Moon Pointing

Viriya (5 of 5) Effortless Effort

Date:
2020-03-27
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-09 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Viriya (5 of 5) Effortless Effort

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Viriya (5 of 5) Effortless Effort

Continuing on this week's theme of the energy factor, the effort factor of the five faculties[1]. The last aspect of the effort faculty might be called effortless effort. There comes a time when it just feels like what is carrying us in meditation, what's carrying us in our life, is a very wholesome and healthy momentum, effort, engagement, aliveness, and vitality that doesn't seem to be something we are making effort to do. So, in that sense, it's effortless from the point of view of our work. But, it might take a lot of calories or something. Something is happening, something's working.

The analogy that I have for this is when I used to run a lot. I remember that when I began running the first 50, 100 feet at least, there would be these signals coming out of my body that were basically saying, "Stop. Don't do this. This is too difficult." And I just kind of ran anyway, knowing that I didn't have to listen to those. Some of it was maybe just making that effort was unpleasant. But then as I began running and kept going and going, I would get into the groove. I would get into the rhythm of running. And it would feel like at some point that the running was effortless. It was just the body was running. Running was running itself. And it was a great joy. And I'm sure I was expending a lot of calories. So, there was a lot of energy being expended. But the involvement, the harmony, the attunement, the relaxing into it, the rhythm of it, it felt just effortless. It was just happening on its own.

And I think a lot of activities can be that way. Maybe sports can be that feeling sometimes, or maybe playing an instrument or doing something that we enjoy and really get absorbed in doing. The same thing can happen in meditation. We really give ourselves wholeheartedly to it and just really place ourselves in the middle of our experience, and really, this is what we're doing. It is not an easy task. Meditation is harder than things which grab our interest and are fascinating in and of themselves. But that's part of the benefit of meditation, is that we're discovering how to really be present, really be here in a full, complete way without needing the extra help of fascinating things, interesting things, things which bring us a lot of joy or some kind of satisfaction. Or things which are dangerous, and so we're really engaged and very nicely present because there's just the right amount of danger. But we're doing this with just being very simple and ordinary and working through all the different activities of the mind and the heart that get in the way of just that full embodiment of being here in a simple way. Not chasing after what interests us or our desires, or running away from what we don't want. Just here. It's a difficult task, but to have that full embodiment and presence in meditation is that when it really happens, that becomes effortless effort. It just feels like we're just here.

And that's a wonderful stage of meditation. It's very satisfying in and of itself. And it creates a wonderful platform for deeper and deeper layers of letting go. If there's something besides us operating, if it's effortless, then it becomes clear that the ego, the self-identity, the contraction around self, and me being the agent, is not needed as much, and we are loosening up this tight grip that the self has on us. This effortless effort space can just help us to relax and soften that.

And this topic of effort that we've done this week, there are many perspectives on it, but one of the interesting perspectives is that it is just an ongoing process of letting go. And with letting go comes benefits. Something arises. So, you could talk about what arises and what comes into place as we practice. But it's nice because the end of the path in Buddhism is a very deep form of letting go, release. It's kind of interesting to go back over these five days to see how each of these steps represents a kind of letting go.

Initiating effort is the effort where we have to let go of something that we're doing in order to start fresh, start new, start now. So, even if it's just starting to meditate, to go sit down to meditate, we have to let go of some of the activities of the day that we're doing. Stop looking at emails, stop doing something or other, and then sit down. So, we're letting go of something in daily life to sit down and be here. Once we're here, the initiating effort is to let go of the stream of thinking that we're caught up in and involved in that interferes or makes it impossible to really be present in a full way. So, the initiating effort involves a letting go of some degree of preoccupation.

As we settle down further, then there is this right endeavor aspect of effort, where we can differentiate between what is healthy, wholesome, helpful to be involved in and what is not. And then we let go of what is unhealthy, unwholesome. And that letting go, even if it's not actively pushing it away or letting go of it—if it's just letting it be in a field of friendly awareness—what we're letting go of is our clinging to it. Our involvement with it. And that's maybe enough. So, the thoughts we might be having might still be there, but we hold them in a very broad mind where we're not actually involved anymore. And so, there's a kind of letting go there, and then some of the wholesome things that arise, sometimes just arise on their own. This gets to the third effort, which is persistent effort, persistent relaxed effort; that also is a kind of letting go of the things that come along that want to pull us out of the flow of the practice.

It's possible to notice a thought arise and be so attentive you see the beginning of interest in it and the mind says, "No, thank you." And you stay in the flow of awareness. Another thing comes, "No, thank you." Stay in the flow of awareness. When I've really been in that flow of awareness, there were times where I felt that there was a rubber band attached to my thoughts. And if my thoughts would kind of wander off, because I was wandering off with my thoughts, the rubber band would get stretched and at some point they would just pull me right back into the present moment. And so this kind of effort—keep coming back, keep coming back—involves some letting go.

And then this Dharma[2] energy that can arise, that's something else beginning to carry us and to move through us. And letting go of what interferes with that, letting go of maybe the idea that I have to do it, that it's always up to me and me, myself, and mine, but making space for something to move. We let go of what crowds the space. We let go of the idea of "I'm in charge here" and allow the Dharma energy to begin to move through us.

And then this effortless effort is a place where there can be a lot of letting go of the same thing, of self. Effortless effort is almost like a variation or continuation of this Dharma energy that can arise. But, it also can come to a place of a lot of equanimity, a lot of non-reactivity, a lot of non-resistance, non-preference, non-attachment that goes on. And we get a feeling for this kind of equanimity and non-attachment that now we are very sensitive to the subtlest movements of attachment. And to really allow this effortless effort to kind of flower, there's even more letting go, more letting go.

And then at some point the benefit of really getting in the stream of effortless effort of equanimity is that the forms of release of letting go which correspond to awakening in Buddhism are not something that we can do. It's not something we can say, "Okay, now I'm going to be awake. Now I'm going to let go once and for all in a deep way." It's something where there has to be a lot of not self, a lot of non-involvement, a lot of non-reactivity, a lot of not making anything, creating anything, thinking about things, making a self, resisting anything, a lot of this kind of effortless effort, a lot of equanimity. And so there's a lot of letting go that has brought us to that point. And it's kind of like an ancient analogy: it's like a rope that over time and weathering has gotten thinner and thinner. And then at some point there's just one little thread holding that rope together. And then at some point that last thread just lets go. The last holding on, attachment lets go.

And then this effortless effort takes a whole different quality. And in a certain kind of very profound way, the system, our psychophysical system, recognizes that nothing more needs to be done. No effort needs to be expended of a certain kind. That the effort to search for freedom, the effort to move along a path of liberation, to some degree we recognize the place in us where there is nothing to attain, nothing to do, nothing to be. There's this absence, a beautiful absence of so many things that crowd us and limit us and propel us and all this stuff. And we start recognizing that in us there exists this place of no effort. A particular kind of place, not lethargy or dullness or inertia, but no effort. No effort is needed. Nothing needs to be done, nothing needs to be attained. And maybe initially it's not a dramatic place. It's just clear enough that it's a reference point. And that too is a reference point then to recognize better and better all the places where we still have work to do, all the places where the practice still needs to unfold and develop and grow.

And then we still come back to this initiating effort. We always become beginners, starting over, starting over, not trying to hold on to some higher state or some great thing that's the ideal. But when we come back to be a beginner again, to start over again, initiating effort, hopefully the degree to which we let go allows us to do that with greater equanimity, less self, greater ease, greater appreciation and joy at the very opportunity to make effort, to practice. We're very fortunate to have a practice, very fortunate to be able to make this effort. And may it be that we can make this effort forever together. And find a wonderful way in which we all support this world to become a safer and happier and freer place for all beings. So, thank you.

Q&A

Since it's Friday, I had this idea that for those of you who would like to stay on, I'm happy to try with the chat box to answer some questions if any of you have. And before I answer some questions, or maybe some of you are typing one, I want to make one announcement that might be relevant for you or people you know. Because many people are now sheltered in place (some places they call it in much more dramatic terms; shelter in place may be just a little bit mild compared to what's really needed now, some places they call it more lockdown), and maybe people who wanted to learn meditation for a long time would like to devote some time to it. So I thought I'm going to offer a two-week series every day on introduction to mindfulness meditation, kind of based on the five-week course that I do. But it's going to be over nine days, Monday through Friday next week and the following week, Monday through Thursday. And so if you know anyone who might be interested in meditation, has lots of time, who would like to do something nice like this every day to get into the flow of it, you might tell them it's at 9:30 to 10:30 California time and there's more information on the website.

Chris asks, "How much media do you consume about the virus?"

I actually don't do a lot. I maybe read two or three articles a day. I'm certainly not keeping up with how much would be useful to know, or I don't know if useful is the right word that I could know. I feel like I pick up plenty of what's happening. And I feel like I know enough to really be concerned and to have a lot of empathy and care for what's going on in the world. I talk to people who are affected by all the changes that are going on with the virus and what's happening. And it's pretty dramatic what's happening all over the world. So I guess the question is how much media do I consume. I'm trying to find a balance between how much would be useful for me to know both as a person but also as a teacher who's responsive to a community of people who are maybe wanting some relevant teaching at this time. Finding a balance of that versus the other activities that I do and the balance between the impact those things have on me and how to stay balanced and not be somehow consumed. So, I try to do the news in wise ways. I try to do it in times and places where it feels like I can read the news in a balanced, relaxed way itself. I try to do it in a way that I either take it in small dosages so I can reflect on it and live with it, or I try to do it in times where my powers of reflection are strong. So I can really kind of reflect on what I'm reading and question it and wonder about it and things like that. So that's my maybe inadequate answer to your question.

Someone asks, "Will we meet at 7:00 a.m. Pacific time next week?"

So we're not going to meet Saturday and Sunday, but my plan is indefinitely now to continue these 7:00 a.m. sittings and talks. And we're doing this five-week series now on the five faculties, and we've covered the first two faculties, and next week I'll talk about the five aspects of mindfulness.

"Do we need to know what phase of effort we're at in any given moment? If so, what's a balanced way we do that without getting caught up in that?"

It's a great question. I think that if your practice is sincere and you're really just engaged in careful, devoted mindfulness and making space for the situation, really being present, staying with your breath, developing your practice, and you feel encouraged to do that, then you don't have to know where you're at, how far you've gotten, measuring yourself, and all that. It'll all unfold by itself. It'll all reveal itself to you. There are some advantages sometimes to identify where we are in practice because then sometimes we can open to that phase a little bit more fully. We can allow for it. We can appreciate it. We can value it. So, there is value to it. That's why I'm teaching this. But you have to be very careful not to try too hard, not to spend a lot of time measuring ourselves. Sit down and follow three breaths and say, "How far have I gotten?" Like kids in the backseat, you know, "Are we there yet?" You want to be very patient with this practice. And perhaps if we had six days to do the effort, one of the efforts would have been patient effort as well.

"What should I focus on when I'm having a very difficult meditation session and I cannot quiet my mind or focus on the present moment breath at all?"

Yeah, that's a common experience for all of us. What do we do then? There's a few things you might decide to do. If your primary thing that you want to do is keep developing mindfulness practice, you might just turn towards the very difficulties you're having and let them be the focus of mindfulness. So, not to let them be a distraction, but let them become the meditation. Don't try to quiet your mind, but do mindfulness of a noisy mind, of a busy mind. The breath doesn't have to be the subject of meditation. The present moment does. But now to be in the present moment with the busy, agitated mind, really feel the agitation. This is where mental noting can be helpful. The mind is out of control, and you notice yourself, "Wow, this is a mind that's out of control. It's really busy, really active." And you keep saying that gently to yourself until you pull yourself out of the entanglement with it. It's like you step back, and you really see, "Oh, this is what's happening. This is what it's like."

A little bit like this, what I do sometimes when my mind is really busy thinking, and I can't seem to settle down, I'll say to myself the word "here," h-e-r-e. Just "here." And when I say the word, I open my awareness up to receive and recognize what is here. It's very permissive, it's very allowing. I don't have an agenda what's supposed to be recognized. "Here." And because I'm so caught up in things, that "here" opens up just for a second to what's here. But often then I'll notice, "Oh, here is a mind that's out of control. Here is a mind that's troubled." And I'll try in that moment to stay with that, just feel and recognize it. But I'm kind of allowing myself to be the way I am, but I'm stepping back and recognizing it. "Here." And I'll do it again. "Here." And I do it repeatedly. "Here." Very permissive, but just to really recognize what's there. And after maybe five minutes of doing that, generally then I begin to loosen the grip in my mind a little on what I'm thinking and what I'm doing, then it begins to soften and relax. And then I might start focusing on my breathing because then I have the capacity to really stay there and develop that.

One of the interesting things to do when the mind is out of control and we're having a lot of difficulty is to identify if there's an emotion which is fueling it all. And then to do a mindfulness of emotions with it. To really feel where it is in the body and hold it and all that. Things that I'll talk about in this intro meditation class coming up next week. So, hopefully that's a nice answer.

"How to practice in the middle of the night when raw fear arises?"

Yes. That's easy to have raw fear, especially with what's happening in the world these days, and some people will wake up in the middle of the night with anxiety and fear. Because the usual distractions, preoccupations of the day are quieted down enough that as we sleep, it seems like we touch into some of the deeper layers of what's really operating, what's really going on for us. And fear is one of those things, and it's not uncommon for people to wake up in the middle of the night and feel anxiety or fear or something. I've had that sometimes when I have a concern for a particular relative who has challenges. I seem to wake up at 2:00 in the morning. If I wake up at 2:00 in the morning, I know there's a little layer of anxiety for me because of this relative that I'm thinking about.

So, what to do about it when fear arises? Depends a little bit on how strong it is. Raw fear is a strong term. One of the possibilities is to start mindfulness practice. It might be helpful to actually sit up in bed if you can or go to your meditation cushion because the intentionality of really taking an upright posture or sitting posture, rather than just continuing to lay in bed, gives a little bit of freedom. It breaks a little bit the crust of the fear. It's kind of like you're empowering yourself a little bit to sit there in a clear conscious way and to feel the fear. Unless it triggers more fear to feel the fear. To allow yourself to be afraid. It's not a mistake to be afraid. It's uncomfortable, but if you're only free when things are comfortable, you're not really free. So, what does it mean to be free while being afraid? Is that possible? Is it possible to step back from the fear enough that you aren't afraid? There is fear here. And that fear, if it's not you afraid, but if it's you that you're afraid, it's a little bit hard to offer care to the fear. But if you really see fear is happening here, then you can bring care to it. You can bring kindness to it. You can offer safety to it. You don't want to fix it. You don't want to get rid of it. You don't want to see it as wrong or as a problem. But just kind of make space and feel and allow what's going on. And allow yourself to begin experiencing the layers and dimensions of the fear, the beliefs that are operating, the memories it's triggering. Maybe it connects to early fears we've had in our life that have been reactivated. To feel it in the body, to feel what our relationship is to fear, and so forth like that.

And then if none of that seems to help, and the fear is really strong, then you want to try to do something that's grounding. Go get some warm milk, have some food, maybe even take a warm shower. Sometimes journaling can help ground you and distract yourself from it, read a book, do something that gets you out of the grip of it so that you have more useful presence. And finally about fear like this, please try to hold yourself with a lot of compassion these days. Lots and lots of care and love and attention to yourself and respect. This is not an easy time that we're going through. But it is a very important time for us to really have a chance to work with and look at and resolve some of the deeper spiritual, psychological issues that are part of the path of liberation, but seldom get stirred up this far, this easily. So rather than seeing the feelings we might have with this phase that we're in of our global society as a problem, someone on a path to liberation can say, "Okay, this is where the practice is. Now it's time to really practice with this. This is something I've been waiting for for a long time. Now I'm ready to work with this fear."

So I hope that's helpful. And I want to thank you all for coming here and being part of this and I hope that this supports you and I look forward to doing this with you again on Monday. Thank you.



  1. Five Faculties: In Buddhism, the five spiritual faculties (indriya) are faith (saddhā), energy or effort (viriya), mindfulness (sati), concentration (samādhi), and wisdom (paññā). ↩︎

  2. Dharma: A Sanskrit word with many meanings, but in Buddhism often refers to the teachings of the Buddha, the nature of reality, or universal law. ↩︎