Happiness That Doesn't Have to Be Ours
- Date:
- 2026-11-10
- Speakers:
- Diana Clark [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-13 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
Happiness That Doesn't Have to Be Ours
So we'll start with a little story. The other day, a friend of mine sent me a text. She was so happy. Her child got into the college that he wanted to get in. It was his number one choice, and he already knew that he was going to go where he wanted to go. She was so happy because he was so happy, and she shared it with me, and then I got happy. It's such a nice thing to be a young person and to have this dream of where you want to go to school and have it come true. It's very exciting just to be at that stage of your life when things are opening up in a nice way.
Probably you've had very similar things happen for you. Maybe somebody that you know got good news from the doctors, or got a promotion, or maybe somebody close to you married somebody that you think is just such a good fit for them. Just this recognition that good things are happening for other people, and sometimes we feel happy. We feel happy with what's happening with them. We've all had this experience.
So what's happened is that your friend or somebody that you know—maybe it's not even somebody that you know personally—has had some good fortune, and yet you're the one that's smiling, maybe in addition to their smiling. There's something interesting here that we often overlook.
We often think about happiness, or what's going to make us smile, in terms of finally getting what we want. Finally, the circumstances out there are organized in such a way that it makes us happy. Or maybe we've had some pleasure: we've had a great meal, we slept in on a morning and had our favorite breakfast, or maybe went for a walk and the weather was just lovely outside. There are birds, squirrels, creatures, and trees, and we just feel happy. There's this way in which we might be associating happiness with getting something that we want, having a particular pleasant experience, or accomplishing something. We've finally finished that big project, finally finished cleaning out the garage and organizing it, or maybe there was a big project at work and it went over well. When we think about happiness, we are often thinking about these types of things.
So what does our ability to rejoice, our ability to be happy when somebody else is happy, tell us about happiness? What does that tell us about our capacity for happiness? What does that tell us about the causes of happiness? This is something that we can explore through the Buddhist teachings of mudita[1]. Maybe some of you are familiar with this idea. Often mudita gets translated as sympathetic joy or appreciative joy, just being happy when somebody else is happy. This is a specific quality, and I'll talk a little bit more about this later, but the Buddha recognized this. As opposed to something that we are often dismissing, this is something that can be appreciated, cultivated, and learned from.
Often, our understanding of happiness might be limited to something that we receive or accomplish. We think that happiness will come when the ducks are in a row or we finish a project. But there can also be this way in which we have finished that project—let's say the garage looks fantastic, or the boss likes the work that you did—and then notice how there might be this sense of, "Oh fantastic, that was so great. Okay, now I got to go do this other thing, and I got to do this." This happiness just lasts for what, a few seconds sometimes? And then there's this incessant drive: "Okay, now I have to go achieve, attain, accomplish something else." When we are so quick to dismiss happiness, it leaves us dependent on making sure that circumstances are a certain way all the time. If we want to have some happiness and ease in our lives, it leaves us feeling like we have to be forever organizing the world, forever trying to control things out there: managing, manipulating, manufacturing, and engineering. It's exhausting. And most often, it doesn't work in the way that we want it to or expect it to. It's not a lasting source of happiness. It might bring some pleasure, but it's not a lasting source of happiness.
The Brahma Viharas
So what is this about mudita? It's from the Buddha's teachings. Some of you, as I said, might be familiar with this: it's one of the Brahma Viharas[2]. Brahma Vihara is a word that often gets translated literally as dwelling in a heavenly realm. But most often these days, we just talk about them as heart qualities. They are qualities that are not so much about what the mind is thinking, but more about what the heart is leaning towards. There are four Brahma Viharas.
The first one is loving-kindness, metta[3]. This is just goodwill, warmheartedness, and care for others and for ourselves. Just basic warmheartedness.
The second one is compassion. When there's this sense of warmheartedness, care, goodwill, or benevolence, and we are extending this to others, we might encounter someone who's really suffering and having difficulties. When our care and warmheartedness meets someone who has difficulties, that warmheartedness transforms into compassion. Compassion is this warmth and care with a wish for somebody's suffering to be diminished and to go away. It's care with a wish that their suffering be lessened. That's compassion in the Buddhist definition.
The third—and these are going in order—is mudita, as I'm talking about. In the same way, when there's this sense of love radiating out, this care, warmheartedness, and goodwill, instead of encountering an individual that's suffering, it encounters somebody who's having good fortune and happiness. Mudita is this love meeting good fortune. There's this sentiment of, "May your happiness continue. May your good fortune continue. May it grow. May it flourish." It is this wish for somebody else.
And then the fourth is equanimity, upekkhā[4]. It's when this warmheartedness recognizes the limits. It's like, "Yes, I wish for all beings to have safety, well-being, and to be healthy and happy," yet recognizing that I can't make it so. Even though we might be wishing this, we recognize that we can't make this happen for others. Often we can't even make it happen for ourselves. Equanimity is this warmhearted wish for them to be safe, happy, and healthy, coupled with a recognition that we don't control their lives. Our inability to make their lives better isn't something that has to diminish our care for them. So those are the four Brahma Viharas, and mudita is the third one.
There's this movie I remember seeing when it first came out quite some time ago: Love Actually. Some of you might know this movie; it usually comes around Christmas time. The opening scene is at the airport, showing all these people greeting each other coming off the plane. There are all these little reunions, and you just see all these people hugging and being happy to see one another. It's such a lovely beginning to the movie. There's a little bit of an uplift that happens just seeing all these reunions. I don't remember exactly what the voiceover at the beginning of the movie says, but what I do remember is feeling this happiness watching all these different reunions. This is the mudita that's being pointed to here. It's this way in which we can rejoice in other people's happiness, and yet, like all those at the airport that are meeting, that happiness is completely theirs.
Often we think about happiness as our getting something, but this really has nothing to do with us. When we recognize that, we realize we don't have to attain or get anything. Other people's experiences can be a support for us, and we can be touched by it. There's a way that we can participate in happiness without making it about us, without taking anything away from their experience, and without diminishing anything from their experience.
The Sources of Happiness
Where does happiness come from? Sometimes, as I said, we assume it comes from getting things that we want. The Buddha pointed out that while sometimes it does come from getting what we want, sometimes it comes from meditation practice. Some of you might have this experience. It's well-described and experienced that sometimes, when the mind and the body start to settle down, happiness starts to really increase. Especially with retreat practice and extended meditation, there can be this beautiful bubbling up of an incredible sense of well-being, joy, and happiness. So much so that happiness is actually one of the Seven Factors of Awakening[5]. It is pointed to as a necessary ingredient for more freedom and more ease in one's life. But there's also this third way that I'm talking about: appreciating goodness that doesn't belong to us. It doesn't belong to us, but it arises in relationship to when we encounter it and see it in others.
Sometimes, just like we dismiss some of the happiness we have after accomplishing something—thinking, "Okay, yeah, what's next?"—we do the same when we see other people's happiness. We can be dismissive and not let it touch us or have an impact on our own hearts. Why is it that we somehow limit ourselves from experiencing happiness? With the recognition that it doesn't even have to be about us, just witnessing it can bring an uplift to the heart. But why don't we do this more often?
One reason could be comparison. Maybe a friend is telling us about some success they've had—they got a promotion at work, received some professional recognition, or got an invitation to something meaningful for them. They're very happy, and they're sharing it with us. You genuinely care for this person and want what's best for them, and yet you don't quite feel happy because comparison shows up. There's this little tightening that we feel, something a little bit uncomfortable, because in a quiet way we're wishing, "Oh, I wish something like that would happen to me. Why can't that happen to me?" Or maybe there's a feeling of getting left behind: "They're having all this success, and I'm still here doing whatever it is I'm doing."
So now there are two experiences happening. One is their happiness, and the other is your comparison. This tightening, this uncomfortable feeling of being left behind, is not happiness. But notice how it has nothing to do with their happiness; it just has to do with something that came up in our minds. We get caught in this idea that what's good for them doesn't feel so good for us, and we end up being dismissive of their happiness, not letting it touch us, register, or be acknowledged in any way.
Part of it is because, without really thinking about it or saying it explicitly, we might treat happiness as a commodity. We act as if there's a fixed amount available in the world, and if somebody has some, that means there's less available for me. This is ridiculous if we think about it. Happiness can be infinite. But we can have this unspoken feeling that there isn't enough for us, or that we're getting left behind if someone close to us is progressing. That's one reason why we don't experience happiness when we see other people's happiness.
Selective Rejoicing
Another reason could be that it's easier to rejoice when good things happen to people we care about. But what about somebody that we don't really like? What if something good happens to them? Can we rejoice in their happiness? Logically, the happier they are, the less likely they are to do that irritating thing that makes you dislike them. The more happiness people have, the more generous, appreciative, and accommodating they are. We could say they're less annoying. So, using this kind of weird logic, we should be encouraging people's happiness and be happy when they're happy. And yet, so often we are not. Our appreciative joy becomes selective: "I'll just do it for these people over here that I like, but not so much for those people over there."
These teachings are pointing to whether we can be happy even when somebody we don't like finds happiness. Why not take advantage of any opportunities for happiness? We don't have to like everything about someone, and we don't have to approve of everything they've done, but we can appreciate when something good happens in their life. This just makes it more likely that we will encounter and experience happiness when we open up to having mudita for more individuals.
A third limitation is that we might hear about a good thing happening to a community that we have no connection with whatsoever. Geographically they are far away, or maybe philosophically they have a different worldview than we do. They're celebrating something good, and yet this kind of happiness doesn't even enter our minds. Why can't we be happy when other people are having good things happen to them, even if it has no direct relevance to us? Maybe they're celebrating a holiday, spending time with their families, and exchanging gifts—or just exchanging time together. Why should goodness have to be personally relevant to us before we can appreciate it?
We often limit our opportunities for mudita—this appreciative or sympathetic joy—through comparison, preference for only certain people, or a lack of personal relevance. But these limitations aren't fixed. They can change, and there are practices we can do to help change them. They might be habits and tendencies, but they're not fixed.
Cultivating Boundless Mudita
Some of you might be familiar with the practice for cultivating appreciative joy. I'll just mention it at a high level. It's a meditation practice in which you bring to mind somebody that you care about. You connect with them, sending them good vibes, appreciation, or goodheartedness. Then, you bring to mind something good that's in their life. If you don't know the details, you can just imagine that they had a great meal or that something nice has happened for them. While feeling connected with this person, you can internally intone something like: "May your happiness continue. May your happiness grow. I'm happy for your happiness." It's quite something what an impact this has. Just in a quiet, meditative way, expressing these messages helps us start to feel happier and happier.
After that's established, we can expand it to people that we don't know, then to people that are difficult for us, and finally expand it even more to all beings. The phrases might be tweaked slightly depending on whether we know them or if we are directing them to all beings. In this way, we discover more and more opportunities to experience happiness—not because there is suddenly more happiness in the world, but because we are becoming more receptive to what's already there.
This points towards the idea of boundless, limitless mudita—an ability to be with all beings we encounter. We recognize that all of us have suffering; we're not pretending that suffering doesn't exist. That's undeniable. We're also not celebrating every success indiscriminately. If someone is feeling happy due to something that caused harm, exploitation, or oppression, we're not condoning or celebrating that.
Nor does this idea of having mudita mean that we have to be cheerful all the time, because that's unrealistic. But mudita allows us to recognize and welcome goodness when we encounter it. It allows us to welcome goodness in a way that uplifts our own heart, supports our life, and allows us to share happiness with others. Rather than a doom spiral, it's an upward spiral in which more people can feel warmheartedness, care, and joy.
Mudita reveals that happiness isn't just about having all our ducks in a row or having particular meditative experiences. Happiness can be found simply because other people are happy and experiencing success in their life. We can just delight in it, very simply. Why not? The world needs people that have warmheartedness; the more warmheartedness, the better. The world also contains countless expressions of goodwill, happiness, and well-being. I'm not denying the terrible things that are happening, but we shouldn't let our negativity bias tilt us entirely in one direction. We can also recognize that there are good things happening in the world too.
May you be happy. And may your good fortune, in whatever way it shows up, grow and flourish. Thank you.
Q&A and Reflections
Yogi 1: Thank you for your talk. A couple of years ago, there was a men's basketball game at UC Berkeley, where I went to graduate school, playing against Cornell, where I went as an undergraduate. I thought about going and sitting with my friends from Berkeley and cheering for every single basket that got made, whether it was Berkeley or Cornell. I decided that probably wasn't such a wise thing to do. [Laughter] I didn't quite want to go try that experiment, but it did cross my mind.
Diana: It was joy for whoever makes the basket.
Yogi 2: I have a similar story. I usually don't watch basketball, but I had an occasion to watch it recently. I didn't really know the teams or understand much about the sport, but I was just so amazed by the athleticism, the power, and the jumping. I kept going, "Wow, wow!" for whoever was doing anything. The people sitting around me actually thought I was silly at first, but it was just beautiful to see humans do some of this stuff.
Yogi 3: Thank you for your talk. I was just going to say how easy it is for me to feel joy when I see my dog joyful. It is so uplifting when he gets to the beach and is just in heaven, jumping around and so happy with himself. That's a really strong example for me of getting joy from seeing his joy.
Diana: That's a great example. I had this recently too with a friend's dog. It just felt so joyful to be around this creature that was so joyful.
Yogi 3: You can't help it; it's contagious. With humans, when you see other humans smile, you can smile too through a kind of mirroring. But when you asked why we don't savor the happiness when we notice it in other people, I think it's because we're so busy. We're just moving from one thing to another. I knew there was a holiday in India recently, the festival of lights—Diwali. I noted it in my head so quickly. I know it's a super joyful holiday, but I just moved on so quickly to whatever was next. So it's about slowing down and being more mindful and aware.
Diana: Exactly. Thank you.
Yogi 4: In psychology and parent-infant research, there's a phenomenon where when the baby squeals with joy—or any emotion really, but definitely with happiness—the caregiver responds in a similar arc of emotion, but cross-modally. If the baby has a vocal intonation, the mother very naturally mirrors it with a different physical expression. To be honest, at the moment I'm forgetting the punchline in psychology! [Laughter] But I think it's about helping the baby embody the experience and realize that they are not alone. By seeing it translated in the caregiver in a cross-modal way, they get a very visceral sense that their joy was shared by another person.
Diana: Nice. So this is something that is important to us as humans, that we are sharing our joy and communicating it. Thank you.
Yogi 5: One thing I was thinking about is the comparing mind. Sometimes you'll see people where things seem to be going really well in their life. You might feel envy, or you try to feel happiness for them. In the public arena, we hear stories of celebrities who exude all of that, but you find out later it wasn't what it seemed. There's self-harm, there's suicide. My point is just that it's really hard to know what is really going on; we just never know. There's a little mystery involved in that, I think.
Diana: Yeah. We don't know how deep that happiness is. And if it is deep, we don't know what preceded it. Maybe there was a lot of work or misery that happened before that. Especially these days with social media, where it's so curated, people only upload the things that make it look like they're having the perfect life, when nobody is having the perfect life. Thank you.
Yogi 6: I work as an early childhood educator, and I find throughout my day various moments where a smile comes to my face simply observing my four- or five-year-old students. But I've also become more aware of moments where a smile comes to my face with a sense of effort. It's a contrived sense of happiness in order to keep things light for the students. Relating to the parent interaction with a baby mentioned earlier, I believe the mother's reaction is an expression of mudita—wanting the baby's happiness to increase and continue. By seeing the mother's happiness, the baby gets that feedback. This leads to my point about this contrived sense of happiness: in wanting to make sure my students feel safe and happy, even in moments where I'm not present to naturally experience their joy, I try my best to mirror it. It's often when a student says, "Look at what I did!" with a big smile, but I was busy running around and can't always naturally produce that feeling. Part of me believes I should be happy—like seeing a dog playing—but when it doesn't connect, I put on that smile.
Diana: So sometimes you feel like it's contrived, but you're doing this because you want the kids to feel recognized in their happiness?
Yogi 6: I believe so. I also think a part of me feels that I should be happy in those moments.
Diana: Well, this can be exhausting, right? Do you feel at the end of your time with them like, "Oh, that was a lot"?
Yogi 6: Yes, but the sense of purpose of wanting the students to feel joy kind of balances it out. It's exhausting, but it's the job of taking care of them.
Diana: Is there a way that can be done that feels like a natural expression of what's happening? I don't know the answer; I'm just dropping in a question. Because if you're feeling frustrated, you obviously don't want to just lash out at them. I'm not an expert in this arena at all, but I have deep bows of appreciation for people who work with four- and five-year-olds. Thank you for doing that.
Well, this dog thing, you know... [Laughter] I go over to Peet's Coffee in the middle of the park almost every morning, and this woman brings by her dog. It's like, is the dog making me happy or am I making the dog happy? I don't know, but it's exciting. This is why we have pets! [Laughter]
Yogi 7: You mentioned that happiness is infinite, but there are practical situations where happiness could be finite. Say there are ten people—and I'm one of them—and there's only one spot available. One person gets it, and I don't get it. That means there was a finite amount of happiness for that particular reason to be shared. How do you cultivate mudita in such a situation?
Diana: I see. I wouldn't make that link. It's not that there's a finite amount of happiness just because there was only one spot out of ten. What you're describing is the happiness connected to having the circumstances that we want, and that's not what's being pointed to here. That's related to dukkha[6]. The recognition is that one person having happiness doesn't diminish the amount of happiness that's available overall. Every single living being can be happy at the same time in terms of the amount of happiness that's available in the heart. That's what I'm pointing to, rather than everybody getting what they want. Does that make sense?
Yogi 7: Yeah.
Diana: Okay. So, thank you. Wishing you a wonderful rest of the evening and safe travels home. Thank you.
Mudita: A Pali word often translated as "sympathetic joy" or "appreciative joy," meaning taking delight in the happiness and good fortune of others. ↩︎
Brahma Viharas: The four "divine abodes" or sublime states in Buddhism: loving-kindness (metta), compassion (karuṇā), empathetic joy (mudita), and equanimity (upekkhā). ↩︎
Metta: A Pali word meaning loving-kindness, goodwill, and benevolence toward all beings. ↩︎
Upekkhā: A Pali word meaning equanimity; a balanced, peaceful state of mind that remains stable regardless of circumstances. ↩︎
Seven Factors of Awakening: The seven mental qualities that lead to enlightenment in Buddhism: mindfulness, investigation, energy, joy (or happiness), tranquility, concentration, and equanimity. ↩︎
Dukkha: A Pali word often translated as "suffering," "stress," or "unsatisfactoriness." ↩︎