Moon Pointing

Karma and Intention

Date:
2019-06-30
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-13 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Karma and Intention

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Karma and Intention

The teachings on karma and intention are very important topics. The Dalai Lama is quoted to have said that it's more important to understand the Buddhist teachings on causality—which is what karma is—than to understand such teachings as not-self and emptiness. This says a lot, especially since in Tibetan Buddhism, emptiness is a very important teaching.

And then in the Zen teaching, they have this koan[1], this little teaching story called Hyakujo and the Fox[2]. And the story goes this way: Hyakujo was a Zen master, the abbot of a monastery, and he would regularly give Dharma talks. I guess the monastery was open for people from the outside to come in. Whenever he gave a Dharma talk, there was an old man who would come to the talk, sit in the back, and then leave at the end. After a long time of doing this, at one point the old man stayed behind and went up to the abbot. He said, "Once upon a time, I was the abbot of this monastery. Someone asked me the question, 'Is an enlightened person subject to cause and effect, to karma?' And I said, 'No.' Because of that answer, I am not really human now; I've been reborn five hundred times as a fox. These are the karmic consequences of saying 'no.'"

"And now I come to ask you the question: Is an enlightened person subject to cause and effect?" And the abbot, Hyakujo, answered, "An enlightened person does not ignore cause and effect." With that, the old man somehow woke up, or something happened. He said to the abbot, "Thank you. Tomorrow morning, behind a certain boulder back in the forest up in the hills, you'll find the body of a fox that has died, and that will be me. Please give this fox the burial that is due for a monastic." So in the morning, Hyakujo gave instructions to his monks, and they went out and found the fox. They came back and buried him, meaning that his many lifetimes as a fox came to an end when he got the answer, "You don't ignore cause and effect."

The Dalai Lama says it's very important to understand it. And if you don't watch out, you might be a fox for a long time. [Laughter]

The teachings on karma are very particular in the early teachings of Buddhism. It's a teaching that puts a lot of emphasis on the importance of the present moment. This is one of the hallmarks of mindfulness practice: to be present for our present moment experience, not so much to enjoy it, but rather to be able to really use the present moment to its fullest potential.

One of the potentials of the present moment, when we're really here, is we see that we have a choice, and then we are able to exercise that choice wisely. If we don't slow down enough, pause long enough, or pay careful enough attention to what's going on, many of us will operate on automatic pilot. We'll just say things, we'll do things, we'll just kind of barrel ahead. Things are done without much reflection or without any deeper understanding of why we're doing them, what purpose we're doing them for, and what the consequences are.

Now, it could seem like a drag to stop and pay more attention, slow down, and restrain yourself from being impulsive. But there's a difference between front-loading and end-loading our life. If you front-load your life with more attention given to why you do things, the purpose, the intention for what you do, and the consequences that you're putting into place by what you do, then you can be more careful and you don't have to take care of a lot of things afterwards. If you don't do that, and are impulsive, saying things without thinking about it or acting on things that you later regret, then chances are you'll have to end-load afterwards. You have to spend a lot of time apologizing, defending, explaining, justifying, and remedying whatever you did.

So it might seem like a drag to front-load your life, to spend more time or care about what you do in the present moment, but actually you end up saving yourself a lot of work later—sometimes saving yourself the kind of regrets that people have for a lifetime. But also, you put into place much better conditions for the movement of your life. We can start doing those things which have beneficial consequences for our life. That's the heart of the teachings of karma: our actions have consequences, and we should be careful with those consequences.

The word karma is a big word. It is not some kind of theory about life having to do with multiple lifetimes. Often multiple lifetimes come into play in traditional Buddhist teachings around karma because of the causality that continues through lifetimes, they say. But that's not the heart of what the teachings are about. The heart of the teachings is about really being careful with what you choose to do in this present moment. Karma is also not a teaching that provides cosmic justice.

We have, for good reasons—and I think wonderful reasons—a strong desire for justice, however we might understand that. But it's sometimes hard to see that there's justice in this world. One of the ways to get justice is to use this teaching of karma to say, "Justice will happen in the person's next lifetime. Everything will be back in order. I can rest assured that that no-good, lousy person is going to get it, and not just get off scot-free for the terrible thing they did."

It would be nice; maybe that's true. But I think our strong desire for justice might actually do us a disservice, because it might take us away from dealing with the present moment. We need to champion justice here in this lifetime for our society, but also deal directly with our discomfort around what goes on and work with that. If we have an excuse to kind of put a salve over it—saying, "Oh, it'll be taken care of in the next lifetime, then I don't have to take care of this now"—we're relieved a bit and reassured. I think it's more maturing to not look at some theory of justice over multiple lives, but really work with what's here and look at it.

Also, the theory of karma has little to do with explaining what's happening to us based on what happened in the past. It's not a theory that everything you did in the past is the cause of what happens today. It doesn't put ultimate responsibility for everything that happens to you on what you did before. It's really a focus on our capacity for responsiveness, our capacity to be present and respond wisely and with choice. Mindfulness puts us in that seat. It puts us in the driver's seat of caring, being patient, and being attentive to what we do. And as I said, it might seem like front-loading work, but actually, it is much less work in the long term.

With karma, there are actions and the consequences of actions. The word karma literally means "action". It has come down to sometimes meaning the consequences of action. People say, "That's the person's karma," and what they mean is that it's the fruit of their action. But technically, the word just means "action". So we want to pay attention to the action, and then actions have consequences.

Where can we see the consequences of our actions? We can see the consequences right away. There is a quality to what we say, what we do, and even what we think, that has a valence. If we think with thoughts of hate, if we speak with words of hate, if we act with hate—if you really pay attention, it actually feels grating for the whole system. It's actually painful as a contraction. So the consequence is right there.

The problem with something like hate is that it's often focused on a purpose, on an object of hate, and trying to get rid of something. So the attention is outwardly directed. The hating person doesn't really pay attention to what the effect is in here for them. The effect is still here; it's uncomfortable for them, and that's often the unconscious fuel for further hate. They're trying to get rid of something because they feel so bad. But part of the function of mindfulness is to turn the attention around and really see what is happening for us when we speak and act, and even think, in ways that are unskillful.

We think with ill will, with greed, or lust. We think or act with jealousy, spite, resentment, or all kinds of things: criticism, self-criticism, and even guilt. Guilt is a common enough emotion for people, but Buddhists say there's no really valuable purpose for guilt. There might be a valuable purpose for regret, but guilt is a kind of self-criticism that is painful—more of this contraction. So we start paying attention to the immediate, simultaneous effect of what we're doing: the quality of it and the impact on us.

There's also the effect of our actions down through time. And we don't have to look at it too mysteriously. Karma is not some kind of metaphysical accounting system that exists someplace up in the sky keeping tabs on everything. But there are consequences that we experience over time. One of them is the effect it has on our level of tension or relaxation: the muscles that get tight, and the muscles that soften and relax. The conditioning on our body by what we think, act, and do might be minuscule in one act of speech, thought, or action. But if we have the same chronic activity over and over again, the effect can be huge over time.

I've been told that Abraham Lincoln once said that by the time a person is forty, they are responsible for their face, because of all the holding patterns and attitudes that get carried along. So there are these traces that are left behind. There are traces in our memory, and memory can go underground for a long time and then pop up. One of the remarkable things about ongoing meditation practice is that sometimes long-lost, long-forgotten memories will return.

Sometimes those are good memories. I've known people who had forgotten about really important, pleasant memories of feeling safe or contented as children. Somehow those reappeared through meditation and became a source of strength for them. But the opposite can also happen. People in meditation sometimes will remember things that were very unfortunate: the regrets they had or how they hurt people. Sometimes it comes with a big bang: "Oh, what did I say twenty years ago?" I have known people who felt, after twenty years of having forgotten something they did, that they had to go make amends or apologize to someone.

These things live inside our psyche as memories—sometimes memories we don't consciously remember. At some point they can come up, and it's much better for them to come up and be resolved and worked through while you're still in relatively good health, through meditation or something. Sometimes when people are dying a little bit slowly, the inhibitions and conditions are such that those memories will come back then, and maybe we're not so able to deal with them or work them through. It's rather unfortunate to die with regrets in our minds, so it's good to clean up our act ahead of time.

The other way that our actions have a consequence down through time is that they set conditions in place, and that conditioning affects further things. For example, the hateful person who creates this contraction in their body that's uncomfortable—that's a condition. Through that discomfort, they will then react, push away, drink alcohol, or do something unhealthy about this discomfort they're feeling. The opposite can happen as well. We can do things that create good conditions for ourselves, that help us feel content, happy, peaceful, more relaxed, more generous, more beautiful. All kinds of wonderful ways of being in the world feel good. The quality of inner being is better, and those tend to generate nicer, more supportive ways of being.

We are the custodian of the conditions. We are really the custodian of the quality of our life. You want to set up conditions that support a good quality of life, and make choices that put in place things that are conditioning or influences on you that are supportive and helpful, and bring out the best in you, as opposed to putting in place conditions that bring out the worst in you.

This can be simplistic, as in a very simple little choice. I have to make this choice sometimes if I'm going up to San Francisco: choosing to go on Highway 280 rather than 101. I've noticed that I actually feel better going up 280 than 101, and I arrive in San Francisco in a little bit better place. It's not a big deal, but it's a little bit better positioned place, and I think it is nicer. So I'm caring for these conditions and what influences they have on me. Our actions are consequential, and the focus on karma—not ignoring karma—is to be careful with the choices we make in what actions we do.

Actions in Buddhism also include what we think. And within what we think—in the mental world—are our intentions. Buddhism often puts a tremendous emphasis on intention, and sometimes seems to imply that the seed of intention is like a seed for our karmic consequences. Almost everything we do has some intention, some purpose, some motivation behind it. It's kind of like the beginning of all our actions.

To be quiet enough, or have strong enough mindfulness to see what our intention is moment by moment, to see what our motivations are, is huge. Looking at the quality of the intention has a big impact on all these things. Notice the quality of an intention: is that quality of intention something that you feel good about, that is supportive and nourishing, or is it something which is not nourishing, which is painful to have, or undermines us or drains us?

Ask yourself the question: "Why am I going to say what I'm about to say? Why am I going to do what I'm about to do?" Or if I need to do something, not "What should I do?", but "What is the intention with which I want to do it?" Spending time in your life taking the time to ask yourself that question—"I'm about to do something, what purpose do I want to do it for? What am I trying to accomplish here?"—can really awaken a richer, deeper, more valuable way of living in the world.

Here I'll give you another example which is pretty simplistic, perhaps ordinary. I've done this when I have to go shopping for food for my family. What's the intention? Someone asks me, "Why are you going shopping?" "Because my family needs food." Okay, that's nice. You learn some information, but it doesn't really say anything particularly deep. But before I go shopping for food, I can ask myself what the intention is for doing this. "Oh, I want to care for my family. I want them to feel when they come home that they're being met with support, with care, with love, that there's food there for them."

But actually, I could have other intentions. I could go to the market to buy food, and my intention could be that for every person I encounter who is willing to look at me, I want to meet them in a way that's going to make their life a little bit better. So that's my intention: to go there and make a difference for people. I've been grumpy and gone to the market with my shopping cart thinking, "All these people are in the way, and I'm not going to look at anyone." I probably didn't create a very good wake behind me.

I've also gone to the market, and I'm surprised by how looking around, being present, and being interested to connect to the people around me is actually nice. It's not so dangerous because most people don't want to connect, but it is nice for me. Now that my wife is often traveling these days, I'm going to Safeway early, because Safeway is open 24 hours. I go super early in the morning, and it's kind of fun. There are all these people stocking the shelves, and I also meet people in line. I've gotten to know some of the clerks because they're the same clerks. I'm getting to know some of them by name and having little conversations. It's a very different feeling. Because they're stocking the shelves, the stockers are apologizing because their boxes are in the aisles, and it gives me a great chance to say, "You know, it's not a problem." It's a great little exchange, and I kind of like it.

So I could have the intention to go and connect with people or make a difference in that little way. By giving some thought to it, I enliven and enrich what I'm doing with nice purposes. Whether I'm successful or not—that's another topic—but the fact that I can go into the market with that kind of liveliness actually feels quite good. If all I'm doing is buying food for my family and there's no other reason—"They sent me, I don't want to go, but I'm going to go because they told me to"—that's a pretty limited world to live in. Can you expand your world through care and attention to your intention?

The world of intention is a very significant world to consider. What are the priorities that you have? What intentions do you give priority to, or what intentions are central to how you want to live your life as a whole? Is there a larger purpose for your life that you have, a sense of meaning, a sense of value, a sense of direction? I think it's a wonderful thing to spend time regularly reflecting on: "What is my deepest intention? What is the deepest purpose that I have for this human life that I have?" It's an amazing thing.

One of the consequences for me of doing all those years of Buddhist practice is I don't take being alive for granted. I don't take being conscious for granted. I think it's just amazing that this whole show exists, that even the fact that I'm conscious I just find amazing. To care for this and ask the question, "What is my deepest intention?" I did that for at least a year, every day. I would ask myself that question, sometimes multiple times through the day. It was fascinating to watch how over the year it morphed and changed. Sometimes it was exactly the same, sometimes it changed.

One of the ways it changed over time is it felt like I went deeper and deeper. I would come with an intention and I would say, "Yes, and what's the intention for that intention, or where does that come from?" If I had a negative intention—like, "I want to live without fear"—I found it really important to ask, "Well, what is the positive version of that? If I had no fear, then what would be my intention?" And to go deeper and deeper. There are many things that could be an answer to that.

Some care needs to go around answering the question, "What is my deepest intention?" We don't want to bring with us societal ideas that we've inherited of what a human being's life is supposed to be like. One of the great intentions is not what we do with our life—like having a great career or something—but rather the intention of how we're going to live this life. We're going to live with compassion, care, or generosity. Or we're going to focus on practice, kindness, and how that might be the organizing principle for our life, more than saving the world in some way. Keep looking into your heart.

A variation that I did for myself around "What is my deepest intention?"—which was very interesting for another year—was asking myself, "If I'm going to die tonight, how would I live this day? What would be most important for me? What was the most important thing to do if this was my last day?" That put a mirror on my life that was very powerful. Because I did it for a year, it kept morphing and changing. It was really valuable for me.

It is very useful to be careful with intention, to develop the skill and the ability to look at why we do things, the purpose for what we do, the motivation, and what we're intending as we do it. Many years ago, I met a family who told me that one of the most common questions they had in the family for each other when they were talking about something was, "What are you intending? What are you intending in doing this or saying this?" It's kind of like plumbing deeper, dropping deeper into what is going on here.

To combine these ideas of intentionality, our deepest intention, and the idea of karma: intention is an action, and it's an action which has consequences. Because intentions are a psychological state or psychological condition, cause and effect plays out in a variety of ways. But in and of itself, it plays out psychologically.

If we act on an intention, the physical action in the world plays out in all kinds of other ways. But simply having an intention that we dwell in and stay with—you're not off scot-free. It has consequences for you; it conditions you. It sets memories in you; all kinds of things go on. When I was young, I had strong greed for things that stayed in there over and over again. I look back at some of those things with regret: why was I spending all that time? I don't think it conditioned me in a good way. It didn't set up my mind or set up my heart in a healthy kind of way. I never acted on them, but still, it had an effect on me.

So intentionality—the intentions we have, even if we don't act on them and they are more like wishes or hopes—is consequential in the psychological unfolding, development, and growth that we have. So how do we care for it? One of the ways is through meditation.

Meditation, for some people, is a really wonderful way of getting the mind just quiet enough. It doesn't have to be dramatically quiet, but more quiet than usual, in such a way that we can start caring for the quality of our mind, the intentions of our mind, and the desires of the mind that are operating. In meditation, we learn a lot about letting go of what arises, and we can drop deeper. But also in meditation, as we calm down, we have access to deeper wellsprings of intentionality, deeper wellsprings of emotions, values, and ways of being. These can be the source of very skillful and helpful intentions that are much harder to tap into if the mind is agitated and running around being busy.

We sit quietly enough to be deeper in touch with ourselves, to become still enough to see the points of choice that we have. One of the choices we have in meditation in particular is a choice to let go: "Not this, I don't need to continue this train of thought. This is not helpful. This is not a useful thought to have." That ability to let go is not just to let go of something, but might also be to allow ourselves to let go into a deeper place inside, to let go into a deeper listening of what's really here. And then over time, to be able to ask yourself the question, "What is my deepest intention?"

When I did Zen practice many years ago, one Zen teacher told me to define Zen practice as the practice of purifying our intention. It was a very thought-provoking idea that that's what the practice was: purifying or clarifying our intention. I like to think that the intentions we base our lives on are so preciously important that we want to really attend to them and care for them well. Let intentionality be an inner well that we have.

Don't have your intentions, and what you want your life based on, be confused with how successful you are in living up to them. Sometimes it's just powerful that we're living based on these good intentions. Whether it plays out well in life or not can sometimes be secondary to the benefits we get from knowing that we're resting and dwelling in these wonderful good qualities that we are capable of having.

Finally, I'll say that I've advised people... you know, I'm a meditation teacher, so you would think that meditation is important, right? And it is. But as a contrast, I've sometimes told people it's actually more important than meditating to ask yourself regularly: "What is your deepest intention?" It's that important. So don't ignore cause and effect, or you'll be a fox. [Laughter]

Group Discussion

So, we have our potluck in a little bit, but we have about ten minutes left. What I'd like to propose is that—for me, I believe this topic is very important—I think it'd be very nice if you all could have a few minutes to talk about this topic of the talk. Your relationship with intentionality, what was meaningful for you, or what your experience has been with intention and exploring intention with a few of the people sitting around you. Maybe you can form little groups of three or four, introduce yourselves, and spend a few minutes just chatting about it. And then in about ten minutes or so, at a quarter to eleven, we'll ring a bell and we can set up for the potluck. Thank you.



  1. Koan: A paradoxical anecdote or riddle used in Zen Buddhism to demonstrate the inadequacy of logical reasoning and to provoke enlightenment. ↩︎

  2. Hyakujo: (Baizhang Huaihai) A Chinese Zen master. The transcript originally contained several mistranslations ("yeah Cujo", "Yakuza", "suckage Oh") which were corrected to Hyakujo based on the context of the famous koan Hyakujo and the Fox. ↩︎