Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation Part 2 (7 of 8): The Hindrance of Doubt
- Date:
- 2020-04-29
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-11 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Introduction and Q&A
Greetings. I am happy to be here and happy to see that there are already some questions here. Before we start, maybe I can take a few.
"What is the difference between exploring and contemplating thoughts in insight meditation? When is it useful to do each?"
That is a great question. A wise life is both mindful of thinking and also reflective with thinking. It thinks about things wisely, learns critical thinking skills, and spends time contemplating subjects and things going on that are important to us.
The thing is that many people have a strong habit of thinking. And so even when they are going to think about necessary or useful things, the way that they think is somewhat addictive. It reinforces the strong emphasis that some people have that thinking is important—we're supposed to think—and it reinforces the habit.
In mindfulness meditation, there's very little we need to think about. Some teachers like to emphasize the difference between content and process. With thinking in mindfulness meditation, we're moving away from content—the things we're thinking about—to being aware of the process of thinking. So we're not using mindfulness meditation to think better, think deeply, reflect on things, or contemplate things. We're using it to see things. Seeing is a little bit more silent than the mind that thinks and has conversations.
We're not necessarily getting rid of all thinking or not thinking at all, but it's helpful to distinguish between different kinds or levels of thinking. There's discursive thinking, which is having a conversation in one's mind, holding forth and making commentary about things. That's a much more involved and complicated form of thinking. Thinking about the future and thinking about the past has really no role in meditation practice. It might at other times in our life.
Then there is a very similar kind of thinking that might still be a little bit like sentences, or multiple sentences, that act as commentary about the present-moment experience. Some of that might be a little bit helpful at times to find our way, but we don't overdo it. We want to let the thinking become even quieter.
Quieter thinking is to think very simple thoughts. Maybe giving yourself instruction, like, "Let me feel the breath now. Where's that inhale? Where's that sensation? What are the sensations of the inhale? Where does the inhale begin? What happens if I just kind of ride the inhale from beginning to end?" There are very simple, instructional open questions that encourage not more thinking, but a quieter observation of what the experience is.
And then there's quieter thinking still: single words, the mental notes. So we're using the thinking mind so it's employed, but it's very, very simple in support of getting calm, settled, and still. The mind can get stiller. And that is to use an inner voice—a quieting or calming voice—to have a single word for maybe a breathing in: "in," breathing out: "out." Or if a hindrance arises, in a calm voice, not an alarmed voice, noting: "desire." This is desire. This is aversion. This is ill will. As opposed to, "Oh, no, this is terrible."
So thinking can be part of it, but the direction, if we're using thinking as part of meditation, is all for the purpose of becoming quieter and stiller. It's all for the purpose of seeing the experience directly and not thinking about it. A lot of discursive thoughts we let go of and relax. Or if we're caught in it, we focus on the process—the activity of thinking—not the content. Outside of meditation, I hope all of us become wiser and wiser thinkers about things, and we take time to have tea, go for a walk, and have profound thoughts.
That took quite a bit of time to answer. That's the only question I see, so that's convenient. Let's start.
Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation Part 2 (7 of 8): The Hindrance of Doubt
Thank you for being here and coming back. This is the second to last day of our Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation Part Two, where we're looking at the hindrances[1]. We are looking at what hinders clarity, what hinders concentration, and what hinders a clear presence and being connected to our life as we live it.
It's important, as I've been saying, to not see the hindrances as problems, but as something to turn towards. If you turn towards a hindrance and really recognize that it's there, it's no longer hindering. It's a hindrance because it hinders our ability to see what's happening. But if what's happening is desire, ill will, sloth and torpor, restlessness and worry, or doubt, and we really see it clearly—"Oh, this is what's happening"—then it's no longer a hindrance. It has been transformed from the hindrance of desire to just desire. From hindering doubt to just doubt.
That's the power of mindfulness: to transform something from a hindrance into just being itself. When it is just itself, then we can begin finding our freedom with it, finding our wisdom with it, and having a different relationship to it. As long as something is a hindrance—meaning it's hindering us—there's no way of getting around that. That's why we keep coming back with the practice of clear recognition.
We are learning over time how powerful it is to step back and clearly recognize, "This is what's happening." We might at first recognize, "I feel restless, that's terrible. I'm restless and I shouldn't be restless, and what am I going to do about my restlessness?" There is a kind of mindfulness there, but we're caught up restlessly about the restlessness. Instead, step back and see, "Oh, this is restlessness." Maybe the first time you're still kind of caught in it, but we keep saying it: "This is restlessness. Restlessness." Until we see, "Oh, this is what's happening. No doubt about it. This is clearly what's happening." There's restlessness, but the knowing of the restlessness has become calm. The knowing of the restlessness is not restless about the restlessness, or aversive to it, or running away from it.
As you learn this art over time—the part of mindfulness that has to do with clear recognition—a hindrance is no longer hindering. Then we don't call it a hindrance anymore. Then we just call it desire, ill will, sloth and torpor, restlessness, worry, and doubt.
The topic for today is doubt. There is a long tradition of seeing doubt as the most dangerous of the hindrances in terms of meditation practice. Doubt has a way of camouflaging itself, of coming with tremendous authority about what we're doing. It questions it, doubts it, and gives us no confidence. We aren't able to commit to the practice, thinking, "There must be another way. There must be something else, not this."
When doubt is really strong, we don't do the things that we should do, the things that are healthy or beneficial for us. We might give up on things prematurely or unnecessarily. So from a Buddhist practice point of view, doubt is the most dangerous because if we doubt the practice, or doubt ourselves in the practice, we can give it up. We can leave our meditation; we can just stop meditating. We can just walk away.
I know one person who had very strong doubt on a long, silent residential retreat. She said she had a "multiple hindrance attack," meaning all of them were there, but doubt was the strongest. At some point, she doubted being there and was uncertain about the importance of being there. She decided it was not the place for her and decided to leave. Flying cross-country back home, in the middle of that flight, she suddenly woke up and said, "Wait a minute. That was a multiple hindrance attack. I got caught up especially in doubt, and I didn't need to do that. But that got the upper hand on me, and here I am flying home." That's a dramatic story, but this idea of doubt can be very powerful. It has a huge influence on us in a way that can cause a lot of suffering and difficulty.
Another word for doubt is uncertainty or indecisiveness. We're uncertain what to do. We don't know what to do. "Should I be paying attention to my breathing? Or should I be doing loving-kindness practice? Should I sit on this retreat or that retreat? Should I read this teacher or listen to that teacher? Is this the right time to practice? I don't know if this is the right time to practice; maybe tomorrow is the right time. Tomorrow comes—no, I'm not sure what's right."
One very insidious kind of doubt is having doubt that the practice is going to work, or doubt that we can do the practice. "This practice is not good practice. I don't know if it's for me. I don't think it's going to work." If we're caught up in the hindrance of doubt, with those thoughts spinning around and going a mile a minute, then it's a self-fulfilling prophecy. Of course, it's not going to work if we're spinning out in thoughts like that. There's a paradox or irony that the very questioning and doubting that this is going to work is the very thing that causes it not to work. And then people give up the practice.
I think it's useful to distinguish between hindering doubt and questioning doubt. There is doubt which is healthy to have. There is doubt that questions things. "Is this really true, what I'm hearing? I don't know about this. Let me question it, reflect on it, study it, and see what works for me and what is true." The difference is that hindering doubt disconnects us from our experience, pulls us away, shuts us down, creates a veil, and creates a distance in our ability to see and be present. Questioning doubt, in a healthy way, is one that opens us, moves us towards something, and engages us to look more carefully and more deeply.
Questioning doubt often involves thinking outside of meditation. Questioning and reflecting is a healthy thing to do. But be very careful: Does it involve uncertainty? Does it involve indecisiveness? Hindering doubt tends to be very discursive. It tends to be a lot of thinking and ideas. This is where mindfulness of thinking becomes very useful.
The basic instruction practice I gave in Part One included instructions for how to be mindful of thoughts and thinking. As we get skilled in recognizing thinking and the different kinds of thinking, we start feeling that certain ways of thinking are distancing. They disconnect me from myself and from what's going on. Certain kinds of thinking put me up in my head, spinning around in an agitated way, and I'm not settled. As we learn about the quality and the effect that thinking has on us, we can see at some point that the process of this thinking is not useful. It's not settled; it's not relaxed. It's tense and agitated.
Rather than judging the kind of thoughts or being concerned with what we're thinking, we can see that this is not a healthy way to be. Let me get reconnected. Let me come back to breathing. Let me do the three-breath journey and settle down. Let the thinking mind settle down, so my thinking can rest in the mind, rest in the brain, or rest inside of me. I can still think, but I'm not spinning out and caught up in it.
If we can learn to recognize the difference between settled, easeful, relaxed thinking and agitated thinking, then we have a better opportunity to notice when we're in doubt. We have a better ability to question the validity of what doubt is saying, or the authority that says we're supposed to be caught up in all these thoughts. Instead of staying caught, we can try to settle the mind. One way to do that is to say to the thoughts, "Let me consider you later. Let me first get settled. You might have some interesting point, there might be some validity to this doubt, but thinking about it in an agitated way is not helpful. Let me calm down and settle down. Once I'm settled and reconnected, then let's look at it."
Chances are that when we get really settled, if the doubt is a hindering doubt or involves a fear-based uncertainty, and that quiets down, then we'll think about it more accurately and more usefully. We might feel, in the calmness of our being, that there is a natural confidence to practice. There is a feeling in the calmness of it all that this is the right thing to do. When we're agitated, caught up in thoughts of doubt, fear, expectation, striving, and wanting something else, it's very uncomfortable. It lends itself to a lack of confidence. It's hard to find confidence in those states.
To repeat: learning the basic practice of mindfulness, including learning how to be skillful in recognizing our thinking and the quality of our thinking, can show us the ways in which we're thinking that are not useful. We aren't dismissing what we're thinking about, but we know it's useful to calm down and settle first. We consider the concern from a very different vantage point. We might see the situation very differently from this new, calm, settled place.
Sometimes doubt arises when our goal in practice is too grand. We have very lofty goals or expectations. It could be as simple as, "For this meditation session, I'm going to be with every breath and not miss one, and not wander away at all." That might be too big of a goal. With that kind of expectation, if the mind keeps wandering off—even if it wanders off only 10 times in a 40-minute meditation session—it might be discouraging. We start having doubts. "Can I do this? Is this the right practice? Maybe I should do something else." It has a lot to do with the fact that it was an unrealistic goal. To be full-time with every breath in a sitting is maybe unrealistic until the mind is really well-settled and concentrated.
What can be helpful is to have a much more modest goal. It might be to do the three-breath journey. Maybe you can have confidence that you can, more or less, do the three-breath journey. And then do it again. And then do it again. That builds confidence. "I can do the three-breath journey. I know how to do that." If three breaths is too much, then maybe just be satisfied with one breath. If one breath is too much, just do the inhale. And then do the exhale. Build confidence on these small steps.
With small steps, confidence builds over time. Don't set up too big of a goal or have high expectations, because you're guaranteed to have self-doubt. Be content with small goals, being present for this moment, and this moment. The walk up a very high mountain is done one step at a time. Each step, stepping, stepping. The goal of Buddhist practice is pretty great, pretty lofty in a sense, but the way there is only one step at a time. That's where the confidence gets built up over time.
The other thing that's helpful for doubt, as I said, is understanding and being sensitive to the different qualities of thinking. In the same way, it's useful as we develop our practice to become a connoisseur of the quality of our physical being. How do we feel in our body? What gets tight, what gets agitated, what collapses, and where does the energy go? Start recognizing what's happening in the body, because that can very quickly be a first clue that somehow we're losing touch with ourselves.
I've been sitting and meditating, feeling very connected, very grounded. The energy of attention and awareness was centered in my torso and my belly, and it felt very stable. And then I had one single thought come up that was so captivating and arousing that I almost felt like this energy inside whooshes up into my head with some emotion, preoccupation, or thought. Notice that difference, that change in how things feel and what gets activated. "Oh, this is a time to be mindful. I think something radically changed. Let me be cautious here. Let me bring attention to what just happened." If I don't do that, then it's very easy to get pulled into those worlds of thinking.
The more familiar you become with your body and the changes in your body, able to track it, the more you get the clues that support you to notice when you get pulled into doubt. What I'm pointing to here is not directly addressing the subject of the doubt, but rather addressing how we feel mentally, physically, and maybe emotionally when doubt happens. Turn the attention back on that. Look at this carefully, and maybe settle it and relax it.
Now, some doubts we have maybe can't be settled that way. Some doubts about the practice or about the teachings are best addressed by finding someone to talk to. It could be a friend. Sometimes just talking it out and hearing ourselves talk, we come to a better understanding ourselves. Or maybe the friend has some perspective to offer. Or go talk to a teacher. Sometimes doubts are very valid to have, and those can be clarified in talking with a teacher.
Doubt, uncertainty, and indecisiveness can come up in this practice. When it does, it is just as valid a focus of attention as anything else. It's just as valid to step back and clearly recognize, "Oh, this is doubt. This is indecisiveness. This is uncertainty." Keep a relaxed, open, step-back recognition until you start feeling that you're a little bit free or a little bit separated from the doubt itself. You're not entangled with it.
The metaphor I like—a little more visual for this idea—is being with a group of people who are all arguing and talking at once. You're participating in the whole thing. And for some reason, you step away, 10 or 15 feet, and then you turn around and look at them. You're no longer participating in the animated conversation and argument, you're just watching it. And you say, "Wow, that's a lot of energy over there. They're really caught up." It feels kind of nice to be away from the fray and just watch it and look at it. Maybe you care for it—you're not being aloof. But this stepping away: "Oh, doubt is happening. This is doubt." That is clear recognition.
Guided Meditation
Show meditation
Hide meditation
Guided Meditation
So with that, maybe we could do our meditation today. I'll say one more thing about doubt before we do. If a doubt is not too strong and we recognize it, sometimes it can be useful to use discipline to settle it and overcome it. To just say, "Okay, I know there's doubt there. I'm just going to be committed to just being with my breath, just doing my practice." Don't give the doubt a lot of attention or energy, but put the attention and energy on just doing the practice.
If you don't have enough confidence in the practice, you might also try to borrow the confidence of another practitioner. Maybe you know another meditation practitioner or a teacher, and they seem to have a lot of confidence. Try to pick it up and borrow it. "They have confidence, I'm going to borrow theirs and really get myself over this for these minutes that I'm here, and see if that can overcome this minor doubt that I'm caught in."
I will offer you my tremendous confidence in this practice as we do this meditation. So, if you can, take a meditation posture. For this purpose today, you might take a posture that expresses confidence, if you can do that without any tension. Sitting with confidence, and gently closing your eyes.
Take the three-breath journey. Counting to three, one for each of the next three breaths.
And then maybe doing it again, this time taking some fuller breaths. Three full breaths in a gentle way. Breathing in fully, and exhaling fully.
Then, letting your breathing return to normal. Take a little bit of time now to look around your body. Feel around your body for any place where you feel tense or the muscles are held tight. See as you exhale, whether you can relax that a bit. If it's not easy to relax, it's fine. It doesn't matter too much. But maybe relaxation means being accepting of yourself as being tense. Shoulders are tense. If they don't relax, the relaxation is in the mind, accepting the fact that there's tension in the shoulders.
One more thing to do in preparation here: look around your body. Is there any place in your body that you associate with confidence, a place of confidence? For some people that can be their feet or their legs. Some people, their hands. Some people, the chest or the heart. Some people, it's the belly area, wherever it is for you.
Let yourself explore and feel that part of your body where you feel some kind of confidence. It doesn't have to be strong or dramatic. Even if what you discover approximates confidence, that's good enough. Perhaps breathing with this place, feeling or imagining that you breathe in and out through this place of confidence.
Then, maybe with some perfume of confidence in the background, let yourself settle into the experience of the body breathing. Perhaps as you exhale, letting go of your thoughts. Quieting your thoughts. Letting go into the exhale. Letting go into breathing.
Rather than trying to attain something in meditation, or trying to make something happen, maybe you can allow your meditation to be very simple. Simply recognize what is happening. Try to have that recognition be relaxed and calm, but also clear. Allow the recognition to be recognizing what is easy and obvious to recognize, as opposed to thinking about it or analyzing it. If it's not clear what's happening, it's completely appropriate for the mental note to just be "something." "Something is happening." To be clear: "Oh yeah, something is happening. I don't know what it is, but something is happening." That might be all you need to do to be mindful.
This central role that recognizing has means that the practice is successful each time, each moment, where there is some kind of clear recognition.
As you're sitting here now, is there any degree of doubt? Even if it's very teeny. Any uncertainty? Any indecisiveness? If there is, recognize it as such. As you recognize it, notice what influence it has on your thinking, on your feelings, or on your body.
If there are any subtle forms of doubt, indecisiveness, or uncertainty, feel it in the body. Feel it in the mind. Notice the quality of the thinking. Notice the quality of the process of your body and mind involved in doubt thoughts, without giving too much attention to the content of the doubt.
As you exhale, release yourself into the exhale. Allow the release. Letting go of the exhale, allowing it to continue to the very end of the exhale. Not straining to do so, but relaxing to do so.
To end this sitting in a gentle, kind way, take a few longer, slower breaths. As if you're waking yourself up from meditation in a shower of kindness, of caringness.
Breathing in deeply, letting go as you exhale. As if you're stepping into the world again with kindness, with care, and with calmness. Having let go of doubt the best you can, maybe opening your eyes now with the eyes of trust, of confidence.
Reflections on Fear
One of the important or significant causes or conditions for the arising of doubt is fear. Part of the path of mindfulness is to learn to become well-familiar with how anxiety and fear work for us. That takes being willing to stop and look at fear. Perhaps the bumper sticker for mindfulness practitioners is, "I stop for fear." Stop and look and get to know it. That's one way to become free of fear. Not free because of its absence, but free because we're no longer caught by it or limited by the fear we have. One way to do that is to study it, get to know it, understand it, and understand ourselves in relationship to it.
Fear can come up as doubt. There can be fear of how we're going to be changed by meditation. Fear of altered states of mind. Fear of really looking at ourselves deeply, and uncertain or doubtful whether that's really worth doing, or "Can I do it?"
When there's a lot of doubt, sometimes you want to ask yourself: Is there fear? When anxiety and fear are a regular companion for oneself, it's likely that that fear needs something from you. Rather than dismissing it, trying to fix it, trying to solve it, trying to analyze it, or trying to talk yourself out of it, there is this powerful thing we do in mindfulness of turning around and looking at something and really recognizing it. "There it is. This is fear."
But what might be important, once we can really see it there, is to realize that maybe the fear needs something from us. And one of the things that our fear often needs—especially anxiety and chronic fear that has gone on for years—is it needs to feel safe. Our task is to help our fear feel safe. That means that if you're trying to fix it, get away from it, you're embarrassed by it, you're angry at it, or you're trying to overcome it, it's not going to feel safe. It's going to feel like it's not wanted. It's going to feel like it's wrong.
Imagine coming from underneath the fear with the soft palms of mindfulness. Find where it is in the body, feel the sensations of it, and really recognize it as a physical aspect of fear. Come with awareness and just hold it in the soft palms of awareness. Try to make it feel safe. One of the great mantras to do this is to say to it, "It's okay." You don't have to explain what is okay. That's a very powerful mantra: "It's okay."
One of the things you're trying to convey to the fear is, "It's okay to be afraid. I'm here with you, I'll protect you. It's okay for you to be afraid right now." When fear starts to feel safe, then it begins to thaw. It begins to open up, it begins to relax. Some of the problems we have in life, some things we are afraid of, are not things that need to be solved, but rather they represent something that needs to dissolve. If we're always solving, we don't allow this deeper interpersonal process of dissolving to happen. It can happen if we get out of the way while at the same time holding it in awareness.
So experiment with that. Those of you who have chronic fear or anxiety, and it's a regular companion—it's very common for humans to have that. It's a completely worthwhile and useful object for mindfulness. You can develop and strengthen a lot of mindfulness with fear as the subject. See if you can hold it and help it really feel safe. Like maybe you've never done this before, allow the fear to have its time in the sun, in the sun of awareness.
I say this because sometimes doubt is prompted by fear. The real issue is not the doubt, it is the underlying fear, and we need to look at that.
Q&A
We have about 10 minutes before the end, and I can take some questions and try to respond to something that's particularly useful for some of you.
While we are waiting for questions, I could say that tomorrow is the last day for this hindrance series. There have been some requests for an Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation Part Three. One person sent a very nice message suggesting that it could be on what the Buddha's teachings call the Seven Factors of Awakening[2]. In the Buddha's teaching, the hindrances and the Seven Factors of Awakening are paired up like two sides of a seesaw. As the hindrances go down, these seven good factors of mind get stronger. When the hindrances get stronger, the Seven Factors of Awakening disappear. The Buddha clearly paired them up that way. I'll think about doing it, though I might need to wait a while, maybe until June. You can keep an eye on the schedule on the IMC website.
"Thank you, Gil. Any insights on how to handle overwhelming thoughts of doubt about the future?"
Chances are there's a lot of fear then, if they're overwhelming. Maybe what needs to be addressed is the fear about it. If it's really overwhelming, what you might do is write your fears down. Write your doubts down. Maybe do a stream-of-consciousness writing about what you're afraid of, and then after you've done that for maybe 15 to 20 minutes, you might go back and reread it a few times. Or even copy those doubts down on a second piece of paper. Getting them out on paper and being really clear about them might give your mind a different relationship to them. You might understand them in a different way.
Something I've done in the past, when I had not doubt so much, but when I was really troubled by something and had a lot of grief and sadness: when I was driving and alone, I would talk to myself out loud about it. I found that when I talk out loud, I access a different part of my mind than when I quietly think to myself. It turned out that there's more clarity, more wisdom, more objectivity, and more access to a wider intelligence sometimes in talking out loud than just getting caught up in the mental chatter. Journaling or talking out loud might give you more clarity and keep you from getting caught so much in it. It might give you an opportunity to think more wisely about what you're doing.
If you're overwhelmed by the future and you're constantly reading the news, stop reading the news. Most news is actually old. Things haven't really changed so much in thousands of years; it's just old in a different form and shape. It might be helpful just not to read so much, for example.
"I'd appreciate anything you have to say about trust."
I love the word trust. I like it more than faith, for example. What can I say about it? Certainly trust is confidence. But trust is an openness and an allowing that there's something good here, that something is right here, something is supportive here. You don't just trust blindly or trust anything, but to trust mindfulness, to trust meditation, to sit in meditation, and learn to clearly recognize what's happening. Being present for what's happening in the present, and opening to it. That's a very trustable process, meaning it's okay to open to it. It's okay to allow it to move through us.
Good things come when we open up and allow it to move through us, even if what happens is more intense and more difficult at first. I've learned you can trust that process, to keep opening. For me, trust has this connotation of, "It's okay to hang in there with this. Something is supporting us, something is moving through right now." That's not always the case in all human situations, but if you practice mindfulness, most situations work out for the best. That's what I've found. But that means really practicing mindfulness and not getting tripped up by reactivity.
"I have a doubt when I use RAFT and BELLA during meditation." / "I can't find the archived versions of this series of talks."
If you need some clarification about how this practice of RAFT or BELLA[3] works and you need to ask some questions, or come up with different explanations or understandings or even different acronyms for yourself that work for you, you don't have to stick to exactly what I'm teaching.
Also, if you say, "I have doubt when I use these practices during meditation," maybe what really needs attention is to turn away from those practices and focus on the doubt itself. Just be mindful of doubt until the doubt has abated and quieted. Then you can use these other practices in some way.
These practices that I give with the acronym RAFT (which I did in Part One) and BELLA (for this one) are not always the best things to use. Even though I've taught them, and I think they're useful for me and many people, they are not always the right call or what's needed. Sometimes I shouldn't be trying so hard. Sometimes I shouldn't try to always be doing practice and techniques to figure out how to make it work and find my way. Sometimes mindfulness is not so much about getting something, acquiring something, or becoming something. The heart of mindfulness is this recognition, just clearly recognize. BELLA and RAFT are supports for what to recognize, but they are not meant to get over something.
Maybe your doubt has something to do with using them as a technique, or avoiding what's really happening, or maybe you're using them too much. Sometimes you just want to sit peacefully with what is, even if it's difficult.
Regarding the archived versions of these talks, it should be on YouTube. We have a YouTube channel for IMC called Insight Med. You can get to it through the IMC website. On the YouTube channel, there's a thing called playlists. Under playlists, the Introduction to Meditation playlist should be there. On Audio Dharma, we are doing the audio recording. It should be there, but it's not in any kind of list. You have to look by my name and by the date. If you search for "hindrances," you can probably find it. I might have missed one, so there might be one talk that hasn't made it up yet.
"Thank you for differentiating the two kinds of doubt. I was not able to articulate them before. Now I feel more legitimate in having questioning doubts and testing them out."
Great.
"The guided meditations that relate to the topic each day have been helpful. How do we transition that to meditating on our own without guidance?"
Great question. You could re-listen to some of these for a while until they become a little more second nature and more familiar, so you know how to do it for yourself. Or you can alternate days: one day alone, one day with guided meditation, so that you're experimenting and exercising your ability to find your own way. Long term, you want to find your own way. Long term, you want to become your own teacher. So yes, transitioning is actually part of the process. How you do that is probably individual for each person.
If you ask yourself that question, maybe the answer will come easier if you think of this path of mindfulness as being a path of trial and error. There will be plenty of error because something didn't quite work. But try trial and error, and see what works for you. One of the principles of mindfulness meditation and Buddhism is to ask the question: "Is it helpful, what I'm doing?" And in Buddhist terminology, is it helpful in the process of becoming free?
"How does procrastination lie in the hindrances?"
I don't think I've ever thought about this, but thinking about it now, it might be interesting to look at when there's procrastination to see if any one of the hindrances underlies it. I could well imagine that aversion, or resistance, might be there. "I don't want to do that." There could be desire to enjoy the comfort of whatever I'm doing. "I don't want to leave that, I'm going to hold on to it, and that's why I don't do something which is more uncomfortable." It could be sloth and torpor. It could be there's too much restlessness to get started. Worry. And it could be that there's a lot of doubt. You might look and see what is underlying the procrastination.
"What's your recommendation for staying open with fear and not closing down during meditation? Thank you."
Going back to the question of trust, when there's a lot of fear—and some fear is really strong, some people have terror inside of them, and things happen in life that give people good reason to have very strong fear that lives in them and can be reawakened pretty easily—it takes a lot of care and wisdom. There are times when it's important to practice at the speed of trust. You don't have to go any faster than the degree to which you have trust and confidence that you can be with what's going on. Don't go deep into strong fear unless you have the trust to do that. Fear represents a lack of trust, but you only go into it at the speed of trust.
Even if it takes days, weeks, or years, take your time with it. Don't think you have to stay open to fear continuously. Sometimes it's enough, and very powerful and useful, to open to it briefly. Maybe that's okay to do, and then step away and reground oneself. Recenter oneself. Even if you have to distract yourself for a few minutes, open your eyes and look around. Come back into your body and get centered again. And then at some point when you feel like you have enough trust, confidence, and stability, then open to it again. If it's a big issue in your life, don't go for very long, just tap into it.
I've sometimes given people the instruction to imagine awareness is like soft cotton balls. Just come and tap the fear very gently, and then pull away. Over time, things might open, and it feels safer to go deeper and deeper into it. When the trust is there, then we can open more and more. Sometimes with really difficult fear, it's the fear of fear which is the big issue. So we wait until we trust that it's okay to be with a fear. In terms of paying attention to the obvious or the primary thing, sometimes what's useful is not to bring attention to what we're afraid of, or the central fear, but rather to bring mindfulness to the fear of the fear. Once that fear of the fear has quieted down, then it might be easier to be present for the central fear.
"Is it possible that you experience at the same time desire and aversion towards the same object or situation? I think it might be, and this leaves one very confused."
Yeah, I think so. Confusion is part of human life. It is easy to get confused and easy to have many multiple conflicting things going on at the same time. One could have a strong desire for a committed relationship, and a lot of aversion to it. That confusion around wanting and pulling away can be confusing for you, and it can also be confusing for the people you're with.
Confusion is not a sin, it is not a crime. What we're trying to do in mindfulness is to live an honest life. If what we really feel is confusion, really stay with that. "Oh, this is confusion." If you're in a relationship or doing something in the world where an honest relationship is what's needed, then be honest about the confusion. It might be a very different interpersonal process to talk about the confusion around desire and aversion than to talk about either one by themselves. I think people are more sympathetic if they realize you're confused.
"How to deal with delusion in general and in doubt-related thought?"
I think delusion can be treated very similarly to the practice with how I've been talking about doubt today. But to recognize delusion, it really helps to have a quiet mind. Know when your mind is not quiet, and know how to get some semblance of a quieter, more settled, more mindful mind. If your mindfulness is strong enough and your mind is quiet enough, you can see the beginning point of an arising thought. If you can see a thought when it first arises, then you're more likely to notice it is just a thought. And you can put a question mark next to it: "Is this accurate?"
For example, there can be some delusion about some other person. You have a judgment or a bias about a person. But if you can notice when that bias or judgment first comes up, there might be enough space to put a question mark. "Is this really so?" Look more carefully to see if that's the case, to see if you're operating on some kind of bias, preconceived idea, or prejudice. To just talk to someone who is spinning around in their thoughts and agitated and say, "Notice your delusion," is very hard to do. But if you practice, if you really want to get underneath and not live a deluded life, become calm. If you become calm, then you can be wise about it and see how it operates.
"Perhaps tomorrow you could address the best way to deal with our suffering sense of loss due to impermanence[4] of people, of things we love. People and things we love, we lose them. People die, things disappear."
Yeah. Sometimes the mindfulness practice is learning to be present honestly with what's there, without resistance, without clinging, without being for or against. Learning to trust just being open to it.
With the sense of loss and grief, what's best is to just let our hearts break. Sometimes this life of ours is heartbreaking. I've certainly learned through this practice to allow my heart to break many times. Sometimes it breaks many times a day. I've learned to kind of be at ease with that and to allow it. Doing so, it's kind of clean or clear. I don't get stuck in it so much. I don't see it as wrong or a mistake.
I did give a talk two days ago on Monday evening here at IMC on grief, addressing in particular what's going on with COVID-19 and the tremendous amount of grief and loss that's going on. I think many people are feeling some level of grief these days. You might want to listen to that talk, and maybe that would be helpful for you.
So this is great. I very much appreciate the questions, the thank-yous, and the little statements about how this has been useful for you. Two months ago, I never would have thought that I could be talking to a camera with the computer on and feel such warmth from all of you, along with my warmth for you, my care, my sense of connectedness, and my delight at what we're doing here and how we are together. I thank you all very much for this time and this opportunity. I look forward to being with you again tomorrow. Thank you.
Five Hindrances (Nīvaraṇa): In Buddhism, the five hindrances are mental factors that hinder progress in meditation and daily life. They are sensory desire (kāmacchanda), ill will (vyāpāda), sloth and torpor (thīna-middha), restlessness and worry (uddhacca-kukkucca), and doubt (vicikicchā). ↩︎
Seven Factors of Awakening (Bojjhaṅga): A core framework in Buddhist practice that outlines the mental qualities that lead to awakening: mindfulness, investigation, energy, joy, tranquility, concentration, and equanimity. ↩︎
RAFT and BELLA: Acronyms developed by Gil Fronsdal to aid in mindfulness practice. RAFT typically stands for Recognize, Accept, Feel, and Trust, while BELLA is another mnemonic he uses to guide practitioners through specific meditative attitudes. ↩︎
Impermanence (Anicca): A foundational Buddhist concept stating that all conditioned things are in a constant state of flux and change, and that clinging to them causes suffering (dukkha). ↩︎