Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (7 of 9)
- Date:
- 2020-04-07
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-13 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (7 of 9)
Good morning here in California. Good evening, good night, and good day to all of you listening from around the globe. I am very deeply appreciative that people from so many different places, near and far, are interested enough in this mindfulness meditation to come take this course. So, thank you.
I want to emphasize right from the start that mindfulness is meant to be a very simple practice. Sometimes the way the instructions are given—the way I give the instructions—can seem like a lot of technique, a lot of doing that you're supposed to do. Pay attention to breathing, to the body, to emotions, to thoughts. And then for emotions, there's the RAFT that I taught: Recognize, Allow, Feel, and Tease apart. It seems like a lot.
But there are two ways of understanding mindfulness instructions. One is that it is a prescription of what you do. You learn the technique, learn the prescription, and you apply it. The other is if you take it as a description of what you will be aware of if you relax and really open up your awareness to what's happening here in the present moment. If we're not interfering with reality—if we're not thinking a lot, judging a lot, fantasizing a lot, and commenting a lot, which is a kind of selective use of our attention—but if we relax and open up the awareness and get centered in the present, then over time our awareness will begin noticing what is obvious in the present moment. What is most compelling or predominant.
If you're sitting quietly, then you'll probably start noticing your breathing. You'll notice your body. You'll notice your emotions and feelings. You'll notice what goes on in the mind. Not necessarily as a technique, like, "Now you do this," but this is what reveals itself to you, what you open up to and what you settle with.
So, whether it's a prescription or a description varies from day to day, from moment to moment, as you're practicing. But the descriptive side points to the fact of being relaxed and receptive and not having a big agenda, not trying too much. The idea of just doing this as a description, of kind of just noticing what's here, can sometimes lead to complacency and not making enough effort. The prescriptive approach, where you actually apply yourself to a technique, can keep a little more energy going and a little bit more brightness of the mind. How you navigate that between calming of the mind and keeping it bright—whether you apply yourself a little bit or whether you just open up and receive what's happening—that's kind of the art of meditation that you'll learn over time. Through trial and error, you just learn the balance over time. It's looking for that balance.
Some people are predisposed to techniques, to doing. They enjoy it; it works well for them. Other people are predisposed that way and it just leads to stress, tripping over themselves, and trying too hard. Some people are predisposed to just being relaxed, at ease, and receptive. Sometimes they end up falling asleep, and sometimes it just works really well for them. It is the undoing of all the doing of their day, and they just feel so good to settle and not do anything but be brightly aware.
We're talking about thinking yesterday and today—mindfulness of thinking. You don't have to go looking for thinking or make this a technique, but sooner or later it will become clear that thinking is predominant. You'll notice you're lost in thought. At that point, you have to decide whether you're taking the more prescriptive approach or the more descriptive. Meaning, more just, "Oh, this is what's happening." You just recognize what's happening and maybe let go and come back to your breathing. Or a little bit more prescriptive, meaning, "Oh, I keep getting lost in thought. There's a lot of thinking going on here. Let me look at this more carefully. Let me apply myself to it. Let me look and feel the physicality of thinking. What does it feel like physically?"
As I said yesterday, the more strongly we're thinking, the more likely there will be some physical component to it. You might be interested in asking yourself what the emotion connected to the thought is, and then you maybe discover that. So, that's a little bit more prescriptive. You're asking yourself a question: "What's going on here?" to see more clearly. Or you just settle back to just notice what's here. And as you notice and just open up, you see, "Well, it's thinking, and yes, there are feelings connected to it. Yes, there are body sensations." They just get revealed. How you navigate this is up to you.
Now, in terms of thinking, I think part of living a wise life is to become wise about our thinking. Wise about our relationship to thinking, wise about the role that thinking has in our life. Not necessarily the content of our thoughts, but rather the default ways in which we relate to thinking, believe thinking, and prioritize thinking or not.
One of the interesting things I saw in the news today is from a study at Stanford Medical School. They have done some clinical studies, and from their preliminary studies, they're going to open it up to a wider group now. They've discovered that one of the most effective therapeutic ways anybody has ever recorded for dealing with depression is to quiet people's thinking. To somehow have thinking slow down a little bit and become quieter.
That makes sense if you consider that part of what depression is, is the rumination that we have, the self-talk that we do. Some of that self-talk is not only very negative and discouraging and undermines us in and of itself, but it might also have to do with the speed and the activity of thinking. If there's too much thinking going on, it's exhausting. It's very tiring. I've known many meditators who started to meditate, and one of the first discoveries they had was how weary they were. A deep, deep weariness, not ordinary tiredness. Maybe they had a good night's sleep, but they felt a deep weariness from the onslaught, the engagement, the searching, the doing of thinking all the time.
Slowing thinking down or quieting is one of the approaches to begin meditation practice. Rather than thinking you have to get rid of your thoughts—so it's all or nothing, let go of them, or think or don't think—one way of viewing meditation is as a way to allow thinking to quiet. To become softer, to become slower. If you meditate, you will also start noticing that thinking starts becoming thinner and thinner, lighter and lighter, until at some point thoughts pass through the mind like a cloud passing through an empty sky. It has no more weight or substance than a cloud, probably less. It's just very transparent and thin, and there's no tendency to get onto the cloud or latch onto it. It doesn't have any weight; it's not a burden what's being thought about. It just kind of floats by. It comes and goes.
This idea of thinking becoming thinner and thinner, lighter and lighter, is a strange idea for people who haven't meditated. But what I'm trying to point to is that what we call thinking is variable. We can think in different ways, and thinking can change. We're not stuck thinking the way we're always thinking. Our relationship to thinking can start changing as well. We can stop investing so much importance in it, hanging on to every thought, or letting every thought push us around. We can start leaving thoughts alone and let them be. Let them float away.
Let's do a little meditation around thinking. I'll do some guided exercises to give you a little bit more sense of what we're exploring, what the potential of meditation is with thinking, and maybe even the potential of becoming wiser with your thoughts.
Guided Meditation
Show meditation
Hide meditation
Guided Meditation
If you can, put yourself in a nice meditative posture. A posture that expresses both alertness and relaxation.
First, we want to spend a little bit of time relaxing. There's a correlation between having a tense body, a tense mind, and squeezing out thoughts. Tension tends to speed up and strengthen the power of thinking. So, begin by softening and relaxing your body. As you relax the parts of your body that are easy to relax, see if you can at the same time quiet your thinking a little bit. Rather than letting it go, quiet your thinking. Quiet whatever thoughts you have about what you're relaxing.
You might relax the muscles of your face. Soften in the face. Perhaps softening in the eyes, especially if you find yourself using your eyes even when they're closed to look and see and stare. Relax and soften around your shoulders, the shoulder blade area. Maybe if you pull in your spine between your shoulder blades just a little bit, it allows you to relax your shoulders a bit more.
And then to soften in the chest, the area of the heart and the solar plexus. Maybe as you exhale, softening the diaphragm and chest. Maybe as you exhale, releasing a little bit more at the end of the exhale. So, you exhale a little longer, resulting in a little bit more softening and relaxing in the chest.
Then feeling the belly and relaxing the belly. Again, maybe at the end of the exhale, relaxing the belly a little teeny bit more. Maybe for a moment you breathe out longer, and there's a little bit more softening in the belly.
Now bring your attention to that part of your body that you most associate with thinking. Perhaps behind the forehead, behind the eyes, the middle of the skull. But it could be anywhere. Take a few moments to feel the part of your body where thinking resides, or where the energy of thinking is found. And then as you exhale, perhaps you can relax the thinking muscle. Soften the energy of thinking.
Notice your thinking. Notice the energy of thinking, how fast or slow you're thinking. How strongly you're pulled towards thinking and involved with it, or how well you can sit back and just watch it. In whatever way that you might be thinking—words or images—see if you could slow it down. Just a little bit. Make it a little bit quieter. Like you've walked into a library and you soften and quiet your voice. Gently quieting your thinking. Maybe noticing or allowing for a little bit of space between one thought and the next.
Generally, the tendency is that if thinking quiets and slows down, there's more capacity for mindfulness and awareness. Especially a kind of silent awareness that senses and feels what's happening. You might bring your attention to that part of the body where it is easiest to feel your breathing. The body breathing. Feel that part of your body, and ride the rhythm of breathing in and breathing out as it's experienced in the body.
As an exercise to discover more about thinking, you might again become aware of yourself thinking. Sometimes thinking is shy and disappears if you bring that kind of attention to it. That's okay. But you'll think again. With a light touch, without a lot of expectations or ideas of right and wrong, notice if you can the relative strength of your thinking. Is your thinking quite loud and strong, almost like it's demanding attention? Or is it quiet and soft and drifting by? Or anything in between?
Is there a mood associated with your thinking? Almost like a tone of voice. Like you're listening to yourself. If you're listening to yourself or to another person's voice, what kind of voice is it? Or what kind of picture is it? Is there a harshness to your voice, or a gentleness? Is there an insistence or an easygoingness with your inner voice, your inner pictures and images? If you heard someone speaking the way you might be talking to yourself—maybe even hearing them in a foreign language—what is the mood or tone of voice? Or if you're thinking in images, is there mood music, like for a movie, that goes along with the images?
Is there any physical tension associated with your thinking? It might be very subtle pressure or tension, a subtle agitation. See if you can relax that tension, soften. Perhaps there's a way you can step away from your thinking. Letting it float away. Then come back to your breathing.
If there's any tendency to think, think about the breathing in a soft way. Perhaps with a simple thought of "in" as you breathe in, "out" as you breathe out. Rising, falling. If you use those mental notes, see if you can use them with a soft, quiet thinking mind. Almost as if the very saying of the word has a calming influence on you. Return to beginning again with your breathing.
In the last few minutes of this sitting, if you would like, see if you can just relax one more time. Relax your awareness. And just be open to whatever comes into awareness. You don't need to prioritize breathing. Just notice. Maybe the mental notes are notes of description of what arises in the present moment. It could be sounds, sensations in the body, breathing, thoughts, or emotions. Keep settling back, opening up, allowing things just to show themselves to you. Be careful not to get reactive, involved, or start thinking about what's happening. Rather, just be receptive to whatever way things arise in awareness.
When I ring the bell to end this meditation, listen to the three bell rings, but watch your mind. Notice if there are any changes in how you think. The strength of thoughts, the speed of thoughts, your involvement with thoughts, how they take over. Notice how things shift with the end of the meditation.
Reflections on Thinking
I hope that you're getting a little sense of the richness of thinking. There are people who, when I teach mindfulness of thinking, don't have a clue what I'm talking about. Some people are so involved in their thoughts—they're definitely thinking—but it's like the saying that the fish doesn't seem to see the water it swims through. Some people don't see the thinking that they swim with, that is always there. Everything is seen through thinking. The idea of being able to turn around to see thinking doesn't work because seeing is happening through thinking.
There are many relationships people have with thinking. One of the fascinating aspects of mindfulness is how we learn about ourselves in the process. We learn how we're involved in the world, how we react to the world, the desires we have, the things we're attached to, and the things we have aversion to. We can start seeing this much more sensitively as we tune into our body, our breathing, our body sensations, our emotions, and our thinking. A heightened sensitivity to these areas of our life corresponds to a heightened sensitivity to how we're reacting and involving ourselves in the world. That reactivity and involvement has a lot to do with how we suffer, how we feel stress, distress, and dis-ease.
To begin seeing that we're involved with things, wanting things, pushing things away, or attaching to things—becoming more and more sensitive to it in a meditative way means observing with an awareness that's not for or against. It doesn't condemn anything and is not in conflict with anything. It is curious to get to know it better, to look at it more carefully. "Well, this is what it's like to be attached. This is what it's like to be really caught up in my thoughts and pulled into them, like a gravitational field that we keep getting pulled into."
We start seeing more and more what's going on, seeing the different dynamics of our psychology, our emotional life, and our physical life. As we see more, at some point we see places of choice. We see that we have a choice whether we keep thinking something, whether we keep despairing over something, wanting something, or pushing something away. We have a choice about whether to hold on to something or let it go.
Early on in my meditation practice, I had a lot of physical pain, and I discovered that when I had self-pity and felt so sorry for myself for having the pain, the pain would get worse. But if I let go of the self-pity, the pain would get slightly better. I saw that I had a choice. I could collapse into self-pity, or I could not do that. Because it made a difference in the pain level, I chose not to succumb to the self-pity. Before I saw that, I had no idea that I was collapsing into, or in a sense choosing to be involved with, self-pity. I just thought it was the nature of the universe. It felt like some truth, and I had no way of thinking it should be any different. Self-pity had a certain authority. But when I saw this close connection to the pain, and how it got stronger or weaker depending on how involved I was with self-pity, I started seeing I had a choice.
This idea of choice around thinking is something I use a lot. If I'm going about my day and I notice what I'm thinking, and I feel my thought train is not useful, I'll stop thinking it. "This is not useful. I'll let go." If I'm driving, I might decide, "I'm going to think about something else. I'm going to think about the Dharma talk I'm going to give, or what I'm going to buy for my family." This idea of choosing, having the flexibility and freedom to see thoughts, notice what they're doing, and not be wedded to them or gripped by them, allows us to relax and have some choice.
The idea of choice is a really important one if we want to live a more peaceful life—a life that is less in conflict, less caught up, agitated, afraid, angry, or resentful. Seeing where that moment of choice is, is crucial. People who don't see the place of choice don't have a choice. Then something else is in control. But as mindfulness gets stronger and we're more and more present for the moment-to-moment unfolding of our experience, we'll see more places of choice.
This relates to thinking. A lot of our attachments are in relationship to thinking. A lot of the compulsivity of wanting, grabbing, and pushing away has to do with the energies we have around thinking and the ideas we hold on to. This mindfulness of thinking can be revolutionary if we can learn it. It takes a while. You don't want to be in a hurry, but turn and look at thinking and get to know it better.
I had this little image come up many years ago that was very nice for me in relationship to thinking. I imagined that I was an astronaut who had been sent deep into space. Deep in space, there was a thought floating around. Somehow a thought had escaped someone's skull, escaped our atmosphere, and was floating around. No one had ever actually seen a thought before. We perceive them in the mind's eye or hear them, but no one had ever seen the shape, weight, or color of a thought. This astronaut was the first to see what a thought looks like. It would just be amazing. It was maybe kind of like the first photograph of the earth from the moon, seeing this beautiful globe floating in space.
Seeing a thought floating in space—this amazement, I imagined, would not depend on what the thought was. The content wasn't so important to me. It could have been an awful thought or a beautiful thought. But just the fact of a thought—wow. That little imagery helped free me from the content of what I was thinking, the storyline of my thoughts. It helped me to back up a little bit and just observe, "Oh, thinking is happening. Isn't this amazing, all this thought?" If I was thinking about what to have for dinner, there were a few times I said to myself, "Wow. Five billion years of evolution and it's come to this: a mind which is thinking about dinner. Isn't that amazing?"
This idea of being amazed or just observing the phenomenon of thinking—as opposed to getting sucked into the story and the content—offers a choice. Where do we put ourselves? Do we put ourselves in the story, or do we step back and see, "Oh, here's thinking. Here's a person thinking about dinner. These are dinner thoughts"? We don't have to be involved in them, just see, "It's just thinking, energy of thinking, pressure to think."
Being amazed as opposed to being despairing is helpful. It's not uncommon for some meditators to think that the purpose of meditation is not to think and to just stay concentrated on breathing. That tends to create a negative relationship with thinking. My hope is that with mindfulness meditation, people develop a friendly relationship with thinking. Not necessarily positive in the sense that thinking is all good and we should always be thinking, but rather just friendly towards it. Take it or leave it. Have the freedom to know when it's useful to think and when we can leave it alone.
The other interesting thing you can do with your thinking is to be prepared and plan ahead a little bit to be alert for this: When you notice that you've been pulled into a black hole of thinking, you've been lost in your thoughts for some time, and you finally wake up and realize what's happening, don't do anything in particular except notice what that was like. Notice what your awareness was like in that state. Notice what your body was like and what your sense of presence was like. What was it like to be in that black hole of thinking?
Some people report that it just feels like everything went dark. Some people feel everything got narrow, small, and contracted. Some people say, "I could feel the tension in my body, in my shoulders," when they were caught up in it. In a friendly way, just get to know the experience of what it was like to get lost in thought.
This is educational. As we start seeing, feeling, and knowing what that experience is like, we're more likely to catch it earlier. We might even see it coming so we don't easily get swept up in it. Part of the education is learning how getting caught up and preoccupied in thoughts is a kind of diminishment of ourselves. Not all of us is present. Being attentive and mindful in a full, present way is actually nicer. We're fuller; more of ourself is here. Sometimes just seeing that contrast very clearly makes it easier to choose to be mindful and present. Not as an aversion, not as pushing anything away, but just moving towards where it's most peaceful, pleasant, and enjoyable. Coming back here. Present.
Q&A
We have a little more than ten minutes left in this hour. Usually, when I do an introductory course, I take questions. This format is a little bit hard, but we can try if you're up for it. I will try to answer some questions about what I've talked about so far, any part of the instructions, thinking, and any challenges you have. If you can type it in the chat, we will experiment together and see how well this works.
Ah. "What if you have to sneeze?" What a great question.
You can sneeze. You're welcome to. There's no prohibition from sneezing. If you're meditating with other people, then of course cover your mouth in a good way—sneeze into your elbow or something. But something like a sneeze is also an opportunity. If you're inspired by the opportunity—this is not a duty—what you can do is bring a lot of mindfulness to the sneeze, to the impulse to sneeze. Maybe it's pretty uncomfortable, and rather than giving into it automatically, see if you can just bring a lot of attention to the sensations of the nose or wherever the pressure to sneeze is. Feel the pressure, feel the physicality, the emotions, and the thoughts all connected to the sneeze. Hang out with it and stay with it as long as you're interested and feel like you're up for the challenge.
It's a wonderful thing to learn how not to give in to the impulses we have. It's not just the impulse to sneeze, but the impulse to give in to the sneeze. We also learn how to be with discomfort. Learning how to be present with discomfort in a mindful way without being troubled by it is part of the art and benefit of this practice.
Let's see what else we have here. Thank you for asking so many questions.
"Is mental noting the same as a thought we are to recognize?"
That's nice. I think it becomes an endless loop that way. You just keep it simple. If you use mental noting to note what's happening in the moment, don't turn around and note the note. Then it's like an infinite regress. Just keep it simple. Use the noting to help you recognize and be present for what's going on in a nice way, and leave it at that.
"After doing a lot of concentration work, I find mindfulness is quite a task, sometimes unsettling. I'm not sure why that is."
Sometimes the very concentrated mind is calm and peaceful. If we switch over to mindfulness, and mindfulness is an activity that we do—it seems like a prescription like, "Now I'm going to be mindful"—we might be applying ourselves too much. Maybe even using the mental notes is too much work. Then it can be tiring and even unsettling. If the mind has gotten still and quiet through concentration, see if there's a way to be aware rather than mindful. Just be aware in a relaxed way of how things unfold. In the state of awareness, don't make awareness work. It's almost like the fruit of strong concentration. Awareness relaxing and opening to things arising and passing is almost like the vacation you get from having done concentration.
"How to deal with continual comparing mind? It's relentless."
Yes, it can be that way. One thing to do, which is not necessarily mindfulness but can break the energy or the hold it has, is to let it break your heart. Feel the suffering of that and how unfortunate it is to live a life that way. Sometimes just letting it break your heart is enough to break the dam and let something settle.
Another thing to do is mindfulness of the comparing mind. Don't analyze the comparisons, why you do it, or what happened to you in your life that makes you compare. Be simply aware of comparing, but notice in particular the suffering, stress, or distress that comes with that comparing mind. Feel how it's a drag to do it. Sometimes it's only when we fully feel the cost of what the mind is doing that we begin letting up. "Okay, this is not worth it. Whatever promise I'm trying to accomplish through comparing mind, I'm not accomplishing it, and it's not really helping. In fact, it's a drag." Sometimes only when we see the downside of it does the mind become willing to let go and relax.
I've known people who have done that with anger. The more mindful they become, they start seeing the tremendous personal cost of anger that they never saw when they were consumed with it and outwardly directed. But when the attention gets turned around internally 180 degrees, they feel, "Wow, this is rather unfortunate that I should be harming myself this much with my anger."
"Do you have any advice on how to practice watching thoughts without getting caught in them?"
If you keep getting caught while you're watching them, using a mental note like "thinking, thinking," or a bigger mental note like "this is thinking," can sometimes create distance. If you get into a relaxed rhythm of saying, "Thinking... thinking," that can allow you to watch it and not get caught.
But it also might be counterproductive to try to be focused on thinking. Sometimes, if you're really caught up in thoughts, it might be nice to do a little bit of a concentration practice, like counting your breaths. Diligently count your breaths from one to ten. If you lose count, just start again at one. If you get to thirty-two before you notice that you've gone beyond ten, just start again at one. When I count the breath, I tend to count the inhale and the exhale with the same count. I do the whole exhale with the count: "One." The inhale is more like I imagine I'm saying "one," and then on the next breath, "two." Use the count to help you get concentrated and settled. That can break the sticky glue or the intensity of the thinking. Once you're calmer, you can be mindful of thinking without getting caught in it.
"Any tips for not falling down a rabbit hole of thoughts?"
I think the same thing I just said applies. If you keep the practice simple—mindfulness of breathing as your primary meditation object—and develop a little bit of concentration to help you relax, with time your mind will become stronger than your thoughts. Every time a thought arises, let go and come back to your breathing. That very simple practice is often the best strategy when being pulled too readily into thoughts.
"I've been struggling with how to be aware of my body and yet feeling myself taken over by my hypochondria. How do the two awarenesses interrelate?"
Thank you, that's a great question. There are two things that look very similar: awareness of ourselves (our body, our breathing) and being self-conscious about it. Some people confuse awareness with being self-conscious. Self-consciousness involves fear, conceit, and other things besides being aware. The hypochondria, I think, is a kind of fear about what we're paying attention to.
That kind of self-consciousness is not awareness. Awareness has no agenda. Awareness by itself is not for or against anything. Awareness is not afraid of anything or angry at anything. Awareness just knows. It just makes space for things. That's where we're going eventually with the practice. But to get there, we have to learn a lot about the tricks of the mind and learn a lot about ourselves and what actually goes on in here. That's why we keep emphasizing mindfulness—just recognize what's happening.
The fact that you're seeing that this is what goes on means you're on the right track. See it better. Get more familiar with how this works. I'm confident that the more you see it and are familiar with how this phenomenon works, the more you'll become free of it. It eases up and becomes lighter until the time comes when you see the choice of which direction to go.
I'll do one more here.
"Is being in the present not also thinking that you are in the present?"
It can be. We have different capacities for attention. We have a family of faculties that help us be aware or attentive to the present moment. We have our physical sensations, which are always happening in the present. However, feeling those sensations doesn't require a thought to know that you're present. You can be aware of them silently. You can be aware of a sound with a mind that doesn't tell itself, "Oh, now I'm present with the sound."
There can be a present moment awareness without the thought, "Now I'm aware, now I'm present." If we spend too much time saying, "Now I'm present," we're not really that present. The state of being present becomes limited by this little statement repeating over and over again. It's fine to have simple, occasional thoughts like, "Oh, now I'm present. This is good. I've finally arrived. I'm here. I'm not wandering off so much." That's an innocent enough thought to have. But don't start thinking about it more or repeating it. Use that ability to be present to open to more of the silent awareness that we're capable of—the silent perceiving of phenomena, the silent spacious awareness of breathing in the body.
Thank you. We have two more days on this mindfulness course, and I've really appreciated this. Maybe these next two days, in the last ten minutes or so, we can take some questions in the same way. Tomorrow I will present what we've done over these days in one big overview, and also begin talking about how we can develop this mindfulness practice further. Thank you, and I look forward to our time tomorrow.