certainly, one of the inspiring statements of the Buddha regarding anukampā speaks to the actions that come out of awakening. It's what the Buddha said to the first sixty of his students who practiced under him and became fully awakened. They were traveling together, and they had done what had to be done; they were liberated and free. The Buddha made this statement to them: "Travel forth for the welfare of many, for the happiness of many, out of care for the world, for the good, the welfare, and happiness of gods and humans."
Here, the Buddha's instruction to awakened people about what kind of behavior to engage in is to go forth in order to support and promote the welfare, happiness, and good of others. Intimately connected to awakening is this idea to go forth out of care. This anukampā, this care, is really the source of enlightened behavior in the world. We see this in references to the Buddha where he teaches out of care (anukampā), and he visits people out of anukampā. That characterizes how the Buddha engages with and cares for the world. Maybe all his teaching was inspired by anukampā.
There's a fascinating story of a doctor named Jīvaka[6] who is talking to the Buddha. Jīvaka says that the great god Brahmā[7], the overlord of the gods, lives with a mind of the divine abodes (Brahmavihāras[8]): loving-kindness (mettā), compassion (karuṇā), sympathetic joy (muditā), and equanimity (upekkhā). These four flavors of a certain kind of love characterize Brahmā. Jīvaka says, "I've heard that the god Brahmā has these states. Now that I see the Buddha, I see that you abide in loving-kindness. You abide in compassion. You abide in sympathetic joy. You abide in equanimity."
The Buddha's response is very unusual in my mind. He says, "No, don't say that. However, if what you mean is that I abide without the greed, hatred, and delusion that gives rise to ill will, cruelty, displeasure, and repulsion, then I allow you to say that I abide in loving-kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy, and equanimity."
In other words, the Buddha is reluctant to have himself characterized as abiding in these four Brahmavihāras, but he is willing to say that he abides without the greed, hate, and delusion that give rise to interpersonal behavior characterized by ill will, cruelty, displeasure, and repulsion. It's almost as if, when there's no greed, hatred, and delusion, then there is love. Then there is something that looks like care, compassion, and all these things. The absence of certain things looks like something else.
I want to give a small example. You may have heard of two people who both look from the outside as if they're patient while in a very difficult, challenging situation. On the inside of the first person, all their buttons are pushed. It's really stressful. They're internally getting angry, irritated, upset, and discouraged. For that person, it's a lot of work to keep breathing, to relax, to be mindful of what's going on, and to stay connected to themselves so they don't get caught in the reactivity. They have very strong mindfulness, and with all the work of paying attention, they are able to physically and visibly remain non-reactive. They look behaviorally equanimous, and others say, "Oh, look, that person is equanimous."
The second person looks just as patient. However, the second person has no buttons being pushed inside. They don't get irritated, angry, upset, or discouraged. There are no attachments, preoccupations, or worries being triggered. For that person, patience is not something they have to do. They're not working at being patient. It's an absence of anger and irritation that makes them seem like they're patient.
In that sense, the Buddha replies to Jīvaka, "You can refer to me as having abandoned greed, hatred, and delusion. In that sense, you can say that I have loving-kindness and compassion." It isn't like compassion and loving-kindness are something to be done, or that one has to work on them. In their absence, it simply looks like what we would call loving-kindness and compassion.
If Jīvaka had asked, "Does the Buddha abide in anukampā?" I suspect the Buddha would have said, "Yes, I allow you to say that. I abide in that." The Buddha really felt that someone who abides in anukampā has abandoned ill will and hatred. It is said that to dwell in anukampā for all beings, one abstains from harming them. When one has abandoned ill will and hatred, one abides with anukampā for the world. Anukampā is primary for the Buddha. It is what he is willing to say is there when there's no greed, hatred, and delusion: this fundamental underlying situation of care.
I'd like to end with a few thoughts. First, this care that is present in the absence of greed, hatred, and delusion is not an obligation. Sometimes when I hear teachings about compassion, it feels like I'm supposed to be this way, that I need to cultivate it, and that I have an obligation to be in the world in a compassionate way. I think compassion is fantastic, but the idea that it's obligatory feels a little oppressive, like, "Oh, really? I'm not good enough. I have to do this now?"
Instead, care is found through letting go of greed, hatred, and delusion. Awakening this deeper, natural sensitivity means that rather than being concerned with ethical responsibility, we can be concerned with ethical responsivity. We want to discover that place of skillful ethical responsivity where we can respond wholesomely to the world. Rather than discovering what our responsibilities are, we discover our capacity for responsivity.
My hope is that as we discover this, it translates into actively learning about the world enough to understand where our lives cause harm, and where we can benefit and support the world. That responsivity travels out through circles of care into the world, making our circles of care all-inclusive. This happens in a place where we do not succumb to greed, hatred, and delusion.
I hope this exploration of anukampā and care has given you some food for thought, a new concept to explore for yourself, and maybe it has some value and interest for you.
As closing words, I'll continue with these Monday morning sittings. For the next four weeks, the theme for the talks will be the Four Noble Truths[9]. Now that we've done beauty last week and care this week, maybe we're ready in a different way to look at this very important teaching, practice, and insight. Next week, we'll do one week on each truth, going deeper and deeper. Maybe after exploring beauty and care, we'll be ready next week to explore the topic of suffering.
Thank you very much for being part of this. And for those of you in the AudioDharma world who are listening to this, thank you for following the series and giving me a chance to share something that was important to me.
Q&A
Q: Can you speak about the Brahmavihāras? Gil: Thank you, Sandy. Yeah, maybe that can be another theme for these early morning sittings. I can do maybe one week on each at some point. That would be nice. Also, IMC has a happy hour right now that they're doing this coming week, I think every afternoon. At happy hours is where they do the Brahmavihāras, mettā, and so forth.
Q: You also say that care is a direct liberation practice because it lessens greed, hate, and delusion? Gil: Absolutely. I think that's a wonderful thing. If you want to be free of greed, hate, and delusion, go out there and try to care for people and care for the world, but do so paying careful attention to what's going on inside yourself. Notice what gets in the way of care. You can notice how greed, hate, and delusion operate. It offers a whole different perspective on attachment and clinging that can arise in service, compared to if we just sit and meditate. It's very valuable and important; it is its own path itself.
Q: If I understood correctly, you believe anukampā is a better foundation for ethics rather than compassion. Could you explain more about the relationship between mindfulness and ethics? Gil: Well, is it better than compassion? It's a slightly tender question to answer since compassion is a foundation for many people's religious and personal lives. I can say that for myself, for decades I believed compassion was at the heart of my ethical life. But over the last few years, especially when I discovered this word anukampā as care, I realized I had lumped together two different feelings or attitudes and saw them both as compassion.
I had no language to distinguish between a very simple, quiet tenderness—what I now call care—that has no object (like sitting quietly by myself and meditating, where a caringness just exists), and the compassion where I encounter suffering in the world, feel empathy, and wish to alleviate it. I used to call both of these compassion. Now I've separated them out.
Because compassion (depending on how you define it) is the concern for the suffering of others and wanting to help, it is a little more conceptual. It involves self and other in a simple way. The state that is not conceptual and doesn't involve self and other is what I used to call compassion, but now I'd like to align with the Buddha's distinction and call it care. It's a bit of a semantic issue, so we have to be careful not to treat this as an absolute difference between people.
Q: (From a listener in Iran) Gil: LH, I don't know if you're from Iran, but if you're Iranian, you might be interested to know I had some discussion with an Iranian Dharma teacher about possibly doing an online intro class in Farsi. If that actually happens, maybe you'll be interested. We'll do it through IMC and it'll be on the website.
This is wonderful to have all this. I just love seeing you and the questions. Thank you very much. I look forward to more opportunities to be this way. Thank you very, very much.
Anukampā: A Pali word often translated as sympathy, compassion, or care. ↩︎
Karuṇā: A Pali word typically translated as compassion. It is one of the four Brahmavihāras. ↩︎
Kusala: A Pali word meaning skillful, wholesome, or morally good. ↩︎
Sīla: A Pali word often translated as ethics, morality, or virtuous conduct. ↩︎
Bhikkhu Bodhi: An American Theravada Buddhist monk and a prominent translator of the Pali Canon into English. ↩︎
Jīvaka: The personal physician of the Buddha and the Indian King Bimbisāra. ↩︎
Brahmā: In Buddhism, a title given to exalted heavenly beings or the leading deity in the Brahma realm. ↩︎
Brahmavihāras: The four "divine abodes" or sublime states in Buddhism: mettā (loving-kindness), karuṇā (compassion), muditā (sympathetic joy), and upekkhā (equanimity). ↩︎
Four Noble Truths: The foundational teaching of Buddhism, encompassing the truth of suffering (dukkha), its cause, its cessation, and the path leading to its cessation. ↩︎