Moon Pointing

Reverence for The Breath

Date:
2019-10-14
Speakers:
Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-09 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Reverence for The Breath

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Reverence for The Breath

I'd like to tell you a little bit why I offered a guided meditation on breathing as part of the meditation we just had.

I was touched by some of the encounters I had today. Some were just ordinary encounters around town, seeing people rushing around, seemingly preoccupied with whatever their activities were. In that rushing around and preoccupation, I couldn't sense that there was much reverence for the fact that they were alive. A sense of reverence, respect, or awe—almost like it is sacred just to be alive.

I visited some friends today who are elderly. One has a husband who is uncertain if he's going to live for two more weeks or two more years. Someone else just came from surgery and was still under the tremendous impact of it. A third person has a neurological condition, and knowing the person for many years, it was moving to watch them shaking, seeing this human condition. Seeing people who are older and the conditions of old age taking their effect, I was feeling the reverence of life and the care of it.

For me, to sit and be mindful of the breath is not just a dutiful exercise—like going to the gym to do your reps. To be with the breathing is to savor, sense, or feel the reverence for this life that we can feel from the inside out, just to be alive now.

I find that to really feel the simplicity of breathing—such a simple thing, but to feel it sensitively and fully—is like touching into the heart of life. It's touching into the specialness of being alive and conscious. Just to be here with this is sometimes pretty special. We feel that specialness because we're not preoccupied; we're just here with this amazing miracle that we are alive.

Someone once came to a teacher who was rumored to know about miracles and asked, "Can you tell me what a miracle is?" The teacher said, "Your next breath. Your next breath is a miracle." Cell phones are miracles too, which we can appreciate. In the old days, it was telepathy; now we have cell phones. [Laughter]

Reflections on the Three-Breath Journey

What was it like for some of you if you followed along with that little exercise, the three-breath exercise?

Yogi: It was nice, and it felt loving. Particularly the one about "no more breaths"—it was okay. Maraṇasati[1] is a longtime practice for me. Tracking back to the first time I did it, however many years ago, we were supposed to go to bed and imagine we wouldn't wake up. I was up on the roof of the building all night watching the sunrise; I didn't sleep much. Watching my transition, there was an initial spike of fear, and then I thought, "That would be okay." There was a softening to that recognition that it could be okay for there to be no more breaths.

Gil: Great, thank you. That possibility... very nice. Did anything change for any of you during those three-breath exercises?

Yogi: For some reason, as I was doing it, I became very aware of my posture and the way I was holding my neck and back in a way that was painful. It had been in the background, and then the breathing brought it forward. It caused me to shift and correct things to find that point where there was less pain.

Gil: Nice. I find that when I really tune in to my breathing, there's a lot I start discovering about the rest of my body. In the instructions that the Buddha gave for mindfulness of breathing, at some point as you settle into it, you become aware of the rest of the body, or sabbakāya[2], the whole body. Becoming more embodied as we breathe is one of the great delights of mindfulness of breathing.

Yogi: I noticed with the focus on the exhale, I started forcing the breath out more, whereas it was gently slipping into an exhale until I brought my attention to it.

Gil: Thank you, yeah. Sometimes it's helpful in meditation, especially to keep your interest or attention, to have a slightly longer exhale than you would if you just let it do its own thing. But the art of it is to do it so it's not forced. I find what I do is I just let go more. Just letting go extends it further. When you start forcing it, you get out of breath, and it gets tiring and difficult. It's very gentle. It can be interesting if you have a slightly longer exhale just by letting go into it more, which then tends to make the inhale a little bit fuller.

You're all so quiet, you meditated for 45 minutes! [Laughter]

Yogi: Hi. I had the same sort of softening when the guidance got to the last three breaths, feeling the reverence of that, and how the breath embodied more than just the breath—it really was life. But I thought it was interesting that before the guidance started, I was deeper in meditation. When the guidance started, I kind of raised up; it was a little more conscious thinking. At the end of it, it was great, I got something from it, but I realized that I wanted to get back deeper down into that feeling. The rising and falling of getting back to where I was before the guidance was really interesting, because that was the first time I think I've gone through that in and out very consciously—wanting to get back deeper, and then being able to get back to that spot.

Gil: Nice. It's becoming familiar enough that you can follow the trail.

The Buddha's Instructions on Breathing

Buddhists have been doing mindfulness of breathing since the time of the Buddha. There are stories that survive from that ancient time that talk about the Buddha going on his own retreats. He would go for a month at a time into the woods to meditate, and he would tell people that what he was doing on retreat was mindfulness of breathing.

Maybe I'm peculiar in my associations, but I find it very meaningful to feel my own breathing and imagine that it's not that different from how the Buddha experienced it. Maybe his was much smoother, I don't know, but it was the basic idea: the inhale and exhale. When I make that association, it becomes richer; it feels more valuable. This is what it's like. I'm at home in a place where the Buddha was at home—settled, focused, and present.

In one of the ancient discourses that gives the clearest instructions for mindful breathing, the Anapanasati Sutta[3], there is a long prologue that sets the scene. It's almost graphic in its description, like a guided painting. In the ancient world, they didn't have writing; everything was spoken, so if you wanted to learn anything, you listened to these teachings.

It begins with this beautiful setting, and I can't help but think that the setting is preparing people to receive the instructions. The setting is a full moon in the fall, right around this time of year, on the plains of India in a wooded area. There are large clearings in the woods, and around the clearings are groupings of different Buddhist monastics, each gathered around a senior disciple of the Buddha.

These little groupings—ten here, twenty or thirty there—were on retreat for three months. They had been practicing, sitting, and working with their teachers who were giving them guidance. It was a beautiful, clear sky with a full moon, late at night, so it was dark except for the bright moon. The Buddha was inspired by the three months of meditation practice his monastics had been doing. He asked them to join him and said, "This is really great what you're doing. It's wonderful. You've made progress, you've settled, your practice has been great." And then he says, "Do it for another month." So they do it for another month, and when the next full moon comes, he gathers them together again.

In this setting in the woods, with these people who are very dedicated to the practice, likely in deep silence, focusing on being present and breathing—in that context, the Buddha gives the instructions for mindfulness of breathing. I think the text intentionally lays out this setting because it creates imagery; it touches the imagination. When we sit down to meditate, we don't just sit down without our imagination. We can meditate as if we understand the context—connected to the natural world, to the cycles of the moon, and to a large community of other people who are doing it. We don't do it alone. This idea of reverence and care, participating in something much bigger than just my in-breath and out-breath—there's something much more going on. It's a rich world.

There's another story where the Buddha gives the same instructions for mindfulness of breathing. It's maybe a little sentimental, but this story has to do with him giving this instruction to his own son, Rahula. (I have sons; I wish they would take instructions from me! [Laughter]) The Buddha takes his son aside and gives him a beautiful set of preparatory instructions before doing mindfulness of breathing, which I also think uses the imagination. He says before you start meditating, make your mind like the earth. The earth is not troubled by the things people throw upon it. Make your mind like water; water is not troubled by people washing things in it. Make your mind like fire; fire is not disturbed by burning trash. Make your mind like the air; throw rocks in the air, and the air is not disturbed.

He sets this imagery of a mind that is equanimous—peaceful, unreactive, not troubled by the things that happen. I imagine that maybe his son had trouble that day. We think his son was about thirteen in this story, and teenagers have challenges. He gives this imagery of being like the earth, and then he gives the instructions on breathing.

The core instructions on breathing are also the beginning instructions the Buddha gave for mindfulness practice. There are three major discourses where the Buddha teaches mindfulness, and they all begin with the same steps. They begin with being aware of whether you're taking short breaths or long breaths. Why is that so interesting? It's like giving you a handle to be present for your breathing. Rather than just "be present," it gives you a little handle to hold onto: is your breathing short and shallow, or is it long and deep?

Part of the reason for offering this is that as people settle into meditation, their breathing tends to become longer at first. It becomes more relaxed. As the muscles and diaphragm relax, and the chest relaxes, the holdings we have begin to let go, and the breathing tends to become longer—longer exhales and longer inhales. If you tune into your breathing and start noticing that it's shallow or short, you don't have to change it. You're simply taking in information that the mind needs to know to begin settling. Then you start noticing it becomes longer over time as you get focused and present, which is a good sign.

As meditation goes deeper, sometimes the breath gets shallower again, but it does so because it gets more subtle. In really deep meditation, the breath seemingly stops. The first time it happened to me, I was so content and happy sitting there, so peaceful. The breath got more and more subtle, and I was completely unselfconscious about it, absorbed in the experience. Then the breathing stopped. It was so peaceful, until I noticed it had stopped, and I suddenly gasped. In my mind, I thought, "I'm going to die!" because you're supposed to breathe to stay alive, right? That instinct operated, and it took me some time to learn that in deep meditation, you don't die when you no longer experience yourself breathing.

A huge part of the energy system in our body fuels our brain. If the brain gets really calm, you don't need as much energy. The metabolism that creates energy and sends it to the brain isn't needed as much. So the breathing gets more and more shallow and quieter because you don't need as much oxygen; a big part of the energy drain is no longer draining energy. As the mind gets really peaceful and calm, the breathing can feel like it completely stops. It can be a beautiful experience. But first, it can start with shorter breaths, then it gets deeper as you calm down, and later it might get short and shallow again, but in a completely different way.

The Buddha said to notice this as a little handle on the experience of breathing, to stay focused and hang in there. I've found that trying to be aware of the breath for a whole 45 minutes of meditation is too ambitious. But three breaths—that's more modest. If you do three breaths, and then do it again, and again, it can actually be easier to hang in there and get focused and settled. After a while, you don't count anymore because you're just there and settled. This three-breath meditation is what I call a "three-breath journey."

If you try that in the middle of your daily life, you can probably afford to take three breaths out of your schedule. Whatever you're doing, just stop, close your eyes, and take a three-breath journey. Just stay with three breaths, and chances are you'll be a different person at the end of them. It doesn't take that much to change things if you fully give yourself over to the breath. If it's only for three breaths, it's often easier to give up your thoughts and concerns because you know you can always get back to them quickly.

So do the three-breath journey in the middle of the day. Do it periodically through the day, and you will probably have a very different day. Also, in longer periods of meditation, you can start off with a series of three-breath meditations.

After giving these instructions to just know whether it's a short breath or a long breath, the Buddha said to become aware of the whole body as you're breathing. As people settle into their breathing and get more focused, it tends to be natural that the body starts speaking to them. They become aware of how the body experiences breathing. What happens in the body as it breathes? You become aware of the range of sensations, the expansion and contraction in the torso. It fills out, and you have an embodied sense of breathing.

This embodied sense of breathing adds to this reverent sense of specialness and fullness. "Wow, I'm really here." And if you succeed in letting the mind get quieter and quieter, having a high-quality experience of really being here can be mind-changing. Many people—like those I saw rushing around distracted today—can spend a lifetime not really being present for their experience. There is something about letting go of all other concerns, really being here with your experience, relaxing, settling in, and feeling it fully—three-dimensionally alive, contentedly alive. Just breathing, just here for that. It is so sweet. More than sweet, it is phenomenally healing for many people.

To not do that is, for many, to be fragmented. It is to be caught up in concerns, worries, anxieties, desires, and fantasies. We become dispersed and fractured, running around with our minds split, chasing distractions. But if we're not distracted and are really here for the fullness of our experience, it's profoundly healing. The Buddha said to be aware of short breaths or long breaths, to be aware of the whole body as you're breathing, and then he said: as you breathe, relax your body. Relax the tensions, the places of holding, the tightness in the muscles, the places where our posture is held tight. What is relaxing is often the impact the mind has on the body. The tensions we carry in our bodies frequently originate in what the mind is doing. If the mind is anxious or tense, that easily transfers into the body. There's a feedback mechanism: if you begin to relax the body in the places that are tense because of the mind, the mind also begins to relax. These are the basic instructions the Buddha gave for mindfulness of breathing.

In one discourse (the Satipatthana Sutta[4]), he builds on this to give the basic instructions of mindfulness. In another (the Anapanasati Sutta), he expands this into sixteen steps—sixteen different exercises to go deeper and deeper into meditation.

In a Zen monastery in Japan, I had a teacher who said, "Everything you need to know about Buddhism can be discovered through your breathing." That was a pretty cool thing to say. For him—a monk for many years and a great teacher—to say that certainly got my attention. Your breath is the book of Buddhism that will reveal so much.

I would say that one of the great treasures of my lifetime has been over forty years of meditating on my breath. You might think after a while I'd get bored with it, but it's the opposite. The more I do it, it just continues to get richer, more valuable, and more interesting. Life comes alive. It's almost like the spiritual dimensions of life get revealed. Greater experiences of freedom, presence, joy, and happiness come from this simple experience of giving myself over to the breath, relaxing into it, and entrusting myself to the experience of breathing.

Entrusting ourselves to the breath is an alternative to the unconscious entrusting we give to our thinking. We must have a lot of confidence in our thinking, otherwise we wouldn't do so much of it. But the track record of our thinking successfully isn't always so great. I'd rather hang out repetitively with my breathing than with some of my repetitive thoughts, which are often quite boring. We can shift what we entrust our life to. Instead of trusting that thoughts are somehow going to solve all our issues, we can really trust the breathing and watch what opens up.

Trust the breathing so the thinking mind feels safe enough that it doesn't have to try to think so hard anymore. It doesn't have to plan the future, worry about what happened, or make up entertaining fantasies. Just breathe. The thinking mind becomes quiet. The world opens up in a very dramatic way, becoming expansive and still.

In the process of doing this, all kinds of difficulties will come up, and they are meant to come up so we can face them. It's almost as if, as we settle in more and more, we go through the layers of the mind where there is holding, attachment, clinging, fears, and difficult memories. Going through them is like doing a housecleaning; we just breathe with them. I've sometimes imagined that my breathing is a broom sweeping the floor. All kinds of difficult emotions can come up in meditation. I just think, "Okay, that's what it is today," and I imagine breathing through it. As we breathe with it, things get settled and resolved.

Some of the things we struggle with don't need to be solved; they need to dissolve. Sitting quietly in meditation and just breathing through it allows this dissolving to happen. Being too concerned with finding a solution is often adding to the problem. It's like putting things in a straitjacket so they can't unravel themselves. But if we breathe through it, open up, and just be with it, much of our inner turmoil has a chance to unravel and dissolve.

What happens to many people who meditate a lot is they begin entrusting themselves to this dissolving, unraveling process that happens when we stay present. As soon as we try to solve things in meditation, we interrupt that deeper process. So mindfulness of breathing is just to breathe in and breathe out, settling in. This is my sense of reverence for breathing and the value of it, which I wanted to share with you.

There will be a day, you know, when it will be your last breath. The Buddha gave instructions on mindfulness of breathing to his son, and he makes a remarkable statement at the end of that teaching. The last thing he says to his son—at least what's recorded—is: "If you cultivate mindfulness of breathing, you will be mindful of your last breath." Is this what you tell a thirteen-year-old? [Laughter] I've been doing this so long that I would feel blessed to be mindful of my last breath. I kind of hope that I am; it would be like a dream come true.

I'm not in a hurry for it, but I would actually love to know that this was my last exhale and just go out with it. I welcome the idea of dying—I'm not looking for it or speeding it up, but when the time comes, it's not a frightening thing. I could have a horrible death—we never know, it's like a lottery what kind of illness or death you get—but the reason I have this positive disposition toward it is from what I've experienced in meditation. The deep letting go, the deep dissolving, and the deep quieting that happens in meditation gives so much freedom and wellness. If I can just be present for that last exhale, it will probably be one of the best things going in town.

Questions and Answers

We have about ten minutes if any of you would like to ask questions or make comments.

Yogi: Sometimes when I'm practicing mindfulness of breathing and a thought arises, it's difficult for me to distinguish between pushing away the thought and just returning to my breathing. It almost feels like returning to my breathing is the same thing as rejecting the thought.

Gil: It's a nice question. You have the attention to the total experience to ask that kind of question, so I want to appreciate that first. My somewhat unusual advice is: if you can't tell the difference, don't worry about it. Just keep doing your practice until it becomes evident. Is whatever you're doing onward leading? Does it help you get more focused, more present, and more here in the experience? If it's not obvious, don't worry about it. If it is more obvious, one way to tell if you're pushing away is that you're not getting settled. If you're paying careful attention, you'll probably notice a sense of being contracted and tight when you push things away.

Yogi: This was the first time I heard the description of extremely shallow breathing in a Buddhist setting. That was how I originally learned to meditate in a yoga community. During those times, I actually had the sensation of my body disappearing. I would have to touch my fingers to feel myself! It was interesting to hear that mentioned in a Buddhist context.

Gil: Yes, in almost all forms of meditation, as we get calmer and more concentrated, the breathing becomes more subtle—subtle, soft, or slow. Different people use different words. Then it can seemingly disappear. Sometimes, when there is that kind of deep focus and concentration, the mental activities needed to construct our sense of the body fall away. People experience their body not being there, or the boundaries of the body becoming quite diffuse or expansive. I've sometimes opened my eyes to make sure I'm still there! [Laughter] It's okay. You don't have to make that too much of a goal, but it's quite lovely when it happens.

Yogi: That exercise where you deeply breathe in and then breathe out longer, I've been doing it for quite some time at the beginning of meditation. I noticed it tends to quiet the mind. It's not mind over body; it's body over the mind. I find it very helpful.

Gil: Nice, keep it up.

Yogi: I was also struck by your mention of the use of imagination in meditation practice, and I'm not sure I quite understand what you mean by that.

Gil: I gave a whole talk yesterday morning on imagination in Buddhist practice, so you could listen to that talk. Most of what we experience as human beings is an act of imagination. My definition of imagination is the mind's ability to construct an image, a sense, or an impression of what's going on. When we're thinking about what happened today, or about a friend, or what might happen tomorrow, the mind is imagining what that's like. It might be a caricature of what happened, or we might be stuck in an old image. We're living with an impression the mind has created. Even memories are reconstructions that are partial and selective.

Even in the present moment, there is a degree of imagination, projection, and selection going on in the mind. This whole inner world of mental construction can be creative or destructive. We are already doing it all the time.

When we sit down to meditate, we bring with us our habits of imagining ourselves. Sometimes the idea of who we are is not very kind, but it is deeply embedded in our experience. We imagine ourselves into existence. I might sit down and feel like I'm a lousy person, as if that's just the way the universe built me. It's so subtle it's not even a thought; it's an impression or a mood. Sitting down with the mood that I'm a lousy person is a contribution of the imagination. We're doing it all the time anyway.

So it's reasonable, to a small degree, to use fire to fight fire—to choose the imagination, image, or impression you want to sit down with. For example, you could go meditate in an alley behind a fast-food restaurant with overflowing trash and cars going by. That creates a very strong atmosphere in which to meditate. Or you could go to a beautiful, peaceful, forested setting with greenery and beautiful light, and you'd have a completely different mood in which to meditate.

When you sit down to meditate in the privacy of your own home, can you construct a framework or context in your mind that sets a mood for what you're about to do? Buddhists do this all the time. A common thing they do is chant the refuges. They evoke and remember the Buddha, the Dharma[5], and the Sangha[6] before they meditate. Their imagination is fired up. They remember an image of the Buddha—maybe a statue—sitting upright, dignified, confident, and present. This changes the atmosphere in the back of their mind. They think of the Dharma and the Sangha. By using our imagination to construct these impressions, we can change the mood and the atmosphere. It can be overdone and become escapism, but you can use it just enough to help you get focused and present rather than scattered.

The first time I ever heard of someone doing this in Buddhist meditation was a teacher who told me that when she sits to meditate on her breathing, she imagines the breath as the wings of an eagle going up and down. That image draws her attention into the breathing and keeps it right there. At some point, the mind settles down, and then she lets go of the wings, and she still flies. That is an example of using imagination to correct for the other imaginations that are mostly not helpful. As we go deeper and deeper into meditation, we want to drop away from that kind of use of imagination. But to get started, why not?

Yogi: Thank you, that was very helpful.

Gil: So this was a little bit of a different evening. It's rare that I've done a guided meditation on a Monday evening like this. I'm sure some of you didn't care for it too much, but what did you think? Is this something we should do a little bit more often? [Audience responds "Yes"]. There were a lot of yeses. If there are any noes that don't want to speak up, you can tell me privately! Thank you for this evening, and I bow to you with great reverence.



  1. Maraṇasati: Mindfulness of death, a Buddhist meditation practice of remembering that death can strike at any time. ↩︎

  2. Sabbakāya: A Pali term meaning "the whole body." ↩︎

  3. Anapanasati Sutta: The Buddha's foundational discourse on mindfulness of breathing (Majjhima Nikaya 118). ↩︎

  4. Satipatthana Sutta: The Buddha's core discourse on the four foundations of mindfulness (Majjhima Nikaya 10). ↩︎

  5. Dharma: In Buddhism, the teachings of the Buddha and the universal truth or law those teachings reveal. ↩︎

  6. Sangha: The Buddhist community, particularly the community of monastics or awakened practitioners, but broadly inclusive of all practitioners. ↩︎