Paññā (2 of 5) Distinguishing Wisdom
- Date:
- 2020-04-14
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-10 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Paññā (2 of 5) Distinguishing Wisdom
This will be the second talk on the faculty of wisdom. It is a part of the field of wisdom to be motivated to understand, to be propelled or inspired, or to have no other choice but to engage in the practice of becoming free of suffering. Suffering, in one way or the other, is the cauldron fire for which practice, the interest in mindfulness, and concentration—showing up, being present—arises as we begin to practice. A very important function or capacity of wisdom, of paññā[1], is that as we get clearer, as we are more mindful, we start making distinctions. There is distinguishing wisdom. This is not a wisdom that is highly sophisticated, but it's the wisdom that arises out of our clarity of mind, where we are able to see not just a big buzzing, confused event of the moment, but we can start seeing clearly the different elements that make it up.
For example, if I'm sitting, practicing, or just being, and I feel terrible—I guess it's terrible if I'm feeling terrible—but "terrible" is a very vague way to say something. It points to something, but it's a very vague category. If I settle, get a little bit quieter, and start paying attention to what's going on, I can start distinguishing that part of it involves physical experiences of maybe contraction and tension, part of it involves certain kinds of thinking, and some of it involves certain emotions that are present. To be able to tease apart, to distinguish these different component parts of being "terrible," gives me a handle on the experience. It gives me something to be more attentive to, to find some freedom in relationship to it. The word "terrible," the concept of it, is a little bit hard to even know what that means, where to start, or how to relate to that experience. But as the mind's capacity to see clearly develops, we start distinguishing.
If I can see that a part of my terribleness is tension in the body, then I'll have the opportunity to bring careful attention to that tension. Maybe I've noticed there's tension in the shoulders, and so I relax my shoulders. Then my whole terrible feeling, the gestalt of it all, begins to shift and maybe quiet down a little bit. Or maybe I noticed that I'm feeling really sad, and I hadn't really noticed that I was sad. But when I really see, "Oh, this is sadness," something releases. "Oh, yes, that's what it is." Maybe I'm not unconsciously pulling away from the sadness and the discomfort of it. In recognizing it, I kind of say, "Oh, that's what's happening." There's more of a settling, and then this gestalt that I call terrible begins to change and be a little different.
Then I notice my thinking. I'm thinking about some of the comments you wrote here about background noise. I'm having all these thoughts about background noise, what I should do, and what I should say. I say to myself, "Oh, that's the kind of thought I have. I'll just explain it." Probably what you heard today was garbage collection day. If it was intermittent, the sound you heard was quite loud—the garbage trucks, and there was more banging of garbage cans today than I've ever heard. I don't know if that was the issue, but we'll find out. [unintelligible] I'll look into it. So I see the thoughts, and the thoughts quiet down. Slowly, by making distinctions, I start being able to see that I also have some choices.
The greater the distinctions we make about what's going on, the greater choice we have about what our experience is and how we relate to it. This idea of how we relate to our experience is also part of this distinguishing quality of wisdom. There are always two things happening in broad categories: there is what's happening, and there is how we relate to that experience. There might be something uncomfortable happening, and in relationship to that discomfort, there might be fear about it, blame, anger, irritation, distress, or judgments and ideas about it. The experience and the relationship to it are two separate things. We might not be able to change the experience, but we might have some choice with how we relate to it, what we think about it, and how we feel about it. Maybe we could just not be so judgmental, or maybe we don't have to be so afraid, so glued to it, attacking it, or entangled with it. We can see that there is the experience, and then there are ideas about the experience. Some of those ideas might be true, and some of them might not be so true. But we see, "Oh, here's the experience, and here's my idea."
For instance, here's a person that I'm seeing, and here are my ideas about that person. It turns out that person looks like one of my elementary school teachers who was really scary, and the reason I feel afraid of this person might be because of this idea that I associated with my elementary school teacher. To see that on one hand there's my whole inner experience of association, and on the other there's the person—making that distinction means we can make a choice. We can see there's nothing about that person, really. I can choose to look at the person more carefully, or I can tend to look at myself more carefully. This ability to make distinctions and then to make choices is a very important part of the wisdom factor of practice. As we begin being able to make very simple choices, we reach the heart of distinguishing wisdom: being able to distinguish between that which is healthy and that which is unhealthy. In Buddhist language, this is called skillful or unskillful, wholesome or unwholesome, that which is helpful and that which is not helpful. We become our own teachers in our ability to make distinctions.
So I could see that my judgments and fear around the person who looks like my elementary school teacher, having that kind of preoccupation that's not necessarily accurate about the person I'm with, is not so healthy, not so skillful, and not so helpful. Now I can choose to do something skillful. I can be careful about what I say, I can be careful about what I think, or how I relate to my view of that person.
We sit in meditation and we start making distinctions, but not by actively analyzing or trying to figure it all out. As the mind gets quieter and becomes clearer, as we see more clearly what's here, it's a natural functioning of the mind to make distinctions. As it quiets down, we'll see more clearly, "Oh, there's this and there's that." At some point, as the settling comes in, we see that there's this and there's that. If I keep thinking about—I'm trying to think of something silly that maybe would be painful to keep thinking about—but if I keep thinking about all my anger at the fact that someone left a little bit of trash outside of IMC on the sidewalk, and I keep thinking and repeating it, and I find myself getting more irritated, maybe that's not a skillful or helpful train of thought when I'm meditating. Maybe the skillful thing to do is to acknowledge my irritation, my annoyance, and to acknowledge my concern that there's a need to keep the place a little bit clean and cared for during this shelter-at-home time. Now that I've acknowledged it, maybe the skillful thing to do is to settle in and breathe with the sense of tension that I'm feeling because of thinking about the trash. So I sit there and feel, and that's a skillful thing to do. That's a good thing to do. I'm not denying it, I'm not criticizing being this way, but I'm finding a skillful, helpful way to be with it.
Distinguishing wisdom recognizes that there's almost a natural capacity, independent of doing a lot of analytical thinking. Maybe a little bit is used sometimes, but this wonderful capacity to distinguish also relates to how we do the distinguishing. If we keep making distinctions and it makes us tense and agitated, then it's not so skillful to keep doing it. Maybe we need to find a calmer way to do it, or wait for another time to do it that will come later. Or maybe we can find a way to very gently make distinctions that help us become more settled, calm, and quiet.
I'll end with this: one of the distinctions that is possible to make is distinguishing between different ways of thinking. We can distinguish different tones of voice in which to think, different speeds in which to think, different colors in which to think, or different images to settle into, if we think a lot with images. Rather than it being an either/or of whether we're thinking, it's possible to begin thinking in wiser ways or more supportive ways for meditation. We make the distinction between ways in which we think. If we can choose ways that help us be more settled and become clearer, and help the clarity make even further supported distinctions, then we're riding and being supported by our capacity for wisdom.
Because this distinguishing wisdom can seem to be very intellectual, remember that we're talking about a form of wisdom that really follows on the foundation of our body, our being grounded, and on our faith, energy, mindfulness, and concentration. Don't be in a hurry to do distinguishing wisdom. Just use what's available that's supportive for you.
May distinguishing wisdom support you and all beings. Thank you very much.
Paññā: A Pali word typically translated as "wisdom," "knowledge," or "insight." It refers to the intuitive grasping of the true nature of reality. ↩︎