Intimacy
- Date:
- 2019-05-26
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-10 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Intimacy
The topic for today is intimacy. It's a topic which Western Dharma teachers have picked up on quite a bit. Among Western Dharma teachers, especially in Zen, they love the saying that to be awakened is to be intimate with all things. The other thing they like to say in Zen is, "Not knowing is most intimate." If we know too much and we come with our preconceived ideas, we can't really know what's directly here. I think this idea of "not knowing is most intimate" is an interesting perspective from which to look at Dharma practice.
I'll talk a little bit first about some of my own experience with this topic, and then at the heart of the talk, I'll say some things which are maybe not specifically Buddhist. Finally, I'll bring it back to a Buddhist perspective on the value of intimacy at the end.
I think of intimacy as having two major elements. It might be interesting for each of you to consider how you use the term, if it has any value for you, or even if it has no value at all. For me, intimacy involves knowing something well, and in that knowing, not having any barriers. Some people might say that intimacy involves feeling a deep connection with something. I think that's nice, but I prefer to say "with no barriers to the knowing." When you talk about being deeply connected, it's too easy to slide over into thinking we should be connected, or that we're supposed to be a certain way. Whereas if you express the idea of no barriers to connection, then whatever is supposed to happen—where there's no static, where nothing gets in the way—can happen freely on its own. Who knows what it's supposed to look like? Maybe it doesn't have to look like being deeply connected.
Intimacy with Oneself
For me, discovering some of the value of what I call intimacy probably began most clearly with sitting meditation. It was in Zen meditation specifically where I started to know myself in deeper ways, and feel a kind of intimacy with myself—with my feelings, thoughts, and emotions. I felt an intimacy with my inner life in a way that I had never known when I was younger. It felt very rich and satisfying to be connected. Even if what was being known was not very pleasant, it still felt very precious to be in touch with it, to really experience it and let it be there without any hindrance or barrier.
This is represented by an experience I had at the Zen monastery Tassajara. When you first go there to be part of a three-month intensive practice period of meditation, as is the custom in Japan, there's a rite of passage you have to pass in order to enter the monastery. This rite of passage involves sitting in the meditation hall for five to ten days without moving. Three times a day you were given a meal, and you could turn around in your seat because all the meals were eaten in the meditation hall. After the meal, you had a half-hour break, and then you had to go back and sit. There were no bells; you just had to sit until the next meal. If you really needed to move or go to the bathroom, you could, but the custodian of the meditation hall decided how long you sat. If they saw you going to the bathroom often or fidgeting a lot, it was going to be longer rather than shorter.
I did this twice; I had to do it in Japan as well, where it was seven to fourteen days. In Japan, you had to prove your sincerity first. You show up at the monastery gates and stand out there however long it takes to prove your sincerity. You just stand there, and at some point, they feel, "Okay, this person is serious, let him come in." Then you go to the first little anteroom right next to the main entryway where you get to sit for seven to fourteen days.
This is a long way of saying that it was pretty painful not moving for a long period of time. When I was at Tassajara, there were three of us doing it together, sitting in a row. In order to cope, I had to really come to terms and be present with the leg pain I had. I had to be very attentive to what was going on so that fear, aversion, despair, and self-pity didn't get the upper hand. I learned quickly that if I had self-pity, the muscles over my knee would ever so slightly contract, and it would hurt more. If I had no self-pity, it wouldn't hurt as bad. I preferred not hurting so bad, so I had to watch what was going on in my mind very carefully. I saw that what I thought about affected my relationship to the pain, which affected how much at ease or disease I had with it.
Because it was five to ten days, having to be meticulous with watching my mind in order to survive meant I had never been so closely in touch with myself. I didn't know how long it was going to be. At some point, I was sitting there in the meditation hall and I felt fingers tapping me on the back of my shoulder, and I knew it was over. I started crying, because I thought, "I'll never be this intimate with myself ever again, because who would put themselves through that on purpose?"
What I discovered, though, is that you don't have to sit in pain to have that intimacy. As my meditation practice continued and I learned to be more meticulous in being present, it was like a window opened. I could see all the subtle movements of my mind, my emotions, and my feelings. As I got quieter and stiller, it felt more intimate, detailed, and deep. It felt so good to be deeply in touch with myself.
As I did that, I saw the forces that would come up in me where I would lose that intimacy—where I would start thinking about things, reacting, or getting involved in my preferences or dislikes. I could actually feel how I left that close connectedness. That was a powerful teacher for me. The more I knew how to be at ease in a deep peace with myself, the more it became a teacher for me to see how I reacted and pulled away from it.
Meditating with Others
The other thing that happened in those Zen days was sitting in seven-day sesshins[1]. We would sit in the meditation hall for seven days, sitting just a couple of inches apart in a row facing the wall. In Zen, you meditate with your eyes open. What I started to discover was that sitting next to someone for seven days, I would be aware—without trying to be—of their breathing. Out of the side of my eyes, I could see their chest or belly moving, how they sat, and when they were struggling or crying, or when they were really clear and still.
Especially with the breathing, I felt such intimacy with those people. I felt I knew them better than if I'd spent seven days talking to them. Talking teaches you something about people, but there's something deeper about meditating with someone. They're touching into deeper parts of themselves, and there were less barriers for me to take it in. I felt very precious about the people I sat next to. It wasn't done intentionally; it came from the openness, the clarity, and the presence of sitting there.
Intimacy in Daily Life
One of the great insights I had as a meditator is that my mind is essentially the same mind in meditation and outside of meditation. The inner life I carry with me is the same everywhere. To have a higher quality of mind and heart in meditation and not have it outside of meditation is to live a divided life. It became very clear to me: why should I have this freedom, intimacy, poignancy, and integrity in meditation and let it remain there?
That realization shifted my focus from just doing meditation to trying to discover how to have that depth of contact with myself in the world around me. That was what motivated me to live at the Zen Center—not to do more meditation, but to be in an environment where I could learn to extend what I was discovering into the rest of my life, my work, and my conversations.
An important place for me was working in the monastery kitchen. I learned how much I was not really present for my daily activities. I had a lot of preferences, things I wanted to do and didn't want to do. I wasn't really there with chopping the carrots. The carrots became part of my important monastic teachers. I would spend months chopping vegetables, and sometimes I didn't want to be there so much that I had my body turned around facing the door, chopping sideways. I would notice this and turn my body back so it was just me and the carrot. I'd notice my mind taking me away, and just like sitting with the pain in the rite of passage, I had to really be there with the carrot. I had to know myself well and not give in to all the highways and byways of the mind.
I became more intimate with myself, but I also felt very intimate with the carrots. Maybe that sounds funny—"What did you accomplish after years of Buddhist practice, Gil? Intimacy with carrots!" [Laughter] But those carrots represent a lot of different things you can really be present for. Zen training was largely about bringing this presence, attention, and fullness to each thing you do, which is another way of describing being intimate with each thing you do. I felt this intimacy and care with the carrots, with washing pots, with sweeping the grounds.
Intimacy with People
Then there was the challenge of people. Sometimes meditation is a lot easier than being with people. What is it to be intimate with people, and what barriers did I have to being present in a caring way without any barriers? I started to experiment with how I talked with people. Am I really present for them, or am I more involved in my reactions, preferences, and negotiating to have an impact on them?
I learned a lot about myself, and it was rather humbling. One of the first things I learned in the kitchen was how much I wanted to be liked. I noticed how much I was constantly doing social gymnastics to get everyone to like me. I was the kitchen manager, and there were sometimes a dozen people working in the pressure cooker of a monastery kitchen—not the ideal place to try to get everyone to like you. Doing those social gymnastics was very stressful. I learned that the desire to be liked interfered with being really present for the person I was with; it interfered with intimacy. I probably thought that if people liked me, we could be intimate, but that was mostly just my veil of desires. I had to let go of the desire to be liked in order to have real intimacy, which is perhaps counterintuitive.
Three Channels of Intimacy
I want to talk about three approaches, or channels, in which intimacy occurs. These might not necessarily be Buddhist, but hopefully, they have some universal value.
The first channel is feeling intimate with someone else because you know them well. Some people will share their life story, their situation, or what they're going through, and you feel really connected to them. You feel like, "Wow, there's a real intimacy here because I know so much about them." This can be a very satisfying feeling. However, it can become dysfunctional in helping professions, like therapists or Dharma teachers. People tell them deep, personal aspects of their life, and the teacher feels connected. But if that's the only place they have intimacy—using their role for that closeness—it isn't so healthy.
The second channel is feeling intimate because someone else knows you well. It's the feeling of being understood and seen. To really feel like you've been seen and understood can be very satisfying. Some people crave that, and it's the only kind of intimacy they know. They aren't really interested in other people; they just want to share themselves so they can be experienced by someone else. Being known with care, respect, and safety is deeply meaningful.
The third channel is being intimate with oneself. When it's quiet enough, and you don't have the static in your mind interfering with recognizing what's going on, you start knowing and feeling deeply. In meditation, the stillness is not for the purpose of being still, but so there's no static to obscure the deeper impulses, feelings, desires, fears, and beliefs that we have.
These three channels can work together. If you're trying to really understand someone else and support them through something challenging, it takes a lot of intimacy with oneself. You have to be able to tune into your own feelings, sensations, beliefs, and history to resonate with them. We take someone in through deeper places inside, not simply with our rational minds. The greater capacity we have for sensing and feeling in ourselves, the deeper we can sense the fullness of someone else. I think it's ideal to know intimacy through all three channels, because then the doors of knowing and awareness are equally open in all directions.
The Buddhist Perspective on Intimacy
What is the Buddhist approach to these three channels? The heart of Buddhism is learning how to be free—free of attachments, clinging, resistance, and the barriers we have to being intimate. If we use the deeper intimacy we experience as the material for our practice, we are going to recognize, "Oh, here I am stuck. Here I am being reactive. Here my preferences are operating. Here I have a desire for intimacy, and lo and behold, that desire is interfering with being intimate. Here I have a desire to run away or protect myself."
When you really feel and understand what is going on in this deeper way, the process of being intimate is not just for intimacy's sake, but for the sake of freedom. Discovering greater ease in relationship to other people is a fascinating process. As people get to know each other deeply, those very close relationships are often driven by a lot of attachment. It's hard to find a relationship where we don't have attachments to our preferences and desires. Sometimes the more intimate people are, the deeper the subtle expectations and attachments operate. Intimacy by itself doesn't always come attachment-free; sometimes people are intimate because they share the same attachment.
To discover how to be free—not trying to get everyone to like you, or trying to get approval, love, status, or safety from a relationship—but to stay open and meet someone else in that openness, is one of the great delights of Buddhist practice. In the Zen tradition, the ability to meet another practitioner mind-to-mind or heart-to-heart in that field of freedom is considered ideal. They use it as a reference point for discovering how free you really are.
It's possible to feel free in a limited way when you're alone in meditation. But then you run into people and discover you're not so free! Jack Kornfield tells a wonderful story of meeting one of the famous Sufi masters who was living here in the West, Idries Shah[2]. He said something like, "You take almost any of the great spiritual masters from Asia who seem so wonderfully enlightened, and you put them in an American suburb with kids, a dog, work, a mortgage, and leaking plumbing under the sink, and they're going to be challenged."
Bringing the practice to our relationships to discover how to have this freedom, clarity, and no barriers is an explicit part of the work in some schools of Zen. They have a wonderful saying—and it looks like a cliché: "Only between a Buddha and a Buddha." It means that something about the nature of practice can only happen in relationship to other people. When you go to a Zen teacher for a formal interview, it stops being a place you go for advice, and becomes a place you go to meet from the depth of your practice. You show up and be your practice, and the teacher be's her practice. You see what kind of meeting happens there—is it static-free? Is it attachment-free?
Exploring intimacy can be very satisfying, but it's also a great help for Buddhist practice. As we explore how to become freer in our relationships, this practice purifies and clarifies our intimacy, making it safer. If the intimacy we feel is used as a field of practice—looking at the static, looking at the attachments, and feeling our way to greater freedom—the process of intimacy is protected. There is a wonderful reciprocal relationship: intimacy supports the practice, and the practice supports intimacy.
My hope with this talk is not to have taught you something, but rather to have evoked something in you. I hope it evokes a reflection on your own relationship to intimacy. What is your relationship to it? Does it have a role in your life? Do you tend to feel intimacy more through knowing others, being known by others, or knowing yourself?
Intimacy can be quite frightening, so you don't have to be intimate whatsoever! But before the potluck, it would be great if you would turn to one or two people next to you and just say hello and share your name. If that's as far as you want to go, great. But you might want to say something safe about this theme today, whether it was evocative, interesting, or challenging for you.
Thank you for being here.
Sesshin: A period of intensive meditation in a Zen monastery, often lasting several days. Original transcript mistranscribed as "oisin". ↩︎
Idries Shah: A prominent teacher and author in the Sufi tradition who helped introduce Sufism to the West. Original transcript mistranscribed as "he drew Shah". ↩︎