Dharma in Times of Challenges
- Date:
- 2020-03-16
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-10 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Dharma in Times of Challenges
So, welcome everyone to our Monday evening talk here at IMC. I'm very happy if anybody is joining us now, or maybe listening to or watching this in the future, welcome.
And so, we are now well into a new world. This is March 16th, 2020, and a big part of the globe is now challenged with the spread of the COVID-19 virus. Here in the counties and areas where I live in the San Francisco Bay Area, we just had an announcement—or it was just proclaimed in the form of a new temporary order—that we should shelter in our homes and no longer leave except to go shopping for food or medicine, and to take care of the essentials of our life. Otherwise, we are to be homebound, with the exception of maybe going to an open space like a park to do some exercise. So, it's a radical curtailing of life as usual.
Many people now are not going to work. Many of the children in this area, their schools are closed. Many of the businesses have either closed or sent people home to work. Quite a few people are now out of work and wondering how they're going to make their rent and be able to pay for food for their families without a steady income coming in.
Some places of work have sent people home and continue to pay their salary regardless of whether they are working at home or not. It's just that this is a time when they feel that everyone has to band together, support each other, and do what we can to stretch and make this work for our friends, our colleagues, our employees, and our neighbors. And to really make this whole thing work, in a sense. For those places in the world—in Italy, Spain, China, and other places—where they've taken such radical restrictions on movement and asked people to stay at home, it's a remarkable movement or expression of how many people have to work together to create welfare for everyone. Without everyone cooperating, many people will get sick and many people will die. Even though we might not be directly affected ourselves, we're all sharing in the protection of curtailing its spread by curtailing our lives dramatically. So it's a new world that we live in.
I'm aware that some people are quite anxious. Some people are confused and distressed. Some people are quite sad at the distance they have, the lack of direct contact with family, friends, colleagues, or even neighbors, and maybe feel isolated at home.
On the other hand, some people are seeing this as an opportunity. I'm sure some people are quite happy with the idea of being home. It's not quite a coincidence, but I was starting to teach a retreat yesterday. At our retreat center, it was supposed to be a residential retreat with about 50 people, and that was canceled because we can't come together and be together in that kind of setting in this new environment. But we transferred it into being an online retreat.
Now there are about 70 people doing the online retreat, and most of the people are very local in this Bay Area. Most of them are very much affected by this new ordinance that we have to be sheltered at home. And that's exactly what they started doing yesterday: taking refuge in their homes, making their homes their meditation center, and dedicating this week as best as possible—with whatever kind of home life and situation they have—to focus on meditation practice, Dharma practice, and Dharma teachings. It's remarkable for them. In a sense, they went into retreat yesterday, and now all their neighbors everywhere are doing the same. It's not exactly a meditation retreat—the government calls it being sheltered, we call it being on retreat. People out in the wider world call it isolation, and in Buddhist language, we call it seclusion.
Seclusion is almost like a metaphor in the ancient tradition of Buddhism for meditation release: being alone, dedicated, not involved with the ordinary activities of daily life, and spending that time engaged in spiritual practice.
So there's a wide range of challenges that people have. Now, these talks that I give on Monday nights are meant to be Dharma talks. And so the question is: what is the Dharma? How does this relate to this new era, what people are struggling and challenged with? What are the opportunities in these challenges, and what are the ways to practice with it? What's the orientation we can have that is somehow supported by Dharma teachings?
The Three Trainings
As I reflect on this, I think of what are called the three trainings: sīla[1], samādhi[2], and paññā[3]—usually translated into English as ethics, meditation, and wisdom. These three trainings are the set of practices that we train ourselves in. We are developing and cultivating ourselves, and growing in them when we are involved in Dharma practice.
These are the core activities of Dharma practice. There is the activity of taking care of our ethics and living an ethical life. There is the activity of meditation and cultivating or developing our inner life. And there is the activity of cultivating and developing wisdom, which is how we understand our life. So these are activities that we can intentionally engage in. These are the basic Dharma activities with which we enter the world and try to understand how to live our life.
And so here, these three trainings become just as relevant now as at any other time, or maybe more so. We can reflect on what these three trainings look like now in this COVID-19 era. For a Buddhist, this is directly connected to how we engage in practice for the benefit of ourselves and others at this time. What does that practice look like, and how do we use this period to grow and develop?
It's also a great expression of the confidence and sense of purpose that comes with Dharma practice. We're not adrift at sea, nervous, being pushed around by the currents of life, going willy-nilly here or there, or being swept over by the tides or tidal waves of what goes on in our life. Rather, we look to see how we can meet whatever the circumstances are—no matter how difficult or how wonderful—as places to practice these three trainings.
Sīla (Ethics)
The first one, ethics, has a lot to do with two things. It has to do with not causing harm on one hand, and on the other hand, bringing benefit, supporting the welfare of others, and doing good. On the side of not causing harm, how do we live our life now in a way that doesn't contribute to harm to anyone whatsoever?
The thing that stands out for me right now in this area—I don't know what's happening so much in terms of hoarding in other parts of the world, but here in the United States, there are some places where people are rushing to the supermarkets and emptying the shelves. I've been through some of these supermarkets and remarkably seen row after row of empty shelves. Before, in this wealthy country that we have, the cornucopia of choices and abundance of goods for sale in these huge supermarkets was remarkable, and to see them empty is quite something.
One of the things I went to look for and buy was a certain kind of over-the-counter medicine, and that was completely gone. Certainly, we were asked to stay indoors and shelter for the next three weeks here in the area. So ideally, if we had bought enough food for those three weeks so we didn't have to go out so much, that would be fine. But there are people who are buying enough supplies to last a year. When people buy up supplies, there are necessities for others that disappear. For example, if you don't really need a certain over-the-counter medication right now, but you buy a year's supply, then there are people who come along who do need it, and it's not available.
When there's hoarding way beyond what's needed as a way of protecting ourselves for a long time, and a lot of people do this, then the vulnerable in our society—the people who can't get to the supermarkets or stores, or maybe who don't have the money to buy huge stockpiles of food—are left scrambling unnecessarily. These essential supplies in this country of ours are not going to run out that easily, but they will run out in the short term for some people. In terms of not causing harm, we should think a little bit about how we are behaving. What are we shopping for? What are we doing? We shouldn't just think about ourselves, but think of it in the aggregate of many other people who are doing the same as we are. Do we succumb to the herd mentality and just do what everybody else is doing, or do we try in small ways to mitigate some of the unnecessary harmful side effects of how people behave in this time and place?
But then there are people who are thinking about, "What can I do that's good?" There are our neighbors now who are thinking, "Can I go shopping for you? I'm going to the store, could I get something for you?" Or we can share what we have if we need things. And so there's the idea that we are also here to support each other, and how do we help each other?
When I went to the market on Saturday, I was struck by how there was much more mutual care in the supermarket aisles. I had the feeling that people were more caring, more friendly, and more supportive in that environment. I didn't feel like they were hoarding or greedy. I felt that they were acquiring what they needed, but I also felt that there wasn't a sense of competition or a sense of "I need to get it more than somebody else."
My wife went to the market today, and she saw someone with a big basket full of squash. She thought, "Oh yes, squash is a good idea, that'll keep for a long time." She went to the squash counter and there was no squash left. Coincidentally, she was standing next to the woman who had bought them, and they had a conversation. My wife mentioned there was no squash left, and the woman happily gave her a squash. So, you know, these are small little steps, but do we want to live in a world where we're making it harder for people, or do we want to make a world where we're supporting people and being generous with people?
This has to do with ethics. Ethics as a training, as a practice, is not about doing the moral thing necessarily. It's not about some external rules that we have to follow to be a good person. If that's the only reason you do this, it actually doesn't train the heart. Sīla, the ethical training in Buddhism, is supposed to train your heart. It cultivates your heart, develops the goodness of your heart, expands your heart, and makes it bigger. It nourishes your inner life, so that as you look into yourself, you see these beautiful qualities of being that you're happy to have, that you're inspired to have, that you feel delighted to have. This is what the Buddha called a form of wealth; that's the wealth to have. That's what we want to acquire and develop: qualities like generosity, being harmless, being compassionate, being caring, being supportive of other people, and making room for people.
So if a person wants to be engaged in Buddhist training in the Dharma, they'll be thinking about this. They'll be thinking about the ethics of it, thinking about how they might be able to reduce the amount of harm they cause, or what they can do to bring benefit to others. It's a beautiful reflection, and may it be so. May all of us support others.
Samādhi (Meditation)
The training in meditation is also a training in developing these inner qualities and capacities we have, but it's directly involved with that, rather than indirectly. By sitting down in meditation and doing inner practices, we cultivate the heart and mind so that the inner life becomes beautiful and inspiring. The inner life becomes a place you go—you go inside, reach deep inside of yourself, really touch into what's deep inside and who you are on the inside, and what you find in there makes you happy, makes your heart sing. This is good.
It's not an easy thing to come to for many people—certainly it wasn't for me. To dip inside, reach deep inside, and start seeing what's there can be quite difficult. There can be anger, grief, sadness, fear, and terror. There can be distress and feelings of shame, and all kinds of things housed inside. These are not problems for the purposes of Buddhist meditation. They are the food, the fuel, or the basis of what we're practicing with. We're trying to meet these things with the best qualities of heart that we can evoke. We're trying to meet the challenges in our hearts with kindness and compassion. We try to meet the challenges we have without shaming or belittling ourselves for having them, but instead holding them with mindfulness, being mindful of them, and not critical of them.
The image I have for what mindfulness is for the difficult material in our hearts is that of cupping our hands together and holding our difficulty, holding our fear, holding our shame. Just gently holding it in cupped, soft hands. Gently offering support, holding it, and just being with it. Not trying to make it go away, not to fix it, and not to condemn it, but simply letting it be seen and held in this supportive embrace of awareness.
It's remarkable what that does. Things begin to thaw, things begin to open. Things begin to come alive, unfold, or resolve simply because they're seen, held, and respected in a good way. And so, we're developing our mindfulness as we meet these difficulties. We're developing our capacity and courage to be present for what's difficult. We're developing our capacity for focus and concentration—staying present, not drifting off in thoughts. We're developing our capacity to let go.
So when thoughts, distractions, unhealthy reflections, ideas, and fantasies come along, we're not trapped by them or caught by them. We know how to recognize them, we know how to let go of them, and we know how to come back. Slowly over time, we're cultivating and developing an inner life so our inner life becomes healed, whole, and settled. It becomes a place that is good to abide in. It can become our home, from which we then look at the world with different eyes.
Paññā (Wisdom)
Looking at the world with different eyes is the domain of the third training: wisdom. Wisdom is coming to a new understanding of this life of ours, to see it in ways that maybe we didn't understand growing up, or ways we somehow acquired in the process of our life so far. It is to see our life and understand it from the perspective of one that's not selfish, not self-absorbed, and not limited or contracted by self-preoccupation.
When we're mindful of "selfing"—self-preoccupation, being self-absorbed, self-concerned—there's nothing to be ashamed about. It's something that can be seen, held, and minded. But as we really feel into and are present for the self-involvement and self-attachment that is so common in human life, we'll start seeing the limitations of it. We'll start seeing the pain of it, the stress of it. And if we really hold it kindly, it'll begin to soften and dissolve, and we start seeing that there's much more. There's a different perspective on our life.
There's this way of seeing the world and seeing this psychophysical being that we are that's freed of self-preoccupations, self-entanglement, and self-absorption. It's a remarkable thing to relax, open up, and have the forces of fear, greed, or conceit—which reinforce and strengthen this brittle sense of self—begin to soften and dissolve. We can just as well take care of ourselves without the self-absorption. Actually, we can take care of ourselves better the less self-absorbed and contracted we are. To start seeing the world in a new way is part of the wisdom teachings of Buddhism.
The other thing is to begin understanding how suffering arises in us, to really begin understanding the operating system of suffering, or the elements, the ecology of our suffering. In particular, to understand the nature of clinging, craving, and attachment, how those work in our minds, hearts, and bodies, and how they contribute to suffering.
It's kind of a truism in Buddhism that if you crave, you will suffer. You can't get away from it if you're craving. Partly because craving itself—this compulsive desire that has us by the nose or by the throat—is a state where there's contraction, force, and pressure. We can't just let go of it; it kind of has us, rather than us having it. We can have desire, but craving is this powerful desire that has us, and we end up doing things that later we regret, or when we have wisdom, we realize wasn't a wise thing to do. Craving can be subtle, yet still powerful.
And so, part of the wisdom aspect of Buddhism is to develop the sensitivity[4] to see clearly what is going on in the ecology of suffering. Can we notice and see craving? Can we notice and see clinging as it occurs? Not to condemn it, not to feel shame for being that way—of course we have it, we're human, and unless people practice, it's very hard to become free of it. But it is possible to become free, and the beginning of that is to have a new understanding, a new perspective. One that sees that there's also non-clinging, finding the heart's capacity for non-craving, and the two, in a sense, can live side by side inside of us.
If we really know how to connect, feel, see, and be mindful of craving, then we can start looking beyond the edges of it, looking underneath it or above it, and see that it's not the whole show. There's more; we're much more than the craving. There's much more here than the contracted forms of clinging and what we're attached to and want. To be able to open up the field of awareness, to see that there are other things happening here—there's the whole body, the heart, the emotions, the space, the mindfulness. And just the mindfulness itself.
If we can be clearly mindful of clinging, then we are not defined by the clinging. We can say we have clinging, but we are not the clinging. When the clinging and the craving are really strong and compulsive and have taken over, then in a sense, we are clinging. That kind of defines us, if that's where we rest and are centered. But if we're no longer centered in it and we find another center—a center of non-clinging, non-craving, which is the nature of mindfulness. It's right there in the mindfulness. In that kind of awareness practice of mindfulness, there isn't any clinging or craving in it when mindfulness is clear.
And to be able to separate these two out, so that on one hand we can see the cravings we have, and on the other hand we really are mindful of it. It's a little bit like being in the middle of a group of people—maybe we're standing around having a big argument about something, and everyone's yelling, screaming, and talking at once, and we're part of all that. But at some point, it occurs to us to step four, five, or ten feet away and look back at them. We see that they're still arguing, but we are not, and it's clear that we're not in the argument; we're just observing it. The same thing happens with mindfulness. We can metaphorically step back from what we're caught up and entangled in, to the point where we can just see it: "Now, that's what's happening. I'm afraid, I'm preoccupied, I'm worried, I am fantasizing. I'm thinking about imaginary futures, and entangled in what might come and what might happen. And that's what's happening."
In that stepping back and saying, "Oh, that's what's happening," begins a new perspective. That's an understanding that belongs to the wisdom side of the training—to see clearly what's happening. As we see clearly our clinging, we see the relationship between clinging and our suffering. We start seeing that the absence of clinging is the absence of suffering.
Bringing Practice to Challenge
So, there are three trainings: there's a training in what we do, a training in how we are, and a training in how we see and what we understand. When we live in times of challenges, if we want to bring our Buddhist practice to bear on the circumstances—whatever our challenges are—we can ask ourselves three questions:
What is it that I can do at this time that avoids causing harm and brings benefit to myself and others?
How can I be in this time of challenge? How can I focus on developing inside of me, cultivating good qualities, developing the heart and mind, and bringing forth what's best in me, rather than succumbing to what's not the best?
And then for wisdom, how can I step back and see this from a new perspective? How can I have the mindfulness and steady attention so that I'm not pulled into the argument, not swept up and caught up in the experience, but really step back, get the broader view, or see clearly? This way, I have a perspective that is freeing, a perspective where I find some ease and peace with what's going on, rather than being agitated, preoccupied, and uneasy with it all. To really bring the Dharma to our challenges like this often takes a lot of dedication. It takes courage. It takes a real conviction that this is worthwhile to do.
If there are a lot of people around us who feel anxious, upset, and angry, sometimes they expect us to share that with them. There's a strong sense of needing to conform to how other people are feeling and what's going on, and they might even feel disturbed if we're not like them—if we're discovering how to be calm and centered and trying to see the situation from a different perspective.
So it takes some care, some courage, and really relying on our faith, conviction, and confidence to step forth and do the practice. If you're not interested in doing Dharma practice, or if it's not clear to you that Dharma practice is relevant to what's going on, no one's here to argue that you should practice the Dharma in these circumstances. Trust that you use your wisdom the best you can. You know what you should do. But the Dharma is good. It is said that the Dharma is good in the beginning, good in the middle, and good at the end. The word that the Buddha used for that "good" is kalyāṇa[5], which also means beautiful.
The Dharma is beautiful in the beginning, the Dharma is beautiful in the middle, and Dharma practice is good at the end. I hope that you bring forth your beauty, and you use this time of COVID-19 to bring forth and discover. Use this time, especially if you're sheltered or on retreat in your own home and can't go out. This is a time to cultivate and develop the Dharma, and support yourself.
Sīla: A Pali word commonly translated as "ethics," "morality," or "virtue." ↩︎
Samādhi: A Pali word referring to concentration, meditation, or mental discipline. ↩︎
Paññā: A Pali word translated as "wisdom" or "insight." ↩︎
Correction: The original transcript contained the phrase "sytze village," which has been corrected to "sensitivity" based on context. ↩︎
Kalyāṇa: A Pali word meaning "beautiful," "good," "auspicious," or "noble." ↩︎