Stimulus and Response
- Date:
- 2026-11-16
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-17 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Stimulus and Response
Thank you, Daniel. Am I loud enough for you all?
I would like for this talk today to bring together a few things that I've been reflecting on this week and to offer a kind of common thread through them. I'd like to evoke the difference between stimulus and response. This is a fairly common idea. Many of you have heard of this, and sometimes it gets emphasized as a key part of mindfulness: the ability to see the distinction between a stimulus that we have and a response to it.
We sometimes distinguish between response and reactivity. Reactivity is where there's no space between the stimulus and the response. There's no choice. There's an automatic reaction. Something is activated automatically, habitually, or unintentionally, where our conscious mind hasn't chosen to do it—there is no deliberation. Maybe we're aware of doing it while we're doing it, or sometimes afterwards, and sometimes we make mistakes because of that.
I've had situations where I had an inner reaction to something, and thought that I would maybe give them a piece of my mind, or at least I would have that thought. Then I looked at who it was, and something about the nature of the person made everything dissolve right away. For example, maybe a person bumped me in a very aggressive way. The judgment comes right away: "How could anybody do that? These are terrible people here." Then I turn around, look, and it's a person who's blind and who maybe is even lost. Immediately, everything dissolves.
Many years ago, there was a child behaving on his lawn on the side of the road in a way that was kind of unacceptable, with cars driving by, including mine. Then I learned that this person had severe mental challenges, that it wasn't really a choice, and that this person was struggling and trying to find out how to be in this world. So my feelings immediately dissolved. Maybe everyone has causes and conditions for how unusually they behave. We don't know the background of people. We don't know what they've been through in their life or their current challenges. We don't know if their spouse just died and they're on the edge of what they're capable of, making them a little bit short in their words. If you don't know that, you think, "Well, this is a terrible person."
This is the difference between stimulus and response—to be able to wait a little bit to have some space. Mindfulness is that space between the stimulus and the response. It is the stillness, the thoughtfulness, the silence, or a gap that allows us to then respond with understanding, to respond with a clear choice: "Oh, this I stand behind. This way of speaking, this way of relating to someone, I can completely see myself doing this." Or conversely, "I don't know if this is what I want to do. My reaction is coming with a lot of authority, a lot of power. And who am I to get in the way of my own inner authority? That's me, right?" No, you don't know what the situation is like.
I've made mistakes in my life of saying things too quickly without taking time to find out what was going on. I still carry with me as a reminder an example I've talked about here, from many years ago. I was at work, the shifts were changing, and a friend came in for his shift. We were good friends, and so I immediately started joking with him. I hadn't taken the time—it wouldn't have taken long—to just look at him a little bit more carefully. One of his best friends had died just a few hours before, and he was in shock. He was still coming to work, and here I was, being playful with him in a way that wasn't right. I felt very bad about what I had done. That was a real lesson to stop, wait, and take time to really feel what's there and what's going on.
That's part of the power of mindfulness: to give us that little gap, that little space, or the ability to take in the wider picture of what's happening so we're not on automatic pilot. Reactivity is not there. What often happens is that the less reactive we are and the more space we allow, the more wisdom can arise. It allows for a lot of discovery to happen. What's really happening here? What's really going on? We make fewer mistakes.
That's true in the privacy of our own minds as well. In your mind, you can get away with a lot of things. Maybe we're not paying attention to what's really going on—what we're thinking, saying, and doing in our minds and fantasies. But there too, if there's a space between stimulus and response, we have the ability to see what's going on. "Do I really want to have this fantasy? Do I really want to imagine or think about this now? Is this really what I stand behind? Is this really who I want to be?"
You might think you shouldn't ask that question because, of course, it's who you are; you're the one thinking it. The mind is ready to defend anything and everything. But no, are you your thoughts? You don't have to be your thoughts. Thoughts are just thoughts. You don't have to go along with them. This amazing ability to question, look, stop, and have more choice is a big part of what mindfulness is.
The Four Phases of Chaplaincy
This theme has come up in two areas over the last week. First, I teach a chaplaincy program here through the Sati Center[1], and we met in the meditation hall on Friday for our session. I adapted something that I've often taught there: in a chaplaincy setting, it is possible to organize a chaplain's visit—someone who's going to show up to offer spiritual care—into four phases. Each of these steps relies on there being space and time for something deeper to happen and be discovered.
The first step, when a chaplain goes to see someone for the first time—whether in a hospital, hospice, jail, or prison—is not knowing. It is to recognize: "There's a lot I don't know here. I don't know about this person. I don't know about the situation. I've heard something about them and I have some sense of what the story is, but I really don't know very much. Let me remember not knowing." This makes a lot of space for a gap, for discovery, and for not being on automatic pilot. You actually put aside things you have learned. If someone is in a hospital because of an automobile accident, the chaplain doesn't automatically say, "Well, that was terrible to have an automobile accident." That would mean you're already coming in with an idea. Rather, you go and say, "Hi, I'm from spiritual care. I'm here just to check on you, is there anything you need?" You keep it open-ended. They might say that the accident is the last thing on their mind. They might say, "My child is graduating from high school today and I won't be able to be there." Okay, now we're in a different world. It's not about the accident; it's about this important milestone in family life that has now been disrupted. So it starts with not knowing what is happening and not knowing who this person is today. Let's find out.
That's the next step of a chaplaincy visit: discovery. The chaplain finds out who this person is, what's important to them, what they want to talk about, and what they want to show. A good chaplain asks nice, opening, connecting questions. They don't ask probing, assertive, or rhetorical questions, nor do they ask questions that are secretly advice, like, "Have you thought about meditation?" [Laughter] They ask simple questions that allow someone to reveal themselves in the way they like, without expectations or demands. Some people are very happy to talk about themselves if asked a simple question. "Oh, tell me more. That must be hard not to be able to go to your child's graduation." It's just a very simple statement, and then they're ready to say more. You listen, and you discover.
The third step is offering. What's the offering the chaplain might make? For some religious people, chaplains pray. Buddhist chaplains usually don't pray unless someone asks them to. Some Buddhists think, "What? I have to pray?" But yes, if that's what people want and need. Prayer is a beautiful thing to do for people. The associations people have with prayer are usually too narrow; prayer is just a sacred way of speaking to people, using words that are evocative, meaningful, and deeply touch the heart, values, and purpose. Alternatively, the offering might be: "I see that you're really anxious about your upcoming surgery. Would you like to do a little breathing exercise that might calm and prepare you?" Or, if someone is dying, "Would you like me to call your estranged child you haven't talked to in ten years to let them know you're here?" There are all kinds of things the chaplain might offer to do to support someone and help bring forth their own wisdom and inner resources. Chaplains try to serve people, not fix them. In the world of chaplaincy, they emphasize serving over helping. Serving means you respect the wholeness of the person, helping their purpose and meaning to come forth.
Then there is bringing it to an end. Saying goodbye can be a very important time. It might be a moment where trust and connection have developed, allowing for something deeper to happen. Even a simple "thank you for the visit" can be very significant for someone to hear; they feel respected and their dignity is preserved or enhanced. The chaplain might say, "May you stay close to the calmness you found in this breathing exercise for the next half hour as you get ready. It was nice to see you, and thank you."
I'm telling you this because I just taught it, so it's on my mind! But also because each of these steps happens in that gap between stimulus and response. There is a lot of space and time to find out what's here, what's going on, and what the response might be.
The Mind as a Puppeteer
The other thing on my mind is how this process works internally for ourselves. I was marveling at my own mind in that place of a gap between stimulus and response.
One of my favorite metaphors from the ancient texts is that of a puppeteer. The mind is a puppeteer, and it has all these strings attached to the puppet—our body. The puppeteer pulls the strings, and the arms and legs move. When you start having thoughts that are frightening, your belly pulls in. You might have thoughts of anger, and your fists tighten up. You might have thoughts of confusion, and your forehead bunches all up. It's not always just muscles; sometimes it's more like an internal place gets activated. When we have certain thoughts, we can feel parts of the body getting activated.
The more still and quiet you are—which is one of the advantages of meditation—the more you can feel the impact the puppeteer has on you. You can feel the strings pulling down, what gets activated, and where there's an impulse to respond or react. It might be an impulse in the legs to run, or in the muscles of the upper arms tightening up to fight. It might be excitement, anticipation, fear, or worry, but they all have an expression in the body.
It is possible to have those thoughts, whatever they might be, see them clearly, and feel that the strings have fallen off. There are no strings anymore. Maybe they've been cut, and you really feel that there are no strings attached to the thoughts. They're just thoughts; they're not going anywhere, and they're not tugging on anything. There is a freedom. Your body is free right now. Something about my inner life has a freedom, a gap, a pause, a spaciousness, and a stillness where those thoughts don't reach in and affect me. When I have a thought, it's just a thought.
One of the great aspects of mindfulness practice is being able to see a thought arise as it's occurring and to be so clear: "Oh, it's just a thought happening." And then it goes, because there are no strings attached. When there are strings attached to thoughts, they tend to stay. It's almost like a two-way string: the puppeteer in the mind and the puppeteer in the body tug back and forth on each other, escalating the reaction. But when there are no strings, no attachment, no clinging, and no automatic reactivity, a thought is just a thought. There is no participation in it. Nothing is tugged, nothing happens.
It is such a delight to see that. I had this delight this week—marveling, "Oh yeah, this is kind of cool." These thoughts come and go, they are seen very clearly, and I know I'm free. Thank you. Just seeing it as it is.
This stimulus and response, the gap between them, the silence—it doesn't have to be called a gap. It could be called a sense of stillness. It could be a sense of great spaciousness, a wide awareness that has space for all of it. Something happens, and it is seen within that spaciousness with no response. If someone is breathing really heavily, huffing and puffing, and you're squeezed up against their body in a small elevator, it's uncomfortable. But if that same person is in the bleachers on the other side of a large sports arena, it's easy to love humanity! [Laughter]
It's the same thing with the mind. If the mind has lots of space in it, it's easy to love your thoughts or the unusual things you experience. It's when you're claustrophobic with them that even our own thoughts can become difficult. We need this space, this spaciousness, this stillness, and this silence.
The Foundations of Mindfulness
Now we come to the last thing that's been on my mind this week, which touches on a core Buddhist teaching around all of this. In Buddhism, there is the practice of mindfulness. There's an ordinary practice of mindfulness that anyone can learn relatively quickly and easily. Sometimes it's said that mindfulness is easy; what's difficult is remembering to do it. We now have secular mindfulness that has spread through our society and is used in many environments without any reference to Buddhism.
Recently, I was invited to teach a wonderful group of Jewish rabbis for an organization that has taken Buddhist mindfulness principles to bring forth their Jewish spirituality. They are now training retreat teachers to teach this on retreat. Because I'm a retreat teacher, and one of the rabbis had sat with us at Insight Retreat Center, they asked me to come and talk to them a little bit about mindfulness and retreat teaching. It was a wonderful privilege to be in this spiritual circle of people exploring the uses of mindfulness for what their religion is about.
In the Buddhist context, there are two large phases of mindfulness. One is the ordinary phase for beginners. At some point, as the practice matures, there is enough gap, space, pause, and stillness between stimulus and response that the practitioner begins to see something very meaningful. What they experience there in that gap becomes the basis for doing mindfulness. The reference point becomes something different than just, "I'm being mindful." There is something deeper supporting it.
In the ancient language, there are three primary things that become the foundation or support for mindfulness. I'll give you my modern rendering of these words first, because it is very hard to translate words from 2,500 years ago from a very different culture and still catch their emotional richness. If a modern-day American went back to India in the time of the Buddha and said, "I miss apple pie," it wouldn't mean anything to them. But for some people here, "apple pie" evokes America; it represents so much. The same is true with these ancient words—they are very inspiring in India, but our English translations are unfortunate.
So, I'll first give the English rendering that makes it inspiring. At some point, when the gap between stimulus and response is wide enough, there are three things: independence, freedom, and peace.
Independence means that the strings are severed. The puppeteer is no longer running the show, making you do what you didn't choose to do. You're not on automatic pilot anymore. You are separated from clinging attachments. You might have emotions, thoughts, and even attachments, but there's a sense that you are independent from them. Awareness has become independent. "I see it, but I'm not it. I have a choice whether or not to participate in it." In Buddhism, we wouldn't use the word "independence"—which sounds like a license to do whatever you want—we would use the phrase "not dependent." Not dependent means that you are not being defined, run, or controlled by anything. The puppeteer no longer has a job with you.
Freedom means that not only are you independent, but you are free from the things you were caught by before. This is a freedom from craving, clinging, addictions, certain kinds of fear, and anger. We see this freedom operating: "Those things that kept me entangled before are no longer running the show. I am free from them." Newcomers to mindfulness don't even know how unfree they are. That's the "bad news" that happens as you do mindfulness practice: you have to meet yourself in a deeper way, and occasionally, what you see is not good news. You see how attached, reactive, and opinionated you are. But it is remarkable to come through this and see that within the mindfulness, there is freedom.
Peace means that something has stopped. The agitation has stopped. The restlessness, the spinning mind, the churning, and the worry have stopped. It doesn't mean that these things have disappeared completely, but rather that the awareness we have of everything is founded on peace. We know things peacefully. You might be furious, and everything inside you is spinning with anger like a volcano. But believe it or not, there is something in the mindfulness that peacefully knows, "Wow, I could power the California electrical grid with all this energy!" [Laughter] As opposed to all the thoughts getting folded into the volcano and becoming lava that burns everything up, the awareness is rooted in peace. It's a radical thing: you are allowed to be everything you are, but you know it from a radically different place. You are no longer buying into it or participating in it. There is space, stillness, quiet, and freedom.
This is a turning point in mindfulness practice. It might take years of practicing regularly before it starts dawning on you: "Wait a minute, there's something new here. I'm still mindful, but the mindfulness now has a characteristic it never had before. Things are calm, independent, and peaceful."
Now I'll offer you what these three are called in "Buddhist English." Independence, freedom, and peace are evocative and warm-hearted. But when we translate the Buddhist language into English, we don't get the same feeling, even though in ancient India these words were quite inspiring. They are: seclusion (viveka)[2], fading away or dispassion (virāga)[3], and cessation.
Should we go for it? Let's have more seclusion, more dispassion, and let's just cease and desist! [Laughter] It doesn't quite work in English.
Viveka is usually translated as seclusion, but it more literally means separation—being separated from worldly entanglements. Virāga, translated as dispassion or fading away, is actually a very inspiring word with multiple meanings. The prefix vi- means separated from or without rāga[4]. Rāga has two primary meanings. One is lust—though some people tell me I shouldn't use that in English and should use "passion" instead. But in California, passion represents everything that's good! [Laughter] Rāga also means a dye for coloring cloth. So virāga also carries the sense of the dye fading away. Our attachments, cravings, and clinging fade away until we feel we are free from them. And then at some point, they stop entirely. This full stop of agitation is cessation. We don't even know how active and busy the mind is until we experience this profound peace that saturates everything.
Leading to Relinquishment
In the ancient teaching, the full explanation goes like this: Mindfulness supported by independence, freedom, and peace leading to...
I'll give you the most common English translation. Put yourselves on the edge of your seats, or I'll stop now—cliffhanger for next week! Where does it lead to? What could this independence, freedom, and peace possibly lead to? Well, you have to deal with Buddhist English because the words are usually not very inspiring. The usual translation is: relinquishment. Thank you. [Laughter]
The Pali word for it is paṭinissagga[5]. It is fascinating because it has two meanings, just like virāga. It means "giving" and it also means "letting go." Why does it have two meanings? You have to read the texts in context. If you just have to give something up because you have no choice, that isn't relinquishment. But giving can be beautiful; generosity is voluntary and wonderful. These two ideas are supposed to be held together: there is a profound letting go, but that letting go feels as wonderful as a gift being given away.
We are giving away something profound. We're giving away all that obstructs our lives, but we're not attacking it, rejecting it, or throwing it away. We let it go freely and generously. It's a great movement. We give it away for the benefit of others. Not to give everyone else our attachments, but so that the best of who we are can meet other people. We can meet people without obstacles to our love, care, respect, and our ability to listen and hear them. We can be like a chaplain: showing up with "not knowing" to discover what is here, making an offering that is supportive and meaningful, and saying goodbye in a way that expresses value and care.
Conclusion
All of that is found in the simple distinction between stimulus and response. Isn't that nice? So when you hear someone talk about that stimulus and response thing, you'll be inspired. You know now how great it is.
Those are my thoughts, and thank you very much for being here. I'm going off this afternoon to Insight Retreat Center for another retreat. I'll be back in two weeks when we have a potluck, which is always nice. Travel well, and for those of you who want to take a little bit of time to be here and talk to your neighbor, you're welcome to say hello and check in about the talk. Otherwise, thank you.
Sati Center: The Sati Center for Buddhist Studies, an organization dedicated to the study and practice of Buddhist teachings, including offering programs like Buddhist chaplaincy training. ↩︎
Viveka: A Pali word commonly translated as "seclusion" or "detachment," referring to physical and mental separation from worldly entanglements. ↩︎
Virāga: A Pali word often translated as "dispassion" or "fading away." It literally means the absence of rāga. ↩︎
Rāga: A Pali word meaning "lust," "attachment," or "greed." Historically, it also referred to a dye used for coloring cloth. ↩︎
Paṭinissagga: A Pali word meaning "relinquishment," "giving up," or "letting go." ↩︎