Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (6 of 9)
- Date:
- 2020-04-06
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-08 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Introduction to Mindfulness Meditation (6 of 9)
Welcome back to the intro to mindfulness meditation course. This is the sixth class of nine. Last week, the idea was to lay down a foundation for practice. It is nice to think that all we do is put down the foundation. The idea behind this—that all we're doing is putting down the foundation for practice—is that we're creating the conditions by which the Dharma[1], what's healthy, can unfold. It's like we're making space for a natural movement toward health, a natural movement toward becoming more peaceful, less in conflict with things, less fragmented in our lives, and less caught up in our inner difficulties, so we can see everything more clearly.
Rather than the practice being something where we're responsible to make something happen—where we're at the forefront trying to figure it out, trying to get concentrated, or trying to be more mindful, as if we're responsible for the practice—we are responsible, but not so much for the outcome. We are responsible for offering the foundation to the practice.
In this idea that the practice is like a pyramid or a mountain, the first foundation is the body. Connect to your body. Breathe with your body. Just being grounded in your body, centered in your body, familiar with what's going on in your body, and relaxing your body creates a basis. It is a foundation upon which we can begin to be more aware and see more clearly what's here.
With that foundation, we also then open up to the experience of our emotional life. It's an important part of life, and we want to see it, know it, and make room for it in a meditative way. This means we want to be present for it, but not entangled with it, wrapped up in it, reactive to it, actively feeding it, or participating in it. We want to see and feel our emotional life clearly, so it can be a foundation and allow the deeper support of meditation to hold us, rather than us being the one who's doing it.
This support of the body and our emotions—knowing how to rest in them and be aware of them—is a foundation for becoming aware of thinking. Thinking is an important part of human life. Meditation is not meant to be in conflict with thinking, nor should we see thinking as an enemy or a problem. But thinking is certainly something that gets us into trouble when we get pulled into its world, or if we believe every thought we have and follow it along.
The idea is not to be in conflict with thinking, but to bring a meditative awareness to it, holding it in this deeper foundation. If we learn how to be in touch with our body—regularly checking in with our body and our breathing, and in touch with our emotional life—then on top of this pyramid or mountain of practice comes a smaller part: thinking. The proportionality of a mountain or a pyramid, where thinking is near the top, means it's just a small segment of the whole mass. This gives thinking a certain important place. It feels like it's important because it's on top, but it's not the majority of who we are as human beings. Thinking is a small part of who we are. It is an important part, but there's a lot more of who we are that gets left out when we get caught up and lost in our thoughts and rumination.
That's why I like to teach this course by beginning with breathing, beginning with the body, and then emotions. Now, it's time to talk about thinking.
To begin this, I'd like to do a very short meditation together. It's so short, you might not want to change your posture. Just be the way you are. I'll start with something we've already done together. Close your eyes, and maybe take one deep breath, relaxing as you exhale. Then, breathe normally and take the three-breath journey. Just stay with three breaths, counting one to three as you go through them, feeling and experiencing your breathing.
And then, with your eyes still closed, do the same with your thinking. Count three distinct thoughts that you have. Count them, then wait for the next one to come and count two, and wait for the next one to come and count three. Clearly step back and count three thoughts in a row.
And then you can open your eyes.
The three-thought exercise I call the "three-thought journey." Sometimes, stepping back and watching your thinking in the way that is needed to count three distinct thoughts—whether it's three distinct thoughts, one basic theme with three different parts, or three different little paragraphs or sentences—can create a little bit more space. Saying, "Oh, there's that one, two, three," can quickly create a bit more distance or freedom from being pulled into the world of thinking, or being swept up and involved in it. You develop a very different relationship to your thinking just by counting it three times.
If you find yourself caught up in thought when sitting down to meditate, you might try doing a three-breath journey first. Maybe that settles you a little bit and changes the inner atmosphere or ecology just enough so that you're in a better place to do the three-thought journey. You just count, not to condemn any thought, criticize it, or validate it, but simply to clearly see, "Oh, it's thinking."
One of the things that begins to change with mindfulness is how we relate to our thinking, how we think about thinking, and our attitude toward it. Some people are so enmeshed in their thinking that it's almost like, "I think, therefore I am." Every thought they have is believable, comes with authority, and seems important. We can be very strongly identified with our thoughts, caught in them, and involved in them.
With meditation, as I said earlier, we're not condemning thinking, but we're changing our relationship to it. Rather than believing it or thinking, "That thought is who I am," we are just stepping back and observing. "Oh, here is thinking. This is thinking. Wow, I'm thinking."
You can use mental notes[2]. Some people who don't normally use the mental noting that I've been teaching here will reserve it for thinking. There's something about naming a thought that takes a little bit of the power away from it, or reduces our investment in it. "Oh, that's thinking," or "This is thinking." I like the phrase, "That is thinking," because it emphasizes stepping back and observing it rather than being in it. Then just allow it to be there; let it go by.
One of the really wonderful instructions I got around thinking—I might have mentioned this the other day—is a Zen teaching. It's not inherent to Zen, but that's where I learned it: "Don't be bothered by your thinking." If you bring meditative, mindful awareness to thinking, and you're not bothered by it or in conflict with it, it doesn't agitate you no matter how often you go off in thought. You can just say, "Oh, I'm just thinking. I'm thinking."
So let's do a meditation together, and I'll include a little bit of guidance around mindfulness of thinking.
Guided Meditation
Show meditation
Hide meditation
Guided Meditation
Now, if you would, take a meditative posture—some posture that you consider will support you in being present with your experience, your present-moment experience.
In taking this posture, you might take a few moments to adjust it a little bit. Make small adjustments, both to make the body a little bit more comfortable and alert, but also as a mindfulness exercise in itself. Begin to direct your attention to your body as you make these small adjustments, and then let your body be still.
Perhaps there's a way of letting the body feel the stillness or quietude of just being here.
Gently take a few long, slow, deep breaths. Breathe in, and then exhale a little bit longer than you normally would, just to complete the sense of letting go. A little longer exhale comes not from forcing the breath out, but from relaxing or releasing a little bit at the end of the exhale.
Then, letting your breathing return to normal, allow your body to be a foundation. Allow the body to be the foundation for you to be aware. You might take a few moments to relax your body. Relax some of the major muscles and holding patterns. Maybe soften the face. Maybe relax the shoulders. Maybe, as you exhale, soften the rib cage, and perhaps soften the belly.
Especially if you're sitting cross-legged, where the body takes roughly the shape of a mountain or a triangle, see if you can feel a sense of stability or groundedness. Feel the substance and weight of your body, helping you to feel rooted and connected here and now.
Within your body, as part of your bodily experience, become aware of how the body experiences breathing. Perhaps each time you exhale, you can let go of your thinking. Or, if you can't let go of it completely, let the thinking mind become quieter or softer. As you exhale and let go, soften your thinking. Let go into the breathing. Let go into the quietness or the quieter state, so that you're quiet as you're aware of the inhale. Let go during the exhale, and have a quiet awareness of the inhale. Not trying too hard; just gentle.
An important part of meditation is to avoid any idea that you're not doing it right. It's also possible to avoid any idea that you're doing it wrong. No wrong, no right. Just here.
While you're here with your breathing, if there are body sensations that are more compelling, bring a meditative awareness to that part of your body. Bring a mindful awareness that recognizes what's happening. Maybe use a mental note, where what is emphasized is a simple recognition, an awareness, rather than thinking and reacting to the body sensations.
After doing that for a little while, you can either continue focusing on the body sensations, or you can always try to come back again to your breathing.
For this little exercise, you can now let go of focusing on your breathing and instead allow yourself to be completely mindful of thinking. For this exercise, you're allowed to think whatever your mind thinks. But while you're thinking, clearly recognize that you're thinking. You might want to use a simple mental note that supports that recognition. It could be as simple as saying to yourself, "Thinking."
Allow yourself to think, but clearly recognize it, as if you're looking thinking right in the eye and saying, "I see you. This is thinking."
If the thinking becomes quiet this way, return to your breathing until thinking starts again. And then, calmly begin recognizing thinking.
As you're looking at your thinking, recognizing yourself thinking, you might notice: do you think more in words, or more in images?
If you speak in words, is there a location for the loudspeaker that says the words? If they feel more like being spoken, or like words on a page, is there a place where that page is? If you think more in images, is there a place where those images are projected?
As you recognize yourself thinking, see if you can also recognize if there is a general location. It might help you to see it more clearly if you see it in that location. And if there's a location for your thinking, it can become clear that thinking is only a particular part of the whole. It's not everything.
It might be helpful to be more specific with your mental note. If it's words, say "words" instead of "thinking." If it's images, say "images."
As you're being mindful of thinking, continuing to allow yourself to think, if you are quiet, go back to your breathing. When thinking returns, be content and happy that you can do the exercise—to look upon your thinking and notice your relationship to it. Do you have an attitude about it? Do you have a more positive attitude or a more negative one? Are you leaning into your thoughts, or pulling away? Are your thoughts your friend? Are you friendly toward your thoughts, or do you see them as the enemy?
What changes in how you relate to thinking if you add the word "just" in front of the label "thinking"? As you observe and are aware of yourself thinking, call it "just thinking." It's just a thought.
And as you say "just thinking," is there any way you can also become aware of a tendency to be involved in thinking, to react, or to participate? You get involved. A new thought comes up, and you lean into it or get pulled into it. You pick it up.
Return to your breathing now. Let go of focusing on thinking and let yourself settle onto your breathing again. Maybe with every exhale, let go into breathing. Perhaps think of breathing and the body as a foundation upon which to rest awareness.
To end this sitting, take a few deeper breaths, letting go more fully. As you exhale, feel your body. Feel your body against your cushion, your chair, the floor. Remember where you are. And then, when you hear the three bells, at the end of the third bell, you can open your eyes.
Dharma Talk
So that meditation session was an exercise with, for some of you, maybe a lot of new information or a new kind of exploration of your inner landscape, your mind, and your thinking. If that stirred you up or gave you a lot to think about, that's quite understandable if it's all new. It can be quite useful to start understanding aspects of thinking and our relationship to it. It begins to create more capacity to see and be mindful, the more we see what's actually there rather than generalizing or being abstract about it. If some of what came up was news to you, you might need to digest it, be with it, or maybe go for a walk just to process what happened.
I want to follow this up by making a distinction between the activity of thinking and a word I've coined: "thoughting." It's not a normal English word, but in contrast to thinking, there is "thoughting"—the activity of the mind having a thought. The mind is a thought machine. That's what it does. Most of the time, it will produce thoughts, ideas, imagery, memories, and perceptions of things. It produces all kinds of cognitive movements.
With our involvement, we then create associations to the thoughts that come up. We tie an individual thought into the next thought, get involved with it, or react to it. We pick up that thought. For example, if I say the word "lunch," the thought "lunch" appears in your mind. That is "thoughting." But then you start planning your menu for lunch, and now you're thinking.
This distinction helps us to see that "thoughting" is just what the mind does—thoughts are created. But thinking is our involvement with them. That involvement can be multifaceted. We can experience our thinking very differently based on our involvement. Some thoughts can be very strong and substantial because we're really invested in them. Other thoughts arise with no investment; we're just relaxed, and they float up and float away. And there is everything in between.
None of this is wrong. In mindfulness practice, we're trying to see what is actually happening. Getting a sense of the landscape and ecology of thinking can help us observe it rather than getting lost in it.
I'd like to exemplify this idea of getting caught in thoughts or entering into the world of a thought with an analogy. (I might have used this last week, so please forgive me if I did.) Imagine you've gone on a nice hike in the countryside. It's been a wonderful day, and you come to a nice tree on the edge of a beautiful little river going by. You have your lunch, maybe take a little nap, and you wake up refreshed and content. Everything is good right now. For these minutes you're there, nothing is needed. It's such a nice thing to just be present in a very alive, clear, relaxed way, watching the river and the current flow by. You find yourself happily absorbed in watching the ripples of the water, and everything is good.
Then, down the river comes a big New Orleans showboat—a big boat with banners, bands, dancing, and wonderful music coming off it. You watch this boat coming down to pass you by. The next thing you're aware of, you're on the boat, involved with all its activity. The next thing you're aware of, two weeks have passed. You got so absorbed in the boat that you didn't even notice you climbed onto it. You eventually say, "Wait a minute, how did I get on the boat?" You get off the boat, make your way back up the river, eventually get back to that tree, and you're sitting there again. You're happy to sit there.
The next boat that comes down is a big warship. They're fighting the great war, the just war, guns blasting. The next thing you know, you're on the boat fighting the great war for justice. It takes you even longer to understand, "Wait a minute, how did I get on the boat? I was at that tree." So you get off the boat, and you get back to your tree.
The next boat that goes by is an old, decrepit raft that's barely floating. You feel so sorry for it; it's about to sink. The next thing you know, you're on that boat, thinking, "Poor me. It's so hard." You spend a long time on that boat until you realize it, get off, go back to the tree, sit there, rest, and watch the river.
In the same way, our thoughts are like boats. It's possible to just watch the boats go by and see them as boats. "It's a boat. It's a thought. Thinking." Or we can get on the boat and get involved. We get lost, no longer present or clearly cognizant of what's happening because we're so involved in the ins and outs of our thoughts, fantasies, memories, or images of the future.
This analogy is not meant to say that it's wrong to think or have boats go by. But it's a whole different experience if we can stay grounded in ourselves, cognizant of what's happening, and just watch the boats pass. It doesn't mean we never get on a boat or get involved in thoughts, but we have much more choice if we have the ability to step back and notice them. "Oh, just a thought. Just a thought is happening."
This is especially useful in meditation. In meditation, there is very little you actually need to think about. Ninety-nine percent of what you think about during meditation is not really needed for the purpose of the practice. So, it's fine to let go of it. You can pick it up later. Develop the capacity to just observe. "This is thinking. This is thinking."
I considered redoing the analogy using the image of sitting and watching a screen, scrolling through websites. Soon enough, you find a website and get pulled into its universe, not knowing how long you spent there until you pull out. But I prefer the imagery of sitting back against a tree and watching things go by.
The basic instructions around thinking for mindfulness meditation are to stay with mindfulness of breathing as the default. It's the anchor or home base where we train ourselves to be centered, focused, and mindful of something that's recurring, simple, and always in the present moment. But if thinking becomes predominant and we keep getting pulled away over and over again, then the instructions are to just be mindful of thinking. Take a few moments to recognize it. Sometimes it's enough to just name it a few times—"thinking, thinking"—and then come back to the breathing.
Sometimes it needs more attention than just a few moments. It's fine to keep your attention on exploring it and being mindful, just saying, "Just thinking, thinking." Sometimes it's useful to be a little bit more specific with the label because it creates clearer recognition. If we recognize planning thoughts as "planning, planning," memory thoughts as "remembering, remembering," or fantasy as "fantasy," it's easier to gain some freedom from the thinking and just watch it go by without being so involved. Then, come back to the breathing and let go into the breathing again.
If the thinking is really compelling, and you keep getting pulled into it—or you let go of it and immediately go back to it over and over again—then spend a little bit more time focusing on thinking. Notice what's going on. One of the most useful things to notice when there's a lot of thinking is what emotion is associated with it. What emotion seems to support it, feed it, or underlie it?
The stronger the thinking and the more involved we are, the more likely there will be some emotion underlying it. I think of the emotion underlying a thought as the factory that keeps producing it. If all you do is let go of the thought but don't attend to the factory, the factory will keep pumping out more thoughts. But if you can attend to the emotion, that's probably what needs more attention. It's what needs to be recognized, felt, and cared for. The emotion is waving a flag saying, "Hey, over here, pay attention over here!" but we pay attention to the flag instead of what's holding the flag.
Do not give so much credence and importance to the thoughts, but rather give importance to what's happening on a deeper level. For example, if there are a lot of planning thoughts, more often than not, there is some kind of fear, anxiety, or apprehension around them. Sometimes it's a delightful anticipation. But whatever energy or emotion is underneath, if you can bring your attention to that and not let it remain subconscious, more freedom can happen. We're less likely to get involved in the thinking and can stay in the present moment.
If there are a lot of memories, there could be strong emotions behind them. It could be anger or resentment about what happened. What needs our attention is the anger or resentment, not necessarily reviewing the story and coming up with a better response for the conversation you had yesterday. Just really feel the anger. This is why mindfulness of emotions is important to teach before mindfulness of thinking. Sometimes, to find our freedom with thinking, we have to drop down to this deeper foundation from which the thinking is emerging.
If thoughts are relatively light and don't really have a big pull, it's fine just to let go of them and come back to cultivating stability with the breathing. If the thoughts are stronger, turn toward them and recognize they're there. Give them permission to be there; don't try to let go of them too quickly. Take your time. Just recognize, "Thinking. That's what's happening now." Maybe be a little bit specific, calling it "planning," "remembering," or "fantasy." If that's enough to settle them so you're not pulled into their orbit and you can stay with your breathing, then go back to your breathing.
If thinking is really compelling and you can't let go of it, take your time with mindfulness of thinking. Turn toward it as if you're in it for the long term. It's not a problem, and you're not bothered by it, but this now becomes the object of your mindfulness practice. The object of meditation becomes you yourself thinking.
You might do some of the things we did in the exercise. Notice if there's a location for your thinking—for the voice that speaks, the projector that projects, or the screen on which it appears. Sometimes having a specific location makes it more clear. "Oh, this is thinking," as opposed to amorphously being involved with it and having it suffuse into ourselves. Look at what emotion underlies it. The stronger the thinking, the more likely there's an emotion. Consider that it's the emotion that needs you more than the thoughts.
One thing to be careful of with this relationship between thinking and emotions is that if we keep staying involved in spinning stories, reviewing, and ruminating, it tends to feed the emotion. An emotion that is not attended to tends to feed more thinking. There is a reciprocal feeding between stories and emotions. Psychologists say one of the leading causes of depression is rumination—thinking the same thoughts over and over. If those thoughts are depressing or critical, that supports the depression.
As mindfulness of thinking begins to separate the emotions from the thoughts, it creates space. Our thoughts are no longer the primary influence on our mood. We begin to see thinking as just thinking. "That's a thought there, and I'm here." Whatever thought you're having is only a small piece of the big picture of who you are. Get a sense that there's much more here beyond the edges of your thoughts. If you do this for a while, you'll discover that if you're no longer defined by your thoughts, there's a lot more goodness here. You have much more goodness, beauty, and value inside of you that sometimes can't be seen if we're always on the boat of thinking. We are good people at our core, and sometimes we just need to gain a little separation from our constant thinking to feel this goodness.
For now, I would encourage you, sometime before our session tomorrow, to spend 20 minutes—or if you're comfortable enough, expand it to 25 or 30 minutes—of meditation. Begin to be mindful of thinking whenever it becomes compelling or strong. As you go through your daily life over the next day, look for opportunities to check in. Notice your thinking. Recognize that it's happening. Notice the quality and character of your thinking, and your relationship to it. You might try the three-thought journey a few times through the day, maybe every hour on the hour. Just count three thoughts and see what happens. See if this study and curiosity about how thinking works in your life shifts your relationship to thoughts, creating more health, peace, independence, and freedom.
May you become free of the influence of your thinking, so that you can think more wisely and better.
I hope this is helpful. Tomorrow we'll continue a bit more with the exploration of thinking. If anything I said today seemed complicated or too much, don't worry about it. Drop it, or listen to this recording again if it's helpful. There is a very important principle about mindfulness: if it's not simple, it's not mindfulness. So if it seems like what I said today was too much to remember, it's really enough to just go back to your breathing and make that the primary focus. Then, as it becomes obvious that something else needs attention, maybe you'll remember some of these things and can bring some mindfulness to them.
I hope you enjoy your thinking. I hope you have a friendly relationship to your thoughts, learn to offer kindness to yourself as you think, and that this next 24 hours is a useful, nice time for you. I look forward to our time tomorrow. Thank you very much.
Dharma: A Sanskrit term (Dhamma in Pali) encompassing the teachings of the Buddha, the truth of the way things are, and the path to liberation. ↩︎
Mental Noting: A mindfulness technique where the practitioner softly and silently labels objects of experience (e.g., "thinking," "planning," "breathing") to support recognition and presence. ↩︎