Moon Pointing

Awakening

Date:
2019-07-15
Speakers:
Nikki Mirghafori [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
Location:
Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
Generation:
2026-11-08 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
Keywords:
Awakening

This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.

Awakening

We have to be awake for this particular topic because I'm going to talk about awakening, and you can't be asleep when you're listening to awakening! The path we're on—this path of meditation, insight practice, mindfulness, Vipassanā[1]—a rose is sweet by any name. It goes somewhere. There is a destination. This path naturally leads somewhere, and where it goes is awakening, or enlightenment. It's often translated as "enlightenment" in the West, and there are many other words that are used for it, which I'll talk about more in a moment.

The first thing is that we don't usually talk about enlightenment or awakening very much in this tradition, or actually in any tradition. It almost feels like it's a taboo to talk about Nibbana[2], awakening, and enlightenment. I'm curious, how many people have felt that? How many people have practiced and felt there's not a lot of discussion? Yeah.

There is a very good reason for it. Given that this practice has come from monasticism—from monks practicing for 2,700 years—there is a Vinaya[3] rule. The Vinaya is the code of monastic rules, and there is a specific rule about monks not being able to claim any attainments to lay practitioners. They are not to discuss what their attainments are or what stage of enlightenment they are at. It's considered a gross infraction if they lie about what their attainment is, and it's even considered a minor infraction if it's true. Even if they really are at a particular stage, they're not supposed to talk about it to laypeople.

When I was preparing this talk, I was curious about that, so I looked it up. The reason actually makes sense: the Buddha didn't want laypeople to favor one monk over another and give one monk food and alms while thinking, "No, you're not as enlightened. I'm just going to give all the food to the enlightened one so that there's more merit." There is the idea of merit generation in this practice, so you can imagine that laypeople would have preferences. So the Buddha said, "No, you're just not going to discuss any attainments you have at all."

Even as lay practitioners, there is a sense of not discussing it. And of course, there is a good reason for it, because if there is a healthy way to discuss it, there is also an unhealthy way. The unhealthy way would be declaring, "Hey, I'm enlightened," which is an oxymoron. If you're actually awakened—if there is enough wisdom arising—then there would be enough wisdom for there not to be the conceit to try to show it off. So it makes sense that it's not really a topic discussed in that way.

And yet, there is a constructive and really supportive way to still bring it in. It is important to know that yes, this practice has a destination. We're not just sitting and walking willy-nilly for no reason. This practice goes somewhere. It naturally leads somewhere, just like the streams and rivers lead to the ocean. By simile, this practice leads to the ocean of awakening.

Living the Questions

My hope for offering this talk tonight, covering various things—some nitty-gritty and some more general—is to provide a reference point, an inspiration for this practice. I have to tell you that as I was preparing this talk, I actually felt really inspired myself to up my own practice, thinking, "Wow, there's so much more. This is exciting."

My hope is to provide inspiration and aspiration, which is uplifting. It's like your North Star. When you have a North Star, you set it, and then you don't check it every five minutes; you just know you're going towards it. My hope is not to set up any expectations. There is a difference between expectation and aspiration. Aspiration is an orientation in life. It's this North Star that you set your compass by, and then you're just going that way without striving. Expectation is tight. It's bearing down: "I want this to happen. I want to put the medal of awakening on my chest." It's comparing, it's needy, it's incomplete.

As you listen to this talk tonight, my invitation is to listen to it the way Rainer Maria Rilke suggested to the poet Franz Kappus[4]. In Letters to a Young Poet, Rilke wrote about living and loving the questions themselves. As I pose lots of questions and ideas tonight, I invite you to live and love the questions and not necessarily seek answers. This is what Rilke says:

"I want to beg you, as much as I can, dear sir, to be patient toward all that is unsolved in your heart and to try to love the questions themselves—like locked rooms and like books that are written in a very foreign tongue. Do not now seek the answers, which cannot be given you because you would not be able to live them. And the point is, to live everything. Live the questions now. Perhaps you will then gradually, without noticing it, live along some distant day into the answer."

So live and love the questions themselves, and maybe some distant day, you will live into the answers.

The Punchline: Letting Go

First, I want to give you the punchline of the talk, so that if you fall asleep, at least you have the punchline! The punchline is this: there are lots of different ways of understanding awakening, even within this tradition, but no matter how you understand the process, it's really not about getting anything. It's not about attainment.

This was well captured years ago when a famous monk started his talk. He had been a monk for thirty or forty years, and he started by saying, "You know, I have been a monk for thirty, forty years, and I haven't got anything out of this." The audience thought, "What is he complaining about? Is he going to disrobe?" And then he continued, "I haven't got anything, but I've let go of a lot. I've let go of greed. I've let go of conceit. I've let go of all my crazy ways of thinking. I have let go of so much." [Laughter]

Awakening is about letting go. It is about what we let go of—all the extra things that we carry heavy in our hearts and in our minds. How that happens—the different models—I'll talk about in a little bit. But now you've got the punchline: it's really about letting go.

What is Nibbana?

The word in Pali is Nibbana. You might have heard the Sanskrit equivalent, Nirvana. The most frequent translation for it is "enlightenment." For me, that was my least favorite translation until a few weeks ago. I was moderating a panel on enlightenment at a conference on Buddhism in Berkeley, with Gil Fronsdal, Norman Fischer, Ayya Anandabodhi, and Richard Dixie as the panelists. I expressed that it was not my favorite translation, and I learned from Norman Fischer that Nibbana was translated as "enlightenment" as a nod to the intellectual and cultural movement of the 17th and 18th century. The Enlightenment stressed reason, logic, criticism, and freedom of thought over dogma, blind faith, and superstition.

Now I like the word "enlightenment" as a translation because it emphasizes that this is about your own experience and your own practice. It's your own freedom of thought—not dogma or blind faith telling you, "this is what it's going to be like." It happens for you; it's very individual.

A word that I also still like is "freedom," because we get more free when we put down all the extra things that are heavy and that we are carrying around. Imagine if you were carrying boulders on your back and rocks in your pockets. It's heavy. And then you put it down. Ah! There's a sense of lightness, a sense of freedom, a sense of ease. I also like the word "awakening" because it feels like you're waking up to another way of seeing yourself and another way of relating to reality—waking up as if from a dream or a haze of confusion.

There are thirty-three synonyms for Nibbana in the suttas[5], and I'll just read a few of them so you get a taste of some other ways the Buddha referred to it: the unconditioned, the destruction of lust, hate, and delusion, the truth, the other shore, the subtle, the stable, the peaceful, the deathless, the sublime, the auspicious, the amazing, the wonderful, dispassion, purity, freedom, non-attachment, the island, the refuge, the destination, and the path leading to the destination.

Models of Awakening in Theravada

There are three different major traditions of Buddhism: Theravada (the early school, which is where we are practicing), Mahayana and Zen (the middle school), and Vajrayana or Tibetan Buddhism (the later school). They all have different teachings and conversations about awakening. But even strictly within our tradition, Theravada, there are three or four different ways to understand awakening.

One is the Burmese model, which is based on the Abhidhamma[6] and the Visuddhimagga[7] (The Path of Purification). Those texts provided the training for all the Burmese teachers. Teachers such as Mahasi Sayadaw[8] and my teacher Pa-Auk Sayadaw[9] are in that tradition. Mahasi Sayadaw was the teacher of Jack Kornfield, Joseph Goldstein, and Sharon Salzberg.

Then there is the Sri Lankan model, which is based strictly on the suttas—the early oral tradition of what the Buddha actually said, rather than the commentaries that came later.

And then there's the Thai Forest Tradition. Ajahn Chah[10] (who was also Jack Kornfield's teacher), Ajahn Sumedho, Ajahn Pasanno, and Ajahn Amaro are in this tradition, and they have another understanding. I also recently read a paper that Gil Fronsdal had written offering yet another understanding of Nibbana.

In both the Abhidhamma and the suttas, there is the concept of path and fruition (magga-phala[11]). In the Burmese Abhidhamma model, the path moment (magga) is a supramundane consciousness like a stroke of lightning that cuts the root of defilements. It doesn't repeat; there's only one path moment for each of the four stages of enlightenment. The fruition moment (phala) immediately follows the path moment; it is what one enters into to re-experience the bliss of awakening, though it doesn't eradicate any further defilements itself.

In the sutta model, the path happens gradually as you become a dedicated practitioner over time, and the fruition is the lightning moment that actually cuts the root. Think of it like a thick rope made of many tiny threads. As you keep practicing, the threads are getting cut, getting cut, getting cut, until there's just one little thread holding it together. In that moment when the practice is really strong, snap—that's what gets disconnected. The fruition moment can happen years after you've entered the path. The understanding here is that when a dedicated practitioner has entered the path, they will definitely experience the fruition moment in this very life. That's inspiring!

In the Thai Forest Tradition, there is the idea of an unconditioned awareness that is thought to be the state of awakening. Nibbana is associated with a state of consciousness—a consciousness that's not ordinary, and you can just rest and abide in it. There is a point of contention between the traditions about this, but I won't get into the controversy. The point is that there are awakened beings in every tradition. No matter what model you subscribe to, there are people who have put down the fetters, and you can see from the way they are in the world that they have profoundly changed.

Gil Fronsdal has proposed looking at Nibbana as an action, not as a thing or a state. The word Nibbana and the verb nibbāti mean "cools," "becoming calm," "ceasing to burn," or "ceasing to blow" (like a light extinguishing). These are action verbs. When we talk about Nibbana, it's really about being "nibbanized"—all the greed, hatred, and delusion are being cooled and extinguished. He points out lots of sutta references where the Buddha refers to awakening as an activity: the stilling of all formations, the relinquishing of all attachments, the destruction of craving, fading away, cessation. None of these are states; they are all activities.

The Stages of Awakening

No matter what the model is, what really matters is what is relinquished and how the person has changed. René Daumal[12], in his book Mount Analogue, says:

"You cannot stay on the summit forever; you have to come down again. So why bother in the first place? Just this: What is above knows what is below, but what is below does not know what is above. One climbs, one sees. One descends, one sees no longer, but one has seen. There is an art of conducting oneself in the lower regions by the memory of what one saw higher up. When one can no longer see, one can at least still know."

We practice for these openings so that even when we are back in ordinary life, we are changed. In Theravada Buddhism, there are four stages of awakening, and at each stage, certain fetters (or defilements) are dropped:

  1. Stream-entry (Sotāpanna): Three things are let go of. First, the identity view goes away. Taking oneself so personally, believing every thought that comes up, and all our habitual neuroses change—one ends up having a completely different relationship to oneself. Second, doubt goes away. Any doubt or uncertainty about this path leading to the end of suffering completely vanishes. Third, attachment to rites and rituals drops. This is the belief that doing external rituals will make you enlightened. A stream-enterer also develops a firm, natural commitment to the Five Precepts; it is said they cannot commit any major infractions of the precepts because it just doesn't make sense anymore to lie, steal, or harm once you've seen your true nature.
  2. Once-returner (Sakadāgāmī): A stream-enterer is said to have at most seven more rebirths. The next stage is called once-returner, meaning they will only have a human rebirth one more time. At this stage, sensual desire and ill will are heavily attenuated (weakened), though they are not fully dropped because they are so sticky.
  3. Non-returner (Anāgāmī): Sensual desire and ill will completely drop.
  4. Arahant[13]: In this final stage, the remaining five fetters drop. Attachment to the material meditative absorptions (the rūpa jhānas[14]) and the formless absorptions drops. Even though they are delicious and wonderful states, any desire for them falls away. Conceit (māna) drops—not just regular conceit, but the deep fundamental conceit of "I am" and the sense of the self being the center of the universe. Restlessness drops. And finally, ignorance (avijjā) drops. I think of ignorance as simply not knowing any better. If we truly knew our true nature, we wouldn't do the things that hurt ourselves and others. Ignorance is the root of all ills in the world.

Practice for the Sake of Practice

What is truly significant about awakening is not the big bang experience, but how your behavior and your personality change. If you go to a master nowadays and say, "I had this experience," the master will say, "Okay, let's see your behavior in a year or five years." That's how it is in Zen. Experiences are a dime a dozen—you can take drugs and have experiences—but how are you changed? Are you kinder? Are you wiser? Are you more gentle and patient toward yourself and others?

I'd like to read an excerpt from a report written by Ajahn Liem[15] about how his experience of awakening came up. Let this wash over you as an inspiration:

"The meditation was very peaceful, and then a reflection came up: 'We don't practice for anything; we practice for the sake of practice.' Keeping this teaching in my mind, I kept on meditating normally. I would sit in meditation until about 10:00 or 11:00 p.m. and then stop to have a rest, but on this day I continued sitting for about eight hours without moving or making the slightest change in posture.

"With this experience of peace, the mind changed. The feeling of peacefulness shot up and pervaded throughout the whole body as if something were taking hold. It felt cool, a coolness that diffused the whole body... an experience of the whole body becoming completely light and at ease. The head felt so cool the whole day and night, as if there was a fan blowing over it. Cool, peaceful, quiet, and still. No experience of thoughts at all, and no clue at all where they had disappeared. Everything silent, completely. The only experience left was that of utter peace and stillness. The body felt tranquil and light.

"This experience continued on throughout the whole year, not just for a day or two. In fact, it has continued on unchanging for many years. There is this state of coolness as if in the brain, whether sitting or lying down, coolness in every position. All worries, concerns, or similar thoughts from the thinking mind are totally gone. Seeing somebody, I just had the feeling of seeing it as absolutely normal—to see a person as simply a person, just that much. No beautiful person, no ugly person. People simply would be exactly the way they were. This is the kind of peace and tranquillity that arose.

"I try to recall and pin down that which is called dukkha[16] (the word for suffering)—what is it? I really don't know. I only know how to discern the meaning in terms of conventional language, because dukkha is just something created by common conventions. When the mind has no dukkha, all conventions whatsoever don't exist in the mind. And the experience of this feeling has lasted on continuously all the time since then."

I love hearing that. The sense of no stress, no dukkha—all gone. It is possible.

In our practice, whether there is a big bang or little bangs, it changes us little by little. Returning to the metaphor of the rope and the threads, as we keep sitting and walking, we are being "nibbanized" little by little. These threads keep getting cut more and more, and maybe someday it gets cut completely. But as you do the practice, trust that more and more of the thread is being cut. That's where this practice is going.

Conclusion

Show meditation Hide meditation

Let's just sit together for a moment in silence. As we are sitting together, I invite you to think about one thing you might be taking home from this talk—perhaps something that inspired you or that you learned, something you'd like to take forward in your life and your practice to support you.

[Silence]

May all beings be happy. May all beings taste freedom, including us. Thank you for your kind attention.



  1. Vipassanā: Insight meditation, a central practice in Theravada Buddhism aimed at seeing the true nature of reality. ↩︎

  2. Nibbana (Nirvana): A Pali word often translated as "extinction," "liberation," or "enlightenment," representing the ultimate goal of Buddhist practice, the end of suffering. ↩︎

  3. Vinaya: The regulatory framework and code of monastic rules for the Buddhist monastic community. ↩︎

  4. Franz Xaver Kappus: The recipient of the letters in Rainer Maria Rilke's Letters to a Young Poet. Original transcript said "Franz coppice", corrected based on context. ↩︎

  5. Sutta: A Buddhist discourse or scripture (Sanskrit: sutra). ↩︎

  6. Abhidhamma: The third basket of the Pali Canon, containing a detailed scholastic analysis and philosophical systematization of the Buddha's teachings. ↩︎

  7. Visuddhimagga: "The Path of Purification," a foundational 5th-century Theravada Buddhist commentary written by Buddhaghosa. ↩︎

  8. Mahasi Sayadaw: An influential Burmese Theravada Buddhist monk and meditation master known for the Mahasi noting technique. ↩︎

  9. Pa-Auk Sayadaw: A Burmese Theravada Buddhist monk and meditation teacher known for his rigorous emphasis on concentration (samādhi) and jhāna practices. ↩︎

  10. Ajahn Chah: A highly revered Thai Buddhist monk who was instrumental in establishing the Thai Forest Tradition in the West. ↩︎

  11. Magga and Phala: Pali terms for "path" and "fruition" in the context of the stages of awakening. ↩︎

  12. René Daumal: A French writer and poet, author of the allegorical novel Mount Analogue. Original transcript said "Renee tamal", corrected based on context. ↩︎

  13. Arahant: A fully awakened being who has abandoned all ten fetters and will not be reborn. ↩︎

  14. Jhāna: Deep states of meditative absorption or concentration. ↩︎

  15. Ajahn Liem: A prominent Thai Buddhist monk in the Thai Forest Tradition, successor to Ajahn Chah as the abbot of Wat Nong Pah Pong. Original transcript said "Oh Jen Liam", corrected based on context. ↩︎

  16. Dukkha: A Pali word often translated as "suffering," "stress," or "unsatisfactoriness." ↩︎