Mindfulness of Death
- Date:
- 2019-11-18
- Speakers:
- Nikki Mirghafori [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-08 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Mindfulness of Death
Good evening. Are you asleep? Good evening, and welcome my brothers and sisters, my siblings in birth and death. With that kind of a welcome, if you're wondering what the topic is tonight, I invite you to sit with that for a moment. We are all siblings in birth and death. We're not so different from one another in that we come and we go in this life, and we're on this planet in this body for a while.
The topic for tonight: I want to share some reflections on one of the mindfulness practices that is appropriate for both beginners and experienced practitioners. You've heard of mindfulness of the body (Kāyagatāsati)[1], mindfulness of mind (Cittānupassanā)[2], and the topic for tonight is Maranassati[3], mindfulness of death. Passing away, we all do it. In a hundred years, not a single one of us in this room will be alive. It's an interesting thought.
Look around, actually, for a moment. Welcome each other, smile at each other, in this form, in the way you are right now sitting here. In a hundred years, none of us will be here. It's a truth, it's an awareness, it's a practice we often like to avoid. You all do mindfulness of the body, body awareness, mindfulness of emotions, all of that, but being aware—Maranassati. Marana, lord of death; sati, often translated as mindfulness, but really awareness is a better translation. Mindfulness of death, awareness of death. It's a practice we don't usually practice.
What I like to cover for most of the talk tonight is really the enlivening benefits. I have ten, but every time I teach this practice I come up with more benefits. So far I have ten, maybe by the end of tonight it will be twelve, we'll see. The various benefits actually in our humanity, in our waking up, in the way that we live our lives, in the way we die in so many ways. This is such a profound and skillful practice for us to bring into our consciousness, instead of avoiding it, which is what we usually do.
Terror Management Theory and the Denial of Death
The talk is structured in the following way: At first, I like to talk about the denial of death, what's called the Terror Management Theory (TMT). Psychologists have a great name for it. I'd like to talk a little bit about that, and then about some typical responses that we have as human beings born out of this theory. Then, I will discuss some of the immortality stories that we tell ourselves, which are very prevalent in the culture and in the way that we consider our mortality. Finally, I like to turn our attention to how mindfulness of death is actually a liberating practice, the amazing benefits that it has, and how normal actually that is.
Let me start by talking a little bit more about Terror Management Theory. What is that? TMT proposes that there is a basic psychological conflict that results from us knowing that we're going to die. As human beings, we are very unique animals. The author of The Denial of Death[4]—which was a Pulitzer Prize winner for general nonfiction in 1974, Ernest Becker—puts it in a succinct way. This is the paradox he presents (by the way, this was written in 1974 and the author is using "he", so maybe I'll use "they" to make it more general):
"They are dual, up in the stars and yet housed in a heart-pumping, breath-gasping body that once belonged to a fish and still carries the gill marks to prove it. Human beings are literally split in two: one has an awareness of one's own splendid uniqueness in that one sticks out of nature with a towering majesty, and yet one goes back into the ground a few feet in order to blindly and dumbly rot and disappear forever."
I think he captures it really well. He just doesn't mince words. It is a terrifying dilemma to be in and to have to live with. The lower animals are of course spared this painful contradiction as they lack a symbolic identity and the self-consciousness that goes with it. They merely act and move reflexively as they are driven by their instincts.
Ernest Becker's book really started the Terror Management Theory idea; in psychology, it was born out of his book, and psychologists have done a lot of research on it since. Out of this terror—out of our ego not being able to contemplate its own demise—a sense of fear arises. In order to manage this terror, we engage in a lot of cultural beliefs and symbolic systems in order to create a durable form of meaning.
What are some typical responses? Ignorance, oblivion, putting our heads in the sand. "Oh gosh, is she going to talk about death tonight?" Fear, aversion, shopping, drugs. Again, I want to quote Ernest Becker: "Human beings literally drive themselves into a blind obliviousness with social games, psychological tricks, personal preoccupations so far removed from the reality of their situation that they are forms of madness—but madness all the same." And here's one more paragraph from him: "The modern man is drinking and drugging himself out of awareness, or one spends one's time shopping, which is the same thing."
I love that line. He equated shopping with drinking and drugging oneself. Amazon beware!
As awareness calls for types of heroic dedication that one's culture no longer provides for one, society contrives to help one forget. And that is true. The society really contrives to make us forget. There's a next thing to want, there's a next iPhone, there is a next gadget, there are all the preoccupations that the society provides for you—not to even mention Facebook and Twitter and the other distractions that we have filling every single moment, lest we consider our impermanence in this life and the limited time we have.
Four Immortality Stories
I also want to talk about a few immortality stories that we tell ourselves. The credit for these goes to Stephen Cave[5], the philosopher, from his book Immortality. He has four stories that we tell ourselves. Let's see if these are familiar to you.
The first immortality story we tell ourselves is the elixir story. There's an elixir of life, the Fountain of Youth, and this is the most basic form of an immortality story—basically avoiding death physically by staying young and healthy forever. In the past, previous cultures like the ancient Egyptians about 4,000 years ago, and the Chinese about 2,000 years ago, considered their cultures to be so advanced (the same way that we consider our culture to be pretty advanced) that they thought death-defying technology was right around the corner. They were almost there; they could almost feel it.
How does that take shape in our present culture? Well, you might have heard of various diets, intermittent fasting that is supposed to lengthen your life. There are anti-aging investments in Silicon Valley. There are many supplements, research, biohacker[6] collectives... You can buy these supplements and live long and healthy, and basically extend your life. Extend your life, just don't die. This body can just be extended. As I tell you these stories, see how they resonate for you. Is this a sense of, "Oh yeah, this is true," or maybe not?
The second immortality story he calls the resurrection story. The idea is that if we're unable to extend our lives indefinitely in this body, well, maybe we can rise after dying and live again. Historically, there are stories of resurrection in Christianity, as well as Islam and Judaism. The new scientific resurrection story of our zeitgeist is cryonics. As of November of last year, Alcor[7], which is this company, had 1,678 patients in cryopreservation. Whole bodies or brains preserved in liquid nitrogen awaiting a future when they could be brought back to life. Anyone want to be frozen so that you could be brought back to life? Apparently, 1,678 people have signed up, and the numbers keep going up.
The third immortality story we tell ourselves is the story of the soul. If we embrace the idea of the soul, we can give up the body altogether. It's not really needed, because our true essence becomes not the physical organism but an immaterial thing. Historically, there are religious beliefs in the afterlife in many religions. Plato, as well as the Hindus, believed that the body is an obstacle to immortality and really the main goal in life is to become pure spirit. The reincarnation impetus of this idea in our modern scientific society is mind uploading. Scientific fields like whole brain emulation, and organizations like Carbon Copies, hope to create accurate computational models of neural tissue at the scale of complete brains, and develop neuromorphic hardware to run simulations of your brains on these models. This is the new version of the story of the soul: you get to be re-run.
Just to say as a footnote, as science has progressed, we know that the idea of a separate immaterial soul is becoming less plausible. The idea of "you" is not just your software, not just the way you think and your neural connections, but it's really dependent on your body, on your physical manifestation, your genetic makeup for each of you individually.
Moving on to the fourth immortality story, it's called the legacy story. Consider the example of Achilles. When he was given the choice to go home and live a long and happy life, or stay in Troy, fight, and die but be remembered forever as the greatest hero of all times, why did he choose to stay in Troy? To become known as the greatest hero of all time. The legacy story. Historically, many people have been inspired by the pursuit of immortality through fame or cultural legacy, and it continues today in our culture. Now we have a new form of it: technology giving each and every one of us the means to instant fame by creating our own statues via tweets and through Instagram posts, and capturing and preserving the memories of our lives. But many consider this route to immortality a little too indirect. There's this quote from Woody Allen where he says, "I don't want to live on in the hearts of my countrymen; I want to live on in my apartment."
The Buddhist Perspective: Nature and Impermanence
The alternative to these immortality stories that we tell ourselves is actually to pivot and become aware. Mindfulness of our impermanence, of the fact that we die. Awareness and acceptance of the truth of death. Carlos Castaneda says, "Death is the only wise advisor we have." I love that quote. It's a practice I've done a lot, which is imagining that death is this wise advisor on my shoulder. I have limited time. Is it wise, do I want to do this? Death is as normal as birth. As I welcomed all of you, my siblings in birth and death, who have all been born, we will all die. There's nothing unnatural about it. Nothing unnatural about coming and going; it's a part of our humanity.
I'd like to invite you actually at this point to reflect on the people who have been near and dear to you and who have passed on. Maybe grandparents, maybe parents, relatives, loved ones, friends. Maybe cultural figures, icons, teachers. By bringing them close in this room right now with us, we're inviting a sense of intimacy. It's not so far, and it's part of our lives. Many people whom we have loved and cared about have gone through this threshold, and everyone does it successfully, and so will we.
While fear of death seems to be natural given what we were just discussing with Terror Management Theory, it's not rational, as it is part of life. Many of you might have heard the story of Kisa Gotami[8] in the time of the Buddha. She was the wife of a wealthy man, and the story is that she loses her only child and is absolutely devastated. She's desperate to the point that many thought she had lost her mind due to grief. Someone tells her to go to the Buddha. She goes to the Buddha and begs him to bring the dead child back to life. The Buddha says, "I will do that, only if you go and bring me a mustard seed." At that time in India, mustard seeds were very common; every household had mustard seeds. "If you go and bring me a mustard seed from a household that has not seen death, has not experienced death."
So she goes to the village, knocks on the door. "Do you have a mustard seed?" "Oh, of course we do." "Has there been death in your house?" "Oh yes, uncle, brother, child... sorry." Next door, knock, knock, knock. "Do you have a mustard seed?" "Oh yes." "Wait, death?" "Yes." She continues that over and over and over, every door of the village, until it dawns on her. She gets a sense of insight that every household, everyone is visited by death. She returns to the Buddha and ordains, and she becomes awakened.
We are nature. This body is nature. It has come out of nature, we will go back into nature. Just as leaves fall, this body will, as Ernest Becker put it, rot in the earth. We are nature, and we are not to take the body personally. One of the practices in Buddhism that we do in order to actually see the nature aspect of this body is called corpse contemplation. It's laid out very clearly in the Satipatthana Sutta[9], the teaching of the Buddha on the four foundations of mindfulness. In the first foundation on the body, one is to contemplate the body going through different stages. Many of the monks and many people in Asia have done this practice by going to the charnel grounds.
I remember actually a few years ago, Gil Fronsdal[10] leads a training every year for the Buddhist Chaplaincy program. As part of that program, the trainees have the privilege—because it really is a privilege—to go into an anatomy lab where bodies have been donated to one of the colleges for students to learn autopsy. This group of trainees gets to actually go and visit the corpses which have been preserved and dissection is happening on them. Once, I was able to join the group, and it was quite a profound experience to see that this body is alive, and that body is no longer alive. This body will be just like that body at some point. Not with formaldehyde, likely, but not so different.
There are different perspectives in the Western and Eastern responses to death. I'd like to read a little excerpt from an article that showed up in Tricycle magazine in the winter of 2014 called The Sea of Sorrow by Ronna Kabatznick[11]. On the eve of the 10th anniversary of the Indian Ocean tsunami, a psychologist who volunteered to help survivors in Thailand recalls her staggering confrontation with death and considers how a Buddhist country coped with the truth of impermanence. Here are a couple of paragraphs from it:
There were shots of bikini-clad corpses on beaches and stunned survivors frantically searching among them for loved ones. Video clips showed demolished homes and hotels, capsized fishing boats, crushed cars, and acres of debris. Sea water still gushed from broken storefront windows and down the streets and alleys. The Indian Ocean tsunami turned out to be one of the most devastating natural disasters in recorded history, leaving an estimated 227,000 dead, 125,000 injured, 45,000 missing, and 1.69 million displaced. In the idyllic tropical setting the day after Christmas, who could have imagined that this would be the day that I die? Consider that this will be the day that I die.
The Thai way of grieving, from what I could see, was composed, reflecting what is known as jai yen[12], a cool heart. Mourners appeared to see death as a part of life, not as an injustice or a dreadful mistake, even when it was unexpected or swift. Expressing emotions wasn't an issue. For Westerners who had jai ron[13], a hot heart, many felt angry and betrayed by the tsunami and by the experts who didn't detect it in time to transmit warnings. "They should have known, how irresponsible," they declared. Parents bitterly blamed themselves for not being able to protect their children from death. "I am a bad parent, it's my fault," they confessed, as if they were personally responsible for the natural disaster.
This difference between the two perspectives demonstrates one of the Buddha's key teachings: our minds are habituated to relate to suffering by resisting it through blame, bitterness, anger, resentment. That resistance is what the Buddha called the second arrow, which follows the first arrow, the direct experience of pain. So much additional suffering comes from believing that things shouldn't be this way, when in fact they are that way. Although a tragedy and loss feel personal, they are not. Suffering and loss are built into the human condition. I spoke with one local woman in her late 20s who stood beside three stacked caskets containing her young son, daughter, and husband. "Pen thammachat,"[14] she whispered in response to my condolences. "This is natural. This is nature."
So I invite us to consider our reactions to death. Considering it as an injustice, somebody's fault, with blame, bitterness, anger, resentment? Or that it's natural, it's nature.
The Benefits of Mindfulness of Death
I'd like to turn our attention to the benefits of mindfulness of death practice, whether you're a beginner or an experienced practitioner. Why the heck would you want to do this anyway, especially if it sounds morbid to you?
The first and foremost reason to do it is it aligns our life with our values. Often what we actually have is called a misalignment problem. What is the misalignment problem? Most of us want to spend our time in a particular way, we have particular values, but we actually end up spending our time in a different way. Nobel Prize winner Daniel Kahneman surveyed a group of women and asked them about their voluntary activities, what did they enjoy doing. They reported that they got more satisfaction from prayer, worship, and meditation than from watching television. And yet, on average, they spent an average of five times more time watching television than engaging in any of those other activities. Does it ring a bell for anyone? In fact, there's another study that reports people said they value socializing and communication with others more, but they actually spent twenty times longer on TV than religious and spiritual activities. Take your pick, wherever you are on the spectrum.
The misalignment problem is when we know what we value, what we want to do, what we get satisfaction out of—spending time with friends, communicating, meditating—but we end up spending our time in a different way. The solution is not to come up with resolutions. Resolutions are a stick approach: "Don't do this." Whereas what we want is a carrot approach, and the carrot approach in this way is to bring the scarcity of time to our consciousness. How do you bring the scarcity of time to your consciousness? Mindfulness of death. You realize your time is precious. You don't live forever. Sam Harris has a wonderful quote: "If you're like most people, you'll spend most of your time tacitly presuming you'll live forever. Like watching a bad movie for the fourth time or bickering with your spouse. These things only make sense in light of eternity." What do you do that really only makes sense in light of eternity? It really makes no sense in light of the limited time that you have in this body and in this life. Bringing the scarcity of our time into our consciousness, realizing "I'm not gonna live forever, do I really want to watch this bad rerun for the fourth time, or bicker with my spouse?"
The second benefit is we live without fear of death for our own sake. We don't end up engaging in filling typical escape activities. It frees up so much psychic energy. The various immortality stories that we tell ourselves—no need. There can be so much more peace and space in life. I teach a death contemplation retreat at Spirit Rock[15] every year. There was a practitioner who at times during the retreat was having a lot of challenges with mindfulness of death. I remember on the last day he stopped me and said, "Thank you." He said, "How do you put a value on coming in with a mortal fear of death and leaving with peace? To live your life without a fear of death. Oh, that burden lifted, gone. Just living with ease and freedom, not this terror that you need to manage all the time by drugging yourself or shopping."
The third gift of mindfulness of death is to live without fear of death for the sake of our loved ones. Because if we are not afraid of death, it's a huge gift we can give our loved ones. My mom passed away almost two years ago, and she was not afraid of dying, and that was one of the biggest gifts she gave me—just a sense of peace and ease. She held my hand through it. She knew what was going on. Similarly, with me having done death contemplation for such a long time, I was able to hold her hand through it. My peace with my death allowed me to be available for her, so that we can be present for those who are passing and not clinging to them, and not make their process even more difficult, but actually make it more easeful. It can create so much intimacy and ease.
Fourth, death contemplation practices sharpen our lived experience. Many of you might have already experienced when your mind is really still and present, the experience of your life becomes sharper. Tastes become tastier, colors become more intense, just the experience of this moment becomes brighter, it feels like it expands. There is the classical mindfulness of death experience taught in the Maranassati Sutta, which is briefly the contemplation of this breath right here. "This in-breath could be my last in-breath. This out-breath right here, right now—not that I'm gonna die in 10 years, all I have time for is now—this could be my last out-breath, there may be no more." This practice taken on as a formal practice on the cushion can really intensify the experience right here, right now. There may not be so much time. Who knows, maybe there is an asteroid and somehow NASA has missed it. This could be the last moment.
Fifth, we can awaken in life through non-clinging. The practice of mindfulness of death can be an awakening, liberating practice of letting go in this life.
Sixth, in the process of dying, it can actually be a gift to ourselves to enjoy the process. It's a mystery, we don't know what's going to happen. If we're not scared, maybe we can actually be relaxed and open to the process. Who knows, it might actually be very interesting. There are also Buddhist teachings about awakening at the moment of death, like the teachings given to Anathapindika[16] on his deathbed by Sariputta[17] to let go. Systematically let go, let go, let go, let go. The moment of death can actually be a meaningful moment of awakening, liberation, Nirvana.
Finally, gratitude and appreciation can arise for this precious human life, along with mettā and compassion. In the Dhammapada[18], you've likely heard: "Hatred never ends through hatred; by non-hate alone does it end." The line after this is: "Many do not realize that we here must die; for those who realize this, quarrels end." A sense of perspective, compassion, love. Why are we quarreling? We're all dying.
I'd like to end with this sense of gratitude and appreciation arising for this precious human life with a couple of quotes, one from Stephen Cave and another from Ajahn Chah[19].
If we're not fearing death, and we don't think it's an injustice, we feel more grateful having had the chance to live all together instead of having this sense of entitlement. Stephen Cave says: "In fact, if you think how unlikely it is that the book of your life should have ever come to be written—all the coincidences from the beginning of life that brought you here—the proper attitude is not fear that it might come to an end, but gratitude that it should have been written at all. So there is no room to complain how short life is. The only thing that matters is that you try to make it a good story."
And here's a last quote from Ajahn Chah: "'You see this goblet?' asks Ajahn Chah, the Thai meditation master. 'For me, this glass is already broken. I enjoy it, I drink out of it. It holds my water admirably, sometimes even reflecting the sun in beautiful patterns. If I should tap it, it has a lovely ring to it. But when I put this glass on the shelf and the wind knocks it over, or my elbow brushes it off the table and it falls to the ground and shatters, I say, "Of course." When I understand that the glass is already broken, every moment with it is precious.'"
With that, I appreciate your attention. Your kind attention, my sisters and brothers, siblings in birth and death. May you be well, and may you make it a good story. Thank you.
Kāyagatāsati: A Pali term for mindfulness of the body. ↩︎
Cittānupassanā: A Pali term for mindfulness of the mind or consciousness. ↩︎
Maranassati: A Pali term translating to mindfulness or awareness of death. ↩︎
The Denial of Death: A 1973 work of psychology and philosophy by Ernest Becker, which won the Pulitzer Prize for General Non-Fiction in 1974. ↩︎
Stephen Cave: Philosopher and author of Immortality: The Quest to Live Forever and How It Drives Civilization. Original transcript said 'Steven cave'. ↩︎
Biohacker: Original transcript said 'nanar o hacker', corrected based on the context of longevity and anti-aging subcultures. ↩︎
Alcor: The Alcor Life Extension Foundation, a nonprofit organization that researches and advocates for cryonics. Original transcript said 'Al Gore'. ↩︎
Kisa Gotami: An early Buddhist follower whose story of losing her child and learning the universality of death through a mustard seed is a famous teaching on impermanence. Original transcript said 'kiss ago to me'. ↩︎
Satipatthana Sutta: The Discourse on the Establishing of Mindfulness, one of the most important texts in the Pali Canon regarding meditation practices. Original transcript said 'Indus a teapot an Isetta'. ↩︎
Gil Fronsdal: A prominent Insight Meditation teacher and author. Original transcript said 'Gil'. ↩︎
Ronna Kabatznick: Psychologist and author who wrote the article The Sea of Sorrow for Tricycle magazine. Original transcript said 'Rona kupets kibbutz Nick'. ↩︎
Jai yen: A Thai term meaning "cool heart," reflecting composure and equanimity. Original transcript said 'je n a cool heart'. ↩︎
Jai ron: A Thai term meaning "hot heart," reflecting emotional reactivity, anger, or frustration. Original transcript said 'Jai Ron a hot heart'. ↩︎
Pen thammachat: A Thai phrase meaning "It is nature" or "It is natural." Original transcript said 'Penta Mota Penta matcha'. ↩︎
Spirit Rock: Spirit Rock Meditation Center, a prominent Buddhist retreat center in Woodacre, California. ↩︎
Anathapindika: The chief lay disciple and primary patron of the Buddha. Original transcript said 'anata pandita'. ↩︎
Sariputta: One of the two chief male disciples of the Buddha, renowned for his wisdom. Original transcript said 'sari put out'. ↩︎
Dhammapada: A widely read collection of sayings of the Buddha in verse form. ↩︎
Ajahn Chah: A highly influential master in the Thai Forest Tradition of Theravada Buddhism. ↩︎