Moon Pointing

Q & A

Date:
2019-12-16
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-11 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Q & A

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Q & A

Introduction

I have had the very good fortune to not have anything on my mind. We could spend the evening talking about how wonderful that is, given some of the alternative possibilities that people do with their minds. But I thought it might be a nice evening if you'd like to ask any questions, have some discussion, or if you have any particular requests for something you want to hear about. Yes, sir, the mic is on, and it'd be nice if you said your name and spoke into it so we have a sense of community here.

The Joy of Generosity

Questioner 1: I'll cut to the chase here. At the very end of my meditation, I was thinking very fondly about buying another set of Makita tools. I had just bought them for a friend of mine, a guy who works for me, and I got him a very nice set. I was just very pleased; it was a great present. He showed them to me and said, "Boy, those are better than anything I've got!" though I've got all the same things. So then I started to think, this isn't really very Buddhist. There ought to be something that would make me happier than these new tools, which wouldn't make me very happy very often. So I'm glad that you've made yourself available to answer that question for me. What would make me happier than these Makita tools? They are very good tools, and I could give you more details if you'd like.

Gil Fronsdal: Well, maybe you answered the question yourself. You said that you gave him the tools, and he was so happy to have them that he showed them to you, and it really made your day. It really made you happy. Is that what happened?

Questioner 1: Yes, that's what's better than getting the tools for yourself. Well, I've already done that. Maybe it's almost time to come for myself, don't you think?

Gil Fronsdal: There are two things. There might be someone else you can give another set of tools to. If you can afford to buy them for yourself, then maybe find someone else to give the gift to. You get to feel that joy and delight, and that shared delight lasts a lot longer down through time than when you just get them for yourself. That's one thing that occurs to me.

The other thing has to do with the delight, the joy, and the appreciation your friend had in getting the present. I would worry a teeny bit if you got one also. You guys work together all the time. Just wait a little while, because if you got the same thing, it might set up a little bit of a different dynamic for him. Maybe it's not quite as special for him, or it just augments his happiness to be able to see you struggling with your old tools. [Laughter]

But the short answer is that helping other people to be happy, rather than you being happy yourself, is sometimes a better thing.

The Role of Memory in Practice

Trudy: I've been wondering lately about memory and where memories fit in the scheme of things when we're practicing. Memories can be pleasant, and can that pleasure be a distraction? Memories can have all kinds of emotions attached to them. I just wonder, can memories be useful in our practice, or are they to be avoided as a distraction?

Gil Fronsdal: They can be both. They can be useful if you use them to learn. If you remember that you were distracted by memories yesterday and it didn't really serve you very well, then when the memories come today you can say, "You know, I remember this didn't really go anywhere useful," and let go of them. But if it's the first time you've ever had a memory, it might be hard to let it go. When your practice is strong, you realize there are better things than memory. The pleasure of memory is nice, but there are better things.

For meditation, there are times where it is useful to remember lessons that teach you something about the meditation itself. Those memories serve your meditation, because you're actually not trying to remember and feel the pleasure of memories. The idea is that there are actually better things to experience in meditation, better goals and possibilities than riding along down memory lane. Outside of meditation, it's wonderful sometimes to sit, have a cup of tea, remember wonderful things, and feel that pleasure. That can be an innocent and wonderful event. But in meditation, we generally discourage it.

Meditation and Substance Abuse

Show meditation Hide meditation

Jonathan: I met someone a couple of days ago, and I told him that I come here sometimes. He was curious about the practice and wanted to learn a bit more about meditation. Specifically, he is interested in how meditation can help him with his substance abuse and addiction issues. I didn't have any experience with that, so I told him I was going to see Gil on Monday and I'd ask.

Gil Fronsdal: Great. We do have a recovery group here at IMC. In terms of bringing those two together explicitly—doing meditation and having discussions—we have this group that meets once a month on Sunday evenings. So that's a possibility.

There are many ways in which mindfulness can help with substance abuse issues. One of them has to do with being able to track oneself better—to really recognize the symptoms and signs that come along when we're in danger. Generally, if someone has an ongoing problem with substances, it's often trying to compensate for some suffering or distress that they might have. There are times with stress or other things when we're much more susceptible to drinking or taking drugs. To be mindful enough to see the symptoms early, get the early warning signs, and then learn how to do something different that's healthier and more healing is possible. If stressors build up and we don't see them coming, we get to a point where we react impulsively, or the craving is so strong it feels like we have no choice. To be calm enough, centered enough, and familiar enough with oneself to see it coming and know what alternatives to choose is one thing that mindfulness can help with. It takes time and a lot of attention.

The other thing is that if a person is strongly motivated to not take the substance—if that's really their heart's wish—meditation can teach a lot of discipline and self-control. You sit to meditate, and your practice is basically not to move, not to follow your thoughts, and not to follow your cravings or aversions. Every time that you let go of a thought in meditation, you get a little bit stronger in not following it. Every time you have a strong desire in meditation and you say, "No, I'm going to go back to my breathing," you get stronger. That discipline and that muscle gets stronger and stronger. Lo and behold, you walk by a liquor store, feel the urge to go in, and realize, "I can let go of that. I know what desire is like, and I can let go."

Another thing that meditation helps with—and this is probably one of the closest things the Buddha said around this particular issue—is that it gives a person a sense of happiness and well-being that is so much greater and better than the addiction. The balance tips so much more in favor of not partaking, because the person knows something really healthy and good. Some of the best quality happiness and well-being that a person can experience in life can come from meditation.

So awareness, discipline, and a sense of well-being. And as a reminder, this talk is also recorded and on audiodharma.org, so feel free to reference that as well for your friend.

The Craving for Distraction

Avi: I have this desire of constantly feeding myself with something. After this meditation for about an hour, I can just go by without any music or anything playing on the side, and I can just be silent within myself and outside. But after that, like when driving or just sitting and working, I need something playing in the background. It feels like something is missing. It's not that I desire something specific; it's just that the vacuum puts too much thought in my head. How do I go about not craving some kind of podcast, music, or input?

Gil Fronsdal: That's a great question, and I think it's one that probably many people have. You have discovered a treasure. I think one thing to do is to appreciate what is happening to you. Sometimes really appreciating something lets it live in us stronger.

This is where mindfulness is useful. When you find yourself wanting to put on music or a podcast—something that's distracting or fills the void for a little while—don't do it. Instead, stop whatever else you're doing, maybe sit and close your eyes, and turn inwards to see what's really going on for you. Become an expert on it. Become like you're going to get a PhD on Avi, on what happens in you when you have this craving for the music. Are you lonely? Are you scared? Do you feel somehow bereft or lost? Do you have thoughts which are painful and you're trying to mask or hide from them? What's really going on? Don't just settle for the first one or two impressions. Take a deep, honest look.

After you've gotten to know it well, ask yourself the question: Is there a healthier way to deal with this need? Is there a better way to respond to it? Based on what you said this evening, it's possible meditation is a better way.

Another thing you can try is to take maybe three times when the craving comes along and simply refuse to give in to it, just like an exercise. Say, "No way am I going to do it. I'm going to see this through until that desire is not there." Be there and see what happens if you don't give in to it and get to the other side.

And finally, if you can't beat something, begin changing it just a little bit in a healthy direction. If you're listening to music and you can't avoid it to feel whatever is going on for you, go find some meditation music. It's still music, but it's pointing you in the direction of meditation and reminding you of it. That might be a nice transition.

Working with a Wandering Mind

Jane: To tease out a little bit more of what he was saying, I notice there are times when I'm not in practice that my mind will start to wander, and I want to stop it because my wandering mind has not always been my friend. I think I have an anticipation of possibly what's next, if I can either train myself not to do that, or to maybe understand that there is something on the other side of that.

Gil Fronsdal: You have all kinds of options with that. One would be simply to let go of your wandering mind as quickly as you can when it comes up. Slowly over time, the energy for distraction will abate and the energy for being present will grow, shifting the balance in a nice way.

Another thing to do, which sometimes is wiser because it produces more understanding, is on a day when your mindfulness seems strong enough, you might try very gently to go along with the wandering mind. Don't stop it. Let it go, but because your mindfulness is strong enough, you watch it. You're not lost in it, but you watch it happen and you study it to understand: What is this? What's happening emotionally? Just like with the music we talked about—what is it trying to meet? Is it covering up loneliness or anxiety? Try to get wise about what's going on with you. If you just simply let go of your wandering mind over and over again, you might not see what's triggering it or what need it's trying to fill. When the mindfulness is strong, you don't get sucked into it, but you can watch it happen and learn a lot about yourself.

There also might be a day where your mindfulness is strong enough, but at the same time, that drive to wander off into thought is super strong. What you might try doing is thinking, "Today is not going to be a very enjoyable meditation. Today, a successful meditation is going to be that I grit my teeth, get tense, and I'm not going to give in to the wandering mind." Because the wandering mind is so strong, unless you do that, you will wander off. That is an interesting exercise to do at least once. Most people want to meditate because they want to relax, but sometimes you want to get a handle on the whole thinking mind. To really steel yourself up, be a warrior, and say, "I'm not going to give in whatsoever." Try that at least once and see what happens.

Reflections on Addiction and Recovery

Joel: I really dislike speaking publicly, especially with the mic. I don't so much have a question as much as I'd just like to share with everyone. As I've struggled with my own battles with addiction, meditation practice has been really helpful for me. After a year of not practicing my meditation, I came here tonight and was really just moved. I felt so fulfilled to be able to be here tonight and honored by everyone's presence and connection.

As far as your friend goes, there's also a Dharma and recovery group that meets once a month in the North Bay Meditation Center, and also a group that meets once a month in the Berkeley Buddhist temple. They're both really helpful and really positive. In addition, there's a book by Gabor Maté[1] called In the Realm of Hungry Ghosts, which is really powerful and has helped me along the way despite my own hiccups along the road. I want to thank everyone here for just being here and putting positivity into the world.

Gil Fronsdal: Joel, thank you very much for all of that. I appreciate it, especially since it's hard for you to speak this way.

Meditating on Big Decisions

Simon: I have kind of a large decision in my life coming up imminently. As I've been meditating quite a bit, I intuitively said, "I'm going to meditate on it." Then I quickly realized I didn't really know how to meditate on decisions specifically. I have come to understand now that my logical, linear thinking mind is not going to be an effective tool at grappling with these complex systems of life and predicting the future. So I figured I'm just going to sit, clear my mind, and it's going to come to me.

Gil Fronsdal: What I've discovered for myself when I've had to make a big decision is that it's actually useful for me to spend a lot of time thinking about it. I go for walks and I think about it. I'm driving around in my car thinking about it. But I've learned that the answer is not going to come from the thinking. It used to be that I was thinking in order to get the answer, but I learned over time that the thinking is creating the conditions for the mind to do its work.

In this way, when I'm least expecting it—when I'm doing something different and I've forgotten the issue—that's when something comes back. "Oh, now I know what to do," and I get crystal clear. But if I hadn't spent time thinking, I wouldn't have gotten the momentum going, or the synergy of the mind going with that churning. Something works offline in the back room. So thinking about it is helpful, but it's not where the answer comes from; it creates the conditions for the answer to come in a different way.

Simon: That's extremely helpful because I think I've really just had an aversion to thinking about it. I had just been sitting and having quietness of mind, but there was nothing clearly giving me a sign or a sense of intuition about which path I should take.

Gil Fronsdal: Your mind needs to be working the problem. You have to do some kind of input. But if you know that your thinking mind is not going to provide the answer directly, then you don't have to invest so much in it, wait anxiously for the answer, or feel bad because you can't figure it out. You're not supposed to figure it out; you're supposed to put the ingredients into the soup.

Meditation can be very helpful for this process, because when you've done your part of churning away with it for a while, and you quiet the mind in meditation, that's the time when some deeper background process in the brain has a chance to operate. You've cleared the space for some deeper processing to happen, and that's the kind of situation where something new can arise that was unforeseen.

Balancing 12-Step and Dharma Practice

John: I actually found this place five years ago as an alternative to my 12-step group. There's a book by an author named Kevin Griffin that's about Buddhist recovery as well, called One Breath at a Time[2]. That's a great one that helped me in a time of crisis. Over the years, I've had some sobriety and had a child, and I hadn't been coming here as much. Thankfully, I was able to do that because I found this place and some other support. But lately I had a slip, and I found myself back in 12-step for the last couple of weeks. I was speaking with my therapist, and we basically agreed that if I had a good week I would come here, and if I had a bad week I would go to my 12-step group. It starts at the same time, 7:30 on Mondays, and it's basically the same direction—I just turn left to the meditation and right to the 12-step. So I'm hoping I'll be back next week.

Gil Fronsdal: I'm happy you have a nice alternative that both support you. You're lucky to have it.

The Paradox of Desire

Scott: I have been wrestling with a bit of a paradox, coupled with a feeling of being a hypocrite. It stems from the fact that it feels like we're engaging in a practice of seeking a sense of happiness or solace—almost desiring this—but at the same time, aren't we engaged in a practice to not want to engage in desire? So I'm wanting something, engaging in a practice where I'm not supposed to want something. Is that a different type of desire? Is it the wrong or right type of desire?

Gil Fronsdal: I think you're right, there are different types of desires. Not all desires are equal in terms of being problematic, and it's the problematic desires we want to become free of. In Buddhist language, the problematic desires are usually called craving[3]. They are desires that have compulsivity to them, where we are not free in relationship to them. Those desires, which are for things that are harmful for ourselves or for other people, we want to avoid.

But there are desires that involve no compulsivity, that have no craving, that we are free in doing, and they're really healthy for us. They're healthy for us, healthy for others, healthy for the world. They are ones that support us, nourish us, and help us to thrive internally and become better people. Those we want to act on and live by.

If we're doing Buddhist practice and really tuning in mindfully to what's going on, we'll start discovering that even desires for healthy things can be a little bit tiring and stressful for the mind. It can be a little bit of a drag to always be thinking the same thoughts over and over again. Just because it's a healthy desire and we feel free in having it doesn't mean it's in our best interest to keep thinking about it. So in meditation especially, we learn to let go. We learn to let go of even good desires. We don't want to let go of them forever, but at least in order to have deeper rest and deeper clarity of the mind, we have to learn to let go of those so we can see more deeply.

So there is something true about learning to let go of desire, but we have a desire for the letting go of desire. We have a desire for what's better than desire, and that's fine to have, because as you get to the edge of that, it's clear you have to let go of that too. But until you get to the edge of it, it serves you. Go along with it.

Parenting, Boundaries, and Forgiveness

Bethany: I have two daughters, five and ten, and I've been thinking a lot about forgiveness as a parenting tool. My younger daughter has some behavioral challenges. She has big reactions to things, like the wrong bowl at the breakfast table, or the carrots are not on the plate. You want to teach them that hitting or kicking is not okay. But sometimes when I go in to explain to her that her behavior is not okay, that ramps up her behavior because she feels bad about it on top of feeling the big emotion. There have been a few times where I've thought, "You're okay, you're still loved," but it's hard to find that line between "Am I coddling?" and "Am I spoiling the child?" I've just been trying to figure out how to get the forgiveness in but also teach her to be aware of her behavior.

Gil Fronsdal: It's a great question. I wonder if maybe forgiveness is not quite the issue in the junctures you're talking about. The kids are young, and it's absolutely the role of the parent to intervene so they don't cause harm—so they don't kick or bite. But forgiving them doesn't seem like the right thing to do if you haven't taught them to just stop doing it. How do you get them to stop doing it in a way that they don't feel shamed or experience anger from you, but where it's very definitive?

Like if two kids are fighting, and you just step right into the middle of it and sit down and say, "Oh, I could see that you guys are fighting, and I got to think if I sit here in the middle maybe that'll stop it." No one is being blamed.

As you were speaking, I remembered when I was fourteen. My friend and I came across the keys to my father's car, and we thought we would try to drive it. Neither one of us knew how to drive. We got in the car, turned on the engine, and the car was parked right next to a bulldozer. When the engine turned on, the car lurched forward and hit the bulldozer. The bulldozer was fine, but my father's car got banged in. I called my father on the phone and said, "You know, this thing happened and I crashed your car into a bulldozer." He just said, "Does it still drive?" I said, "Yes, but we can't open the passenger door." He said, "Well, just see what you can do about it, and I'll look at it when I come home." And that was the end of it; I never heard anything about it again. Maybe my voice was such that he understood I felt bad and there was no need to be angry with me. But I got a big lesson about acceptance, about not being angry, and about finding your way with these things.

Sometimes when kids are acting out and hitting, they have a need, and chances are they need love, care, and attention. How do you offer them a little bit of attention and love without condoning what they did, or without doing it as a reward for what they did? When my kids were growing up, I used distraction all the time—which is something I train people not to do when they meditate! But it seems like a good strategy as parents. Sometimes distraction worked to just run away the temperature so it didn't escalate.

As a matter of fact, just telling them, "No, we don't do that here in this house," is important. Sometimes my son would be misbehaving and I couldn't stop it. I'd say, "Okay, it's time to go to your room." He would be furious, and I would pick him up and take him to his room. I'd close the door, but I'd stay in the room with him, so I wasn't abandoning him in there. I'd sit down in the doorway so I could block the door, and I'd say, "It's fine for you to be angry, but we're just going to sit here until you calm down."

It's a really important question, because the instinct people have to punish the kids or be angry doesn't serve them in the long term. Finding healthy alternatives is really good.

Well, it's nine o'clock, and it's very important that these young kids go to bed on time, because then they're better behaved the next day. And it might be true for adults too! I hope you all go home and to your usual bedtimes, go to sleep contentedly and happily, and wake up and be loving people for this world tomorrow. Thank you.



  1. Gabor Maté: A physician and author known for his work on addiction, trauma, and childhood development. His book In the Realm of Hungry Ghosts explores the roots of addiction. ↩︎

  2. Kevin Griffin: A Buddhist teacher and author known for integrating Buddhist mindfulness practices with the Twelve Step recovery program. One Breath at a Time is one of his foundational books on the subject. ↩︎

  3. Craving (Taṇhā): A Pali word literally meaning "thirst." In Buddhism, it refers to the compulsive craving or unwholesome desire that leads to suffering (dukkha). This is contrasted with Chanda, which can refer to a wholesome desire, intention, or zeal to practice the path. ↩︎