Moon Pointing

The Three Trainings

Date:
2019-04-28
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-09 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
The Three Trainings

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

The Three Trainings

In Buddhism, many good things come in threes. One of them is the three trainings, and another is the three underlying guidelines for those trainings. Another is that each of those three trainings has three aspects. So I'm going to do a lot of threes today.

As an introduction, I'd like to say that Buddhism is notoriously famous for all its lists. Some people get a little bit annoyed by all these lists, and it seems like it's very analytical and abstract. But how I understand it is that these teachings are not meant to point to some individual essential truth or philosophical truth, saying "this is how it is," but rather they are a deep exploration of our lives.

Our lives are an ecology, an ecosystem of many factors. When you look at all these different lists, it's because there are all these different species in the ecosystem, and they all interact in different ways with each other. Sometimes we focus on one, sometimes the other, but in order to understand the ecosystem, you have to understand how they all work together in a kind of balance.

In something called the three trainings, this is a fundamental aspect of the Buddhist teachings: that there are three categories or areas of training. It isn't just one thing we're supposed to do. Depending on causes and conditions, different parts of this training come into play. Depending on what's going on internally or in the world, you might engage more in one of these trainings than the others, or a combination of them.

So we get a sense of a dynamic unfolding, a dynamic participation in our lived life, as opposed to a one-size-fits-all approach where there's one practice, one thing, one understanding that you hold on to for dear life, expecting reality to cope with you, rather than us wisely coping with reality, which is constantly shifting.

It's interesting to call these the "three trainings." There's not exactly a word in early Buddhism that translates into our very popular English Buddhist word "practice." Buddhists like to practice, and they're practicing, practicing, practicing. Bob Thurman once said, "These Buddhists, they're always talking about practicing. When is the performance?" [Laughter] The comparable word—not the same word, but the word that covers the same idea in the ancient language—is "cultivate."

Here in the West, we might ask, "What are you practicing?" and we have a particular idea of what that means. Sometimes it means, "I'm practicing meditation, Vipassana, concentration, or Metta." People usually respond by referring to a technique. The ancient word is to "cultivate." If you ask someone, "What are you cultivating?" you get a different answer: "What are you trying to develop in yourself?" "I'm trying to develop loving-kindness," or patience, equanimity, receptivity, or acceptance. Rather than focusing on a technique, it focuses on the personal qualities we're trying to grow.

It's a very different emphasis. When you talk about practices, you're pointing to something outside of the ecosystem, like a thing. Whereas when we talk about what you're cultivating, it's pointing to something working close in and intimate. In the same way, the word "training" maybe fits between those two. Training implies both what you're doing, but also what you're training for.

What are you training for? One of the things we train for is liberation or freedom, not getting caught. But there are three—again coming back to all good things in three—there are three underlying principles that support these three trainings that the Buddha taught. I'll state the principles, and then we'll get into the trainings.

Again, these fundamental principles are not philosophies. They're not some metaphysical truth about the nature of reality, but rather they have to do with inner qualities that are emphasized to be developed, to be cultivated. These three principles that underlie all Buddhist practice are: to do no harm, to cultivate what is helpful, and to purify the heart.

So: don't cause harm, cultivate what is helpful—helpful for our welfare and the welfare of others—and purify the heart. I think those are beautiful things. How do we do that? On different days we're focusing on different ones, but how do we do this?

This is where the three trainings come in. The three trainings are three big areas that Buddhist practices are divided up into. The first is training in ethics, training in virtue. The second is training in Samādhi[1]—training the mind, cultivating the mind, cultivating the heart. And the third is training in wisdom or insight.

The first one, training in virtue and ethics, has to do with how we behave in the most obvious ways as we live our life. There are three areas of training in ethics—always three, right? There is the training of the body, of speech, and of mind.

We want to be careful with our behavior, that we're not causing harm. Not causing harm is paramount in Buddhism. In terms of the lay precepts, it is very important not to kill—not to kill anything if you can help it. Then, not to steal. There is a higher bar for this, because the literal wording is that you don't take what is not given. Even if you think it can be taken, you're supposed to wait until it's offered or it has clearly been stated you can have it. Then, not engaging in sexual misconduct, which is easiest understood as: don't cause harm to anyone through your sexuality.

Those are the three physical trainings of the body. Then there's the training of speech. The primary one is: don't lie. But there's also a more refined care around speech. Don't have divisive speech; don't speak in such a way that you divide people against each other, so no gossip and no slander. It's a little funny—I don't quite know what it meant in the ancient language, but it's usually translated in English as "no frivolous speech" or "no idle chatter." A lot of good social relationships are built around idle chatter, getting to know each other and just talking. So it must mean something specific. It probably means a kind of idle chatter which doesn't do anyone any good, whatever that is.

Then there are the ethical trainings of the mind. This involves being very careful so that the mental dispositions, thoughts, ideas, and impulses to do physical and verbal harm are held in check and settled down. So rather than being all or nothing—"Thou shalt not kill," "Thou shalt not steal" (of course you shouldn't)—it's considered a training to develop and grow in the capacity to do that. The primary training to do this is called restraint.

I think many people don't come to Buddhism to learn restraint. If the advertisement was, "Come and learn restraint," probably not a lot of people would come. But it's a powerful thing to learn to keep your impulses in check so that you don't cause harm. Not so that you're repressed, but so that other people don't have to deal with the repercussions of your harmful behavior.

Traditionally in Buddhism, this is considered the first training. People develop, train, and refine this coarser aspect of life—the physical manifestation of their ethics—so that they can go through the world in a good, ethical way. One of the purposes for this, in terms of personal training, is to develop a certain kind of happiness, usually characterized as the happiness of blamelessness. This is the happiness of knowing no one can blame you for your behavior. You're not going to do or say anything that will cause people to blame you, saying, "You really blew it," or "You did a terrible thing there."

There's a certain happiness when we can go through the world knowing that no one has any cause or reason to blame us. We feel good. I was quite surprised when I first went to Thailand, my first contact with this early Buddhist tradition, and I met people there who were happy because they were ethical. I thought, "That's bizarre." I hadn't grown up in any context where someone would reflect on their ethics and behavior and feel happy because of it. I was more or less ethical growing up, mostly from a lack of imagination. But it hadn't occurred to me that I should be content with it. If anything, I would have thought that someone who was super ethical was a goody two-shoes, someone to be suspicious of. But here were people who were happy because they were ethical. I met these people in Thailand who were that way.

After practicing for a fairly long time in Thailand, intensely involved and versed in the practice there, lo and behold, I discovered a kind of inner ethical goodness that surfaced inside of me. I felt happy being there. "Wow, that's why they're happy. This is good." So the idea is not just to be ethical because of some policy that says you're supposed to be ethical. It's really a way of training ourselves and cultivating a capacity for well-being and happiness. This is also the purpose of the second training.

The second training is in Samādhi, sometimes translated into English as concentration, but that doesn't really do justice to the word. It's cultivating states of well-being. There's a range of states we can cultivate, training ourselves to enter into states of well-being. There are plenty of people who, without consciously thinking they're doing it, have trained themselves to cultivate states of ill-being. Some people have trained themselves quite proficiently in resentment, hate, disappointment, self-criticism, and all these ruminations of the mind. The constant self-talk undermines and deflates us.

It's a training in the sense that it's conditioning. Whatever we do repeatedly conditions the mind. Sometimes it's very hard to overcome a very strong habit of mind just by snapping your fingers or thinking you can stop doing it, especially if some of these trains of thought and dispositions have been going on for decades. So it's a training to begin reversing or changing the direction of the dispositions and momentum of our mind, moving from what is undermining us to what supports us and allows us to develop states of well-being.

One definition I have for Samādhi—a kind of "Gil-ism" for how to understand it—is that the practice of Samādhi is to fill out into the happiness that's here. It's like buying clothes for a growing kid that are too big. Over time, they fill into them as they keep eating and growing. We're filling into the happiness. I like this idea of "filling in" because Samādhi is not a narrowing and constricting; it's an opening and expanding into wonderful states.

So it's training the mind. There are all kinds of things we can train the mind to do. We can train the mind to concentrate, and that's a very powerful thing. Our minds become sharper, smarter, and more capable once we're concentrated. We can train the mind to be mindful, which is also very helpful; it heightens our ability to be sensitive and attentive to what's going on inside and outside. We can train the mind in loving-kindness, compassion, patience, equanimity, and generosity. There are all these helpful things we can train. The operating idea is that these are helpful states to develop, not because it's obligatory or because you're a bad person if you don't, but rather because it's just a helpful thing to do. You want to spend your time cultivating what's helpful, as opposed to cultivating what's unhelpful.

Sometimes it feels like the easy way for our minds to operate is to follow the path of least resistance. If you're lazy, it's easy to follow the habits of the mind that are well-grooved channels. If some of those are unhelpful and deleterious—having those thoughts over and over again—it can still feel comforting to follow the easier route. It can feel like, "Why should I burden myself with the hard route of cultivating good states of mind?" There might be a lot of inner protest. But one way or another, whether you're in charge or not, your mind is constantly being shaped by what's happening in your environment, what's happening with you, and what you do. If all you did was listen to politicians and watch advertisements, and that was the only conditioning for your mind, it's frightening to think what would happen. There are people who want to shape your mind, how you think, and how you feel. If you just listen to those things over and over again, it will shape you.

To begin shaping the mind in healthy ways takes a little time and effort at first. Maybe it feels like climbing uphill and doing hard work. But changing the direction of the mind is a worthwhile thing to do, and it eventually leads to it becoming a habit. Those channels become well-oiled, and after a while, it's easy. It just becomes the obvious place to go.

So we train in these different qualities. In this theme of threes, there are three primary values of Samādhi, of developing this meditation practice and developing the mind. These three things are cultivating stability, cultivating happiness or well-being, and cultivating self-confidence.

One of the functions of concentration and meditation practice is to settle the agitation of the mind, the wobbling, the outward centrifugal force, and the fragmentation that happens when the mind jumps around thinking of different concerns, fears, preoccupations, and greed. The practice begins settling the mind so its agitated energy quiets down and the turmoil in the heart begins to rest. The mind's fragility and oversensitivity to everything going on diminishes. The mind becomes stronger, more resilient, and settled. With a stable mind, whatever is going on in the world and however it impacts us, we are not thrown off course by it. We have stability.

The second is to cultivate happiness or well-being. All the concentration practices in Buddhism keep emphasizing that what we're cultivating is happiness, well-being, different kinds of joy, bliss, and contentment. It's remarkable that a person can, through meditation, begin finding easier access to inner states of well-being. It is a remarkable thing in meditation to come to the day when it's possible to feel a real, contented, fulfilling, satisfying feeling of happiness for no reason.

Usually, we have reasons to be happy: "I just won the lottery," or "I got a promotion," or "It was a nice day." But here, nothing has changed in the external world. What has changed is that the mind has gotten settled and focused, and is no longer in conflict with anything. A settled mind that is no longer in conflict harmoniously releases feelings of well-being, harmony, and goodness. Nowadays they say it's because endorphins and serotonin get released. I don't care where it comes from!

Then this third thing about confidence is important. When the mind gets trained well and we become masters of our minds, when we have the ability to be steady and stable, the ability to connect to a sense of well-being, and the ability to not be impacted by every little thing that happens in life but instead be spacious and porous to it, we can feel a lot of confidence. We can go through the world and not feel as afraid or fragile. We don't feel like we're at the whims of whatever changing circumstances are here. There can be a strong sense of confidence both in oneself and in the trainings—knowing that mindfulness, concentration, and compassion give us tools to navigate the world and make things better.

So part of the function of the second training, Samādhi, is stability, happiness, and confidence. This is particularly important because of what's going to happen in the third training.

The third training is training in wisdom. In principle, wisdom sounds like a good thing. It's probably fine to call it wisdom, but I prefer to call it insight. Wisdom can suggest to some people that we're going to learn something wise, acquire knowledge, and then carry it around with us—portable knowledge that we can apply to all kinds of situations. In the Buddhist tradition, the word Paññā[2] has more to do with insight, perception, or discernment in the moment, where we see for ourselves what's going on. The wisdom we need is revealed in the present as it's needed, as opposed to bringing along pre-learned ideas of what truth or value is and applying them everywhere. There is that kind of wisdom, and it can be good, but the essential wisdom we are training in is the ability to really see what's happening in the moment.

That's why mindfulness is so important: to cultivate the capacity to take a good look at what's happening now. What's happening internally with me now? What's happening around me now? In that clear seeing, a wisdom that brings freedom, ease, or a healthy response becomes available. In the cultivation of wisdom or insight, there are three primary insights for early Buddhism and for our practice here.

These three are the opposite of the things that the training in Samādhi was cultivating: the opposite of stability, the opposite of happiness, and the opposite of self-confidence. We cultivate the mind to be stable so it can have insight into instability. We cultivate the mind to be happy so it can have insight into unhappiness, into suffering. We cultivate confidence so we can have insight into the absence of self or self-identity.

Now, if you just tell people right off the street to cultivate those three insights—"Come to Buddhism and we're really going to show you how impermanent and unstable things are, and we're going to show you how much suffering there is, and we're going to show you that you can't find any self"—that's just bad news for some people.

Some people have lived amazingly unstable lives, growing up in war zones, poverty, or fractured families, and they didn't have any stability. To tell them that in Buddhism they're going to learn to have insight into how unstable the world is might push them over the edge. Some people are just suffering so much. They say that everyone comes to Buddhism because of suffering. So if the first thing you're told when you walk through the door is, "We're really going to show you how to see suffering, you'll suffer better," that's not inspiring.

And some people have very unstable or poorly formed concepts of self, with very little self-confidence, self-understanding, or inner stability. To be told that there's no self—which is what some people say in Buddhism—can make them feel even more lost.

That's why the Samādhi trainings are so important. It's really good to have healthy, strong stability. It's really good to have a capacity for well-being as a part of one's life. It's really good to have confidence and self-confidence. With those as a support, it's a lot easier to see the phenomenal degree to which this experience of the world is constantly shifting and changing. There's no lasting stability; everything is inconstant and changing all the time. But we see that and we're not troubled by it, because we're seeing it from a vantage point of stability.

There's something very important about seeing how much suffering and stress there is in this life. It's phenomenal how much there is in this world of ours, but we need to see it through the eyes of happiness or well-being. This happened to me when I was practicing Vipassana in Burma. I had been practicing on retreat for a couple of months, spending a lot of time looking at my mind. I was doing walking meditation one day, and my mind was very quiet and stable. There was a lot of joy and happiness and stillness as I was concentrated on the walking. But my mind was still thinking sometimes. Thoughts would bubble up, and some of those thoughts were relatively innocent, while others were difficult. Because of the sensitivity I had, I could feel that even those so-called innocent, simple thoughts had inherent in them a degree of agitation or stress. I could only see it because my whole system was so peaceful.

If I'm running around Redwood City, shopping, making dinner for my kids, and doing everything, I'm not going to notice the subtle little tension of thinking, "What should we have for dinner today?" But in the context of being on retreat, I saw that all these little thoughts had inherent in them a degree of suffering. In the next moment, I realized that if everyone is having these subtle thoughts all the time that have a little inherent agitation and stress in them, then the amount of suffering in this world is really immense. I was blown away by the scale of suffering. But I didn't get depressed, because I was seeing it through the eyes of feeling happy and having a lot of subtle joy. It was a remarkable juxtaposition.

With that juxtaposition, I felt more inspired to practice in order to get to the bottom of that suffering, to come to the end of it, to understand it deeply, and to come back into the world and try to help people so they don't suffer as much. That joy was a very important part of putting that suffering into context.

Then one of the things that happens as Vipassana practice deepens is that we see all the different data points of experience arising and passing, moment by moment. We see that none of those sensations or experiences qualify as "This is who I am," or "That's really my true nature." It turns out that the idea of a true nature, of "who I am," is kind of an abstraction. Most ideas of who I am as a self are abstractions. When you're really in the moment with experiences as they come and go, there's an impersonal quality that's quite liberating. To see a thought arise—even a horrific thought—and not take it personally is liberating. Thoughts are just nature having a thought, having a little mental burp. I don't have to say it's "my" thought or "your" thought; it's just a thought arising. A feeling is there—just a feeling.

It becomes really clear that when we have a particular emotion, feeling, thought, or reaction, yes, it's really there. I feel it and recognize it. But it doesn't make any sense to assume or claim that it defines who I am. That limits us, and it reduces our freedom to take any particular thing or generalization as "the self".

For some people, when they get to this deep state of Vipassana and they can't find anything that qualifies as a self, they get disoriented. But if you go into those states with a lot of confidence, there's no disorientation. The confidence carries us through. "Oh, look at this, I can't find any self here. Well, that's pretty cool!" You remain confident where you're sitting. There is presence, strength, happiness, and stability, but nothing qualifies as a self.

So, three trainings, and three principles to support the trainings: not causing harm, cultivating what is helpful in our hearts and minds, and purifying the heart.

The first training is in ethics: training ourselves to be ethical through our actions, to be ethical in our speech, and to have some semblance of an ethical mind.

The second training is in Samādhi: cultivating stability, cultivating happiness, and cultivating confidence.

Those, in turn, support the cultivation of the third training, which is cultivating deep insight—the perception of impermanence (anicca[3]), suffering (dukkha[4]), and not-self (anattā[5]).

All of those together create a foundation of stability and strength of mind. With confidence, happiness, and real insight and self-understanding, something deep inside of us can let go. What we are letting go of are the deepest clinging attachments that we have. To let go of attachments is a great thing. There are many lists of different kinds of attachments, but there is a list of three. One of the lists of three is letting go of attachment to sensual desire or comfort, letting go of attachment to self-identity, and letting go of attachment to our views—the stories we live by.

So good things come in threes. There are three "letting go"s, and it's all part of the ecosystem. In different situations, we emphasize different ones as they become relevant. Over time, as you do Buddhist practice, you get a better sense of these different elements and trainings, and you know which one to call upon at any given time. If you're going to Las Vegas, you might think, "I need to work on the first training of ethics!" [Laughter] If you're going to a difficult family gathering, you might think, "Probably what's needed is the second training. I need a lot of stability to prepare myself." Or maybe you're going on retreat and you think, "Now I'm ready to really see what's going on here," so the three insights through the training in wisdom become relevant. It morphs and changes in different circumstances.

As we practice over time, we get to know the map. We get to know the ecosystem, the geography of the whole thing, and we learn how to navigate in that geography in a smooth, easy way. This is opposed to thinking there's only one practice, one understanding, or "this is how it is." That rigid approach is not really good for ecosystems. Our lives are more fluid and organic.

So please do not harm. Please cultivate what is helpful, the good qualities of mind, and purify your hearts. We all have a precious human heart. It's good to take care of it, value it, and be the custodians of this good human heart that we have. These three trainings are a way of caring for our good hearts, cultivating, developing, and purifying them.

Q&A

Question: I had a question about the third principle you mentioned, purifying the heart. I got a little lost in the ramifications at the beginning. Which specific training relates to purifying the heart? I have a feeling it's wisdom, but I am not so sure.

Gil Fronsdal: They are all purifying the heart from its attachments. When we train in ethics, there is a purification of the coarser things. When training in Samādhi, what we are working on is a little more refined, so there is a kind of purification, but it's temporary because you can slide back. It's the training in wisdom that leads to a more lasting purification, because that's what helps to uproot the attachments, as opposed to just having them abate or be put aside.

Question: Thank you, Gil, for laying out the map. It's like you're giving us Google directions! I'm wondering, is the destination "no self", and could you explain what "no self" is?

Gil Fronsdal: Yes, it can be confusing. I'll try to explain, and maybe one of these Sunday mornings I can give a whole talk on this. We have to be very careful with the words that we choose. You said "no self," and wording it that way implies something. The literal translation from the ancient language is "not-self," and it's considered a characteristic of things. Things are characterized as not-self.

For example, this bell that I'm holding in my hand is not me. It's not-self. That's pretty easy to see, right? Maybe it's mine, but it's not me. But maybe it's a little bit harder to see with my clothes, because sometimes we feel that clothes or cars or possessions make a person. But if you really look, my clothes, my possessions, my things are not my self.

So you look more closely. If you clip your fingernail and it falls on the bathroom counter, is that you? Once it's clipped off, you realize, "No, that's not my self." We begin asking these questions, shaving things away. Is your hair your self? No. Are your kidneys your self? Are your eyelashes your self? Is your ear canal the self? "Oh, no, these things are not self. Self is not any of these things." As the mind gets quieter and more concentrated, we see what slows up the mind; we see where we're caught.

One of the places people are caught is by subconsciously assuming, "This is who I am." Because of that, we can't settle down due to an underlying agitation. For example, I have a high forehead. When I was in middle school, I discovered that I had a high forehead, which I thought was clearly a fault. I was quite concerned that this meant I would soon be bald. So I spent an inordinate amount of time in middle school measuring with my fingers the distance from my nose to my hairline to make sure it wasn't receding. [Laughter] I didn't have the language for "self" back then, but somehow the "true self" of Gil was connected to that forehead and hairline. I was agitated and preoccupied, and I don't know what was going on in class because I was busy measuring my forehead!

Now, if you asked me, "Are you defined by your forehead?" I couldn't care less. I don't think that's who I essentially am. I'm not so concerned. As people age, there are things they once identified with—"that's who I am"—that they outgrow. "No, I'm not that anymore. It's okay."

This process of slowly realizing, "I don't have to identify myself or see myself in these different things," is what this not-self process is. "Not that, not that, not that." It is not a statement that "there is no self." That statement is just confusing and ends up in a philosophical quagmire: "What do you mean there's no self? I'm here! If there's no self, who is it that is hungry?" "There's no self here, and I'm hungry, maybe you should eat!" [Laughter]

It's not a statement that there is no self. It is very particular. It's always: "This is not self, this is not self, this is not self." As the meditation gets deeper, it's not a complicated thing the mind has to think about. As the mind gets quieter and quieter, it bumps up against a place where it's not so quiet around this "self" thing. "Wow, I didn't know I was identified with my nose." Or, "I took my anger as who I really am, and no wonder I feel so bad about myself." Or, "I took my history, my experience as a child, as who I really am. Wow, I can see now I'm holding on to that as who I am. Okay, I don't need to do that anymore. Let's not see that as a self. Not that, not that, not that."

As that process goes deeper and deeper, a beautiful letting go happens. You are able to experience a purity of heart, an ease of heart, an openness and freedom of heart that in no way needs to be defined by anything we would call a self. Does that make sense?

In the meantime, the assumption in this Buddhist practice is that there's a lot of emphasis on the person. You have efficacy, you can take responsibility, you can develop confidence. You can really muster yourself as a strong, integrated person who is engaged in the world and engaged in the practice. It isn't like, "Well, there's no self here, I might as well just be self-effacing, be empty, and be a wallflower." It's the opposite, helpfully so.

It would be great if you would stay and meet each other, and bring your wonderful selves to say hello and spend a little time in community. It's a friendly group here. If you're new here, turn to someone next to you and welcome them, say hello, and invite them to have lunch. Thank you for being here.



  1. Samādhi: A Pali word commonly translated as "concentration," referring to the state of meditative absorption or the unification of the mind. ↩︎

  2. Paññā: A Pali word often translated as "wisdom," "insight," or "discernment." It is the profound understanding of the true nature of reality. ↩︎

  3. Anicca: A Pali word meaning "impermanence" or "inconstancy." It is one of the three marks of existence in Buddhism. ↩︎

  4. Dukkha: A Pali word often translated as "suffering," "stress," or "unsatisfactoriness." ↩︎

  5. Anattā: A Pali word meaning "not-self" or "non-self." It refers to the doctrine that there is no unchanging, permanent self or soul in living beings. ↩︎