The Noble Truths of Becoming
- Date:
- 2019-01-13
- Speakers:
- Gil Fronsdal [Talks] [@AudioDharma]
- Location:
- Insight Meditation Center [Talks] [@YouTube]
- Generation:
- 2026-11-22 (gemini-3.1-pro-preview) [Prompt Template] [Raw Markdown] [YouTube Video]
- Keywords:
This is an AI-generated transcript from auto-generated subtitles for the video above. It likely contains inaccuracies, especially with speaker attribution if there are multiple speakers.
The Noble Truths of Becoming
It is the custom for me to use my first Sunday talk of the year to talk about the Four Noble Truths. It is often considered to be one of the central teachings of the Buddha, or Buddhism. It is a very useful, practical teaching, and it lends itself to a lot of different applications—or we could say, a lot of different interpretations.
I would like to talk about one particular application of this famous teaching, which is found in the Buddha's discourse on turning the wheel of the Dharma, the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta[1]. This has the pride of place of being considered the first sermon of the Buddha after he was awakened. They usually use the word "sermon" maybe to give it more importance. Certainly, the Buddha gave a first teaching at some point or other, so that is probably historically accurate. However, the chances that this particular record represents exactly what he actually said is pretty small. The discourse is canonical, as it is in the ancient suttas, but it's an excerpt from a longer work that was probably written at least a hundred years after the Buddha died, laying out the history of the Buddha's early teaching career. It is a genre of literature which doesn't really belong in the early texts. The subjects, the topics, and the mythology that come in there clearly belong to a different period.
Even though it is held up as being the first sermon of the Buddha, most scholars will say it's not quite historically exact. But that shouldn't worry us too much if the teachings in there are useful. And we find they are useful, particularly in how they are applied.
Most Dharma teachers who talk about the Four Noble Truths and refer to this first discourse will say, "This is what the Buddha first taught: he taught the Four Noble Truths." Then they proceed to tell you what the Four Noble Truths are, but it's mostly like Cliff Notes. They have read very selectively what the text says, and then they expand from there. What I would like to do today is to really dig into the text, focusing on the part that is often ignored. You will see it is a particular application of this teaching that, if taken literally, some of you may find useful. But if we take it more figuratively, then maybe it is useful for all of us here.
Introduction: Assuming Roles and Personas
As an introduction to this topic, I would like to do a little thought experiment.
Imagine you could look down from the sky into everyone's homes early in the morning. Perhaps a wonderful documentarian in a blimp has somehow taken the roofs off people's homes and is looking down at them when they wake up from their beds. First, everyone is sleeping. People's sleep may be a little different from each other, but basically, it's just people sleeping. You don't know much about them. Then they get out of bed. Maybe they have pajamas on, which doesn't tell you much about them—they're just pajamas. They are disheveled, they haven't had their coffee yet, and they are stumbling into the kitchen to get their breakfast ready and take a shower.
As they proceed in getting started for the day, maybe they are going to work. Depending on the work, they put on clothes particular to their job. Firefighters put on firefighting clothes; police officers, nurses, or medical technicians put on their uniforms. Or maybe people are going off to a place of faith, and they dress accordingly. In some places, they put on suits and ties—which we seldom do here, I don't see anyone dressed like that!
So you see that as people get started in their day, they are assuming a role. They are assuming a way of being: a police officer, a firefighter, a nurse, a plumber. They are putting on an outfit that represents that role. But it isn't just putting on the outfit so people know who they are, or because it's practical for the job. With that comes taking on the role psychologically—what it means to be that person, how you present yourself, how you speak, how you hold yourself. In different jobs, you have a different persona.
A person doesn't just put on the uniform; they also assume a persona. There is nothing wrong with that. It is quite appropriate to have different personas in different environments. It's not necessarily insincere. It's quite sincere to say, "In this environment, this is how I am. This kind of persona is appropriate. This is what I'm asked to do and what is expected."
The issue is not assuming the personas, but becoming the persona. Assuming implies that it's temporary, provisional, and just useful for the moment. If you go to a funeral, we assume the role of a mourner, which means you present yourself a certain way. You expect to dress a certain way and talk in a low voice. In other places, you show up and it's a party, and you're expected to dance and celebrate. I went to a funeral once where the cultural expectation was initially a tremendous amount of anger. It was awesome—it was fury and anger at the person who died! Once everyone had gotten this off their chest, they proceeded to dance and party and celebrate the person's life. It was their last chance to express that anger, right? But here in California, I think you'd be hard-pressed to find a funeral where you're supposed to stand up and let the person have it. The angry persona is not one you put on here; mostly you put on a reverent way of being because it's expected.
We assume these personas. Sometimes we don't even know we're assuming them; it's just second nature that we enter into different personas depending on where we are. The issue is the difference between assuming a persona appropriately versus becoming it.
The Problem of Becoming
Becoming is a deeper level of identification. It's a deeper level of saying, "This is who I am. This is how I define myself. This is how I want to represent myself to the world. This is my true nature, and now I have to convince other people that this is who I am."
It's not just assuming it for the moment, where it is flexible and fluid, and you can take off the uniform and be something else. Now you have to go through life having this particular way of being, this becoming, this identity. You have to hold onto it, defend it, champion it, and keep constructing and reinforcing it for everyone's sake—especially for your own sake, because you are attached to it. It is important to you.
For some people, it's the persona of their profession. They do it for 10, 20, 30, or 40 years, and it settles in. They get so identified with it that it becomes who they are, and they can't easily drop it. We know people who, when they retire, are completely lost because their whole sense of being in the world is oriented around that persona. Without that job, some people are lost. They say that some people even die shortly after retiring when there is such a big loss of identity.
Then there are deeper psychological identities that we take on, some of which are quite dysfunctional. Some people become the person who is inadequate, the person who is not quite acceptable, the person who is somehow wrong. "Everyone else has it together but me. I'm somehow unworthy. I'm the one who is always left out." Or, "When I was in high school, I was the one no one wanted to listen to, so now I've made up for it. Why do you think I took this profession?" [Laughter]
We carry these ideas about ourselves. Some are acquired from how people treat us, some from inner insecurities, and some from conceit: "Look, I'm better than everyone else. If you do anything that threatens my sense of being superior, I'm going to compete with you and show you how I'm even better."
All this, in Buddhist terms, fits under the category of becoming. It means being something that is more than just temporarily assumed. It's taking an idea, saying, "This is who I am," being attached to it, and in that attachment, suffering a lot.
When we are attached to a becoming, there isn't much maneuvering room to be flexible and fluid in different environments. Some identities need to be constantly reinforced or defended. If the identity is taken away or threatened, it is painful. Furthermore, some forms of becoming are inherently painful because they are negative self-images that we hold onto.
One way or the other, this attachment to an identity is a central issue that Buddhism points to and wants us to overcome. This is the central issue in the so-called first sermon of the Buddha.
The First Noble Truth: Suffering and Stress
In the Four Noble Truths, the Buddha first says that there is a Noble Truth of suffering[2]. The word suffering is maybe not the best translation in English. He goes through and describes what he means. In the translation I have here by Thanissaro Bhikkhu[3], he translates the Pali word not as suffering, but as stressful.
The first statement reads: "Birth is stressful." The more common English translation is "Birth is suffering." The problem with that translation is that the word "suffering" has all kinds of associations. People assume it only refers to the biggest problems we face. Additionally, the word "suffering" in English can be both an adjective and a noun. When people read "Birth is suffering," many interpret it as two nouns equated to each other: X is Y. Birth equals suffering, and that's all it is.
The usual translation continues: "Aging is suffering. Death is suffering. Sorrow, lamentation, pain, distress, and despair are suffering. Association with the unbeloved is suffering. Separation from the loved is suffering. Not getting what one wants is suffering."
But Thanissaro Bhikkhu's translation reads: "Birth is stressful. Aging is stressful. Death is stressful. Sorrow, lamentation, pain, distress, and despair are stressful. Association with the unbeloved is stressful. Separation from the loved is stressful. Not getting what is wanted is stressful."
You get a slightly different feeling, right? Other people prefer the adjective painful. When you say, "Birth is painful," it's not the final story. For those of you who have given birth, there are usually other emotions present in addition to the pain. For some people, giving birth is the highlight of their life, even though it is painful. Using adjectives like stressful and painful gives a different feeling: "Oh yes, I recognize this. There is a lot of pain and stress in this life."
Some people find that just hearing this First Noble Truth opens their eyes. They say, "Wow, finally! I've been struggling and couldn't understand how difficult life is when everyone else is saying it's great. Now I finally hear someone say, 'Yes, life is difficult, it's painful.' That's part of it." Some people can relax just having this acknowledged. For others, it's simply depressing to hear, because they don't see it as a truth that finally makes sense of things.
The Second Noble Truth: Craving and Becoming
Then the Buddha goes on to explain the Second Noble Truth: "The Noble Truth of the Arising of Stress."
What we find here in this text is not a one-to-one correspondence. It is not the definitive definition of the Second Noble Truth, just as "birth is painful" is not the entire definition of the First Noble Truth, but rather an elaboration of one aspect of it. Here too, the commentary about the arising of suffering is a particular application of it—a nuance you don't get in many standard teachings.
Most people will refer to the very beginning of the elaboration and say, "This is the Noble Truth of the arising of stress: Craving." (The literal meaning of the Pali word is thirst). They teach that craving is the cause of all suffering. It is a bit of a tall order to try to shoehorn every cause of suffering into this particular kind of desire, but it is a very useful teaching. We can look at our desire, our attachment to craving, and see what role it plays in the ways that we suffer. Many people who practice meditation and have some sense of stillness and focus can become increasingly sensitive to seeing how their wants lead to suffering. Even more significantly, the craving itself is suffering; it is just uncomfortable to be craving all the time.
However, in the first sermon, the Buddha didn't stop there. This is the part that is usually left out. He says, "The craving that..." The use of the word "that" suggests we are talking about a particular kind of craving. He says: "The craving that makes for further becoming."
Here we are at the word becoming, which is why I did the whole introduction. The Buddha is talking about the particular craving that leads to creating and holding onto identities—what Buddhism calls a becoming, as opposed to an assumed persona.
I will read it more fully: "The craving that makes for further becoming, accompanied by passion and delight, relishing now here and now there."
In the ancient world, they seemed to have a lot of issues with relishing or over-delighting in things. Certainly, joy plays a strong, important role in early Buddhism, but there are certain kinds of joy that we don't quite know how to translate into English to capture the nuances. The word "relishing" works relatively well. Here it is translated as "delight," but I prefer "delighting" as a verb. What's wrong with delight? But "delighting" means you are leaning into it, you're engaged in the compulsion of it.
It is a craving that turns desire into a compulsion. You can't put it down; it's a strong habit, almost an addiction. The way some people relate to their identity probably qualifies as an addiction. It is so intense how caught up people are in it, and it's so difficult to put it down. You might even go through withdrawal because we are so dependent on understanding ourselves in certain ways and having that identity reinforced by our loved ones and friends.
I remember when I was first beginning to see all this becoming and identification that I lived under, I felt like I needed to put it down. One of the things that made it difficult was that my friends expected me to continue being that way. That expectation was part of the understanding of how we related to each other. If I wasn't going to relate to them in that way, some of the juice between us—the medium of communication—didn't quite exist. It was hard to find a new way to be. I sometimes reverted back to my old persona because I couldn't navigate how to stay with my friends when they expected the old persona to be there. There is often a lot of reinforcement for this becoming.
Three Kinds of Craving
The Buddha gives a little bit more specificity to what this craving is. It is craving for sensuality, craving for becoming, and craving for non-becoming.
Craving for sensuality, pleasure, and comfort is deeply embedded in the human psyche. It is one of the driving forces of human behavior. You can probably do a fairly easy analysis of your own life to figure out how much money and time you spend—that isn't really needed to live a basically settled, comfortable life—just getting things a little bit nicer. A little bit nicer food, nicer clothes, nicer furniture, a nicer car. What is the drive behind getting things a little bit nicer than you really have to? Chances are, some of it has to do with straight-ahead sensual pleasure. It is enjoyable. There is nothing wrong with that; it's not a crime. But we see that this drive is strong and sometimes becomes a craving.
Sometimes, however, the drive for a little bit more is not because of pleasure, but because of becoming. "I want to be a certain kind of person. I want to be seen as a certain kind of person. I want to prove to myself that I am this kind of person." So we inhabit this persona by making sure we have these kinds of shoes, clothes, or cars. We are shoring up an identity. How much of our identities are shored up by what we spend our money and time on?
Then there is the third category: craving for non-becoming. Some people have a strong desire not to be. I lean in this direction in certain ways. Those of you who have been around me for a long time have probably never seen me wear clothes with a big logo on them. The idea of wearing something that has something written across it... I have a certain hesitation around it because it feels like now I am becoming something, and I would rather not. I am always presenting myself in some way—I can't get around it—but I lean more in the direction of non-becoming. It's fine for other people to wear clothes with logos, but not me. It also goes along with my non-becoming side that I would not be sitting in the center of the front of the room. I'd be sitting in the back row somewhere, out of the way. Like this fellow back there in the corner, smiling and laughing, who doesn't want anyone to notice! [Laughter]
The craving for non-becoming is also sometimes a negative thing where we want to become something specifically because we don't want to be something else. The creation of identity is partly to avoid an identity that we don't want. Some people struggle against identities that are natural to have based on what they look like. There is a lot of suffering in our society over skin color, size, and ethnicity. We project identities onto other people in horrific ways—like racism—and then people have to live under that. Living under that, some people want to get away from who they are and try to prove they are somebody else. There is a strong craving to non-become. Then there is a whole healing process that must go on where they are willing to step into who they are, feel proud, comfortable, and natural, and not feel ashamed.
This whole world of becoming and identity is a tender, challenging place where a tremendous amount of suffering arises. This is what the Buddha was talking about.
Most literally, he was probably talking about becoming on a more cosmic scale, because he believed in rebirth—becoming in the next lifetime. For the Buddha, this is not an innocent act. You don't simply die and pop up someplace else. The mechanisms that get us reborn have a lot to do with a craving to become. It shapes the kind of next life we have. Simply the act of becoming, or the desire to become (independent of becoming anything in particular), can get us reborn.
If you bring it back to this lifetime—which I prefer—and look at how becoming works psychologically day-to-day, you see that for some people, the attachment around becoming is not to becoming anything in particular. It is an attachment to just being the process of becoming: the "I am." Some people find it a beautiful feeling to let go of all different identities and come to a very rudimentary, vibrating feeling of "I am-ness," as if that is the ultimate state. But for the Buddha, that "I am" is still a form of attachment. But craving for non-becoming is also a problem. You are not supposed to want to get rid of identity or the sense of "I am-ness" just to avoid being part of this samsara[4], this complicated swirl and fragility of identity.
The Third and Fourth Noble Truths: The Path to Freedom
So what is the alternative? Are we trying not to become? Are we trying to become the right thing? What is our proper relationship to these identities?
This brings us to the Third Noble Truth, which is the good news. Again, this is a particular application of the Third Noble Truth in relationship to this topic of becoming:
"This is the Noble Truth of the cessation of stress. It is the remainderless fading and cessation, renunciation, relinquishment, release, and letting go of that very craving."
Those are great words. It is the remainderless—a very absolute term, meaning no longer remaining—fading and cessation, renunciation, relinquishment, release, and letting go of that very craving. This text reinforces that we are talking about a very particular kind of craving: the craving for identity. Identity is not the problem, nor is assuming a persona necessarily a problem; it's the attachment to it, the compulsion around it, that is the problem.
We are talking about aspects of human psychology that are deeply embedded. It is hard to see how this operates in our normal, busy lives. It feels mysterious why we are suffering because this is the operating system below the surface. This is one of the main reasons for meditation: to get quiet and still enough, not just for the purpose of being calm, but to have adequate calmness to see underneath the surface of the conscious mind and see how these attachments operate.
We are talking about touching beautiful, vulnerable aspects of the inner life. When we talk about identity and becoming, it is very intimate. It takes care and respect to look at this and not feel like we are wrong or bad. If we can get quiet enough to drop down and really see this, we are getting in touch with an inner quality that is beautiful, that has the potential to support us, inspire us, and give life meaning and purpose. It is incredibly valuable to base one's life on that.
But it is not easy to do. So the Buddha offered the Fourth Noble Truth to help us. Given how difficult this craving is to deal with, and given that we are looking to bring a total cessation to some of the deepest, most tenacious cravings we have, we need a lot of help. The Buddha offers this:
"This is the Noble Truth of the way of practice leading to the cessation of stress: precisely this Noble Eightfold Path—Right View, Right Resolve, Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood, Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, and Right Concentration."
If people are interested in doing the deep work of uncovering, understanding, and getting under the surface of our suffering around becoming, it takes ongoing work. It takes refining and looking at ourselves in the way represented by the Eightfold Path.
We need to learn a particular perspective to do this work, which is Right View and Right Resolve. We need to have our ethical life in just enough order so that we are not agitated (Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood). We want to have an ethically relaxed heart so we can go under the surface. If we have an ethically agitated heart, it stirs the waters and we can't see.
Once we are settled, we do the meditation practice—the last three steps of the Eightfold Path (Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, Right Concentration)—to develop the clarity and stillness that allows us to touch these beautiful, tender parts inside in a way where we feel deeply safe. We cultivate a deep sense of trust and well-being, a place where we can lower our guard, lower our fear, resolve our animosities and resentments, and drop into places where there is no doubt.
That is the place where attachment and craving to identity can give way and let go. What a beautiful thing it is to be able to be in this world without always having the filter of being someone for yourself or for someone else. You get to just be.
Being free is better than becoming. If you are free, then you can be more playful around all the different personas you might assume. If you assume them appropriately, it is going to be quite fun to be flexible and fluid, rather than rigidly holding onto being different people. It is like having different personas depending on the circumstance; if you are playing with a three-year-old, it's really good to have a different persona!
Thank you.
Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta: The Buddha's first discourse, translated as "Setting the Wheel of Dhamma in Motion." ↩︎
Dukkha: The Pali word often translated as "suffering," "stress," or "unsatisfactoriness." ↩︎
Thanissaro Bhikkhu: An American Buddhist monk and prolific translator of the Pali Canon. ↩︎
Samsara: The continuous cycle of birth, death, and rebirth; the worldly realm of suffering and conditioned existence. ↩︎